I've given the Greenbush several tries, but I'm left feeling \"meh\" about my experiences eating there.\n\nYes, the christmas lights almost give it a kitschy atmosphere, but not quite. It looks more like someone threw lights on the ceiling of their grandparents' 70s basement rec room. It has great potential to be quirky and awesome but doesn't quite get there. The plastic auditorium chairs they use for seating are also wickedly uncomfortable.\n\nYes, the food is substantially local and has the potential to be very good, but it doesn't quite get there either.   It seems a bit uninspired and underflavored, and the last time I was there the bottoms of my ravioli were burned black. I'm not even sure how such a thing would be accomplished, but accomplished it was.\n\nThe service is also \"meh.\" Pleasant enough, but my drink and my water went unrefilled throughout my entire meal AND dessert so I left quite thirsty.  Not only did I not receive another non-burned helping of ravioli when I informed the waitress of my burned dish, I didn't get comped for even a penny for being served something that was more or less unedible.  The waitress had said she'd \"take care of it\" but apparently that means only that she'd get the dish off the table.\n\nI really want to think this place is a fabulous local gem, but really it's just a mediocre place that needs better service and a lot more heart.