united states house of representatives elections , 1868
james m ashley has a first elected year which is earlier than that of samuel shellabarger .
{'row_1': '3', 'row_2': '1', 'col': '4', 'col_other': '2', 'relation': 'less', 'record_mentioned': 'no', 'diff_result': None}
{'func': 'less', 'args': [{'func': 'num_hop', 'args': [{'func': 'filter_str_eq', 'args': ['all_rows', 'incumbent', 'james m ashley'], 'result': None, 'ind': 0, 'tointer': 'select the rows whose incumbent record fuzzily matches to james m ashley .', 'tostr': 'filter_eq { all_rows ; incumbent ; james m ashley }'}, 'first elected'], 'result': None, 'ind': 2, 'tostr': 'hop { filter_eq { all_rows ; incumbent ; james m ashley } ; first elected }', 'tointer': 'select the rows whose incumbent record fuzzily matches to james m ashley . take the first elected record of this row .'}, {'func': 'num_hop', 'args': [{'func': 'filter_str_eq', 'args': ['all_rows', 'incumbent', 'samuel shellabarger'], 'result': None, 'ind': 1, 'tointer': 'select the rows whose incumbent record fuzzily matches to samuel shellabarger .', 'tostr': 'filter_eq { all_rows ; incumbent ; samuel shellabarger }'}, 'first elected'], 'result': None, 'ind': 3, 'tostr': 'hop { filter_eq { all_rows ; incumbent ; samuel shellabarger } ; first elected }', 'tointer': 'select the rows whose incumbent record fuzzily matches to samuel shellabarger . take the first elected record of this row .'}], 'result': True, 'ind': 4, 'tostr': 'less { hop { filter_eq { all_rows ; incumbent ; james m ashley } ; first elected } ; hop { filter_eq { all_rows ; incumbent ; samuel shellabarger } ; first elected } } = true', 'tointer': 'select the rows whose incumbent record fuzzily matches to james m ashley . take the first elected record of this row . select the rows whose incumbent record fuzzily matches to samuel shellabarger . take the first elected record of this row . the first record is less than the second record .'}
less { hop { filter_eq { all_rows ; incumbent ; james m ashley } ; first elected } ; hop { filter_eq { all_rows ; incumbent ; samuel shellabarger } ; first elected } } = true
select the rows whose incumbent record fuzzily matches to james m ashley . take the first elected record of this row . select the rows whose incumbent record fuzzily matches to samuel shellabarger . take the first elected record of this row . the first record is less than the second record .
{'less_4': 'less', 'result_5': 'true', 'num_hop_2': 'num_hop', 'filter_str_eq_0': 'filter_str_eq', 'all_rows_6': 'all_rows', 'incumbent_7': 'incumbent', 'james m ashley_8': 'james m ashley', 'first elected_9': 'first elected', 'num_hop_3': 'num_hop', 'filter_str_eq_1': 'filter_str_eq', 'all_rows_10': 'all_rows', 'incumbent_11': 'incumbent', 'samuel shellabarger_12': 'samuel shellabarger', 'first elected_13': 'first elected'}
['district', 'incumbent', 'party', 'first elected', 'result', 'candidates']
[['ohio 7', 'samuel shellabarger', 'republican', '1864', 'retired republican hold', 'james j winans ( r ) 50.2 % john h thomas ( d ) 49.8 %'], ['ohio 8', 'john beatty', 'republican', '1868 ( s )', 're - elected', 'john beatty ( r ) 52.0 % john h benson ( d ) 48.0 %'], ['ohio 10', 'james m ashley', 'republican', '1862', 'lost re - election democratic gain', 'truman h hoag ( d ) 51.5 % james m ashley ( d ) 48.5 %'], ['ohio 11', 'john thomas wilson', 'republican', '1866', 're - elected', 'john thomas wilson ( r ) 54.2 % john sands ( d ) 45.8 %'], ['ohio 16', 'john bingham', 'republican', '1864', 're - elected', 'john bingham ( r ) 50.8 % josiah m estep ( d ) 49.2 %']]