Unnamed: 0.1
int64
0
113k
Unnamed: 0
float64
0
113k
title
stringlengths
7
246
abstract
stringlengths
6
3.31k
embeddings
listlengths
512
512
200
200
Feature Dynamic Bayesian Networks
Feature Markov Decision Processes (PhiMDPs) are well-suited for learning agents in general environments. Nevertheless, unstructured (Phi)MDPs are limited to relatively simple environments. Structured MDPs like Dynamic Bayesian Networks (DBNs) are used for large-scale real-world problems. In this article I extend PhiMDP to PhiDBN. The primary contribution is to derive a cost criterion that allows to automatically extract the most relevant features from the environment, leading to the "best" DBN representation. I discuss all building blocks required for a complete general learning algorithm.
[ -0.03782697021961212, -0.031022094190120697, 0.04055771231651306, -0.024766486138105392, 0.03921455889940262, -0.11411827057600021, -0.03525427356362343, 0.010736185126006603, -0.06031052768230438, 0.048192571848630905, 0.04007836803793907, -0.03846815228462219, 0.024522749707102776, 0.02372063137590885, -0.02244870737195015, 0.004409672226756811, 0.01348782703280449, -0.009031618013978004, 0.05033116787672043, -0.0673728883266449, 0.08195693790912628, 0.01324361003935337, -0.03193599358201027, 0.013404568657279015, -0.05808869004249573, 0.07352761924266815, 0.0007652952335774899, -0.02898976020514965, 0.005629773251712322, -0.028669388964772224, -0.014027181081473827, -0.01452321745455265, -0.03383486345410347, 0.010864336974918842, 0.03569161146879196, -0.04521966353058815, 0.01618465967476368, -0.04338359087705612, 0.0047020334750413895, 0.015608538873493671, -0.009864350780844688, -0.008930987678468227, 0.030566595494747162, 0.02038581855595112, 0.061785850673913956, 0.07804641127586365, -0.0041016340255737305, -0.04972713440656662, 0.027070680633187294, 0.03910753130912781, -0.046530552208423615, 0.022991614416241646, 0.0023120094556361437, 0.0005444006528705359, -0.051553696393966675, 0.04657864198088646, -0.04528362303972244, 0.014125530607998371, 0.011671471409499645, -0.0033766059204936028, 0.05139629542827606, 0.05560256168246269, -0.026453176513314247, 0.02581777237355709, -0.0498797632753849, -0.03698068484663963, -0.008960059843957424, -0.01641474850475788, -0.011281806975603104, 0.004349997732788324, 0.05176524445414543, -0.020948512479662895, 0.008761218748986721, 0.01147486362606287, 0.02172253467142582, 0.027613762766122818, -0.05677540972828865, 0.029934803023934364, 0.04843693599104881, 0.10947678238153458, -0.06484131515026093, 0.020597921684384346, -0.004539693705737591, 0.06684156507253647, -0.024452831596136093, 0.010705742053687572, -0.024875380098819733, -0.008765973150730133, -0.02015741728246212, 0.020242124795913696, -0.02116202749311924, 0.02503773756325245, -0.035493891686201096, -0.0148426229134202, -0.04483820125460625, 0.07703184336423874, -0.06297290325164795, 0.036684952676296234, -0.006346262060105801, -0.004279886372387409, 0.02146111987531185, 0.0009118831367231905, 0.05664621293544769, 0.005686941556632519, -0.01611105352640152, -0.03310704976320267, -0.00843274500221014, 0.02640421874821186, -0.05924258753657341, -0.024949174374341965, 0.061487190425395966, -0.05743483453989029, 0.0014275609282776713, 0.0157957524061203, -0.09169481694698334, 0.09116529673337936, -0.0005534096853807569, 0.08624880015850067, 0.023792719468474388, 0.024079224094748497, -0.029419945552945137, -0.002739651594310999, -0.03879247605800629, -0.00953454989939928, 0.14943304657936096, -0.06191800907254219, -0.023186862468719482, -0.06404038518667221, 0.07453122735023499, 0.002438085386529565, -0.035476598888635635, 0.08732675015926361, 0.08376633375883102, -0.0644482970237732, -0.06475798785686493, 0.03826024383306503, -0.007811530493199825, -0.05904369801282883, -0.029366839677095413, 0.0553077757358551, -0.00429306598380208, 0.030488912016153336, 0.0328926146030426, -0.031320828944444656, -0.04771065339446068, -0.00029741923208348453, 0.011005925945937634, 0.03435841202735901, -0.002537643304094672, 0.055077552795410156, -0.060565900057554245, -0.09086361527442932, 0.03432382643222809, -0.018482690677046776, 0.01815073750913143, 0.001370066893287003, 0.013254725374281406, -0.005301854573190212, 0.0070717716589570045, 0.0313534252345562, -0.03811045363545418, 0.0006083400221541524, -0.012246442958712578, 0.023612909018993378, 0.07681439816951752, -0.0034524116199463606, -0.015736505389213562, 0.020337937399744987, -0.0881807878613472, -0.045821674168109894, -0.07437165826559067, -0.03103051707148552, 0.03472890332341194, 0.03751237317919731, -0.013190554454922676, -0.04678264260292053, 0.018608199432492256, 0.0019338518613949418, 0.019904498010873795, 0.008880866691470146, 0.032710105180740356, -0.04248909652233124, -0.015377855859696865, -0.052448075264692307, 0.03193599358201027, -0.019235145300626755, -0.01163844857364893, -0.03128301724791527, 0.06581386178731918, -0.002629260765388608, -0.036828745156526566, 0.014434533193707466, 0.03275495022535324, 0.0403834693133831, -0.013967083767056465, 0.041059575974941254, 0.030242010951042175, 0.044387731701135635, 0.07594490051269531, 0.019285766407847404, 0.01665169931948185, 0.0029573796782642603, -0.04085594415664673, -0.06489673256874084, -0.004202437121421099, -0.010720385238528252, 0.0682341530919075, -0.037276048213243484, -0.016844602301716805, -0.068119578063488, 0.002069654641672969, -0.033297065645456314, -0.05171481519937515, 0.008802478201687336, 0.055669475346803665, -0.06765040755271912, -0.03712641820311546, -0.04229261726140976, 0.05817487835884094, -0.04623609036207199, -0.027571938931941986, -0.02110014669597149, -0.01987559162080288, 0.08319824188947678, -0.04955553635954857, 0.0029415797907859087, -0.023796867579221725, -0.052494000643491745, -0.01573210209608078, 0.061066094785928726, 0.010246948339045048, -0.03181761875748634, 0.03937871754169464, -0.026040000841021538, -0.0007248549372889102, 0.07686897367238998, -0.030570998787879944, -0.07989712059497833, -0.04797058552503586, 0.03674720227718353, -0.04507271200418472, 0.10080930590629578, 0.033892806619405746, -0.019196396693587303, 0.032239511609077454, -0.0458633191883564, 0.01416880264878273, -0.03383175656199455, 0.0017368743428960443, 0.001237494871020317, -0.017406482249498367, -0.029809560626745224, 0.017756778746843338, -0.01644871011376381, -0.008306891657412052, -0.007455588784068823, -0.042313531041145325, 0.07533378899097443, 0.04441119357943535, -0.014868036843836308, 0.0002943010476883501, 0.04617707058787346, -0.004768930375576019, 0.046182405203580856, 0.045255497097969055, 0.07543911039829254, -0.015569665469229221, 0.012888672761619091, 0.025839004665613174, -0.01117037609219551, -0.03328806534409523, -0.020936263725161552, -0.01953413151204586, 0.08173014968633652, 0.006413672585040331, -0.03752743825316429, 0.014843541197478771, 0.059543877840042114, -0.009551635943353176, -0.06302651762962341, -0.004176872782409191, 0.024170085787773132, 0.060078732669353485, 0.061291251331567764, 0.012747703120112419, 0.05845239385962486, -0.08868332952260971, 0.05963212996721268, 0.03935595601797104, 0.02997090294957161, -0.09983314573764801, -0.02947317808866501, -0.08485841751098633, 0.0006302960682660341, 0.06878842413425446, -0.05518001317977905, 0.03176563233137131, -0.05178436264395714, 0.0367472879588604, -0.029745524749159813, 0.04050160571932793, -0.018308192491531372, 0.017436379566788673, -0.010233405977487564, 0.05220244452357292, 0.059938300400972366, 0.008811852894723415, 0.02360532246530056, -0.1237528920173645, 0.0383758582174778, 0.035364534705877304, 0.026964101940393448, -0.001422929810360074, -0.0007437088643200696, 0.08215129375457764, -0.02590487152338028, 0.0036222010385245085, -0.010100234299898148, -0.10034588724374771, -0.004267862997949123, 0.01697826012969017, 0.03514247015118599, 0.05758058279752731, 0.0035403803922235966, -0.07541847974061966, 0.02301289327442646, 0.01457907259464264, 0.06293175369501114, 0.0006479123258031905, -0.028028737753629684, -0.0629982054233551, -0.008814339525997639, -0.02990276925265789, 0.017957055941224098, -0.11185547709465027, -0.0019269484328106046, -0.07332705706357956, -0.0004319201107136905, -0.029088499024510384, -0.030262179672718048, -0.03871313855051994, -0.10000268369913101, -0.04194456711411476, -0.031097959727048874, 0.07081760466098785, 0.056436747312545776, 0.06843450665473938, -0.020933369174599648, 0.0018353068735450506, 0.07734622806310654, -0.025095855817198753, 0.05004657432436943, -0.02171093039214611, 0.04187619313597679, -0.04047159105539322, -0.039871279150247574, 0.04701808840036392, 0.006283206399530172, -0.01969744823873043, 0.02049338072538376, -0.013386871665716171, 0.0170388575643301, -0.010961652733385563, 0.008374029770493507, -0.009313205257058144, 0.040889922529459, -0.04085197299718857, 0.04605523496866226, -0.04920361936092377, -0.07545650005340576, 0.0348518043756485, 0.018083680421113968, 0.011168055236339569, 0.02500954456627369, 0.04178830608725548, -0.009943774901330471, 0.07672137022018433, -0.021690741181373596, 0.0015403226716443896, 0.08772118389606476, -0.003411496989428997, -0.004620799329131842, -0.024662023410201073, -0.11610293388366699, -0.11265222728252411, -0.029023578390479088, -0.010957641527056694, -0.03809001296758652, 0.03087521530687809, -0.04550141468644142, -0.0388769656419754, -0.010959764011204243, 0.0027456791140139103, 0.012520572170615196, 0.03553780913352966, -0.02611670084297657, 0.07783126085996628, 0.03654984384775162, 0.030549122020602226, 0.08743932843208313, -0.01720646768808365, -0.04840019345283508, -0.018619820475578308, -0.0356731191277504, -0.06965319812297821, 0.0351400263607502, 0.09808316081762314, 0.04161136969923973, 0.024525098502635956, 0.05914011970162392, 0.022057469934225082, 0.07917241752147675, -0.010088915936648846, -0.023024659603834152, 0.02567417360842228, -0.0013280755374580622, -0.04227278381586075, 0.026348669081926346, -0.05430649593472481, -0.05845008045434952, -0.012697888538241386, 0.01296414528042078, 0.015250852331519127, -0.003008026396855712, -0.0689024105668068, -0.03421908989548683, 0.034422799944877625, 0.05017682909965515, -0.00631790840998292, 0.04548633098602295, -0.03490765392780304, -0.012651697732508183, -0.0746886134147644, 0.005187477450817823, 0.03263460844755173, -0.009839844889938831, 0.04984838515520096, -0.050572555512189865, 0.01747784949839115, -0.030059754848480225, -0.004641879349946976, 0.025059202685952187, 0.03175991773605347, -0.07612390071153641, 0.00686109671369195, 0.048304483294487, 0.05224549025297165, 0.02092306688427925, 0.07118018716573715, -0.044388119131326675, -0.020981620997190475, 0.05047023296356201, 0.08640125393867493, -0.030675169080495834, -0.02865608036518097, -0.045464929193258286, 0.0537576898932457, 0.02254965528845787, 0.026157088577747345, 0.016684304922819138, -0.0005155571852810681, -0.07547595351934433, 0.02929438091814518, 0.04558059200644493, -0.09585437923669815, -0.008067481219768524, 0.054033346474170685, 0.038207508623600006, 0.07851041853427887, 0.030615730211138725, -0.05428100377321243, 0.022331582382321358, 0.03033316321671009, -0.06682375073432922, -0.03582201153039932, 0.10458864271640778, 0.05708139389753342, -0.018877394497394562, -0.01978040486574173, -0.04545104131102562, 0.009597299620509148, 0.0664021372795105, -0.0016173417679965496, 0.025062168017029762, -0.057619091123342514, 0.03855961561203003, 0.04157079756259918, -0.07631484419107437, 0.011419008485972881, 0.016648340970277786, -0.016752220690250397, -0.0357874259352684, 0.014676829800009727, 0.03112119995057583, -0.028332944959402084, -0.0540691576898098, -0.01938549615442753, -0.04928620532155037, 0.0826137512922287, -0.05776722729206085, 0.019504014402627945, -0.06842686980962753, 0.014935234561562538, 0.06324519217014313, 0.10297313332557678, -0.0513601116836071, 0.04408002644777298, -0.034095242619514465, 0.038873374462127686, 0.0031424630433321, -0.02910476177930832, 0.096489816904068 ]
201
201
Importance Weighted Active Learning
We present a practical and statistically consistent scheme for actively learning binary classifiers under general loss functions. Our algorithm uses importance weighting to correct sampling bias, and by controlling the variance, we are able to give rigorous label complexity bounds for the learning process. Experiments on passively labeled data show that this approach reduces the label complexity required to achieve good predictive performance on many learning problems.
[ -0.016528762876987457, 0.012464619241654873, 0.018688946962356567, 0.009088190272450447, 0.03194529935717583, -0.10719854384660721, -0.030388610437512398, 0.023806801065802574, -0.01623271219432354, 0.01777689903974533, -0.06148504093289375, 0.02297505922615528, -0.0432809516787529, -0.009600978344678879, 0.016993260011076927, 0.013890056870877743, 0.010490565560758114, -0.015765853226184845, 0.03604652360081673, -0.024547141045331955, 0.0023372999858111143, -0.013532663695514202, 0.006320499815046787, -0.04610632359981537, 0.03646872192621231, -0.05306988209486008, 0.0009948224760591984, 0.0197316762059927, -0.0054321312345564365, 0.00008221282041631639, -0.08064976334571838, -0.024909913539886475, 0.026933182030916214, 0.03081010840833187, -0.0001669909106567502, -0.03830021619796753, 0.03202449530363083, -0.07619019597768784, -0.07158099114894867, -0.012777082622051239, -0.014484201557934284, -0.021281424909830093, -0.021867765113711357, -0.0011865445412695408, -0.005504417698830366, 0.037655215710401535, 0.005193877499550581, -0.034882593899965286, 0.0014739034231752157, 0.039487432688474655, -0.11610472947359085, -0.005735471379011869, -0.017503947019577026, -0.05522151291370392, 0.04821412265300751, -0.03625642508268356, 0.0025026469957083464, -0.04890330880880356, -0.03274167329072952, -0.041507042944431305, 0.03085259720683098, 0.07955087721347809, -0.028339102864265442, -0.05719909816980362, -0.008700263686478138, -0.06295574456453323, -0.07205676287412643, -0.025381820276379585, -0.033540140837430954, 0.023022279143333435, 0.0173815730959177, -0.096982941031456, -0.0027836300432682037, 0.04818742349743843, 0.08233057707548141, -0.018836474046111107, -0.05648048222064972, 0.016316542401909828, 0.035073619335889816, -0.009526541456580162, -0.01935405842959881, -0.0074854264967143536, 0.0006150894332677126, 0.05781765654683113, -0.08785250782966614, -0.028976919129490852, 0.029387012124061584, -0.012586904689669609, 0.04510851204395294, 0.02320847474038601, -0.01530378870666027, 0.01436434406787157, -0.05397643893957138, -0.061406105756759644, -0.014813650399446487, 0.03101363591849804, 0.055770229548215866, -0.030996600165963173, 0.019402332603931427, 0.05512986332178116, 0.005555006675422192, 0.016690123826265335, 0.03860972821712494, 0.0452810600399971, -0.006855917163193226, -0.03291989490389824, -0.06749968975782394, 0.04182698577642441, 0.06425222009420395, 0.03524240106344223, 0.09118276834487915, -0.027137652039527893, 0.010436146520078182, 0.010714266449213028, -0.04240049794316292, -0.0063089937902987, -0.044211920350790024, 0.018374329432845116, 0.06881409883499146, 0.022663259878754616, 0.03867793083190918, 0.0040037548169493675, -0.0955495834350586, 0.020359516143798828, 0.01791352778673172, -0.021975703537464142, -0.016686538234353065, -0.06700397282838821, 0.08048688620328903, -0.006651474162936211, -0.06769529730081558, 0.015630044043064117, -0.07086291909217834, 0.026131821796298027, -0.03201762214303017, 0.012552361004054546, 0.0630238875746727, -0.061823420226573944, 0.002766295801848173, 0.04333265870809555, -0.06135363131761551, 0.02110692858695984, 0.0179248359054327, -0.002895704470574856, 0.024502260610461235, 0.04691525548696518, -0.020331596955657005, -0.037328653037548065, -0.03192856162786484, 0.024381320923566818, 0.0036087471526116133, -0.02828550711274147, 0.029347388073801994, 0.034159090369939804, 0.061769723892211914, -0.07609564810991287, 0.016719115898013115, 0.003172802273184061, -0.014318978413939476, -0.006740903481841087, -0.019727790728211403, 0.011604535393416882, 0.04117090255022049, 0.05937249958515167, -0.05295524373650551, 0.03331240639090538, -0.028318755328655243, -0.013575674965977669, -0.03004147671163082, -0.025960223749279976, -0.052210547029972076, 0.0030575150158256292, -0.006606339477002621, 0.011628394946455956, 0.09364326298236847, -0.02008960396051407, 0.022539513185620308, 0.024624895304441452, 0.04086913540959358, 0.04906788095831871, 0.08008958399295807, -0.017989765852689743, -0.03742459416389465, -0.008392831310629845, 0.06144259124994278, 0.024317262694239616, -0.02464720979332924, 0.01465228758752346, 0.0631757602095604, -0.03138894960284233, 0.005882014986127615, -0.002755779540166259, -0.011464206501841545, 0.03447618708014488, -0.05085878074169159, 0.03902969881892204, -0.022852972149848938, -0.031171586364507675, -0.027061542496085167, 0.06241629272699356, 0.027510536834597588, -0.0008255651337094605, -0.06136518344283104, -0.058694176375865936, -0.04011141508817673, 0.02045532688498497, 0.03152987360954285, -0.0671093761920929, -0.016536284238100052, -0.030430052429437637, -0.004677027929574251, 0.017546772956848145, 0.07472879439592361, 0.015179161913692951, -0.006575008388608694, -0.05847306549549103, -0.026176951825618744, 0.040990352630615234, 0.06770222634077072, 0.07919035106897354, 0.013831778429448605, -0.03933991864323616, -0.033349066972732544, 0.09400191158056259, -0.06142645329236984, 0.053451038897037506, 0.10841493308544159, -0.05238264426589012, -0.05073891580104828, 0.13256502151489258, -0.07170651853084564, -0.02145114541053772, -0.02843373268842697, -0.04588416963815689, -0.04579769819974899, 0.052472073584795, -0.06243424117565155, -0.012401334941387177, -0.019652077928185463, 0.022658610716462135, -0.06025271117687225, 0.05632372945547104, -0.02976340800523758, -0.026339733973145485, 0.044898662716150284, -0.0004614353529177606, 0.060547590255737305, -0.010223877616226673, -0.05611594393849373, 0.0005276962765492499, 0.0037068245001137257, -0.004637390840798616, -0.030675619840621948, -0.044115785509347916, 0.0541260726749897, 0.009129381738603115, 0.047319695353507996, 0.05327620357275009, 0.0783005803823471, 0.07481551170349121, 0.024394569918513298, 0.10426090657711029, -0.04915943369269371, -0.018536413088440895, 0.09658365696668625, -0.044336844235658646, -0.04290124401450157, -0.004317903891205788, 0.005285529885441065, -0.0032759730238467455, -0.07449144870042801, -0.056340064853429794, 0.019655365496873856, 0.06302418559789658, -0.04527916759252548, -0.03947729989886284, -0.05996061861515045, -0.031681910157203674, 0.07794243842363358, -0.01911957375705242, -0.06696213781833649, 0.022423628717660904, 0.06007508188486099, 0.022116219624876976, 0.04430750757455826, 0.008232614025473595, -0.03130144253373146, -0.060269445180892944, 0.07953200489282608, 0.026699459180235863, -0.02059265598654747, 0.012417047284543514, -0.03968052566051483, 0.0413898341357708, 0.06839717924594879, -0.07072275876998901, 0.05622059479355812, 0.02406522072851658, -0.002187742618843913, -0.0036809975281357765, 0.014022553339600563, 0.05305339768528938, 0.04673091322183609, 0.013847170397639275, 0.010060610249638557, 0.042370907962322235, 0.007828871719539165, 0.043845612555742264, -0.035055313259363174, 0.017202479764819145, -0.0036308506969362497, 0.017827648669481277, -0.044541917741298676, -0.024313850328326225, -0.028436819091439247, 0.0038046282716095448, 0.0028301533311605453, -0.0472165122628212, -0.03362235799431801, -0.04618801549077034, 0.01642483100295067, -0.026093555614352226, -0.009583708830177784, -0.0634259581565857, -0.05899319425225258, -0.06734786182641983, -0.013416205532848835, 0.0628216564655304, -0.07806317508220673, 0.05506112426519394, -0.04659741371870041, 0.02495872601866722, 0.015112222172319889, 0.10405543446540833, -0.018211770802736282, 0.02160157449543476, -0.03883877024054527, 0.07393445819616318, -0.03521259129047394, -0.006066713482141495, -0.0235028937458992, -0.0217979047447443, -0.05602366849780083, 0.026976564899086952, -0.019620845094323158, 0.003356953151524067, 0.10104990005493164, 0.00008587392221670598, -0.019467279314994812, 0.07021971046924591, -0.09512877464294434, 0.07890916615724564, -0.08774162828922272, 0.06600217521190643, -0.0052210246212780476, 0.0755213052034378, 0.04149416461586952, -0.057971470057964325, 0.03194161131978035, -0.014163707382977009, 0.012836955487728119, 0.03590426594018936, -0.021058188751339912, -0.00002425788807158824, -0.025718921795487404, 0.019053848460316658, -0.008910088799893856, 0.005685025360435247, -0.015142662450671196, -0.014251073822379112, 0.018022365868091583, 0.013260248117148876, 0.031062051653862, 0.03315211459994316, 0.07294994592666626, -0.003080191556364298, 0.014157441444694996, -0.06770510226488113, -0.028806254267692566, 0.08511843532323837, -0.04221021756529808, -0.02557339332997799, -0.027272814884781837, -0.008792257867753506, -0.037531137466430664, -0.06493498384952545, -0.06722931563854218, -0.041501112282276154, 0.07812310010194778, -0.012908906675875187, 0.012482899241149426, -0.0822477862238884, -0.0013259650440886617, 0.0008802824304439127, -0.011006955057382584, -0.014121429063379765, -0.026086943224072456, 0.007936637848615646, 0.022961560636758804, -0.04729092866182327, -0.07681332528591156, -0.02055494859814644, 0.03319597244262695, -0.12573814392089844, -0.07587593048810959, 0.053376518189907074, 0.050696298480033875, 0.060186658054590225, 0.05303899943828583, 0.06532290577888489, 0.02140950597822666, 0.0005734600126743317, -0.009857531636953354, 0.027290770784020424, -0.024500565603375435, 0.058452144265174866, 0.019976845011115074, -0.02712918631732464, 0.028776809573173523, -0.07047519087791443, 0.03860580921173096, 0.026062585413455963, 0.03916627913713455, -0.0031482456251978874, 0.008743898011744022, 0.10714040696620941, 0.01708223670721054, 0.03465072810649872, -0.03908548504114151, 0.09715251624584198, -0.00510984705761075, -0.00456357141956687, -0.07032585889101028, 0.05364508181810379, 0.005123968236148357, 0.01689574308693409, 0.06536181271076202, 0.038297899067401886, -0.04395629093050957, -0.0011643661418929696, -0.10114075243473053, 0.020514925941824913, 0.0337456613779068, 0.028675314038991928, 0.04341365024447441, 0.08318612724542618, 0.009926208294928074, 0.00697110453620553, 0.08946393430233002, 0.02843921072781086, 0.003106168005615473, 0.00013507458788808435, 0.047552336007356644, -0.044121142476797104, -0.02228577807545662, -0.008926653303205967, -0.02476586028933525, -0.04980209097266197, 0.06524146348237991, -0.03820134326815605, -0.0032293873373419046, -0.05474412813782692, 0.007688607554882765, 0.011249583214521408, -0.08446208387613297, -0.001134292921051383, -0.034134119749069214, -0.047773655503988266, 0.026357615366578102, -0.04365787282586098, -0.032336004078388214, -0.009971337392926216, -0.030658382922410965, -0.06458316743373871, 0.0075170560739934444, 0.018834169954061508, -0.03295058012008667, -0.0633227527141571, 0.05948926880955696, 0.027114104479551315, 0.07896237075328827, -0.08107912540435791, 0.03654124587774277, 0.06770212203264236, 0.03513308987021446, 0.03444559872150421, -0.026402145624160767, 0.0693708136677742, 0.002263903385028243, 0.02541474625468254, 0.022553833201527596, -0.03238612413406372, 0.009472829289734364, 0.029126303270459175, 0.007915119640529156, -0.043128881603479385, 0.004562176298350096, 0.014258756302297115, 0.04418163374066353, 0.10147427767515182, 0.09194447100162506, -0.022655373439192772, 0.07070247828960419, -0.00026698620058596134, 0.030338462442159653, 0.0016738689737394452, 0.03146855905652046, 0.015954019501805305, 0.046424366533756256, 0.014333946630358696, -0.03715561330318451, 0.01509298849850893 ]
202
202
A New Clustering Algorithm Based Upon Flocking On Complex Network
We have proposed a model based upon flocking on a complex network, and then developed two clustering algorithms on the basis of it. In the algorithms, firstly a \textit{k}-nearest neighbor (knn) graph as a weighted and directed graph is produced among all data points in a dataset each of which is regarded as an agent who can move in space, and then a time-varying complex network is created by adding long-range links for each data point. Furthermore, each data point is not only acted by its \textit{k} nearest neighbors but also \textit{r} long-range neighbors through fields established in space by them together, so it will take a step along the direction of the vector sum of all fields. It is more important that these long-range links provides some hidden information for each data point when it moves and at the same time accelerate its speed converging to a center. As they move in space according to the proposed model, data points that belong to the same class are located at a same position gradually, whereas those that belong to different classes are away from one another. Consequently, the experimental results have demonstrated that data points in datasets are clustered reasonably and efficiently, and the rates of convergence of clustering algorithms are fast enough. Moreover, the comparison with other algorithms also provides an indication of the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
[ -0.05481623858213425, -0.036028310656547546, 0.014777450822293758, 0.033612556755542755, 0.050224702805280685, -0.020299414172768593, 0.024984026327729225, -0.045410655438899994, -0.10213325172662735, 0.06166119873523712, 0.004757240414619446, -0.03838731348514557, -0.01982998475432396, 0.026046937331557274, 0.0359908789396286, -0.021577561274170876, -0.03702933341264725, 0.05083591490983963, 0.0501871295273304, -0.06590992212295532, 0.06946122646331787, -0.06768503785133362, 0.0065255919471383095, 0.027356181293725967, -0.02126145549118519, -0.072182796895504, -0.006896882317960262, -0.034167829900979996, -0.0027869383338838816, 0.04418221116065979, 0.00210018758662045, 0.025834040716290474, 0.06469697505235672, 0.01870478130877018, 0.008609521202743053, -0.03712080419063568, 0.006854028441011906, 0.00404726667329669, -0.05036165192723274, -0.07239974290132523, -0.04092733934521675, -0.012838316150009632, -0.0017544953152537346, 0.03275115042924881, 0.00494705606251955, 0.014650397002696991, 0.0025887140072882175, 0.01480407640337944, -0.011120029725134373, 0.02668003924190998, -0.10912756621837616, 0.050784241408109665, -0.03942134976387024, 0.029383182525634766, -0.06009196117520332, 0.052771806716918945, -0.05707123875617981, -0.0006881761364638805, -0.007923783734440804, -0.03884414583444595, 0.040152281522750854, 0.03514588624238968, -0.05238114669919014, -0.020835964009165764, -0.07382876425981522, 0.028829246759414673, 0.06484795361757278, -0.01692931354045868, -0.04252944886684418, -0.000931720482185483, 0.04164668917655945, -0.008305821567773819, -0.0059982710517942905, 0.044254105538129807, -0.0070999134331941605, 0.020031563937664032, -0.013449483551084995, 0.017850156873464584, 0.0334283784031868, 0.04101960361003876, -0.06874414533376694, 0.0026851205620914698, -0.05856553092598915, -0.009010547772049904, -0.013865029439330101, -0.029425494372844696, 0.09947173297405243, -0.05696364492177963, 0.0028156002517789602, 0.025551047176122665, -0.03865664824843407, -0.027184469625353813, -0.0569152906537056, 0.005097907967865467, -0.020477306097745895, 0.03201562911272049, -0.07251482456922531, 0.007945982739329338, 0.05374525859951973, 0.04510325565934181, -0.07711786031723022, 0.006813919637352228, 0.0780201330780983, 0.05949966982007027, 0.03451002761721611, -0.010376361198723316, -0.06038382649421692, 0.03519465774297714, 0.048551227897405624, -0.048584435135126114, 0.03270089253783226, -0.0000828727352200076, -0.04321715608239174, 0.006826288532465696, -0.028244270011782646, 0.030434533953666687, -0.002248532837256789, 0.0719514712691307, -0.08181164413690567, -0.014381399378180504, -0.01572125032544136, -0.07126055657863617, -0.040805574506521225, 0.05685289576649666, 0.006427462678402662, -0.08258478343486786, -0.050958432257175446, 0.03115868754684925, 0.07404760271310806, 0.01893925853073597, -0.06022162362933159, 0.013036441057920456, -0.03852003067731857, 0.0035407922696322203, -0.08923353254795074, -0.0038001982029527426, 0.06913802027702332, -0.0295571256428957, 0.006368409376591444, 0.0716356486082077, -0.0556064210832119, -0.04200967401266098, -0.054535895586013794, -0.01585405133664608, 0.0828932374715805, 0.015615819953382015, -0.003781229257583618, 0.020569361746311188, 0.038316842168569565, 0.01822960190474987, 0.03253117948770523, -0.03911607339978218, 0.0002869252348318696, 0.04295280948281288, 0.009095343761146069, 0.028196370229125023, -0.09834427386522293, -0.03330456092953682, 0.008096392266452312, 0.05499466508626938, -0.005337764974683523, 0.05395227670669556, -0.016840726137161255, -0.050797250121831894, 0.020837876945734024, 0.03823518380522728, -0.02629849687218666, -0.005432140547782183, -0.013639295473694801, -0.042988285422325134, 0.01936311274766922, 0.010367357172071934, -0.012081698514521122, -0.011051831766963005, 0.05338367074728012, 0.013835002668201923, -0.03203805908560753, 0.02631639875471592, -0.017371488735079765, 0.04181712120771408, 0.06542231887578964, -0.03828112408518791, -0.041273441165685654, 0.07002885639667511, 0.11896167695522308, 0.1301593780517578, 0.041165899485349655, 0.04405124485492706, 0.0004725394828710705, -0.04032137244939804, -0.020392276346683502, 0.04919914901256561, 0.05653137341141701, -0.062264274805784225, -0.08053839206695557, 0.09041257202625275, 0.004277083091437817, -0.0500272773206234, 0.04044095426797867, 0.032923828810453415, -0.0006557549932040274, 0.011682200245559216, -0.043426305055618286, -0.032637182623147964, -0.06692440807819366, -0.07660837471485138, 0.044169746339321136, -0.053440503776073456, -0.06459971517324448, -0.04527018964290619, 0.02726234868168831, -0.03232874721288681, 0.0017454021144658327, 0.00033857105881907046, -0.021883342415094376, -0.019576044753193855, -0.12273512035608292, -0.07267720997333527, 0.03913917765021324, -0.008053232915699482, -0.03871183097362518, -0.02901572547852993, -0.05370284616947174, 0.006526458542793989, -0.048041895031929016, 0.02490583248436451, 0.010407454334199429, -0.005776226986199617, -0.07484058290719986, 0.007437468972057104, -0.05839487165212631, -0.013275520876049995, 0.017314832657575607, 0.06446115672588348, 0.032458554953336716, 0.019694071263074875, -0.04399607330560684, 0.02835312858223915, -0.050823941826820374, -0.048100899904966354, -0.04891961067914963, 0.04220171645283699, -0.0546015240252018, -0.021093815565109253, 0.04998653009533882, -0.05491761490702629, 0.011694196611642838, 0.03832407668232918, -0.02518306113779545, 0.006333447527140379, 0.011563185602426529, 0.04742618277668953, -0.05121647194027901, -0.007526728790253401, 0.010763848200440407, 0.049868326634168625, 0.03259927034378052, 0.04230060428380966, 0.10409438610076904, 0.06904196739196777, 0.04718242213129997, 0.04454706609249115, 0.003458986058831215, 0.028866786509752274, 0.03782862424850464, -0.03354126960039139, 0.020822856575250626, 0.0753757506608963, -0.017537211999297142, -0.016385454684495926, 0.05118979513645172, -0.04488714039325714, -0.0705273225903511, 0.07231346517801285, -0.06499001383781433, -0.09057296812534332, -0.011062441393733025, 0.036818865686655045, -0.06697630137205124, -0.08870913833379745, -0.004773256368935108, -0.011092581786215305, 0.0037482145708054304, -0.05588075891137123, -0.0789325088262558, -0.0394522100687027, -0.09708695113658905, -0.04864370822906494, 0.020578663796186447, -0.020787866786122322, -0.05355309695005417, 0.013396176509559155, -0.0991135984659195, -0.07910611480474472, -0.027341092005372047, -0.09925006330013275, 0.05088924989104271, 0.051516540348529816, 0.02624429762363434, 0.009660321287810802, -0.02964206412434578, -0.01625841110944748, 0.016555357724428177, 0.06680498272180557, -0.02793327160179615, 0.07397200167179108, 0.03668076545000076, 0.044714026153087616, -0.06749197095632553, 0.024491552263498306, -0.02709210105240345, 0.03861300274729729, -0.04754548519849777, -0.04194438084959984, 0.03702450543642044, 0.06732629239559174, -0.003339441493153572, 0.02809716947376728, -0.06649769097566605, 0.046857766807079315, 0.06987231969833374, -0.052408959716558456, 0.019821949303150177, 0.002362531842663884, -0.023793550208210945, -0.037718966603279114, -0.0031281777191907167, 0.03796489164233208, 0.04755751043558121, 0.012127304449677467, -0.10892192274332047, 0.03409586101770401, -0.0576862171292305, 0.03890141099691391, 0.01097057480365038, -0.019701093435287476, -0.03882709518074989, -0.02515149861574173, -0.02974216267466545, 0.039593327790498734, 0.012253867462277412, -0.027505841106176376, 0.03916711360216141, -0.0024017372634261847, 0.017642442137002945, 0.04580899700522423, 0.0664929747581482, -0.018193384632468224, -0.008553994819521904, -0.008751694113016129, -0.08962500095367432, 0.06039278954267502, -0.06805247068405151, -0.003365518292412162, -0.012274844571948051, 0.08277678489685059, 0.011282197199761868, 0.009864479303359985, 0.015715621411800385, -0.025127900764346123, 0.008715013042092323, 0.002117064781486988, -0.04865178093314171, 0.03979004919528961, 0.017813371494412422, 0.02751191519200802, -0.0009096236317418516, 0.01124689169228077, -0.04074200242757797, -0.06501725316047668, 0.07347719371318817, -0.006077492143958807, -0.02359023503959179, -0.03666058927774429, 0.030928827822208405, -0.08154713362455368, -0.013622290454804897, -0.011580443941056728, -0.03725194185972214, 0.05747965723276138, 0.0033596199937164783, 0.029038812965154648, -0.03191201016306877, 0.004216043744236231, 0.021702388301491737, 0.013685266487300396, 0.026056412607431412, 0.0007158049265854061, 0.03606615588068962, 0.017122676596045494, 0.016821671277284622, -0.05202889069914818, 0.002592833014205098, 0.031200077384710312, 0.003538991091772914, -0.020802894607186317, -0.02784578502178192, -0.02275744639337063, 0.02375657856464386, -0.03231175243854523, -0.04927394166588783, -0.04678906872868538, -0.08690711110830307, -0.0867934599518776, -0.10393760353326797, 0.0010231269989162683, -0.05732851102948189, 0.05539654567837715, 0.0741809830069542, 0.0707162544131279, 0.02144494280219078, 0.010759261436760426, -0.08384652435779572, 0.04303612932562828, -0.03529813513159752, 0.010084562934935093, -0.010813269764184952, -0.003043488832190633, 0.02252374030649662, -0.0065130009315907955, -0.06761538982391357, 0.025209909304976463, 0.041694819927215576, 0.02639065869152546, -0.05884220078587532, 0.005982669070363045, 0.0394071489572525, 0.023634890094399452, 0.05879862233996391, 0.00850170198827982, -0.03696360066533089, 0.013343377970159054, 0.001709916046820581, -0.01286690216511488, 0.04338688403367996, -0.006079470738768578, 0.02618567645549774, -0.04082570970058441, -0.032027363777160645, 0.0537039153277874, 0.08703263849020004, -0.0024710267316550016, -0.03318284451961517, -0.013233758509159088, 0.032185737043619156, 0.03890957310795784, -0.03460234776139259, 0.023035898804664612, 0.08723531663417816, 0.009187743999063969, -0.013769394718110561, -0.029093552380800247, 0.05854354426264763, -0.02940225787460804, 0.02781650796532631, 0.0042799594812095165, 0.04315716028213501, 0.0042525241151452065, 0.057561084628105164, -0.08626307547092438, -0.024928877130150795, -0.06692944467067719, 0.052393317222595215, -0.0006844219169579446, -0.030126042664051056, 0.0028824247419834137, 0.004063562024384737, 0.016468733549118042, 0.061010751873254776, -0.026475299149751663, -0.05100258067250252, 0.023135585710406303, -0.0009743685950525105, -0.054577864706516266, -0.034003302454948425, 0.013267198577523232, 0.02407168038189411, 0.018715519458055496, -0.07634245604276657, -0.015918515622615814, 0.03856918588280678, 0.04721926525235176, 0.05884842202067375, 0.015818346291780472, 0.06580978631973267, -0.02148059569299221, 0.017046084627509117, 0.04705480858683586, 0.04104771837592125, 0.022934766486287117, 0.019842464476823807, -0.07775275409221649, 0.022603856399655342, -0.014792163856327534, -0.017970241606235504, -0.03159914165735245, 0.04975368082523346, 0.012929115444421768, -0.06427355855703354, 0.07077226042747498, 0.05527788773179054, 0.012374205514788628, -0.00010146282147616148, -0.010045438073575497, 0.04726824536919594, -0.014464471489191055, 0.06125939264893532, -0.06670177727937698, -0.057760898023843765, 0.0212041474878788, -0.031138760969042778, -0.0004002059285994619 ]
203
203
A Novel Clustering Algorithm Based Upon Games on Evolving Network
This paper introduces a model based upon games on an evolving network, and develops three clustering algorithms according to it. In the clustering algorithms, data points for clustering are regarded as players who can make decisions in games. On the network describing relationships among data points, an edge-removing-and-rewiring (ERR) function is employed to explore in a neighborhood of a data point, which removes edges connecting to neighbors with small payoffs, and creates new edges to neighbors with larger payoffs. As such, the connections among data points vary over time. During the evolution of network, some strategies are spread in the network. As a consequence, clusters are formed automatically, in which data points with the same evolutionarily stable strategy are collected as a cluster, so the number of evolutionarily stable strategies indicates the number of clusters. Moreover, the experimental results have demonstrated that data points in datasets are clustered reasonably and efficiently, and the comparison with other algorithms also provides an indication of the effectiveness of the proposed algorithms.
[ -0.10488217324018478, -0.04382767528295517, -0.012995492666959763, 0.036875102669000626, -0.007886623963713646, -0.09366410970687866, 0.032644420862197876, -0.05014681816101074, -0.03703233599662781, -0.023081308230757713, 0.032606951892375946, -0.047700367867946625, 0.005417151842266321, 0.008238033391535282, 0.04562199488282204, 0.01211603544652462, -0.01768636889755726, -0.00025846267817541957, 0.02436450682580471, -0.04025110602378845, 0.018262984231114388, -0.06321865320205688, 0.015911618247628212, 0.020959459245204926, -0.03039027936756611, -0.04902080073952675, 0.02125130593776703, -0.029830846935510635, -0.041136905550956726, 0.03391604870557785, 0.009375814348459244, 0.027996525168418884, 0.011181109584867954, 0.031469061970710754, 0.007126726675778627, -0.08050969988107681, 0.027345852926373482, -0.04884932562708855, -0.010135749354958534, -0.04558831825852394, -0.028783898800611496, -0.012120639905333519, -0.05930979177355766, 0.0243034940212965, 0.004133644048124552, 0.020421229302883148, 0.009786613285541534, 0.05736109986901283, 0.02285025455057621, 0.07974959164857864, -0.15868504345417023, 0.004805090371519327, -0.021258477121591568, -0.07161474227905273, -0.015929197892546654, 0.05518601834774017, -0.08740450441837311, 0.050501637160778046, -0.0855116918683052, -0.05566912144422531, 0.07122085988521576, 0.039561424404382706, -0.05613061785697937, 0.002343989908695221, -0.03817451000213623, 0.0062781511805951595, 0.039191316813230515, -0.013168754987418652, -0.02549724467098713, -0.07162002474069595, 0.039003659039735794, 0.040736425668001175, 0.02366432547569275, 0.008937792852520943, -0.05226743221282959, 0.051348526030778885, -0.018051354214549065, 0.007388581987470388, -0.005193779245018959, 0.0624532550573349, -0.07695178687572479, -0.0473807118833065, -0.029542353004217148, 0.052782781422138214, -0.009655713103711605, 0.01974751614034176, 0.062331464141607285, -0.05080907791852951, -0.016733957454562187, 0.013554427772760391, -0.03298703953623772, -0.0502968393266201, -0.07019481062889099, 0.01758320815861225, -0.011578281410038471, 0.07871835678815842, -0.160986989736557, -0.006450507789850235, 0.0157187357544899, 0.06584155559539795, -0.0421454980969429, -0.03205055743455887, 0.0367598719894886, 0.08642829954624176, -0.008367292582988739, 0.028806835412979126, -0.05322880670428276, 0.05529734864830971, 0.060732342302799225, -0.031193196773529053, 0.02113480493426323, -0.045070432126522064, -0.02691436931490898, 0.06067781150341034, -0.00624707480892539, 0.06760503351688385, -0.018599139526486397, 0.06268970668315887, -0.052865587174892426, 0.008280046284198761, 0.03743049502372742, 0.007745442911982536, -0.04114564508199692, -0.019246967509388924, -0.028884105384349823, -0.04586297273635864, -0.07463563233613968, 0.024098575115203857, 0.07231341302394867, 0.030813073739409447, -0.07232128828763962, 0.024806369096040726, -0.13175898790359497, -0.10251901298761368, -0.026674233376979828, 0.016289660707116127, 0.07541827112436295, 0.005619911942631006, 0.04256315901875496, 0.029544245451688766, 0.005674482323229313, -0.023738132789731026, -0.056452132761478424, 0.00942071434110403, 0.03132697939872742, 0.010066889226436615, -0.019128646701574326, 0.07124338299036026, 0.04064294695854187, 0.05071477219462395, 0.001071090460754931, -0.038111232221126556, -0.0008776242611929774, 0.04668985307216644, 0.008051733486354351, 0.011814393103122711, -0.09824537485837936, -0.054150041192770004, 0.008083812892436981, 0.0128221046179533, -0.04087905213236809, 0.009372027590870857, -0.01264148112386465, -0.07172135263681412, 0.004137461539357901, -0.0020276899449527264, -0.02298298478126526, 0.007603832054883242, -0.007131698075681925, -0.041823744773864746, -0.02623174898326397, -0.006213946733623743, -0.03900354728102684, -0.029788373038172722, 0.058413561433553696, -0.024430708959698677, 0.030570756644010544, 0.02576972171664238, -0.02709897793829441, -0.02412586100399494, -0.00766154658049345, -0.02047610841691494, -0.0019602100364863873, 0.002647377783432603, 0.08821085840463638, 0.08977051079273224, 0.06171160563826561, 0.03432955965399742, 0.002652726136147976, 0.07146035879850388, -0.027072584256529808, 0.007610774133354425, 0.01287823636084795, 0.008341467939317226, -0.045415136963129044, 0.07340417057275772, -0.02469082921743393, -0.03173597902059555, 0.04227307438850403, -0.0016885650111362338, -0.015277656726539135, 0.009524744004011154, -0.08082284778356552, 0.0026664845645427704, -0.044736530631780624, -0.028722655028104782, 0.033501241356134415, -0.023012282326817513, -0.10198622941970825, -0.0217099878937006, -0.007764323148876429, -0.009958945214748383, -0.06567297875881195, -0.031563401222229004, 0.006056439131498337, 0.03885366767644882, -0.14148452877998352, -0.07276708632707596, 0.10765684396028519, -0.0062469239346683025, -0.08293935656547546, 0.029956679791212082, -0.06932958960533142, 0.028059624135494232, -0.06618640571832657, 0.029044240713119507, 0.033086590468883514, 0.04787338897585869, -0.0857531875371933, -0.0011174138635396957, -0.06391917169094086, -0.06297194957733154, -0.05146145075559616, 0.03541706129908562, -0.031021589413285255, 0.04724045842885971, -0.06926855444908142, 0.008056990802288055, -0.03160201385617256, -0.01772853545844555, -0.02630043588578701, 0.025635872036218643, 0.029039302840828896, -0.02725440450012684, 0.05972221493721008, -0.02097112312912941, 0.0318215936422348, 0.027227364480495453, -0.06754080951213837, -0.06597383320331573, 0.013055598363280296, 0.045544855296611786, -0.04442950338125229, 0.033115800470113754, 0.05185588449239731, -0.021562911570072174, -0.01303826179355383, 0.014921381138265133, 0.08227018266916275, 0.022772282361984253, 0.03111116774380207, 0.01839464344084263, 0.02700367197394371, -0.031473807990550995, 0.09683232009410858, 0.03191642090678215, 0.00662177475169301, 0.06522947549819946, 0.024288691580295563, 0.02277008444070816, -0.007135630585253239, -0.040146276354789734, -0.0602213479578495, 0.08904121071100235, -0.03606831282377243, -0.0658537894487381, 0.0043502007611095905, 0.016147149726748466, -0.04240715131163597, -0.05480958893895149, -0.05170680582523346, 0.02538091316819191, 0.04007949307560921, -0.03161110728979111, 0.002775348722934723, -0.016439257189631462, -0.017474904656410217, -0.02598891593515873, 0.03775421530008316, 0.05322758108377457, -0.03924253210425377, -0.04387242719531059, -0.03597262501716614, -0.04947866126894951, 0.02242933213710785, -0.03173420950770378, 0.05367080122232437, 0.04755554348230362, -0.036620378494262695, -0.035249847918748856, -0.014323506504297256, 0.02220078743994236, 0.0028986812103539705, 0.04135441407561302, -0.029838694259524345, 0.06191154941916466, 0.007180411368608475, 0.08246532827615738, -0.06884533166885376, -0.029342496767640114, -0.014553171582520008, -0.005407923832535744, -0.021636929363012314, -0.03806706890463829, 0.003092175116762519, 0.06142250448465347, 0.012832826003432274, 0.004903719760477543, -0.03365662693977356, 0.034133799374103546, 0.00855281762778759, -0.05469047278165817, -0.012318472377955914, -0.03954096883535385, -0.052680082619190216, -0.027752453461289406, -0.02482825703918934, 0.039626624435186386, 0.016352085396647453, -0.0064044794999063015, -0.09878268092870712, 0.00006441488221753389, -0.0023652594536542892, 0.04837062582373619, -0.02189762145280838, 0.01369086466729641, -0.012935970909893513, -0.027276767417788506, -0.0064114537090063095, 0.055389367043972015, -0.051724307239055634, -0.04296780005097389, -0.040224604308605194, -0.020789645612239838, 0.005030813626945019, 0.03371604159474373, 0.03072836995124817, 0.053037263453006744, -0.011870474554598331, 0.009114345535635948, -0.067101389169693, -0.020106103271245956, -0.08888120949268341, -0.0030323793180286884, -0.05751338228583336, 0.044221118092536926, 0.020557235926389694, 0.06847484409809113, 0.013955138623714447, -0.01614200323820114, -0.02091841585934162, -0.0033553228713572025, -0.010287530720233917, 0.00598933594301343, 0.037776295095682144, 0.05186427757143974, -0.014673899859189987, -0.022325091063976288, 0.02021552249789238, -0.08435231447219849, 0.048297200351953506, 0.002234505955129862, -0.045200761407613754, -0.01312665082514286, 0.0038759219460189342, -0.08416036516427994, -0.011491143144667149, -0.006665575318038464, 0.008553306572139263, 0.08899077028036118, -0.009266352280974388, 0.03321054205298424, -0.00020210455113556236, -0.06049278378486633, 0.06211249902844429, -0.04631614312529564, 0.038676124066114426, -0.006167749874293804, 0.03258870914578438, 0.032814476639032364, 0.03480171412229538, -0.05786851420998573, -0.008224407210946083, 0.06281951814889908, -0.009732259437441826, -0.04087495058774948, -0.015851614996790886, 0.017690280452370644, 0.02128690853714943, 0.004078712314367294, -0.058410171419382095, -0.07536768168210983, -0.03964093700051308, -0.04584917426109314, -0.05602429062128067, 0.002530655125156045, -0.03753635287284851, 0.04595990478992462, 0.01767977885901928, 0.030865425243973732, -0.001910134102217853, 0.03009883128106594, -0.05249766632914543, -0.03337184339761734, 0.0027801585383713245, 0.021275486797094345, 0.06344038993120193, 0.020005928352475166, 0.03872283548116684, -0.05158020555973053, -0.02305659092962742, -0.02376795932650566, 0.022092079743742943, 0.006891933269798756, -0.04866044223308563, 0.012441841885447502, 0.011552302166819572, 0.012041944079101086, 0.06365908682346344, 0.11467999219894409, -0.05645154416561127, -0.043368853628635406, -0.039013903588056564, -0.03185649216175079, 0.027101607993245125, -0.01927797682583332, 0.0423712357878685, -0.06599204242229462, -0.02451401762664318, 0.009049645625054836, 0.03663363307714462, -0.006964029278606176, -0.05301331728696823, -0.020147057250142097, -0.02725970558822155, 0.02624945156276226, -0.0058202059008181095, -0.023741982877254486, 0.023397259414196014, 0.019499706104397774, 0.00714187091216445, 0.04639734700322151, 0.05419961363077164, -0.01971295289695263, 0.08539918065071106, 0.015946462750434875, 0.03546791523694992, 0.009497635066509247, -0.035372622311115265, -0.15092003345489502, -0.06585582345724106, -0.031306058168411255, 0.018916627392172813, -0.0022794839460402727, -0.01461566798388958, 0.0008715707226656377, -0.016437092795968056, -0.02812083624303341, 0.02524792030453682, -0.009962351992726326, -0.026409847661852837, -0.01605180837213993, 0.052622467279434204, -0.08334663510322571, 0.008620845153927803, 0.04503616318106651, 0.025609005242586136, -0.006832302547991276, -0.047813478857278824, -0.03477650135755539, 0.023492181673645973, 0.05925869941711426, 0.0660872533917427, 0.07071811705827713, 0.07185697555541992, -0.07740473747253418, -0.04214756563305855, 0.01646692119538784, 0.02941627986729145, -0.03843418508768082, 0.01572500541806221, -0.032312434166669846, 0.019077135249972343, 0.02088119462132454, 0.007219392340630293, -0.018301542848348618, 0.09706158936023712, -0.007192016113549471, 0.027967067435383797, 0.06660615652799606, 0.017610643059015274, 0.019177431240677834, 0.013833120465278625, -0.027863092720508575, 0.042368195950984955, 0.013571376912295818, 0.08304060995578766, 0.030575856566429138, -0.024812178686261177, 0.032640811055898666, -0.020263908430933952, 0.05722811445593834 ]
204
204
MIMO decoding based on stochastic reconstruction from multiple projections
Least squares (LS) fitting is one of the most fundamental techniques in science and engineering. It is used to estimate parameters from multiple noisy observations. In many problems the parameters are known a-priori to be bounded integer valued, or they come from a finite set of values on an arbitrary finite lattice. In this case finding the closest vector becomes NP-Hard problem. In this paper we propose a novel algorithm, the Tomographic Least Squares Decoder (TLSD), that not only solves the ILS problem, better than other sub-optimal techniques, but also is capable of providing the a-posteriori probability distribution for each element in the solution vector. The algorithm is based on reconstruction of the vector from multiple two-dimensional projections. The projections are carefully chosen to provide low computational complexity. Unlike other iterative techniques, such as the belief propagation, the proposed algorithm has ensured convergence. We also provide simulated experiments comparing the algorithm to other sub-optimal algorithms.
[ 0.0270911306142807, -0.014860295690596104, 0.0034267865121364594, -0.036402955651283264, 0.01735541597008705, -0.037261962890625, 0.033427730202674866, -0.04048372805118561, -0.01421996671706438, 0.12330217659473419, -0.026809172704815865, -0.02281610667705536, -0.025288790464401245, 0.014674903824925423, -0.021168377250432968, -0.04084945097565651, -0.01507793553173542, 0.004681597929447889, 0.019884806126356125, 0.005628169048577547, -0.02375541441142559, -0.05346469581127167, -0.001339229173026979, -0.04203648120164871, 0.0937948003411293, 0.017081838101148605, -0.045462701469659805, 0.05083347111940384, 0.04716627299785614, 0.017784535884857178, -0.06161519140005112, 0.09010850638151169, -0.010690273717045784, -0.05271830037236214, 0.003995469305664301, -0.06104925647377968, 0.09447416663169861, 0.01190195046365261, 0.0004923704545944929, -0.01876593567430973, 0.009438477456569672, 0.019365333020687103, 0.002641538390889764, 0.02188562974333763, 0.04759600758552551, 0.045822739601135254, 0.06043755263090134, 0.005264254752546549, -0.0597345232963562, 0.0007243790314532816, -0.032366879284381866, 0.029089897871017456, -0.0271792970597744, 0.027806967496871948, 0.03186875581741333, 0.020902499556541443, -0.001554116839542985, -0.04943191632628441, -0.045510146766901016, 0.007625938858836889, 0.010108180344104767, 0.10593956708908081, -0.025095408782362938, -0.03401848301291466, -0.012250323779881, -0.04615266993641853, -0.05616247281432152, -0.027570147067308426, -0.05046640709042549, -0.04857442528009415, 0.03619049862027168, -0.05985517054796219, -0.008920283988118172, -0.06921958178281784, 0.07309435307979584, -0.03140438720583916, 0.05133366212248802, 0.02999233268201351, 0.045801687985658646, 0.07536302506923676, 0.008838283829391003, -0.023959172889590263, 0.03601858392357826, 0.0015104638878256083, -0.09931892901659012, 0.044577185064554214, -0.004734190646559, 0.03166578710079193, -0.03060297481715679, -0.001744624343700707, -0.05241706967353821, 0.04393146187067032, -0.04087720066308975, 0.00031048370874486864, -0.09846742451190948, -0.010885963216423988, 0.012159541249275208, -0.008971749804913998, -0.04106142744421959, 0.08767431974411011, 0.021338732913136482, 0.022450130432844162, 0.014368241652846336, 0.05336114391684532, -0.0009673922904767096, 0.015252802520990372, -0.052037712186574936, 0.09782806038856506, -0.0010130037553608418, 0.01960129104554653, -0.013278395868837833, 0.021530693396925926, 0.042694829404354095, -0.014568214304745197, -0.0016273538349196315, 0.048956334590911865, 0.05753658711910248, 0.0729365274310112, -0.010043825954198837, 0.009864339604973793, 0.009066782891750336, 0.04056643694639206, 0.07267480343580246, 0.041731636971235275, 0.054816946387290955, -0.02641572430729866, 0.012197515927255154, -0.08175625652074814, 0.0636477917432785, 0.005515678785741329, -0.07047028094530106, -0.0385383740067482, -0.0037610160652548075, 0.10644428431987762, -0.10751140117645264, 0.007482861168682575, -0.0391787588596344, -0.08397118747234344, -0.0026528986636549234, 0.02450830303132534, 0.04900656268000603, -0.030978765338659286, -0.013169455341994762, 0.005423631519079208, -0.03546682000160217, -0.0186147540807724, -0.10328313708305359, -0.012218810617923737, -0.027303533628582954, 0.013670495711266994, -0.02225610427558422, -0.05029846727848053, 0.03705061972141266, 0.00007132020982680842, 0.03912453353404999, -0.08214568346738815, 0.016704479232430458, -0.12556204199790955, 0.024039966985583305, 0.08073971420526505, -0.09331721067428589, -0.006642685271799564, 0.015321859158575535, 0.042717017233371735, -0.0008081324049271643, -0.020320508629083633, 0.07613309472799301, -0.12358307093381882, 0.0120223518460989, -0.06772726774215698, -0.01051915530115366, 0.05917908623814583, -0.037056878209114075, -0.028518762439489365, -0.0006288106669671834, -0.0330248661339283, 0.03310326114296913, -0.014559847302734852, -0.04805441200733185, -0.00743007380515337, 0.011038083583116531, -0.031084245070815086, -0.02371797151863575, 0.027675269171595573, 0.024935517460107803, 0.06549269706010818, 0.0280909463763237, 0.04633083567023277, 0.02106691710650921, -0.03572279214859009, 0.06382797658443451, 0.0059650009498000145, 0.004665839951485395, -0.004848383367061615, 0.007984044961631298, 0.06259175390005112, -0.02450547181069851, -0.036532990634441376, 0.012569911777973175, 0.054956842213869095, 0.02370183914899826, -0.017088642343878746, -0.020594263449311256, -0.10736379772424698, -0.06859031319618225, -0.006441914010792971, 0.00725430715829134, -0.08127059042453766, 0.03598961979150772, -0.010137609206140041, 0.05788172408938408, -0.013647819869220257, 0.01619943603873253, -0.0264434851706028, 0.04198014363646507, -0.038960084319114685, -0.010777533985674381, -0.07918524742126465, -0.015176992863416672, 0.03372205048799515, -0.06591422110795975, 0.002445055404677987, -0.0032552755437791348, 0.08459078520536423, -0.01757384091615677, -0.011429072357714176, -0.0020816675387322903, -0.059305690228939056, 0.010385106317698956, 0.020770661532878876, 0.019777115434408188, -0.039928946644067764, -0.01781042106449604, 0.0033033345825970173, 0.042641498148441315, 0.05953079089522362, -0.0095688970759511, -0.009551708586513996, -0.013777193613350391, 0.0035059149377048016, 0.005133673083037138, 0.008016745559871197, -0.012098330073058605, -0.05998379737138748, 0.03564940020442009, -0.017500722780823708, 0.04276430606842041, 0.020068718120455742, -0.02380865439772606, 0.044404223561286926, 0.06290552020072937, -0.0413811057806015, -0.023089278489351273, -0.03128323331475258, 0.08045677095651627, 0.017172345891594887, -0.031076667830348015, 0.006730312015861273, 0.08076885342597961, 0.07879945635795593, -0.021853182464838028, 0.04972146824002266, -0.06983494758605957, 0.02837550826370716, 0.045139264315366745, 0.030506813898682594, 0.003151886397972703, 0.05038873851299286, -0.0024135769344866276, 0.004868223797529936, -0.042176105082035065, -0.012648806907236576, 0.0025011938996613026, -0.01855410449206829, -0.04379213973879814, 0.015194103121757507, 0.0455934964120388, 0.07124488055706024, -0.022517500445246696, -0.005971148610115051, -0.02603684738278389, 0.06324470043182373, 0.04351713880896568, -0.047362226992845535, -0.007962044328451157, 0.04006525129079819, 0.054487403482198715, 0.027117544785141945, -0.0372045636177063, -0.02588149905204773, -0.03884994238615036, 0.07472511380910873, -0.010762590914964676, 0.019479911774396896, -0.033218007534742355, -0.03261508792638779, 0.04369697719812393, -0.0006224295357242227, 0.025169076398015022, -0.0030014680232852697, -0.048274844884872437, 0.003468148410320282, 0.08922373503446579, -0.020773161202669144, 0.0172050092369318, 0.06642862409353256, 0.045586638152599335, 0.02856813371181488, -0.03765895962715149, -0.04356563836336136, -0.006093788892030716, 0.04839737340807915, -0.14037871360778809, -0.005416014697402716, 0.014024616219103336, -0.07575134932994843, -0.06358090043067932, -0.04488582909107208, -0.013063579797744751, 0.025907952338457108, -0.002607070142403245, 0.06161543354392052, 0.016307303681969643, -0.029173510149121284, -0.046176645904779434, -0.02935698628425598, -0.06954069435596466, 0.028436878696084023, -0.08214816451072693, -0.007451076526194811, -0.053523220121860504, 0.04279836639761925, -0.07397414743900299, 0.004280292894691229, -0.005941407289355993, 0.02870500087738037, -0.03547809645533562, 0.010977759957313538, -0.010902555659413338, 0.008623587898910046, -0.012091650627553463, -0.08131488412618637, -0.0408814437687397, -0.04785068705677986, 0.05966494232416153, 0.01434576977044344, 0.07335593551397324, -0.0022182308603078127, -0.02864980697631836, -0.0008912626653909683, -0.09701953828334808, 0.00045759088243357837, 0.008940894156694412, -0.00740554416552186, 0.06410955637693405, 0.07993466407060623, 0.023347647860646248, 0.0073571582324802876, -0.08155578374862671, 0.00934837106615305, -0.04438139125704765, 0.027307432144880295, 0.045370474457740784, -0.017108429223299026, 0.004861893132328987, 0.09192219376564026, -0.04050615057349205, 0.027807671576738358, -0.012704096734523773, 0.023179367184638977, -0.006528046447783709, 0.017485396936535835, 0.050200965255498886, -0.036887820810079575, 0.050332166254520416, -0.024726158007979393, 0.09768709540367126, -0.03853724151849747, -0.010956385172903538, 0.03708864748477936, -0.04976087808609009, -0.04775305837392807, -0.07943238317966461, -0.04898620396852493, -0.06663759797811508, 0.007504800800234079, -0.03157747536897659, 0.018240688368678093, 0.0007358449511229992, -0.00025867047952488065, -0.018030086532235146, 0.0008314686128869653, -0.05693512409925461, 0.060642048716545105, 0.004877171479165554, 0.019619964063167572, -0.03958635777235031, -0.02998075634241104, -0.0359063558280468, -0.037117280066013336, -0.04242100939154625, 0.01607251726090908, 0.049745284020900726, -0.09485315531492233, -0.08600158244371414, -0.015865730121731758, -0.04872795194387436, 0.06068556010723114, -0.03441619127988815, 0.047371864318847656, 0.007034153677523136, -0.018500404432415962, -0.026769790798425674, 0.039840955287218094, -0.004462214652448893, 0.0455109067261219, -0.04384925961494446, -0.0018475473625585437, -0.004302144516259432, -0.001173782511614263, 0.02284356951713562, 0.052530281245708466, -0.05005822703242302, -0.01807958446443081, 0.01099687721580267, 0.008631943725049496, 0.0024051156360656023, 0.07859322428703308, -0.0489385612308979, 0.029455585405230522, -0.12302352488040924, -0.08179919421672821, -0.09221220761537552, 0.025371836498379707, -0.037631478160619736, 0.00830994825810194, 0.014096343889832497, -0.02914343774318695, -0.03057270124554634, 0.036910440772771835, -0.015896007418632507, -0.10757003724575043, 0.05244643986225128, 0.023411236703395844, 0.00837676227092743, 0.07473597675561905, 0.0505804643034935, -0.013584518805146217, 0.021968422457575798, 0.0336817167699337, -0.05223478004336357, 0.01230695005506277, 0.027301905676722527, 0.008509275503456593, 0.01639115996658802, 0.07140562683343887, -0.08393722027540207, 0.00705282436683774, 0.03606759384274483, 0.03440888226032257, -0.07771939039230347, -0.04083554819226265, 0.03850933536887169, 0.006106893066316843, -0.01156828086823225, 0.013365722261369228, -0.03762143477797508, -0.005989390425384045, 0.0522133968770504, 0.018105147406458855, -0.08878783136606216, -0.013174670748412609, 0.030186448246240616, -0.0006972266710363328, -0.009900689125061035, 0.003377486253157258, -0.017686104401946068, -0.062424056231975555, 0.00920870527625084, 0.004546161275357008, 0.00288902479223907, -0.006348339840769768, 0.04836118593811989, 0.029581720009446144, 0.01008725818246603, 0.07672253251075745, 0.00016983738169074059, -0.05592036992311478, 0.07491961121559143, -0.015959899872541428, 0.04129837080836296, -0.010669286362826824, -0.010421120561659336, 0.05594531074166298, 0.010231390595436096, 0.007204312831163406, -0.03415899723768234, -0.008954960852861404, 0.1043056920170784, -0.04077683761715889, 0.031704969704151154, -0.02300107665359974, 0.010184633545577526, 0.03489842265844345, 0.03449520468711853, 0.03602699190378189, 0.030582880601286888, -0.09373755753040314, 0.034172043204307556, 0.055848751217126846, -0.09197317808866501, -0.02343481220304966 ]
205
205
Distributed Preemption Decisions: Probabilistic Graphical Model, Algorithm and Near-Optimality
Cooperative decision making is a vision of future network management and control. Distributed connection preemption is an important example where nodes can make intelligent decisions on allocating resources and controlling traffic flows for multi-class service networks. A challenge is that nodal decisions are spatially dependent as traffic flows trespass multiple nodes in a network. Hence the performance-complexity trade-off becomes important, i.e., how accurate decisions are versus how much information is exchanged among nodes. Connection preemption is known to be NP-complete. Centralized preemption is optimal but computationally intractable. Decentralized preemption is computationally efficient but may result in a poor performance. This work investigates distributed preemption where nodes decide whether and which flows to preempt using only local information exchange with neighbors. We develop, based on the probabilistic graphical models, a near-optimal distributed algorithm. The algorithm is used by each node to make collectively near-optimal preemption decisions. We study trade-offs between near-optimal performance and complexity that corresponds to the amount of information-exchange of the distributed algorithm. The algorithm is validated by both analysis and simulation.
