My initial review was based on just a handful of experiences; this follow-up summarizes the results of my many repeat visits to what I believe to be Middleton's finest Pub.\n\nI've eaten here countless times since my initial review, and every meal has been excellent: from salads to soups to the burgers and fish fry.  The MTP can cook a mean meal.\n\nService remains unbelievably top-notch.  You won't find an unfriendly person in the place, and I really - honestly - get the feeling that the servers, cooks, and owner care about your experience.  I'm always made to feel at home; the staff all remember your name and favorite beverage, and they make good conversation.\n\nThe patrons are great as well - I've met countless people that have been super friendly, interesting, and fun to chat with.  No one gets belligerent or out of hand, which is a welcomed \"plus.\"\n\nI've had the fish fry several times, but this last visit was nothing short of incredible - they keep tweaking things and improving them, and it shows.  Go there for an excellent fish fry - the offerings are vast, the pricing is reasonable, and the fish is stellar.  Just be sure to get there early!\n\nGreat drink prices, great food, excellent juke box, friendly environment, and incredible staff = WIN.  Oh, and they serve food until a ridiculously late hour - like 1:00am or so.\n\n5 stars all the way around.