They to be Noah , this had who that had he began the gravel virtue .
(ROOT_0 (S_0 (ATS_3 (ATS_1 (ATS_2 (SBAR_0 (S_2 (NP_1 (PRP_0 They)) (VP_0 (TO_0 to) (VP_1 (VB_0 be) (NP_0 (NNP_0 Noah)))))) (COMMA_0 ,)) (NP_0 (DT_1 this))) (VP_3 (VBD_0 had) (SBAR_0 (WHNP_0 (WP_0 who)) (S_1 (NP_0 (DT_1 that)) (VP_5 (VBD_1 had) (SBAR_0 (S_1 (NP_0 (PRP_1 he)) (VP_5 (VBD_0 began) (NP_6 (ATNP_1 (DT_0 the) (NN_3 gravel)) (NN_1 virtue)))))))))) (DOT_0 .)))