This won in spades. Sophisticated bistro . Varied. Very intelligent wine/aperatif  list. Stellar dine at the bar service Fine fish soup \nwith excellent alioli + croutons. Rognons a la  moutard approximate my own moose version. Tartare highly satisfactory ( still, read Robichon ) frites sucked - but so do they in most Parisian bistros these days,41/2 stars.