[ -0.03304138034582138, -0.020554963499307632, 0.029368722811341286, 0.01104915700852871, -0.0011657497379928827, -0.010520203039050102, 0.025972794741392136, -0.050950370728969574, -0.022565225139260292, 0.021917980164289474, 0.016209645196795464, -0.06696299463510513, -0.0005383302923291922, -0.02646442875266075, 0.045277442783117294, -0.03405637666583061, -0.004061959683895111, 0.0426635816693306, -0.020493175834417343, -0.05295125022530556, -0.028312858194112778, -0.0026846418622881174, 0.00011359683412592858, 0.022627873346209526, 0.04884396120905876, -0.034706961363554, -0.010923580266535282, 0.04117169231176376, -0.015461266972124577, -0.0064005120657384396, -0.06842172890901566, 0.035485997796058655, 0.01438184455037117, 0.0002519077097531408, -0.022473221644759178, -0.08355968445539474, 0.022037915885448456, -0.04286517947912216, -0.04731202498078346, -0.03457771986722946, -0.0008893855265341699, -0.0853104293346405, -0.07324078679084778, -0.03975212574005127, -0.012734375894069672, -0.04412117227911949, 0.024568604305386543, 0.0883355364203453, 0.026503492146730423, -0.017627952620387077, -0.034939441829919815, -0.04832777380943298, -0.0650281310081482, 0.05258871614933014, -0.020425327122211456, 0.040136486291885376, -0.11452819406986237, -0.06988339871168137, -0.0179127287119627, -0.07298250496387482, 0.054650094360113144, 0.09252925962209702, -0.05263814702630043, -0.001871710759587586, -0.033983346074819565, 0.00752366753295064, 0.049131862819194794, 0.02119995467364788, 0.008025848306715488, -0.014468026347458363, -0.020151928067207336, 0.024474823847413063, -0.055781248956918716, 0.05224379897117615, 0.012479733675718307, 0.005114685278385878, -0.001523382030427456, 0.053915075957775116, 0.0036576318088918924, 0.04122980684041977, -0.05563542991876602, 0.04505755007266998, -0.009307850152254105, 0.02640499174594879, 0.0055672829039394855, -0.0016806882340461016, -0.013208932243287563, 0.008547566831111908, 0.02371469885110855, -0.012397431768476963, 0.0009805954759940505, 0.06569676846265793, -0.051865965127944946, 0.0017547416500747204, -0.03585465997457504, -0.017810942605137825, -0.09092925488948822, 0.0236210860311985, 0.05406962335109711, 0.09985838830471039, -0.008078012615442276, 0.020062124356627464, 0.017742684110999107, 0.022045092657208443, -0.026120897382497787, -0.00914811808615923, 0.0089443763718009, 0.0368192121386528, 0.00006617284816456959, -0.061834290623664856, 0.013224412687122822, -0.016270948573946953, -0.061894740909338, 0.02355383150279522, -0.00726982019841671, 0.06405090540647507, -0.03391537815332413, 0.014943000860512257, -0.05289630964398384, 0.024882392957806587, -0.046825822442770004, -0.028516441583633423, -0.08069805800914764, 0.028706062585115433, -0.030147559940814972, -0.09003552794456482, -0.049475714564323425, -0.004175567999482155, 0.08179307729005814, 0.07441089302301407, -0.058685965836048126, 0.008509972132742405, 0.008623244240880013, -0.06712564826011658, -0.11144661158323288, 0.10487125813961029, 0.07037783414125443, -0.045717254281044006, -0.0017754716100171208, 0.07345457375049591, 0.02738112583756447, -0.05917946621775627, -0.01124033983796835, -0.012318744324147701, 0.02289004437625408, 0.009879142977297306, 0.016296468675136566, -0.005925646983087063, -0.003751266049221158, 0.025382932275533676, -0.030545242130756378, -0.04575315862894058, 0.02835954912006855, 0.0024830373004078865, -0.01146035548299551, -0.024166252464056015, -0.05935700237751007, -0.0058020371943712234, -0.0544281043112278, 0.06271743029356003, -0.03290722146630287, 0.07067219913005829, 0.04068097844719887, -0.03384631499648094, 0.039142102003097534, -0.01467866450548172, -0.03857584670186043, 0.04732930660247803, -0.012607001699507236, -0.022556690499186516, 0.046332698315382004, -0.012460261583328247, 0.007718685083091259, 0.048910997807979584, 0.029100244864821434, -0.04382307454943657, -0.01829734444618225, -0.013402529992163181, 0.003817965742200613, 0.00664752721786499, 0.012501410208642483, -0.09127583354711533, 0.014463398605585098, -0.020495854318141937, 0.057312700897455215, 0.09489328414201736, 0.02772035077214241, 0.055842697620391846, 0.07069137692451477, 0.029452009126544, -0.08025580644607544, 0.007200527470558882, 0.045194949954748154, -0.0044122422114014626, 0.0029609501361846924, -0.021289192140102386, -0.10425535589456558, 0.01636383682489395, 0.02917487733066082, 0.03679220750927925, 0.07087910920381546, 0.03198288008570671, -0.08877043426036835, -0.008463884703814983, -0.07798482477664948, 0.032554615288972855, 0.02093466743826866, -0.018110575154423714, 0.006389854941517115, -0.026985937729477882, 0.035424936562776566, -0.026419086381793022, -0.03398137912154198, 0.02324831485748291, 0.03523153439164162, -0.01565789058804512, -0.049692749977111816, -0.06867513060569763, 0.001256449962966144, -0.022083265706896782, -0.06522159278392792, 0.04132426530122757, -0.05334443226456642, 0.0042401887476444244, -0.058653175830841064, -0.00953790731728077, 0.05022956803441048, 0.038330916315317154, -0.06893141567707062, -0.010320528410375118, 0.04489557445049286, -0.05587666481733322, -0.003011578693985939, 0.07318329811096191, -0.04148530587553978, 0.08833177387714386, -0.02199653349816799, -0.0551673099398613, -0.006522109266370535, -0.03858134523034096, -0.005985045339912176, 0.029432076960802078, -0.00570461293682456, 0.012352896854281425, 0.1172550618648529, 0.026391753926873207, 0.0018143331399187446, -0.021335508674383163, -0.0666661337018013, 0.016853947192430496, -0.0006254905019886792, -0.038837283849716187, -0.012664224952459335, 0.06193920597434044, -0.01169546227902174, -0.060005102306604385, 0.03075001761317253, 0.084549181163311, 0.07154892385005951, 0.08181030303239822, 0.03125162795186043, 0.0605391226708889, -0.0475737564265728, 0.007673798128962517, 0.06717805564403534, 0.004900419153273106, 0.07619018107652664, 0.027185814455151558, -0.0187981054186821, -0.018411878496408463, -0.006595919840037823, -0.03791722655296326, -0.013290725648403168, 0.10761622339487076, 0.007557932287454605, -0.005578876007348299, -0.006725548300892115, -0.008073508739471436, 0.016728674992918968, -0.03944097459316254, -0.06639642268419266, -0.00287248520180583, 0.0057694558054208755, 0.028882762417197227, -0.003890272928401828, -0.01360323652625084, -0.0751836970448494, -0.05343525484204292, 0.05557018145918846, 0.050109781324863434, -0.08457133919000626, 0.029445122927427292, -0.11241234838962555, -0.0433349683880806, 0.0009704474941827357, -0.048778217285871506, -0.035275641828775406, 0.023698853328824043, 0.06888117641210556, 0.02705695666372776, 0.01340896263718605, 0.01578565128147602, 0.04878858104348183, 0.07121112197637558, -0.008984959684312344, 0.0339663028717041, 0.022579718381166458, -0.02751270867884159, -0.08412904292345047, -0.014999963343143463, 0.008047126233577728, 0.08094079792499542, 0.036116380244493484, 0.0448041707277298, 0.05227760225534439, -0.004267022479325533, -0.010712837800383568, -0.0037508464884012938, -0.032735761255025864, 0.0579054057598114, -0.006143348757177591, 0.027254940941929817, 0.00422815652564168, -0.01890970952808857, 0.03226668760180473, 0.030597787350416183, 0.02966783568263054, 0.07160110771656036, -0.006138397380709648, 0.06487347930669785, -0.06478925794363022, -0.025176534429192543, -0.021752016618847847, 0.06187793239951134, -0.016083097085356712, -0.02245301380753517, -0.07460064440965652, 0.00882581528276205, 0.0035553378984332085, 0.05403332784771919, -0.09512446820735931, -0.07152249664068222, -0.04660945385694504, -0.043291449546813965, 0.06601982563734055, 0.10043293982744217, 0.06600771099328995, -0.035934530198574066, 0.037362612783908844, -0.019079584628343582, -0.03254806622862816, 0.01346353068947792, -0.02650410495698452, 0.01028451044112444, -0.03691700100898743, -0.025884360074996948, 0.04026975855231285, -0.027076691389083862, 0.04699515923857689, 0.013521483168005943, -0.017915775999426842, -0.031700607389211655, -0.031741417944431305, 0.007858578115701675, 0.018968410789966583, 0.017774729058146477, -0.09476713836193085, -0.018168950453400612, 0.001290278509259224, -0.02260868437588215, 0.002109293593093753, -0.025995107367634773, -0.06643950194120407, -0.03920629620552063, 0.06415411829948425, -0.0039058367256075144, 0.057030707597732544, -0.05645995959639549, 0.037778377532958984, 0.0052374438382685184, -0.012840794399380684, 0.03149301931262016, -0.011727447621524334, -0.06103019788861275, -0.00046983949141576886, -0.04237160086631775, -0.012593849562108517, -0.011602473445236683, 0.03933306783437729, 0.024145089089870453, 0.019916625693440437, 0.02201453410089016, -0.010090364143252373, 0.013134140521287918, 0.060921795666217804, 0.011609728448092937, 0.05223872512578964, 0.03883707523345947, -0.05247248336672783, 0.06209797412157059, -0.026018211618065834, -0.09606828540563583, -0.03332167863845825, -0.0316416472196579, -0.042484283447265625, 0.013833925127983093, -0.011883722618222237, 0.10278775542974472, -0.05816539376974106, -0.020902695134282112, 0.07927416265010834, 0.03750194236636162, -0.03332775831222534, 0.022962363436818123, -0.01672307401895523, -0.0011222305474802852, -0.0018673344748094678, -0.042458824813365936, -0.005982186179608107, -0.018446752801537514, -0.010675975121557713, -0.03242359310388565, -0.015901176258921623, -0.05606416240334511, -0.0790204256772995, -0.0013834998244419694, 0.018989969044923782, -0.003021863754838705, -0.004483504686504602, 0.05754539370536804, -0.09345810860395432, -0.09076426178216934, -0.07791253179311752, -0.025768214836716652, 0.009185359813272953, 0.05598568171262741, 0.045666344463825226, -0.038571782410144806, 0.009354602545499802, -0.05328859016299248, 0.06014758720993996, 0.010798756033182144, 0.03361496701836586, 0.06638019531965256, -0.01572658121585846, 0.0068283225409686565, -0.008510278537869453, 0.01375837903469801, -0.006898959632962942, 0.0659165233373642, 0.006578830536454916, 0.03805582970380783, 0.12325934320688248, -0.04805715009570122, -0.012051736004650593, -0.148321270942688, 0.01836327649652958, -0.013438837602734566, -0.021613264456391335, -0.0737677812576294, -0.028228754177689552, -0.03125159814953804, -0.008640328422188759, -0.00941723957657814, -0.015767689794301987, -0.019233400002121925, 0.026121821254491806, -0.0490901917219162, 0.08369436115026474, 0.008331609889864922, -0.05596466735005379, 0.004203987307846546, 0.036721859127283096, -0.022982832044363022, -0.0022369595244526863, -0.04012599214911461, 0.055175308138132095, 0.07438335567712784, 0.0034589215647429228, -0.0036506932228803635, 0.013515735976397991, 0.0466863177716732, -0.041328560560941696, -0.014209688641130924, 0.03761746361851692, 0.017196230590343475, -0.013155694119632244, 0.028090747073292732, 0.0441475585103035, -0.04301515966653824, -0.07553426176309586, -0.10144688189029694, 0.038389623165130615, 0.04955437406897545, -0.01285733375698328, 0.01904945634305477, 0.03464696928858757, 0.020111629739403725, 0.08558747917413712, 0.004519646987318993, 0.014951063320040703, -0.02464614436030388, 0.018247919157147408, 0.05555373430252075, 0.042644064873456955, 0.021124839782714844, 0.07782336324453354, -0.009069221094250679, 0.0005594742833636701, 0.018248502165079117, -0.0754232257604599, 0.00786015298217535 ]
206
206
A Theoretical Analysis of Joint Manifolds
The emergence of low-cost sensor architectures for diverse modalities has made it possible to deploy sensor arrays that capture a single event from a large number of vantage points and using multiple modalities. In many scenarios, these sensors acquire very high-dimensional data such as audio signals, images, and video. To cope with such high-dimensional data, we typically rely on low-dimensional models. Manifold models provide a particularly powerful model that captures the structure of high-dimensional data when it is governed by a low-dimensional set of parameters. However, these models do not typically take into account dependencies among multiple sensors. We thus propose a new joint manifold framework for data ensembles that exploits such dependencies. We show that simple algorithms can exploit the joint manifold structure to improve their performance on standard signal processing applications. Additionally, recent results concerning dimensionality reduction for manifolds enable us to formulate a network-scalable data compression scheme that uses random projections of the sensed data. This scheme efficiently fuses the data from all sensors through the addition of such projections, regardless of the data modalities and dimensions.
[ 0.0060468073934316635, -0.04335067421197891, -0.06865350902080536, -0.025965461507439613, 0.0332697257399559, -0.030624520033597946, -0.012632879428565502, -0.06003877893090248, -0.016901269555091858, 0.05789678171277046, 0.019226185977458954, -0.0007609460735693574, -0.03033081814646721, -0.0317545048892498, -0.04549504816532135, -0.030979353934526443, -0.04305797070264816, 0.013850433751940727, 0.09993047267198563, -0.04926417022943497, 0.001013423316180706, -0.028712360188364983, -0.05402842536568642, -0.021622922271490097, -0.01675226539373398, 0.013745768927037716, -0.048572733998298645, -0.018115418031811714, -0.035706739872694016, 0.015279256738722324, 0.053280990570783615, -0.04315989091992378, 0.027631636708974838, -0.0015031825751066208, -0.05803011730313301, 0.020396528765559196, 0.06775527447462082, 0.00552028464153409, -0.027372686192393303, -0.013091949746012688, -0.035122986882925034, 0.009679262526333332, -0.00939795933663845, -0.06850311905145645, -0.01365354098379612, 0.1167561337351799, -0.0035656774416565895, -0.019590068608522415, 0.047291334718465805, 0.04094037413597107, -0.13458794355392456, 0.042735081166028976, -0.020620232447981834, -0.012262754142284393, -0.019391141831874847, 0.09153922647237778, -0.020385602489113808, 0.015287610702216625, 0.025922048836946487, -0.047831010073423386, 0.10883041471242905, 0.04527132958173752, -0.09226325899362564, 0.0117742158472538, 0.03916269540786743, 0.0050738477148115635, -0.10503710806369781, -0.061262983828783035, -0.08500150591135025, -0.015991931781172752, -0.076509028673172, -0.06646617501974106, -0.12095914036035538, 0.012392635457217693, 0.06920706480741501, 0.016149155795574188, 0.011735831387341022, -0.0069378395564854145, -0.0133275231346488, 0.05285535007715225, -0.05311806499958038, -0.0023200830910354853, -0.025792071595788002, 0.09000616520643234, -0.028990961611270905, -0.0070962742902338505, -0.008699633181095123, -0.014497688040137291, 0.01601319946348667, -0.031498298048973083, -0.04740581661462784, -0.0026158110704272985, -0.11299611628055573, 0.1047605648636818, -0.07149234414100647, -0.013460801914334297, -0.12425179034471512, 0.03734681010246277, -0.04500489681959152, 0.04397941380739212, 0.005093226674944162, 0.036652736365795135, 0.04167113080620766, 0.057838305830955505, -0.010817643254995346, 0.02330118790268898, -0.0273185595870018, 0.03319714590907097, -0.010690520517528057, -0.03693384677171707, 0.054738473147153854, -0.053482264280319214, -0.00523510342463851, -0.0387040339410305, 0.050444990396499634, 0.02400132268667221, 0.018346983939409256, 0.07494128495454788, -0.04661526158452034, -0.029120441526174545, -0.01586322858929634, -0.0274434145539999, 0.05862771347165108, 0.02172078751027584, 0.08050238341093063, -0.053797293454408646, -0.011245304718613625, 0.018780484795570374, 0.06904187053442001, 0.04184882715344429, -0.0617901086807251, 0.004031560383737087, 0.04461658373475075, 0.032637905329465866, -0.05154139921069145, 0.03338584303855896, 0.06615833193063736, 0.029376700520515442, -0.010249787010252476, 0.06435813754796982, 0.04851613938808441, 0.004295676946640015, 0.02021399885416031, -0.040825579315423965, 0.055891767144203186, 0.027952464297413826, 0.028091877698898315, 0.08177606761455536, 0.017103303223848343, -0.023770885542035103, -0.025511980056762695, -0.10744015127420425, 0.010106327012181282, 0.007672338746488094, -0.017984548583626747, -0.012287238612771034, 0.009116431698203087, 0.0011829299619421363, 0.007991759106516838, 0.034346722066402435, -0.07258085161447525, 0.06784876435995102, 0.027157895267009735, 0.08576081693172455, 0.034916460514068604, -0.02551041729748249, -0.04728556424379349, -0.00257636490277946, -0.03401065617799759, 0.016804929822683334, -0.058875687420368195, -0.03156895190477371, 0.012198438867926598, 0.006124331150203943, -0.008951336145401001, -0.015754196792840958, -0.08287505060434341, -0.00037203976535238326, 0.013505280017852783, -0.017313875257968903, -0.03629320114850998, -0.005899142939597368, -0.0032226850744336843, 0.06810899823904037, 0.008236355148255825, 0.07074964791536331, -0.07084115594625473, 0.022524718195199966, 0.04130362346768379, -0.020128751173615456, 0.0773429349064827, 0.061774902045726776, 0.013351686298847198, -0.010015559382736683, -0.019051197916269302, 0.031203007325530052, 0.008277498185634613, 0.03892183676362038, 0.015973249450325966, 0.06530050188302994, 0.02588403783738613, -0.009082821197807789, -0.03773372992873192, -0.06452612578868866, -0.03306659311056137, 0.04061712697148323, 0.0036509933415800333, -0.004297967534512281, 0.004075570963323116, -0.005038827192038298, 0.006502899341285229, -0.0509350448846817, -0.03821743652224541, 0.004491484258323908, 0.03220435604453087, -0.056283604353666306, -0.0761786624789238, -0.10269098728895187, 0.0434703566133976, 0.027111001312732697, -0.09571252018213272, 0.06534218043088913, -0.08866965770721436, 0.04160543158650398, -0.0723661556839943, 0.012116549536585808, 0.01073694322258234, -0.03984390199184418, -0.01991141401231289, 0.016588522121310234, -0.057267963886260986, -0.0571322962641716, -0.04965709149837494, -0.04474295303225517, 0.04122742637991905, 0.0826883465051651, -0.053932689130306244, 0.004466671496629715, 0.022043006494641304, 0.09675461798906326, -0.014356546103954315, 0.056646980345249176, 0.06641537696123123, 0.0007728156633675098, 0.023220479488372803, -0.04375232756137848, 0.017579402774572372, 0.07795173674821854, 0.019972074776887894, 0.018406014889478683, 0.003982076421380043, 0.031582508236169815, 0.06353028118610382, 0.047947824001312256, 0.0034059276804327965, 0.04432205110788345, -0.0014534080401062965, 0.02216332033276558, 0.050792139023542404, -0.006413803435862064, 0.03214506059885025, -0.00014618123532272875, -0.03626413643360138, -0.008084953762590885, 0.05760921537876129, 0.06228933855891228, 0.021370571106672287, 0.0719270333647728, -0.01920446939766407, 0.013073239475488663, 0.0075250049121677876, -0.05233414098620415, -0.054622672498226166, 0.017420807853341103, -0.0005012406036257744, -0.007865752093493938, 0.037588201463222504, 0.14083760976791382, 0.017496546730399132, -0.027523912489414215, -0.07530402392148972, 0.06351611018180847, -0.04132404178380966, -0.01950889080762863, -0.007896017283201218, -0.01487096305936575, 0.022266758605837822, 0.06235721334815025, -0.04933403432369232, -0.021288955584168434, 0.00669280206784606, 0.04114333167672157, -0.07590573281049728, -0.013909907080233097, 0.0508093535900116, -0.06733514368534088, -0.0021829011384397745, -0.0006869699573144317, 0.01754096709191799, -0.013086714781820774, 0.008975047618150711, 0.0016105221584439278, 0.06549201160669327, 0.02667933702468872, 0.037281379103660583, 0.035972144454717636, 0.1286066770553589, 0.04742569103837013, -0.05149844288825989, -0.02387942373752594, -0.019866572692990303, 0.01977471075952053, -0.020154336467385292, -0.002960811136290431, -0.007889560423791409, -0.023441560566425323, -0.029862098395824432, 0.07956194877624512, -0.019837839528918266, 0.040959134697914124, 0.018752677366137505, -0.043531809002161026, -0.016558388248085976, -0.031806521117687225, 0.016659919172525406, -0.019871478900313377, 0.008921223692595959, -0.01655234582722187, 0.013587462715804577, 0.03577736020088196, -0.028055550530552864, 0.02745196223258972, -0.04483557865023613, 0.13742695748806, -0.02256353572010994, -0.03619519621133804, -0.03051106259226799, 0.05222573131322861, -0.03208356350660324, -0.02295498736202717, -0.048457831144332886, 0.011420298367738724, -0.035625141113996506, -0.052944786846637726, 0.012297123670578003, 0.05922500416636467, 0.09357918798923492, -0.04052026569843292, -0.029443180188536644, 0.016274644061923027, -0.049592409282922745, 0.01638614945113659, 0.01984269730746746, 0.07614122331142426, 0.03632174804806709, 0.02932664565742016, 0.05964706465601921, 0.03484252467751503, -0.03277312591671944, -0.04139290750026703, 0.0285117719322443, 0.05355452001094818, -0.06336817145347595, 0.013761378824710846, 0.0028775641694664955, 0.08894484490156174, -0.07511833310127258, 0.030680987983942032, -0.01458662934601307, -0.07353115826845169, 0.042078468948602676, -0.024678315967321396, -0.022333309054374695, 0.026161465793848038, 0.10735118389129639, -0.003680152352899313, 0.041058145463466644, -0.013620570302009583, -0.034129783511161804, 0.02842709608376026, 0.028928114101290703, -0.0452740304172039, -0.046899259090423584, -0.04691989719867706, -0.0042450567707419395, 0.07117220759391785, 0.034489955753088, 0.030877120792865753, 0.01037990115582943, 0.017641110345721245, 0.006067004520446062, 0.0468740351498127, 0.03042919561266899, -0.00813276693224907, 0.05031378194689751, -0.01818333938717842, 0.035782624036073685, 0.006567519623786211, 0.051145169883966446, -0.02210201695561409, 0.02555019222199917, -0.010423458181321621, -0.07582813501358032, -0.056141212582588196, -0.04376712813973427, -0.011196441948413849, 0.004305907990783453, 0.030817091464996338, -0.002862668363377452, 0.0006651622243225574, 0.05885614827275276, -0.03763337433338165, -0.03369665518403053, 0.030067406594753265, 0.0454399399459362, -0.018136121332645416, 0.02395329624414444, 0.009862696751952171, 0.0739908292889595, -0.05812022089958191, -0.05719869211316109, -0.01649804413318634, -0.054912179708480835, -0.03392980247735977, -0.015178751200437546, 0.013771574012935162, -0.0035285509657114744, -0.005775515455752611, -0.0073297880589962006, 0.05749506130814552, -0.06962458044290543, -0.0076170978136360645, -0.01455608569085598, 0.03436547517776489, 0.07766712456941605, 0.002573055448010564, -0.007197545375674963, -0.07368215918540955, 0.020480860024690628, -0.03049645386636257, -0.04923054575920105, -0.010393667034804821, -0.025194190442562103, -0.039913393557071686, 0.033877767622470856, -0.016907479614019394, 0.07398195564746857, 0.03054720349609852, 0.05872609093785286, -0.0038628834299743176, -0.006636361591517925, 0.04170604050159454, 0.09618411958217621, 0.006770955864340067, 0.030865898355841637, 0.04879113286733627, 0.006198355462402105, 0.02481565810739994, 0.036115650087594986, -0.07712537050247192, -0.0037366661708801985, -0.02732021175324917, 0.02251718007028103, 0.021528122946619987, 0.008324543945491314, -0.017090674489736557, 0.021000757813453674, 0.05646633729338646, -0.013970951549708843, 0.021433629095554352, -0.037797052413225174, 0.01849544793367386, -0.022947486490011215, -0.01690998114645481, 0.03544105216860771, -0.020572641864418983, 0.004546545911580324, -0.029514266178011894, -0.0400821790099144, -0.06692599505186081, 0.03635420277714729, 0.035582736134529114, 0.0012232160661369562, 0.03385022282600403, 0.02318277768790722, 0.05722043663263321, 0.013973299413919449, -0.035255566239356995, 0.032596997916698456, 0.007865389809012413, 0.03515615686774254, -0.009901853278279305, 0.01285089086741209, 0.03453441336750984, -0.014810972847044468, -0.04492690786719322, 0.02537584863603115, -0.008021624758839607, 0.057149022817611694, 0.023770689964294434, 0.029405444860458374, -0.06345506757497787, -0.007968327030539513, 0.05226181447505951, 0.05704956501722336, 0.02899244800209999, 0.03768904134631157, -0.016287846490740776, -0.03356677293777466, 0.0694127082824707, -0.03989015519618988, -0.08008033037185669 ]
207
207
Joint universal lossy coding and identification of stationary mixing sources with general alphabets
We consider the problem of joint universal variable-rate lossy coding and identification for parametric classes of stationary $\beta$-mixing sources with general (Polish) alphabets. Compression performance is measured in terms of Lagrangians, while identification performance is measured by the variational distance between the true source and the estimated source. Provided that the sources are mixing at a sufficiently fast rate and satisfy certain smoothness and Vapnik-Chervonenkis learnability conditions, it is shown that, for bounded metric distortions, there exist universal schemes for joint lossy compression and identification whose Lagrangian redundancies converge to zero as $\sqrt{V_n \log n /n}$ as the block length $n$ tends to infinity, where $V_n$ is the Vapnik-Chervonenkis dimension of a certain class of decision regions defined by the $n$-dimensional marginal distributions of the sources; furthermore, for each $n$, the decoder can identify $n$-dimensional marginal of the active source up to a ball of radius $O(\sqrt{V_n\log n/n})$ in variational distance, eventually with probability one. The results are supplemented by several examples of parametric sources satisfying the regularity conditions.
[ 0.03443396836519241, -0.026467472314834595, 0.05839274078607559, -0.028028402477502823, 0.039625946432352066, -0.023113703355193138, 0.015990635380148888, 0.042215991765260696, -0.03166019544005394, 0.02725512534379959, -0.04644147306680679, -0.023815849795937538, -0.05175769329071045, -0.010845981538295746, -0.042171306908130646, -0.029527828097343445, -0.04129979386925697, -0.013177675195038319, 0.02831394597887993, -0.0710054561495781, -0.04255887120962143, 0.00020922305702697486, -0.045222245156764984, -0.08234346657991409, 0.06281134486198425, 0.012731020338833332, -0.0627284124493599, -0.018703963607549667, -0.06588799506425858, 0.06774435937404633, -0.07176583260297775, -0.06011388450860977, 0.03551672399044037, 0.10856571048498154, -0.004285268019884825, 0.043972503393888474, 0.05701064318418503, 0.018953440710902214, -0.029240965843200684, -0.025183673948049545, -0.05785077065229416, -0.05347821116447449, 0.0673762634396553, -0.016064632683992386, 0.003942757844924927, 0.027246233075857162, -0.05771755054593086, -0.017135636880993843, -0.06203634664416313, -0.01778862439095974, -0.019309047609567642, -0.016461573541164398, 0.024458490312099457, -0.018576860427856445, -0.0044534350745379925, 0.05139601603150368, -0.039626430720090866, -0.0035968441516160965, 0.016704583540558815, -0.03829158470034599, 0.08953265100717545, 0.10580591857433319, 0.006842086557298899, -0.047937553375959396, -0.0237980205565691, -0.018406525254249573, -0.040396858006715775, 0.03250143304467201, -0.06024544686079025, 0.008343508467078209, 0.035559117794036865, -0.05184045433998108, 0.05516195669770241, -0.04610632359981537, 0.010077626444399357, 0.04705869406461716, 0.009152330458164215, -0.024701081216335297, 0.010327204130589962, 0.11062847822904587, -0.04767432436347008, 0.02260095626115799, -0.055620260536670685, -0.06346055865287781, -0.049553029239177704, 0.02518126368522644, -0.01734698936343193, 0.044229552149772644, -0.01630450040102005, -0.09417140483856201, -0.0073646255768835545, -0.04310977831482887, -0.1368335336446762, 0.06022357568144798, 0.03318970277905464, 0.06836492568254471, 0.048438649624586105, 0.04777233675122261, -0.03300680220127106, -0.008929910138249397, 0.06825383752584457, 0.038193318992853165, 0.0845356360077858, 0.048830777406692505, -0.0003685426781885326, 0.037284087389707565, -0.0467383973300457, -0.001472470466978848, 0.027563288807868958, -0.01790964975953102, 0.007081849966198206, 0.043786633759737015, -0.015539842657744884, -0.06268336623907089, -0.047328509390354156, 0.02937128394842148, 0.034794315695762634, 0.09579816460609436, 0.05972422659397125, 0.05046673119068146, -0.020969467237591743, -0.003953367471694946, -0.019486552104353905, 0.008135293610394001, 0.05864975228905678, -0.04839864373207092, -0.08008400350809097, -0.027059229090809822, 0.09028107672929764, -0.0026171524077653885, -0.02840578183531761, 0.012295223772525787, 0.09597940742969513, -0.016866903752088547, 0.002662450075149536, 0.005155179649591446, 0.026897834613919258, 0.007608686573803425, -0.0026120746042579412, 0.021347735077142715, -0.025069542229175568, -0.01599947176873684, -0.009178077802062035, 0.10186712443828583, 0.013084318488836288, 0.03696731850504875, 0.003962095361202955, -0.004081915132701397, -0.015767453238368034, -0.015379407443106174, -0.040877070277929306, 0.013572527095675468, 0.03640037029981613, 0.024575674906373024, 0.052633561193943024, -0.0741036981344223, -0.010107554495334625, -0.007776892744004726, -0.0457201823592186, 0.056181397289037704, -0.013401663862168789, 0.1096716821193695, 0.04258725047111511, 0.08723828941583633, -0.02861739508807659, -0.018046658486127853, -0.002753431210294366, -0.031067946925759315, -0.07198204100131989, -0.026704689487814903, -0.0708705484867096, -0.06246868520975113, -0.0031980460043996572, -0.0024327191058546305, -0.058586739003658295, 0.03198700770735741, 0.058082837611436844, 0.003468271577730775, -0.010076573118567467, 0.005391494836658239, 0.07394762337207794, -0.036237917840480804, 0.023884376510977745, 0.08432197570800781, 0.023780150339007378, 0.031587887555360794, -0.03020225465297699, 0.008880787529051304, 0.019204288721084595, 0.05052705854177475, 0.00044409200199879706, -0.0014851257437840104, -0.019026320427656174, 0.02755584754049778, -0.09042878448963165, 0.04522757604718208, -0.04029334709048271, -0.030921295285224915, -0.009727071039378643, 0.08572831749916077, 0.047317590564489365, 0.009887263178825378, -0.006607487332075834, -0.07521197944879532, -0.059828318655490875, 0.05228167772293091, 0.04536100849509239, -0.037230104207992554, 0.011971479281783104, -0.01920359395444393, -0.037682633846998215, 0.022450456395745277, 0.06763523072004318, -0.04697239026427269, -0.04141900688409805, -0.004794393666088581, 0.02737627923488617, -0.04548175632953644, -0.02567504718899727, -0.05398121848702431, -0.029884405434131622, 0.08998844027519226, -0.004516586195677519, 0.032661858946084976, -0.018501615151762962, -0.01786968484520912, 0.07113658636808395, 0.09030158817768097, -0.06628861278295517, 0.04146015644073486, -0.05535128712654114, -0.031117694452404976, -0.08104903995990753, -0.06677296757698059, -0.015907559543848038, 0.05556400865316391, -0.05983348190784454, -0.0699799656867981, 0.023310448974370956, 0.002638806588947773, -0.01750052534043789, 0.03202136233448982, -0.039096131920814514, 0.005182170774787664, 0.03060547076165676, 0.013830499723553658, 0.08625240623950958, 0.021758565679192543, 0.035104360431432724, -0.02075100503861904, 0.024987440556287766, -0.005231379996985197, 0.07449869066476822, -0.060144685208797455, 0.03295229375362396, -0.034780990332365036, 0.021768050268292427, -0.008454603143036366, 0.02374871075153351, 0.04387063905596733, -0.004858200438320637, 0.023254770785570145, -0.01985054463148117, -0.028209401294589043, 0.050591688603162766, 0.0026379546616226435, -0.016703443601727486, 0.022126540541648865, 0.052758343517780304, 0.02946319431066513, -0.016250479966402054, -0.04723908007144928, -0.06990533322095871, -0.00311489962041378, -0.027881678193807602, -0.04592384770512581, 0.037675000727176666, -0.0053746672347188, 0.03943730518221855, -0.006767028942704201, -0.06540390849113464, 0.045808516442775726, 0.004266779869794846, 0.000628453039098531, 0.016419079154729843, 0.06300345808267593, -0.09042614698410034, 0.10972092300653458, 0.033056337386369705, 0.08087392151355743, -0.011579088866710663, 0.09079831093549728, -0.09007330238819122, 0.06613773107528687, -0.005005866754800081, -0.0054214149713516235, 0.00006409912748495117, 0.03469091281294823, 0.04349112883210182, -0.022182147949934006, 0.01142987608909607, -0.040220778435468674, -0.0264919251203537, 0.08610918372869492, 0.01841762103140354, 0.03761202469468117, 0.061435673385858536, 0.031231891363859177, -0.01493444200605154, -0.03179532289505005, 0.004999139346182346, 0.03090996854007244, -0.01780892349779606, -0.012972135096788406, -0.01419408805668354, -0.06450557708740234, -0.033691082149744034, -0.01394936814904213, -0.02409382164478302, -0.01565684750676155, 0.008136841468513012, 0.031221073120832443, -0.052700359374284744, 0.017967762425541878, -0.07224927842617035, -0.03842013701796532, -0.10943367332220078, 0.03623942285776138, -0.052088648080825806, 0.0392916314303875, -0.0327177569270134, 0.031410157680511475, -0.025318259373307228, 0.07888539135456085, -0.004398270510137081, 0.009709005244076252, 0.05303243175148964, -0.017247559502720833, 0.01885169930756092, -0.0019291279604658484, 0.013897418044507504, -0.027927329763770103, 0.0013631731271743774, 0.0023237797431647778, -0.009634439833462238, 0.03716406598687172, 0.08181889355182648, -0.05136794224381447, -0.003321537049487233, 0.0471365861594677, -0.058340348303318024, -0.0035769545938819647, -0.01950415037572384, 0.04584302380681038, 0.0059237913228571415, 0.07300179451704025, 0.0028727143071591854, -0.017266081646084785, 0.007584218867123127, 0.032726533710956573, 0.002921728417277336, 0.01486955489963293, 0.01656515710055828, -0.004224035423249006, 0.05842334404587746, 0.08035963773727417, -0.06781938672065735, 0.02473156899213791, -0.005549137480556965, 0.035831429064273834, -0.03480509668588638, 0.06531717628240585, 0.023328660055994987, 0.013076136820018291, 0.0434521920979023, -0.021772336214780807, 0.04369658976793289, -0.12220576405525208, 0.015332655049860477, -0.008785886690020561, -0.031441736966371536, -0.018524901941418648, -0.01053228136152029, -0.014597125351428986, -0.05199097841978073, -0.04540431872010231, 0.009402355179190636, 0.02039901353418827, -0.003337281057611108, 0.05147750675678253, -0.06533964723348618, -0.08513087034225464, -0.019126158207654953, -0.015066166408360004, 0.054599639028310776, 0.016177279874682426, -0.03641314059495926, -0.015061353333294392, -0.03622850403189659, -0.039960186928510666, 0.037514105439186096, -0.009873231872916222, -0.08744747191667557, -0.01358227338641882, -0.0976683497428894, -0.015013438649475574, 0.08026885986328125, -0.021823102608323097, 0.019755464047193527, 0.018702426925301552, -0.011368240229785442, -0.03406791016459465, -0.04173756763339043, -0.005656982306391001, 0.0404924638569355, 0.06553107500076294, 0.07438906282186508, -0.0023689197842031717, -0.007871934212744236, 0.0003913631080649793, 0.01081481296569109, -0.04281703010201454, -0.01840086840093136, -0.036910057067871094, -0.016030842438340187, -0.007861441001296043, 0.04354337975382805, 0.009083208627998829, -0.06664968281984329, 0.04780512675642967, -0.06394842267036438, -0.043742623180150986, 0.00042665156070142984, 0.01474722195416689, 0.05086900293827057, -0.06051691994071007, 0.007530173286795616, -0.09661728888750076, 0.007039641495794058, -0.00002714346192078665, -0.0363403856754303, 0.0318637490272522, 0.008254030719399452, 0.021946417167782784, 0.08289346098899841, 0.033052802085876465, 0.0486607551574707, 0.009981774725019932, 0.13832558691501617, 0.013869967311620712, 0.0523233525454998, 0.04178323969244957, 0.03628316521644592, 0.01653009094297886, -0.007748725358396769, -0.009378300048410892, -0.019684532657265663, -0.02594851888716221, 0.11416777223348618, -0.040586166083812714, -0.06460556387901306, -0.0626257061958313, 0.019611191004514694, 0.01662387326359749, -0.019006572663784027, 0.028352761641144753, 0.0004585373098962009, -0.025523699820041656, 0.07127568125724792, -0.001057152054272592, -0.053072739392519, -0.0009250616421923041, 0.027891915291547775, -0.05322961509227753, 0.0070409709587693214, 0.009716914966702461, 0.008834520354866982, 0.013454164378345013, -0.0009265124681405723, -0.004984263330698013, 0.0035341333132237196, -0.027131322771310806, 0.021549640223383904, 0.1097954735159874, 0.03868253901600838, -0.001028195139952004, -0.017665768042206764, 0.013406472280621529, 0.01736423373222351, 0.007068759761750698, 0.08988890796899796, 0.017363758757710457, 0.016125431284308434, -0.0005190095398575068, -0.0027222863864153624, 0.01956864260137081, 0.018445979803800583, -0.01258092187345028, 0.060177333652973175, 0.028325146064162254, 0.11381136626005173, -0.020130561664700508, 0.0038864477537572384, 0.05717642232775688, -0.02051621489226818, 0.02234487235546112, 0.029293909668922424, -0.029767081141471863, -0.03701434284448624, 0.02297108992934227, 0.02090689353644848, 0.015052403323352337 ]
208
208
Achievability results for statistical learning under communication constraints
The problem of statistical learning is to construct an accurate predictor of a random variable as a function of a correlated random variable on the basis of an i.i.d. training sample from their joint distribution. Allowable predictors are constrained to lie in some specified class, and the goal is to approach asymptotically the performance of the best predictor in the class. We consider two settings in which the learning agent only has access to rate-limited descriptions of the training data, and present information-theoretic bounds on the predictor performance achievable in the presence of these communication constraints. Our proofs do not assume any separation structure between compression and learning and rely on a new class of operational criteria specifically tailored to joint design of encoders and learning algorithms in rate-constrained settings.
[ 0.034034498035907745, -0.06975741684436798, 0.02174036018550396, -0.031839769333601, 0.06664634495973587, -0.09515475481748581, 0.004608738236129284, 0.018167084082961082, -0.04575057700276375, 0.05350913479924202, -0.00869511254131794, 0.019066408276557922, -0.026712803170084953, -0.005716319661587477, 0.010917896404862404, -0.08088313043117523, -0.04214094951748848, 0.04186238721013069, 0.03781864047050476, -0.023803165182471275, 0.00799545831978321, -0.015395554713904858, 0.006027128081768751, -0.04178422689437866, -0.03216491639614105, -0.03949118033051491, -0.03317771106958389, 0.03849034383893013, 0.014815187081694603, 0.0011593201197683811, -0.028543246909976006, -0.014514284208416939, -0.029821103438735008, 0.03601068630814552, -0.0035346541553735733, 0.0146139245480299, 0.048712681978940964, -0.0639619305729866, -0.060970865190029144, 0.014574512839317322, -0.06319236010313034, 0.010514909401535988, 0.005582272075116634, 0.015283647924661636, -0.0092901811003685, -0.02358528971672058, -0.07091133296489716, 0.02163594588637352, -0.04557666927576065, 0.041292302310466766, -0.05551939457654953, 0.007726535201072693, 0.018583735451102257, -0.05179186910390854, -0.04089632257819176, 0.017850585281848907, 0.013278591446578503, -0.058753084391355515, -0.06399916857481003, -0.017316222190856934, -0.03273146227002144, 0.06644333899021149, 0.040139295160770416, -0.05174022540450096, -0.020601704716682434, 0.02138892561197281, -0.05844425782561302, 0.039644449949264526, 0.028127126395702362, -0.0053474209271371365, 0.011024708859622478, -0.04927751049399376, 0.051292937248945236, 0.015608071349561214, 0.06281843781471252, -0.04147285968065262, -0.04546671360731125, 0.009808131493628025, -0.004141517449170351, 0.014715203084051609, -0.04914197325706482, 0.06194496154785156, 0.0216266717761755, 0.05691032484173775, -0.0307709239423275, 0.014750165864825249, -0.019860435277223587, 0.004427232779562473, -0.019110726192593575, -0.0741809755563736, -0.007361696567386389, 0.07037008553743362, -0.07700628787279129, 0.010186237283051014, -0.0007693273364566267, 0.04268322512507439, -0.01099261362105608, 0.006149644497781992, 0.010796976275742054, 0.01558017823845148, 0.09055998921394348, 0.022160112857818604, 0.011894441209733486, 0.06908111274242401, 0.010998827405273914, 0.009961488656699657, -0.03872036561369896, 0.045988671481609344, 0.05965692549943924, -0.02198905497789383, 0.015990249812602997, -0.009245031513273716, -0.024443194270133972, -0.06293872743844986, -0.04096120968461037, 0.1161406859755516, 0.003366363001987338, 0.04839025437831879, 0.028818173334002495, 0.04713987186551094, -0.0011382503435015678, -0.01429857686161995, -0.034431781619787216, 0.027836786583065987, 0.06205424293875694, -0.017716120928525925, -0.03719601780176163, -0.058903492987155914, 0.08724012970924377, 0.03189777582883835, -0.020516037940979004, -0.03474627807736397, -0.02322455495595932, -0.026251668110489845, -0.02652406506240368, 0.021218089386820793, 0.015425845049321651, -0.009859289042651653, -0.01672571524977684, -0.05422702804207802, -0.0032749641686677933, -0.04339037090539932, -0.03009924478828907, -0.06851088255643845, 0.02213755063712597, 0.06261341273784637, 0.011360776610672474, -0.004815979395061731, 0.022682933136820793, 0.011617077514529228, 0.011005752719938755, -0.044860560446977615, 0.009642749093472958, 0.027148811146616936, 0.07265716046094894, -0.044864486902952194, -0.06986445933580399, -0.03335849195718765, -0.05297334864735603, 0.07836151868104935, -0.03714472055435181, 0.015321530401706696, 0.08676258474588394, 0.058466628193855286, -0.03097979910671711, -0.01215434167534113, -0.034882061183452606, -0.0648711696267128, -0.07154570519924164, -0.035178497433662415, -0.0408107191324234, -0.0384797565639019, -0.005579483695328236, 0.0020625030156224966, 0.036792345345020294, 0.0014340162742882967, -0.012813285924494267, 0.007445048075169325, -0.0130290063098073, -0.05325872078537941, 0.028512319549918175, -0.030285470187664032, -0.03551725670695305, -0.025064388290047646, 0.045943498611450195, 0.1364905834197998, -0.0026838481426239014, 0.06557713449001312, 0.04841504991054535, -0.029250049963593483, 0.06698185950517654, -0.029880834743380547, 0.009866406209766865, 0.04344112426042557, -0.10847515612840652, 0.030175697058439255, -0.0444583036005497, -0.011259203776717186, 0.020079249516129494, 0.07127752155065536, 0.05581168457865715, -0.04419602081179619, -0.024717338383197784, -0.018652785569429398, -0.09477681666612625, 0.014448468573391438, -0.012124420143663883, -0.09543037414550781, 0.0016998425126075745, -0.0031502435449510813, 0.031197257339954376, 0.0037184476386755705, 0.03002573549747467, -0.027195142582058907, 0.012959287501871586, -0.06216222792863846, -0.01783399097621441, -0.049797557294368744, 0.049349814653396606, -0.05187855660915375, 0.005737269297242165, 0.04042414575815201, -0.05682076886296272, -0.034679390490055084, -0.00339922565035522, 0.012896185740828514, 0.051875561475753784, 0.019709063693881035, -0.084363654255867, 0.015104967169463634, -0.02322368323802948, -0.04046104475855827, -0.04568397253751755, -0.019686562940478325, -0.026735424995422363, 0.016701718792319298, -0.042457688599824905, -0.038147758692502975, -0.04072382301092148, -0.00026728343800641596, -0.06337118148803711, 0.019285980612039566, 0.0011975637171417475, 0.046416956931352615, 0.07611166685819626, -0.043313369154930115, 0.03125549852848053, 0.017857763916254044, -0.05026078596711159, -0.03676904737949371, 0.12168491631746292, 0.013579336926341057, -0.01300260704010725, -0.02995448373258114, 0.0693625882267952, 0.031138896942138672, 0.0517134889960289, -0.02839653566479683, 0.07624279707670212, 0.05476526543498039, 0.004408858250826597, -0.010716965422034264, -0.06143437698483467, 0.0598238967359066, 0.05033472180366516, -0.007162656635046005, -0.08970626443624496, 0.08006953448057175, 0.04413124546408653, 0.0327703095972538, -0.039959147572517395, -0.008215748704969883, -0.024186985567212105, 0.021258050575852394, -0.0728820338845253, 0.0029057159554213285, 0.0872313380241394, -0.008225503377616405, 0.042957741767168045, 0.04435087740421295, -0.041276123374700546, 0.027520276606082916, -0.059126757085323334, 0.031278274953365326, -0.016686633229255676, 0.037351008504629135, -0.03364704176783562, 0.01849331706762314, -0.030106013640761375, 0.03267287835478783, -0.04484934359788895, 0.02242991328239441, -0.00847387220710516, -0.000500640831887722, 0.04896952211856842, -0.05103760585188866, 0.019028518348932266, 0.029849369078874588, 0.04866008460521698, -0.07647303491830826, -0.001095890998840332, -0.05786805599927902, 0.03707579895853996, 0.0869160145521164, 0.02284429594874382, 0.07820113748311996, 0.0806160569190979, 0.019897745922207832, -0.04387287423014641, -0.029673177748918533, 0.035596467554569244, -0.007445530034601688, -0.014651614241302013, -0.02022191509604454, -0.028201868757605553, -0.05246955156326294, 0.019015228375792503, -0.02674262598156929, 0.014725524000823498, -0.08170101791620255, 0.08558528125286102, -0.05302989110350609, -0.03317474573850632, -0.0008979620179161429, -0.08354514092206955, 0.043012090027332306, 0.03776390105485916, -0.02422979287803173, -0.05217619240283966, 0.0015543350018560886, -0.124642014503479, -0.02388300560414791, -0.0022222213447093964, 0.11479991674423218, 0.015620777383446693, 0.05539882928133011, -0.03389589861035347, -0.038269009441137314, 0.00043277369695715606, 0.08748036623001099, -0.00690501369535923, -0.09748651087284088, -0.05509037524461746, -0.07651906460523605, 0.035527314990758896, 0.031436510384082794, 0.09050030261278152, 0.010278841480612755, 0.002172945998609066, 0.05942155793309212, -0.03714469447731972, -0.034728456288576126, -0.005122228991240263, 0.019307078793644905, -0.022713234648108482, 0.010083438828587532, 0.013784267008304596, -0.013732552528381348, 0.02281028963625431, -0.009298937395215034, 0.020434733480215073, 0.016277944669127464, -0.02937689796090126, -0.042928799986839294, 0.04167331010103226, 0.044425882399082184, 0.008000052534043789, 0.002260555513203144, -0.10293368250131607, -0.025849781930446625, -0.027949731796979904, 0.06005594879388809, -0.015567448921501637, 0.021530577912926674, -0.003536292351782322, -0.069495789706707, -0.0012199763441458344, -0.0262847151607275, 0.02694726549088955, 0.08632880449295044, -0.05213760584592819, 0.004592888988554478, -0.017363792285323143, 0.04618058353662491, -0.05856014043092728, -0.009579738602042198, -0.08701442182064056, 0.009615796618163586, 0.07950571924448013, 0.044224709272384644, -0.09016703814268112, -0.04606695473194122, -0.021971048787236214, -0.01006049383431673, 0.08644647151231766, -0.015295040793716908, -0.02109450288116932, -0.0026548055466264486, -0.06648442894220352, -0.004208794329315424, 0.046924248337745667, -0.04997429996728897, 0.04289141669869423, -0.02149321511387825, -0.08413615822792053, -0.01565399207174778, 0.030139228329062462, 0.036599159240722656, 0.04954875260591507, 0.00941446889191866, 0.017399756237864494, 0.03262098506093025, -0.03285732865333557, 0.051684193313121796, -0.034872621297836304, 0.035397738218307495, -0.01993681862950325, -0.009289145469665527, 0.01973818615078926, -0.052120599895715714, -0.03271462023258209, -0.03998001664876938, 0.01110667921602726, -0.05144123733043671, 0.08535300940275192, -0.00195877393707633, 0.027172766625881195, -0.0036940898280590773, -0.015056499280035496, 0.018173731863498688, -0.01928689330816269, -0.00277314311824739, -0.04793022200465202, -0.05697175860404968, 0.05059158802032471, 0.06023167818784714, -0.019193138927221298, -0.024864891543984413, 0.01129190158098936, 0.035158392041921616, -0.10463487356901169, 0.021985996514558792, 0.022014232352375984, 0.00914707686752081, -0.006388933397829533, 0.014454441145062447, 0.01299013290554285, 0.03290596604347229, 0.06598468124866486, 0.04500792920589447, 0.028691790997982025, -0.006904393434524536, 0.04849163442850113, -0.015987267717719078, -0.01901225931942463, -0.045154672116041183, 0.01074843481183052, -0.023589355871081352, 0.05936521291732788, -0.02689976803958416, -0.07161299139261246, -0.036303192377090454, 0.03845495730638504, -0.013697795569896698, -0.03572280332446098, -0.006987065076828003, -0.0029036446940153837, 0.020901501178741455, 0.07390754669904709, 0.02610616199672222, -0.022168796509504318, 0.030389320105314255, -0.033154696226119995, -0.07373489439487457, 0.024616174399852753, 0.04413571208715439, -0.004833899904042482, -0.04613430052995682, 0.017147736623883247, -0.001779153710231185, -0.03916754573583603, -0.03796960413455963, -0.0025908013340085745, 0.02277044951915741, 0.11945995688438416, 0.02558441460132599, -0.06111188605427742, -0.02635241113603115, 0.04092822223901749, 0.09033776819705963, -0.030206430703401566, -0.023225048556923866, 0.02409718558192253, -0.024061916396021843, 0.047985419631004333, -0.04400525242090225, 0.018976932391524315, -0.019540468230843544, 0.012888569384813309, 0.09090953320264816, 0.04213262349367142, 0.028106870129704475, 0.012191742658615112, -0.009616446681320667, 0.08716827630996704, 0.08433876186609268, 0.10833468288183212, 0.04463827610015869, -0.05420204997062683, 0.058318573981523514, -0.05941625311970711, 0.07977928966283798 ]
209
209
A Limit Theorem in Singular Regression Problem
In statistical problems, a set of parameterized probability distributions is used to estimate the true probability distribution. If Fisher information matrix at the true distribution is singular, then it has been left unknown what we can estimate about the true distribution from random samples. In this paper, we study a singular regression problem and prove a limit theorem which shows the relation between the singular regression problem and two birational invariants, a real log canonical threshold and a singular fluctuation. The obtained theorem has an important application to statistics, because it enables us to estimate the generalization error from the training error without any knowledge of the true probability distribution.
