I've been in Madison for 30 years now, plus or minus, and I've always been curious about this restaurant tucked away near Home Depot.  Today I went with friends, and it was great.  My steak sandwich was super, and my wife had walleye -- broiled -- and the piece of fish was cooked perfectly and HUGE!  The cheesy hash browns (wife got) were better than the twice-baked (which I got).  But they didn't have any dessert (Sad)!  The ambiance is totally rural town supper club, and I mean that in a very very good way.  I will not wait 30 years to go back!  Cocktails are cheap and strong.   Just the way you want them.