Noah deserved discovered in he , But it mutter to his calculations .
(ROOT_0 (S_0 (ATS_3 (ATS_4 (ATS_0 (S_1 (NP_0 (NNP_0 Noah)) (VP_5 (VBD_2 deserved) (S_2 (VP_0 (VBD_0 discovered) (PP_1 (IN_1 in) (NP_0 (PRP_1 he))))))) (COMMA_0 ,)) (CC_0 But)) (S_1 (NP_0 (PRP_1 it)) (VP_5 (VBP_0 mutter) (PP_2 (TO_0 to) (NP_3 (PRPDOLLAR_0 his) (NNS_0 calculations)))))) (DOT_0 .)))