with the sturdy idiom , he had happened before boy pale .
(ROOT_0 (S_0 (ATS_3 (ATS_1 (ATS_2 (PP_2 (IN_0 with) (NP_6 (ATNP_1 (DT_0 the) (JJ_1 sturdy)) (NN_1 idiom))) (COMMA_0 ,)) (NP_0 (PRP_1 he))) (VP_3 (VBD_1 had) (VP_2 (VBN_0 happened) (PP_2 (IN_0 before) (NP_3 (NN_3 boy) (JJ_0 pale)))))) (DOT_0 .)))