[ 0.035880569368600845, -0.06995298713445663, 0.04537670686841011, -0.07834530621767044, 0.02852504514157772, -0.0018720184452831745, 0.04148175194859505, 0.04758652299642563, -0.02736607939004898, 0.03334702178835869, 0.035859715193510056, -0.007742326240986586, -0.03506546840071678, 0.04109887778759003, -0.01042648684233427, -0.03521094098687172, -0.0024116095155477524, 0.04032602533698082, -0.0007764748297631741, -0.03663818910717964, 0.0009144698269665241, 0.12844190001487732, 0.07909298688173294, -0.049684662371873856, 0.005500555504113436, 0.03905998170375824, 0.01672258786857128, 0.054451834410429, -0.016841093078255653, -0.016716448590159416, -0.07010835409164429, -0.0028471124824136496, -0.05385095626115799, -0.027440445497632027, 0.02037886343896389, -0.03515758737921715, 0.008048548363149166, -0.005907736252993345, -0.025647765025496483, -0.018183382228016853, 0.01847199909389019, -0.05889911577105522, -0.008815701119601727, -0.0033422051928937435, 0.013802483677864075, 0.02631056308746338, 0.08159693330526352, -0.010584472678601742, -0.010469251312315464, 0.022204671055078506, -0.011261438950896263, 0.06404335796833038, -0.09055399149656296, -0.0888538584113121, 0.05396107956767082, -0.07473158836364746, 0.007221783511340618, -0.0032102300319820642, -0.011709638871252537, 0.019520994275808334, -0.08768445253372192, 0.10638067871332169, -0.05419202893972397, -0.05425721034407616, -0.010602074675261974, 0.02706492878496647, -0.11537735909223557, 0.019463080912828445, 0.06115381792187691, -0.008642073720693588, 0.07144375890493393, -0.0005623358301818371, 0.05693333223462105, 0.025877008214592934, 0.049619872123003006, -0.1073899120092392, -0.011364713311195374, 0.002501397393643856, -0.04012430086731911, 0.040257614105939865, -0.033135365694761276, 0.04387041926383972, 0.027282675728201866, 0.004705979023128748, -0.0780370756983757, 0.0034063956700265408, -0.016821105033159256, 0.009440886788070202, 0.01355519238859415, -0.05341293662786484, 0.03083261474967003, 0.04909045621752739, -0.013751709833741188, -0.02906865067780018, -0.011411194689571857, 0.02281026355922222, -0.022847365587949753, -0.04798230528831482, -0.009504904970526695, -0.034562643617391586, 0.04081227257847786, 0.02435421198606491, 0.08919193595647812, 0.06729909032583237, 0.0033541019074618816, 0.03805927932262421, 0.012691485695540905, 0.06129828840494156, -0.027191881090402603, -0.03888790309429169, -0.019944651052355766, -0.09628826379776001, 0.011686463840305805, 0.027894973754882812, -0.028838180005550385, 0.12183862179517746, 0.006362032610923052, 0.020078623667359352, 0.048290103673934937, -0.028417015448212624, 0.0867767184972763, 0.015983378514647484, -0.04647357389330864, -0.0011775075690820813, 0.04831954464316368, -0.044675562530756, -0.04731355607509613, -0.08689140528440475, 0.12375394254922867, 0.008586641401052475, 0.0017817667685449123, 0.031954579055309296, -0.005983687471598387, -0.027437860146164894, -0.05096659064292908, 0.0730249211192131, 0.03595856949687004, 0.030955718830227852, 0.019362276419997215, 0.0591801255941391, -0.0018078851280733943, 0.016348794102668762, 0.016780680045485497, -0.0684417262673378, -0.05108710750937462, 0.046832211315631866, 0.017359349876642227, -0.06884114444255829, -0.056170422583818436, 0.011779310181736946, 0.040766000747680664, -0.03445868566632271, -0.0013242181157693267, -0.0065744309686124325, 0.14528310298919678, -0.0596638061106205, 0.009295416995882988, 0.037366852164268494, -0.012864485383033752, 0.04686933010816574, -0.029552260413765907, -0.0659719780087471, 0.02734725922346115, -0.01461976207792759, -0.03179905191063881, -0.015568631701171398, -0.011473123915493488, -0.091896653175354, 0.0294032022356987, -0.015182733535766602, -0.025649817660450935, -0.02711632288992405, -0.002458803588524461, -0.01996690407395363, -0.013407613150775433, -0.019537825137376785, 0.001276720897294581, -0.048518091440200806, -0.005662215407937765, 0.002617897465825081, 0.013194623403251171, -0.026320049539208412, -0.0071642124094069, 0.050749391317367554, 0.05529110133647919, 0.10850272327661514, -0.035412926226854324, -0.03755845129489899, 0.08976513147354126, 0.037340860813856125, 0.12115062028169632, 0.031676243990659714, -0.0774441510438919, -0.020515166223049164, -0.02788582257926464, 0.014434780925512314, -0.09004203230142593, -0.019870802760124207, 0.02001437544822693, 0.02271830104291439, -0.003333903383463621, 0.02386770397424698, 0.005831066053360701, -0.035803455859422684, -0.03669389709830284, 0.08790789544582367, 0.02159384824335575, -0.07519958168268204, 0.009745490737259388, 0.025835979729890823, 0.035713933408260345, 0.010368251241743565, 0.021721890196204185, -0.04616841301321983, -0.011207032017409801, -0.0661332756280899, 0.02374448999762535, -0.04104458540678024, 0.05236070975661278, -0.03924434259533882, -0.016979513689875603, 0.028194477781653404, 0.06294773519039154, -0.0016923830844461918, -0.09902041405439377, -0.005235927179455757, -0.023311762139201164, 0.014421856962144375, -0.040168315172195435, 0.06711890548467636, 0.024909930303692818, -0.042039476335048676, 0.016871502622961998, -0.02520466409623623, 0.02724486030638218, 0.058609142899513245, -0.08868108689785004, 0.056299176067113876, -0.002046986948698759, 0.06344373524188995, -0.016443539410829544, -0.03240262717008591, -0.08720973134040833, -0.0005360820214264095, -0.048512671142816544, 0.0035983389243483543, 0.04218291863799095, 0.03940407931804657, 0.1071310043334961, -0.042123522609472275, -0.0027121487073600292, -0.05752509832382202, -0.01880841702222824, -0.057142406702041626, 0.009208242408931255, 0.0304348636418581, -0.03137141466140747, 0.05013459175825119, -0.01412709429860115, 0.041276585310697556, -0.023690685629844666, 0.09804603457450867, -0.031960342079401016, 0.02552640065550804, 0.05028665065765381, 0.03301750868558884, 0.02251187153160572, 0.008478031493723392, 0.00028494803700596094, 0.023864027112722397, -0.05911844223737717, -0.048162464052438736, -0.01744089275598526, 0.029998978599905968, -0.0641281008720398, 0.026671027764678, 0.04435800388455391, -0.021595897153019905, 0.06919307261705399, 0.023001622408628464, -0.024456167593598366, 0.04368308559060097, -0.014967360533773899, -0.019370760768651962, -0.007736162282526493, 0.054287247359752655, 0.03399525210261345, -0.059024982154369354, 0.0223843976855278, 0.0442957803606987, -0.06175481155514717, 0.053940482437610626, -0.00851534679532051, -0.02882605418562889, 0.019321659579873085, 0.0033233887515962124, 0.04704735055565834, 0.005132730584591627, 0.04789010062813759, 0.027688488364219666, 0.01797674223780632, -0.0002142708981409669, 0.04551571235060692, 0.0049425456672906876, 0.04802531376481056, 0.030073942616581917, 0.017224498093128204, -0.03354593366384506, -0.022017817944288254, -0.02187412604689598, 0.045059531927108765, -0.023039251565933228, -0.041462648659944534, -0.02385852113366127, 0.06989490240812302, -0.0501297190785408, -0.005606804508715868, -0.04792730137705803, 0.0011735295411199331, -0.034825399518013, -0.032870836555957794, 0.0195438452064991, -0.052685145288705826, -0.04101336747407913, -0.05354733765125275, 0.0663486197590828, 0.04081735014915466, -0.0059678698889911175, -0.0673251673579216, -0.00965043157339096, -0.0015398396644741297, -0.06045093387365341, -0.048215102404356, 0.12480706721544266, 0.00835411623120308, 0.06142153590917587, -0.0638202577829361, -0.03341785818338394, 0.04340881481766701, 0.0006010069628246129, -0.05319313332438469, -0.04578066244721413, -0.01631256192922592, 0.027704278007149696, 0.006666194647550583, 0.04294738546013832, 0.07043140381574631, -0.042902909219264984, -0.0833764374256134, -0.03329122066497803, -0.042841240763664246, -0.003356876317411661, 0.033754460513591766, 0.005433640442788601, -0.030576510354876518, 0.045614153146743774, -0.01854906789958477, -0.03977976366877556, 0.021993206813931465, 0.003342776093631983, 0.037094596773386, 0.0423484742641449, -0.03153993561863899, 0.024452388286590576, 0.002338667865842581, 0.03708084672689438, -0.03372417017817497, 0.07005373388528824, -0.018109433352947235, 0.07525549083948135, -0.012233222834765911, 0.007325415033847094, -0.011973623186349869, 0.049320779740810394, 0.0229052621871233, -0.0008708247914910316, 0.0019127721898257732, -0.022697703912854195, -0.05071202293038368, 0.01913691870868206, -0.044133760035037994, -0.004389142617583275, -0.11000750958919525, 0.05751842260360718, -0.007497117388993502, -0.04206555336713791, -0.010103159584105015, -0.019306091591715813, 0.03643786534667015, -0.010098055936396122, 0.02797406166791916, 0.014850905165076256, 0.00957932323217392, 0.06789945065975189, -0.020637378096580505, 0.08181151747703552, -0.012848337180912495, -0.02650809846818447, -0.08383236825466156, 0.02526772767305374, 0.003674768377095461, -0.019701333716511726, -0.027416490018367767, -0.021135864779353142, -0.055279165506362915, 0.011607096530497074, 0.003609907580539584, -0.005140269175171852, -0.04194618761539459, 0.030355194583535194, 0.032922737300395966, 0.01037017721682787, -0.05274084582924843, 0.03356681019067764, -0.06544652581214905, -0.012244006618857384, 0.02040555141866207, -0.04923364520072937, -0.003717975690960884, -0.035219956189394, 0.009305373765528202, 0.053435541689395905, -0.0063050054013729095, -0.02686813473701477, 0.011804105713963509, -0.04967370629310608, 0.00640405248850584, 0.051577191799879074, 0.0616115964949131, 0.018514689058065414, -0.07190010696649551, -0.06259986758232117, -0.0929916501045227, 0.008268103003501892, 0.014556228183209896, -0.07743288576602936, -0.04686235263943672, -0.05402252823114395, 0.00030801017419435084, -0.05313647538423538, 0.0012514404952526093, 0.03427105024456978, -0.02122366428375244, 0.020553218200802803, -0.03378796577453613, 0.0439843013882637, 0.008702266030013561, -0.04319016635417938, 0.0066932616755366325, 0.03667771816253662, 0.009234697557985783, 0.009136153385043144, 0.008336755447089672, -0.011056600138545036, 0.004497260320931673, 0.02683228813111782, 0.008519155904650688, 0.017752336338162422, -0.019633328542113304, 0.03973638266324997, -0.05701744928956032, -0.07192107290029526, -0.03228604048490524, 0.03598157688975334, -0.14586623013019562, -0.035849932581186295, 0.022652171552181244, 0.012721825391054153, 0.03504427149891853, -0.028046658262610435, -0.005086670629680157, -0.02436237223446369, -0.008934970013797283, -0.002123958198353648, -0.031115395948290825, -0.006877894513309002, 0.021199386566877365, -0.0741654559969902, 0.026393910869956017, -0.08575554937124252, -0.02389669232070446, -0.05977329984307289, -0.03059685230255127, -0.03944501653313637, 0.08432892709970474, 0.0922454446554184, 0.030300676822662354, -0.023083992302417755, 0.10644511878490448, 0.019514283165335655, 0.058408305048942566, 0.004310096148401499, -0.05266186594963074, 0.005951357074081898, 0.02357933670282364, 0.02687409706413746, -0.04837075620889664, -0.007001111749559641, -0.04587746411561966, -0.0006679503712803125, 0.0172707661986351, 0.03982231393456459, -0.01262695249170065, 0.03558969125151634, 0.014559052884578705, 0.025033511221408844, -0.026592658832669258, -0.08663459122180939, -0.016705630347132683, 0.0757245123386383, 0.0016998180653899908, -0.03914691135287285 ]
210
210
Matrix Completion from a Few Entries
Let M be a random (alpha n) x n matrix of rank r<<n, and assume that a uniformly random subset E of its entries is observed. We describe an efficient algorithm that reconstructs M from |E| = O(rn) observed entries with relative root mean square error RMSE <= C(rn/|E|)^0.5 . Further, if r=O(1), M can be reconstructed exactly from |E| = O(n log(n)) entries. These results apply beyond random matrices to general low-rank incoherent matrices. This settles (in the case of bounded rank) a question left open by Candes and Recht and improves over the guarantees for their reconstruction algorithm. The complexity of our algorithm is O(|E|r log(n)), which opens the way to its use for massive data sets. In the process of proving these statements, we obtain a generalization of a celebrated result by Friedman-Kahn-Szemeredi and Feige-Ofek on the spectrum of sparse random matrices.
[ -0.017955174669623375, -0.05109405890107155, 0.06055410951375961, -0.10017798095941544, 0.00705723837018013, -0.022046871483325958, 0.05393575504422188, 0.03200588375329971, -0.04612558335065842, 0.013932639732956886, 0.03034868836402893, -0.03824612870812416, 0.0029039967339485884, 0.05988074094057083, -0.07844890654087067, -0.07992126047611237, -0.044544611126184464, -0.012229305692017078, 0.012070750817656517, -0.04175233840942383, -0.006275082007050514, -0.03415246680378914, 0.04573459550738335, -0.04351527988910675, -0.011383864097297192, 0.05904947221279144, -0.028133485466241837, 0.0036122570745646954, -0.010526622645556927, -0.07373537868261337, -0.06615704298019409, 0.016571057960391045, -0.011193258687853813, -0.02358054555952549, -0.02564411237835884, 0.012966561131179333, 0.05684715509414673, 0.02677016332745552, -0.012326396070420742, 0.0010327848140150309, -0.047244343906641006, 0.02082294039428234, -0.024273931980133057, 0.009797336533665657, -0.009083868004381657, 0.07122315466403961, 0.06152220070362091, 0.0053046769462525845, 0.02647790126502514, 0.0011804980458691716, -0.007421512622386217, 0.04521928355097771, 0.012270255014300346, -0.03427470847964287, -0.07576655596494675, -0.010810840874910355, -0.014150296337902546, 0.040253788232803345, -0.0026753717102110386, -0.0007756486884318292, 0.04576031491160393, 0.055087752640247345, 0.055060409009456635, -0.05135286599397659, 0.04590039327740669, -0.016669560223817825, -0.04170052707195282, 0.042165059596300125, -0.0465753972530365, -0.05551113188266754, 0.005152067169547081, -0.09525849670171738, 0.09683418273925781, 0.013282405212521553, 0.05927053466439247, 0.0494440495967865, 0.025658758357167244, 0.0159373190253973, 0.016859952360391617, 0.06370294839143753, -0.02978632040321827, 0.08141575753688812, -0.0034673730842769146, 0.02167390286922455, -0.05063968896865845, 0.06859437376260757, -0.07934679836034775, -0.021220557391643524, 0.011936227791011333, -0.06976737827062607, -0.07365190982818604, -0.0012519890442490578, -0.09176202863454819, 0.07198961079120636, -0.006769844330847263, 0.07077087461948395, -0.042093995958566666, -0.01256625261157751, -0.0775466039776802, 0.08565591275691986, 0.09180311858654022, 0.03497174009680748, 0.0024956469424068928, 0.06256978958845139, -0.058102015405893326, -0.010906360112130642, -0.051312945783138275, 0.03008398227393627, -0.00895973015576601, -0.03674757853150368, -0.025708362460136414, 0.0007824786007404327, -0.0119751812890172, 0.011348088271915913, -0.03405121713876724, 0.04141291230916977, -0.023836569860577583, 0.07602671533823013, -0.038425762206315994, -0.022953549399971962, 0.05094378814101219, -0.035958386957645416, -0.02889886312186718, 0.07525061815977097, -0.012854569591581821, -0.004076104611158371, 0.0022733407095074654, -0.02559276670217514, 0.08001752942800522, -0.03205018863081932, -0.0841594934463501, -0.039638686925172806, 0.04970165714621544, -0.02347940020263195, -0.08943599462509155, -0.011435582302510738, 0.019627004861831665, -0.04911952465772629, -0.02475832775235176, 0.04185749962925911, 0.02722884714603424, -0.04259609803557396, -0.0023399952333420515, -0.04228807985782623, 0.003566269064322114, -0.04820014536380768, 0.0345015786588192, 0.024599887430667877, -0.07828281074762344, -0.01735062524676323, -0.06166763976216316, -0.04688045755028725, 0.016213078051805496, 0.018080029636621475, 0.04963582754135132, -0.07824698835611343, -0.07771644741296768, -0.01831900328397751, -0.05405746400356293, 0.02772403322160244, -0.09829797595739365, -0.0003735432110261172, -0.020465852692723274, 0.049516625702381134, -0.057810116559267044, -0.0011081105330958962, -0.0007599020027555525, -0.05118994787335396, 0.001847496721893549, -0.012970145791769028, 0.040997494012117386, 0.059749994426965714, 0.023652922362089157, -0.0022298875264823437, -0.034650079905986786, 0.0074100736528635025, 0.05337250232696533, -0.007014155853539705, -0.028269685804843903, -0.0987967848777771, 0.0052116853184998035, -0.025345275178551674, -0.023194445297122, -0.01719895750284195, 0.002173098037019372, 0.07054593414068222, 0.04014543816447258, 0.02216438390314579, -0.007603703998029232, 0.035410020500421524, 0.05697590857744217, -0.04067641496658325, 0.008546379394829273, -0.07088419049978256, -0.02924683503806591, 0.07148188352584839, -0.09498775005340576, 0.029387954622507095, 0.08029881119728088, 0.022348472848534584, 0.017411047592759132, 0.03873065859079361, 0.02991722710430622, -0.09458084404468536, -0.043558184057474136, -0.014883020892739296, -0.009044112637639046, 0.03738681226968765, 0.043413616716861725, 0.034690115600824356, 0.06754861772060394, 0.05762580409646034, 0.007063138764351606, -0.060087885707616806, 0.044922780245542526, -0.0123347332701087, 0.029292728751897812, -0.03705494478344917, 0.010694257915019989, 0.032938454300165176, -0.02879432588815689, 0.02692795917391777, -0.04552054405212402, 0.0029568783938884735, -0.05630410090088844, 0.010239724069833755, 0.06644155830144882, -0.017407409846782684, -0.022245053201913834, -0.02089153788983822, -0.01555146835744381, -0.045694150030612946, -0.05494614690542221, -0.031747713685035706, -0.0014676436549052596, 0.06474953144788742, -0.014231628738343716, -0.0013442282797768712, 0.026110604405403137, 0.053491245955228806, 0.08162833750247955, 0.056015536189079285, 0.031193111091852188, -0.008372805081307888, 0.0008315779850818217, -0.05735543370246887, 0.03785523772239685, 0.0328560397028923, 0.008925708942115307, 0.056483667343854904, 0.020135696977376938, 0.021231122314929962, -0.0184607096016407, -0.03412846848368645, 0.06621052324771881, 0.05452125146985054, 0.0235885139554739, 0.010519455187022686, 0.0035226147156208754, 0.054350122809410095, 0.05477001890540123, 0.02106454223394394, -0.06008373200893402, 0.06669994443655014, 0.024867581203579903, 0.04051373898983002, -0.07827700674533844, 0.014127055183053017, 0.009846242144703865, 0.10102291405200958, 0.014583823271095753, -0.014916381798684597, -0.032730236649513245, 0.10497014224529266, -0.04505203291773796, 0.02144538424909115, 0.053965888917446136, 0.11187334358692169, -0.025392627343535423, -0.04779118299484253, -0.0010006369557231665, 0.07654881477355957, -0.0454157255589962, 0.00979665294289589, 0.016430385410785675, 0.015245014801621437, 0.043141864240169525, 0.04112048074603081, 0.01831865683197975, 0.032252561300992966, -0.024985244497656822, 0.021562498062849045, -0.021312054246664047, -0.018092568963766098, 0.015038865618407726, 0.0023003476671874523, 0.016305508092045784, 0.0348762646317482, 0.00521126901730895, -0.0010460367193445563, 0.04264809191226959, -0.024110516533255577, 0.007176889572292566, -0.020906997844576836, 0.018475119024515152, -0.010999901220202446, 0.09768875688314438, 0.046857792884111404, -0.025593727827072144, -0.014695871621370316, 0.029450561851263046, -0.028585055842995644, -0.03149963915348053, -0.03434935584664345, 0.0029673557728528976, -0.025778833776712418, 0.003731163451448083, -0.07321161031723022, 0.09169766306877136, -0.04535260796546936, 0.0038259520661085844, -0.055656153708696365, 0.013634060509502888, -0.010609951801598072, -0.08323998749256134, -0.038533296436071396, 0.021493369713425636, 0.04194627329707146, -0.003934402950108051, -0.062213651835918427, 0.00910810474306345, 0.0021155597642064095, 0.0010656550293788314, 0.05629218742251396, 0.08472586423158646, 0.009541608393192291, -0.02538203075528145, -0.03958883509039879, 0.004191641230136156, 0.017917601391673088, 0.04519597813487053, -0.020233862102031708, -0.03990839049220085, -0.010792194865643978, 0.0773836150765419, 0.07598299533128738, 0.0515286959707737, -0.06463652849197388, 0.03517152741551399, 0.0017998333787545562, -0.0452454537153244, 0.02497611939907074, 0.0656767338514328, 0.030603831633925438, 0.014250664040446281, 0.012260179035365582, 0.06103809177875519, 0.06148518621921539, -0.005413129925727844, 0.0455644465982914, -0.018558122217655182, 0.07365783303976059, -0.022871581837534904, 0.0014611238148063421, 0.0033053099177777767, 0.019992420449852943, -0.026974443346261978, -0.0062932213768363, -0.04063492268323898, -0.0024654080625623465, 0.053300220519304276, -0.027640918269753456, 0.022129779681563377, -0.009684372693300247, -0.06520099192857742, -0.06539901345968246, 0.04704367741942406, 0.0078622130677104, 0.07327970117330551, 0.07299738377332687, -0.05535687133669853, 0.017095424234867096, -0.03546074032783508, 0.008838808164000511, -0.008956083096563816, -0.004965789616107941, -0.08141956478357315, 0.02328410930931568, 0.056232351809740067, 0.031369492411613464, 0.006816212087869644, 0.059023842215538025, 0.05491577461361885, -0.0014471984468400478, 0.02922573871910572, 0.0023532516788691282, 0.004752831533551216, -0.022171394899487495, -0.02139391377568245, -0.05012037232518196, 0.06889552623033524, -0.03258039429783821, -0.00696579460054636, -0.03984157368540764, -0.048687905073165894, -0.0026040314696729183, -0.04234927520155907, -0.0014696825528517365, 0.01090273167937994, 0.08414860814809799, -0.0024069887585937977, 0.017997464165091515, -0.04113268107175827, 0.01834949292242527, 0.021489741280674934, -0.002334539545699954, -0.010748437605798244, 0.01332961767911911, -0.04201476275920868, -0.04334362968802452, -0.0011978312395513058, 0.008921487256884575, 0.012164209969341755, -0.04812949523329735, -0.006109701935201883, 0.03695039078593254, 0.07659228891134262, 0.018093105405569077, 0.052863750606775284, 0.04380669817328453, -0.049678731709718704, -0.04097364470362663, 0.02452724426984787, -0.005877752788364887, 0.025888964533805847, -0.060910698026418686, -0.0152357779443264, -0.022518914192914963, -0.031764280050992966, 0.011583829298615456, -0.04501911625266075, -0.010293954983353615, -0.08612770587205887, 0.008535370230674744, 0.07878664135932922, 0.07380064576864243, 0.07174443453550339, -0.03149259462952614, 0.07029437273740768, 0.06585852801799774, -0.010860182344913483, 0.026438144966959953, -0.03978486731648445, -0.008496283553540707, -0.0376812182366848, 0.03426447883248329, 0.09416060894727707, 0.034625645726919174, 0.05015451833605766, -0.019576838240027428, -0.05992614105343819, -0.025215165689587593, 0.02279834635555744, -0.008823777548968792, -0.009599392302334309, -0.09215009212493896, 0.05966087430715561, 0.025811227038502693, 0.06626009941101074, 0.052930548787117004, -0.028337709605693817, 0.07749281823635101, -0.06208687275648117, 0.002631332026794553, -0.00034573039738461375, 0.046585168689489365, 0.04736550152301788, -0.07926100492477417, -0.0020874538458883762, -0.005576649680733681, -0.019211135804653168, -0.0850977897644043, 0.02915865369141102, 0.033464640378952026, 0.04708602651953697, 0.06029048562049866, -0.07945676147937775, 0.03174222633242607, 0.05923543497920036, 0.04642122983932495, 0.04104335606098175, 0.036909304559230804, 0.06579684466123581, -0.002972518326714635, -0.033347874879837036, 0.005873446352779865, 0.0326341912150383, 0.006027293857187033, 0.029934436082839966, 0.03143073618412018, -0.010468004271388054, -0.015158247202634811, 0.060227952897548676, 0.0015708764549344778, 0.08717408031225204, 0.08620837330818176, -0.01905200257897377, -0.08870325237512589, -0.05186533182859421, 0.1109711155295372, -0.018079036846756935, -0.06326428055763245 ]
211
211
Model-Consistent Sparse Estimation through the Bootstrap
We consider the least-square linear regression problem with regularization by the $\ell^1$-norm, a problem usually referred to as the Lasso. In this paper, we first present a detailed asymptotic analysis of model consistency of the Lasso in low-dimensional settings. For various decays of the regularization parameter, we compute asymptotic equivalents of the probability of correct model selection. For a specific rate decay, we show that the Lasso selects all the variables that should enter the model with probability tending to one exponentially fast, while it selects all other variables with strictly positive probability. We show that this property implies that if we run the Lasso for several bootstrapped replications of a given sample, then intersecting the supports of the Lasso bootstrap estimates leads to consistent model selection. This novel variable selection procedure, referred to as the Bolasso, is extended to high-dimensional settings by a provably consistent two-step procedure.
[ -0.006802544929087162, -0.04085833206772804, -0.04105221852660179, -0.01717003434896469, 0.006878268904983997, -0.06481345742940903, 0.029022864997386932, -0.017268385738134384, 0.04674064740538597, 0.08799511194229126, 0.00925472192466259, -0.03376884013414383, -0.010936085134744644, 0.061071328818798065, -0.038588620722293854, -0.05209178477525711, -0.03345827758312225, -0.03551378473639488, 0.03719519078731537, -0.02748381905257702, -0.07231272011995316, 0.006020136643201113, 0.05543573945760727, -0.07367667555809021, 0.04805043339729309, -0.026246361434459686, -0.003526433138176799, 0.05778643116354942, 0.0016943253576755524, 0.019227279350161552, -0.0591411367058754, 0.05791524425148964, 0.02959304116666317, -0.028606725856661797, 0.03794608265161514, -0.06745710223913193, 0.03656572848558426, 0.04702046141028404, -0.015050144866108894, -0.040550630539655685, 0.05258098244667053, -0.03676600754261017, 0.08348067104816437, 0.00701946159824729, 0.020647335797548294, -0.043514933437108994, 0.06539293378591537, 0.03794213756918907, -0.051667582243680954, -0.02086634188890457, -0.01948714256286621, 0.05226322263479233, -0.05688503012061119, -0.027232680469751358, 0.08430583775043488, -0.0041345576755702496, -0.07523186504840851, -0.010861113667488098, -0.06710276007652283, -0.015286151319742203, 0.034167297184467316, 0.05589476600289345, 0.03171177953481674, -0.08099628984928131, 0.018630174919962883, 0.017637038603425026, -0.07694536447525024, -0.0176563560962677, -0.05942147970199585, -0.03770971670746803, 0.015589619986712933, -0.09222135692834854, -0.0109549630433321, 0.005817955359816551, 0.040541842579841614, -0.013623442500829697, 0.02122146636247635, -0.04298792779445648, 0.001559079741127789, 0.04670435190200806, -0.010686353780329227, -0.026454444974660873, 0.029674449935555458, 0.036151986569166183, -0.043141525238752365, -0.017953967675566673, 0.04390157014131546, -0.030511585995554924, 0.035634845495224, -0.019264034926891327, -0.0019699346739798784, 0.04498070105910301, -0.023243483155965805, 0.03164346143603325, -0.026556268334388733, 0.06999728828668594, 0.06043069809675217, 0.03166075050830841, -0.026457246392965317, 0.011896438896656036, 0.06336638331413269, 0.007643070071935654, 0.03806031867861748, 0.0687347948551178, -0.04072396829724312, 0.02973543293774128, -0.014653443358838558, 0.01841406524181366, 0.01135967206209898, 0.005189843010157347, -0.01929691806435585, -0.03247855231165886, 0.04747324436903, -0.0016837121220305562, 0.0027002361603081226, 0.06266681849956512, -0.005164085887372494, 0.07638251036405563, 0.027633335441350937, -0.0538015179336071, 0.03073805384337902, 0.05646364018321037, -0.03580904006958008, 0.04788237810134888, -0.01749355159699917, 0.007070403546094894, -0.0010895478771999478, -0.0908920168876648, 0.08830529451370239, -0.04181317239999771, -0.035030853003263474, -0.04233914241194725, -0.022320682182908058, 0.015572329051792622, -0.06916406750679016, 0.023541660979390144, -0.029896089807152748, -0.055020950734615326, -0.07315904647111893, 0.07625023275613785, -0.07209772616624832, 0.011801312677562237, -0.022978991270065308, 0.06103368103504181, -0.04609842970967293, 0.006071588024497032, 0.020624125376343727, -0.0034138313494622707, -0.027347879484295845, -0.035870473831892014, 0.01608968712389469, -0.0689585953950882, 0.01371004804968834, 0.02914264425635338, 0.09295331686735153, -0.04701431468129158, 0.006270078010857105, 0.019887344911694527, -0.013214761391282082, 0.04102921113371849, -0.03541629761457443, -0.01132179144769907, 0.008068480528891087, 0.019238367676734924, -0.09223872423171997, -0.058702725917100906, -0.033263493329286575, 0.05766448751091957, -0.04484384134411812, 0.03942633792757988, -0.06263120472431183, 0.03205561637878418, -0.13005797564983368, -0.04654288664460182, 0.057864960283041, 0.03921637684106827, 0.11781568080186844, 0.03198860213160515, -0.057165153324604034, -0.05095139518380165, 0.04489627853035927, 0.022081667557358742, 0.02214251644909382, 0.026113951578736305, -0.01597975380718708, 0.06895123422145844, -0.008294468745589256, 0.01823367178440094, 0.025933001190423965, -0.05741102248430252, 0.08104608952999115, 0.00019889902614522725, -0.025977762416005135, 0.07396629452705383, 0.011369620449841022, 0.038135334849357605, -0.031956110149621964, 0.013899325393140316, 0.027721306309103966, -0.00019045142107643187, 0.030246244743466377, -0.002166919643059373, 0.01308799721300602, -0.08724981546401978, -0.01785929873585701, 0.012026477605104446, 0.07245747745037079, -0.06658340990543365, 0.010818298906087875, -0.03955836594104767, 0.002071510534733534, 0.024767713621258736, -0.07144356518983841, -0.08039138466119766, 0.019108988344669342, -0.04455602541565895, 0.023585671558976173, -0.06760779768228531, 0.03673670068383217, 0.04501166194677353, -0.006486144848167896, 0.07968998700380325, 0.053613897413015366, 0.01653965562582016, -0.06521706283092499, 0.01793794333934784, 0.04749426245689392, -0.023060793057084084, 0.018789147958159447, 0.052710868418216705, 0.00024388478777837008, -0.051933374255895615, -0.004675938747823238, 0.0194749366492033, -0.03780979663133621, 0.042648784816265106, 0.02932523936033249, -0.038541387766599655, 0.021355224773287773, -0.01725812815129757, -0.027104530483484268, 0.03849845379590988, -0.0003685696283355355, -0.0668146163225174, -0.06541137397289276, -0.019238203763961792, 0.05954873561859131, 0.02064247988164425, -0.032021887600421906, 0.00045838384539820254, -0.017931675538420677, 0.0033824003767222166, -0.033792320638895035, 0.00595512893050909, 0.009426522068679333, 0.0008099507540464401, -0.06463002413511276, 0.017701663076877594, -0.017848413437604904, 0.06204494833946228, 0.06978841125965118, 0.10727444291114807, -0.0757836401462555, -0.04214085265994072, 0.017155518755316734, -0.027331560850143433, 0.004789024591445923, -0.01138464268296957, 0.005849394015967846, 0.0228803139179945, 0.04177770018577576, -0.026757752522826195, -0.046355120837688446, 0.022943126037716866, -0.05712137371301651, -0.012403314933180809, 0.03937694802880287, 0.026111790910363197, 0.05272609367966652, -0.02631429210305214, 0.020678535103797913, 0.05223075672984123, 0.016496343538165092, -0.08771124482154846, -0.08692197501659393, -0.04666460305452347, 0.04158034175634384, 0.04804442077875137, -0.029611671343445778, 0.010227467864751816, -0.1175815612077713, 0.023296194151043892, 0.037024833261966705, 0.01941121555864811, -0.007134031038731337, -0.011678680777549744, 0.09229303151369095, -0.03318903222680092, 0.054515376687049866, 0.057563815265893936, -0.023406920954585075, 0.01557464711368084, 0.022536352276802063, -0.026955347508192062, -0.003198508871719241, 0.027495259419083595, 0.055173419415950775, 0.04645579680800438, -0.051350969821214676, 0.033342402428388596, -0.0368618406355381, -0.017071526497602463, -0.05705655738711357, -0.05592219904065132, -0.04246673732995987, -0.025947874411940575, -0.03236952796578407, -0.07244627177715302, 0.05736270174384117, 0.028754808008670807, 0.07988004386425018, 0.004355842247605324, 0.038738373667001724, 0.033400606364011765, -0.08253534138202667, -0.055859483778476715, -0.03557926043868065, 0.06691855937242508, 0.046816401183605194, -0.008839058689773083, 0.010317799635231495, -0.029470834881067276, -0.033029645681381226, 0.0197906494140625, -0.01660829968750477, 0.016190599650144577, -0.061233095824718475, -0.07042620331048965, -0.05882461369037628, -0.035927098244428635, 0.010350137017667294, -0.014566482044756413, -0.03750952333211899, -0.004579246509820223, 0.023163527250289917, -0.02370290644466877, 0.058898862451314926, -0.040909189730882645, -0.06144658848643303, -0.008478507399559021, -0.083803191781044, 0.027296077460050583, -0.015392815694212914, 0.04984647408127785, -0.03653373941779137, 0.06553559005260468, 0.06859011948108673, 0.009681623429059982, -0.039620038121938705, 0.03122255951166153, -0.02330428920686245, 0.0394931398332119, -0.005849899724125862, -0.032192353159189224, 0.018869414925575256, 0.09088429808616638, -0.013507403433322906, 0.03672395274043083, -0.0043009063228964806, 0.0704784244298935, -0.005224729422479868, 0.05431993305683136, -0.014066599309444427, 0.020727375522255898, 0.008201178163290024, -0.04708798602223396, 0.028059324249625206, 0.03637076914310455, 0.006180963944643736, 0.05546983331441879, 0.022245565429329872, -0.07101542502641678, -0.04947362467646599, -0.009406737051904202, -0.009805259294807911, -0.03837210312485695, -0.01859770528972149, -0.026386141777038574, 0.09479127824306488, 0.005689348094165325, -0.0010236474918201566, -0.06143108755350113, 0.016753854230046272, 0.04729189723730087, 0.1067543551325798, 0.08570615947246552, -0.009325365535914898, -0.0539143942296505, -0.003465345362201333, -0.046134356409311295, -0.024338318035006523, -0.013254674151539803, 0.04696028307080269, -0.08491867780685425, -0.05769255757331848, -0.008660925552248955, 0.029411371797323227, 0.012667467817664146, -0.03178061544895172, 0.026778053492307663, 0.03788432106375694, -0.035716548562049866, -0.05578678473830223, 0.0667392909526825, 0.03753688558936119, 0.054335664957761765, -0.009517830796539783, -0.030323904007673264, -0.005169020500034094, -0.07535768300294876, 0.05549374595284462, 0.031836215406656265, 0.0070445421151816845, -0.00018385745352134109, 0.0383337028324604, -0.0029723425395786762, 0.025185734033584595, 0.06349854171276093, -0.02612191252410412, 0.07015072554349899, -0.000916841090656817, -0.008950416930019855, -0.09687843918800354, 0.006392083130776882, -0.06700324267148972, 0.0421779528260231, -0.007623977027833462, 0.00011587738845264539, -0.04952094331383705, 0.02262823097407818, -0.016789644956588745, -0.08074821531772614, -0.008571425452828407, 0.029528820887207985, 0.04390328750014305, 0.09594783186912537, 0.03253459930419922, 0.025383859872817993, 0.08280865103006363, 0.0594773031771183, -0.018051952123641968, 0.015106971375644207, -0.05780387297272682, -0.041304636746644974, 0.017033960670232773, 0.043982572853565216, -0.01145673356950283, -0.060941431671381, 0.03143371269106865, -0.020783979445695877, -0.020688701421022415, -0.07222761958837509, 0.033612966537475586, 0.02495146356523037, -0.06064913794398308, 0.016426917165517807, -0.05437295511364937, 0.0186257716268301, -0.00714621739462018, 0.027253681793808937, -0.029719650745391846, -0.005996731575578451, -0.046275459229946136, -0.006869654171168804, 0.03923933953046799, -0.03199848532676697, 0.07164689898490906, -0.11691249907016754, 0.011671853251755238, 0.056955963373184204, 0.006535923574119806, -0.04850177466869354, 0.043458156287670135, 0.06758080422878265, 0.03718877583742142, 0.04088146612048149, -0.048393577337265015, -0.0005300233606249094, -0.01569829322397709, 0.03250075504183769, -0.011175857856869698, 0.027649808675050735, 0.05374604091048241, -0.00830153189599514, 0.029086392372846603, 0.05912381783127785, 0.02106528729200363, 0.010047528892755508, 0.06876900792121887, 0.06801646947860718, 0.003682020353153348, -0.029757676646113396, 0.029398765414953232, -0.022708557546138763, 0.03635053709149361, 0.05143077298998833, 0.009863185696303844, -0.05810541659593582, -0.06323143094778061, -0.0445220060646534, -0.06468933820724487, -0.00046009328798390925 ]
212
212
On the Dual Formulation of Boosting Algorithms
We study boosting algorithms from a new perspective. We show that the Lagrange dual problems of AdaBoost, LogitBoost and soft-margin LPBoost with generalized hinge loss are all entropy maximization problems. By looking at the dual problems of these boosting algorithms, we show that the success of boosting algorithms can be understood in terms of maintaining a better margin distribution by maximizing margins and at the same time controlling the margin variance.We also theoretically prove that, approximately, AdaBoost maximizes the average margin, instead of the minimum margin. The duality formulation also enables us to develop column generation based optimization algorithms, which are totally corrective. We show that they exhibit almost identical classification results to that of standard stage-wise additive boosting algorithms but with much faster convergence rates. Therefore fewer weak classifiers are needed to build the ensemble using our proposed optimization technique.
[ -0.03706809878349304, -0.05216261371970177, 0.04125707596540451, -0.0129682132974267, 0.03356024622917175, -0.014499758370220661, 0.008097236976027489, -0.03874913975596428, -0.010183587670326233, -0.021053116768598557, -0.037093110382556915, -0.054759133607149124, -0.08835998922586441, 0.06748241931200027, 0.014127491973340511, 0.04963616654276848, -0.015896692872047424, 0.018373506143689156, 0.017794102430343628, -0.004554465878754854, 0.025319458916783333, 0.0021729429718106985, -0.024905072525143623, -0.02448936551809311, -0.015209539793431759, 0.01584562472999096, 0.010494682937860489, 0.004211719613522291, -0.049336791038513184, 0.014283547177910805, -0.02642699144780636, -0.004691731184720993, -0.011094051413238049, 0.05104844272136688, -0.011746867559850216, 0.03931146860122681, 0.06555674970149994, -0.04101777449250221, -0.0618499331176281, 0.0021905526518821716, 0.0006877373089082539, 0.03780169412493706, -0.005061459727585316, -0.01529985573142767, 0.04960229992866516, 0.05158824473619461, 0.05459297448396683, -0.031179964542388916, -0.024388369172811508, 0.02222268097102642, -0.057471562176942825, 0.02780798077583313, -0.04861762374639511, -0.036759406328201294, 0.04051019996404648, -0.05554528534412384, -0.01717807725071907, -0.008337629958987236, 0.003970629535615444, -0.012289970181882381, 0.01821763813495636, 0.10480765253305435, -0.07381571829319, -0.0026669728104025126, -0.028354400768876076, -0.006751303095370531, -0.04318021610379219, -0.015341872349381447, -0.020898861810564995, -0.012735841795802116, -0.034090735018253326, -0.08395616710186005, 0.044063158333301544, 0.11387403309345245, 0.05004401504993439, 0.003699235850945115, -0.025986146181821823, -0.055391836911439896, -0.005487917922437191, 0.030494319275021553, -0.06883696466684341, -0.008455857634544373, -0.002519761910662055, 0.0538148395717144, -0.012071359902620316, -0.0757584199309349, 0.018581287935376167, -0.057080067694187164, 0.02216183952987194, -0.07440505921840668, 0.08354953676462173, -0.005674831569194794, -0.05000342056155205, 0.05583571642637253, -0.024570131674408913, 0.05220281705260277, -0.008551683276891708, -0.0033652675338089466, 0.05101923644542694, 0.014083359390497208, 0.0029667981434613466, -0.010588211938738823, 0.08346286416053772, 0.05340523645281792, -0.014572582207620144, 0.024916792288422585, -0.034791942685842514, 0.014677007682621479, 0.046879127621650696, -0.025113096460700035, 0.011979050002992153, -0.04709531366825104, 0.015661146491765976, -0.029946492984890938, 0.015812424942851067, 0.00962733943015337, -0.043524742126464844, 0.05171366408467293, 0.04381100833415985, -0.006152025889605284, -0.007134477142244577, -0.05152420699596405, -0.027623847126960754, 0.010074600577354431, -0.010720093734562397, -0.050863537937402725, -0.04570308327674866, -0.06551391631364822, 0.12295316904783249, -0.0471196286380291, -0.03682892024517059, 0.054735369980335236, -0.012437252327799797, -0.006597201339900494, -0.0607135072350502, 0.036858513951301575, 0.01861610636115074, -0.05609802156686783, 0.006336176302284002, 0.09292419254779816, 0.01701338030397892, 0.052050475031137466, 0.0015643034130334854, 0.04492466524243355, 0.09143774956464767, 0.02752217836678028, 0.001652287202887237, 0.04487975314259529, -0.009369066916406155, 0.03439030423760414, 0.018631769344210625, -0.01748719997704029, 0.03494516387581825, 0.05577344074845314, 0.03196125105023384, -0.018309790641069412, -0.0059881024062633514, -0.03164541348814964, -0.03267434611916542, -0.06853698194026947, -0.07840416580438614, 0.008142153732478619, 0.07564067095518112, 0.008868063800036907, -0.010414021089673042, -0.033002693206071854, -0.006138937082141638, -0.011871065944433212, -0.05962783843278885, -0.07535451650619507, -0.03911031037569046, -0.03553349897265434, -0.01925523951649666, 0.022731062024831772, -0.025199241936206818, 0.01330405194312334, -0.011372890323400497, -0.07448921352624893, -0.023358020931482315, -0.02232280559837818, 0.04379374533891678, 0.06584840267896652, -0.03179071843624115, 0.010540802963078022, 0.07050690799951553, 0.11722702533006668, -0.05367222800850868, 0.02639438770711422, 0.0638105496764183, 0.0571138933300972, 0.05253760889172554, 0.012844257988035679, -0.03201306611299515, 0.052568111568689346, -0.046933166682720184, 0.056410789489746094, -0.09913428872823715, 0.0025046993978321552, 0.006047843489795923, 0.03311328962445259, 0.021651294082403183, -0.023593507707118988, 0.023136796429753304, -0.09089676290750504, 0.013215523213148117, 0.0695449486374855, 0.08180578052997589, -0.058372862637043, 0.018394416198134422, -0.0493498370051384, -0.020967667922377586, -0.024949058890342712, -0.03311583772301674, -0.03422879800200462, 0.005346525926142931, -0.06457529962062836, -0.0532347708940506, -0.03864021226763725, 0.06939283013343811, 0.002233570907264948, 0.054897576570510864, 0.017680421471595764, -0.05674298480153084, 0.041629478335380554, -0.006396517623215914, -0.0347418375313282, 0.038628898561000824, 0.0364072285592556, -0.02787678688764572, 0.05821998789906502, -0.018072346225380898, -0.07710222154855728, -0.004489914048463106, -0.03661464899778366, -0.022988608106970787, 0.015495477244257927, -0.013224722817540169, -0.04429971054196358, 0.060305021703243256, -0.026204781606793404, -0.05722296983003616, 0.01622409000992775, -0.061995573341846466, -0.010695042088627815, -0.009734716266393661, -0.004918794613331556, 0.05805344134569168, 0.0882112979888916, 0.02917558141052723, 0.007694114465266466, 0.025176340714097023, 0.012425537221133709, 0.02177405171096325, 0.011010675691068172, 0.0425712987780571, -0.02110384963452816, -0.012264071963727474, 0.08955810964107513, 0.06488586962223053, 0.13725121319293976, 0.025829948484897614, 0.021931421011686325, -0.05430370196700096, -0.036734987050294876, 0.02297677844762802, 0.041943080723285675, 0.01942179538309574, 0.023234590888023376, -0.029776399955153465, 0.056773941963911057, -0.07958219945430756, -0.08836019784212112, -0.04009773209691048, 0.020497746765613556, -0.03721492737531662, 0.021060703322291374, 0.04768381267786026, -0.007430668454617262, 0.03542589396238327, -0.009004266001284122, -0.039495304226875305, 0.0009974816348403692, -0.02013879455626011, 0.06661296635866165, -0.00785776972770691, 0.015714403241872787, -0.020349588245153427, 0.006032455246895552, -0.004787600599229336, 0.040953729301691055, -0.04091427102684975, 0.04043331369757652, 0.003391595557332039, 0.035292256623506546, 0.010560148395597935, -0.06229323521256447, 0.01659325696527958, 0.03298655524849892, 0.01988951489329338, -0.05172552913427353, -0.00947061087936163, -0.004313338082283735, 0.06236176937818527, 0.00385533575899899, -0.06664759665727615, 0.10476727783679962, 0.03738728165626526, 0.07063233852386475, -0.10238759219646454, 0.0026392170693725348, 0.037649545818567276, -0.034337118268013, -0.00816167239099741, -0.0576733835041523, -0.002330630086362362, 0.039296090602874756, -0.07413782179355621, 0.012906611897051334, 0.027880681678652763, -0.026313362643122673, 0.030236341059207916, 0.026728983968496323, 0.0019288078183308244, 0.008062461391091347, -0.13881346583366394, -0.049780841916799545, -0.033363983035087585, -0.025840546935796738, -0.033638741821050644, -0.004777994938194752, -0.04295176640152931, -0.02645561844110489, -0.022110288962721825, 0.05114799737930298, -0.03159523010253906, 0.01966729201376438, -0.03195355087518692, -0.039298757910728455, -0.02120264060795307, 0.0064497957937419415, -0.029082639142870903, -0.034066878259181976, 0.01218609418720007, 0.05586130917072296, -0.10499312728643417, 0.02267879620194435, 0.006835537496954203, 0.038175247609615326, -0.028575235977768898, 0.011386625468730927, -0.09974400699138641, -0.015025481581687927, -0.09654197841882706, 0.07933912426233292, 0.020102960988879204, -0.035187337547540665, 0.06066586822271347, -0.028838010504841805, -0.004050457384437323, -0.028908342123031616, -0.004177822731435299, 0.06459444761276245, -0.009503507055342197, -0.05218801274895668, 0.047698091715574265, 0.06471048295497894, -0.03379380702972412, 0.025022797286510468, -0.03716119006276131, 0.019610321149230003, -0.024334589019417763, 0.07544513791799545, -0.045376669615507126, 0.0016399750020354986, 0.05503176525235176, -0.05035315826535225, 0.04924489185214043, 0.0531938299536705, -0.10115459561347961, 0.04346457123756409, -0.0032823674846440554, -0.01711040735244751, -0.03599202260375023, 0.024320635944604874, -0.0514824241399765, 0.007343909237533808, -0.07244830578565598, -0.013789508491754532, 0.08668238669633865, 0.03640883043408394, 0.032532669603824615, -0.1198396235704422, -0.04390176013112068, 0.03617188706994057, 0.05161147937178612, 0.03806251659989357, 0.01111747045069933, -0.0383605994284153, -0.0439484566450119, -0.07327678799629211, 0.032342955470085144, -0.04320612922310829, 0.016493385657668114, -0.11190000921487808, -0.03947579115629196, 0.05466578155755997, 0.04384914040565491, 0.051161278039216995, 0.05621134117245674, 0.00930080097168684, 0.03628650680184364, 0.00013791414676234126, -0.07111727446317673, 0.057879552245140076, 0.036054577678442, 0.012853419408202171, 0.06528171896934509, -0.02692214958369732, 0.04759156331419945, -0.04336276277899742, 0.01757240481674671, 0.005825006868690252, 0.051453571766614914, 0.0038945982232689857, 0.07123499363660812, 0.014068812131881714, 0.040594957768917084, 0.08925975114107132, 0.0006497865542769432, 0.029316524043679237, -0.04151187837123871, 0.056720249354839325, -0.05411997810006142, 0.007254003081470728, 0.05249808728694916, -0.002402334474027157, 0.055086277425289154, 0.02982238307595253, -0.013670763932168484, -0.03335345908999443, -0.054010339081287384, 0.038634948432445526, -0.06688244640827179, 0.0033697779290378094, -0.03619811683893204, 0.08793172240257263, 0.07230909168720245, 0.057094380259513855, 0.05094429850578308, -0.018034454435110092, -0.020738879218697548, 0.0213311817497015, 0.01567431539297104, 0.003981646150350571, -0.015819445252418518, 0.024751923978328705, -0.09924241900444031, -0.011131208389997482, 0.008078458718955517, -0.04204622656106949, 0.0006964475032873452, -0.0629279613494873, -0.0127261932939291, -0.06644999980926514, 0.008862514048814774, -0.028483718633651733, -0.023204704746603966, 0.030228836461901665, 0.03706584498286247, 0.01909705251455307, -0.03749532997608185, 0.015217225067317486, 0.0005478112725540996, -0.03707895055413246, 0.009879613295197487, 0.011102749034762383, -0.05418425053358078, -0.08971348404884338, -0.0004145564162172377, -0.018346482887864113, -0.05611763522028923, 0.037741996347904205, 0.040365397930145264, -0.019847827032208443, -0.01776970364153385, 0.007173499092459679, -0.044311340898275375, 0.05391445755958557, 0.039400115609169006, 0.05845249444246292, -0.028738848865032196, 0.045375365763902664, 0.018517717719078064, 0.014261696487665176, -0.011267237365245819, 0.017321307212114334, 0.03708971291780472, -0.03635111823678017, -0.004033421166241169, 0.11568295210599899, 0.03552945330739021, -0.04945868253707886, 0.05752263590693474, 0.03096046857535839, 0.01976451836526394, 0.05800328403711319, 0.00044324525515548885, 0.027189206331968307, 0.021477332338690758, -0.021135350689291954, -0.04212402179837227, -0.02162492275238037 ]
213
213
Cross-situational and supervised learning in the emergence of communication
Scenarios for the emergence or bootstrap of a lexicon involve the repeated interaction between at least two agents who must reach a consensus on how to name N objects using H words. Here we consider minimal models of two types of learning algorithms: cross-situational learning, in which the individuals determine the meaning of a word by looking for something in common across all observed uses of that word, and supervised operant conditioning learning, in which there is strong feedback between individuals about the intended meaning of the words. Despite the stark differences between these learning schemes, we show that they yield the same communication accuracy in the realistic limits of large N and H, which coincides with the result of the classical occupancy problem of randomly assigning N objects to H words.
[ -0.0018427299801260233, 0.02941155806183815, 0.03605251386761665, 0.020467588678002357, 0.023224148899316788, -0.15103347599506378, -0.047453973442316055, -0.04104941710829735, -0.017443478107452393, -0.01316584087908268, 0.005271619185805321, -0.02704860270023346, 0.030699918046593666, 0.09396842867136002, 0.01765880361199379, -0.019862497225403786, 0.0060777259059250355, 0.012918232008814812, 0.0029595820233225822, -0.045701224356889725, 0.00899970531463623, 0.015153377316892147, -0.003408316755667329, 0.0167568176984787, -0.027903791517019272, -0.011861532926559448, -0.052662428468465805, 0.04154757410287857, -0.011767704971134663, 0.00982683151960373, -0.05565228685736656, 0.01690150797367096, 0.06394035369157791, 0.05845220386981964, 0.03642038255929947, 0.015646521002054214, -0.0013197665102779865, 0.007841896265745163, -0.025917790830135345, -0.030474044382572174, 0.010846548713743687, -0.027600139379501343, 0.04394359514117241, 0.022042516618967056, 0.028772618621587753, -0.0502338632941246, 0.014025263488292694, 0.02050965465605259, 0.06265662610530853, 0.04594995081424713, -0.10164639353752136, -0.03152114897966385, 0.05319910869002342, 0.005798514932394028, -0.032004501670598984, -0.014718570746481419, -0.014108914881944656, 0.02890617586672306, -0.0461210161447525, -0.03533323109149933, 0.03664333000779152, 0.1307651251554489, -0.013303267769515514, 0.01998892053961754, -0.0497625507414341, 0.04691508784890175, -0.08404188603162766, -0.053272794932127, 0.023511318489909172, 0.042803600430488586, 0.05519338697195053, -0.013123287819325924, 0.04807690158486366, -0.03003469854593277, 0.0394451804459095, 0.020452603697776794, 0.019759317860007286, -0.014004331082105637, 0.015075627714395523, 0.035750940442085266, -0.0635683611035347, 0.049510397017002106, 0.006603119894862175, 0.00946817360818386, 0.003958476707339287, -0.022454554215073586, -0.0506596565246582, -0.04263218119740486, 0.0026907501742243767, 0.04464564099907875, -0.020743338391184807, -0.01139917690306902, -0.11709344387054443, 0.022265292704105377, 0.006608010735362768, 0.05673236772418022, -0.003777956822887063, -0.006929079070687294, 0.06229328736662865, 0.019103078171610832, -0.029138728976249695, -0.02282780036330223, -0.01620376482605934, -0.013724696822464466, -0.06029185652732849, 0.058730464428663254, -0.027850333601236343, 0.08662586659193039, 0.039571188390254974, -0.014649143442511559, 0.027339283376932144, 0.05344780534505844, 0.018957849591970444, -0.03147672489285469, -0.04524353891611099, 0.11451739072799683, 0.007052249740809202, 0.05290990695357323, -0.002535973908379674, -0.006019036751240492, -0.009458133019506931, -0.01176481880247593, -0.027349529787898064, -0.030902396887540817, -0.0064030783250927925, -0.0401587188243866, -0.04723123833537102, -0.0052734604105353355, 0.06979119032621384, -0.010416950099170208, -0.06645411252975464, -0.04741944372653961, -0.03923097625374794, -0.002090774243697524, -0.0376514233648777, 0.07752495259046555, 0.0003692286554723978, -0.015108073130249977, 0.04269368574023247, 0.0005321360658854246, 0.0016286351019516587, 0.007941430434584618, -0.007456751074641943, -0.0032509886659681797, 0.035848166793584824, -0.019310086965560913, -0.002524500247091055, 0.016891468316316605, 0.07227835804224014, 0.02141171135008335, -0.02380581758916378, -0.03570951148867607, 0.11490293592214584, 0.027728799730539322, -0.027348296716809273, -0.0465102382004261, -0.06342088431119919, -0.0190078504383564, -0.029174750670790672, 0.03876688703894615, -0.013199823908507824, 0.006884575821459293, 0.009666947647929192, -0.023096581920981407, 0.00980290211737156, 0.04306652769446373, -0.11575110256671906, 0.044132109731435776, -0.010326137766242027, -0.053514767438173294, -0.04398735612630844, 0.009993554092943668, -0.013370747677981853, 0.036691851913928986, 0.005859043914824724, -0.006177782546728849, 0.013190465979278088, -0.02081882208585739, -0.03126624971628189, -0.00441806809976697, 0.07719690352678299, -0.04532492533326149, 0.014175957068800926, -0.053242217749357224, 0.06969282031059265, 0.09136489778757095, 0.045918360352516174, 0.07774311304092407, 0.02564186230301857, -0.02647467516362667, -0.0017045473214238882, 0.007402932271361351, -0.010261395946145058, 0.014602262526750565, -0.1222110465168953, -0.03397790342569351, -0.03018813394010067, 0.07251328229904175, -0.04133707284927368, 0.01868567429482937, -0.022095533087849617, -0.009635195136070251, -0.015347439795732498, -0.04889877513051033, 0.01957681030035019, -0.009907781146466732, 0.006115785334259272, -0.03521253913640976, 0.05243169143795967, -0.02260112203657627, 0.041911084204912186, 0.02531532198190689, -0.017999475821852684, 0.0021894546225667, 0.042871247977018356, -0.02439531683921814, -0.001885205158032477, -0.04174208268523216, 0.00649481825530529, 0.03066229075193405, -0.053806595504283905, 0.012793147005140781, 0.021218260750174522, 0.04009169340133667, 0.03731578588485718, -0.04426084831357002, 0.03465524688363075, 0.021342765539884567, -0.008717847056686878, -0.023872068151831627, -0.1333559900522232, -0.06708933413028717, -0.07236861437559128, -0.10765188187360764, -0.05332288146018982, -0.027793696150183678, -0.06851812452077866, -0.020723611116409302, -0.06377443671226501, 0.014275615103542805, -0.02895587682723999, 0.040226031094789505, 0.033370062708854675, 0.019321247935295105, -0.0039531029760837555, -0.015886595472693443, -0.011288258247077465, -0.04006025195121765, -0.04564560949802399, -0.008186537772417068, 0.016537614166736603, -0.018744848668575287, -0.0006030352669768035, 0.030351337045431137, 0.08270744979381561, 0.0022161495871841908, 0.043524179607629776, 0.07411230355501175, 0.01552103366702795, 0.10644520074129105, 0.03031536005437374, 0.028278818354010582, 0.009965908713638783, 0.059510987251996994, 0.1021687388420105, -0.05075521022081375, -0.04656801000237465, 0.05475187301635742, -0.04493682458996773, -0.03278805688023567, -0.008266525343060493, -0.03668607026338577, 0.03128131851553917, 0.03793584182858467, -0.022436166182160378, 0.000052142731874482706, 0.017505880445241928, 0.03219614177942276, 0.015943385660648346, -0.0568770207464695, -0.06341903656721115, 0.07866565883159637, 0.021826786920428276, -0.044951971620321274, 0.051888421177864075, -0.054931145161390305, 0.02242085710167885, 0.02050752006471157, -0.0431109294295311, 0.02615882270038128, -0.00003762221604119986, 0.03408694639801979, -0.0281849205493927, 0.02894158847630024, 0.0684569701552391, -0.03667896240949631, 0.021388623863458633, -0.013770334422588348, -0.01434554997831583, -0.05133352428674698, -0.0030158965382725, 0.022844377905130386, 0.009879992343485355, 0.030673347413539886, 0.03914057835936546, 0.04403914138674736, 0.015481941401958466, 0.08564749360084534, -0.06719377636909485, 0.03522391617298126, 0.08511261641979218, 0.009376827627420425, 0.013719785958528519, 0.04568633809685707, -0.0036147150676697493, -0.0006421809084713459, -0.008822893723845482, -0.055324260145425797, -0.031052224338054657, -0.020330624654889107, 0.023538611829280853, -0.044798899441957474, 0.030842628329992294, 0.04359404370188713, -0.011188832111656666, -0.0633942112326622, -0.029836324974894524, -0.029129786416888237, -0.10608124732971191, 0.06185310333967209, -0.06722918152809143, 0.03244711086153984, 0.016123654320836067, 0.1108873263001442, -0.007222231011837721, 0.009847314096987247, -0.08091163635253906, 0.03419448807835579, -0.0059423428028821945, 0.03384196758270264, -0.0514080747961998, -0.10942935943603516, 0.006247781682759523, 0.07491100579500198, 0.05649813637137413, 0.011462683789432049, 0.0748457983136177, -0.016802968457341194, 0.012138457037508488, -0.04310794547200203, -0.03223000466823578, -0.035227157175540924, -0.08304701000452042, 0.006379680708050728, -0.07278873771429062, 0.017418410629034042, 0.03049527108669281, -0.05143190920352936, 0.005392358638346195, 0.012724163010716438, 0.05256398394703865, 0.07135733962059021, 0.021371103823184967, -0.020499497652053833, -0.005639064125716686, 0.0964849591255188, -0.04729326441884041, -0.006839368958026171, -0.08286683261394501, -0.028074361383914948, 0.00028569469577632844, 0.016189519315958023, 0.012600195594131947, -0.031113609671592712, 0.010940305888652802, -0.03154316172003746, 0.04142429307103157, -0.06378006935119629, 0.01378259900957346, 0.0811154767870903, -0.026968995109200478, -0.011914987117052078, -0.04292375221848488, -0.003009169828146696, -0.004351507406681776, 0.03055614046752453, -0.028721729293465614, 0.003439171239733696, 0.0836036205291748, -0.014608551748096943, -0.013996289111673832, -0.03336625546216965, 0.025582347065210342, 0.04833206906914711, 0.009484397247433662, -0.03531536087393761, 0.01915351301431656, -0.08436652272939682, -0.07300727814435959, 0.013121147640049458, -0.032309647649526596, 0.021321311593055725, 0.0229482538998127, -0.0156809501349926, -0.05611668527126312, 0.031133580952882767, 0.06622877717018127, 0.0907343178987503, 0.019552340731024742, 0.020468128845095634, -0.018044395372271538, 0.12000605463981628, -0.07469429820775986, 0.04097408056259155, -0.022327527403831482, 0.0541364960372448, -0.005586567800492048, 0.009238622151315212, 0.022024210542440414, -0.05337955057621002, -0.04033970460295677, 0.020454220473766327, -0.042405180633068085, 0.015271996147930622, 0.047285716980695724, -0.05737099051475525, 0.06313260644674301, -0.011289364658296108, 0.04934887960553169, 0.027993639931082726, -0.041704196482896805, -0.1182950884103775, -0.038657430559396744, 0.01155324187129736, 0.040919698774814606, 0.04747173935174942, -0.015996582806110382, -0.04319752752780914, 0.0024884012527763844, 0.024898719042539597, -0.07332316786050797, 0.012820235453546047, 0.05231746286153793, 0.04339781776070595, 0.039039142429828644, -0.0011153864907100797, 0.05013785883784294, -0.04063507542014122, 0.04446791484951973, 0.012668641284108162, 0.020442085340619087, -0.03075302764773369, 0.06130514666438103, -0.004497271962463856, -0.07275528460741043, -0.08233486115932465, 0.05321647599339485, -0.02556047961115837, 0.025837481021881104, -0.10875760018825531, -0.05868174135684967, -0.06867626309394836, -0.000876051839441061, -0.011461681686341763, -0.007884556427598, -0.037378545850515366, 0.029396286234259605, 0.04577057436108589, 0.03165392950177193, 0.013184577226638794, -0.0388718917965889, 0.0009045657934620976, -0.04036909341812134, -0.05087299644947052, -0.02702638879418373, 0.08542516827583313, 0.08909769356250763, -0.039366114884614944, 0.03248917683959007, -0.06730963289737701, 0.026325052604079247, 0.05783473327755928, -0.04112796112895012, 0.032767895609140396, 0.024563457816839218, 0.030368410050868988, -0.0437907837331295, 0.01992747001349926, 0.013216394931077957, 0.06597711145877838, -0.04663704335689545, -0.007531195413321257, 0.0521424226462841, -0.04996713250875473, -0.03268766030669212, 0.04135895520448685, 0.014206528663635254, 0.02088768780231476, 0.019182713702321053, 0.04403601214289665, 0.06813868880271912, -0.01381642185151577, 0.016273854300379753, 0.029475491493940353, 0.05905395746231079, 0.028852054849267006, 0.08406951278448105, 0.02769949473440647, -0.03725649416446686, 0.01755322702229023, -0.07431739568710327, 0.022440528497099876 ]
214
214
Practical Robust Estimators for the Imprecise Dirichlet Model
Walley's Imprecise Dirichlet Model (IDM) for categorical i.i.d. data extends the classical Dirichlet model to a set of priors. It overcomes several fundamental problems which other approaches to uncertainty suffer from. Yet, to be useful in practice, one needs efficient ways for computing the imprecise=robust sets or intervals. The main objective of this work is to derive exact, conservative, and approximate, robust and credible interval estimates under the IDM for a large class of statistical estimators, including the entropy and mutual information.
