I decided to take the owner up on her offer of a dozen free cupcakes, which she offered after reading my original review to try to entice us to give her business another chance. I called ahead of time to let them know the situation and that I would be stopping by. The lady on the phone said that I could pick the order up at anytime before the close of business. \n\nUpon arrival, I was immediately greeted by a staff member. I then informed them that I was there to pick up the aforementioned cupcakes. Roughly a minute later, I was greeted by the owner and promptly questioned as to \"whyyyy\" I had posted a negative review on Yelp. She then asked why I had not called them personally to express my concerns about the cake tasting. I explained to her that Yelp is an open site, and consumers are free to share their reviews/experiences, whether they be good or bad. At which point she agreed, but still seemed displeased. \n\nShe mentioned that the bakery never charges for tastings. They merely require a deposit of $20 via a credit card. If a customer fails to show for their cake tasting appointment, the credit card is charged. I stated that it appeared to be a miscommunication by her staff, as I was led to believe that I was being charged for the tasting. On this point, I was incorrect in my original review. \n\nShe gave me the cupcakes (They were were cold. Which, I found strange) and said, \"I hope you post a better review this time.\" To which I stated, \"Well I hope we like the cupcakes.\" I promptly thanked her and took the cupcakes, (a random assortment chosen by the staff before my arrival) and left to go home and call my fiance to vent. \n\nMy fiance and I will most likely will not be eating all of them, but for the ones we do taste, our opinions are as follows - \n\nBetter Than Sex Cake - The fudge was tasty; a little thick, but some people like it that way. The cake itself was soggy and the flavor was somewhat flat. The caramel was a plus but could barely be tasted. I believe the caramel is the reason why the cake was soggy. The whipped cream filling and toffee pieces were a delicious accent. Very messy. \n\nLittle Deb - The fudge frosting was good, but again too thick. The whipped cream filling again was delicious. The cake was dry and again somewhat flat. \n\nPlain Jane - The cake was dry, however the cream filling was delicious. \n\nPlain Jack - The cake was moist and the filling was tasty. Out of all of them, I think we liked this the best. \n\nOreo - The cake was pretty moist. The whipped cream filling was again a hit. The more you eat the frosting, the more the Oreo flavor comes through. \n\nCosmos - The cake was dry. Raspberry filling was decent, very tart. The coconut was a nice touch. The frosting was overly sweet. \n\nBoston Cream - Pretty good. And I'm not a big fan of cream style pies. The cake was very moist. \n\nSpumoni - The pistachio Bavarian cream filling was more like a pudding. The green color threw me at first, but i overcame my fear of snot colored food and sampled some. The cake was moist. \n\nCake of the Month - PB&J. The peanut butter frosting, terrible. The cake was moist and there was actual grape jelly inside. That flavor combo was not bad. If they could have actually used peanut butter, instead of the peanut butter frosting, it would have probably been better together. \n\nNow that we've OD'd on sugar, we can safely say that the cake was overall dry. The frostings were neither a hit nor a miss. The whipped filling was the star of the cupcake. Its safe to say that if we're in the mood for cupcakes, I'll save myself the money and make them myself at home. \n\n4 Stars for the cupcakes being free \n2 Stars for the cupcakes being overall nothing to write home about. \nGoing with 2 stars (If I could give a 1/2 a star here, i would rate it 2.5)