We went to Casa Rugantino 2 weeks ago, and it was a great experience. We went there without reservation at around 7pm on a Thursday evening, and were greeted friendly.  The restaurant is fairly small, but feels cozy, so we were happy that we managed to get the last table. Everyone working there seemed to have a great time and enjoy themselves. The food was great, we had garlic bread and two different pizzas that were both great! We have since bought gift cards for friends, would definitely recommend. Next time, we would probably make a reservation to make sure we get in