[ -0.061489034444093704, -0.015585234388709068, -0.007138912566006184, -0.05087811499834061, 0.017494196072220802, 0.04663339629769325, 0.036616429686546326, 0.0289224311709404, -0.002079673344269395, 0.0030105197802186012, -0.032743338495492935, -0.07383554428815842, 0.008664094842970371, -0.04722910374403, -0.0030118844006210566, -0.06828953325748444, -0.032449740916490555, -0.02568119578063488, -0.01341013703495264, -0.014912160113453865, -0.007461735978722572, 0.048352472484111786, 0.05011868476867676, -0.10275168716907501, -0.04645521566271782, 0.00755705451592803, -0.05608266592025757, -0.03936139866709709, -0.037999264895915985, -0.07440287619829178, -0.09706421941518784, 0.012081639841198921, 0.016533277928829193, -0.004627101123332977, -0.039561543613672256, -0.01576700061559677, 0.01695820689201355, 0.0037569678388535976, -0.07708225399255753, -0.011946517042815685, 0.026476042345166206, -0.027372201904654503, -0.012702729552984238, 0.03367370367050171, 0.04035583510994911, 0.01160363294184208, 0.0379391610622406, 0.08393923938274384, 0.008645785041153431, -0.041231684386730194, -0.11874127388000488, -0.01584758423268795, -0.039377108216285706, -0.042370833456516266, 0.04702918976545334, 0.045425012707710266, 0.01621890813112259, 0.046319328248500824, -0.002652640687301755, -0.05291835591197014, 0.00977084320038557, 0.09781572222709656, -0.0026614463422447443, -0.00868163350969553, -0.04030199348926544, -0.028256095945835114, -0.04535771161317825, -0.004368659108877182, -0.04592703655362129, -0.03210709989070892, 0.024500850588083267, -0.07110670208930969, -0.023076312616467476, 0.011440534144639969, 0.010849354788661003, -0.04370831325650215, -0.05539202690124512, 0.029212547466158867, 0.028872109949588776, 0.008421631529927254, -0.0656137764453888, -0.05314767360687256, -0.06643445044755936, 0.02248302660882473, -0.07980196177959442, 0.0210792925208807, 0.04721653088927269, -0.0026822579093277454, -0.0013591221068054438, -0.05041852965950966, 0.02153187431395054, 0.006600400432944298, -0.03616035357117653, 0.061460405588150024, -0.015106813982129097, 0.05365125462412834, 0.019522564485669136, 0.009954611770808697, 0.021246518939733505, 0.016872311010956764, -0.00014270977408159524, -0.021598825231194496, 0.05286448448896408, 0.01453329436480999, 0.02124403417110443, -0.0265126284211874, -0.022427137941122055, 0.06201136112213135, -0.032397180795669556, -0.020072365179657936, 0.039922021329402924, 0.007162640802562237, -0.009491953998804092, 0.03734588250517845, -0.06821111589670181, 0.033980533480644226, -0.03768480196595192, -0.004032785538583994, 0.020573830232024193, 0.0726117193698883, -0.0020592189393937588, 0.024168478325009346, -0.0095728300511837, -0.012080029584467411, 0.04603663831949234, -0.03123401291668415, -0.01689891517162323, -0.03346405178308487, 0.13926810026168823, -0.07443861663341522, 0.01260512787848711, -0.004098210483789444, -0.06016165763139725, -0.013316329568624496, -0.011298442259430885, 0.0709710642695427, 0.04638873413205147, 0.056817855685949326, 0.07520321011543274, 0.002622291911393404, -0.010362899862229824, -0.042504750192165375, 0.015063248574733734, 0.009382566437125206, -0.04690699651837349, 0.05577598139643669, 0.03154074400663376, 0.00806550681591034, -0.08798342198133469, -0.03643852844834328, 0.021358473226428032, 0.034704145044088364, 0.02553391642868519, 0.035378895699977875, -0.01704748161137104, -0.06149835139513016, -0.00028915624716319144, -0.028254050761461258, -0.06590130180120468, 0.03856520727276802, -0.01678241789340973, 0.0365738607943058, 0.0838153138756752, 0.026591913774609566, -0.056175269186496735, 0.03247571364045143, -0.029227688908576965, -0.001457478734664619, 0.011529484763741493, -0.03061426803469658, -0.07148706912994385, -0.029564447700977325, -0.014335819520056248, 0.03704981505870819, -0.0035761925391852856, -0.0006273933686316013, -0.06234545633196831, -0.005604867823421955, -0.009097916074097157, 0.03138110786676407, -0.0069642988964915276, -0.013967637903988361, -0.01658017374575138, 0.04689991474151611, -0.015357757918536663, 0.003689081873744726, -0.03724055737257004, 0.047146689146757126, 0.018876833841204643, 0.06414040923118591, 0.018407026305794716, -0.030378790572285652, -0.03100655786693096, 0.07993774861097336, 0.001488582929596305, 0.054613325744867325, 0.009935680776834488, -0.06684830784797668, -0.014765738509595394, 0.05321306735277176, 0.010867356322705746, -0.007471946533769369, -0.02575555443763733, -0.006204284727573395, -0.07614114880561829, 0.012995670549571514, 0.01779443584382534, -0.034590743482112885, 0.027391016483306885, 0.004802312236279249, 0.00010155723430216312, 0.004811398219317198, 0.014043915085494518, -0.003432369790971279, 0.059385720640420914, -0.06607279926538467, -0.02112840674817562, -0.017766522243618965, -0.023717734962701797, 0.10359949618577957, 0.008795619010925293, 0.04802814498543739, -0.008905908092856407, -0.013964006677269936, -0.052990298718214035, 0.04153827577829361, 0.11954906582832336, -0.03936779871582985, -0.04484530910849571, 0.08692038804292679, 0.03374532237648964, -0.025285689160227776, -0.07714646309614182, -0.044096652418375015, 0.01851136051118374, -0.030060024932026863, -0.008636134676635265, -0.07188239693641663, 0.07933701574802399, 0.008909905329346657, -0.022581595927476883, 0.08002278953790665, 0.04282376915216446, 0.017266323789954185, 0.0166589617729187, -0.04852437600493431, 0.0011256266152486205, 0.039932094514369965, 0.005553518421947956, 0.1021312028169632, 0.029596291482448578, -0.016533538699150085, 0.012912220321595669, 0.007777454797178507, -0.021215764805674553, -0.0025748845655471087, -0.03778260573744774, 0.09577641636133194, 0.060791343450546265, 0.12096524983644485, 0.028863223269581795, -0.03496513143181801, 0.08755075931549072, -0.00349063822068274, 0.02479497902095318, -0.00042312536970712245, 0.035100650042295456, 0.10006476938724518, 0.022542035207152367, 0.02271517552435398, -0.02627396583557129, -0.02937617525458336, 0.007907427847385406, 0.04408483952283859, -0.04237677529454231, 0.012068561278283596, 0.009705325588583946, 0.08651219308376312, -0.006983193103224039, 0.02320856787264347, -0.032080065459012985, 0.061654847115278244, -0.04445407912135124, 0.000021445457605295815, 0.0017740267794579268, 0.014720340259373188, -0.01439065020531416, 0.023853035643696785, 0.03024355322122574, 0.005875178147107363, -0.018317053094506264, 0.0060617211274802685, 0.017495399340987206, -0.04852626100182533, 0.0482434444129467, 0.020233923569321632, 0.06890738010406494, -0.007093150168657303, 0.04975203052163124, 0.01225188747048378, -0.008250639773905277, 0.002142336219549179, 0.08241821080446243, 0.017167219892144203, -0.01886262185871601, 0.05658041313290596, 0.026384655386209488, 0.05708523839712143, -0.03190036118030548, -0.04660357907414436, -0.02104773372411728, 0.013789071701467037, -0.009322340600192547, 0.043226830661296844, -0.056907862424850464, -0.010194179601967335, -0.022048920392990112, 0.008072086609899998, -0.055274367332458496, -0.017129266634583473, -0.027973437681794167, -0.026101617142558098, 0.0059806182980537415, -0.02312288247048855, -0.07026434689760208, -0.045816853642463684, -0.029293308034539223, -0.03774729743599892, -0.06344067305326462, 0.07826090604066849, -0.05196278169751167, -0.025054533034563065, -0.09551370143890381, 0.0515175461769104, -0.06540536135435104, 0.09693905711174011, -0.12433699518442154, 0.0229555144906044, -0.012750917114317417, -0.0360710471868515, -0.05711841583251953, -0.09282471239566803, 0.0186943206936121, -0.014945215545594692, 0.06060505658388138, 0.05788148567080498, 0.05482446774840355, 0.020066190510988235, -0.040820810943841934, 0.04636416956782341, -0.03612188622355461, -0.006969773676246405, 0.06413485109806061, 0.0268266424536705, 0.033976104110479355, 0.047012586146593094, 0.04480966553092003, -0.005957288201898336, 0.002936695469543338, 0.05232030525803566, -0.0022593277972191572, 0.09240473806858063, -0.029323698952794075, -0.03535829484462738, 0.06212528049945831, 0.025536905974149704, 0.017808405682444572, -0.029453160241246223, -0.04342776536941528, 0.0377475805580616, -0.03007645718753338, -0.034367628395557404, 0.048763688653707504, -0.00226717465557158, 0.02782980352640152, 0.07056855410337448, 0.07978510111570358, 0.014299051836133003, 0.004047342576086521, 0.023691706359386444, -0.08432640135288239, -0.10013911128044128, 0.015847105532884598, 0.0010742468293756247, -0.06130187213420868, -0.07702097296714783, -0.0357741117477417, -0.040424007922410965, 0.10737987607717514, -0.011321615427732468, -0.037480469793081284, -0.060563139617443085, 0.04840259626507759, -0.05642283335328102, 0.01234009861946106, 0.004523042123764753, -0.028193140402436256, -0.03269200772047043, -0.017160935327410698, -0.04149346426129341, -0.013927524909377098, -0.0546710342168808, 0.02457760088145733, -0.02996252104640007, -0.03497811034321785, -0.08471878618001938, -0.012686028145253658, 0.018275445327162743, -0.0509510301053524, 0.057167742401361465, -0.028719287365674973, -0.010098435916006565, 0.04477975517511368, -0.016270408406853676, -0.02115064673125744, 0.03257974609732628, 0.04857912287116051, 0.005409852135926485, -0.04249365255236626, -0.10426987707614899, -0.020038116723299026, -0.03237113729119301, -0.04831773787736893, -0.021014448255300522, 0.032643526792526245, 0.02286631613969803, 0.03495479375123978, 0.05825138837099075, -0.03447500243782997, 0.03454231098294258, 0.018173206597566605, -0.06828594207763672, -0.05480654165148735, 0.06066952273249626, 0.050004471093416214, 0.011712546460330486, -0.006679301615804434, -0.029877712950110435, 0.018473567441105843, 0.05098709464073181, -0.012580704875290394, 0.04144078865647316, 0.04584674909710884, 0.09237722307443619, -0.03928357735276222, 0.06777248531579971, 0.022186480462551117, -0.036412473767995834, 0.021008264273405075, 0.05136817693710327, 0.02522294595837593, -0.03513100743293762, 0.06420660018920898, 0.006677612196654081, 0.03410113975405693, 0.009767399169504642, -0.0009270611335523427, -0.04536422714591026, 0.11470616608858109, -0.02065492421388626, -0.01178484782576561, 0.0032748819794505835, -0.030789373442530632, 0.013447917997837067, -0.09837909042835236, 0.0016727456822991371, -0.016386961564421654, -0.020158328115940094, 0.052505627274513245, 0.019651349633932114, -0.0919978991150856, 0.0017683079931885004, 0.06002064049243927, -0.008364411070942879, 0.02230389416217804, 0.002336060395464301, -0.03620825335383415, -0.015106318518519402, -0.06235396862030029, -0.05704556778073311, -0.01322872843593359, -0.08909378945827484, -0.08691024780273438, 0.061621181666851044, 0.04882747307419777, 0.054270002990961075, 0.02805868349969387, 0.004029958974570036, -0.04083286598324776, 0.036083973944187164, 0.024992307648062706, -0.0005130663048475981, 0.003553219838067889, 0.036324478685855865, -0.04532437399029732, 0.060110513120889664, -0.022527502849698067, 0.03585948795080185, 0.022050149738788605, -0.0383862666785717, 0.0361752063035965, -0.07847302407026291, 0.07371827214956284, -0.0649099126458168, 0.04536062106490135, 0.014153417199850082, 0.03714606165885925, -0.026686498895287514, -0.04208427667617798, 0.054075680673122406, 0.05721687152981758, -0.056703608483076096 ]
215
215
Fixing Convergence of Gaussian Belief Propagation
Gaussian belief propagation (GaBP) is an iterative message-passing algorithm for inference in Gaussian graphical models. It is known that when GaBP converges it converges to the correct MAP estimate of the Gaussian random vector and simple sufficient conditions for its convergence have been established. In this paper we develop a double-loop algorithm for forcing convergence of GaBP. Our method computes the correct MAP estimate even in cases where standard GaBP would not have converged. We further extend this construction to compute least-squares solutions of over-constrained linear systems. We believe that our construction has numerous applications, since the GaBP algorithm is linked to solution of linear systems of equations, which is a fundamental problem in computer science and engineering. As a case study, we discuss the linear detection problem. We show that using our new construction, we are able to force convergence of Montanari's linear detection algorithm, in cases where it would originally fail. As a consequence, we are able to increase significantly the number of users that can transmit concurrently.
[ -0.004587679170072079, -0.07081448286771774, 0.018382050096988678, -0.023238442838191986, -0.019945569336414337, -0.08101096004247665, 0.0020637204870581627, -0.05928969383239746, 0.017698662355542183, 0.060187939554452896, 0.03811444714665413, -0.05257555469870567, 0.059118062257766724, 0.03629809245467186, 0.05167707800865173, -0.01860617659986019, 0.059379879385232925, 0.09932450205087662, 0.021708758547902107, -0.05215083435177803, 0.052565380930900574, -0.016545725986361504, 0.00855537410825491, -0.005219986196607351, 0.0689152181148529, 0.04608985036611557, -0.07254865020513535, -0.0033876679372042418, 0.003019121941179037, -0.04271714389324188, -0.1427595019340515, 0.053736720234155655, 0.012375361286103725, -0.02461151033639908, 0.06143856793642044, -0.07641639560461044, 0.014537221752107143, -0.061968930065631866, -0.021053239703178406, -0.00008176553092198446, 0.023173272609710693, -0.11961163580417633, 0.012311321683228016, -0.039228830486536026, 0.030628198757767677, 0.04716713726520538, 0.06590612977743149, 0.056266751140356064, -0.002168629551306367, 0.03611506149172783, -0.033491820096969604, -0.010323470458388329, -0.10410092025995255, 0.05637967213988304, 0.047363508492708206, -0.0007412881241180003, -0.032725099474191666, -0.026817383244633675, -0.03420095518231392, 0.023840544745326042, -0.013637026771903038, 0.10073766112327576, 0.014941971749067307, -0.0313410609960556, -0.07715080678462982, -0.015190460719168186, -0.04027586057782173, -0.015081374906003475, -0.019514543935656548, 0.00878748670220375, 0.053564880043268204, -0.025335898622870445, 0.053236592561006546, -0.010439418256282806, 0.07552959769964218, -0.05525411292910576, 0.007912206463515759, -0.0544218085706234, 0.012224663980305195, 0.10564088076353073, -0.0128696383908391, -0.031028563156723976, 0.0015795443905517459, 0.04427047818899155, 0.009235966019332409, -0.020809533074498177, -0.03582869842648506, 0.025264766067266464, 0.03229483962059021, -0.0528852641582489, 0.004106882959604263, 0.05923213064670563, -0.05670120194554329, 0.034706562757492065, -0.02878079190850258, -0.033387038856744766, 0.02439252659678459, -0.0715758427977562, -0.04470788314938545, 0.04620479792356491, -0.0462043471634388, 0.05434092506766319, 0.06252819299697876, 0.05215100571513176, -0.07404402643442154, 0.007012505549937487, -0.08031030744314194, 0.05409437417984009, 0.029375700280070305, -0.031065380200743675, 0.08640722930431366, -0.03853016346693039, 0.009994632564485073, 0.01266720611602068, -0.01220380887389183, 0.05553184449672699, -0.02005973644554615, 0.08579128980636597, 0.009751956909894943, -0.022831549867987633, 0.036750003695487976, 0.014392465353012085, 0.0007694372325204313, 0.0520155169069767, 0.04938998445868492, -0.02585773356258869, 0.06297234445810318, -0.04436293616890907, 0.09910514205694199, 0.016907252371311188, 0.04202497750520706, 0.012735467404127121, -0.014037157408893108, -0.03338470682501793, -0.01608632691204548, -0.008957724086940289, -0.0002724482910707593, -0.007824783213436604, -0.09697439521551132, 0.09153006970882416, -0.02316836267709732, -0.04140998423099518, 0.017354266718029976, 0.0027285958640277386, 0.04228019341826439, 0.03674907982349396, -0.03940295800566673, -0.032207392156124115, -0.02528924122452736, 0.050889547914266586, -0.005397183820605278, -0.022054307162761688, -0.011994829401373863, 0.005423911847174168, 0.060401707887649536, -0.02438715286552906, -0.05777783319354057, 0.007655668072402477, -0.032165709882974625, 0.11045855283737183, -0.03378622606396675, -0.014789666049182415, -0.02580401860177517, 0.08876997232437134, -0.0196229200810194, 0.01597224548459053, -0.056965284049510956, -0.03731182590126991, -0.035396307706832886, -0.061968740075826645, 0.06628894805908203, -0.028948694467544556, 0.006452389992773533, 0.022070927545428276, 0.023604391142725945, -0.03545806184411049, 0.02851681597530842, -0.02714812383055687, 0.01852796971797943, -0.042951203882694244, 0.01807343401014805, -0.08371560275554657, 0.02959156408905983, 0.006502844858914614, 0.040948957204818726, 0.06924953311681747, -0.007611333858221769, 0.003389019286260009, 0.06917745620012283, 0.02654772438108921, 0.019185470417141914, 0.10110568255186081, 0.017828334122896194, -0.061731260269880295, -0.07284639030694962, 0.028401734307408333, -0.052005261182785034, -0.015910543501377106, -0.023984069004654884, -0.03975190594792366, -0.006577067077159882, -0.011684072203934193, -0.026431581005454063, -0.05473850667476654, 0.0023626978509128094, 0.06209636107087135, 0.04944538697600365, -0.06156234070658684, 0.062280699610710144, -0.030921250581741333, 0.01945197954773903, 0.02309407666325569, -0.02010621689260006, -0.012209503911435604, -0.005131724290549755, -0.0847976952791214, -0.017550691962242126, -0.10681474953889847, -0.03096199221909046, 0.017382044345140457, 0.013320679776370525, 0.07705401629209518, -0.014290831983089447, 0.012928448617458344, -0.05700284615159035, 0.041791561990976334, -0.004311187192797661, 0.06013863906264305, -0.041237492114305496, 0.03445705771446228, -0.029236821457743645, -0.014368845149874687, -0.03459572419524193, 0.03604498878121376, -0.020156744867563248, 0.07295001298189163, -0.07122041285037994, -0.029697122052311897, -0.006360757164657116, -0.031033795326948166, -0.07417935878038406, 0.017007485032081604, -0.03618950769305229, -0.04507467895746231, 0.09202440083026886, 0.021816354244947433, -0.011919166892766953, 0.040149543434381485, -0.018179258331656456, 0.06734707951545715, 0.0025332614313811064, -0.03825884684920311, -0.0600983202457428, 0.0334445983171463, 0.06704298406839371, 0.04451727494597435, -0.02938281185925007, 0.02300792559981346, 0.09059382975101471, 0.048708751797676086, -0.021850189194083214, 0.005873513408005238, -0.06266982853412628, -0.0017316106241196394, 0.11521393805742264, 0.026599502190947533, -0.020413687452673912, -0.010661016218364239, 0.01675611548125744, 0.02356264926493168, 0.005755309481173754, -0.08650153130292892, -0.004651384428143501, 0.05518749728798866, 0.008857309818267822, -0.024875041097402573, -0.022769592702388763, 0.013240009546279907, -0.010665870271623135, -0.01730271242558956, -0.06595432013273239, 0.02580403722822666, 0.04777828976511955, -0.026587411761283875, 0.01945604383945465, -0.016971759498119354, 0.012992197647690773, 0.004812529776245356, 0.009430592879652977, -0.022431541234254837, -0.03026220202445984, -0.006930594332516193, -0.010184441693127155, -0.019324705004692078, -0.01069942768663168, -0.08290603011846542, 0.025899508967995644, -0.012507885694503784, -0.020418737083673477, -0.08136755973100662, -0.011542963795363903, -0.005916418042033911, 0.055864784866571426, 0.015284018591046333, 0.03716585040092468, 0.09028288722038269, -0.021659189835190773, 0.02577728033065796, -0.019229328259825706, -0.04948339983820915, 0.05098230019211769, -0.046550169587135315, -0.06319336593151093, -0.04592874273657799, 0.025549396872520447, 0.01649314910173416, -0.08432755619287491, -0.009449835866689682, -0.07302538305521011, -0.008890246041119099, -0.017834916710853577, -0.02104225754737854, -0.021809153258800507, -0.01872580125927925, -0.006251505576074123, 0.011894915252923965, -0.021120812743902206, 0.0693485364317894, -0.04734428972005844, 0.0117488419637084, -0.07582249492406845, 0.013267525471746922, -0.016823362559080124, 0.14768949151039124, -0.0825294479727745, -0.05327002331614494, -0.053189538419246674, -0.05415409058332443, 0.09294979274272919, 0.03808002918958664, -0.022826792672276497, -0.0689811035990715, -0.0016830607783049345, -0.008192605338990688, 0.007930677384138107, 0.09326763451099396, 0.0532648004591465, 0.016499480232596397, -0.0646468847990036, -0.015833444893360138, 0.00003440828368184157, 0.03975861519575119, -0.030393417924642563, -0.010504495352506638, -0.0012258150381967425, -0.027529362589120865, 0.04516610503196716, -0.07105223834514618, -0.028385447338223457, 0.03986416012048721, -0.05899202823638916, 0.0635211318731308, 0.0016997144557535648, -0.02191130630671978, 0.042718205600976944, 0.06417618691921234, -0.04828912764787674, -0.005613409448415041, 0.0011334269074723125, 0.07138533145189285, -0.05963514745235443, 0.0008343890076503158, 0.029804609715938568, 0.010758206248283386, 0.037236928939819336, -0.017275232821702957, 0.04497426748275757, 0.039584409445524216, -0.0027815743815153837, 0.07119115442037582, -0.015726426616311073, 0.04229603707790375, -0.08135764300823212, -0.008595317602157593, 0.0075778476893901825, 0.0037455393467098475, -0.03006649576127529, 0.04852893948554993, 0.021288447082042694, -0.0418841652572155, -0.00934760645031929, -0.03379625082015991, 0.06550411134958267, 0.1099504604935646, 0.034994643181562424, -0.02592402882874012, 0.021604863926768303, 0.02593163214623928, -0.013283484615385532, 0.006099270191043615, -0.051828768104314804, -0.006564595736563206, -0.0084161888808012, -0.0156831257045269, -0.008481684140861034, 0.01864093355834484, -0.018369242548942566, 0.03253569453954697, 0.02370893396437168, 0.10425253212451935, 0.038594331592321396, 0.02181931957602501, -0.023442059755325317, 0.014142001047730446, -0.012251797132194042, 0.03602597489953041, -0.011982887051999569, 0.04870123788714409, -0.02932594157755375, -0.02613145485520363, 0.022376080974936485, 0.08548688143491745, 0.0699210837483406, 0.02774769812822342, -0.019176725298166275, -0.02231551706790924, 0.09878873825073242, 0.020755475386977196, -0.05135345458984375, 0.0063115814700722694, -0.04116220772266388, 0.004385799635201693, -0.052341658622026443, -0.023189134895801544, 0.022509923204779625, 0.0017243094043806195, 0.0010496854083612561, 0.003615311114117503, -0.014528010971844196, 0.0512816347181797, -0.04471008479595184, -0.026081010699272156, -0.03071717731654644, -0.01142961997538805, 0.0011522516142576933, 0.04366075620055199, 0.08807451277971268, 0.03548262268304825, 0.03760869801044464, 0.06766502559185028, -0.03574419021606445, 0.0746881440281868, -0.0268530435860157, 0.0050169737078249454, -0.010565939359366894, 0.016089582815766335, -0.0545426607131958, -0.0016426966758444905, 0.004602488595992327, -0.005461216438561678, -0.024608856067061424, -0.014232853427529335, -0.01247407030314207, -0.004010958597064018, -0.01899249292910099, 0.014222987927496433, -0.03768597170710564, -0.047864485532045364, 0.034661609679460526, -0.04516274482011795, -0.10645215213298798, 0.0051239263266325, 0.008057513274252415, -0.023716192692518234, 0.008925472386181355, 0.006222406402230263, 0.0009250197908841074, -0.011593558825552464, 0.04291233792901039, -0.019912224262952805, 0.04007105156779289, -0.001406651339493692, -0.04799308627843857, 0.04279983788728714, 0.035717472434043884, 0.015083340927958488, -0.06216474622488022, 0.005743416491895914, 0.06165742129087448, -0.01477792952209711, 0.01231913361698389, 0.0412948876619339, -0.02276625856757164, -0.034290898591279984, 0.01140742190182209, 0.06970080733299255, 0.01258254237473011, 0.011576331220567226, 0.0571037121117115, -0.02001463994383812, 0.001248332904651761, -0.0235238429158926, 0.024364911019802094, 0.02717939019203186, -0.009340526536107063, 0.06784729659557343, -0.016255179420113564, -0.008474646136164665, -0.07984229922294617, -0.007790654897689819, -0.11506810784339905, 0.03634928911924362 ]
216
216
Non-Confluent NLC Graph Grammar Inference by Compressing Disjoint Subgraphs
Grammar inference deals with determining (preferable simple) models/grammars consistent with a set of observations. There is a large body of research on grammar inference within the theory of formal languages. However, there is surprisingly little known on grammar inference for graph grammars. In this paper we take a further step in this direction and work within the framework of node label controlled (NLC) graph grammars. Specifically, we characterize, given a set of disjoint and isomorphic subgraphs of a graph $G$, whether or not there is a NLC graph grammar rule which can generate these subgraphs to obtain $G$. This generalizes previous results by assuming that the set of isomorphic subgraphs is disjoint instead of non-touching. This leads naturally to consider the more involved ``non-confluent'' graph grammar rules.
[ -0.052548039704561234, -0.07532741874456406, 0.028342444449663162, 0.016995420679450035, 0.024346940219402313, 0.021956296637654305, 0.044482987374067307, -0.07088103890419006, -0.02468436025083065, -0.03160036727786064, -0.010614588856697083, -0.07840707898139954, 0.03412696346640587, 0.008827500976622105, 0.06398100405931473, 0.012624377384781837, 0.006167410872876644, 0.025234298780560493, -0.003126151394098997, -0.005555029958486557, -0.04255547747015953, 0.02538513019680977, 0.032461270689964294, 0.029318710789084435, 0.045416876673698425, -0.024451835080981255, -0.017905626446008682, 0.019755827262997627, -0.06308431923389435, -0.00846701581031084, -0.07391228526830673, 0.005589835345745087, -0.010045059025287628, -0.05220837518572807, -0.02027457393705845, -0.05277104675769806, -0.06289681047201157, 0.048159681260585785, -0.018466953188180923, -0.002237514592707157, 0.08144029974937439, -0.05120137706398964, -0.024885892868041992, -0.09757938981056213, -0.023669427260756493, 0.031604260206222534, 0.00017108145402744412, -0.08965372294187546, 0.08249619603157043, 0.03870440647006035, -0.05920464172959328, 0.02502184920012951, 0.03058520331978798, -0.013864761218428612, -0.02764364331960678, 0.037611350417137146, -0.03006170317530632, 0.015767084434628487, -0.0017346723470836878, 0.01470008585602045, 0.05638275295495987, 0.06537820398807526, -0.01293142233043909, 0.0053083342500030994, -0.0679103210568428, 0.02273586392402649, 0.030735492706298828, 0.055104613304138184, 0.058049675077199936, 0.043113309890031815, -0.0044778697192668915, -0.050277549773454666, -0.01124695036560297, 0.07331954687833786, 0.005452658049762249, 0.02231086604297161, -0.039465226233005524, -0.03122779168188572, -0.01869855262339115, 0.07056320458650589, -0.07271336019039154, 0.013768961653113365, -0.06518270075321198, -0.1183832436800003, 0.02759145013988018, 0.03663993999361992, -0.010923380963504314, -0.03615963086485863, -0.033988192677497864, -0.029285239055752754, -0.019275208935141563, -0.04161779582500458, -0.008892354555428028, 0.03233269974589348, 0.012925870716571808, -0.007951363921165466, -0.002647196175530553, -0.007899885065853596, 0.020595498383045197, -0.010365583002567291, -0.024170752614736557, -0.011692830361425877, -0.029834376648068428, -0.018287548795342445, -0.14085914194583893, -0.03216525912284851, 0.048235274851322174, 0.0046800910495221615, 0.06341181695461273, -0.0401117242872715, -0.0002669907407835126, 0.015588886104524136, 0.017185429111123085, 0.025173457339406013, 0.0025204916018992662, 0.037276577204465866, -0.02820066176354885, 0.037316035479307175, 0.03664587065577507, 0.023759333416819572, -0.04551791399717331, -0.03289617970585823, -0.06445807218551636, 0.03333449736237526, -0.02823689579963684, -0.08344609290361404, -0.11029619723558426, -0.042211346328258514, 0.007877948693931103, -0.021920759230852127, -0.00956613291054964, -0.021190008148550987, -0.0722823515534401, 0.005748596508055925, -0.0874033123254776, 0.05580546706914902, 0.019574500620365143, 0.00385841797105968, -0.02260715141892433, 0.03393937274813652, 0.04688735678792, -0.11235515028238297, 0.014675605110824108, -0.007846425287425518, 0.008521823212504387, 0.08988628536462784, -0.06894628703594208, -0.07447605580091476, 0.05719586834311485, 0.0005280366167426109, -0.01573658548295498, -0.09647029638290405, 0.09184587001800537, 0.0519896075129509, -0.027400899678468704, 0.012508933432400227, -0.09892189502716064, 0.027631547302007675, -0.02094401605427265, 0.042388156056404114, -0.00470627611503005, 0.0031013397965580225, 0.06685539335012436, 0.027735238894820213, 0.015508946031332016, 0.012614581733942032, -0.025936957448720932, 0.03239726275205612, -0.07506418973207474, -0.03303644061088562, 0.0866745114326477, 0.03285054489970207, 0.02891116589307785, 0.029577355831861496, 0.025188708677887917, -0.0667155385017395, -0.03554892539978027, 0.03901979327201843, 0.021838383749127388, 0.012603911571204662, 0.07347040623426437, -0.05966310575604439, 0.039908770471811295, 0.01592525653541088, -0.02378382906317711, 0.07201957702636719, -0.017519349232316017, 0.035132572054862976, -0.025742659345269203, 0.059599537402391434, -0.022533223032951355, 0.07501611858606339, 0.008200209587812424, 0.06110567972064018, -0.05372074618935585, 0.015780732035636902, -0.03383154422044754, 0.09765549004077911, -0.0065999990329146385, 0.007660608272999525, 0.01517405454069376, 0.028605695813894272, -0.003184304106980562, -0.08512260019779205, -0.09048741310834885, 0.02377181500196457, 0.039463214576244354, -0.03110978938639164, -0.027781303972005844, -0.061108388006687164, 0.022906364873051643, 0.0430770143866539, -0.06620656698942184, 0.027755126357078552, -0.023447761312127113, 0.004757966846227646, -0.009827488102018833, -0.05300268158316612, 0.0802563801407814, 0.012415576726198196, 0.028000319376587868, 0.057052336633205414, 0.033262696117162704, -0.02917756699025631, -0.0308702290058136, -0.020102526992559433, 0.009777458384633064, -0.022254643961787224, -0.021762484684586525, 0.04351171478629112, -0.06960263103246689, -0.06515573710203171, -0.04790213331580162, -0.045504163950681686, 0.05404200777411461, 0.02315068058669567, 0.0026461335364729166, -0.007845564745366573, -0.07033946365118027, -0.01337471790611744, 0.028491631150245667, 0.027129102498292923, 0.02731158211827278, -0.04132508486509323, -0.0018156623700633645, -0.01602768898010254, 0.03199530765414238, 0.02201787382364273, 0.045171789824962616, 0.021728144958615303, -0.049662232398986816, 0.02476334013044834, 0.009970573708415031, 0.03408626466989517, -0.02775067463517189, -0.018836217001080513, 0.01821136847138405, 0.0639180988073349, 0.017076143994927406, 0.08985033631324768, 0.03644613176584244, 0.04765034094452858, -0.017906542867422104, -0.049090150743722916, 0.07487675547599792, 0.039295442402362823, 0.05272018164396286, 0.020694194361567497, 0.0032919044606387615, -0.04758501797914505, 0.014628577046096325, -0.06720687448978424, -0.021165668964385986, 0.007937449961900711, 0.0022056763991713524, 0.006662440020591021, 0.011843348853290081, 0.005666771903634071, 0.03918157517910004, 0.013028073124587536, -0.04015902429819107, -0.010187658481299877, 0.06256779283285141, -0.06927525997161865, 0.07653190940618515, -0.034973252564668655, -0.0031505641527473927, -0.05320914462208748, 0.04010523483157158, 0.038574445992708206, 0.016475316137075424, -0.06157625839114189, -0.034965381026268005, 0.025709938257932663, 0.03379974886775017, -0.1032031774520874, -0.011198805645108223, 0.0015234308084473014, 0.01338241621851921, 0.02674853429198265, -0.033046722412109375, -0.009263955987989902, 0.028300544247031212, 0.027083296328783035, 0.0346430242061615, -0.02113840915262699, -0.0038213336374610662, -0.007697156630456448, 0.04463881254196167, -0.03658341243863106, 0.04190563037991524, -0.04066191986203194, 0.07821236550807953, 0.004107375629246235, 0.02796342596411705, -0.004269615281373262, -0.033799972385168076, -0.029009152203798294, -0.08518429845571518, -0.02845771610736847, -0.001367085613310337, -0.008215040899813175, 0.02752688340842724, 0.01178024709224701, -0.022710328921675682, -0.05602205917239189, 0.025833137333393097, 0.07758355885744095, -0.05803292244672775, 0.03786645457148552, -0.04816671460866928, -0.0029446326661854982, 0.028351591899991035, 0.05189898982644081, -0.012253482826054096, -0.05762337148189545, -0.01308304164558649, 0.010647181421518326, -0.02280472218990326, 0.010785847902297974, -0.03841342777013779, -0.08824731409549713, 0.009248826652765274, -0.0020951058249920607, 0.054765135049819946, 0.04885176941752434, 0.01162162609398365, 0.024546874687075615, -0.0007144807605072856, 0.020372476428747177, -0.05033126473426819, -0.044709935784339905, -0.04066983982920647, 0.07788505405187607, 0.003377445274963975, -0.06376808881759644, 0.04136001318693161, -0.04051022604107857, -0.035296253859996796, 0.038427118211984634, -0.05349767580628395, 0.0591624490916729, 0.059456706047058105, -0.03154874965548515, 0.02888297848403454, -0.009049979969859123, -0.014644719660282135, 0.008932676166296005, 0.0281329695135355, 0.019844908267259598, 0.009718724526464939, 0.004507471341639757, -0.040632981806993484, -0.02616155333817005, 0.002711957786232233, 0.005138712469488382, 0.04304566606879234, -0.10694687813520432, 0.023718250915408134, 0.008315361104905605, -0.037330374121665955, 0.022598298266530037, -0.068906269967556, 0.029469404369592667, 0.02139066904783249, -0.060177721083164215, 0.011444241739809513, 0.042479000985622406, 0.08772975951433182, 0.023770460858941078, 0.05072270333766937, 0.07547399401664734, 0.02915783040225506, 0.0005843535182066262, 0.007527745794504881, -0.015281710773706436, -0.05963592603802681, 0.06174416095018387, -0.03506561741232872, -0.006199626252055168, -0.014111191034317017, -0.023860855028033257, 0.02834056317806244, 0.004408444277942181, -0.0363396592438221, -0.07444147765636444, -0.006576583255082369, 0.05421916022896767, 0.02491668239235878, 0.03660210594534874, 0.057927463203668594, 0.11548558622598648, -0.1030595600605011, -0.05502399057149887, -0.044422443956136703, 0.04856863245368004, 0.036826953291893005, 0.06670472025871277, -0.007551339454948902, 0.04077959433197975, -0.00481900991871953, -0.0246067363768816, -0.04274001717567444, -0.03247131407260895, 0.04318759962916374, -0.07663983851671219, 0.09563782066106796, 0.05544062703847885, 0.023512577638030052, -0.10091003775596619, -0.029656488448381424, -0.05299341678619385, -0.1454954892396927, 0.02047170139849186, 0.02454143948853016, 0.003456389531493187, 0.0026568265166133642, -0.039079196751117706, 0.010297697968780994, 0.02260354533791542, -0.04789775237441063, -0.0040773432701826096, 0.031136879697442055, 0.04525033384561539, 0.03573058173060417, 0.020558563992381096, 0.01378200389444828, -0.08480770140886307, -0.013641026802361012, 0.011102170683443546, 0.008747227489948273, -0.02797221764922142, 0.0514536127448082, 0.004064681939780712, 0.023769905790686607, -0.045566923916339874, -0.04075580835342407, -0.04930536821484566, -0.007736315950751305, -0.06228141114115715, -0.003628575475886464, -0.09626941382884979, -0.00405179662629962, -0.037813056260347366, -0.03745676577091217, 0.007071746978908777, 0.07945718616247177, -0.005654037464410067, 0.04891539365053177, -0.055532556027173996, -0.01790718547999859, 0.01854802295565605, 0.04136174917221069, -0.026912519708275795, -0.03839128464460373, 0.012724777683615685, 0.03382005915045738, -0.026503974571824074, 0.06634759157896042, -0.05273852124810219, 0.08167751133441925, -0.013346226885914803, -0.07796567678451538, -0.04104030877351761, 0.02114315703511238, 0.0961957648396492, -0.01240441482514143, -0.03542507067322731, 0.02386271208524704, -0.010303813964128494, -0.028226900845766068, 0.003283255733549595, 0.04551882669329643, 0.05369788780808449, 0.009446012787520885, 0.04499352350831032, 0.011912830173969269, 0.02192949876189232, -0.003618047572672367, -0.025065278634428978, 0.08817841857671738, -0.036192312836647034, -0.03917132690548897, -0.008850326761603355, 0.0460934154689312, 0.032181981950998306, 0.03664672002196312, 0.023426610976457596, -0.10681447386741638, 0.051670391112565994, -0.04744517803192139, 0.003979160916060209 ]
217
217
Tree Exploration for Bayesian RL Exploration
Research in reinforcement learning has produced algorithms for optimal decision making under uncertainty that fall within two main types. The first employs a Bayesian framework, where optimality improves with increased computational time. This is because the resulting planning task takes the form of a dynamic programming problem on a belief tree with an infinite number of states. The second type employs relatively simple algorithm which are shown to suffer small regret within a distribution-free framework. This paper presents a lower bound and a high probability upper bound on the optimal value function for the nodes in the Bayesian belief tree, which are analogous to similar bounds in POMDPs. The bounds are then used to create more efficient strategies for exploring the tree. The resulting algorithms are compared with the distribution-free algorithm UCB1, as well as a simpler baseline algorithm on multi-armed bandit problems.
[ -0.03584354370832443, -0.020340468734502792, -0.016583701595664024, -0.01977749541401863, 0.01568467542529106, -0.08293189853429794, 0.015077969990670681, -0.04970138147473335, -0.023230522871017456, 0.026750825345516205, 0.009153525345027447, -0.05256560817360878, 0.023753318935632706, -0.001877434435300529, 0.07624300569295883, -0.11004287749528885, -0.00867469608783722, -0.03338675573468208, 0.027928683906793594, -0.022782357409596443, 0.07469253987073898, -0.008686201646924019, 0.03464799374341965, 0.014865499921143055, -0.004389370325952768, -0.0034071756526827812, 0.04109671711921692, -0.014097802340984344, 0.00713224895298481, -0.050633713603019714, -0.06945618242025375, -0.008206895552575588, -0.014723683707416058, -0.0017280371394008398, 0.017220987007021904, -0.08268605172634125, -0.013103587552905083, -0.08597797155380249, -0.042307402938604355, 0.010816375724971294, -0.03372534364461899, -0.0404086709022522, -0.026798387989401817, -0.017330162227153778, 0.05988002195954323, 0.06681827455759048, 0.05617541819810867, 0.0415545292198658, -0.042798809707164764, 0.017660807818174362, -0.08000584691762924, 0.05469689518213272, -0.04780551418662071, -0.019347578287124634, -0.035775326192379, 0.058763548731803894, -0.033650174736976624, 0.03107532300055027, -0.003750499337911606, -0.012968502938747406, 0.007836525328457355, 0.05926114320755005, -0.01266332995146513, 0.02345210686326027, -0.06803570687770844, -0.02539854496717453, -0.04349304735660553, 0.003373421262949705, -0.010251387022435665, -0.04175726696848869, 0.05444485321640968, -0.009675833396613598, 0.011549849063158035, 0.0033287263941019773, 0.015798291191458702, -0.05886628106236458, 0.007908662781119347, 0.03841165825724602, -0.05023403465747833, 0.10089156776666641, -0.03579850122332573, 0.09998622536659241, -0.020607782527804375, 0.042313117533922195, -0.054168183356523514, 0.00695129856467247, -0.041381172835826874, 0.010630588047206402, -0.027342790737748146, -0.0074707153253257275, 0.025526465848088264, 0.043140072375535965, -0.040701378136873245, 0.016254253685474396, 0.028966205194592476, 0.05475509166717529, -0.018527183681726456, 0.019848192110657692, 0.007846085354685783, 0.06016434356570244, -0.005838361103087664, -0.011592991650104523, 0.024468228220939636, 0.059687431901693344, -0.05511593446135521, 0.004370610695332289, 0.03678710013628006, 0.015347681008279324, -0.01214668434113264, -0.05033670365810394, 0.0821678563952446, 0.007318474352359772, -0.036804329603910446, 0.02027570642530918, -0.06309918314218521, 0.04098006710410118, -0.060566939413547516, 0.05362125113606453, 0.015399438329041004, 0.09866832196712494, -0.000844266265630722, 0.012893049977719784, -0.025918131694197655, 0.0471809096634388, 0.05312149599194527, -0.08672678470611572, 0.008062092587351799, -0.0020841287914663553, 0.09930578619241714, -0.02108042873442173, -0.02310981974005699, 0.02060568891465664, 0.01900854893028736, -0.03737989813089371, -0.020768487825989723, 0.0203622505068779, 0.028534382581710815, -0.040463149547576904, 0.018171044066548347, 0.060997262597084045, 0.021375322714447975, 0.01807435229420662, 0.043502334505319595, -0.0008400346268899739, -0.008860111236572266, 0.006954773794859648, 0.03710481896996498, 0.06609199941158295, -0.014280086383223534, 0.02028563804924488, -0.06615830212831497, 0.007802144158631563, -0.016902172937989235, 0.04634610190987587, -0.013623428530991077, -0.01867786981165409, -0.06673505157232285, 0.014990491792559624, -0.047624461352825165, 0.050498366355895996, -0.009887521155178547, 0.06452886015176773, 0.011996505782008171, 0.032008104026317596, 0.050999388098716736, 0.037423811852931976, 0.009576299227774143, 0.013464490883052349, -0.02049633488059044, -0.10399900376796722, -0.021375581622123718, -0.03385213389992714, 0.01155836321413517, 0.06430760025978088, 0.007798016536980867, -0.023823650553822517, -0.025614315643906593, -0.03081836737692356, -0.04168792814016342, -0.016197597607970238, 0.03396355360746384, -0.02035054750740528, -0.021734990179538727, 0.005441852379590273, 0.03858218342065811, 0.09102658182382584, 0.01264283899217844, 0.02090148814022541, 0.05354875326156616, 0.026114748790860176, -0.011240897700190544, -0.012746287509799004, 0.04959769546985626, -0.056441374123096466, 0.04711686447262764, -0.04544396698474884, -0.014051550067961216, 0.003368258709087968, -0.006676110904663801, -0.031954653561115265, 0.035233233124017715, 0.06943054497241974, -0.10566452145576477, 0.005404059775173664, -0.0454527847468853, 0.0636160671710968, 0.015869105234742165, -0.04163854196667671, -0.023914506658911705, -0.07629790902137756, -0.00811752863228321, -0.01472084317356348, -0.03699071332812309, -0.055390048772096634, 0.07942801713943481, -0.01915816031396389, -0.05000842735171318, -0.11972980201244354, -0.01290030125528574, -0.007244441658258438, -0.03070097416639328, 0.06547743827104568, -0.003923707641661167, 0.0740823745727539, -0.07919535785913467, 0.0013217106461524963, 0.01950771175324917, -0.029239008203148842, -0.08459117263555527, 0.04193205386400223, 0.005187350325286388, -0.026890601962804794, 0.010139990597963333, -0.0034743587020784616, -0.039715323597192764, 0.08983248472213745, -0.026738498359918594, -0.042570389807224274, 0.05272319167852402, 0.0042319935746490955, -0.010546524077653885, 0.03256962448358536, -0.00017077336087822914, -0.059312473982572556, 0.08885513991117477, -0.026757225394248962, 0.014148306101560593, 0.03201688826084137, -0.030788997188210487, 0.02740020677447319, 0.045134611427783966, -0.02106563374400139, -0.03957280516624451, 0.04666164889931679, 0.0024579286109656096, -0.032312702387571335, 0.030977239832282066, 0.07592561841011047, 0.07103195041418076, -0.05804078280925751, -0.03660730645060539, 0.023761844262480736, -0.014332067221403122, 0.039480991661548615, -0.012260614894330502, 0.0590754933655262, -0.006242016796022654, -0.00031651268363930285, 0.04381122067570686, -0.0416385792195797, 0.015945980325341225, -0.005392745602875948, -0.0031714055221527815, 0.09255966544151306, -0.048497576266527176, -0.0759652629494667, 0.04326231777667999, -0.01216613594442606, 0.006795586086809635, 0.000023922020773170516, -0.11831885576248169, 0.024127978831529617, 0.03325794264674187, 0.05131608992815018, 0.049543529748916626, 0.04421376436948776, -0.017850574105978012, 0.11203275620937347, 0.0041271052323281765, 0.06422735005617142, -0.01931900717318058, 0.024792954325675964, -0.04632968455553055, 0.002983009908348322, 0.059138476848602295, -0.010432224720716476, 0.017490122467279434, 0.015539259649813175, 0.030433103442192078, -0.0008766515529714525, -0.025201642885804176, -0.026553375646471977, 0.10955750197172165, 0.019449379295110703, 0.006098265293985605, 0.05153583735227585, 0.005451743490993977, 0.029626041650772095, -0.042290158569812775, 0.013236056081950665, 0.029469097033143044, 0.00042345465044490993, -0.06964783370494843, 0.05429430678486824, 0.05528884008526802, 0.022767994552850723, -0.03601178526878357, 0.014574725180864334, -0.0199341531842947, 0.09647473692893982, -0.04774601384997368, 0.00757376616820693, 0.034666575491428375, 0.055659811943769455, -0.07927431166172028, -0.002820345340296626, 0.042568106204271317, -0.007813761942088604, 0.008039887063205242, 0.08680609613656998, -0.08005525171756744, 0.004301630891859531, -0.04120965674519539, 0.04924886301159859, -0.08834940940141678, 0.013867054134607315, -0.11528671532869339, -0.00682841707020998, 0.096321240067482, 0.020746635273098946, -0.056866589933633804, -0.11676467955112457, -0.05823780596256256, -0.06437590718269348, 0.006371119059622288, 0.11608598381280899, 0.0002349632850382477, 0.0012272294843569398, 0.00027179665630683303, 0.06879055500030518, -0.010217570699751377, -0.03272300958633423, -0.047070663422346115, 0.08669862896203995, -0.06208299845457077, 0.007378842681646347, 0.03965016081929207, -0.014103149995207787, -0.009978801012039185, 0.01332014612853527, -0.05866934731602669, -0.010745621286332607, 0.0457855686545372, -0.04671337455511093, -0.03592272475361824, 0.03602305054664612, -0.02294747158885002, 0.03276040032505989, -0.025550777092576027, -0.013812622986733913, -0.0072256759740412235, -0.016824951395392418, 0.04845132678747177, -0.04071907326579094, 0.08533051609992981, 0.0008934487123042345, 0.09091603010892868, -0.009308191016316414, -0.042784132063388824, 0.04854928329586983, -0.03850042074918747, -0.011742406524717808, -0.05609791725873947, -0.10820195078849792, -0.03634405881166458, -0.08562153577804565, -0.05928725004196167, 0.0004863132198806852, 0.08309425413608551, -0.07291014492511749, 0.013994863256812096, -0.07632312923669815, 0.07660210877656937, 0.030190512537956238, 0.022562233731150627, -0.04929826781153679, 0.11684293299913406, -0.005964298732578754, -0.05188552662730217, 0.0488242581486702, 0.04241093248128891, -0.04401879012584686, -0.0029041694942861795, -0.040261637419462204, -0.01860991306602955, -0.029918385669589043, 0.034039586782455444, 0.05779040604829788, -0.018651464954018593, 0.009057532995939255, 0.028643308207392693, 0.025020116940140724, 0.03922038525342941, 0.009207003749907017, -0.043213024735450745, -0.015255163423717022, 0.005462774075567722, -0.027908481657505035, 0.031880322843790054, -0.04280108958482742, 0.013683789409697056, -0.06313776224851608, -0.012251234613358974, -0.03930199146270752, 0.008732943795621395, -0.024174343794584274, 0.04706864058971405, 0.05947934463620186, -0.07110603153705597, 0.03813498467206955, -0.006876630708575249, -0.07647736370563507, -0.06896813958883286, -0.042109277099370956, 0.04739489033818245, -0.05718723684549332, -0.015487050637602806, 0.059159260243177414, -0.01435427088290453, 0.0027010964695364237, 0.004518517758697271, 0.059478942304849625, 0.016390739008784294, -0.004975026939064264, -0.02110522799193859, 0.020980119705200195, 0.02327631786465645, 0.022061839699745178, 0.0007177956285886467, 0.044913746416568756, -0.03731265664100647, 0.0021183977369219065, 0.07641508430242538, -0.05158478394150734, -0.008797933347523212, -0.022648217156529427, 0.009003514423966408, 0.03532760217785835, 0.04624982178211212, -0.005334377754479647, -0.014913761056959629, -0.06539776921272278, 0.015735555440187454, -0.00034256739309057593, -0.041970860213041306, 0.018023425713181496, 0.01372569240629673, -0.024820957332849503, 0.08871360868215561, 0.02902582474052906, -0.06945973634719849, 0.036005351692438126, 0.0127492006868124, -0.038697630167007446, 0.005554683040827513, -0.017030296847224236, -0.012692145071923733, 0.0007903826772235334, 0.0010749556822702289, -0.026196030899882317, 0.0022100398782640696, 0.05118822306394577, -0.057440437376499176, 0.0027714455500245094, 0.09755703806877136, 0.00385493622161448, -0.0376971997320652, 0.021557440981268883, 0.06381870806217194, -0.006435327231884003, -0.049366727471351624, 0.005745828617364168, 0.016237778589129448, -0.02237199991941452, -0.0013907781103625894, -0.009427683427929878, -0.047727588564157486, -0.025896212086081505, 0.08758523315191269, 0.06151358410716057, -0.003174616489559412, -0.013029168359935284, 0.05315842106938362, 0.050904531031847, 0.08525528013706207, 0.01674714684486389, 0.02414403297007084, 0.028558282181620598, 0.009772572666406631, -0.023001715540885925, -0.04760346934199333, 0.03341846913099289 ]
218
218
Discovering general partial orders in event streams
Frequent episode discovery is a popular framework for pattern discovery in event streams. An episode is a partially ordered set of nodes with each node associated with an event type. Efficient (and separate) algorithms exist for episode discovery when the associated partial order is total (serial episode) and trivial (parallel episode). In this paper, we propose efficient algorithms for discovering frequent episodes with general partial orders. These algorithms can be easily specialized to discover serial or parallel episodes. Also, the algorithms are flexible enough to be specialized for mining in the space of certain interesting subclasses of partial orders. We point out that there is an inherent combinatorial explosion in frequent partial order mining and most importantly, frequency alone is not a sufficient measure of interestingness. We propose a new interestingness measure for general partial order episodes and a discovery method based on this measure, for filtering out uninteresting partial orders. Simulations demonstrate the effectiveness of our algorithms.
[ -0.019218891859054565, -0.05596248805522919, 0.05882308632135391, -0.011534328572452068, 0.05032873526215553, -0.0268583744764328, -0.025610677897930145, 0.06023034825921059, 0.011084584519267082, -0.01863572746515274, -0.021318787708878517, -0.06510154157876968, -0.03339895233511925, -0.0021359401289373636, 0.028441760689020157, 0.02941947430372238, -0.08986137062311172, -0.049201034009456635, -0.0954338014125824, -0.04289780184626579, 0.020252559334039688, 0.015164816752076149, 0.021210012957453728, -0.022351939231157303, 0.040664661675691605, -0.023925350978970528, -0.026231497526168823, 0.020674634724855423, -0.02443043328821659, -0.06690111756324768, 0.004677558783441782, 0.06892845779657364, -0.006652080453932285, -0.03487216681241989, 0.022324100136756897, -0.05949533358216286, 0.02349463291466236, -0.05037889629602432, 0.014533266425132751, -0.011516335420310497, 0.055890798568725586, 0.00799008458852768, 0.029919307678937912, -0.019615229219198227, 0.07660361379384995, 0.02647031657397747, 0.07001136988401413, 0.02740062028169632, 0.04168572649359703, 0.11033046990633011, -0.02516253851354122, 0.025988997891545296, -0.03444473445415497, 0.004413781221956015, -0.02033742517232895, 0.1052384003996849, -0.05761512741446495, -0.01420945767313242, -0.028369199484586716, -0.02977648377418518, 0.02491806633770466, 0.07468506693840027, 0.008482620120048523, -0.05225507169961929, -0.01755792461335659, -0.044711869210004807, -0.023374784737825394, -0.03466922417283058, 0.012312189675867558, -0.03137423098087311, 0.0020409938879311085, -0.05991925671696663, -0.0062316302210092545, 0.01830645464360714, 0.019141925498843193, 0.0028552068397402763, -0.01963985711336136, 0.08962561935186386, 0.034635789692401886, 0.02096899412572384, -0.04387446865439415, 0.002457215217873454, -0.029495885595679283, 0.020565660670399666, -0.09948671609163284, -0.07669159770011902, 0.03931666538119316, 0.0351373627781868, -0.018214788287878036, 0.005016794893890619, -0.08773817867040634, 0.07642575353384018, -0.1077168807387352, -0.014644631184637547, -0.02605404518544674, 0.037233199924230576, -0.0806722491979599, -0.003323870012536645, -0.054017722606658936, -0.026257963851094246, 0.06634296476840973, -0.05172521993517876, 0.028118275105953217, 0.06530837714672089, -0.04039866477251053, -0.0009265053668059409, 0.012919270433485508, -0.046563707292079926, 0.03773025423288345, 0.017126034945249557, -0.014243964105844498, -0.03344234824180603, 0.02929726243019104, 0.04531693831086159, 0.002825450384989381, 0.05002601444721222, 0.003323317738249898, 0.03656722605228424, 0.0349600613117218, -0.027951430529356003, 0.002653595758602023, -0.0877353698015213, 0.018950678408145905, 0.013122658245265484, -0.007824893109500408, -0.02613908238708973, -0.06676144152879715, -0.031849455088377, 0.11849657446146011, 0.040532153099775314, -0.04047606885433197, 0.023409830406308174, 0.01202615350484848, -0.07716365158557892, -0.010041373781859875, 0.014173728413879871, -0.021741116419434547, 0.06260230392217636, 0.021939340978860855, 0.030323617160320282, -0.004967841785401106, 0.011895818635821342, 0.049160197377204895, -0.02382361702620983, 0.013965833932161331, 0.030577322468161583, -0.02359434776008129, 0.01444927416741848, 0.04237012937664986, 0.045358214527368546, -0.02134687826037407, 0.0003207350382581353, -0.006306859198957682, 0.08435380458831787, 0.02534806914627552, 0.009397508576512337, -0.002650300972163677, 0.018156519159674644, -0.0032442633528262377, 0.04253273829817772, -0.05857871472835541, -0.0004610479809343815, 0.07312944531440735, 0.03502481058239937, -0.007606374565511942, -0.012879404239356518, -0.008387960493564606, 0.09243372082710266, 0.02670261636376381, 0.058270059525966644, 0.05251241475343704, -0.00728078605607152, -0.00203932193107903, 0.02977566234767437, 0.052098795771598816, -0.040650032460689545, -0.01348115224391222, -0.0194231066852808, 0.033663664013147354, -0.0455397292971611, 0.051949113607406616, -0.10095920413732529, -0.03290114179253578, -0.02884044125676155, 0.02228938415646553, 0.013478195294737816, 0.032307885587215424, 0.06916027516126633, 0.01322531420737505, 0.031192760914564133, 0.025450577959418297, -0.030657155439257622, 0.0024196819867938757, -0.011737453751266003, -0.04605871066451073, -0.015001543797552586, -0.012030632235109806, -0.04915386438369751, 0.005110891070216894, 0.04533525928854942, -0.03319372981786728, -0.00045399731607176363, -0.04522443935275078, -0.06468529254198074, -0.0270718764513731, 0.008651196025311947, 0.03821880370378494, -0.04781989008188248, -0.02813049592077732, -0.07567007094621658, 0.07193906605243683, -0.0014956783270463347, -0.020027706399559975, -0.08244568109512329, 0.06332352012395859, -0.030124308541417122, 0.03220868483185768, -0.0052328817546367645, 0.06116606667637825, 0.042267873883247375, -0.03339427337050438, -0.03602388873696327, 0.02883969619870186, 0.03734048828482628, -0.011382030323147774, -0.02449069544672966, 0.04698048532009125, -0.04201355203986168, 0.004704621620476246, -0.0006371272029355168, -0.0822925865650177, -0.027148859575390816, 0.009428752586245537, -0.0044455500319600105, 0.004735860042273998, 0.06661982089281082, -0.00612992187961936, -0.06425045430660248, -0.04270317777991295, -0.03792087733745575, -0.013851740397512913, 0.04777666553854942, 0.08446618169546127, 0.054603368043899536, 0.001123845111578703, 0.0822548195719719, -0.0401633158326149, 0.04792126640677452, -0.04096450284123421, -0.03149283677339554, -0.012089562602341175, -0.03662892431020737, -0.013777540065348148, 0.02389882318675518, -0.007489356212317944, -0.027237560600042343, -0.0884304866194725, 0.02842951938509941, 0.0019360108999535441, 0.0011483140988275409, 0.06040782108902931, 0.011188438162207603, 0.01872473768889904, 0.09297741204500198, 0.02697950042784214, -0.008292780257761478, 0.006309426389634609, 0.05648120865225792, 0.03549819067120552, -0.09925270080566406, 0.007793849799782038, 0.011668904684484005, -0.022822322323918343, 0.1650131344795227, -0.006815387401729822, -0.062182605266571045, 0.027017313987016678, 0.06097331643104553, 0.009091300889849663, -0.04606212303042412, -0.04257404804229736, -0.015678254887461662, -0.05303541198372841, 0.005645060911774635, 0.05622265860438347, -0.01718040183186531, -0.037627071142196655, -0.09913875162601471, -0.024171140044927597, 0.00303755234926939, -0.04344744607806206, 0.0414651595056057, -0.11236770451068878, -0.08575519919395447, -0.007818027399480343, -0.07397948950529099, -0.029403505846858025, -0.04307462275028229, 0.0734238401055336, -0.006405089050531387, 0.020774265751242638, -0.0217849463224411, 0.054393552243709564, -0.02128329873085022, 0.04407775402069092, -0.023300036787986755, 0.019689247012138367, 0.0592016875743866, -0.041542746126651764, 0.0022448000963777304, 0.0012673147721216083, 0.04564511403441429, -0.008878235705196857, 0.04652447625994682, 0.04737614095211029, -0.020762844011187553, -0.04983903467655182, -0.06623102724552155, -0.08312062174081802, -0.008659007027745247, -0.054581500589847565, 0.045403312891721725, 0.017202451825141907, -0.05525098368525505, -0.07040736079216003, -0.03163062781095505, 0.04095721244812012, -0.013272338546812534, -0.07774631679058075, -0.0008396088378503919, -0.0009744371054694057, 0.03838410973548889, -0.02179270051419735, 0.07131747901439667, 0.009221679531037807, -0.04136933758854866, -0.004459207411855459, 0.024266840890049934, -0.008730486035346985, 0.030232861638069153, 0.022275352850556374, -0.029965119436383247, -0.029082225635647774, -0.031912121921777725, 0.11956534534692764, 0.03145188093185425, 0.0702887773513794, 0.010474571958184242, 0.05986548960208893, 0.029604442417621613, -0.05633888393640518, 0.03244160860776901, 0.00592750683426857, -0.027820907533168793, -0.018469400703907013, 0.0004217280074954033, 0.009163814596831799, 0.028762822970747948, -0.00964322965592146, 0.006753319874405861, -0.012593244202435017, 0.05128396674990654, 0.0358857698738575, -0.03462991490960121, 0.0033482550643384457, 0.04872731864452362, -0.040720853954553604, -0.08953395485877991, 0.002803368726745248, 0.017844809219241142, 0.059748727828264236, 0.0011718953028321266, -0.02601964771747589, -0.018553350120782852, 0.0038367032539099455, -0.020961405709385872, -0.02661246620118618, -0.11765453964471817, -0.04581902176141739, 0.048758748918771744, -0.05963215231895447, -0.012229315005242825, -0.025869715958833694, -0.0016785641200840473, 0.013123482465744019, 0.01854279264807701, -0.012149282731115818, -0.0139553751796484, 0.029985036700963974, 0.03123474307358265, 0.04244218021631241, -0.07313288748264313, 0.017041407525539398, 0.008754288777709007, 0.06324673444032669, 0.013300412334501743, 0.06350348889827728, 0.02984837256371975, -0.03703084960579872, -0.006801961921155453, 0.046539030969142914, -0.10640724748373032, -0.03924689069390297, -0.03726227954030037, 0.017774755135178566, -0.0653870552778244, 0.09590400755405426, 0.03446123003959656, 0.06725439429283142, 0.03627610579133034, 0.018029404804110527, 0.011003024876117706, -0.02184760570526123, 0.0492202527821064, -0.07918836921453476, 0.057925499975681305, -0.02378937602043152, -0.01003839261829853, 0.04103171080350876, 0.044308096170425415, 0.04577348008751869, -0.0350642092525959, 0.009266612119972706, 0.008888062089681625, -0.019733676686882973, 0.010105985216796398, -0.00220061675645411, 0.026170209050178528, -0.02380351349711418, -0.03258650749921799, -0.14134320616722107, 0.02508256584405899, -0.04760351404547691, 0.06311647593975067, 0.028332587331533432, 0.022665616124868393, 0.035715214908123016, -0.023979440331459045, -0.06569802761077881, -0.021436868235468864, -0.055227939039468765, -0.0314176119863987, 0.05564243346452713, 0.03968370333313942, 0.03720690310001373, 0.039054907858371735, -0.011327340267598629, -0.04480544477701187, 0.0043061221949756145, -0.038025863468647, 0.06221829354763031, 0.0006138247554190457, 0.0023584417067468166, 0.02921444922685623, 0.03449489176273346, -0.015086877159774303, 0.027328450232744217, 0.004730001091957092, 0.06736963242292404, -0.05208440497517586, 0.04117182642221451, -0.016348129138350487, 0.03659476712346077, -0.059506263583898544, -0.02334507368505001, -0.003830610541626811, -0.027426080778241158, 0.0571911595761776, 0.08394502103328705, -0.04205655679106712, -0.07566573470830917, 0.03609826788306236, -0.02307872660458088, -0.00030280626378953457, -0.03380405902862549, -0.016315216198563576, -0.01873600110411644, 0.03493399918079376, 0.00551110552623868, -0.008978284895420074, 0.04661830514669418, 0.06966806203126907, -0.025779129937291145, 0.004266868811100721, 0.05852833017706871, 0.08598924428224564, 0.000466256431536749, -0.11152675747871399, 0.019576476886868477, -0.03197123855352402, 0.021415788680315018, -0.06666600704193115, 0.014035279862582684, 0.04374157637357712, -0.02161957323551178, -0.029783004894852638, 0.0011393965687602758, 0.06433269381523132, -0.016598505899310112, -0.061999231576919556, 0.027216825634241104, -0.07586122304201126, 0.012886220589280128, 0.08367018401622772, 0.04222992807626724, 0.07300404459238052, 0.029565686360001564, -0.01628202386200428, 0.0010890875710174441, -0.029967378824949265, 0.06656584143638611, -0.06659699976444244 ]
219
219
Extraction de concepts sous contraintes dans des donn\'ees d'expression de g\`enes
In this paper, we propose a technique to extract constrained formal concepts.
[ 0.06763789802789688, -0.013050537556409836, -0.023549271747469902, -0.023961005732417107, 0.014712616801261902, -0.069870725274086, -0.0346064493060112, -0.07130280137062073, -0.05561716854572296, 0.030239233747124672, 0.015272951684892178, -0.012926544062793255, -0.04826843738555908, -0.022128554061055183, -0.015006567351520061, 0.017119837924838066, -0.01996387541294098, -0.03056483529508114, 0.06535463780164719, -0.01445232518017292, 0.028550652787089348, 0.03508254513144493, -0.007098855916410685, -0.016166461631655693, 0.062110256403684616, 0.02446502447128296, -0.04005837067961693, 0.019755642861127853, 0.013919200748205185, 0.06525836139917374, -0.07759144902229309, 0.01562517322599888, 0.022633519023656845, -0.027740437537431717, 0.03667174279689789, 0.00970650278031826, 0.014386068098247051, 0.007950718514621258, 0.024857355281710625, 0.07428243011236191, 0.0470927469432354, 0.043354135006666183, -0.024013064801692963, -0.04622491076588631, 0.0069928462617099285, 0.031218107789754868, 0.009928933344781399, -0.05624565854668617, -0.01647881045937538, 0.0073847039602696896, -0.023093052208423615, -0.023307910189032555, -0.08349011838436127, 0.03641583025455475, 0.03385302424430847, 0.04983207583427429, -0.0287872813642025, 0.01233846228569746, 0.02547069638967514, 0.1253577619791031, 0.007140502333641052, 0.028853537514805794, 0.02376602403819561, -0.02187204919755459, -0.10309432446956635, -0.014651801437139511, 0.005891577340662479, 0.014065200462937355, -0.020944464951753616, 0.02575843594968319, 0.021907780319452286, 0.014871630817651749, 0.010990922339260578, 0.022458888590335846, 0.05708710849285126, -0.05652771517634392, 0.012016943655908108, -0.010354864411056042, 0.0019356213742867112, 0.04367973655462265, -0.018861187621951103, 0.05918363481760025, -0.016155576333403587, -0.06320679187774658, -0.007640262600034475, -0.03156955912709236, 0.09549003094434738, 0.043605905026197433, -0.050233397632837296, -0.034612130373716354, 0.01367038581520319, 0.009037316776812077, 0.006549404468387365, 0.052679188549518585, -0.010158936493098736, 0.029232142493128777, -0.004424361977726221, -0.005637438502162695, -0.05225515365600586, -0.04505407065153122, -0.0740552693605423, -0.011378047056496143, 0.047311507165431976, -0.007491659838706255, -0.1037682369351387, 0.05066879466176033, -0.034888509660959244, 0.05795695260167122, 0.008820565417408943, -0.029805729165673256, -0.005660154391080141, 0.00635584257543087, 0.012098344042897224, 0.06066777557134628, -0.060130152851343155, 0.017793282866477966, 0.04585293307900429, 0.05704640597105026, 0.046894095838069916, -0.016606945544481277, -0.0512726716697216, -0.027471626177430153, 0.027362778782844543, 0.031382620334625244, 0.08678777515888214, -0.025045474991202354, 0.013440500944852829, -0.04718467593193054, 0.07351764291524887, 0.028300773352384567, 0.02934950962662697, 0.11265789717435837, -0.05179325491189957, -0.004340003710240126, -0.016620788723230362, 0.008280105888843536, -0.030523188412189484, -0.04445208981633186, -0.056196436285972595, -0.013066627085208893, 0.04335034638643265, 0.033707261085510254, 0.04588321968913078, -0.04197695851325989, 0.05985281988978386, 0.039657048881053925, -0.10301102697849274, -0.0031765014864504337, 0.010272044688463211, -0.020389806479215622, -0.06321199983358383, -0.07470647245645523, 0.014515741728246212, 0.0006209132843650877, 0.05964553728699684, -0.02223929762840271, -0.007628903724253178, -0.015623162500560284, -0.0033411949407309294, 0.0283197034150362, 0.028044268488883972, -0.08596619963645935, 0.013192513957619667, 0.015032538212835789, -0.011677263304591179, 0.04921116307377815, -0.01156167034059763, 0.019846035167574883, -0.00018173072021454573, -0.08173339068889618, -0.06819445639848709, 0.04761723428964615, 0.03138735517859459, 0.014644940383732319, 0.007817734032869339, -0.018693653866648674, -0.042742688208818436, -0.0257802065461874, -0.03551321104168892, -0.02414746955037117, 0.010020744986832142, -0.07182906568050385, -0.002368178451433778, 0.016124814748764038, -0.024008331820368767, 0.04030635952949524, -0.02493307553231716, 0.012765636667609215, -0.0034755999222397804, -0.03685536980628967, 0.009185446426272392, 0.07074625045061111, -0.008428235538303852, 0.00990432407706976, -0.061549924314022064, 0.030875293537974358, 0.01020058337599039, 0.08879060298204422, 0.005319409538060427, 0.06530190259218216, 0.007216223981231451, 0.03162871673703194, -0.065059594810009, -0.07832451909780502, -0.1031927540898323, 0.049922943115234375, 0.06222100183367729, -0.005972504150122404, -0.026374615728855133, -0.05961903557181358, 0.021818097680807114, -0.019726302474737167, -0.1020418033003807, 0.00170372542925179, -0.010536596179008484, -0.04789361357688904, -0.013132411055266857, -0.026407744735479355, 0.002481760224327445, 0.04006405174732208, 0.0055319019593298435, 0.014275326393544674, 0.05128592252731323, 0.047908760607242584, -0.022439956665039062, -0.04512222111225128, -0.028993621468544006, -0.0614917129278183, -0.02693968638777733, 0.019310781732201576, -0.08665526658296585, -0.05684385448694229, 0.0017307011876255274, -0.005734928883612156, 0.011290021240711212, -0.02726149931550026, 0.016638772562146187, 0.08692028373479843, -0.06576380133628845, 0.02122463285923004, -0.022745681926608086, -0.03193160146474838, 0.03779786080121994, -0.04471900686621666, -0.08133964240550995, 0.017544586211442947, -0.03452505171298981, 0.003965894225984812, -0.00045160556328482926, 0.022111518308520317, -0.0288592167198658, 0.018699806183576584, -0.03007548674941063, -0.01013148669153452, 0.009884684346616268, -0.03577255830168724, -0.010472232475876808, 0.04202522709965706, 0.10343506932258606, 0.016787849366664886, -0.06198910251259804, -0.00214633927680552, -0.10255670547485352, -0.003693298203870654, 0.06608656793832779, 0.06631656736135483, -0.0049583143554627895, 0.08759420365095139, 0.023664748296141624, -0.03748598322272301, -0.02851184457540512, 0.0004126210114918649, 0.001832806272432208, 0.014483559876680374, 0.032083991914987564, 0.011218085885047913, 0.05395793169736862, -0.009924674406647682, 0.03682413324713707, 0.02730894461274147, -0.03274489566683769, -0.0005224758060649037, -0.009493537247180939, -0.01186597440391779, 0.005913820117712021, 0.009414502419531345, -0.020194826647639275, -0.11064372211694717, -0.005850404035300016, 0.0441681370139122, -0.11771607398986816, -0.038867659866809845, -0.008982300758361816, 0.03192403167486191, 0.09058140218257904, -0.0712176188826561, 0.025752047076821327, 0.02936086803674698, 0.038928233087062836, -0.04160497337579727, -0.015404517762362957, -0.001280515338294208, 0.0007922323420643806, -0.020876789465546608, 0.02820233628153801, -0.035075921565294266, 0.01786450855433941, -0.022504320368170738, 0.01131238229572773, 0.023485975340008736, -0.002447685459628701, 0.01624738983809948, 0.05977804586291313, -0.026439927518367767, 0.020755162462592125, -0.0737978145480156, 0.0597439743578434, -0.019369466230273247, 0.01616835594177246, 0.02586539275944233, -0.043495167046785355, -0.08460701256990433, -0.04885231703519821, -0.045629553496837616, -0.06868261843919754, -0.07063077390193939, 0.06576894968748093, -0.018525883555412292, -0.07740971446037292, -0.05440516024827957, -0.10539435595273972, 0.035206541419029236, 0.07090526819229126, 0.10111042857170105, 0.008462782949209213, -0.011350598186254501, 0.0410730354487896, -0.010387993417680264, -0.045854825526475906, 0.023956747725605965, -0.06642446666955948, -0.06528297066688538, -0.000645522668492049, -0.013980960473418236, 0.042779404670000076, 0.02641531638801098, 0.04545918107032776, 0.061432551592588425, -0.03456669673323631, 0.034693531692028046, -0.016077490523457527, -0.08075563609600067, -0.017143264412879944, 0.04313690960407257, -0.05366356670856476, 0.010641658678650856, 0.028866788372397423, -0.007591043598949909, -0.08127149194478989, 0.023760344833135605, 0.03832624852657318, -0.054035548120737076, 0.00479125464335084, -0.02420899271965027, -0.07168898731470108, 0.00413437420502305, -0.012726829387247562, 0.037058573216199875, -0.05036212503910065, -0.010379946790635586, 0.0006422098376788199, 0.012429623864591122, 0.01278362050652504, -0.0032332923728972673, -0.02884691208600998, -0.044164352118968964, 0.12016943842172623, -0.037186648696660995, -0.0026142720598727465, 0.05022180452942848, -0.020985165610909462, -0.026598941534757614, 0.047168586403131485, 0.006392756476998329, -0.022227464243769646, -0.010116343386471272, 0.010652069933712482, 0.020655779168009758, 0.010850838385522366, 0.027501914650201797, -0.08289948850870132, 0.032916922122240067, 0.05303129553794861, -0.026142721995711327, 0.021063726395368576, 0.01572112739086151, -0.09151656180620193, 0.031761229038238525, 0.04994187504053116, -0.018491100519895554, 0.003047775710001588, -0.02122652530670166, -0.036223094910383224, -0.04363051429390907, -0.04042750969529152, -0.09185730665922165, -0.025319963693618774, 0.03871621564030647, -0.02196693792939186, 0.06148555502295494, 0.02550855651497841, 0.037724267691373825, -0.05834313482046127, 0.05011981725692749, -0.032964013516902924, 0.04134373739361763, 0.03408018872141838, -0.016410307958722115, 0.021898550912737846, -0.05216996744275093, -0.002403199439868331, -0.009217155165970325, 0.03418572247028351, -0.029989352449774742, 0.06088735908269882, -0.04537588730454445, 0.09068363159894943, 0.06299998611211777, -0.0056298659183084965, -0.07078789919614792, -0.021669495850801468, -0.0549943633377552, -0.05878160521388054, -0.06901034712791443, 0.06713435053825378, 0.06376855075359344, 0.07367666065692902, 0.07268092781305313, 0.09833145886659622, 0.04941561073064804, -0.04344121366739273, 0.03297276422381401, 0.08651896566152573, 0.01435861922800541, 0.031570740044116974, 0.0526091493666172, -0.03097829967737198, -0.010706494562327862, 0.019475474953651428, 0.012386557646095753, -0.024662844836711884, -0.02934761717915535, 0.04206876829266548, -0.01827079802751541, -0.03499641269445419, -0.00871632993221283, 0.005618507973849773, 0.012516702525317669, 0.035982679575681686, 0.00935439858585596, -0.055802688002586365, -0.040250513702631, 0.04353965073823929, 0.006922331638634205, -0.025116698816418648, -0.0031424269545823336, -0.02213423326611519, 0.034765467047691345, 0.1147175133228302, -0.00034831720404326916, -0.015517625957727432, 0.014252609573304653, 0.052737876772880554, 0.0635376051068306, -0.07104440033435822, -0.01949819177389145, 0.0897446870803833, -0.07475190609693527, 0.04470575600862503, -0.006130571942776442, 0.03125034645199776, -0.021731963381171227, -0.11450549960136414, -0.04595515504479408, 0.019491566345095634, 0.030568620190024376, 0.007603348232805729, -0.09043469280004501, 0.13076283037662506, 0.0093250572681427, 0.001873151515610516, 0.0011727310484275222, 0.02372485026717186, 0.008970232680439949, 0.08538125455379486, -0.029956936836242676, -0.03538069874048233, -0.009910949505865574, 0.0008461836259812117, -0.024220233783125877, -0.011625086888670921, -0.013126257807016373, 0.016636407002806664, 0.03964001312851906, 0.04028553515672684, -0.006015097256749868, 0.04045212268829346, -0.05740419030189514, -0.03462632745504379, 0.062015607953071594, -0.036437008529901505, -0.07768987864255905 ]
220
220
Database Transposition for Constrained (Closed) Pattern Mining
Recently, different works proposed a new way to mine patterns in databases with pathological size. For example, experiments in genome biology usually provide databases with thousands of attributes (genes) but only tens of objects (experiments). In this case, mining the "transposed" database runs through a smaller search space, and the Galois connection allows to infer the closed patterns of the original database. We focus here on constrained pattern mining for those unusual databases and give a theoretical framework for database and constraint transposition. We discuss the properties of constraint transposition and look into classical constraints. We then address the problem of generating the closed patterns of the original database satisfying the constraint, starting from those mined in the "transposed" database. Finally, we show how to generate all the patterns satisfying the constraint from the closed ones.
[ 0.02962643839418888, -0.03290023282170296, 0.05636892467737198, -0.04751996695995331, 0.029023684561252594, -0.05134010687470436, -0.031065139919519424, -0.09100489318370819, 0.00238840957172215, 0.030777093023061752, 0.03093712590634823, -0.08973395079374313, -0.03298730030655861, 0.003064799355342984, -0.040547434240579605, -0.003256939584389329, -0.09648577123880386, -0.044768303632736206, 0.0024590929970145226, -0.08241911977529526, 0.014758197590708733, 0.07857248187065125, -0.032476555556058884, -0.024997062981128693, 0.031751710921525955, 0.004982900805771351, -0.04331069812178612, -0.05648372694849968, -0.021703403443098068, -0.01926981471478939, -0.037435177713632584, -0.03854281082749367, -0.0022856341674923897, -0.007490662857890129, 0.013057347387075424, 0.04995853826403618, -0.045634493231773376, 0.010924199596047401, 0.046842627227306366, -0.002164342673495412, 0.05056741461157799, 0.015544669702649117, -0.0030557457357645035, -0.008828256279230118, 0.033921726047992706, 0.010454660281538963, 0.03243906795978546, -0.006928659044206142, 0.02808898501098156, 0.004811469465494156, -0.06141628324985504, 0.06934436410665512, 0.056146129965782166, 0.02280830591917038, -0.06842168420553207, 0.030603215098381042, -0.07293020188808441, -0.02329312451183796, 0.0827988013625145, 0.05659037455916405, 0.09548300504684448, 0.058977168053388596, -0.02058531530201435, 0.006679911632090807, -0.04856179282069206, -0.03566690534353256, -0.050781287252902985, -0.03562244027853012, -0.019787687808275223, -0.00707464711740613, 0.04243753105401993, -0.04947439953684807, 0.029488420113921165, 0.0517050065100193, 0.06282486021518707, 0.04338229447603226, 0.09204381704330444, -0.009321048855781555, 0.031193003058433533, 0.06124892085790634, -0.08584953844547272, 0.03937570005655289, -0.06379637122154236, 0.011576129123568535, -0.003506855107843876, -0.02618318423628807, 0.11957091838121414, 0.009755479171872139, -0.04273397475481033, 0.019875556230545044, -0.027789361774921417, -0.03299575299024582, -0.10988045483827591, 0.058862101286649704, -0.09657042473554611, 0.03867146745324135, -0.023902487009763718, 0.033839523792266846, -0.01440451666712761, -0.031173013150691986, -0.06930942088365555, -0.002670218702405691, -0.024560414254665375, -0.022403817623853683, -0.031297579407691956, 0.0077771153301000595, -0.047218505293130875, 0.02634536847472191, -0.0388755276799202, -0.1092473492026329, -0.026025157421827316, 0.023357151076197624, 0.012949461117386818, -0.03357812389731407, -0.03207414224743843, 0.039957333356142044, 0.07901891320943832, -0.022005032747983932, -0.012651011347770691, -0.048912398517131805, 0.06377328187227249, -0.06743426620960236, 0.07131155580282211, -0.018714455887675285, -0.014899452216923237, -0.04036552831530571, 0.05616520717740059, -0.05718863382935524, 0.0865173488855362, 0.008747552521526814, 0.03625110164284706, 0.03047412820160389, -0.10920019447803497, -0.052169423550367355, -0.07729487121105194, 0.03765158727765083, -0.07324924319982529, -0.043995678424835205, -0.012197423726320267, 0.10222837328910828, -0.010786856524646282, -0.020525824278593063, -0.022372176870703697, -0.0944116860628128, 0.02151673473417759, -0.02431270107626915, -0.04637384042143822, 0.013944541104137897, 0.05746413394808769, 0.021867405623197556, -0.11351339519023895, -0.024450955912470818, 0.007529255468398333, 0.11042207479476929, -0.019761011004447937, 0.003996704239398241, -0.04731904715299606, -0.042500074952840805, 0.014546756632626057, 0.022384824231266975, 0.01290419977158308, -0.026891609653830528, -0.05144541338086128, -0.0037945008371025324, 0.007560758385807276, 0.01834709942340851, -0.009001514874398708, -0.011944699101150036, 0.0048604910261929035, -0.0015755888307467103, -0.022003106772899628, 0.005873605143278837, 0.054684288799762726, 0.0520150251686573, 0.018823932856321335, -0.029730141162872314, -0.0016620034584775567, 0.08323411643505096, 0.010220902040600777, -0.04111054539680481, -0.030465109273791313, -0.046037063002586365, -0.003103101858869195, 0.03868093341588974, 0.026802508160471916, 0.07767166942358017, -0.00003541350088198669, 0.024036377668380737, 0.014635369181632996, 0.0177320446819067, 0.05890568345785141, 0.04995477572083473, 0.01937440223991871, 0.04946906119585037, -0.030155429616570473, 0.01792391762137413, -0.028592757880687714, -0.005127386189997196, -0.043238356709480286, 0.028610557317733765, -0.02502386085689068, 0.0032268634531646967, -0.00017269302043132484, -0.008595448918640614, -0.047035347670316696, -0.06849709898233414, 0.04005936160683632, 0.002210622653365135, -0.037015650421381, -0.05865412950515747, 0.011366190388798714, 0.011166950687766075, -0.015036680735647678, 0.003805454121902585, 0.0027971500530838966, -0.014717279002070427, -0.012681559659540653, -0.08926819264888763, 0.0663221925497055, 0.012780963443219662, -0.029050324112176895, 0.046607598662376404, -0.010835513472557068, -0.004306429531425238, -0.029728006571531296, 0.02823232114315033, -0.013596532866358757, -0.019905533641576767, -0.06108707934617996, 0.01782969757914543, -0.11221934854984283, -0.040896281599998474, 0.0013206496369093657, 0.04983538016676903, -0.01816273294389248, 0.019064249470829964, -0.020651105791330338, 0.05212060734629631, 0.018207408487796783, 0.07135552167892456, 0.039432886987924576, 0.009354015812277794, 0.006086596287786961, -0.058215800672769547, -0.011946091428399086, 0.04462368041276932, 0.011412986554205418, 0.03650345653295517, -0.0035319742746651173, 0.026513954624533653, -0.04603861644864082, -0.0023419554345309734, -0.002164686331525445, -0.036142073571681976, 0.0803179144859314, -0.052848078310489655, -0.012475681491196156, -0.0068992506712675095, 0.028742091730237007, 0.040160369127988815, -0.006869116332381964, 0.05954916775226593, -0.0806695893406868, 0.010090918280184269, 0.0654430091381073, 0.036097437143325806, -0.04295659065246582, 0.019586049020290375, -0.021621884778141975, -0.038885995745658875, 0.03969356790184975, -0.08941160887479782, 0.019913526251912117, 0.032066527754068375, -0.03975018858909607, -0.07460538297891617, 0.06864216923713684, 0.05062815546989441, 0.023236911743879318, -0.0018849942134693265, -0.11902667582035065, -0.008650768548250198, 0.02391202747821808, -0.0439077652990818, -0.05432312190532684, -0.025709260255098343, -0.02705669030547142, -0.015778930857777596, 0.016529297456145287, -0.010084718465805054, -0.014188835397362709, -0.03787507489323616, -0.051203835755586624, 0.02015039697289467, 0.029516227543354034, 0.025565436109900475, 0.013305380940437317, -0.010898261331021786, 0.032208152115345, -0.023682575672864914, 0.05460380017757416, 0.025569666177034378, 0.022246813401579857, -0.01438334584236145, 0.07557087391614914, 0.025555375963449478, 0.0563066303730011, 0.04084378853440285, -0.022764479741454124, -0.042466163635253906, 0.03906714543700218, 0.022357381880283356, 0.05518323555588722, -0.024634892120957375, 0.030515551567077637, -0.07258252054452896, -0.011262374930083752, 0.07814311236143112, 0.013135666958987713, 0.0207220371812582, 0.008912076242268085, 0.06178685277700424, -0.03980505093932152, -0.006708061322569847, -0.020129255950450897, -0.09487183392047882, 0.021258866414427757, 0.03303789347410202, -0.022594990208745003, -0.031477030366659164, -0.06577730178833008, -0.007894950918853283, 0.019302096217870712, 0.11080707609653473, -0.029570316895842552, -0.019512398168444633, -0.034556638449430466, 0.02971530146896839, -0.06234234943985939, 0.011155599728226662, -0.030606957152485847, -0.09276851266622543, -0.009325625374913216, -0.02981366403400898, 0.0031963118817657232, 0.03258933126926422, 0.05198070406913757, 0.01039642933756113, 0.079434335231781, 0.001473390613682568, -0.01824340596795082, 0.004618978127837181, -0.016849201172590256, -0.0011419345391914248, -0.012958896346390247, 0.03795839473605156, 0.021734608337283134, 0.020701441913843155, 0.00841611623764038, 0.06665587425231934, 0.08403637260198593, -0.04427729547023773, 0.04895473271608353, 0.05693492665886879, -0.03912629559636116, 0.016811339184641838, -0.033968064934015274, -0.04423445463180542, -0.06219726428389549, 0.051090307533741, 0.035627640783786774, 0.026578526943922043, 0.00042633552220650017, 0.04471011087298393, 0.02005515992641449, -0.09246450662612915, -0.011229559779167175, -0.11311443150043488, -0.059432994574308395, 0.06498882919549942, -0.0797404944896698, 0.034755889326334, 0.016502387821674347, 0.016930902376770973, -0.03474412485957146, -0.009330923669040203, -0.007852351292967796, -0.007434049621224403, 0.013427795842289925, 0.03109668381512165, -0.0019795356784015894, 0.034230440855026245, 0.029280157759785652, -0.030491173267364502, 0.0034030203241854906, -0.012772438116371632, -0.1040615662932396, 0.027364196255803108, 0.029059097170829773, -0.0207027830183506, -0.07064937055110931, -0.051046017557382584, -0.06913123279809952, -0.05212864652276039, -0.03904901444911957, 0.014145244844257832, 0.03412691503763199, 0.024039963260293007, 0.012365217320621014, 0.06462522596120834, -0.015015996061265469, -0.012482933700084686, -0.03977469727396965, 0.024111278355121613, -0.027928417548537254, -0.016454525291919708, 0.008217614144086838, 0.09886732697486877, -0.007773908320814371, 0.01562364213168621, -0.0033218807075172663, -0.00020327807578723878, -0.022535238415002823, -0.06138710677623749, 0.08243288099765778, -0.05239137262105942, 0.059223856776952744, 0.028107399120926857, 0.03771892562508583, -0.04633496701717377, -0.07128415256738663, -0.0696270540356636, -0.06438415497541428, 0.028783313930034637, 0.0038945013657212257, 0.05692174658179283, 0.028757328167557716, 0.016444819048047066, 0.09736363589763641, 0.04281030222773552, -0.03118824027478695, 0.04887950047850609, 0.04496549069881439, 0.0349663607776165, 0.03994409739971161, -0.015916047617793083, 0.015829160809516907, 0.00987059436738491, 0.05952104181051254, 0.03721402958035469, 0.027463655918836594, 0.014859768562018871, -0.05059003457427025, 0.008529802784323692, -0.057782623916864395, 0.012737883254885674, -0.07540539652109146, 0.03170328214764595, 0.04097898676991463, 0.030750567093491554, 0.05362332612276077, 0.009409158490598202, 0.04862968996167183, -0.026151767000555992, -0.05899471044540405, -0.07563290745019913, -0.03457529470324516, 0.08505941927433014, 0.04630182683467865, 0.03740162029862404, -0.013833485543727875, 0.029822738841176033, 0.020434077829122543, 0.027438800781965256, -0.05808888375759125, -0.0081169493496418, -0.00498204817995429, -0.031106049194931984, 0.029385389760136604, 0.01747186854481697, -0.0017562287393957376, 0.02513878047466278, 0.0020864447578787804, -0.05078223720192909, -0.029065709561109543, 0.007656997535377741, -0.02994239144027233, -0.05437212809920311, 0.06098981946706772, 0.03011557087302208, -0.009519793093204498, 0.0021802044939249754, 0.00017873836623039097, -0.034855376929044724, 0.0667552649974823, -0.030320173129439354, 0.06066935509443283, -0.03863684460520744, 0.0811949223279953, -0.018599234521389008, 0.011905789375305176, -0.018014321103692055, -0.03639444708824158, 0.09731815755367279, 0.08750566095113754, 0.00946984812617302, -0.05553983151912689, -0.03459712862968445, -0.04184694215655327, 0.029904726892709732, 0.005481584928929806, -0.04558033496141434 ]
221
221
Multi-Label Prediction via Compressed Sensing
We consider multi-label prediction problems with large output spaces under the assumption of output sparsity -- that the target (label) vectors have small support. We develop a general theory for a variant of the popular error correcting output code scheme, using ideas from compressed sensing for exploiting this sparsity. The method can be regarded as a simple reduction from multi-label regression problems to binary regression problems. We show that the number of subproblems need only be logarithmic in the total number of possible labels, making this approach radically more efficient than others. We also state and prove robustness guarantees for this method in the form of regret transform bounds (in general), and also provide a more detailed analysis for the linear prediction setting.
[ -0.00692224083468318, -0.04681049659848213, 0.05017615109682083, -0.06184544414281845, -0.021029233932495117, -0.03914846479892731, -0.05093872547149658, -0.018231216818094254, 0.029799923300743103, -0.026478271931409836, 0.022034013643860817, -0.04123804718255997, -0.023678239434957504, -0.025179846212267876, -0.014657003805041313, 0.007267074193805456, -0.007214174140244722, 0.006815285887569189, 0.021979903802275658, -0.04616473615169525, 0.002288060961291194, -0.05436946451663971, -0.05310995876789093, -0.055427610874176025, 0.023279283195734024, 0.04446570947766304, -0.03840911388397217, 0.020871486514806747, -0.009255346842110157, -0.029722653329372406, -0.09182713180780411, 0.051532357931137085, 0.06423300504684448, 0.07513993978500366, -0.012346092611551285, -0.07724880427122116, 0.006024002563208342, 0.056937698274850845, -0.0813036784529686, -0.0319889597594738, 0.05562004819512367, -0.02577764168381691, -0.0006629609270021319, -0.04937116429209709, 0.015595818869769573, 0.019173771142959595, 0.007961710914969444, -0.11003783345222473, 0.02135382778942585, 0.038077544420957565, -0.09441899508237839, 0.07735669612884521, -0.017886146903038025, 0.00676861172541976, 0.08511161804199219, 0.007704244926571846, 0.005897029303014278, 0.005055547226220369, 0.04892924427986145, 0.001882921322248876, 0.0546920970082283, 0.10284783691167831, -0.05119422823190689, -0.022114770486950874, -0.016410373151302338, 0.003577254479750991, -0.05635758489370346, 0.005928767845034599, -0.025602595880627632, 0.04310997202992439, -0.09033496677875519, -0.06020866706967354, -0.01871592551469803, 0.031690288335084915, 0.05597545951604843, 0.002921058563515544, -0.006289342883974314, -0.05423077568411827, -0.02340743876993656, 0.030303804203867912, -0.0992644801735878, 0.0530901774764061, -0.00023272934777196497, 0.035340674221515656, -0.040269654244184494, 0.014817047864198685, -0.02781190536916256, 0.00624940637499094, 0.031804587692022324, -0.06435948610305786, -0.043511077761650085, 0.026855971664190292, -0.07415235042572021, 0.01642361655831337, 0.06910397112369537, 0.039638444781303406, 0.05804813280701637, -0.02154124528169632, -0.02492409199476242, 0.0592220202088356, 0.04678766801953316, 0.0409298799932003, 0.058077387511730194, 0.06970962882041931, -0.046620924025774, 0.02597229741513729, -0.04444821551442146, 0.05155874788761139, 0.05984204635024071, -0.027356313541531563, 0.03457203134894371, -0.03457488864660263, 0.03435882180929184, 0.007114280015230179, 0.0008482162957079709, 0.01719147525727749, -0.029585905373096466, 0.02470121905207634, 0.01878971792757511, 0.004603559151291847, 0.06560934334993362, 0.03699629381299019, -0.07707079499959946, 0.006277986336499453, 0.06635203212499619, -0.07965125143527985, -0.04318099841475487, -0.03799106925725937, 0.04627121239900589, 0.059329815208911896, -0.008722267113626003, 0.05576367303729057, -0.010905896313488483, 0.024039359763264656, -0.004378551617264748, 0.044268812984228134, 0.06385236233472824, -0.08377698808908463, -0.04777301475405693, -0.004570757504552603, -0.014189912006258965, -0.017736051231622696, -0.026920756325125694, 0.014186100102961063, 0.04769720882177353, 0.04750465974211693, 0.006056968122720718, -0.01252267137169838, -0.05084032937884331, -0.061334848403930664, -0.03598618879914284, 0.0007538662175647914, 0.04999919980764389, 0.06282017379999161, 0.07540705054998398, -0.06055259332060814, -0.02442217990756035, -0.04791869968175888, 0.014373217709362507, 0.020957669243216515, -0.08912277966737747, 0.02328600361943245, 0.07110462337732315, 0.07560724020004272, -0.05772542953491211, -0.02798493392765522, -0.0018044094322249293, -0.010811636224389076, -0.10608100146055222, -0.10058590024709702, -0.052041225135326385, -0.02339613251388073, 0.007632567081600428, 0.048062101006507874, 0.021096426993608475, 0.006626594346016645, 0.030586574226617813, 0.019991720095276833, -0.004417011514306068, -0.056220609694719315, 0.07918763160705566, -0.0035181501880288124, -0.05382745712995529, 0.06974563002586365, 0.11186229437589645, 0.025846512988209724, 0.005633221939206123, -0.024824747815728188, 0.07006519287824631, 0.014039292931556702, -0.001333395717665553, -0.007649769075214863, -0.019717169925570488, 0.06050126254558563, -0.0583125576376915, 0.05541335791349411, -0.020173698663711548, -0.026932645589113235, -0.044002093374729156, 0.004529224243015051, 0.027193205431103706, -0.01364119816571474, 0.012526270933449268, -0.06984053552150726, 0.01398533396422863, 0.011510821990668774, 0.028316933661699295, -0.047005414962768555, 0.0016192381735891104, 0.009474258869886398, 0.021870678290724754, 0.012260712683200836, 0.08155414462089539, -0.0051111443899571896, -0.03594821318984032, -0.026592450216412544, 0.06278729438781738, -0.05769587308168411, 0.08993908762931824, 0.03492351993918419, -0.010000033304095268, 0.10318192839622498, -0.03834189474582672, -0.03984922170639038, -0.07549062371253967, 0.06390468776226044, 0.08804161846637726, -0.04110473766922951, -0.03654862567782402, 0.07387109100818634, -0.027698805555701256, -0.07346837222576141, -0.09702621400356293, -0.03027724288403988, -0.052465181797742844, 0.030295634642243385, -0.0704406276345253, -0.09190018475055695, -0.018509291112422943, 0.009334476664662361, 0.011104803532361984, 0.0226741936057806, -0.0000307512964354828, -0.05340341478586197, 0.020900938659906387, 0.0040457285940647125, 0.07842756062746048, -0.006082459352910519, -0.006183250341564417, -0.028408583253622055, 0.03064970299601555, 0.043281182646751404, -0.024507006630301476, -0.009752015583217144, 0.001342068426311016, -0.017717432230710983, 0.03291650116443634, -0.03375886380672455, 0.06320016831159592, 0.06900783628225327, -0.023585345596075058, 0.02569550834596157, -0.10615304112434387, 0.008350723423063755, -0.011106896214187145, -0.013709180057048798, 0.006012129131704569, -0.029108114540576935, -0.04888995364308357, 0.04638688638806343, -0.03868251293897629, -0.060572922229766846, -0.04592322185635567, 0.029331400990486145, -0.055718421936035156, -0.06096133962273598, 0.00864748377352953, 0.025724543258547783, 0.0039563365280628204, -0.0010113760363310575, -0.053497303277254105, 0.034699946641922, 0.03535900637507439, 0.03131779655814171, 0.012954190373420715, -0.027637284249067307, 0.02287112921476364, -0.020231468603014946, 0.02327411249279976, 0.04759759083390236, -0.04487420618534088, 0.0006227316916920245, -0.05224928632378578, 0.08498134464025497, 0.07072929292917252, -0.04525783658027649, 0.06924460828304291, 0.02978198230266571, -0.0254538394510746, -0.03508731722831726, 0.04015589505434036, -0.010992525145411491, -0.010578932240605354, -0.017563020810484886, 0.028822235763072968, 0.07996919751167297, 0.029646068811416626, 0.0483865924179554, 0.01160077378153801, -0.0431584008038044, -0.001661373651586473, -0.007303777616471052, 0.012613208964467049, -0.012575134634971619, -0.004981379956007004, -0.034709859639406204, 0.049720533192157745, 0.010955896228551865, 0.004715597722679377, -0.01074140053242445, 0.004995689261704683, 0.031665243208408356, 0.004793744999915361, -0.011606007814407349, -0.06458742916584015, -0.004738085437566042, -0.05396535247564316, 0.04725576937198639, -0.04970812425017357, 0.014961719512939453, -0.05478501319885254, -0.02291087992489338, -0.11087635159492493, 0.08997924625873566, -0.0489620715379715, 0.00897868163883686, -0.13362589478492737, -0.03036796860396862, -0.0527409091591835, 0.016556140035390854, -0.031151559203863144, -0.03421373292803764, -0.05207112431526184, 0.01093921810388565, -0.02245783433318138, 0.039958734065294266, 0.07206284999847412, -0.026733949780464172, -0.09872037917375565, 0.0020031933672726154, -0.07223840057849884, -0.0032274192199110985, 0.02420482411980629, 0.08505187928676605, 0.00839829072356224, 0.041529230773448944, 0.08158043026924133, -0.05168338492512703, 0.004818580113351345, 0.02574370987713337, -0.020432041957974434, 0.03262465447187424, -0.04108308628201485, 0.01173228770494461, 0.014484313316643238, 0.08541147410869598, 0.00896224845200777, 0.035930853337049484, 0.0166807658970356, 0.056747689843177795, -0.016833344474434853, 0.026884078979492188, 0.053288646042346954, 0.012858066707849503, 0.03006996586918831, -0.001193595235235989, 0.062237586826086044, -0.06384037435054779, -0.009167767129838467, 0.07158719003200531, -0.03969237953424454, 0.03284364193677902, -0.09368199110031128, 0.0016755672404542565, -0.008139273151755333, 0.010418900288641453, -0.07625061273574829, -0.04262988641858101, 0.03602944687008858, -0.006105367559939623, -0.025502506643533707, 0.006734151393175125, 0.005182366818189621, -0.038158975541591644, -0.05345294997096062, 0.002567037707194686, -0.03027789108455181, -0.04736752435564995, 0.015940507873892784, -0.004879065789282322, 0.004576109815388918, 0.047856081277132034, 0.01636209525167942, -0.07800659537315369, -0.12162645906209946, -0.005965246818959713, 0.006861398462206125, 0.016563866287469864, -0.08669053018093109, -0.03246020898222923, 0.010998131707310677, 0.012967940419912338, -0.05372297391295433, 0.020681679248809814, -0.017388932406902313, 0.03843126446008682, 0.06979600340127945, 0.0017455464694648981, 0.008744512684643269, -0.06392870098352432, 0.030329469591379166, 0.02268153801560402, 0.012046406045556068, -0.011729460209608078, 0.07673924416303635, -0.032315418124198914, 0.002370662521570921, 0.05593900382518768, -0.07996919751167297, 0.020525706931948662, -0.02846374735236168, -0.014014854095876217, -0.09037464112043381, 0.021193215623497963, -0.010873566381633282, 0.005207369104027748, 0.05063522979617119, -0.0018635914893820882, -0.04765663668513298, 0.009861196391284466, -0.08007753640413284, -0.03859357535839081, 0.02325683832168579, 0.03874102979898453, 0.04247066751122475, 0.028994889929890633, 0.012763859704136848, -0.018309621140360832, -0.0025909331161528826, -0.008813129737973213, -0.007561271544545889, 0.04363175854086876, -0.002443803008645773, 0.01413190457969904, 0.002557375468313694, -0.03288974240422249, 0.0012815314112231135, 0.0007675334927625954, 0.09510039538145065, -0.02099854126572609, 0.047820303589105606, -0.015433145686984062, 0.0261845625936985, 0.03684063255786896, -0.0214389581233263, 0.0021831707563251257, 0.019460970535874367, 0.04614711552858353, -0.07421249896287918, -0.02257554605603218, -0.021151352673768997, 0.020241959020495415, 0.005515038035809994, -0.049454789608716965, 0.034389544278383255, -0.031237563118338585, -0.024478070437908173, -0.07209710031747818, 0.04230783134698868, -0.009943448938429356, 0.002728958847001195, -0.01968659833073616, -0.020265046507120132, 0.015410147607326508, 0.004943692125380039, 0.04513522982597351, -0.10710075497627258, 0.0018708425341174006, -0.0032016730401664972, 0.025423726066946983, 0.024422379210591316, 0.014468622393906116, -0.021292518824338913, 0.0017393964808434248, 0.04047142341732979, 0.013635947369039059, 0.03561053425073624, 0.011557976715266705, -0.02196546643972397, 0.05030009150505066, -0.01860206015408039, 0.002875648206099868, 0.04122617840766907, 0.02197672799229622, 0.0039434172213077545, 0.11474207788705826, 0.039749376475811005, -0.03250209987163544, -0.005131451413035393, 0.06016893684864044, -0.02367602102458477, 0.04260604456067085 ]
222
222
Object Classification by means of Multi-Feature Concept Learning in a Multi Expert-Agent System
Classification of some objects in classes of concepts is an essential and even breathtaking task in many applications. A solution is discussed here based on Multi-Agent systems. A kernel of some expert agents in several classes is to consult a central agent decide among the classification problem of a certain object. This kernel is moderated with the center agent, trying to manage the querying agents for any decision problem by means of a data-header like feature set. Agents have cooperation among concepts related to the classes of this classification decision-making; and may affect on each others' results on a certain query object in a multi-agent learning approach. This leads to an online feature learning via the consulting trend. The performance is discussed to be much better in comparison to some other prior trends while system's message passing overload is decreased to less agents and the expertism helps the performance and operability of system win the comparison.
[ 0.030422672629356384, -0.05432477965950966, 0.01672181487083435, 0.035706475377082825, 0.03614132106304169, -0.14099673926830292, -0.08699408918619156, 0.006320426240563393, -0.058945972472429276, 0.006418543867766857, 0.05947130173444748, -0.0136836227029562, 0.020081520080566406, 0.042201168835163116, 0.00041134600178338587, -0.04424482583999634, 0.014592175371944904, -0.05305422842502594, -0.01335502602159977, -0.05202735960483551, 0.08863195776939392, -0.03424448519945145, 0.00489243445917964, 0.0020458451472222805, 0.010162059217691422, -0.0000042329988900746685, -0.09774841368198395, 0.028029946610331535, -0.04564270004630089, 0.03794065862894058, -0.05022738501429558, -0.014127806760370731, 0.0029844369273632765, 0.005487521644681692, 0.04363548010587692, -0.03732253238558769, 0.017976170405745506, -0.013900261372327805, -0.05305095762014389, 0.007605932652950287, 0.022599181160330772, -0.02332496829330921, -0.018993761390447617, 0.018398795276880264, -0.04274439066648483, -0.023740267381072044, 0.005842156708240509, 0.008669397793710232, -0.004276829771697521, 0.07328825443983078, -0.035636235028505325, -0.05519874021410942, -0.03174552693963051, 0.05536384880542755, -0.04901532083749771, 0.0024546319618821144, 0.005978571251034737, -0.046628523617982864, 0.00020062472322024405, -0.03922266885638237, 0.0384957380592823, 0.028376329690217972, -0.04348403587937355, 0.006888675037771463, 0.02807651087641716, 0.046058010309934616, -0.020145203918218613, -0.03397712856531143, 0.013535013422369957, -0.0052543990314006805, -0.00867514219135046, 0.005198873579502106, 0.0177441593259573, -0.04096934199333191, 0.050781216472387314, -0.0009390616905875504, 0.011797325685620308, 0.02131664752960205, -0.006058458238840103, 0.062112048268318176, -0.003704284317791462, -0.019591378048062325, -0.018097104504704475, -0.012676683254539967, 0.008574803359806538, -0.07130726426839828, 0.05831802636384964, 0.014767060056328773, 0.006027993746101856, 0.053651392459869385, 0.011388905346393585, 0.008500336669385433, -0.07748336344957352, 0.005367019679397345, 0.010693246498703957, -0.02368553914129734, -0.06778226047754288, -0.03607357665896416, 0.006777774542570114, -0.012941302731633186, 0.00462539354339242, -0.0006528887897729874, 0.04432601109147072, 0.07736479490995407, -0.04467006027698517, 0.012350206263363361, -0.017867743968963623, 0.08767478913068771, 0.03015780821442604, 0.030977245420217514, 0.002991844667121768, 0.043376922607421875, -0.0012616874882951379, 0.0787922665476799, -0.0017833667807281017, 0.033449236303567886, -0.028592990711331367, 0.10963878780603409, -0.007803285028785467, 0.005181136541068554, -0.037180569022893906, -0.0021710102446377277, -0.09645932912826538, 0.07932019978761673, 0.08000931888818741, -0.08665920794010162, -0.020180732011795044, -0.02181979827582836, 0.11267448216676712, 0.10371974855661392, -0.013660465367138386, 0.05802011862397194, -0.005436636973172426, -0.02390119805932045, 0.003644334152340889, -0.0020456251222640276, 0.018800389021635056, -0.06075407564640045, 0.03440987318754196, -0.04042594134807587, 0.02143225632607937, 0.03237419202923775, 0.02128414995968342, 0.0004943497478961945, 0.0733114629983902, -0.00822162814438343, -0.004951690789312124, 0.05362626910209656, 0.05314832553267479, 0.012510801665484905, -0.004956863354891539, -0.08542370796203613, 0.013688155449926853, 0.03180530667304993, -0.003739606123417616, -0.03606139495968819, -0.04653674736618996, -0.042778730392456055, 0.02273639291524887, 0.07726377993822098, 0.01838034763932228, 0.04352792724967003, -0.029801473021507263, 0.0008047412266023457, 0.04407956451177597, 0.07704895734786987, -0.0820678323507309, -0.03879781812429428, -0.002037379192188382, -0.06897421181201935, -0.04890831932425499, 0.0176562387496233, -0.05851598083972931, 0.014354855753481388, -0.0535464845597744, -0.033062998205423355, -0.013708194717764854, 0.004195560701191425, -0.02086191438138485, -0.0037993215955793858, 0.00675776693969965, -0.07626178115606308, -0.048542335629463196, -0.04487324506044388, 0.037370774894952774, 0.07247628271579742, 0.05897962301969528, 0.06568080931901932, 0.04248747602105141, -0.024491840973496437, 0.009472912177443504, 0.013858363963663578, 0.03035103529691696, -0.03163633495569229, -0.03929223120212555, 0.06421632319688797, -0.02690301276743412, 0.01042289100587368, 0.01948472112417221, 0.01591137796640396, 0.017448585480451584, -0.009234044700860977, 0.07089037448167801, -0.05216575041413307, -0.07947401702404022, 0.03639319911599159, 0.06516244262456894, 0.005931565072387457, 0.02724047191441059, -0.029112355783581734, 0.056412335485219955, 0.013191083446145058, -0.013367206789553165, 0.01433450635522604, -0.04894717037677765, -0.0434415303170681, -0.026800790801644325, -0.04901975020766258, -0.0479961596429348, 0.030514609068632126, -0.012700033374130726, -0.02499448135495186, 0.00046617083717137575, -0.011918767355382442, -0.02363639883697033, -0.005858262535184622, 0.02420227602124214, -0.08286397904157639, -0.07110803574323654, 0.038118328899145126, -0.04845859482884407, -0.061978016048669815, -0.08205918967723846, -0.027653038501739502, 0.08185604959726334, 0.03079710155725479, -0.027370117604732513, -0.008298076689243317, -0.04632047563791275, -0.0423952117562294, 0.006405480206012726, 0.011692828498780727, -0.02856915257871151, -0.05120968818664551, 0.02869473397731781, -0.03448580205440521, -0.0067252847366034985, 0.018209369853138924, -0.06428007781505585, 0.01186377927660942, -0.000017687887520878576, -0.015310919843614101, 0.02391485683619976, 0.011895611882209778, 0.01961115002632141, 0.07058146595954895, 0.019935159012675285, 0.07864176481962204, 0.10156947374343872, 0.084694504737854, 0.007372631225734949, -0.022594021633267403, 0.019936561584472656, -0.03548566624522209, -0.013079674914479256, -0.019819851964712143, 0.04008758068084717, 0.08319846540689468, -0.00464403023943305, -0.009418315254151821, -0.07014381885528564, -0.09172023832798004, -0.04251870885491371, 0.08994114398956299, -0.03471532091498375, 0.04085448756814003, -0.11058343201875687, 0.022358378395438194, 0.024416564032435417, -0.07992878556251526, -0.005663990043103695, 0.014146995730698109, 0.00019171598250977695, 0.0059479898773133755, -0.05134856700897217, -0.0003732490004040301, 0.059597354382276535, -0.017843710258603096, -0.005459343083202839, 0.002449705032631755, -0.06481028348207474, 0.022276686504483223, -0.0633210837841034, 0.03966972976922989, 0.049322083592414856, -0.04932752624154091, 0.036012254655361176, 0.0809035450220108, 0.048471830785274506, -0.0413675419986248, -0.029466111212968826, 0.021315481513738632, 0.07751182466745377, 0.07920683175325394, 0.05265608802437782, 0.09493234753608704, 0.01018969900906086, 0.026713300496339798, -0.05622248724102974, -0.06181256100535393, 0.003495355835184455, -0.003630358260124922, 0.0037966654635965824, 0.03882240876555443, 0.04106081277132034, 0.058600906282663345, -0.0634201318025589, 0.021788431331515312, -0.03175381198525429, 0.08030474931001663, 0.0020304087083786726, -0.0938982218503952, 0.0012587233213707805, 0.0010507017141208053, -0.07063431292772293, 0.016636325046420097, -0.010699957609176636, -0.005347767844796181, -0.08264878392219543, 0.029402583837509155, -0.10226580500602722, 0.006598068401217461, 0.03715083748102188, 0.06612294912338257, -0.024561144411563873, -0.030008146539330482, 0.005717418156564236, -0.015507297590374947, 0.0496053472161293, 0.010725426487624645, -0.09428875148296356, -0.06356854736804962, -0.037646207958459854, -0.005487446207553148, 0.02285790629684925, 0.006886392366141081, 0.06284936517477036, 0.035434674471616745, -0.06757308542728424, 0.03202541172504425, -0.006939138285815716, 0.05088713765144348, -0.10527414083480835, 0.0025069855619221926, -0.03642259165644646, -0.053209736943244934, 0.03753146529197693, 0.03325430303812027, -0.036647409200668335, -0.02665865048766136, 0.021879184991121292, 0.02784779854118824, -0.08883518725633621, 0.0222928524017334, 0.00396083015948534, 0.026474233716726303, -0.04806233197450638, 0.10452166944742203, -0.037389133125543594, -0.0662347599864006, 0.0512414276599884, 0.013974430039525032, -0.04904382675886154, -0.03249610587954521, -0.005789986811578274, -0.06687214225530624, -0.0005529894842766225, -0.0172632597386837, 0.06949630379676819, 0.06033055856823921, -0.03887424245476723, 0.03113744407892227, -0.09300485998392105, 0.005259954836219549, -0.01150994561612606, -0.027955416589975357, -0.03436119481921196, 0.040429890155792236, 0.07596555352210999, -0.017086056992411613, -0.041593536734580994, -0.010201295837759972, -0.05708516389131546, 0.05764734745025635, 0.024002496153116226, 0.006679013837128878, 0.0052987318485975266, 0.03613799065351486, -0.008085891604423523, 0.05182972550392151, 0.004645500332117081, -0.02949630655348301, -0.06860551238059998, -0.0638091117143631, -0.04098106548190117, 0.07387150079011917, 0.002997265662997961, 0.08709879219532013, -0.0026119600515812635, 0.03363819420337677, 0.08415915071964264, 0.005762774497270584, 0.00016360756126232445, -0.07515324652194977, -0.005305230617523193, 0.02342594601213932, -0.025003310292959213, -0.04044019430875778, -0.06573911011219025, -0.08763028681278229, -0.03357752785086632, 0.06309103965759277, 0.02647974155843258, 0.01669447310268879, 0.008236811496317387, 0.016226770356297493, 0.07537441700696945, -0.035102229565382004, 0.025788817554712296, 0.0499194972217083, -0.031109798699617386, 0.04560321569442749, -0.080000139772892, -0.01798967458307743, 0.03435729816555977, 0.07543788105249405, 0.038002122193574905, 0.001281162491068244, 0.046496644616127014, 0.012174763716757298, -0.028304962441325188, 0.029881387948989868, 0.0561678484082222, 0.0041828453540802, 0.037336066365242004, -0.0058397892862558365, -0.0786127969622612, 0.02586062252521515, 0.06117108836770058, 0.03488729149103165, -0.03401389718055725, -0.01109050028026104, 0.06432361900806427, -0.05582968145608902, 0.018230553716421127, -0.06744702160358429, -0.05586970970034599, -0.03144865483045578, 0.022833077237010002, -0.08307808637619019, -0.015861360356211662, 0.019608525559306145, 0.020708493888378143, 0.04267042502760887, -0.04520917311310768, 0.013038327917456627, 0.05833599343895912, 0.023836316540837288, 0.04126911610364914, 0.018080854788422585, -0.07549770176410675, -0.03895685821771622, 0.008312040939927101, 0.007524015381932259, 0.005291393026709557, -0.01926441863179207, -0.043039724230766296, -0.028568509966135025, -0.08985190838575363, -0.05341304838657379, 0.053529344499111176, 0.04684333875775337, -0.010018784552812576, 0.02371286042034626, 0.02520724944770336, 0.013851012103259563, 0.007578396238386631, 0.042963601648807526, -0.02260615862905979, 0.021323516964912415, -0.07797136902809143, -0.0033145893830806017, -0.015106995590031147, 0.01567993126809597, -0.029596654698252678, -0.031237514689564705, 0.04903484508395195, -0.02236873283982277, 0.010493733920156956, 0.0011425587581470609, 0.03252990171313286, -0.017975149676203728, -0.006085340864956379, 0.01822633668780327, 0.07219444215297699, 0.009832457639276981, 0.05648284777998924, -0.017568327486515045, 0.030855344608426094, 0.029187224805355072, -0.03061400167644024, 0.013432817533612251 ]
223
223
Error-Correcting Tournaments
We present a family of pairwise tournaments reducing $k$-class classification to binary classification. These reductions are provably robust against a constant fraction of binary errors. The results improve on the PECOC construction \cite{SECOC} with an exponential improvement in computation, from $O(k)$ to $O(\log_2 k)$, and the removal of a square root in the regret dependence, matching the best possible computation and regret up to a constant.
[ -0.03984024003148079, -0.038068052381277084, 0.015417204238474369, 0.01837192289531231, -0.040618836879730225, -0.07847803086042404, -0.0053833541460335255, 0.03336342051625252, -0.0653902143239975, -0.057956792414188385, -0.027303257957100868, -0.035085733979940414, -0.03556136041879654, 0.0020907397847622633, 0.02242489717900753, 0.011742095462977886, -0.028143445029854774, -0.04571884125471115, 0.01902152970433235, -0.0662400871515274, 0.08029478043317795, -0.010623833164572716, -0.0074090901762247086, -0.016734354197978973, 0.01960599608719349, -0.014292487874627113, -0.006387750152498484, 0.0501653328537941, -0.027036292478442192, 0.016028041020035744, -0.065941721200943, -0.015301831997931004, 0.013899167068302631, 0.017671076580882072, 0.0033533612731844187, -0.05680748447775841, 0.006585775408893824, -0.07215987145900726, -0.005763242021203041, 0.00350101082585752, -0.03708282485604286, 0.02523493394255638, 0.0024674762971699238, -0.026832083240151405, 0.07107827067375183, 0.03079885058104992, 0.07741962373256683, -0.010900166817009449, -0.028461961075663567, 0.040903106331825256, -0.11217433959245682, 0.015733376145362854, 0.002833839738741517, -0.059382226318120956, -0.013730633072555065, -0.037866927683353424, -0.07203464955091476, -0.009734406135976315, -0.0593985915184021, 0.011294860392808914, 0.05323989689350128, 0.05994681268930435, -0.007343549281358719, -0.04537798836827278, -0.04783113673329353, -0.041479580104351044, -0.011609881184995174, -0.07603230327367783, -0.013831467367708683, 0.015708057209849358, 0.03625937178730965, -0.07367302477359772, 0.02007603831589222, 0.061862558126449585, -0.005170554853975773, 0.022460367530584335, 0.06399907171726227, 0.02163940668106079, -0.002914171665906906, 0.05106886476278305, -0.06301587074995041, 0.01650691032409668, -0.06862013041973114, 0.03840062394738197, -0.04077215865254402, -0.019979732111096382, 0.03202085569500923, -0.04487498849630356, 0.00882651749998331, -0.01627306081354618, -0.03226739913225174, -0.04165152460336685, -0.06508395820856094, 0.04705777391791344, -0.07621843367815018, 0.06053686514496803, -0.03219018131494522, -0.002965352963656187, 0.02525860257446766, 0.06730607151985168, 0.04692167416214943, 0.01887514442205429, 0.015865502879023552, 0.08986568450927734, -0.0445132777094841, 0.0372285321354866, -0.012587882578372955, 0.08026181906461716, 0.009340533055365086, -0.03781350329518318, 0.06161988154053688, -0.0548149049282074, 0.022699499502778053, -0.00875563733279705, 0.0026188138872385025, 0.018961232155561447, -0.00964905135333538, 0.02557375840842724, -0.010161035694181919, 0.032925087958574295, 0.04033628851175308, 0.0023721749894320965, -0.014088631607592106, 0.04784078523516655, 0.029705407097935677, -0.0689990222454071, -0.06031067296862602, -0.050246018916368484, 0.052835188806056976, 0.013528112322092056, -0.0621948204934597, 0.10388816148042679, -0.10347253084182739, 0.0028166952542960644, -0.056703582406044006, 0.06670497357845306, 0.05960173159837723, -0.06000512093305588, -0.0020653554238379, 0.08244159817695618, -0.02877969481050968, 0.0325838066637516, -0.020837794989347458, 0.02010427415370941, 0.0328294113278389, 0.018896393477916718, 0.033413249999284744, -0.006863012444227934, 0.021813036873936653, 0.049528222531080246, -0.08014582842588425, 0.018210643902420998, 0.0017756286542862654, 0.08404671400785446, 0.02321152202785015, 0.00922259222716093, -0.03564155474305153, -0.0159103162586689, -0.0031701833941042423, 0.11769357323646545, -0.0008078301907517016, -0.06897144764661789, 0.03255525603890419, 0.06431523710489273, 0.0028278841637074947, 0.04631815105676651, 0.036795131862163544, 0.058259449899196625, 0.01183301955461502, -0.03507689759135246, 0.005224916152656078, 0.05465283617377281, -0.05052211135625839, 0.022214656695723534, -0.03299327567219734, -0.023844219744205475, 0.030203916132450104, 0.03002936951816082, -0.05665625259280205, -0.03184410184621811, 0.07312731444835663, -0.10178402811288834, -0.0031618454959243536, 0.07148329168558121, 0.08040209859609604, 0.0690484568476677, 0.06517542153596878, 0.060932707041502, 0.04092798009514809, 0.08426287770271301, 0.0006222895462997258, 0.0034949674736708403, -0.037581078708171844, -0.022550415247678757, -0.003952619154006243, -0.04498417675495148, -0.0014466049615293741, 0.01645258627831936, 0.017550013959407806, 0.07427796721458435, 0.030409999191761017, -0.013291755691170692, -0.08999014645814896, -0.046960726380348206, -0.06754843890666962, 0.016527099534869194, 0.08745896816253662, -0.011003408581018448, -0.00269799935631454, -0.026061344891786575, 0.026248008012771606, 0.038012128323316574, -0.011032268404960632, 0.04386074095964432, -0.04626074060797691, -0.037257079035043716, -0.07114782929420471, -0.03432494401931763, 0.059817276895046234, 0.04354983940720558, -0.010381235741078854, 0.03259321674704552, -0.040039367973804474, 0.00942027848213911, -0.09020813554525375, -0.014447083696722984, 0.01662987470626831, 0.04917551949620247, -0.0925336480140686, 0.03434489667415619, 0.02062925323843956, -0.002226761309430003, -0.04967928305268288, -0.006256056018173695, -0.04336433857679367, 0.08812520653009415, -0.025759894400835037, -0.016130438074469566, -0.032115016132593155, -0.05507638305425644, -0.024321096017956734, 0.032435834407806396, 0.008236700668931007, -0.029312863945961, 0.032427143305540085, -0.07557094097137451, 0.07980630546808243, 0.03572233393788338, -0.046974241733551025, -0.00005100317866890691, -0.029996898025274277, -0.039444953203201294, 0.0565330795943737, -0.04518374055624008, 0.06999194622039795, -0.030189136043190956, 0.024468638002872467, 0.10999924689531326, 0.03728281334042549, 0.009472922421991825, 0.02665279246866703, 0.019900690764188766, -0.01843397691845894, -0.06750798225402832, 0.018906284123659134, 0.02518092468380928, -0.0639265850186348, -0.04024853557348251, 0.024107474833726883, -0.003487859619781375, -0.04024822264909744, -0.09733718633651733, -0.031432170420885086, 0.06203111261129379, -0.055554021149873734, -0.005570176523178816, 0.021775702014565468, -0.006160722579807043, -0.030057821422815323, -0.02027755044400692, -0.05248578265309334, 0.07902024686336517, 0.02075887843966484, 0.032221321016550064, -0.0012907787458971143, -0.027542145922780037, -0.007342504803091288, -0.00006412497896235436, 0.02791357785463333, 0.028404943645000458, -0.09094639867544174, 0.026453739032149315, -0.045658573508262634, -0.05282452702522278, 0.1294802725315094, -0.0074763004668056965, -0.013775856234133244, 0.06660788506269455, 0.06759826838970184, 0.035874828696250916, 0.030812988057732582, 0.048797544091939926, 0.04102467745542526, 0.07596052438020706, 0.04638954624533653, 0.10371328145265579, 0.01829131692647934, 0.02328031323850155, 0.04622574895620346, -0.022884298115968704, 0.011012429371476173, -0.061022140085697174, 0.009613454341888428, -0.006444422993808985, -0.04171060398221016, -0.013496803119778633, 0.06438355892896652, 0.003041249932721257, -0.05560174211859703, 0.038354985415935516, -0.031216004863381386, 0.011064843274652958, 0.030119797214865685, 0.010168967768549919, -0.07745996117591858, -0.008756925351917744, -0.037350259721279144, 0.04329583793878555, -0.16361944377422333, 0.020787738263607025, -0.046598900109529495, -0.023864751681685448, 0.038597941398620605, 0.040963441133499146, -0.045234858989715576, 0.031829655170440674, -0.027915453538298607, 0.006975114345550537, 0.047462478280067444, 0.03793824091553688, -0.052241820842027664, -0.06573641300201416, -0.036821044981479645, -0.033129092305898666, 0.045909732580184937, 0.054079458117485046, 0.051650822162628174, 0.027450956404209137, 0.02384425885975361, 0.02128567360341549, -0.05139683187007904, 0.01770825684070587, -0.07569077610969543, 0.08255477249622345, 0.0043981256894767284, 0.06287920475006104, 0.05552547797560692, -0.014304322190582752, 0.001390598132275045, -0.0021568515803664923, -0.0007613766938447952, -0.031760647892951965, 0.0012878301786258817, 0.010136407800018787, 0.050452373921871185, 0.0750034973025322, -0.005646355915814638, -0.017580866813659668, 0.04693065583705902, -0.0010104565881192684, -0.015427757985889912, 0.014874815009534359, 0.02341100573539734, 0.02723667211830616, 0.027774784713983536, -0.05703127756714821, 0.018935486674308777, -0.028319338336586952, 0.010604599490761757, 0.07453805953264236, -0.04621700197458267, 0.019771823659539223, -0.0132016995921731, -0.028970234096050262, 0.018948892131447792, -0.0708811804652214, -0.009620069526135921, -0.031551167368888855, 0.0780286118388176, 0.003889314364641905, -0.00013142300304025412, -0.03217105194926262, 0.007901215925812721, 0.01577761396765709, 0.007049373351037502, -0.06531187146902084, 0.032041244208812714, 0.000055025633628247306, -0.013462253846228123, -0.05772005394101143, -0.0010626703733578324, -0.11557289212942123, -0.02491774782538414, -0.009325722232460976, -0.09254022687673569, 0.03357571363449097, -0.01580260880291462, 0.07624420523643494, -0.04412677139043808, -0.014588529244065285, -0.007469426840543747, 0.05578169971704483, -0.020447412505745888, 0.035324230790138245, 0.027158020064234734, 0.034733086824417114, 0.0396108403801918, -0.01380670815706253, -0.026913177222013474, -0.04278018698096275, 0.02385605126619339, 0.04872693493962288, -0.005942045710980892, -0.039310719817876816, -0.05152133107185364, 0.0632820576429367, 0.017531132325530052, 0.012698228470981121, -0.003771159565076232, 0.021262701600790024, -0.061244115233421326, 0.01190088503062725, -0.06370913982391357, -0.00158241530880332, 0.04209831729531288, 0.02054709382355213, 0.0025553919840604067, 0.008345658890902996, -0.013429691083729267, -0.007164266891777515, -0.0915144607424736, -0.02390432171523571, 0.005242704413831234, 0.03198941797018051, 0.009322880767285824, 0.010830423794686794, 0.03125626593828201, 0.003440159372985363, 0.05134949833154678, 0.05012574791908264, 0.06786812096834183, 0.0136564327403903, 0.023302670568227768, -0.031573835760354996, -0.048202455043792725, -0.031805988401174545, 0.02761099673807621, 0.012621372938156128, -0.012850637547671795, -0.033672213554382324, -0.019385620951652527, -0.05818236246705055, -0.02367003634572029, -0.021769139915704727, -0.015364921651780605, -0.015449081547558308, 0.029173467308282852, -0.028220145031809807, 0.04017800837755203, -0.0026488066650927067, -0.021874435245990753, -0.008561504073441029, 0.028408827260136604, -0.026021618396043777, 0.010385589674115181, -0.03736744448542595, -0.053255848586559296, -0.0013331377413123846, 0.01407301239669323, -0.02988055907189846, -0.018473606556653976, -0.03933586925268173, -0.08993476629257202, 0.021991893649101257, 0.09904254227876663, -0.09622862190008163, -0.03713738173246384, 0.036398693919181824, -0.05062936246395111, 0.017691580578684807, 0.0037395169492810965, 0.03229131922125816, 0.038132961839437485, -0.044220127165317535, 0.03818864747881889, 0.001389363082125783, 0.09796507656574249, 0.07748609036207199, -0.02996058017015457, 0.06602013856172562, -0.03005719557404518, -0.037229664623737335, 0.04848804697394371, 0.005008035805076361, 0.02916010096669197, 0.0647352933883667, -0.004266224801540375, -0.03509499132633209, 0.034561507403850555, 0.012867098674178123, 0.006650915835052729, -0.05561994016170502 ]
224
224
An Exact Algorithm for the Stratification Problem with Proportional Allocation
We report a new optimal resolution for the statistical stratification problem under proportional sampling allocation among strata. Consider a finite population of N units, a random sample of n units selected from this population and a number L of strata. Thus, we have to define which units belong to each stratum so as to minimize the variance of a total estimator for one desired variable of interest in each stratum,and consequently reduce the overall variance for such quantity. In order to solve this problem, an exact algorithm based on the concept of minimal path in a graph is proposed and assessed. Computational results using real data from IBGE (Brazilian Central Statistical Office) are provided.
[ 0.045599788427352905, -0.06749968230724335, -0.03791073337197304, -0.0036023466382175684, 0.035730794072151184, -0.0518709272146225, 0.05636047199368477, -0.005306119564920664, -0.05764944851398468, 0.01662754826247692, 0.0023363721556961536, -0.016465969383716583, -0.07145075500011444, 0.03915812447667122, 0.0005863402038812637, -0.01721145212650299, -0.0545090027153492, 0.04327930510044098, 0.022117821499705315, -0.042297158390283585, -0.027375439181923866, 0.016963016241788864, 0.0009341060067526996, -0.017513994127511978, 0.006384825333952904, -0.02060547098517418, -0.021556317806243896, 0.023153144866228104, -0.05303826183080673, 0.021878737956285477, -0.06952083855867386, 0.02669353596866131, -0.026672612875699997, 0.07255175709724426, 0.042771924287080765, -0.039766985923051834, -0.015453146770596504, 0.0018621502676978707, -0.059479717165231705, -0.015787653625011444, 0.01874847151339054, -0.014487219043076038, 0.08534839749336243, -0.008357592858374119, 0.03047710843384266, -0.01179968286305666, 0.03132428973913193, -0.02664007619023323, -0.03409137204289436, -0.03273572400212288, -0.035455696284770966, 0.045213840901851654, -0.05662162974476814, -0.0640440359711647, 0.02076789177954197, 0.006053912919014692, -0.047940678894519806, -0.012230661697685719, -0.003167333547025919, -0.026675084605813026, 0.02192491665482521, 0.09151121228933334, 0.015845300629734993, -0.04185887798666954, -0.007095973938703537, 0.020103901624679565, 0.048294566571712494, -0.03517482429742813, -0.043814290314912796, 0.05400025472044945, 0.06657371670007706, 0.024456612765789032, -0.04180443286895752, 0.07858432084321976, -0.0002207330398960039, -0.038382258266210556, 0.056949183344841, -0.021536091342568398, 0.02635842189192772, 0.035123538225889206, -0.03717201203107834, -0.020236020907759666, -0.020813288167119026, -0.013755791820585728, -0.07286333292722702, 0.027192043140530586, 0.010198377072811127, 0.033112213015556335, 0.043275438249111176, -0.0058280350640416145, -0.06318829953670502, 0.024463579058647156, -0.022671537473797798, 0.026939326897263527, -0.07113401591777802, 0.07978131622076035, -0.0847594290971756, 0.012587298639118671, 0.05209096521139145, 0.03877837583422661, -0.00018621045455802232, -0.06710239499807358, 0.03498559817671776, 0.06076185777783394, -0.022526070475578308, 0.03480718284845352, -0.04293367266654968, 0.07090144604444504, 0.009497529827058315, -0.014992906711995602, 0.009592204354703426, -0.003735366277396679, 0.05400650203227997, 0.009669560939073563, -0.01950799860060215, 0.035686615854501724, 0.035925716161727905, 0.038182687014341354, -0.0022817496210336685, -0.05525500327348709, -0.001175080076791346, 0.003992293495684862, 0.037145551294088364, 0.003624823410063982, -0.024579253047704697, 0.03514735773205757, 0.06971520185470581, -0.06879846751689911, 0.045463498681783676, 0.06201155483722687, 0.024094585329294205, 0.027760088443756104, -0.027564674615859985, 0.03862513601779938, -0.047314681112766266, 0.033805374056100845, 0.025576703250408173, -0.009911241941154003, 0.05709957331418991, 0.026869146153330803, 0.025353096425533295, -0.04383696988224983, -0.028866572305560112, -0.004227145574986935, 0.030327610671520233, 0.057187385857105255, -0.010975216515362263, 0.07502254843711853, -0.061491385102272034, 0.0693458616733551, -0.010995563119649887, -0.057120900601148605, 0.05411992222070694, -0.025499356910586357, 0.09198904037475586, -0.04391093924641609, 0.025176402181386948, -0.028790336102247238, 0.02207392454147339, 0.04907233268022537, -0.019385017454624176, 0.036701660603284836, 0.03491304814815521, -0.008152354508638382, -0.005605143960565329, -0.052408616989851, 0.02347283810377121, 0.010492824018001556, 0.0033576947171241045, -0.00861653033643961, 0.0025090838316828012, -0.02786319889128208, -0.06865786761045456, 0.03739460930228233, 0.020134693011641502, 0.022835806012153625, 0.04329470917582512, -0.03042835183441639, -0.01476252544671297, -0.038271743804216385, 0.10605251789093018, -0.030331475660204887, 0.006615100894123316, 0.011666440404951572, 0.010637258179485798, 0.07656270265579224, -0.03014879859983921, 0.017628910019993782, 0.04721805453300476, 0.05323603376746178, -0.021890586242079735, 0.0006771648186258972, 0.08320556581020355, 0.03826988488435745, -0.046910110861063004, 0.01663747988641262, 0.0021907417103648186, -0.016770174726843834, 0.0963943675160408, -0.0036604036577045918, 0.06393580883741379, 0.007714104373008013, -0.02300291880965233, 0.023719951510429382, -0.07076942175626755, 0.010233216919004917, 0.02657722309231758, -0.07758801430463791, -0.004733658395707607, 0.0067889695055782795, -0.04317326471209526, -0.011135819368064404, -0.000226491509238258, -0.061786070466041565, 0.07446854561567307, -0.026677653193473816, 0.03489050641655922, -0.07645242661237717, -0.05146407335996628, 0.024306785315275192, 0.0051109520718455315, 0.006408099550753832, 0.002946445718407631, -0.023556292057037354, -0.054839037358760834, 0.01301360223442316, 0.06065871939063072, 0.039952781051397324, -0.05868793651461601, 0.03813626244664192, 0.0919354185461998, -0.01909598708152771, 0.04015626013278961, 0.025639886036515236, -0.03880557045340538, 0.036665864288806915, 0.0022194681223481894, -0.032519906759262085, 0.03811970353126526, -0.04309023544192314, -0.04125174507498741, 0.1056760773062706, -0.02900163270533085, -0.03452811390161514, -0.02765040099620819, 0.0014677499420940876, 0.014723735861480236, 0.037441790103912354, -0.1005924642086029, 0.04741346836090088, 0.008248467929661274, -0.015550585463643074, 0.0018011839129030704, 0.01376462820917368, 0.010505279526114464, -0.03835620731115341, -0.013970177620649338, 0.06936192512512207, 0.06627063453197479, 0.10624442249536514, 0.028460288420319557, 0.03183247148990631, -0.03411022201180458, 0.010650034062564373, 0.028942186385393143, 0.06539196521043777, 0.0051934258081018925, 0.04290954768657684, -0.011555415578186512, -0.07380667328834534, 0.016292575746774673, -0.019701549783349037, -0.03360482305288315, 0.031291134655475616, -0.07860110700130463, 0.06105778366327286, 0.03464429825544357, 0.04487669840455055, 0.03359430283308029, 0.0531151220202446, -0.04295705631375313, 0.039347823709249496, 0.04817049950361252, -0.010527649894356728, -0.04445032402873039, 0.042432427406311035, 0.054949790239334106, 0.032823674380779266, -0.030386479571461678, 0.03564881533384323, -0.062127191573381424, 0.022941002622246742, -0.050690822303295135, -0.029311101883649826, -0.0028564671520143747, -0.06325989961624146, -0.046573009341955185, -0.018434077501296997, 0.09764488786458969, 0.03916831314563751, 0.020692743360996246, 0.019113147631287575, 0.007021000608801842, 0.022589141502976418, -0.035197995603084564, 0.04931385815143585, 0.0675245076417923, -0.01875140517950058, -0.09172564744949341, -0.017864178866147995, 0.0710393413901329, 0.03967219963669777, -0.1038827896118164, -0.022395066916942596, 0.024998268112540245, -0.06139150634407997, -0.06743424385786057, -0.028423599898815155, -0.04981150105595589, 0.007189036346971989, 0.00414130138233304, 0.06512218713760376, 0.07396110147237778, -0.025090176612138748, -0.07628925889730453, 0.015421480871737003, -0.03434612601995468, 0.014502203091979027, -0.032212257385253906, 0.04488349333405495, -0.05734584853053093, 0.026769060641527176, 0.007563897408545017, 0.08156963437795639, 0.005226601380854845, 0.03320079669356346, -0.06735614687204361, -0.013810703530907631, -0.029951663687825203, -0.059167880564928055, -0.012960964813828468, -0.08835998922586441, -0.01974373869597912, -0.0013760129222646356, 0.04023756459355354, 0.09211839735507965, 0.052764687687158585, 0.010422439314424992, 0.061622291803359985, -0.045112114399671555, -0.04939741641283035, -0.08413476496934891, -0.04487351328134537, 0.09530059248209, -0.010117271915078163, 0.053236257284879684, 0.08744622766971588, 0.011184603907167912, -0.006056257989257574, 0.01654004119336605, -0.08832955360412598, -0.034912191331386566, 0.008051269687712193, -0.013948110863566399, 0.017286138609051704, 0.031489234417676926, -0.04365766793489456, 0.03313509002327919, -0.07670006155967712, 0.003171168500557542, 0.05554461106657982, 0.04279834404587746, -0.04401909559965134, 0.03778715804219246, 0.03369021788239479, -0.008048794232308865, 0.0814504325389862, -0.07605693489313126, -0.0623282752931118, 0.02747992053627968, 0.023121746256947517, 0.032677799463272095, 0.009252309799194336, 0.032084010541439056, 0.07537207752466202, -0.042314618825912476, 0.029234176501631737, -0.020272741094231606, 0.061279311776161194, -0.007072639651596546, 0.04884794354438782, -0.04000145569443703, 0.03261473402380943, 0.011308192275464535, 0.06714342534542084, 0.08481999486684799, 0.027475669980049133, -0.038524311035871506, -0.06415750086307526, 0.03704957664012909, 0.012368272989988327, 0.016555147245526314, 0.05036685988306999, -0.09385711699724197, -0.06954383850097656, -0.021949347108602524, 0.022014964371919632, 0.0201120525598526, -0.057677917182445526, 0.01599002070724964, -0.007331132423132658, 0.07628728449344635, -0.06572092324495316, 0.029474396258592606, -0.01428962592035532, -0.007351648528128862, 0.0031836675480008125, 0.025735104456543922, -0.03296723961830139, 0.004650137387216091, 0.0655762106180191, -0.07572171837091446, -0.005460141692310572, -0.05207813158631325, 0.02292049489915371, -0.05888383090496063, -0.005113265477120876, 0.09357185661792755, -0.03320804238319397, 0.03868875280022621, -0.07971987873315811, -0.03563695400953293, -0.06292036175727844, 0.02269713766872883, -0.010766981169581413, 0.005568639375269413, -0.057785116136074066, -0.06346990168094635, 0.0015674881869927049, 0.0777350440621376, -0.04274753853678703, 0.04795796051621437, -0.05909143388271332, -0.01755959540605545, -0.04862440377473831, 0.032739635556936264, 0.06327065825462341, 0.0281318761408329, 0.07417397946119308, 0.015331841073930264, -0.07931894809007645, 0.028790505602955818, 0.048092931509017944, -0.060642074793577194, -0.04194661229848862, 0.010086268186569214, 0.022535251453518867, 0.0062760706059634686, 0.0196456927806139, -0.026853812858462334, -0.009191771037876606, -0.05475279688835144, -0.06931392848491669, -0.03289489448070526, -0.049139901995658875, -0.0053839171305298805, 0.01146421767771244, 0.07690250128507614, 0.029893435537815094, 0.019155943766236305, 0.0026258050929754972, 0.04454541951417923, -0.034639954566955566, 0.04705974459648132, -0.04269720986485481, -0.0020444148685783148, 0.042118050158023834, 0.0033331287559121847, -0.019413448870182037, -0.010172258131206036, -0.014265315607190132, 0.027743952348828316, 0.00823399517685175, 0.003357980400323868, 0.10683123767375946, -0.017230337485671043, 0.0019917739555239677, 0.0251338891685009, 0.06680165976285934, -0.04545896127820015, -0.0453118160367012, -0.0005872756009921432, -0.016089392825961113, 0.0032504419796168804, -0.04567525163292885, 0.06517618149518967, 0.037412986159324646, 0.0006219568313099444, 0.03269286826252937, 0.024097537621855736, 0.05041368305683136, -0.11767072975635529, 0.09160828590393066, -0.01194822508841753, 0.027509890496730804, 0.029307745397090912, 0.0586768239736557, -0.03077392280101776, -0.10697895288467407, 0.017644662410020828, 0.021902404725551605, -0.02428608015179634 ]
225
225
Learning rules from multisource data for cardiac monitoring
This paper formalises the concept of learning symbolic rules from multisource data in a cardiac monitoring context. Our sources, electrocardiograms and arterial blood pressure measures, describe cardiac behaviours from different viewpoints. To learn interpretable rules, we use an Inductive Logic Programming (ILP) method. We develop an original strategy to cope with the dimensionality issues caused by using this ILP technique on a rich multisource language. The results show that our method greatly improves the feasibility and the efficiency of the process while staying accurate. They also confirm the benefits of using multiple sources to improve the diagnosis of cardiac arrhythmias.
[ -0.03847361356019974, -0.07960480451583862, 0.0477280430495739, 0.001304798061028123, 0.02426467277109623, -0.09678375720977783, -0.0637294203042984, -0.047110166400671005, -0.06109488755464554, 0.023193234577775, -0.010795882903039455, -0.029459601268172264, 0.05798725038766861, -0.018181582912802696, 0.01872239075601101, 0.024252723902463913, 0.01082558836787939, 0.013452611863613129, 0.023292003199458122, -0.05201250687241554, 0.01657765731215477, 0.004434424452483654, 0.02234043926000595, -0.10587000101804733, 0.051730502396821976, 0.004205693956464529, -0.03092583827674389, -0.045005910098552704, 0.0526459775865078, -0.06128932163119316, -0.0444130077958107, -0.016355691477656364, 0.04954236000776291, -0.00860383827239275, 0.03707479313015938, 0.05413126200437546, 0.03179668262600899, -0.010256321169435978, -0.05427155643701553, 0.06617772579193115, -0.00812736339867115, -0.059771377593278885, 0.05698375403881073, -0.027362538501620293, -0.01925041899085045, 0.0328272245824337, 0.010855058208107948, -0.06455385684967041, -0.0006763935671187937, 0.08485671877861023, -0.12833914160728455, 0.04776295647025108, 0.022963853552937508, 0.002027970738708973, -0.01768091320991516, -0.014736802317202091, -0.014987822622060776, 0.02897956222295761, -0.08959363400936127, -0.016911538317799568, -0.09971120208501816, 0.14729484915733337, 0.04744504764676094, -0.05396728217601776, -0.012210618704557419, 0.0186361875385046, -0.07105015963315964, 0.0029583366122096777, -0.11144043505191803, -0.004537736997008324, -0.023990781977772713, -0.01660781353712082, 0.00938557367771864, -0.03185467794537544, 0.016508927568793297, 0.08075746893882751, 0.008350352756679058, -0.029375873506069183, -0.04826415702700615, 0.08659505844116211, 0.004655186086893082, -0.007534714415669441, -0.1348952054977417, 0.02411004714667797, -0.012285701930522919, -0.03103460930287838, 0.0338510237634182, 0.007277384866029024, 0.06032434478402138, -0.022805336862802505, -0.056750718504190445, 0.0729932188987732, -0.06797841191291809, 0.036495696753263474, -0.026134859770536423, 0.03562449663877487, -0.056359440088272095, -0.0042157298885285854, -0.03919227793812752, -0.004168919753283262, -0.04153714329004288, -0.007769125979393721, -0.0037373711820691824, 0.05856851860880852, -0.007911603897809982, 0.031222272664308548, 0.03723546862602234, -0.005946260876953602, 0.02230742760002613, 0.010870316065847874, 0.045488014817237854, 0.0019145498517900705, 0.026010828092694283, -0.0045769670978188515, -0.05136645585298538, 0.006511269602924585, 0.02138548716902733, 0.05677369609475136, 0.03730476647615433, 0.05704774335026741, -0.06030663847923279, -0.023336656391620636, 0.017874257639050484, 0.028001347556710243, 0.07132283598184586, -0.06417239457368851, -0.05883573740720749, -0.016888458281755447, 0.07953666150569916, 0.03219476342201233, -0.012194947339594364, 0.10629063099622726, -0.07287123799324036, -0.011820788495242596, -0.02755620703101158, 0.02847886271774769, -0.020265424624085426, -0.04251914843916893, -0.024322353303432465, -0.039791498333215714, -0.017594141885638237, -0.0836399719119072, 0.006146540399640799, 0.000019803652321570553, -0.028798185288906097, -0.018738651648163795, -0.04046981409192085, 0.010404128581285477, -0.00275987945497036, 0.01877404749393463, -0.01890740357339382, -0.060305219143629074, 0.04342735931277275, 0.0797906294465065, 0.024410083889961243, -0.0571470633149147, 0.016018442809581757, 0.018955666571855545, -0.03686530143022537, 0.014259588904678822, -0.005033053457736969, -0.005946961697191, 0.03725336492061615, 0.13605524599552155, 0.022061387076973915, 0.03164780139923096, -0.031160691753029823, -0.036509376019239426, -0.13238096237182617, -0.07479370385408401, -0.07937538623809814, 0.03952832892537117, -0.013045147061347961, -0.019112560898065567, 0.05008382350206375, -0.02840711548924446, 0.0196133553981781, 0.013224574737250805, 0.01780126988887787, -0.04721901938319206, 0.04381684958934784, -0.022174153476953506, 0.022434549406170845, -0.006668548099696636, 0.028375763446092606, -0.000566455302760005, 0.006372408475726843, 0.10611051321029663, 0.039396222680807114, 0.07401785254478455, -0.04355386644601822, 0.006830836180597544, 0.003841229947283864, 0.04996705800294876, -0.0013157475041225553, 0.074842669069767, -0.008564685471355915, 0.008876064792275429, -0.0834517627954483, -0.0029160361737012863, 0.033715926110744476, -0.0018730093725025654, -0.00006491524982266128, -0.05500126630067825, -0.004966097883880138, 0.0447106696665287, 0.047973573207855225, 0.026889700442552567, -0.10314545035362244, 0.03375466167926788, -0.007050188723951578, 0.012426157481968403, -0.030056720599532127, -0.03257777541875839, 0.035537514835596085, -0.08255957067012787, -0.012490702793002129, -0.000953895621933043, 0.016283206641674042, 0.04798357933759689, -0.008218574337661266, 0.079887755215168, 0.017825530841946602, 0.016691476106643677, -0.06306439638137817, -0.07647621631622314, -0.024328887462615967, -0.024860002100467682, -0.021503211930394173, 0.023296022787690163, -0.01888468489050865, -0.06033750995993614, -0.05844178795814514, -0.0825137197971344, 0.01858869381248951, 0.0933518186211586, -0.0018536336719989777, -0.029781652614474297, 0.011969787999987602, -0.005594915710389614, -0.003733962308615446, 0.05044853314757347, -0.011058038100600243, 0.0032959061209112406, -0.05343497544527054, 0.05028684437274933, -0.007968056946992874, 0.057418350130319595, -0.007273518480360508, -0.08068793267011642, 0.005701120011508465, 0.0377977080643177, -0.015715481713414192, 0.021462097764015198, 0.017435889691114426, 0.04485412314534187, -0.03032544255256653, -0.010044732131063938, 0.07531969994306564, 0.1017574816942215, 0.02623024582862854, -0.005757234990596771, -0.0353233739733696, 0.05184431001543999, 0.033961787819862366, 0.07440415024757385, -0.009805332869291306, 0.054970454424619675, 0.013630107045173645, -0.0514710359275341, 0.0022503782529383898, -0.06802339106798172, -0.02029726840555668, -0.00191733508836478, 0.027787983417510986, 0.008199027739465237, -0.0034157021436840296, -0.021637216210365295, 0.06947065144777298, -0.06076281517744064, -0.04311938211321831, -0.0020711859688162804, 0.03484749794006348, -0.027897000312805176, -0.016396766528487206, 0.0028565661050379276, 0.021524710580706596, -0.050096482038497925, 0.0715520977973938, 0.0426570363342762, -0.009007002227008343, -0.05174189433455467, -0.0740455761551857, 0.07345119118690491, 0.025533903390169144, -0.08902447670698166, 0.03625384718179703, -0.051851097494363785, 0.029285108670592308, 0.009933095425367355, -0.00870875921100378, 0.028507579118013382, 0.06167158484458923, 0.005750725511461496, -0.026889892295002937, 0.03982933610677719, 0.027572453022003174, 0.031427621841430664, 0.005589071661233902, -0.00040106085361912847, -0.023651257157325745, 0.0316227525472641, 0.054859600961208344, 0.07838858664035797, 0.047810446470975876, 0.02053505927324295, -0.005281834863126278, -0.0007709553465247154, -0.018404852598905563, 0.02144794724881649, 0.02792450785636902, 0.11725060641765594, -0.060369767248630524, -0.05737811699509621, -0.0340874157845974, 0.006543690338730812, -0.059992726892232895, -0.013850308954715729, -0.0778539702296257, 0.028144797310233116, 0.016568191349506378, 0.021819906309247017, 0.03202807530760765, 0.11284593492746353, -0.08092790842056274, 0.03625260666012764, -0.047989800572395325, 0.01884256675839424, -0.05832619592547417, 0.02350851520895958, -0.05512740835547447, -0.03419128432869911, -0.04687364399433136, 0.011669202707707882, 0.03603867068886757, 0.029653135687112808, -0.012852009385824203, -0.009569399058818817, -0.05634460598230362, 0.008387455716729164, -0.08340329676866531, -0.023243067786097527, 0.03964565694332123, 0.001497717690654099, -0.03241536393761635, 0.016725823283195496, -0.03174746781587601, 0.023553891107439995, -0.01616613008081913, 0.05552595853805542, -0.036605354398489, 0.023059021681547165, 0.009838681668043137, 0.03906337544322014, -0.028473874554038048, 0.047867052257061005, 0.02431478351354599, 0.012671076692640781, 0.025198834016919136, 0.0236436128616333, -0.0068204100243747234, 0.07309489697217941, 0.04731396585702896, -0.032273925840854645, -0.027237193658947945, -0.01723066158592701, 0.010321983136236668, -0.010570088401436806, 0.030094720423221588, 0.01470605656504631, -0.06382407248020172, 0.01685311459004879, -0.040926091372966766, -0.01790861040353775, 0.015984145924448967, 0.019771303981542587, -0.056465763598680496, -0.051786597818136215, -0.019122932106256485, -0.003948777448385954, -0.07884159684181213, -0.042865313589572906, 0.02990569919347763, -0.05023995041847229, -0.0017643844475969672, -0.07130111753940582, -0.036519620567560196, 0.025483036413788795, 0.00007767990609863773, 0.05264030769467354, -0.012379691936075687, -0.12004944682121277, -0.03913768380880356, -0.03882046788930893, -0.0719805359840393, -0.014127648435533047, 0.03323657810688019, 0.03936915844678879, -0.07441837340593338, 0.07687016576528549, -0.013365015387535095, 0.03489887714385986, -0.0916309803724289, -0.05265144631266594, -0.0017753045540302992, 0.07009822875261307, 0.027736859396100044, 0.03990893438458443, -0.027462633326649666, -0.049752410501241684, 0.0023528863675892353, -0.009239301085472107, -0.02047629840672016, -0.021611779928207397, -0.02180813066661358, 0.008943337015807629, 0.06186424568295479, 0.051309287548065186, 0.023480432108044624, -0.01994958147406578, -0.05412872135639191, -0.026186639443039894, -0.038498654961586, 0.002704534912481904, -0.014266015961766243, 0.016245365142822266, 0.07348533719778061, -0.016176005825400352, -0.01681293547153473, -0.002355461474508047, -0.03025580570101738, 0.019275180995464325, 0.08524046838283539, 0.03438366949558258, 0.01717327907681465, 0.06241097301244736, 0.037940315902233124, -0.022732866927981377, 0.031136440113186836, 0.09181598573923111, 0.008487414568662643, -0.026215048506855965, 0.005517537705600262, 0.011043716222047806, 0.002045324770733714, 0.0994633287191391, -0.02519662119448185, -0.0015698157949373126, 0.057072293013334274, 0.00047543522669002414, -0.000525180425029248, 0.0009721866226755083, -0.024581652134656906, 0.07368186861276627, -0.011363105848431587, 0.006427259184420109, -0.005831570830196142, 0.007646010257303715, 0.012775509618222713, 0.010146168991923332, -0.0947263240814209, 0.02095336653292179, 0.0011262783082202077, -0.05619940161705017, -0.005714460741728544, 0.0356946736574173, 0.009816710837185383, -0.042731087654829025, 0.026637136936187744, 0.018898246809840202, 0.03631110489368439, -0.022789016366004944, 0.02959168702363968, 0.05685647577047348, -0.0002829768054652959, 0.012691809795796871, -0.04066437855362892, -0.11942121386528015, 0.009653867222368717, 0.017916277050971985, 0.03209734335541725, -0.05651244893670082, 0.02476671151816845, -0.018116317689418793, 0.011524825356900692, 0.02006971836090088, -0.014108113944530487, 0.012106948532164097, 0.017347276210784912, 0.0010371203534305096, 0.03570902720093727, -0.047114189714193344, 0.01979876682162285, 0.028875967487692833, 0.026664262637495995, 0.03598679602146149, 0.07312016189098358, -0.011950662359595299, -0.013566602021455765, 0.05849213898181915, -0.03590570390224457, 0.013296396471560001 ]
226
226
Domain Adaptation: Learning Bounds and Algorithms
This paper addresses the general problem of domain adaptation which arises in a variety of applications where the distribution of the labeled sample available somewhat differs from that of the test data. Building on previous work by Ben-David et al. (2007), we introduce a novel distance between distributions, discrepancy distance, that is tailored to adaptation problems with arbitrary loss functions. We give Rademacher complexity bounds for estimating the discrepancy distance from finite samples for different loss functions. Using this distance, we derive novel generalization bounds for domain adaptation for a wide family of loss functions. We also present a series of novel adaptation bounds for large classes of regularization-based algorithms, including support vector machines and kernel ridge regression based on the empirical discrepancy. This motivates our analysis of the problem of minimizing the empirical discrepancy for various loss functions for which we also give novel algorithms. We report the results of preliminary experiments that demonstrate the benefits of our discrepancy minimization algorithms for domain adaptation.
[ 0.02282784692943096, -0.01930263638496399, 0.07800593972206116, -0.06905511766672134, -0.006769913248717785, -0.06298954784870148, 0.01557648740708828, -0.0015891070943325758, -0.036530062556266785, 0.1341412216424942, -0.003910095896571875, -0.006283423397690058, -0.053805045783519745, 0.07198390364646912, 0.018328266218304634, 0.016708415001630783, 0.0748031809926033, -0.07818059623241425, 0.05569268763065338, -0.07823340594768524, 0.019559724256396294, 0.01515678409487009, 0.022417817264795303, -0.06963833421468735, -0.035711102187633514, -0.039620719850063324, 0.008666480891406536, 0.0015028886264190078, -0.05854576826095581, 0.040399014949798584, -0.07189337909221649, -0.014789208769798279, 0.01483286451548338, 0.027948854491114616, -0.037708885967731476, 0.016556739807128906, 0.028539134189486504, -0.030890027061104774, -0.0972333624958992, -0.07543309032917023, 0.028566664084792137, 0.08439625054597855, -0.03350108861923218, 0.06784976273775101, 0.05112460255622864, 0.10348379611968994, -0.02860763855278492, -0.05199475586414337, 0.05958188325166702, 0.03354206308722496, -0.07355088740587234, 0.0034841420128941536, -0.027148457244038582, -0.08033326268196106, 0.03946083411574364, 0.03087031841278076, -0.04875531047582626, 0.004911394324153662, -0.03104688599705696, -0.036351870745420456, 0.04810776934027672, 0.14294829964637756, 0.003395811887457967, -0.03700348362326622, -0.04925922676920891, -0.025655878707766533, -0.08547734469175339, -0.04927150160074234, 0.03586442023515701, -0.017350591719150543, 0.06333885341882706, -0.031468916684389114, -0.0031098760664463043, 0.037653230130672455, 0.06303106248378754, 0.03139111399650574, -0.03710409626364708, -0.013058544136583805, 0.06216839700937271, 0.0006191061693243682, -0.002809994388371706, 0.05449553206562996, 0.026104377582669258, 0.03997955471277237, 0.03800100088119507, 0.04047027975320816, -0.0074258544482290745, -0.019598297774791718, -0.016098447144031525, -0.03517371788620949, -0.04789218679070473, 0.025466661900281906, -0.05543409660458565, -0.01720765046775341, -0.04748913273215294, 0.1080009862780571, 0.00314049213193357, -0.009168214164674282, 0.006307955365628004, 0.0032157176174223423, -0.04180016368627548, 0.01552898995578289, 0.1028498038649559, -0.008684978820383549, -0.030226269736886024, 0.006213185843080282, -0.020533371716737747, 0.06521297991275787, -0.01511277724057436, -0.007553711533546448, 0.058733150362968445, -0.0555422306060791, -0.05454958602786064, -0.013911056332290173, -0.03621732071042061, 0.04976470768451691, -0.024893052875995636, 0.0485757477581501, 0.0016201154794543982, 0.03504517674446106, 0.01944562792778015, 0.018116535618901253, 0.0027754514012485743, 0.011528684757649899, 0.025730755180120468, 0.03371376916766167, -0.06374648213386536, -0.08342795819044113, 0.07343680411577225, -0.0783279538154602, -0.05534923076629639, 0.028747638687491417, 0.0008634155383333564, 0.027483517304062843, -0.05081823468208313, 0.053368039429187775, 0.00438702804967761, 0.011502222158014774, -0.01039337832480669, 0.018047573044896126, 0.026709530502557755, 0.036967381834983826, -0.027570629492402077, -0.016933990642428398, -0.00586511567234993, 0.013586685061454773, 0.018048707395792007, 0.003566631581634283, 0.024656174704432487, -0.05715707689523697, 0.02210185118019581, 0.02613958716392517, 0.031386781483888626, 0.002786691766232252, 0.02104823850095272, -0.1202147826552391, 0.007086317520588636, -0.020087208598852158, -0.07685063779354095, -0.007415107451379299, 0.029462678357958794, 0.02763136848807335, -0.0018852337962016463, -0.021583132445812225, -0.03972548246383667, 0.004354551434516907, 0.030986906960606575, -0.041750963777303696, -0.04244636744260788, -0.090773805975914, -0.0718393549323082, -0.020153766497969627, 0.034755732864141464, 0.022579045966267586, 0.0627318024635315, -0.01799975149333477, 0.0078131640329957, 0.0727570503950119, -0.015380432829260826, -0.008848285302519798, 0.03446650132536888, -0.0029524597339332104, -0.015425430610775948, -0.013805348426103592, 0.02644556201994419, 0.03148430585861206, 0.020609654486179352, 0.04734973981976509, -0.018105046823620796, 0.0361073762178421, 0.037894561886787415, 0.00311635946854949, 0.021921390667557716, -0.017367655411362648, -0.04623072221875191, 0.036632560193538666, 0.004968988709151745, -0.025198232382535934, 0.024474242702126503, 0.009993184357881546, 0.0241440087556839, -0.0627087727189064, -0.1007814109325409, -0.09552311897277832, -0.04314770549535751, 0.05914247781038284, -0.01674429513514042, -0.04577944427728653, -0.009360521100461483, -0.048314180225133896, -0.05589587241411209, 0.02189619094133377, -0.00004180014002486132, -0.07282310724258423, 0.044834401458501816, -0.05865880474448204, -0.0765945091843605, 0.016552353277802467, 0.029771076515316963, 0.027615053579211235, -0.023998072370886803, 0.0022242781706154346, -0.03215090185403824, 0.08153478801250458, -0.06094788387417793, 0.018355414271354675, -0.02233532816171646, -0.0002617769641801715, -0.006498012691736221, 0.07609345018863678, -0.08712591230869293, -0.029826201498508453, -0.0014784539816901088, -0.020540202036499977, -0.06107901409268379, 0.03554215654730797, -0.05979433283209801, -0.021239733323454857, 0.014460810460150242, -0.04218527674674988, 0.01493906695395708, 0.06865817308425903, 0.009683716110885143, -0.008083482272922993, 0.04732385650277138, 0.035312358289957047, 0.06859422475099564, -0.007676195353269577, -0.001872208551503718, 0.03437171131372452, 0.04317658022046089, -0.01983913965523243, -0.0218972060829401, -0.01045340858399868, -0.027100658044219017, 0.04628165438771248, 0.03944509103894234, 0.006677526980638504, 0.06772845983505249, 0.028631316497921944, 0.037755995988845825, 0.06660325080156326, -0.07536294311285019, 0.020347917452454567, 0.03617183864116669, 0.00019792947568930686, 0.009310182183980942, 0.03263960778713226, 0.007996105588972569, 0.008883119560778141, -0.0344851016998291, -0.05794704705476761, -0.049211613833904266, 0.0877780094742775, -0.06291329115629196, 0.0434902124106884, 0.11114946752786636, 0.07770141959190369, 0.05408189445734024, 0.016595231369137764, -0.057328131049871445, 0.027132974937558174, -0.009794356301426888, 0.01901199482381344, 0.02014808915555477, 0.02026854082942009, -0.05088680237531662, 0.031831275671720505, 0.022195635363459587, -0.027970122173428535, 0.01089160330593586, 0.020051084458827972, -0.04088877514004707, -0.012344982475042343, 0.03533239662647247, 0.038011662662029266, 0.06632403284311295, -0.05575091391801834, 0.015920866280794144, -0.024561498314142227, 0.06875846534967422, 0.07618483901023865, 0.06522107124328613, 0.006380132399499416, -0.01756024919450283, 0.023982468992471695, 0.06268087029457092, 0.03682422265410423, -0.032753899693489075, 0.02274567447602749, 0.01276575867086649, 0.012145844288170338, -0.046570535749197006, -0.0812782272696495, 0.025768306106328964, -0.11946932226419449, -0.02679252438247204, -0.022714823484420776, 0.05561071261763573, -0.016061339527368546, 0.02867930382490158, -0.01971944235265255, -0.0061934106051921844, 0.020362207666039467, -0.10480856895446777, -0.04542173817753792, 0.030522944405674934, 0.03651859983801842, 0.0018379954854026437, -0.022379962727427483, -0.04531263932585716, -0.05544523894786835, -0.004468702245503664, 0.053170811384916306, -0.04737340658903122, 0.07851752638816833, -0.0580335408449173, 0.04816216975450516, -0.03139284998178482, 0.0024001800920814276, -0.0015800350811332464, -0.05386678874492645, -0.012169585563242435, 0.00968857016414404, 0.04461372271180153, 0.04148612543940544, 0.0692451000213623, 0.002956409938633442, -0.06355348974466324, -0.013801882043480873, -0.06913042068481445, 0.048903752118349075, -0.02237716317176819, 0.018203411251306534, 0.07101301848888397, 0.048288214951753616, 0.03920974209904671, -0.029740408062934875, 0.04354046285152435, 0.018713949248194695, -0.006344452500343323, 0.07217681407928467, -0.05670187249779701, 0.03479469195008278, 0.006354983430355787, 0.04351989924907684, 0.02597513608634472, 0.024171294644474983, -0.07692299038171768, -0.011653874069452286, -0.01466323435306549, 0.04800751060247421, 0.03450427204370499, 0.05618976056575775, 0.01721053197979927, 0.026789046823978424, 0.021585024893283844, 0.013955002650618553, -0.02312050573527813, 0.09579512476921082, -0.048888739198446274, 0.015482490882277489, 0.04565076157450676, -0.04043632373213768, 0.006531785242259502, 0.006033612415194511, -0.02193722501397133, -0.0022075187880545855, 0.07460416108369827, -0.05131537467241287, -0.05306342616677284, -0.06040254235267639, -0.02084648609161377, 0.003405210329219699, 0.0013963239034637809, 0.018047260120511055, 0.013708474114537239, -0.04852373152971268, -0.02444824017584324, -0.042212050408124924, 0.018749309703707695, 0.04257899895310402, 0.0036506098695099354, -0.05896609649062157, -0.09045424312353134, -0.01997775211930275, 0.03739699721336365, -0.005918008275330067, 0.014119449071586132, 0.08325958997011185, 0.004461727105081081, -0.0778115838766098, 0.011907192878425121, 0.0044544232077896595, 0.01596708409488201, 0.0003635376924648881, 0.024944068863987923, 0.03234078735113144, 0.02201843075454235, -0.045943502336740494, 0.02519947849214077, 0.006758640054613352, 0.0526706762611866, 0.014981727115809917, -0.026591883972287178, -0.016026923432946205, -0.0077795893885195255, 0.05995779484510422, 0.026536906138062477, 0.07303576171398163, 0.0029770308174192905, -0.047846537083387375, -0.06757039576768875, 0.022442862391471863, -0.022233372554183006, -0.05242472514510155, 0.023212676867842674, -0.035401683300733566, -0.04084726423025131, -0.03694431483745575, -0.012957235798239708, 0.0198665801435709, -0.006865294184535742, 0.04068047180771828, -0.01131652295589447, 0.053199149668216705, 0.01025197934359312, -0.004376544151455164, 0.006078451871871948, 0.0048203421756625175, 0.021990923210978508, -0.005351733416318893, 0.003219291800633073, -0.06534240394830704, -0.010015814565122128, -0.014520209282636642, 0.018347157165408134, -0.026240721344947815, 0.036173511296510696, -0.005417921580374241, 0.005704496055841446, -0.0686277225613594, -0.03355712816119194, 0.07289682328701019, -0.09479302167892456, 0.03600330650806427, -0.017073940485715866, 0.014698191545903683, 0.07052008807659149, 0.04754865542054176, -0.11130670458078384, 0.03694818913936615, -0.0221098642796278, -0.044996775686740875, -0.046251218765974045, 0.0016067432006821036, 0.002966546453535557, -0.0875520408153534, 0.06107853725552559, -0.023507602512836456, -0.02038559876382351, -0.09917021542787552, 0.011770765297114849, -0.06280768662691116, 0.013083795085549355, -0.06202058866620064, 0.03289467841386795, 0.015021869912743568, 0.07252766191959381, -0.0016108390409499407, 0.06714596599340439, -0.005985753145068884, -0.0410827212035656, 0.042451161891222, -0.007797992788255215, -0.032331064343452454, -0.007180278189480305, -0.041139084845781326, 0.04556501656770706, 0.07414770871400833, 0.01802646927535534, -0.007952215149998665, 0.015439449809491634, 0.013658205978572369, 0.08834964781999588, 0.0222859438508749, -0.0021236035972833633, -0.03831810876727104, 0.07183003425598145, 0.09585829079151154, -0.06932824850082397, 0.019711198285222054 ]
227
227
Online Multi-task Learning with Hard Constraints
We discuss multi-task online learning when a decision maker has to deal simultaneously with M tasks. The tasks are related, which is modeled by imposing that the M-tuple of actions taken by the decision maker needs to satisfy certain constraints. We give natural examples of such restrictions and then discuss a general class of tractable constraints, for which we introduce computationally efficient ways of selecting actions, essentially by reducing to an on-line shortest path problem. We briefly discuss "tracking" and "bandit" versions of the problem and extend the model in various ways, including non-additive global losses and uncountably infinite sets of tasks.
[ 0.09208328276872635, -0.04625020921230316, 0.04046735167503357, 0.04846171662211418, 0.00008963078289525583, -0.11071312427520752, 0.015218676999211311, -0.0028182135429233313, -0.021786455065011978, 0.041058968752622604, -0.03341855853796005, 0.0028588776476681232, 0.05131872370839119, -0.019274163991212845, 0.027380209416151047, -0.025035062804818153, -0.03857198730111122, -0.030931856483221054, 0.04468386620283127, -0.1123255267739296, 0.05584138259291649, 0.0160537026822567, 0.08308456838130951, 0.016996778547763824, 0.04654737561941147, 0.03134044259786606, -0.0654580295085907, 0.011977351270616055, -0.020940149202942848, -0.02133263275027275, -0.046785853803157806, 0.0018636897439137101, 0.0266952496021986, 0.0021738179493695498, 0.04704585298895836, -0.05515621602535248, 0.02467988058924675, -0.03487909212708473, -0.01610146090388298, -0.036605868488550186, 0.018019793555140495, -0.02703751064836979, -0.03253454342484474, 0.000012265113582543563, 0.03152928128838539, 0.018021848052740097, 0.0641789361834526, -0.03803391009569168, 0.017452677711844444, 0.0635261982679367, -0.02275809273123741, 0.02603086642920971, -0.05646337568759918, 0.01551982294768095, 0.009732107631862164, 0.05411820486187935, -0.11220310628414154, -0.028772341087460518, 0.024096768349409103, -0.04609599709510803, 0.02346745692193508, 0.07920866459608078, 0.02054603211581707, 0.0421396903693676, -0.02558482438325882, 0.044083595275878906, -0.042910657823085785, -0.023983299732208252, -0.030496682971715927, -0.0007895955932326615, 0.02843368612229824, -0.022109443321824074, -0.006770781707018614, 0.043332818895578384, 0.051110636442899704, 0.05206919461488724, 0.048916883766651154, 0.014136208221316338, -0.012824737466871738, 0.10638799518346786, -0.042326852679252625, 0.026707299053668976, -0.054562583565711975, 0.03582095727324486, 0.030288206413388252, 0.015833796933293343, 0.05345570296049118, -0.02265937626361847, -0.051311347633600235, -0.024420475587248802, -0.010675346478819847, -0.0491345077753067, -0.07196873426437378, -0.012201184406876564, -0.029290132224559784, 0.028244176879525185, -0.024243848398327827, -0.006895249709486961, -0.0628441870212555, 0.02559787780046463, 0.026653392240405083, 0.023725934326648712, 0.038944538682699203, 0.12687964737415314, -0.03249698132276535, -0.05034481734037399, -0.00439611217007041, 0.013411619700491428, 0.011529842391610146, -0.01737278141081333, -0.015667423605918884, 0.026349231600761414, 0.010895643383264542, 0.05570368841290474, -0.010123520158231258, 0.04385722428560257, -0.05095425620675087, 0.10501563549041748, -0.0031079119071364403, -0.026944387704133987, -0.05147390440106392, 0.025843335315585136, -0.07114743441343307, 0.010348443873226643, 0.04254935681819916, -0.06317519396543503, 0.08605770766735077, -0.006771080195903778, 0.02851198986172676, 0.042688798159360886, 0.014024187810719013, 0.07512936741113663, 0.002498872112482786, -0.05439029633998871, -0.022814281284809113, -0.0090756481513381, 0.042987141758203506, -0.05682973563671112, -0.002921526785939932, 0.009955128654837608, -0.017592953518033028, -0.042542412877082825, -0.0686974823474884, -0.03546098619699478, 0.0064084636978805065, -0.052893850952386856, -0.006292682606726885, 0.039183128625154495, 0.04170948266983032, 0.040513984858989716, -0.0706879273056984, -0.028144774958491325, 0.013879046775400639, 0.012379158288240433, 0.050991516560316086, -0.04493936896324158, 0.023710070177912712, -0.03807021677494049, -0.0406438373029232, 0.03497489541769028, 0.045791685581207275, -0.0008022367837838829, -0.04352491721510887, -0.010541864670813084, 0.03278937563300133, 0.017259791493415833, -0.057661451399326324, 0.062873974442482, 0.005865819286555052, -0.03223190829157829, -0.02881341241300106, -0.06095860153436661, -0.00476333312690258, 0.059771716594696045, -0.029287761077284813, 0.0359015129506588, 0.03053431026637554, 0.018316268920898438, -0.05356039106845856, 0.030057944357395172, 0.001646229880861938, -0.05581436678767204, 0.029449813067913055, -0.01751459762454033, 0.06073290854692459, 0.03292936086654663, 0.019021570682525635, -0.027374504134058952, 0.061645906418561935, -0.009353913366794586, -0.032519787549972534, 0.01823512837290764, 0.0009698515059426427, -0.007936948910355568, -0.034251876175403595, -0.01344720646739006, -0.04789139702916145, -0.020626479759812355, 0.010971274226903915, -0.030083585530519485, -0.027051256969571114, -0.040590666234493256, 0.05550733208656311, -0.03650791943073273, -0.08624885231256485, 0.0069655138067901134, 0.008817517198622227, -0.02817806974053383, 0.029873808845877647, -0.05280151218175888, -0.00353914313018322, -0.014042860828340054, -0.047647301107645035, 0.03057877905666828, 0.02862119860947132, -0.08175341784954071, 0.04683481156826019, -0.11266379803419113, 0.019845936447381973, 0.015187912620604038, -0.0736837387084961, 0.09522321820259094, 0.017729351297020912, 0.02791481837630272, -0.058820705860853195, -0.012630810029804707, 0.08626841008663177, -0.04779830574989319, -0.018962211906909943, 0.02609127201139927, -0.08719326555728912, -0.06279552727937698, -0.05734705552458763, 0.07151252031326294, -0.029655562713742256, 0.040887344628572464, -0.052642256021499634, -0.03973419591784477, 0.021487249061465263, -0.08947070688009262, -0.011867191642522812, -0.04152730107307434, -0.0018354133935645223, -0.04240391030907631, 0.006106694228947163, 0.019742097705602646, 0.04498354718089104, 0.02360316924750805, -0.08244158327579498, 0.0044065313413739204, 0.026314638555049896, 0.015591099858283997, -0.0482146218419075, 0.04241824150085449, -0.02499871701002121, -0.03939172625541687, 0.020825844258069992, 0.09221171587705612, 0.01570194773375988, 0.0018670163117349148, -0.001731395022943616, -0.037611473351716995, -0.12082663923501968, -0.0015055114636197686, 0.03315224125981331, 0.05418194457888603, -0.04022569581866264, 0.0077855405397713184, 0.017431894317269325, -0.026743965223431587, 0.010840198025107384, -0.08235537260770798, -0.009478339925408363, 0.08747386187314987, -0.03254032880067825, -0.041105717420578, -0.09267010539770126, 0.03793987259268761, 0.023918475955724716, 0.005422716960310936, -0.10895882546901703, 0.03139682486653328, 0.023734845221042633, 0.007058687973767519, 0.008550751022994518, 0.0556112676858902, 0.06721869111061096, -0.015858497470617294, 0.061257265508174896, 0.05756538361310959, -0.0596148744225502, 0.03570936992764473, 0.0071481019258499146, -0.022375354543328285, 0.02014968730509281, -0.04887132719159126, 0.014363463036715984, 0.05164327099919319, -0.035867445170879364, -0.035854753106832504, -0.01379316858947277, -0.013121718540787697, 0.016834720969200134, 0.06162768229842186, 0.0050858925096690655, 0.07138816267251968, 0.004973387811332941, 0.023553907871246338, -0.07756683230400085, -0.023469526320695877, -0.005444292910397053, -0.01384323462843895, -0.017123941332101822, 0.006304731126874685, 0.03603940084576607, -0.03133759647607803, -0.014654438011348248, 0.028821280226111412, -0.07399681955575943, 0.06964735686779022, 0.013835437595844269, -0.023268135264515877, -0.018934650346636772, -0.006588455755263567, -0.06132519617676735, -0.05784045159816742, -0.03404760733246803, -0.02123970538377762, 0.007825792767107487, -0.030850781127810478, -0.07569437474012375, -0.01964462548494339, -0.04382487013936043, 0.028023701161146164, 0.01037225965410471, -0.043410517275333405, -0.05098549649119377, -0.0002925547887571156, -0.061886291950941086, 0.0016963027883321047, -0.03854161128401756, -0.10310748219490051, -0.09417977184057236, -0.02022404968738556, 0.021593762561678886, 0.04389776661992073, 0.041573554277420044, 0.06146262213587761, 0.001336796092800796, 0.0010358813451603055, -0.09295187890529633, -0.00908444169908762, -0.05264582857489586, 0.0465523861348629, -0.0663430392742157, -0.0540265217423439, 0.06223040819168091, -0.046259745955467224, -0.05643017962574959, -0.001807303517125547, -0.042049091309309006, -0.05757834389805794, -0.05273517593741417, -0.03445196896791458, -0.02393130399286747, 0.017713310196995735, -0.02917461469769478, -0.00545911118388176, -0.10211019217967987, -0.018536057323217392, -0.044731300324201584, 0.03805401921272278, 0.042438335716724396, -0.0052613322623074055, -0.00034857221180573106, -0.04077519476413727, 0.04329666122794151, -0.09808801114559174, -0.006688869092613459, 0.09733767062425613, -0.0873810425400734, -0.02785852551460266, -0.06247309222817421, 0.04261339455842972, -0.07140355557203293, -0.00870597455650568, -0.02396550588309765, -0.027719387784600258, 0.10204020142555237, -0.015266709960997105, -0.07370199263095856, 0.007045222911983728, 0.04090718924999237, -0.00579711701720953, 0.0275109950453043, 0.03522893413901329, 0.04164983704686165, -0.024311555549502373, -0.047825492918491364, -0.012064051814377308, 0.060509588569402695, 0.0635421946644783, 0.033247046172618866, -0.015816515311598778, -0.019316714257001877, 0.05265277251601219, 0.07750915735960007, 0.037568241357803345, -0.016951370984315872, 0.022415362298488617, 0.08332877606153488, 0.0036967438645660877, 0.03376053273677826, 0.009883352555334568, -0.01750473864376545, 0.03258210048079491, 0.06886132061481476, 0.020426737144589424, -0.01083839125931263, -0.0879775807261467, 0.0016970187425613403, -0.006381337530910969, -0.010005410760641098, -0.04306231066584587, -0.06988292932510376, -0.046633753925561905, 0.046553365886211395, 0.01634255051612854, -0.00047576488577760756, -0.011843658983707428, -0.07796863466501236, -0.043658625334501266, -0.025562666356563568, -0.047689564526081085, 0.0035558994859457016, -0.005259216763079166, 0.009644703008234501, 0.01788811758160591, 0.0596310980618, 0.024701450020074844, -0.00403105653822422, 0.07134411484003067, 0.016319189220666885, -0.00894816592335701, 0.019771724939346313, 0.12064184993505478, -0.046188101172447205, 0.028955502435564995, 0.04269247502088547, 0.0008709965622983873, -0.004543833900243044, -0.036405373364686966, 0.10712558031082153, 0.013722694478929043, -0.05188871920108795, -0.03715905547142029, 0.015952639281749725, -0.0225069597363472, 0.03402242437005043, -0.05234207585453987, -0.006976940203458071, -0.032464783638715744, 0.06259555369615555, 0.008657376281917095, -0.030253492295742035, -0.010167662985622883, 0.05360403656959534, -0.003366310615092516, -0.006038282997906208, 0.023782487958669662, -0.11337418854236603, 0.025389565154910088, 0.02691391110420227, -0.031077483668923378, 0.006374279037117958, 0.0070461914874613285, -0.01947777345776558, -0.02758105844259262, 0.07230707257986069, 0.014804801903665066, 0.02712331898510456, -0.001393656013533473, 0.008580227382481098, 0.0021074225660413504, 0.045127399265766144, -0.00004376678407425061, -0.018558967858552933, 0.002331268275156617, 0.04783209040760994, 0.05620765686035156, -0.048030007630586624, 0.0055256434716284275, 0.028485536575317383, 0.0032389156986027956, 0.020986543968319893, -0.09021279960870743, 0.009098226204514503, -0.035887811332941055, 0.0654604583978653, 0.054474327713251114, 0.04961559548974037, 0.013890819624066353, 0.06282161921262741, 0.08114969730377197, 0.03639844059944153, -0.053404126316308975, -0.03883771225810051, 0.011584225110709667, 0.0030535936821252108, 0.028286734595894814, -0.047741200774908066, 0.057833705097436905 ]
228
228
Uniqueness of Low-Rank Matrix Completion by Rigidity Theory
The problem of completing a low-rank matrix from a subset of its entries is often encountered in the analysis of incomplete data sets exhibiting an underlying factor model with applications in collaborative filtering, computer vision and control. Most recent work had been focused on constructing efficient algorithms for exact or approximate recovery of the missing matrix entries and proving lower bounds for the number of known entries that guarantee a successful recovery with high probability. A related problem from both the mathematical and algorithmic point of view is the distance geometry problem of realizing points in a Euclidean space from a given subset of their pairwise distances. Rigidity theory answers basic questions regarding the uniqueness of the realization satisfying a given partial set of distances. We observe that basic ideas and tools of rigidity theory can be adapted to determine uniqueness of low-rank matrix completion, where inner products play the role that distances play in rigidity theory. This observation leads to an efficient randomized algorithm for testing both local and global unique completion. Crucial to our analysis is a new matrix, which we call the completion matrix, that serves as the analogue of the rigidity matrix.
[ 0.02543630078434944, -0.028634605929255486, 0.05718120560050011, -0.06450806558132172, 0.009354863315820694, 0.027696067467331886, 0.049926966428756714, 0.01727660931646824, 0.015705084428191185, 0.0490872748196125, 0.016107600182294846, -0.08846677839756012, 0.007931973785161972, 0.06554446369409561, -0.01526387594640255, -0.021494748070836067, -0.030849194154143333, -0.03364402800798416, -0.009168931283056736, -0.0981159508228302, -0.014964768663048744, 0.07312662899494171, 0.009469888173043728, 0.01595180295407772, -0.07385870069265366, -0.013574621640145779, -0.012742018327116966, 0.02590940147638321, -0.006776170339435339, -0.0267120823264122, -0.0271646399050951, -0.03481600433588028, 0.006264550611376762, -0.017898768186569214, 0.005651703104376793, 0.002455115783959627, 0.011625128798186779, 0.018186697736382484, -0.010219900868833065, 0.005345257464796305, -0.00642679026350379, -0.0023301225155591965, 0.031413547694683075, 0.02696853317320347, 0.06106855347752571, 0.016741186380386353, 0.058696646243333817, 0.009364564903080463, 0.05690208077430725, 0.01974601298570633, -0.0836988016963005, 0.02808579057455063, -0.026886414736509323, -0.018209701403975487, -0.038278017193078995, -0.012185638770461082, 0.019565524533391, -0.04463265463709831, 0.031293146312236786, -0.03742487356066704, 0.03574691340327263, 0.0330832377076149, -0.03372809663414955, -0.01862114854156971, -0.012964699417352676, 0.001727256109006703, -0.03701383247971535, 0.011289490386843681, -0.02736007049679756, -0.0680767297744751, 0.013365150429308414, -0.07303669303655624, 0.07422919571399689, 0.032083410769701004, 0.044272299855947495, 0.03521678224205971, 0.0014459965750575066, -0.03074028342962265, 0.012539447285234928, 0.0904647633433342, -0.06057114154100418, 0.02704322338104248, -0.050514236092567444, -0.009901081211864948, -0.011720742098987103, 0.019009113311767578, -0.000005320147920429008, -0.02383555844426155, 0.03925267234444618, -0.06475813686847687, -0.005277853459119797, 0.04051218554377556, -0.068693608045578, 0.11066699028015137, 0.015942292287945747, -0.040726855397224426, -0.05642334744334221, 0.053374744951725006, -0.017086131498217583, 0.04271673783659935, 0.022091122344136238, -0.002972428221255541, 0.013755789957940578, 0.016219865530729294, -0.019469624385237694, 0.04004676267504692, -0.07500719279050827, 0.029568413272500038, 0.0033843093551695347, -0.031180713325738907, -0.04647085815668106, -0.06933776289224625, 0.011745098978281021, 0.06650309264659882, -0.025374451652169228, 0.08118996024131775, 0.014306105673313141, 0.07821106910705566, -0.011410140432417393, 0.046150367707014084, -0.03234543651342392, 0.00002386600499448832, -0.05521685257554054, 0.04229814559221268, -0.00960164237767458, -0.04672775790095329, -0.04184267669916153, -0.10013125091791153, 0.09062478691339493, -0.01143624447286129, -0.10862069576978683, 0.010555990971624851, 0.025127310305833817, 0.03885211423039436, -0.021162737160921097, 0.07840919494628906, -0.05924391746520996, 0.01592494733631611, -0.030243124812841415, 0.07589493691921234, -0.014305414631962776, 0.05851025506854057, -0.022943753749132156, -0.0492519848048687, 0.02533847652375698, 0.0035183753352612257, 0.0315072126686573, -0.01706482283771038, -0.034612998366355896, -0.045077890157699585, -0.018034985288977623, 0.016580192372202873, 0.054089631885290146, -0.007722141221165657, -0.01705987937748432, -0.01439557783305645, -0.01840859465301037, -0.04792553931474686, 0.008231629617512226, 0.03691387176513672, -0.029896637424826622, -0.00046838633716106415, -0.017965517938137054, -0.014386746101081371, -0.04558459669351578, -0.04441830888390541, -0.005253835581243038, -0.13228927552700043, -0.05537966638803482, -0.018375270068645477, -0.010970545932650566, -0.02361178956925869, -0.02611505798995495, 0.053592924028635025, 0.031584884971380234, 0.03385341912508011, -0.06672599911689758, 0.05174921080470085, -0.02353891171514988, -0.0343717560172081, -0.025602735579013824, 0.019830981269478798, 0.0174141526222229, 0.07219339162111282, -0.01793682388961315, 0.12083771824836731, 0.030273407697677612, -0.0017640215810388327, 0.04745585471391678, 0.039624474942684174, 0.04460765793919563, 0.02262500673532486, 0.013753311708569527, -0.026022901758551598, -0.0744880735874176, 0.05654536560177803, 0.016662655398249626, -0.03250889480113983, 0.06702756136655807, 0.04479734227061272, 0.031084652990102768, 0.032369550317525864, 0.06766743212938309, -0.10567241907119751, -0.03989828750491142, -0.027534153312444687, -0.04707872495055199, 0.011225598864257336, 0.11174361407756805, -0.032862499356269836, 0.036355577409267426, 0.008743380196392536, -0.0106230853125453, -0.07510997354984283, 0.0103940824046731, -0.04971037060022354, -0.055916041135787964, -0.00021488789934664965, 0.027184125036001205, 0.04185791686177254, -0.048780303448438644, 0.0671008750796318, -0.04853387922048569, -0.029170354828238487, -0.05350826308131218, -0.04738774523139, 0.09906772524118423, -0.06026716157793999, -0.0332648828625679, 0.05429055914282799, -0.048655103892087936, -0.0285471361130476, -0.010403487831354141, -0.015850525349378586, -0.021275267004966736, 0.009263747371733189, -0.08284976333379745, -0.020551428198814392, -0.04210864380002022, 0.043235573917627335, 0.011553497053682804, 0.023847710341215134, -0.009800714440643787, 0.03240935876965523, 0.008734229952096939, -0.020403513684868813, 0.004406549967825413, 0.07332964241504669, 0.08619684725999832, 0.029539749026298523, -0.041525278240442276, 0.01102657150477171, 0.007640286814421415, 0.02622474543750286, 0.015230674296617508, 0.05681749805808067, 0.004454324953258038, 0.004130380228161812, 0.031894054263830185, 0.06897436082363129, 0.03413831442594528, -0.01068540383130312, -0.04722415283322334, -0.0011721901828423142, -0.0032372865825891495, -0.02142307534813881, 0.03111959807574749, -0.014941257424652576, -0.016063345596194267, -0.02712061069905758, 0.00555542903020978, -0.037599168717861176, -0.03415936976671219, 0.04034256190061569, -0.05385187640786171, -0.016547104343771935, -0.0004137428186368197, 0.06375515460968018, -0.07140520215034485, 0.01249619573354721, -0.12530559301376343, 0.01598392426967621, -0.00672646751627326, 0.007660052739083767, -0.027210718020796776, 0.025185998529195786, 0.005884546786546707, 0.026763690635561943, 0.011703590862452984, -0.034058231860399246, -0.061976030468940735, 0.032055165618658066, -0.050369374454021454, -0.018345752730965614, 0.0058157616294920444, -0.09322383254766464, 0.01664062961935997, 0.014750837348401546, 0.028913959860801697, 0.01330604963004589, 0.015671491622924805, -0.00924648530781269, 0.01020845863968134, 0.006704906467348337, 0.05154626816511154, 0.022897832095623016, 0.12328353524208069, 0.03594890981912613, -0.02238631248474121, 0.01624634489417076, -0.017078518867492676, -0.014771179296076298, -0.007296663708984852, -0.031767211854457855, 0.08234010636806488, -0.04155869036912918, 0.017608387395739555, -0.014589070342481136, 0.02590620145201683, -0.029912831261754036, -0.0037610267754644156, -0.03265579417347908, 0.035239327698946, -0.010730050504207611, -0.14170284569263458, 0.006247824523597956, -0.0011804979294538498, -0.05417966842651367, -0.009943122044205666, -0.020670954138040543, -0.09320424497127533, -0.011900383979082108, -0.03506157547235489, 0.028558801859617233, -0.023421889171004295, -0.005872227251529694, -0.05853092297911644, -0.03874120116233826, -0.0028408265206962824, 0.018848387524485588, 0.04489041119813919, -0.1150972843170166, -0.048337146639823914, -0.03191252052783966, 0.008050911128520966, 0.0284123495221138, 0.1379064917564392, -0.042889032512903214, -0.006197053473442793, -0.08164722472429276, -0.06942971795797348, -0.0039469096809625626, 0.036734431982040405, 0.04279569536447525, -0.016760291531682014, 0.06766559183597565, 0.03706159070134163, 0.08719731867313385, -0.006165211088955402, 0.046710193157196045, -0.03946543112397194, 0.08964555710554123, -0.07183754444122314, -0.015767626464366913, -0.047832198441028595, 0.04579950124025345, 0.018958549946546555, -0.031369637697935104, -0.054491523653268814, 0.06482869386672974, 0.021242141723632812, -0.015502450056374073, 0.07115136086940765, 0.028029218316078186, -0.004850063938647509, -0.02450566738843918, 0.06608458608388901, -0.007231130264699459, -0.004913762677460909, 0.07899682968854904, 0.06129138171672821, 0.014889144338667393, -0.03487325832247734, 0.060618799179792404, 0.029821982607245445, 0.026122182607650757, -0.02284192480146885, -0.07088861614465714, 0.038297247141599655, 0.0679037794470787, 0.0075951917096972466, -0.04336865246295929, 0.02759351022541523, -0.006809989456087351, 0.0030251790303736925, -0.028718004003167152, -0.013735205866396427, 0.019422905519604683, 0.0019623618572950363, -0.040803272277116776, 0.03149688243865967, -0.0013273523654788733, 0.013641268014907837, -0.05368960648775101, -0.06700068712234497, -0.00958295539021492, -0.05212362855672836, 0.022247962653636932, -0.00940130278468132, 0.10448384284973145, -0.02444891817867756, 0.014958743005990982, -0.005114743951708078, 0.014524165540933609, 0.0334860160946846, 0.009935475885868073, 0.006339141633361578, -0.02832266315817833, -0.02516871877014637, -0.02272270992398262, -0.0050587221048772335, -0.04847230762243271, 0.006597832310944796, -0.029917806386947632, 0.01839401014149189, -0.01418448705226183, 0.027711274102330208, 0.06701973080635071, 0.01697314903140068, 0.07310470938682556, 0.005093960557132959, -0.019187038764357567, -0.007908539846539497, 0.048433396965265274, -0.0009024167666211724, -0.05355308577418327, -0.008564320392906666, -0.05871262028813362, 0.011800727806985378, 0.07537302374839783, -0.014174260199069977, 0.028305012732744217, -0.052348650991916656, -0.02677801437675953, 0.03523244336247444, 0.07070652395486832, 0.028377113863825798, -0.06732182204723358, 0.06424813717603683, -0.013259915634989738, 0.0093705914914608, -0.05520601570606232, 0.015975043177604675, 0.04118114337325096, 0.02749987505376339, -0.028281522914767265, 0.015713617205619812, 0.07953223586082458, 0.06893054395914078, -0.016030915081501007, -0.08157852292060852, 0.041534796357154846, -0.004552708938717842, 0.06999509036540985, -0.040071167051792145, -0.03860364109277725, 0.05014572665095329, 0.021173542365431786, 0.035352982580661774, 0.030696706846356392, -0.04363982006907463, 0.03253231197595596, 0.030018141493201256, 0.018544884398579597, 0.020492997020483017, 0.042934197932481766, 0.08753867447376251, -0.04396172612905502, -0.05226682126522064, -0.03654523566365242, 0.04883267730474472, -0.06293315440416336, -0.0294841006398201, -0.011103196069598198, 0.024802127853035927, 0.058959804475307465, -0.06491491198539734, -0.03016548603773117, 0.1259501725435257, 0.01399941835552454, -0.05481485649943352, -0.010864466428756714, 0.05332319065928459, 0.011663527227938175, -0.010841697454452515, -0.02141408436000347, 0.0035634965170174837, 0.001333343330770731, 0.033745333552360535, -0.0011234855046495795, -0.024540144950151443, -0.02739035151898861, -0.005091232247650623, 0.07126434892416, 0.07073114812374115, 0.04222356155514717, -0.013854739256203175, -0.09829778224229813, -0.037498585879802704, 0.13725826144218445, -0.05561221390962601, 0.02846495248377323 ]
229
229
Prediction with expert evaluators' advice
We introduce a new protocol for prediction with expert advice in which each expert evaluates the learner's and his own performance using a loss function that may change over time and may be different from the loss functions used by the other experts. The learner's goal is to perform better or not much worse than each expert, as evaluated by that expert, for all experts simultaneously. If the loss functions used by the experts are all proper scoring rules and all mixable, we show that the defensive forecasting algorithm enjoys the same performance guarantee as that attainable by the Aggregating Algorithm in the standard setting and known to be optimal. This result is also applied to the case of "specialist" (or "sleeping") experts. In this case, the defensive forecasting algorithm reduces to a simple modification of the Aggregating Algorithm.
[ -0.0014982987195253372, -0.00495282094925642, -0.016117682680487633, -0.009456631727516651, -0.02102750539779663, -0.06007106974720955, -0.03702566400170326, -0.025295544415712357, 0.0034208428114652634, -0.014183519408106804, -0.016963230445981026, -0.04404792562127113, -0.055634647607803345, 0.0265512615442276, 0.09057673066854477, -0.009256863966584206, -0.03321162983775139, 0.04277369752526283, -0.04751211777329445, -0.0028303826693445444, 0.08067498356103897, -0.020730357617139816, 0.06790696829557419, -0.07166336476802826, -0.04729243740439415, -0.061024799942970276, -0.003434996586292982, -0.005930445156991482, 0.012649709358811378, 0.058756981045007706, -0.05344315618276596, -0.0018983540358021855, 0.033891238272190094, -0.012616327963769436, 0.0723377913236618, 0.022427449002861977, 0.06751173734664917, -0.06167306378483772, -0.029631586745381355, 0.009228155016899109, 0.00677510304376483, -0.04007934033870697, -0.0019520686473697424, -0.01030243281275034, -0.03793960064649582, -0.031197072938084602, 0.02528434619307518, -0.044630929827690125, 0.0070719122886657715, 0.02264091558754444, -0.032556451857089996, -0.03473200276494026, 0.03518754616379738, -0.010049204342067242, 0.030238822102546692, 0.013703113421797752, -0.05314091965556145, -0.07457856833934784, -0.006329808849841356, -0.09802419692277908, -0.02661893144249916, 0.055625688284635544, -0.08018223196268082, -0.02305222488939762, 0.015963884070515633, 0.008401368744671345, -0.08259165287017822, 0.023601341992616653, -0.006170209962874651, 0.009655862115323544, 0.042781177908182144, 0.002363593317568302, 0.06605389714241028, -0.010690921917557716, -0.016331160441040993, -0.05442557856440544, 0.016178887337446213, 0.022972244769334793, 0.01975942961871624, 0.07838498800992966, -0.10047522932291031, -0.0021422968711704016, 0.040424495935440063, 0.04865516722202301, 0.04466196894645691, -0.05460764095187187, -0.0061570690013468266, -0.005171694327145815, -0.03532162308692932, -0.05364377051591873, 0.005757761187851429, 0.043683070689439774, -0.06646567583084106, 0.022521711885929108, 0.016598809510469437, 0.07787365466356277, -0.033450059592723846, -0.03645034506917, 0.0814264789223671, 0.024007704108953476, 0.03670871630311012, 0.03835418075323105, 0.0373862199485302, 0.05396462604403496, -0.05822695419192314, 0.0026988277677446604, 0.0265183188021183, 0.002144100610166788, 0.056443799287080765, 0.04279725253582001, 0.0058243852108716965, -0.012051348574459553, -0.016931183636188507, 0.008702736347913742, 0.0028953691944479942, 0.05890730395913124, -0.04620366916060448, 0.05187123641371727, 0.006655750796198845, 0.020518358796834946, 0.04705893248319626, 0.01957986317574978, -0.03520943224430084, 0.024208296090364456, 0.022035278379917145, -0.03844556212425232, -0.013929135166108608, -0.04531923681497574, 0.0651593804359436, 0.008383961394429207, -0.03300812095403671, 0.041296668350696564, -0.04516853764653206, -0.018808599561452866, 0.003558166092261672, 0.04347648844122887, 0.054647963494062424, -0.0326375775039196, -0.02922927774488926, 0.004419280681759119, 0.01161910966038704, 0.021455757319927216, -0.028831543400883675, 0.036779552698135376, 0.04280392825603485, 0.0009279295336455107, 0.04982905089855194, -0.014644493348896503, -0.08993136882781982, -0.008858059532940388, 0.013440865091979504, -0.002602099906653166, 0.06350111961364746, 0.06478054076433182, 0.016650298610329628, -0.010580847971141338, -0.05868775025010109, -0.05781157314777374, -0.037095628678798676, 0.06042089685797691, 0.04765301197767258, 0.060726556926965714, 0.06379573792219162, 0.03550630807876587, 0.043661825358867645, 0.03403535112738609, -0.045673176646232605, -0.014766780659556389, -0.07828856259584427, -0.09893348813056946, -0.06416397541761398, -0.020539898425340652, 0.00911856908351183, -0.06626151502132416, -0.018106335774064064, -0.046189527958631516, -0.016884317621588707, -0.025469450280070305, 0.03027929738163948, -0.01388095784932375, 0.04362685978412628, 0.015573723241686821, -0.04837708920240402, -0.04323272407054901, 0.09012491255998611, 0.08267397433519363, -0.0191538967192173, 0.09241411089897156, 0.03754765912890434, 0.023102719336748123, 0.0037181724328547716, -0.005889050662517548, -0.03041335754096508, -0.002019367879256606, -0.021842312067747116, 0.06307349354028702, -0.048193808645009995, -0.029727274551987648, -0.014674183912575245, 0.05669352784752846, 0.07147916406393051, 0.022140368819236755, 0.015612411312758923, -0.03548309952020645, -0.08270299434661865, -0.00839212816208601, 0.03772657737135887, -0.06370218843221664, 0.03285945579409599, -0.029817314818501472, 0.08862247318029404, -0.07434467226266861, -0.04429733753204346, -0.03109246864914894, -0.024381248280405998, -0.025767264887690544, 0.006420607678592205, -0.08875419199466705, -0.005429387558251619, 0.012494506314396858, 0.05466240271925926, 0.03116057626903057, -0.011122805066406727, -0.04130634665489197, -0.085238978266716, -0.025081828236579895, 0.002212622668594122, 0.017723843455314636, -0.08006448298692703, 0.04510549455881119, -0.04406039044260979, -0.021315114572644234, 0.0076524182222783566, -0.018393227830529213, -0.03828487917780876, 0.008134207688272, 0.0017566297901794314, -0.09230325371026993, -0.0489703007042408, -0.0006562208291143179, 0.019377410411834717, 0.0563424676656723, -0.05147550255060196, -0.008655525743961334, 0.03551039844751358, -0.05459848791360855, 0.030958479270339012, -0.005964090581983328, -0.06081680208444595, 0.004101536236703396, 0.07367932051420212, 0.041367217898368835, 0.0017940376419574022, 0.027582475915551186, 0.038726624101400375, 0.026723435148596764, 0.02288069948554039, 0.08653722703456879, 0.08597809076309204, 0.019903268665075302, -0.011854402720928192, 0.04927271604537964, -0.036740031093358994, -0.01865878328680992, -0.01901305839419365, -0.02290300838649273, -0.012651662342250347, 0.04934368655085564, -0.06785129010677338, -0.01524075772613287, -0.051828257739543915, -0.0020534018985927105, -0.013845999725162983, 0.08364307880401611, -0.015695584937930107, -0.08810891211032867, 0.04266229271888733, 0.050754182040691376, 0.06443290412425995, -0.007893573492765427, -0.01706874556839466, 0.03063846193253994, 0.0022760971914976835, -0.013219214975833893, -0.03212076425552368, -0.05559718236327171, -0.039943959563970566, -0.0028912026900798082, -0.018920710310339928, 0.04211636260151863, -0.09341246634721756, -0.012503392063081264, -0.0811401829123497, 0.040847618132829666, 0.0004068465204909444, -0.03413721174001694, 0.018156249076128006, 0.04414869844913483, 0.039088647812604904, 0.02211228385567665, -0.03790309280157089, 0.004559921100735664, 0.032413311302661896, 0.10348673909902573, 0.047232937067747116, 0.08559409528970718, 0.08129418641328812, 0.08582989126443863, -0.005258774384856224, 0.004333993420004845, 0.03343721106648445, -0.05758417397737503, 0.0013958974741399288, 0.004442929290235043, 0.022904308512806892, 0.04697498306632042, -0.07166839390993118, 0.02616734243929386, -0.04600551724433899, 0.024414807558059692, -0.013220714405179024, -0.06957901269197464, 0.02234361134469509, 0.01760389655828476, -0.08995738625526428, 0.0022837785072624683, 0.03819524869322777, 0.03699609264731407, -0.041016075760126114, 0.0992901474237442, -0.03412909433245659, 0.04060813784599304, 0.021074514836072922, 0.04477066174149513, -0.11353207379579544, -0.01843489147722721, -0.0010547151323407888, -0.0002973269729409367, 0.03442053124308586, 0.010701905936002731, -0.08589296787977219, -0.028553815558552742, -0.007768602576106787, -0.03197973221540451, -0.023700019344687462, 0.054095812141895294, 0.11173404008150101, -0.0038509531877934933, -0.030202591791749, 0.05777031555771828, -0.017540838569402695, -0.04694370925426483, 0.04315454885363579, -0.0029421986546367407, 0.00916493684053421, -0.007130330894142389, -0.03465142846107483, -0.025604885071516037, -0.06293746083974838, 0.05445178225636482, 0.008008412085473537, 0.006802923046052456, -0.04702476039528847, -0.06929411739110947, 0.035874344408512115, 0.05490376055240631, -0.020001757889986038, 0.05368396267294884, -0.05592620000243187, -0.0719083771109581, -0.021951423957943916, 0.017528939992189407, 0.020359262824058533, -0.03347252309322357, 0.03915940597653389, -0.039531562477350235, 0.04082121327519417, -0.046705733984708786, 0.008215467445552349, 0.07545492053031921, 0.004854603670537472, 0.029927683994174004, -0.06686590611934662, -0.08617664128541946, -0.029100429266691208, -0.0016825621714815497, -0.03134872019290924, -0.015721209347248077, 0.08648952841758728, -0.007210616022348404, -0.056002821773290634, -0.021109845489263535, -0.06940241158008575, 0.0371093787252903, 0.032980699092149734, 0.04265134409070015, 0.02219333127140999, -0.02603415958583355, -0.03167715296149254, 0.010021650232374668, -0.007002366706728935, -0.05093555897474289, 0.015020579099655151, -0.06938355416059494, -0.07384954392910004, 0.029476039111614227, 0.05791014805436134, 0.023904507979750633, 0.04391131177544594, 0.02893677167594433, 0.031745243817567825, 0.0395219549536705, -0.058056313544511795, -0.02381143346428871, -0.01574189029633999, -0.004279912915080786, 0.016622712835669518, 0.04785047471523285, -0.03373238071799278, -0.016016149893403053, -0.03733528405427933, 0.06799416989088058, 0.014545323327183723, 0.014267783612012863, 0.11119958013296127, 0.017715122550725937, 0.023090846836566925, 0.05529662221670151, -0.04312994331121445, 0.003360150149092078, -0.10445096343755722, -0.05449449643492699, -0.07783734053373337, -0.06312248855829239, 0.07212699949741364, -0.038275327533483505, 0.10352886468172073, -0.055879443883895874, -0.03550267592072487, -0.005995552055537701, -0.07819788157939911, -0.02791031450033188, 0.06766492128372192, 0.04978874698281288, -0.007936310954391956, 0.058202389627695084, -0.025567928329110146, 0.01785438135266304, 0.05709558725357056, -0.01300064753741026, 0.03030271828174591, 0.0005448449519462883, -0.03275081887841225, -0.06510841101408005, 0.04496080055832863, -0.03508012369275093, -0.030207255855202675, 0.020076874643564224, 0.012390682473778725, -0.07440725713968277, -0.043019477277994156, -0.035198453813791275, 0.019232556223869324, 0.04981132969260216, -0.04614052549004555, -0.028999483212828636, -0.013822694309055805, 0.04354775696992874, 0.05354432761669159, -0.0345432348549366, -0.028519967570900917, -0.06213722378015518, 0.024062128737568855, -0.09131979197263718, -0.06625174731016159, -0.0032743585761636496, 0.018824378028512, 0.002118689939379692, -0.02768782153725624, 0.08722175657749176, 0.008908136747777462, 0.06820783764123917, -0.011283021420240402, 0.03493339940905571, -0.0059125181287527084, 0.011282463558018208, -0.008023058995604515, 0.07024641335010529, -0.00475282734259963, 0.026469171047210693, 0.0148141635581851, -0.0028102644719183445, -0.025091616436839104, 0.007257210556417704, 0.012991429306566715, 0.051902394741773605, 0.06030987948179245, -0.07233887165784836, -0.006088380701839924, 0.0704091265797615, 0.044169146567583084, 0.005426571238785982, -0.017799003049731255, 0.04481096193194389, -0.015148614533245564, 0.012427919544279575, 0.048840150237083435, 0.03090948984026909, 0.0363728366792202, 0.029643747955560684, 0.0352918766438961, 0.03180122375488281 ]
230
230
Multiplicative updates For Non-Negative Kernel SVM
We present multiplicative updates for solving hard and soft margin support vector machines (SVM) with non-negative kernels. They follow as a natural extension of the updates for non-negative matrix factorization. No additional param- eter setting, such as choosing learning, rate is required. Ex- periments demonstrate rapid convergence to good classifiers. We analyze the rates of asymptotic convergence of the up- dates and establish tight bounds. We test the performance on several datasets using various non-negative kernels and report equivalent generalization errors to that of a standard SVM.
[ -0.03815305978059769, -0.07352089136838913, 0.04745472967624664, -0.016381023451685905, -0.01826438307762146, -0.08662303537130356, 0.013089870102703571, 0.015107061713933945, -0.010782764293253422, -0.027651472017169, 0.04389161244034767, 0.02029116451740265, -0.019116688519716263, 0.05977332219481468, 0.003361581824719906, 0.028642969205975533, 0.08228836208581924, 0.0002436328213661909, -0.022455167025327682, -0.09932823479175568, 0.07096721976995468, -0.015428525395691395, 0.020031310617923737, -0.054723870009183884, -0.009667766280472279, 0.034527070820331573, -0.04734502360224724, -0.013948144391179085, 0.09895871579647064, 0.01365732867270708, -0.019983908161520958, -0.03971609100699425, -0.004244439769536257, 0.06777244806289673, -0.048130761831998825, -0.06944043934345245, 0.038685426115989685, -0.008039710111916065, -0.0857393890619278, -0.08642461150884628, -0.03266298398375511, 0.0031285795848816633, 0.03142334520816803, 0.016199015080928802, 0.024430828168988228, 0.0555548369884491, 0.06388169527053833, 0.06937891244888306, 0.009711343795061111, 0.08321750909090042, -0.004756938200443983, 0.004229580983519554, -0.06977127492427826, -0.0506470762193203, 0.01869717426598072, -0.05402917042374611, 0.003554609138518572, -0.0245859082788229, 0.02382236160337925, -0.012427021749317646, 0.044226206839084625, 0.031384654343128204, 0.03260074928402901, -0.05213657394051552, -0.04699055477976799, -0.06416825205087662, -0.003946579992771149, -0.038438424468040466, -0.015112526714801788, -0.029847683385014534, -0.015238398686051369, -0.07435346394777298, 0.009429054334759712, 0.10103641450405121, 0.04259885847568512, 0.0053188675083220005, -0.04761839285492897, 0.030511271208524704, 0.06756506860256195, 0.06335893273353577, -0.029023298993706703, -0.03745272755622864, 0.07905181497335434, 0.02445749193429947, 0.07649736851453781, -0.015903035178780556, -0.007223544176667929, -0.03966127708554268, -0.017973897978663445, -0.06528820842504501, 0.07713500410318375, 0.05778728052973747, -0.05373034626245499, 0.013755694963037968, 0.02801254764199257, -0.02324184775352478, -0.028906775638461113, -0.0060958052054047585, 0.023748502135276794, -0.024114830419421196, -0.04960118979215622, 0.012859812937676907, 0.06483912467956543, 0.04848705977201462, -0.02084328420460224, 0.0024362653493881226, -0.04022524505853653, -0.0036567444913089275, 0.011292845942080021, -0.004144104663282633, 0.04787348955869675, -0.026917286217212677, -0.007535199634730816, 0.018842823803424835, -0.021619020029902458, 0.08779633790254593, -0.010473806411027908, 0.03392884135246277, 0.04604756087064743, 0.035117555409669876, -0.01939619705080986, -0.02443234995007515, -0.08861090242862701, 0.09292299300432205, 0.03827035799622536, -0.04302376136183739, -0.002327220980077982, -0.07707326859235764, 0.06582578271627426, -0.017418891191482544, -0.05910355970263481, 0.021254578605294228, 0.00843476690351963, 0.06814981997013092, -0.05219254642724991, 0.06177549064159393, -0.019282814115285873, -0.051102735102176666, -0.06645301729440689, 0.05914861708879471, -0.01755513995885849, 0.057127695530653, -0.02509443275630474, -0.019628332927823067, 0.08783626556396484, 0.007157293148338795, 0.025170816108584404, 0.008942246437072754, -0.00886770710349083, -0.026481201872229576, 0.027389628812670708, 0.01486838050186634, 0.002934854244813323, 0.010461769998073578, 0.038762882351875305, -0.020652275532484055, -0.05642397701740265, -0.055720891803503036, -0.04299459978938103, -0.000045143729948904365, -0.07284645736217499, 0.023010719567537308, -0.026396380737423897, 0.03372858464717865, -0.0037759938277304173, -0.0888144001364708, -0.023923201486468315, 0.006568432319909334, -0.028433920815587044, -0.08035555481910706, -0.03359676152467728, -0.05050031468272209, -0.04937073588371277, 0.054653316736221313, -0.00004389170862850733, 0.08693676441907883, 0.012743256986141205, 0.02854745090007782, -0.056752875447273254, -0.01806109957396984, 0.029272887855768204, -0.027299223467707634, -0.014325550757348537, -0.03513060882687569, 0.13568530976772308, 0.05994066968560219, -0.015505977906286716, 0.012854269705712795, 0.055396486073732376, -0.015844913199543953, 0.04765831679105759, -0.051573965698480606, -0.02934504672884941, -0.0313337966799736, -0.09430842101573944, -0.019665174186229706, -0.022410031408071518, -0.03141083940863609, 0.0237759817391634, 0.1255423128604889, 0.03366297110915184, -0.03980276733636856, 0.0048157405108213425, -0.06727655231952667, 0.051421236246824265, 0.01780872419476509, 0.0053071011789143085, 0.0035275262780487537, 0.02198985405266285, 0.015265148133039474, 0.054889798164367676, 0.03689631074666977, -0.0015787470620125532, 0.000019465427612885833, -0.0003776545054279268, -0.040274571627378464, 0.029396703466773033, 0.009490877389907837, 0.06002306565642357, 0.024523353204131126, 0.006667759269475937, 0.033527158200740814, -0.018559152260422707, 0.013053522445261478, -0.059168290346860886, 0.0211038775742054, 0.001304494682699442, -0.03096618875861168, -0.050170138478279114, 0.05596613883972168, -0.06815792620182037, -0.07288146018981934, -0.04006318747997284, -0.02984384074807167, -0.02925395593047142, 0.026293573901057243, -0.04584236070513725, -0.043214574456214905, 0.02279105968773365, 0.017332885414361954, -0.01703234389424324, -0.04995414987206459, -0.047802556306123734, -0.04123250022530556, 0.04476997256278992, -0.07940452545881271, -0.031011758372187614, 0.01651865243911743, 0.009545556269586086, 0.000672911643050611, 0.02939024567604065, 0.05325575917959213, -0.022860728204250336, -0.018370183184742928, 0.030137790367007256, -0.008092397823929787, 0.013006213121116161, 0.08339853584766388, 0.014127971604466438, 0.06242115795612335, -0.004392536822706461, 0.047269176691770554, -0.015678931027650833, -0.034486252814531326, 0.047071222215890884, -0.041509609669446945, -0.0648839995265007, -0.025159886106848717, 0.046351782977581024, 0.036778826266527176, 0.00043486966751515865, -0.07942433655261993, -0.03906566649675369, 0.036031585186719894, -0.03612583503127098, 0.002172214211896062, 0.02047024480998516, -0.022236062213778496, -0.03197445347905159, -0.02878820337355137, -0.02707502618432045, -0.025431470945477486, -0.06304562836885452, 0.015188955701887608, 0.006837436463683844, 0.01467258669435978, 0.02139146625995636, 0.006122034974396229, 0.02193470299243927, 0.0032598136458545923, -0.033262699842453, 0.026825502514839172, 0.029939230531454086, -0.027647916227579117, 0.03984573110938072, -0.07449810206890106, 0.05926358327269554, 0.00896212924271822, 0.0012152338167652488, -0.0030717893969267607, 0.06500772386789322, 0.034552332013845444, 0.014551379717886448, -0.05386553332209587, 0.0005806871340610087, 0.010657825507223606, 0.034817710518836975, 0.003540345700457692, -0.05924507603049278, 0.052481312304735184, -0.01897476054728031, 0.01937597244977951, -0.04702715203166008, -0.083783820271492, 0.047760821878910065, 0.026916081085801125, 0.002743916818872094, 0.033842772245407104, -0.004296221770346165, -0.039489999413490295, 0.04175734519958496, 0.03354784846305847, -0.019510453566908836, -0.05221755430102348, -0.10500402003526688, -0.04542926698923111, -0.019085073843598366, 0.061448704451322556, -0.045103900134563446, 0.0379355363547802, -0.058743346482515335, 0.036042287945747375, -0.06396134942770004, -0.006073780823498964, 0.05568355321884155, 0.009858177043497562, 0.006245855242013931, -0.03602214902639389, -0.020622771233320236, 0.0008101460989564657, -0.03584788367152214, -0.06126025691628456, -0.00016691585187800229, 0.025225935503840446, -0.02323654107749462, 0.0052804225124418736, 0.05435251444578171, -0.031377483159303665, -0.05222218483686447, 0.009243117645382881, -0.03346119448542595, 0.03391050547361374, -0.08116579800844193, 0.037119485437870026, -0.037571050226688385, -0.003257687669247389, 0.05573166161775589, -0.007135937921702862, 0.026249201968312263, 0.030816607177257538, -0.04975174367427826, -0.026134826242923737, -0.01669159159064293, 0.035215482115745544, 0.048963144421577454, 0.07536900788545609, -0.020708521828055382, -0.03951355814933777, 0.010931002907454967, 0.031143303960561752, -0.09704045951366425, 0.013193591497838497, 0.10815659910440445, 0.044155023992061615, 0.05528080835938454, -0.02004951611161232, 0.05954808369278908, 0.03364301845431328, -0.015872206538915634, 0.06362272053956985, -0.023622840642929077, -0.03838856518268585, 0.011868666857481003, 0.07868534326553345, -0.01443890668451786, -0.024803996086120605, -0.07164789736270905, 0.018828677013516426, 0.10281828045845032, -0.004211958032101393, -0.069631427526474, -0.07533183693885803, -0.0272546224296093, 0.06908416002988815, -0.019155431538820267, 0.02692713774740696, 0.037379417568445206, -0.02213152125477791, -0.06611373275518417, -0.0674741119146347, 0.0470256544649601, -0.0376441515982151, 0.07383278012275696, -0.023403918370604515, -0.0469355583190918, -0.008408592082560062, -0.040631089359521866, 0.11757288873195648, 0.003341358620673418, 0.14113815128803253, -0.02488771826028824, 0.03176770359277725, -0.020531995221972466, 0.012780219316482544, 0.04004101827740669, 0.06146839261054993, -0.008638807572424412, -0.04277578368782997, 0.040092483162879944, -0.07096345722675323, 0.016638217493891716, 0.06659406423568726, 0.07440121471881866, 0.018643172457814217, 0.020838899537920952, 0.034527234733104706, 0.026635225862264633, 0.11602164059877396, -0.02800319343805313, 0.017170146107673645, -0.12971408665180206, 0.03913426771759987, -0.02870466373860836, -0.03160061314702034, 0.05469387769699097, 0.004031517077237368, 0.0439748577773571, 0.0047076097689569, 0.024266492575407028, -0.046682506799697876, -0.018583493307232857, 0.0256931371986866, -0.07765763252973557, -0.05730212852358818, 0.011295846663415432, 0.045797742903232574, -0.037595491856336594, 0.015964319929480553, 0.05615886300802231, 0.06422407180070877, 0.0010070346761494875, 0.032410793006420135, -0.011356672272086143, 0.010320126079022884, 0.0349084734916687, 0.029643328860402107, -0.051592521369457245, -0.03335755318403244, 0.027011966332793236, -0.010955067351460457, 0.0072488244622945786, -0.01156542543321848, 0.0002227815130027011, 0.06903612613677979, -0.03562501072883606, -0.03761628270149231, -0.07193458080291748, 0.021339084953069687, -0.00229603867046535, 0.009929006919264793, -0.009678160771727562, -0.01863691955804825, 0.0413493886590004, -0.017874019220471382, 0.03961032256484032, 0.01982934959232807, 0.02542632631957531, -0.062798872590065, -0.008653433993458748, -0.0685320496559143, 0.02060171216726303, -0.08672132343053818, -0.007262746803462505, -0.011717022396624088, -0.0024122013710439205, 0.052988991141319275, -0.01927763596177101, 0.08976901322603226, 0.022792065516114235, -0.009505223482847214, -0.05915197357535362, 0.010437501594424248, 0.041064243763685226, 0.024355275556445122, -0.0073859961703419685, -0.02897261083126068, -0.030184084549546242, -0.07129312306642532, -0.020056117326021194, 0.012286937795579433, 0.05627302825450897, -0.010249870829284191, 0.019262561574578285, 0.009318995289504528, 0.05076325684785843, 0.041406869888305664, 0.009980614297091961, -0.03519978001713753, 0.004818607121706009, 0.03483210876584053, -0.08077686280012131, -0.04396063834428787 ]
231
231
Manipulation Robustness of Collaborative Filtering Systems
A collaborative filtering system recommends to users products that similar users like. Collaborative filtering systems influence purchase decisions, and hence have become targets of manipulation by unscrupulous vendors. We provide theoretical and empirical results demonstrating that while common nearest neighbor algorithms, which are widely used in commercial systems, can be highly susceptible to manipulation, two classes of collaborative filtering algorithms which we refer to as linear and asymptotically linear are relatively robust. These results provide guidance for the design of future collaborative filtering systems.
[ 0.04085263982415199, -0.04705416411161423, 0.003584696678444743, -0.01209321990609169, 0.08472585678100586, -0.03833460807800293, -0.013273000717163086, 0.0048257275484502316, -0.035004351288080215, 0.027592511847615242, 0.10211670398712158, -0.060414232313632965, 0.022399885579943657, 0.0875813364982605, 0.018562352284789085, -0.018167713657021523, 0.010739082470536232, 0.05743173137307167, -0.0014027297729626298, -0.024266336113214493, -0.03546919301152229, -0.05026403069496155, -0.0560087151825428, 0.04371202364563942, -0.025942886248230934, -0.009206430986523628, -0.015382060781121254, 0.07424616813659668, 0.024238746613264084, -0.0008768256520852447, -0.01168664451688528, -0.03376580774784088, 0.03655808046460152, -0.05157097429037094, 0.05169133096933365, -0.08211549371480942, 0.04576590657234192, 0.00890327338129282, -0.011399799957871437, 0.05186311528086662, -0.021832618862390518, 0.011369260959327221, 0.04751316085457802, -0.027815867215394974, 0.0520489476621151, -0.06361788511276245, 0.009523896500468254, 0.04558868333697319, 0.024903401732444763, 0.014110423624515533, -0.062287382781505585, 0.00921336468309164, -0.07027347385883331, 0.057199627161026, 0.017690060660243034, 0.0051910411566495895, -0.0026621848810464144, -0.009473759680986404, 0.06206456199288368, 0.0012882021255791187, 0.03578320890665054, 0.10901021212339401, -0.05582330748438835, -0.0667031928896904, -0.036144476383924484, -0.0567270927131176, -0.016859352588653564, -0.03281771391630173, -0.07494963705539703, -0.08465404808521271, 0.0365329384803772, -0.02329208329319954, 0.007358354050666094, 0.009924398735165596, 0.02174374647438526, 0.01534530520439148, 0.018906373530626297, 0.03356767073273659, 0.028987223282456398, 0.08549773693084717, -0.09427996724843979, 0.008565538562834263, 0.02867707796394825, 0.05119331181049347, -0.025305047631263733, -0.006857794243842363, 0.08646587282419205, -0.03641340881586075, -0.026052577421069145, 0.024400008842349052, -0.042845238000154495, 0.008483974263072014, -0.08570210635662079, -0.03680901974439621, -0.04321715235710144, -0.08933359384536743, 0.012589218094944954, 0.06625325232744217, 0.04151201248168945, 0.00797518901526928, 0.04846943914890289, 0.012048471719026566, 0.059105489403009415, -0.009251674637198448, -0.07181056588888168, 0.005510535091161728, -0.06372933089733124, 0.010882779955863953, 0.0259038507938385, 0.013174419291317463, 0.02748679555952549, 0.005052391905337572, -0.04333903267979622, 0.061013709753751755, -0.009784530848264694, 0.016613394021987915, 0.0045203035697340965, 0.07235347479581833, -0.05961013212800026, 0.02900076098740101, -0.0721881315112114, 0.03647354990243912, -0.02345024049282074, 0.06115672364830971, -0.031245701014995575, -0.038757260888814926, -0.04287349060177803, 0.015863824635744095, 0.09472277760505676, -0.06656262278556824, -0.13067729771137238, 0.043482858687639236, -0.05258246883749962, -0.008407268673181534, -0.03940734639763832, 0.0011782357469201088, 0.04282383248209953, -0.017952395603060722, -0.052521880716085434, 0.0582108236849308, -0.005001956131309271, 0.008629800751805305, -0.03010365180671215, -0.0040359473787248135, 0.04205169156193733, -0.04846789687871933, 0.013420064002275467, 0.024659190326929092, 0.10753117501735687, -0.03177274763584137, -0.07551655173301697, 0.01636236160993576, 0.04400379955768585, 0.04095211997628212, 0.006038057617843151, -0.010006928816437721, -0.058401256799697876, -0.0739516094326973, -0.028861550614237785, 0.052308425307273865, 0.012453429400920868, 0.051154207438230515, 0.017862597480416298, -0.01136665791273117, -0.012421298772096634, -0.04972028732299805, -0.013458761386573315, -0.005206770729273558, -0.0412888266146183, -0.07931871712207794, -0.009219598956406116, -0.07675566524267197, -0.028587128967046738, 0.002358865225687623, 0.044002555310726166, -0.06620027869939804, -0.04801306501030922, -0.0092817647382617, -0.03055647574365139, -0.0284116230905056, 0.06158290430903435, -0.03685677796602249, -0.0043619475327432156, 0.0069091059267520905, 0.06278155744075775, 0.08416599035263062, 0.015084771439433098, -0.0052161142230033875, 0.05891704559326172, 0.05835185572504997, 0.06118020787835121, -0.024272073060274124, 0.006406267639249563, 0.028055552393198013, -0.03936614841222763, 0.01825137808918953, -0.022654633969068527, -0.13894373178482056, -0.016458725556731224, 0.022252054885029793, 0.03897211700677872, -0.027810947969555855, -0.003989139571785927, -0.058806948363780975, -0.05581508204340935, -0.004208446945995092, -0.01605970971286297, -0.04944693297147751, -0.02822726219892502, -0.005507408641278744, 0.004802139941602945, 0.07360318303108215, -0.03012498840689659, 0.04072786867618561, 0.03147817775607109, -0.04745577648282051, -0.037658076733350754, -0.03750404343008995, 0.09448934346437454, 0.061702750623226166, -0.008781278505921364, -0.0018826904706656933, -0.022842491045594215, 0.019638989120721817, -0.02611614018678665, 0.013967927545309067, 0.01679818332195282, 0.002031372394412756, -0.07343000173568726, 0.03959571197628975, -0.11476624757051468, -0.046178847551345825, -0.04304659739136696, 0.039590802043676376, 0.013247085735201836, 0.01886262185871601, -0.015822075307369232, -0.0972728282213211, -0.01000952161848545, -0.02548808604478836, -0.029224922880530357, 0.021620500832796097, 0.035890884697437286, -0.04470457136631012, -0.006430057808756828, 0.004286094103008509, -0.03072020225226879, 0.0527895987033844, 0.0063050007447600365, -0.056918445974588394, 0.0749366506934166, -0.01103069819509983, -0.033503297716379166, 0.028204234316945076, 0.03314150497317314, 0.08590354025363922, -0.0673929750919342, 0.01885124295949936, 0.03980158641934395, 0.0602928027510643, 0.041113290935754776, 0.0020500586833804846, -0.018009116873145103, 0.028689639642834663, 0.0895104855298996, 0.06433076411485672, 0.06409438699483871, 0.08040918409824371, 0.026851899921894073, 0.07412603497505188, 0.01524114515632391, -0.08159147202968597, -0.04621151462197304, 0.14842790365219116, -0.07481908798217773, -0.01746167615056038, -0.0011718765599653125, 0.02512894570827484, -0.017149578779935837, -0.06509285420179367, -0.02781866304576397, 0.05646651238203049, -0.0001466403336962685, 0.04819631949067116, -0.015587344765663147, 0.007725598756223917, -0.023917051032185555, 0.009157252497971058, 0.04835375025868416, 0.012359722517430782, -0.06305096298456192, 0.030825259163975716, -0.06757903099060059, -0.03146342560648918, -0.048419468104839325, -0.08774945884943008, -0.017487039789557457, 0.0295446515083313, 0.10034120082855225, 0.011286377906799316, 0.01752900891005993, -0.004894178826361895, 0.04059787094593048, 0.04870070144534111, 0.031174488365650177, 0.023217948153614998, 0.026337839663028717, -0.010211559012532234, -0.05878899618983269, -0.04596593976020813, -0.028231270611286163, -0.05699436739087105, -0.03243405371904373, -0.02656654454767704, 0.04861205071210861, 0.03531447798013687, -0.010886790230870247, -0.07068222761154175, -0.011132342740893364, 0.07371629774570465, -0.020794125273823738, -0.03198489919304848, 0.052137672901153564, 0.0312237236648798, -0.057673968374729156, -0.03120163455605507, 0.051156800240278244, 0.044146813452243805, -0.01595940813422203, 0.002312918659299612, -0.05798150971531868, 0.03205929324030876, -0.034747760742902756, 0.011236809194087982, -0.04427495226264, -0.004533674567937851, -0.1085001602768898, -0.03549772873520851, -0.002433092799037695, 0.09680182486772537, -0.015155958011746407, -0.09012908488512039, -0.011169420555233955, -0.03831176832318306, 0.059673286974430084, 0.04805153235793114, 0.0749770924448967, -0.01693314127624035, -0.04693855345249176, 0.006269871722906828, -0.0410703644156456, 0.05835806950926781, 0.017194382846355438, -0.07212761789560318, 0.038521476089954376, 0.052079882472753525, 0.02690795809030533, 0.050405703485012054, 0.007177232764661312, -0.03653137385845184, -0.008436720818281174, 0.024916568771004677, -0.09752538800239563, -0.0005753007135353982, 0.021703802049160004, 0.04393213987350464, -0.010592594742774963, 0.023341525346040726, 0.005793001037091017, -0.024592628702521324, -0.026449931785464287, -0.028380518779158592, 0.0543292798101902, -0.044197943061590195, 0.030492065474390984, -0.05834655463695526, 0.011295922100543976, -0.02702949196100235, -0.014935343526303768, 0.0046906424686312675, 0.03210722655057907, -0.023722847923636436, -0.0471673421561718, -0.03980495035648346, 0.02717110887169838, -0.005083286203444004, -0.023350408300757408, 0.00821671448647976, 0.06478287279605865, 0.022894447669386864, 0.0199808981269598, -0.05137881264090538, -0.02300751395523548, -0.008018205873668194, 0.07466411590576172, -0.019376976415514946, 0.06846100836992264, -0.06685128808021545, -0.003333239583298564, -0.03946918249130249, -0.08867353200912476, -0.032307662069797516, -0.04942682012915611, -0.11291096359491348, 0.0014951961347833276, 0.00965488888323307, -0.00470976997166872, 0.05408959090709686, 0.002737040864303708, 0.037165481597185135, 0.006995183415710926, -0.024949437007308006, -0.04280625283718109, 0.038969725370407104, -0.009112483821809292, -0.032543081790208817, -0.01714807190001011, -0.05923846364021301, 0.052808359265327454, -0.03395772725343704, -0.007601008750498295, 0.010907967574894428, -0.03283604979515076, -0.030722325667738914, -0.05965077877044678, -0.007519285194575787, -0.021803557872772217, 0.03562361001968384, -0.06863775104284286, 0.028873473405838013, -0.0005892833578400314, 0.031653765588998795, 0.03238365799188614, 0.028256947174668312, -0.0073700835928320885, 0.015935223549604416, 0.02116117626428604, -0.02079940401017666, -0.014324220828711987, -0.020936259999871254, 0.008572160266339779, 0.00468300050124526, -0.04694719612598419, -0.026277219876646996, 0.05287626385688782, 0.027677154168486595, -0.024513009935617447, 0.01684419810771942, 0.04429542273283005, 0.05010291561484337, 0.006845609750598669, -0.06449489295482635, 0.03477854281663895, -0.07563985884189606, -0.010125153698027134, 0.015929779037833214, -0.022531112655997276, -0.09164775907993317, 0.07660073041915894, -0.05499560013413429, -0.04053474962711334, -0.040089841932058334, 0.029042178764939308, 0.027196217328310013, -0.0009500262676738203, -0.015806881710886955, 0.04856783524155617, 0.007720035035163164, 0.04304387792944908, 0.030948925763368607, -0.045417048037052155, -0.01008358784019947, 0.04592142999172211, -0.04723102226853371, -0.015622115693986416, -0.039797596633434296, 0.04088817536830902, 0.008306393399834633, -0.03637511283159256, -0.0011314828880131245, 0.025805093348026276, -0.012103556655347347, 0.03097004070878029, -0.03953230381011963, 0.004670686554163694, 0.034549880772829056, -0.014251534827053547, 0.05290868878364563, 0.04889562353491783, -0.0018478373531252146, -0.008555661886930466, -0.05222146585583687, -0.011013355106115341, -0.010483882389962673, -0.04830232635140419, 0.018949612975120544, 0.03154372796416283, 0.008050890639424324, 0.037186842411756516, -0.025972634553909302, 0.04448949545621872, -0.0381784625351429, 0.004790851846337318, -0.029869969934225082, 0.09479619562625885, 0.007808262016624212, 0.07721921801567078, -0.021843725815415382, -0.0218616034835577, 0.007594600785523653, -0.06571009010076523, -0.008302421309053898 ]
232
232
Efficient Human Computation
Collecting large labeled data sets is a laborious and expensive task, whose scaling up requires division of the labeling workload between many teachers. When the number of classes is large, miscorrespondences between the labels given by the different teachers are likely to occur, which, in the extreme case, may reach total inconsistency. In this paper we describe how globally consistent labels can be obtained, despite the absence of teacher coordination, and discuss the possible efficiency of this process in terms of human labor. We define a notion of label efficiency, measuring the ratio between the number of globally consistent labels obtained and the number of labels provided by distributed teachers. We show that the efficiency depends critically on the ratio alpha between the number of data instances seen by a single teacher, and the number of classes. We suggest several algorithms for the distributed labeling problem, and analyze their efficiency as a function of alpha. In addition, we provide an upper bound on label efficiency for the case of completely uncoordinated teachers, and show that efficiency approaches 0 as the ratio between the number of labels each teacher provides and the number of classes drops (i.e. alpha goes to 0).
[ -0.052876804023981094, -0.014519755728542805, 0.028821559622883797, 0.005955158732831478, 0.06382104754447937, -0.08875160664319992, -0.05378846079111099, -0.017651377245783806, -0.05504480004310608, 0.033324360847473145, -0.062460120767354965, 0.05395553261041641, -0.026458321139216423, 0.03147962689399719, 0.034173741936683655, -0.016794821247458458, -0.031186390668153763, 0.024116137996315956, -0.019588999450206757, 0.004638406448066235, 0.05087004601955414, -0.020251119509339333, 0.0590231828391552, -0.05340578407049179, 0.03150932490825653, -0.09058362990617752, -0.03886910527944565, 0.07517210394144058, -0.03637954220175743, 0.012227348983287811, 0.0014153491938486695, 0.011167174205183983, 0.03636953607201576, 0.00815352238714695, -0.00819096714258194, -0.04563610628247261, 0.04813066124916077, 0.025862138718366623, -0.010094860568642616, 0.0011090058833360672, 0.06444884836673737, -0.07382554560899734, 0.020346855744719505, -0.04934366047382355, 0.0037617641501128674, -0.01283652801066637, 0.0319858118891716, 0.004544952418655157, 0.0654827207326889, 0.03841058909893036, -0.005469891242682934, 0.01157350093126297, -0.008760178461670876, 0.025328615680336952, -0.004073191899806261, 0.01583465002477169, -0.029028447344899178, -0.005964318756014109, -0.013261094689369202, -0.04233120009303093, 0.061835478991270065, 0.06907650083303452, -0.06804526597261429, -0.020261995494365692, -0.011117188259959221, -0.01642061024904251, -0.07744397968053818, -0.05329408869147301, -0.0002508640172891319, -0.016314638778567314, 0.02389816753566265, -0.008343656547367573, 0.08775526285171509, 0.016694143414497375, 0.05987215414643288, -0.004221872426569462, -0.008425876498222351, 0.06268464773893356, 0.047260649502277374, -0.048660021275281906, -0.12260090559720993, 0.02145535498857498, -0.04436216875910759, 0.011171353980898857, -0.00507446750998497, -0.01766340620815754, -0.033697307109832764, -0.01698141172528267, -0.02791176736354828, -0.055098600685596466, 0.0011481813853606582, -0.01077472697943449, -0.08212736994028091, -0.025641920045018196, 0.020411934703588486, -0.0004235795349813998, -0.013320890255272388, -0.06152396276593208, -0.022949162870645523, 0.05008716508746147, 0.0398319773375988, -0.01704060472548008, 0.017163118347525597, 0.027691198512911797, -0.03486345708370209, 0.019886331632733345, -0.016821270808577538, 0.054968107491731644, 0.03861939162015915, 0.005472896154969931, 0.027854682877659798, -0.032880209386348724, -0.03676615282893181, 0.042306531220674515, 0.02327371947467327, -0.03041292168200016, -0.035118892788887024, 0.03879213333129883, -0.0022837400902062654, 0.006224483717232943, -0.021708711981773376, 0.01181643083691597, -0.014034861698746681, -0.007055745925754309, 0.016726229339838028, -0.04378387704491615, 0.010238412767648697, -0.0517721101641655, 0.04368904232978821, 0.011125221848487854, -0.03219547122716904, 0.009219211526215076, 0.027201823890209198, 0.034736182540655136, -0.038497813045978546, 0.006944018881767988, 0.026314541697502136, -0.05995729938149452, 0.00021730750449933112, 0.012951401062309742, -0.047042760998010635, 0.009298259392380714, 0.011013788171112537, 0.060041315853595734, 0.04230568930506706, 0.045201729983091354, -0.05692917853593826, -0.053751591593027115, 0.01810864359140396, -0.04654870927333832, 0.002784240525215864, -0.04171668365597725, 0.0813070610165596, 0.0694938600063324, 0.05522451922297478, -0.06208103522658348, 0.011471213772892952, 0.02262602187693119, 0.07443299144506454, 0.0034758488181978464, -0.027245430275797844, 0.014965464361011982, -0.01056584157049656, 0.03408053144812584, 0.04397321492433548, 0.09621108323335648, 0.002661632839590311, -0.06168189272284508, -0.010642141103744507, 0.0016409519594162703, -0.010829698294401169, -0.005484413355588913, 0.010991453193128109, -0.0022450329270213842, 0.03862680494785309, -0.02167385257780552, 0.02204057201743126, 0.032076120376586914, 0.023470591753721237, 0.011813829652965069, 0.06528031826019287, 0.029078781604766846, 0.017286285758018494, 0.006492079235613346, 0.04950544610619545, 0.07416749745607376, -0.006443890742957592, 0.026702113449573517, -0.023151054978370667, 0.03941533342003822, 0.01114720106124878, 0.02831164374947548, 0.029121123254299164, 0.037476904690265656, -0.06750669330358505, 0.026757000014185905, -0.009364417754113674, -0.06316626071929932, 0.04123714566230774, 0.06540090590715408, 0.04677414894104004, -0.03919399157166481, 0.026875589042901993, -0.045833952724933624, -0.007145919371396303, -0.01593305729329586, 0.036956340074539185, -0.028849482536315918, 0.020382145419716835, -0.053191084414720535, 0.04509963095188141, 0.055905845016241074, 0.023374726995825768, -0.021323347464203835, 0.011147795245051384, -0.012575636617839336, -0.02356000803411007, -0.11408579349517822, 0.04792221635580063, 0.03681492805480957, -0.02697606571018696, -0.028985613957047462, -0.12124112248420715, -0.036065444350242615, -0.021324792876839638, 0.045196522027254105, 0.10099300742149353, 0.01797351986169815, 0.031939443200826645, 0.004000985063612461, -0.08364613354206085, -0.09363391250371933, -0.09608539193868637, -0.045417532324790955, -0.01798493228852749, 0.019711099565029144, -0.1347571164369583, 0.012706058099865913, -0.019295284524559975, -0.009477308951318264, -0.010646500624716282, 0.06371484696865082, -0.040012504905462265, -0.029151596128940582, 0.03577309101819992, 0.016628317534923553, 0.058884188532829285, -0.05255340039730072, -0.06889081001281738, 0.009922828525304794, 0.05282416194677353, 0.026082508265972137, 0.06334373354911804, -0.03601227328181267, -0.00943661667406559, -0.0002717322495300323, 0.032885514199733734, 0.02969410829246044, 0.05651792883872986, 0.08586429059505463, 0.05104553699493408, -0.010918128304183483, -0.051351673901081085, -0.048539455980062485, 0.0788174420595169, 0.04164594039320946, -0.032987091690301895, 0.005745421629399061, -0.017830679193139076, -0.020270058885216713, -0.03647914156317711, -0.07968366891145706, -0.04747424274682999, 0.037734318524599075, -0.023811832070350647, -0.08387111872434616, -0.03679991513490677, 0.013318590819835663, 0.015473089180886745, -0.017307398840785027, -0.039410948753356934, 0.06716064363718033, -0.009325466118752956, -0.04008280858397484, 0.020456675440073013, 0.01986604556441307, 0.05235188454389572, -0.03265853226184845, 0.01776067353785038, 0.03783796355128288, -0.006025767419487238, 0.03766349330544472, -0.06343261897563934, 0.05608474090695381, 0.010671176016330719, 0.014895214699208736, 0.04757344350218773, -0.04266553744673729, 0.05835889279842377, 0.012630614452064037, 0.024814043194055557, 0.051409024745225906, 0.037811584770679474, 0.09729401022195816, 0.015352205373346806, -0.0009006196050904691, 0.06082959100604057, 0.016260873526334763, -0.051320526748895645, -0.041638683527708054, 0.04844171553850174, -0.003514921059831977, -0.022003017365932465, -0.02881406806409359, 0.021442970260977745, 0.006017759442329407, -0.022002920508384705, -0.019134866073727608, -0.014468598179519176, 0.03370925039052963, 0.06738492846488953, -0.06936945021152496, 0.056599028408527374, 0.03216239809989929, -0.09035730361938477, -0.007683244999498129, 0.00940702948719263, 0.026450710371136665, -0.046926017850637436, -0.0021484997123479843, -0.050613872706890106, 0.04125867411494255, -0.051174867898225784, 0.05658949539065361, 0.0061142323538661, 0.05407669022679329, -0.05210908129811287, 0.04358376935124397, -0.1092996895313263, 0.032899774610996246, -0.03135555982589722, -0.048984698951244354, 0.021280840039253235, 0.026916643604636192, 0.027791714295744896, -0.00029331064433790743, 0.08700471371412277, 0.018433984369039536, -0.021517198532819748, -0.1044495552778244, -0.12374167144298553, 0.009430204518139362, 0.019231336191296577, 0.026550274342298508, 0.009113662876188755, -0.01825753040611744, 0.043977078050374985, -0.02705932967364788, -0.01792498677968979, 0.042348116636276245, -0.1043538749217987, 0.09704296290874481, 0.005319362040609121, -0.043486468493938446, -0.03447659686207771, 0.05945894867181778, -0.00196504732593894, 0.013423565775156021, -0.07205479592084885, 0.06217556446790695, 0.01325970608741045, 0.013138231821358204, 0.06070329248905182, -0.048834990710020065, -0.0032671422231942415, -0.04415564611554146, 0.029074594378471375, 0.012184456922113895, -0.00632453104481101, 0.07179627567529678, 0.006159515585750341, -0.011476287618279457, 0.025177739560604095, 0.049819085747003555, -0.017424967139959335, 0.04110022634267807, -0.018105827271938324, 0.018344702199101448, 0.06808008998632431, 0.04981854557991028, 0.009525409899652004, -0.06164279207587242, -0.06326279044151306, -0.01574733667075634, 0.019020695239305496, -0.020009096711874008, 0.006528082303702831, 0.04776947200298309, -0.03933066129684448, -0.052148908376693726, 0.04688511788845062, 0.025961045175790787, -0.01612084172666073, -0.06420435756444931, -0.07872220128774643, 0.044515933841466904, -0.017828242853283882, 0.14409701526165009, 0.00475722411647439, -0.01022595725953579, -0.0010126604465767741, 0.04784329608082771, -0.10691865533590317, 0.024119174107909203, -0.056670255959033966, -0.01740974932909012, -0.064092718064785, -0.008630533702671528, 0.02258158102631569, -0.036467812955379486, 0.0186929814517498, 0.07005418092012405, 0.057982437312603, -0.01624789461493492, -0.029037248343229294, 0.006397828925400972, 0.08479317277669907, 0.01647215709090233, 0.06917005032300949, 0.06502500176429749, -0.04763372614979744, -0.04879915341734886, -0.09812327474355698, 0.04524177312850952, 0.037811413407325745, -0.028979582712054253, -0.012834730558097363, -0.03045462630689144, -0.006345114670693874, 0.011092380620539188, -0.0440913587808609, 0.1040944829583168, 0.00444619357585907, -0.022534901276230812, 0.03704708069562912, 0.04637201875448227, 0.09724655002355576, -0.020514650270342827, 0.04795227199792862, 0.036559831351041794, 0.019503654912114143, -0.02886289916932583, 0.030372213572263718, 0.0038231676444411278, -0.03222159668803215, -0.04595111310482025, 0.035906676203012466, -0.03506522253155708, 0.03955403342843056, -0.09989950060844421, -0.03829067572951317, -0.04971378296613693, 0.004049301613122225, -0.0035135087091475725, 0.022390883415937424, 0.06425269693136215, 0.006972253322601318, -0.018195372074842453, 0.006834274157881737, 0.005038609262555838, -0.028725706040859222, 0.05686645209789276, -0.040970493108034134, -0.03776365518569946, 0.0647362470626831, -0.005815757438540459, 0.03423615172505379, -0.04407445341348648, 0.008013878017663956, 0.01036363746970892, -0.013978401198983192, -0.01151270978152752, -0.09160154312849045, 0.04938587546348572, 0.021558435633778572, 0.030737658962607384, -0.038816433399915695, -0.017890416085720062, 0.011717299930751324, 0.013494007289409637, -0.01632610335946083, 0.018572775647044182, -0.018262851983308792, 0.019686110317707062, -0.08546636253595352, -0.05662631243467331, 0.09110360592603683, 0.06524892896413803, -0.0803740993142128, 0.06782287359237671, 0.005476104095578194, -0.041134174913167953, 0.07070773839950562, 0.07974560558795929, 0.02173350192606449, 0.054736897349357605, -0.024056585505604744, -0.01733219437301159, -0.015165701508522034, -0.013185321353375912, -0.0024221339263021946, 0.07980683445930481 ]
233
233
Multiagent Learning in Large Anonymous Games
In large systems, it is important for agents to learn to act effectively, but sophisticated multi-agent learning algorithms generally do not scale. An alternative approach is to find restricted classes of games where simple, efficient algorithms converge. It is shown that stage learning efficiently converges to Nash equilibria in large anonymous games if best-reply dynamics converge. Two features are identified that improve convergence. First, rather than making learning more difficult, more agents are actually beneficial in many settings. Second, providing agents with statistical information about the behavior of others can significantly reduce the number of observations needed.
[ -0.04886254668235779, -0.037075016647577286, 0.05203259736299515, 0.04564488306641579, 0.02296007052063942, -0.13016024231910706, -0.05219867452979088, -0.06604841351509094, -0.0564175508916378, 0.016184767708182335, 0.04487868398427963, -0.055653009563684464, -0.02810613252222538, 0.04520580172538757, 0.07125087827444077, -0.05759703740477562, -0.025156119838356972, 0.013010007329285145, 0.020569566637277603, -0.04737892374396324, 0.10127263516187668, 0.03493029996752739, 0.007751729339361191, -0.009307443164288998, -0.013928111642599106, 0.013451685197651386, -0.07484832406044006, 0.007544237654656172, -0.0148747768253088, 0.02467491663992405, -0.016358541324734688, -0.012491634115576744, -0.0011610789224505424, 0.051072295755147934, 0.030208246782422066, -0.08269425481557846, 0.0603824146091938, -0.024205509573221207, -0.005080637522041798, -0.026494590565562248, -0.05627918615937233, -0.026708479970693588, -0.041498590260744095, 0.01323486864566803, -0.00007158017251640558, -0.005898057017475367, 0.019138585776090622, 0.004211900755763054, -0.007062493823468685, 0.06977443397045135, -0.06628395617008209, -0.04596155881881714, 0.007538298610597849, -0.029609937220811844, 0.02701594866812229, 0.03060944750905037, -0.0368046760559082, -0.028896264731884003, -0.05974578112363815, -0.0002426315622869879, 0.019954636693000793, 0.056261517107486725, -0.09338059276342392, 0.0127350939437747, -0.0010000079637393355, 0.011727829463779926, -0.018277930095791817, -0.007941045798361301, -0.05193623527884483, -0.016346102580428123, 0.07762794941663742, -0.019334839656949043, 0.03891449049115181, 0.024875197559595108, 0.04462718963623047, -0.008808963000774384, 0.055672768503427505, -0.014812368899583817, -0.015065593644976616, 0.08716064691543579, -0.11503628641366959, 0.0719478577375412, -0.028337594121694565, 0.04063614457845688, -0.044247567653656006, -0.03735290840268135, 0.017120270058512688, 0.0227391105145216, -0.01642680913209915, 0.048918843269348145, -0.022804908454418182, -0.006672068033367395, -0.07480768859386444, 0.013550123199820518, 0.0382075197994709, 0.04983867332339287, -0.10915802419185638, -0.07179062068462372, -0.01868303120136261, 0.04182010889053345, 0.049711186438798904, -0.06067386642098427, 0.056953564286231995, 0.10816242545843124, -0.015158399939537048, -0.0024071086663752794, 0.009986957535147667, 0.042102884501218796, 0.057546213269233704, 0.012817157432436943, 0.032492607831954956, -0.03156604617834091, -0.04326004534959793, -0.0005961800925433636, -0.04930558428168297, 0.055408775806427, -0.04804764688014984, 0.04441932216286659, 0.0279826857149601, 0.01348133385181427, 0.013350293040275574, -0.07170268148183823, -0.05463448166847229, -0.03972476348280907, 0.03557397797703743, -0.08748374879360199, -0.009875980205833912, 0.009505641646683216, 0.07522761821746826, 0.0569295734167099, -0.027471767738461494, -0.05157958343625069, -0.01933469995856285, -0.09922964125871658, -0.03394461050629616, -0.011560477316379547, 0.001270501408725977, -0.045758385211229324, -0.01844678819179535, 0.013197011314332485, -0.024523328989744186, 0.046129487454891205, -0.08291440457105637, -0.0236513651907444, -0.01822223700582981, -0.027611661702394485, 0.03400677815079689, 0.037299178540706635, 0.02988353930413723, 0.07273390889167786, -0.024224383756518364, -0.01916513219475746, 0.037207573652267456, 0.09896701574325562, 0.01837237924337387, -0.007064659148454666, -0.04636243358254433, 0.0019779386930167675, -0.01071123406291008, 0.057120852172374725, 0.0689338818192482, 0.017390063032507896, 0.0021289971191436052, 0.011052016168832779, 0.12325023114681244, 0.01911812461912632, -0.0666319951415062, 0.046096283942461014, -0.012263375334441662, -0.012927792966365814, -0.005589192733168602, -0.029856394976377487, -0.040328554809093475, 0.009055793285369873, 0.011451427824795246, -0.04447448253631592, 0.0316692516207695, 0.05710276961326599, 0.01484143827110529, 0.008595443330705166, -0.010347571223974228, -0.03538117557764053, 0.026869602501392365, 0.007730552926659584, 0.09780973196029663, 0.09103791415691376, 0.06503916531801224, 0.06277232617139816, 0.028667641803622246, -0.015224623493850231, -0.09115737676620483, -0.02293488383293152, 0.026554284617304802, 0.012892204336822033, -0.047024812549352646, -0.02344982884824276, -0.030050035566091537, -0.0035529823508113623, 0.0315634049475193, -0.007296886295080185, 0.04691895842552185, -0.01762639917433262, -0.05948346480727196, 0.029796024784445763, -0.012268722988665104, 0.04635949432849884, 0.008239245042204857, -0.025273755192756653, -0.0557076558470726, -0.015749162063002586, 0.0002152691304218024, 0.009866473264992237, -0.09864474087953568, -0.018775366246700287, 0.0554780550301075, 0.012367471121251583, -0.011248285882174969, -0.042272474616765976, 0.057461339980363846, -0.07799860090017319, 0.0019233848433941603, 0.051089026033878326, -0.05615747347474098, 0.024768542498350143, -0.025676541030406952, 0.005784249864518642, 0.06024696305394173, -0.0023570461198687553, -0.06929284334182739, -0.007613275665789843, -0.04343653842806816, -0.01644882559776306, -0.0545932911336422, -0.05887310579419136, -0.06357897818088531, 0.023929603397846222, -0.05130743607878685, -0.04931795969605446, -0.027789587154984474, -0.0007558673387393355, -0.004380958154797554, -0.0009033187525346875, 0.024518538266420364, 0.00808627437800169, 0.11605403572320938, 0.0032001498620957136, -0.000736856774892658, 0.032685209065675735, -0.10343144834041595, -0.009084898047149181, 0.10960037261247635, 0.011678637936711311, -0.006472937297075987, 0.01577061600983143, 0.04834289103746414, 0.011119724251329899, 0.01626545935869217, 0.05266790837049484, 0.09290070831775665, -0.001780922175385058, -0.03561800718307495, 0.00280544045381248, -0.02865315042436123, 0.000593226111959666, 0.06923306733369827, -0.011242564767599106, -0.011923384852707386, 0.08243682235479355, 0.048572104424238205, -0.015798205509781837, -0.0015386121813207865, -0.06840788573026657, -0.006257636938244104, 0.05787670612335205, -0.07730782777070999, -0.08609937876462936, 0.015225408598780632, -0.04278641194105148, 0.03125304728746414, -0.0670681968331337, 0.006148544605821371, 0.02733059599995613, 0.005352778825908899, -0.01984790340065956, -0.03213393688201904, 0.04400426894426346, 0.006825676187872887, 0.027666326612234116, 0.02528095431625843, 0.0070248073898255825, -0.07406006008386612, -0.007376131601631641, -0.03334582597017288, -0.0010279311100021005, -0.007946253754198551, -0.06800548732280731, -0.030512820929288864, -0.023823697119951248, 0.036694444715976715, -0.045701730996370316, -0.00733196921646595, 0.013491861522197723, -0.0026125828735530376, 0.02589976228773594, 0.03517504781484604, 0.057591814547777176, -0.017767926678061485, 0.011052669025957584, -0.06548833101987839, -0.07882923632860184, 0.039599910378456116, 0.00043912039836868644, -0.01615918055176735, 0.008741798810660839, 0.061426546424627304, 0.024753181263804436, -0.007987625896930695, -0.025052189826965332, -0.03796564042568207, -0.016291175037622452, -0.0258951373398304, -0.030672196298837662, 0.015518018044531345, 0.050989773124456406, -0.04774467274546623, -0.006720296107232571, -0.024399705231189728, 0.04669278487563133, -0.03373248130083084, 0.009795180521905422, -0.06250397861003876, -0.004360156133770943, 0.01991751790046692, 0.09731943160295486, -0.0510292612016201, 0.017465578392148018, -0.021531958132982254, -0.09651413559913635, 0.01759662665426731, 0.08111271262168884, 0.008607282303273678, -0.09256547689437866, -0.03626944124698639, 0.015768229961395264, 0.07096324861049652, 0.07939416170120239, 0.12452810257673264, 0.001706108101643622, -0.006547642406076193, -0.021377230063080788, -0.01041040662676096, -0.03731049597263336, -0.04281315207481384, 0.06151379644870758, -0.08786282688379288, -0.01748533733189106, 0.039460763335227966, 0.009583712555468082, 0.014104589819908142, 0.011455342173576355, -0.023561831563711166, 0.025119230151176453, -0.010504872538149357, 0.004051011521369219, 0.01647690311074257, 0.06392677873373032, -0.057453691959381104, 0.018544146791100502, -0.11775292456150055, -0.03564033284783363, -0.03396087512373924, 0.005810035392642021, -0.03754482790827751, -0.051220059394836426, 0.018566129729151726, -0.04141469672322273, -0.01683046668767929, 0.004575253929942846, -0.021761957556009293, 0.06045914068818092, -0.044643886387348175, -0.0002954003575723618, 0.014743898063898087, -0.02430015429854393, -0.021461395546793938, 0.016865713521838188, -0.009710804559290409, -0.017539504915475845, 0.027439085766673088, 0.032162103801965714, -0.042789146304130554, -0.033046841621398926, -0.04209093749523163, 0.06773912906646729, 0.0486755296587944, -0.031851496547460556, 0.044293396174907684, 0.03524250537157059, -0.07379449158906937, 0.04162302985787392, 0.05068597570061684, -0.07435867935419083, -0.0017786211101338267, -0.06190195307135582, -0.026079857721924782, 0.013392270542681217, 0.03837471455335617, 0.11337259411811829, 0.045027248561382294, 0.0687045305967331, 0.012595638632774353, 0.07425883412361145, -0.024383682757616043, 0.00517715560272336, -0.014988023787736893, 0.028772134333848953, -0.011863122694194317, -0.01306621078401804, 0.009111359715461731, -0.05749692767858505, 0.012396304868161678, -0.019110599532723427, 0.0698881596326828, -0.013117082417011261, -0.04200306907296181, -0.022250348702073097, -0.023764250800013542, 0.01340522151440382, -0.015325277112424374, 0.09744707494974136, -0.03174049034714699, -0.04431440681219101, -0.05926138535141945, -0.02110949717462063, -0.004876515828073025, 0.02863391861319542, -0.010586661286652088, -0.02486955001950264, 0.015590889379382133, 0.005031803157180548, -0.030699560418725014, 0.06869719177484512, -0.05479928478598595, 0.04976807162165642, 0.017534693703055382, 0.018951084464788437, -0.04071120545268059, 0.029989074915647507, 0.07716460525989532, 0.032389312982559204, -0.018636155873537064, 0.030858144164085388, 0.04970178008079529, -0.05486716702580452, -0.0314396470785141, -0.020643120631575584, -0.007816418074071407, 0.0007953421445563436, 0.05984826758503914, -0.013624735176563263, -0.0008977061370387673, 0.00036785120028071105, 0.03358440846204758, -0.003241295926272869, -0.014786404557526112, -0.01469066459685564, 0.04565250873565674, 0.024235889315605164, 0.07844477891921997, -0.034122955054044724, -0.01268729381263256, -0.04938534274697304, -0.031946614384651184, -0.068401038646698, -0.004370603710412979, 0.054587725549936295, 0.0014233477413654327, -0.044588834047317505, -0.022182142361998558, -0.013826742768287659, 0.027860669419169426, 0.06290075182914734, 0.02200988121330738, 0.03443405404686928, 0.08102601766586304, 0.0744052454829216, -0.0578448623418808, 0.009921570308506489, 0.04202626645565033, 0.03729081153869629, -0.026749489828944206, -0.05804438143968582, 0.022202415391802788, 0.032734572887420654, -0.03488645330071449, -0.021474264562129974, 0.09314657747745514, -0.03675834462046623, 0.048323098570108414, -0.006608899217098951, 0.025529494509100914, -0.03686363250017166, 0.04523319751024246, 0.06621333956718445, 0.028447192162275314, 0.0484146885573864, 0.06697603315114975, 0.05488644540309906, -0.021530363708734512, -0.058411285281181335, -0.044053275138139725, 0.03040073998272419 ]
234
234
Differential Contrastive Divergence
This paper has been retracted.
[ -0.07203350216150284, -0.013562800362706184, 0.0077700261026620865, -0.007125149480998516, -0.011207517236471176, -0.07867499440908432, -0.056371141225099564, -0.008539061062037945, 0.049855660647153854, -0.03340018168091774, -0.05387317016720772, 0.10796871036291122, -0.11514389514923096, 0.05006876587867737, 0.013799070380628109, -0.017493214458227158, -0.06747488677501678, -0.025120552629232407, 0.02097703330218792, 0.02875632420182228, -0.0015436279354617, 0.07304876297712326, -0.08461971580982208, -0.059299033135175705, 0.03935232013463974, -0.04551941901445389, 0.017493214458227158, -0.04804703965783119, 0.031621210277080536, 0.02709595113992691, -0.020762072876095772, -0.011283493600785732, 0.024714725092053413, -0.00020384041999932379, 0.0004262118018232286, -0.025372574105858803, 0.10539291054010391, 0.008520529605448246, 0.015858784317970276, 0.07766319811344147, -0.011263109743595123, 0.04978153854608536, -0.014973005279898643, -0.09425581246614456, 0.05044679716229439, 0.05674917250871658, 0.06389470398426056, -0.03422573208808899, -0.007156651932746172, -0.005025593098253012, -0.05617842078208923, -0.016462894156575203, -0.06795669347047806, -0.029302988201379776, 0.013596156612038612, 0.013679545372724533, 0.007782998029142618, 0.1384928822517395, 0.001171155832707882, 0.0647730752825737, 0.12700925767421722, 0.008802199736237526, -0.004669799003750086, -0.051014773547649384, -0.03033330850303173, 0.007319724187254906, 0.026061924174427986, -0.04006391018629074, -0.041690926998853683, -0.02966526709496975, 0.014157180674374104, 0.11950237303972244, -0.06143379583954811, 0.02192489057779312, -0.01576613076031208, -0.05864674225449562, -0.0018327106954529881, 0.10069902241230011, -0.02264481782913208, 0.02524285763502121, -0.03807808458805084, -0.022919075563549995, -0.011103743687272072, -0.03491971641778946, 0.018886741250753403, 0.004328829236328602, 0.09115743637084961, -0.06605911999940872, -0.03706560283899307, 0.017810093238949776, 0.07960894703865051, -0.05622659996151924, -0.0323147289454937, 0.0549183152616024, -0.045045025646686554, 0.01141877006739378, 0.022929731756448746, -0.027196018025279045, -0.02007272280752659, -0.025557883083820343, -0.04405917972326279, 0.029249247163534164, 0.026069337502121925, -0.02716173604130745, -0.0671413317322731, 0.007757054641842842, 0.05606723576784134, -0.013460880145430565, 0.05234622210264206, 0.014743221923708916, 0.04269159585237503, -0.05064137279987335, 0.014984124340116978, 0.0069972858764231205, -0.02782236412167549, -0.013893114402890205, -0.027691258117556572, 0.03578696772456169, 0.02877856232225895, 0.013579478487372398, -0.07014334201812744, -0.046868473291397095, 0.006945399101823568, 0.07263389974832535, 0.05535564571619034, 0.00348196504637599, 0.0010599702363833785, -0.04005464166402817, 0.0694984644651413, 0.006908337119966745, -0.0002557270636316389, 0.07106247544288635, -0.049821726977825165, -0.040004611015319824, -0.0551888681948185, 0.10368435829877853, -0.021014094352722168, -0.01793980970978737, -0.0490402989089489, 0.07867499440908432, -0.003280672710388899, -0.025913676247000694, -0.025524526834487915, 0.05473578721284866, -0.011518836952745914, 0.05975118651986122, -0.039834123104810715, -0.011730089783668518, -0.00974357221275568, -0.08142591267824173, -0.0669337809085846, 0.05328018218278885, -0.04020845144987106, 0.05801854282617569, 0.07139603793621063, -0.030702073127031326, -0.04985473304986954, -0.06561623513698578, -0.026595616713166237, -0.020295092836022377, -0.09573828428983688, -0.015877315774559975, 0.008242565207183361, -0.07809682190418243, -0.06517704576253891, 0.021629322320222855, -0.018619896844029427, -0.057453349232673645, 0.019791051745414734, -0.06527341157197952, -0.02337493747472763, -0.006159686949104071, -0.0026591909117996693, -0.03171015903353691, -0.0359945110976696, 0.11151182651519775, -0.035890739411115646, 0.05015215650200844, -0.01117879431694746, -0.000837598810903728, 0.023675138130784035, -0.039456091821193695, 0.002054155571386218, 0.026382047683000565, 0.05025592818856239, 0.053887996822595596, 0.08894854784011841, -0.02560976892709732, 0.029642103239893913, 0.06425049901008606, 0.04163162782788277, -0.02189616672694683, -0.008405637927353382, -0.012244555167853832, -0.037962500005960464, -0.02991636097431183, -0.03475664556026459, -0.05516292527318001, -0.059654828161001205, 0.046660926192998886, 0.013935272581875324, 0.03938938304781914, -0.04172428324818611, -0.042984385043382645, -0.0014565325109288096, -0.011277934536337852, 0.05497020110487938, -0.04046417772769928, 0.06497691571712494, -0.040723610669374466, -0.04772460088133812, 0.01562529429793358, -0.056821443140506744, 0.019242536276578903, -0.0009849198395386338, 0.024446025490760803, 0.06462112069129944, -0.0538138709962368, 0.09766550362110138, 0.0734122022986412, -0.002056935103610158, 0.002453497378155589, 0.03753628581762314, 0.04527481272816658, -0.004081441089510918, -0.03380044922232628, 0.053398776799440384, 0.02582472935318947, 0.00301683833822608, -0.0025795078836381435, -0.06905372440814972, -0.08533130586147308, -0.005414742976427078, 0.02062865160405636, -0.0017085534054785967, -0.04431120306253433, -0.030716897919774055, 0.08187714219093323, 0.04514138773083687, 0.00797571986913681, 0.01849573850631714, 0.03477888181805611, -0.06401237845420837, 0.03988601267337799, -0.10409945249557495, -0.021557051688432693, 0.025042345747351646, 0.02681613340973854, 0.028085503727197647, -0.0015732774045318365, -0.002342311665415764, -0.026447368785738945, -0.024438614025712013, 0.014224355109035969, -0.023541714996099472, 0.003846561536192894, -0.0694984644651413, -0.029582804068922997, 0.047515202313661575, 0.03451944887638092, -0.0326811783015728, 0.027781596407294273, -0.02958095073699951, -0.01170924212783575, -0.012675167992711067, 0.04826941341161728, -0.015180552378296852, 0.009867729619145393, 0.015640119090676308, -0.04174049571156502, 0.021308042109012604, -0.01612933725118637, -0.0774741843342781, 0.04624583199620247, -0.017356084659695625, 0.03153226152062416, 0.00822496134787798, -0.0191016998142004, 0.022541044279932976, 0.038507308810949326, -0.0059669651091098785, 0.012351803481578827, 0.04769587889313698, -0.04915889725089073, -0.10804283618927002, -0.04396282136440277, 0.11638413369655609, 0.010999970138072968, 0.019353721290826797, 0.05703825503587723, -0.03139142692089081, -0.008704912848770618, 0.005789068061858416, 0.03491230681538582, 0.007578230928629637, 0.04390630125999451, -0.027763064950704575, 0.014176174998283386, 0.05703084543347359, 0.009419918060302734, 0.046647027134895325, 0.03973035141825676, 0.019583504647016525, -0.06084822118282318, 0.051719874143600464, -0.044644758105278015, 0.006490464322268963, -0.030709486454725266, -0.007056585047394037, -0.021440306678414345, -0.03512726351618767, -0.05249447003006935, -0.044266726821660995, -0.01031061913818121, 0.05720874294638634, -0.11869442462921143, -0.013039416633546352, 0.011644847691059113, 0.03467511013150215, -0.015343624167144299, -0.0315396711230278, -0.01170414686203003, -0.020241353660821915, 0.01883670873939991, 0.0070343478582799435, 0.002315441844984889, 0.0018234451999887824, 0.0613003745675087, 0.0022955210879445076, -0.037388041615486145, 0.0006078151054680347, 0.032940611243247986, 0.07311570644378662, 0.01706329733133316, 0.007373463828116655, 0.04171686992049217, -0.010807248763740063, 0.007156651932746172, 0.0029871887527406216, 0.07410896569490433, -0.036472611129283905, 0.028151288628578186, -0.019643694162368774, 0.04657568410038948, -0.016086716204881668, -0.09668707102537155, -0.02039145492017269, 0.05877275392413139, -0.1381000280380249, -0.01688539981842041, -0.02395680919289589, -0.02294965274631977, -0.005116162821650505, -0.0030816965736448765, -0.006102241110056639, 0.06373904645442963, 0.07575451582670212, 0.07210762053728104, -0.07827471941709518, -0.0035042022354900837, -0.040345579385757446, 0.03885569050908089, 0.035520121455192566, -0.04066801816225052, 0.10488609224557877, 0.006022558081895113, -0.0030687248799949884, 0.008603919297456741, 0.04578626528382301, -0.06291812658309937, -0.062441881746053696, -0.06631114333868027, 0.033885691314935684, 0.023904921486973763, 0.09043102711439133, 0.028002114966511726, 0.027069082483649254, 0.017734115943312645, -0.024697525426745415, -0.013701782561838627, -0.026091573759913445, -0.005013547837734222, 0.008765137754380703, -0.025557883083820343, 0.03531257435679436, 0.03242915868759155, -0.008276848122477531, -0.008842968381941319, 0.03467649966478348, 0.0005244258209131658, -0.06253083050251007, -0.048892050981521606, 0.07568780332803726, 0.030398165807127953, -0.03753628581762314, 0.033496540039777756, -0.021605579182505608, -0.03418589383363724, -0.03864443674683571, -0.09934070706367493, -0.011489187367260456, -0.01437260303646326, -0.057104967534542084, -0.030405579134821892, -0.03411918133497238, -0.026862461119890213, -0.028063267469406128, 0.035542357712984085, 0.01410575769841671, 0.015721656382083893, -0.024162502959370613, 0.014876645058393478, 0.012041409499943256, -0.019887413829565048, -0.028063267469406128, 0.028997227549552917, 0.027003297582268715, -0.10264662653207779, 0.03334088250994682, -0.034652870148420334, -0.005514578428119421, 0.04623841866850853, 0.000553612073417753, -0.00919690914452076, -0.0445854589343071, -0.010369918309152126, 0.034030232578516006, -0.0024307030253112316, 0.04800998046994209, -0.027335001155734062, 0.01598108932375908, 0.05250929296016693, 0.05081185698509216, -0.04493384063243866, 0.10571534931659698, 0.007264131214469671, 0.005952140316367149, 0.049788948148489, -0.04668131098151207, -0.09385322779417038, -0.006747118197381496, -0.07717768847942352, 0.0278334841132164, 0.013149560429155827, -0.021073393523693085, 0.006404295563697815, -0.02728126011788845, -0.02443583309650421, -0.0006110579706728458, 0.012204482220113277, 0.03254219517111778, 0.025713542476296425, 0.0006300522363744676, 0.009978915564715862, -0.084679014980793, 0.015017479658126831, -0.07368645817041397, -0.007760760840028524, -0.020358098670840263, -0.0034171068109571934, 0.031755730509757996, 0.06069997325539589, -0.04750964418053627, -0.0589803010225296, -0.044557198882102966, 0.010421805083751678, -0.0326441153883934, -0.0797571986913681, 0.03268859162926674, -0.016955817118287086, -0.009561042301356792, 0.008316689170897007, 0.006155980750918388, 0.00571494409814477, -0.05611170828342438, -0.024809231981635094, -0.022692998871207237, 0.0266493558883667, 0.06783809512853622, -0.029193654656410217, -0.004970000125467777, -0.09570863842964172, -0.02568574622273445, -0.10215740650892258, 0.03623170778155327, -0.035142090171575546, 0.019590917974710464, -0.04397764429450035, -0.017863834276795387, 0.018145503476262093, 0.06466744840145111, 0.00815361738204956, -0.061522744596004486, 0.033503953367471695, 0.06513998657464981, 0.00825183093547821, -0.006015145685523748, 0.003944080322980881, -0.02967916615307331, -0.018786674365401268, -0.035549771040678024, -0.02188875526189804, 0.028178159147500992, 0.0010256879031658173, -0.01988370716571808, -0.013327457942068577, -0.0038840866181999445, -0.06012921780347824, -0.013408993370831013, 0.008010001853108406, -0.023460179567337036, -0.05940280482172966 ]
235
235
A parameter-free hedging algorithm
We study the problem of decision-theoretic online learning (DTOL). Motivated by practical applications, we focus on DTOL when the number of actions is very large. Previous algorithms for learning in this framework have a tunable learning rate parameter, and a barrier to using online-learning in practical applications is that it is not understood how to set this parameter optimally, particularly when the number of actions is large. In this paper, we offer a clean solution by proposing a novel and completely parameter-free algorithm for DTOL. We introduce a new notion of regret, which is more natural for applications with a large number of actions. We show that our algorithm achieves good performance with respect to this new notion of regret; in addition, it also achieves performance close to that of the best bounds achieved by previous algorithms with optimally-tuned parameters, according to previous notions of regret.
[ -0.014407730661332607, -0.045485492795705795, 0.043769579380750656, -0.031423572450876236, -0.0011877187062054873, -0.11580704897642136, 0.047783538699150085, 0.04243380203843117, -0.0456605963408947, 0.04414767399430275, -0.01504344679415226, -0.014219382777810097, 0.005469252355396748, 0.04770682752132416, 0.06061089411377907, -0.05604127049446106, 0.0007876110030338168, 0.00536453677341342, 0.034162260591983795, -0.035184092819690704, 0.0926373079419136, -0.013747655786573887, 0.056718528270721436, -0.04726695269346237, -0.00032553295022808015, 0.0317629836499691, 0.004423927050083876, 0.034415945410728455, 0.010664512403309345, -0.03604626655578613, -0.08328547328710556, -0.005917311180382967, 0.013998021371662617, 0.03413107618689537, 0.010961174964904785, -0.06295591592788696, 0.020202811807394028, 0.009886101819574833, -0.00006217213376658037, -0.04678400605916977, 0.04102581366896629, -0.04151187092065811, -0.06277268379926682, 0.015670202672481537, 0.04732239246368408, 0.04872914031147957, 0.06980890780687332, -0.008406627923250198, -0.006762353237718344, 0.07906389981508255, -0.032322611659765244, -0.04474641755223274, -0.07451313734054565, -0.04628482088446617, 0.02011936902999878, 0.06405273824930191, -0.05958164483308792, -0.010527070611715317, -0.017123611643910408, -0.033920690417289734, -0.03885442763566971, 0.06634874641895294, -0.003370552556589246, 0.05283631384372711, -0.005894403904676437, 0.028797252103686333, -0.034229736775159836, -0.0059486678801476955, -0.09511455148458481, -0.012257897295057774, 0.10941282659769058, -0.016516858711838722, -0.011503700166940689, 0.026320505887269974, 0.037894316017627716, -0.020872944965958595, -0.008193941786885262, 0.08354507386684418, 0.005544713698327541, 0.044306229799985886, -0.02361368201673031, 0.04920237883925438, -0.042128391563892365, 0.04555854946374893, 0.05000867322087288, 0.009248198010027409, 0.0015104961348697543, -0.027280133217573166, -0.03774113580584526, 0.009628480300307274, -0.01183153223246336, 0.00044330564560368657, -0.045462366193532944, -0.030865762382745743, -0.012988189235329628, 0.01395643875002861, -0.029261276125907898, -0.03624356538057327, -0.01515375915914774, -0.0037413183599710464, 0.022675829008221626, 0.020370224490761757, 0.019912848249077797, 0.07614751160144806, -0.038266539573669434, 0.002540148561820388, 0.0009487920324318111, 0.03502250090241432, 0.06792883574962616, -0.04434378072619438, 0.023074451833963394, 0.01961059868335724, 0.01838185079395771, 0.0223036240786314, 0.012699165381491184, 0.03380567580461502, -0.06131624057888985, 0.03879273682832718, 0.026684220880270004, 0.018957605585455894, -0.010757679119706154, 0.04373111203312874, -0.09847050905227661, -0.0009197546751238406, 0.06529181450605392, -0.08917847275733948, -0.04979022964835167, -0.031103231012821198, 0.07543524354696274, 0.031119728460907936, -0.01699839159846306, 0.06685766577720642, 0.00281418371014297, -0.06686965376138687, -0.015422395430505276, -0.055584222078323364, -0.022523747757077217, -0.0660390630364418, 0.030221635475754738, -0.025674648582935333, 0.040314383804798126, 0.045846570283174515, -0.08363622426986694, -0.0702323168516159, -0.01961536519229412, -0.006791233085095882, 0.0036453045904636383, 0.005233163014054298, 0.05755557492375374, -0.03405621647834778, -0.052334368228912354, 0.00851684994995594, -0.03229133039712906, -0.009033883921802044, 0.019806312397122383, -0.04414115473628044, -0.05862680450081825, 0.027593908831477165, -0.038625769317150116, 0.1176336333155632, 0.0017217008862644434, 0.03194098919630051, 0.009966443292796612, -0.03475642949342728, 0.029975786805152893, -0.05729132890701294, -0.02858138270676136, 0.023834416642785072, -0.04444701224565506, -0.05502133071422577, -0.017125071957707405, -0.013897452503442764, 0.024438507854938507, 0.02413424476981163, -0.014299166388809681, 0.005803341045975685, 0.029256055131554604, 0.01703127659857273, -0.04747726395726204, -0.0056285373866558075, 0.016316622495651245, -0.03638128563761711, 0.0025608213618397713, -0.032720889896154404, 0.027789520099759102, 0.02034352347254753, 0.057704512029886246, 0.042573481798172, 0.0856519490480423, -0.0026791172567754984, 0.02569299377501011, 0.012860213406383991, -0.007367320824414492, 0.027812743559479713, 0.01949138194322586, 0.05200546607375145, -0.05034944787621498, 0.001909826067276299, -0.047039080411195755, 0.052753910422325134, 0.021338608115911484, -0.004434598609805107, -0.04442524164915085, -0.06021673232316971, -0.09645511209964752, 0.08353269100189209, 0.03386375308036804, -0.017349136993288994, -0.02278476394712925, 0.016541991382837296, 0.019185248762369156, -0.003886454040184617, -0.07495663315057755, -0.04322739690542221, 0.013530570082366467, -0.06831666082143784, -0.022883953526616096, -0.034242354333400726, 0.09420806169509888, -0.016861550509929657, -0.03730490431189537, 0.04773940518498421, 0.016250256448984146, 0.07434840500354767, -0.04943826049566269, 0.011916954070329666, 0.05895041301846504, -0.048374421894550323, -0.03267887234687805, 0.07108104228973389, 0.0029759586323052645, -0.0011665744241327047, -0.0412241593003273, 0.032651763409376144, -0.06462731957435608, 0.04032087326049805, -0.04226396605372429, -0.04568213224411011, 0.01295114029198885, -0.04609498381614685, -0.02697538025677204, 0.0018112000543624163, 0.003545181592926383, -0.040622491389513016, 0.05925373733043671, 0.06454064697027206, 0.03265101835131645, -0.0073269992135465145, -0.06073424220085144, -0.05216260254383087, 0.039940737187862396, 0.022063525393605232, -0.07319311797618866, 0.004957534838467836, 0.023576796054840088, 0.03019866719841957, 0.02446851134300232, 0.10597924143075943, 0.04605497792363167, -0.01811717078089714, -0.039021141827106476, -0.018135108053684235, -0.11464371532201767, 0.002939494326710701, 0.06943783164024353, 0.008832180872559547, 0.009880682453513145, -0.03686300292611122, 0.0544673353433609, -0.03731037303805351, 0.04592268541455269, -0.06870932877063751, -0.021456319838762283, 0.09529352933168411, -0.07385926693677902, 0.007544331252574921, 0.0139357540756464, -0.03364335000514984, 0.029571324586868286, 0.003746255999431014, -0.11575450748205185, -0.015109390020370483, 0.020599963143467903, 0.009573536925017834, 0.006973791401833296, 0.07756669819355011, 0.0054239374585449696, -0.03628268092870712, 0.041552670300006866, 0.02197578363120556, -0.014013205654919147, 0.0017255661077797413, -0.04103025794029236, -0.016725530847907066, 0.021381616592407227, -0.0399697907269001, 0.012708595022559166, -0.030170654878020287, -0.013511565513908863, 0.007684603333473206, 0.030862806364893913, -0.01362450048327446, 0.06602563709020615, 0.03406749665737152, -0.019187191501259804, 0.08594265580177307, 0.02485889196395874, 0.11607659608125687, -0.06055354326963425, -0.01571265608072281, 0.09205269068479538, -0.023066775873303413, -0.0009836311219260097, 0.01308054942637682, 0.021453389897942543, 0.06565841287374496, 0.04570627585053444, -0.05105722323060036, -0.008453737013041973, 0.06952346116304398, 0.0056167240254580975, -0.011991347186267376, 0.03322404995560646, 0.020989343523979187, -0.07422622293233871, -0.013763269409537315, -0.09894363582134247, 0.007496716920286417, 0.002130049979314208, -0.0163103137165308, -0.07629077136516571, -0.06218713894486427, -0.019838804379105568, 0.03135179355740547, -0.040058258920907974, 0.021324997767806053, -0.10091406852006912, -0.02453901618719101, 0.07449425756931305, 0.05326768383383751, -0.09237443655729294, -0.0693727657198906, -0.03988514095544815, -0.018116852268576622, 0.037923578172922134, 0.012403451837599277, 0.05370001867413521, 0.09368152916431427, -0.04554589092731476, 0.022061198949813843, -0.09640633314847946, -0.038547076284885406, -0.054302725940942764, 0.0459037683904171, -0.006269770208746195, -0.056664712727069855, 0.009940702468156815, -0.042301882058382034, -0.012356591410934925, 0.011572759598493576, -0.04659917578101158, 0.011179636232554913, -0.01374633889645338, 0.028306076303124428, 0.036364275962114334, 0.012659691274166107, 0.0004478281771298498, 0.02992844395339489, -0.04127150774002075, 0.026888413354754448, -0.03843986615538597, 0.05573127046227455, 0.017790785059332848, -0.03918071091175079, 0.0251330453902483, -0.014145441353321075, 0.06924733519554138, -0.04613463208079338, 0.0031333162914961576, 0.02675815485417843, -0.05255788937211037, -0.06584732979536057, -0.010434522293508053, -0.05892321467399597, -0.07551249116659164, -0.029538972303271294, -0.05957513302564621, -0.037416815757751465, 0.025244902819395065, -0.04353030398488045, -0.02414417639374733, -0.03966956213116646, -0.0038465065881609917, 0.027419107034802437, 0.024289574474096298, -0.03301501274108887, 0.05685342103242874, -0.03384530171751976, -0.048815373331308365, 0.012490588240325451, 0.014537918381392956, 0.052757855504751205, 0.04867924004793167, -0.03660109266638756, -0.08981785178184509, 0.016818314790725708, 0.03788115084171295, 0.05666905269026756, 0.013623522594571114, 0.0007974704494699836, 0.05501708760857582, 0.010170829482376575, 0.034263886511325836, -0.054678432643413544, 0.0059937178157269955, 0.049067482352256775, 0.028949661180377007, 0.01331859827041626, -0.023976536467671394, -0.07005073875188828, 0.009749822318553925, 0.020692629739642143, 0.04378277435898781, -0.011218114756047726, -0.0608614943921566, -0.026096735149621964, 0.02266748622059822, 0.06048232689499855, -0.02007448859512806, 0.07505504786968231, -0.026118095964193344, -0.04769767448306084, -0.031128499656915665, -0.00045100547140464187, 0.0681924894452095, -0.002478823298588395, -0.0032822061330080032, 0.07351429015398026, 0.03798577934503555, 0.016754306852817535, -0.05776716023683548, 0.04532277211546898, 0.03636182099580765, 0.013582439161837101, -0.025410542264580727, 0.11900962144136429, 0.002405408537015319, -0.021742628887295723, 0.035280004143714905, 0.0015115629648789763, 0.05176578462123871, 0.029605261981487274, 0.0510421022772789, 0.00440185097977519, -0.05655898526310921, 0.001270923763513565, -0.014123109169304371, 0.053582098335027695, 0.03581901639699936, 0.0011115671368315816, -0.06731010973453522, -0.03133909031748772, 0.016248546540737152, -0.021186333149671555, -0.052318353205919266, -0.07860223203897476, 0.043708931654691696, -0.018703145906329155, 0.009649072773754597, 0.014923355542123318, -0.07699734717607498, 0.10152269154787064, -0.013574052602052689, -0.06468917429447174, -0.006296428386121988, 0.036316342651844025, 0.08294104784727097, -0.04845474660396576, 0.061173215508461, 0.03818254545331001, -0.01109287329018116, 0.06763383001089096, 0.008980363607406616, 0.031269513070583344, 0.08737102150917053, 0.023961447179317474, -0.10025979578495026, 0.03817940875887871, 0.052973706275224686, 0.0454481802880764, -0.03308834135532379, -0.021316980943083763, 0.05527392774820328, 0.041868798434734344, 0.03185523673892021, -0.024440689012408257, 0.003102883230894804, -0.049812790006399155, 0.01982090063393116, 0.02001073956489563, 0.0758032351732254, 0.010294743813574314, -0.004589747171849012, 0.0062102507799863815, 0.005428036209195852, 0.008322554640471935, -0.045732758939266205, 0.030580492690205574, 0.06757012009620667, 0.010006634518504143, -0.07350602000951767, 0.07524590939283371 ]
236
236
Tracking using explanation-based modeling
We study the tracking problem, namely, estimating the hidden state of an object over time, from unreliable and noisy measurements. The standard framework for the tracking problem is the generative framework, which is the basis of solutions such as the Bayesian algorithm and its approximation, the particle filters. However, the problem with these solutions is that they are very sensitive to model mismatches. In this paper, motivated by online learning, we introduce a new framework -- an {\em explanatory} framework -- for tracking. We provide an efficient tracking algorithm for this framework. We provide experimental results comparing our algorithm to the Bayesian algorithm on simulated data. Our experiments show that when there are slight model mismatches, our algorithm vastly outperforms the Bayesian algorithm.
[ 0.023744972422719002, -0.08025588095188141, -0.008067769929766655, -0.024944856762886047, 0.03553691506385803, -0.01995096355676651, -0.0010825524805113673, 0.0516682006418705, 0.029888339340686798, 0.03157734125852585, 0.04636169970035553, -0.00385687337256968, -0.04282023757696152, 0.020566977560520172, -0.008573736995458603, -0.04959473758935928, 0.015133538283407688, -0.034738168120384216, 0.014602246694266796, -0.08388407528400421, -0.031140178442001343, -0.027226224541664124, 0.0011864398838952184, -0.014734111726284027, 0.027708617970347404, 0.023295221850275993, -0.02348540723323822, 0.021917184814810753, 0.06922181695699692, -0.050078384578228, -0.04354163259267807, 0.06087435409426689, 0.031866081058979034, -0.0178705845028162, 0.07431039214134216, 0.06785112619400024, 0.01586412452161312, -0.035238951444625854, -0.004164033103734255, -0.003323659533634782, 0.05698143690824509, 0.009251157753169537, -0.0495825931429863, 0.0015912234084680676, 0.10930442065000534, 0.031117308884859085, 0.06252317130565643, 0.0714900940656662, 0.011487985029816628, 0.06313358247280121, -0.026901395991444588, 0.01184421218931675, -0.10451188683509827, 0.019354090094566345, -0.040085792541503906, 0.11311287432909012, -0.02483045868575573, -0.03999653831124306, -0.05964530259370804, -0.006114563904702663, -0.016683902591466904, 0.12683995068073273, 0.006667499430477619, 0.016064850613474846, -0.008432119153439999, 0.03220085799694061, -0.0785616934299469, -0.002878795377910137, -0.032289862632751465, -0.053414080291986465, -0.0027885318268090487, -0.038651395589113235, 0.036261629313230515, -0.04539347067475319, 0.07818035036325455, -0.02456502616405487, -0.000485199416289106, 0.06565387547016144, 0.07821512967348099, 0.029146727174520493, -0.04811400920152664, 0.018271643668413162, 0.01643616333603859, 0.06625715643167496, 0.017803413793444633, 0.00086648587603122, -0.008135177195072174, 0.005479783751070499, -0.02421312965452671, -0.004273903556168079, -0.01701444201171398, 0.04656967893242836, -0.11420861631631851, 0.03570901229977608, -0.02688923478126526, 0.035583704710006714, -0.00009995215805247426, 0.04473468288779259, -0.0353807769715786, 0.0152504937723279, 0.010306316427886486, -0.04469100385904312, 0.09752931445837021, 0.11696578562259674, 0.02182713709771633, -0.03947727754712105, -0.0002451892360113561, 0.00721578486263752, 0.017496224492788315, -0.039830923080444336, 0.07646781206130981, 0.007880639284849167, 0.041990235447883606, 0.0009572342969477177, -0.03425480052828789, 0.017318982630968094, -0.04626444727182388, 0.08922158181667328, -0.028762830421328545, 0.0018419106490910053, 0.039687380194664, 0.05042504146695137, -0.07632413506507874, 0.010869182646274567, 0.050211019814014435, 0.01847969926893711, -0.05581403151154518, -0.027006663382053375, 0.0949237123131752, -0.05981837958097458, -0.020298214629292488, 0.05369561165571213, 0.023777296766638756, -0.051698487251996994, -0.03676779940724373, 0.038983304053545, -0.029056411236524582, 0.04184083640575409, -0.06233299523591995, -0.04926690831780434, -0.006787504069507122, -0.06435863673686981, -0.017671382054686546, 0.0028354113455861807, -0.00750867510214448, -0.014568726532161236, -0.00936537142843008, 0.037783876061439514, 0.0025497348979115486, -0.02047690562903881, 0.01347239688038826, -0.007352009881287813, -0.021677639335393906, 0.05945279821753502, -0.0031016995199024677, -0.008291969075798988, -0.016268014907836914, -0.024291478097438812, -0.01783861219882965, 0.05475709214806557, 0.027635417878627777, 0.03972111642360687, 0.02027186006307602, 0.03265458717942238, -0.032813433557748795, -0.046908944845199585, -0.029860250651836395, -0.0298442542552948, -0.0016047387616708875, 0.0015219582710415125, 0.0047173635102808475, 0.03576625883579254, 0.03235344961285591, 0.02644679881632328, 0.03546527773141861, 0.013766851276159286, -0.01742452196776867, -0.0029490189626812935, 0.03220807760953903, 0.017674392089247704, -0.022487761452794075, -0.09607453644275665, -0.030208727344870567, 0.005511904135346413, 0.06082070618867874, 0.05191288888454437, -0.0527573861181736, 0.012769574299454689, 0.0414203479886055, 0.00786587968468666, 0.053213220089673996, 0.057133086025714874, 0.02071431279182434, -0.07643546164035797, -0.015817901119589806, 0.04368705302476883, -0.0366961844265461, -0.06520060449838638, -0.010258683003485203, 0.03338783234357834, 0.023066241294145584, 0.013561704196035862, -0.08832129091024399, -0.05415249243378639, -0.10377879440784454, 0.03555640950798988, -0.054733775556087494, -0.065374456346035, -0.007535117212682962, -0.035201217979192734, 0.03187001124024391, -0.010741587728261948, -0.014170384965837002, -0.01853839121758938, -0.030202068388462067, -0.09823071211576462, -0.02173708938062191, -0.06413556635379791, -0.007301577366888523, 0.02147735096514225, -0.016891678795218468, 0.0564495250582695, -0.05487432703375816, 0.06883872300386429, -0.050355464220047, -0.040396589785814285, -0.013692797161638737, 0.015099822543561459, -0.07168552279472351, 0.06684178113937378, -0.07685009390115738, -0.0629020631313324, -0.12050916999578476, 0.023010054603219032, 0.07567406445741653, 0.042179882526397705, -0.030307704582810402, -0.038608260452747345, -0.0195776354521513, -0.018047820776700974, -0.01735086739063263, 0.05245669558644295, 0.006520545110106468, -0.030628571286797523, -0.0033071397338062525, 0.009543921798467636, 0.03908005729317665, 0.05486411973834038, -0.03950398042798042, 0.04546000435948372, 0.0321856364607811, 0.018088869750499725, -0.027416227385401726, -0.016493411734700203, 0.014157564379274845, 0.02418070286512375, -0.06386314332485199, 0.011288762092590332, 0.006476511713117361, 0.03010438196361065, 0.045195747166872025, -0.026460792869329453, -0.061871398240327835, 0.039974406361579895, 0.05692915990948677, -0.01984979771077633, -0.0170175451785326, 0.01313064806163311, 0.026775721460580826, -0.006188984494656324, 0.05619659647345543, -0.011296108365058899, -0.002597697079181671, 0.07802378386259079, 0.002959389705210924, -0.053224775940179825, 0.015209510922431946, 0.07760823518037796, 0.0032750715035945177, -0.011644910089671612, -0.06692389398813248, 0.01700415089726448, -0.03220808878540993, -0.021484578028321266, -0.032407864928245544, 0.09059441834688187, 0.020867502316832542, -0.06602492183446884, -0.01696629635989666, -0.05489177629351616, -0.05121254548430443, -0.013645244762301445, -0.10296136140823364, -0.004092482849955559, 0.013669060543179512, -0.0692678913474083, 0.052574168890714645, -0.033899519592523575, -0.0031021584291011095, -0.004980884492397308, -0.04004756361246109, 0.01879054494202137, 0.06549809128046036, 0.008771494962275028, 0.043695781379938126, -0.036101240664720535, -0.013991005718708038, 0.03811333701014519, -0.023400921374559402, 0.011237170547246933, 0.05950262397527695, -0.061327748000621796, -0.06556878983974457, 0.04154753312468529, 0.06652826815843582, -0.017809974029660225, -0.04578710347414017, -0.0313960500061512, -0.09007462859153748, 0.02513083815574646, -0.006805522833019495, -0.039151597768068314, -0.002379512879997492, 0.012563961558043957, -0.05978617072105408, -0.020729634910821915, 0.03498701751232147, 0.06439299136400223, -0.023766176775097847, 0.07532714307308197, -0.04277573153376579, 0.018324045464396477, -0.027773264795541763, 0.0847964733839035, -0.06840916723012924, -0.053807005286216736, 0.005807972047477961, 0.026780901476740837, 0.07110317051410675, 0.038373757153749466, -0.032166801393032074, -0.08178345113992691, -0.040453750640153885, 0.041158292442560196, -0.03657609969377518, 0.036139778792858124, 0.08770450204610825, 0.008411619812250137, -0.05107492208480835, 0.0005923907738178968, 0.015150860883295536, 0.013830197975039482, -0.0824226662516594, -0.04352150484919548, -0.05258747562766075, 0.0010050003184005618, 0.034005340188741684, 0.02153986506164074, 0.023161401972174644, 0.0015387184685096145, 0.04028810188174248, 0.0183270126581192, -0.03575035184621811, -0.04994430020451546, -0.004927409812808037, 0.04616134241223335, -0.02650204859673977, 0.02930206060409546, -0.009131591767072678, -0.03732713684439659, 0.061888437718153, -0.0218824353069067, 0.07959068566560745, 0.0044671036303043365, 0.08854131400585175, 0.01931624673306942, 0.019351541996002197, -0.009927554987370968, -0.10099796950817108, 0.07285814732313156, -0.04744453355669975, 0.0243258997797966, -0.03526773303747177, -0.06457055360078812, -0.003598178504034877, -0.04467225447297096, -0.045038171112537384, 0.017633182927966118, 0.07392614334821701, 0.055453382432460785, -0.04590320959687233, -0.057080019265413284, -0.0070781703107059, 0.02858278900384903, 0.020679699257016182, 0.043242499232292175, 0.015534315258264542, 0.018742434680461884, -0.028714528307318687, -0.04008995369076729, -0.012295716442167759, -0.04051356390118599, -0.021497001871466637, -0.1125713661313057, -0.03801906481385231, 0.004862581845372915, 0.038319606333971024, 0.03255848586559296, 0.075037881731987, 0.0029799784533679485, 0.054842013865709305, -0.0004036306927446276, 0.0006166787934489548, -0.06749425828456879, -0.05919841304421425, -0.025682250037789345, 0.03495641425251961, 0.034319810569286346, -0.018032871186733246, -0.10660345107316971, 0.040024153888225555, 0.03002016432583332, 0.016245149075984955, 0.04036881774663925, -0.07659588754177094, 0.004243096802383661, 0.05648070201277733, 0.030637700110673904, -0.03249013051390648, 0.02375163324177265, -0.0855129212141037, -0.030140429735183716, 0.03312250226736069, 0.011309976689517498, -0.025324765592813492, -0.03280622139573097, 0.039213236421346664, 0.03155209496617317, -0.056399472057819366, 0.03098428063094616, -0.02241268940269947, -0.06025491654872894, 0.03484993800520897, -0.04229143634438515, -0.01817375235259533, 0.0471104197204113, 0.013727660290896893, 0.0029966423753648996, 0.050984662026166916, -0.07065095752477646, -0.006952858529984951, -0.0024901870638132095, -0.08137205988168716, -0.028524920344352722, -0.05356815084815025, 0.029545016586780548, -0.02480814792215824, -0.009771469049155712, 0.10073493421077728, 0.004989915527403355, 0.08441061526536942, -0.04971148446202278, 0.04113847017288208, -0.0065903617069125175, -0.07994292676448822, 0.02316402457654476, -0.0010317950509488583, 0.018638014793395996, 0.033827316015958786, -0.0019522911170497537, -0.08302068710327148, 0.027669748291373253, 0.006055476609617472, 0.02971947193145752, -0.048510245978832245, 0.023200729861855507, -0.02829725667834282, -0.022824935615062714, 0.014234140515327454, -0.036054935306310654, 0.028570763766765594, 0.061189521104097366, -0.037923697382211685, 0.045449789613485336, -0.012006835080683231, 0.08918581902980804, 0.019971704110503197, 0.029057776555418968, 0.053935982286930084, 0.05396406352519989, 0.04688346013426781, 0.0171323474496603, -0.011674330569803715, 0.036013390868902206, -0.0031037149019539356, -0.02489764429628849, -0.011353189125657082, 0.006271237041801214, 0.000001530758481749217, -0.03430303558707237, 0.04311983287334442, 0.0501009076833725, 0.02618410810828209, 0.0480114221572876, 0.09582997113466263, 0.08454200625419617, -0.008376246318221092, 0.019215025007724762, -0.041142962872982025, 0.01982651837170124, -0.023388534784317017, 0.03622731193900108 ]
237
237
On $p$-adic Classification
A $p$-adic modification of the split-LBG classification method is presented in which first clusterings and then cluster centers are computed which locally minimise an energy function. The outcome for a fixed dataset is independent of the prime number $p$ with finitely many exceptions. The methods are applied to the construction of $p$-adic classifiers in the context of learning.
[ -0.008046830072999, 0.04690610617399216, 0.0022518152836710215, 0.01894461177289486, 0.05831564962863922, -0.013002797029912472, -0.051838427782058716, -0.032774750143289566, -0.007642656564712524, -0.025959061458706856, -0.07522713392972946, 0.0023743438068777323, -0.06989716738462448, 0.042066387832164764, -0.0014749278780072927, 0.047003794461488724, 0.015970679000020027, 0.01624380238354206, -0.015758313238620758, -0.058660246431827545, 0.07064306735992432, -0.005583867896348238, 0.024523742496967316, 0.017716573551297188, -0.015851065516471863, -0.048581819981336594, 0.021302349865436554, 0.04688223823904991, -0.04179908335208893, 0.03083733096718788, -0.01155154500156641, -0.010748564265668392, -0.0877867117524147, 0.00998018216341734, 0.06395020335912704, -0.05073858052492142, 0.005037964321672916, 0.022888006642460823, -0.021476637572050095, 0.022595398128032684, 0.05453895404934883, -0.011120636947453022, 0.022719085216522217, 0.044032856822013855, 0.07467879354953766, -0.026109181344509125, 0.05481218174099922, -0.054884109646081924, 0.05777479335665703, 0.017955202609300613, -0.0434122160077095, 0.028082968667149544, -0.04114115610718727, -0.05562089756131172, -0.0034342228900641203, -0.030085137113928795, -0.05335409566760063, -0.00233067967928946, -0.03152051195502281, -0.043721288442611694, 0.06335893273353577, 0.08656132966279984, -0.007517263293266296, -0.03463492915034294, -0.03480997681617737, -0.06612278521060944, 0.03700520098209381, 0.003681500442326069, 0.015961255878210068, -0.02278999239206314, 0.0826348215341568, -0.0137642752379179, 0.06469915807247162, -0.017333470284938812, 0.03318559005856514, -0.03330793231725693, -0.009807096794247627, 0.01105315051972866, 0.01448507234454155, -0.00845017097890377, -0.0020256531424820423, -0.019838852807879448, 0.02904348261654377, 0.03428080305457115, -0.038922734558582306, -0.0007128767319954932, 0.02493685483932495, -0.0039100912399590015, 0.029889574274420738, -0.061959777027368546, -0.05206015706062317, 0.03421081230044365, -0.05625694617629051, -0.013801642693579197, -0.0307922326028347, 0.004692812450230122, -0.046848148107528687, -0.034458424896001816, -0.024646885693073273, 0.007782923988997936, 0.008585582487285137, -0.014314867556095123, -0.003201377112418413, 0.09893972426652908, -0.04070074111223221, 0.03479062393307686, -0.049263425171375275, 0.02866363897919655, 0.02434796467423439, 0.022185901179909706, 0.13608045876026154, -0.010547911748290062, 0.05623788759112358, -0.009339462034404278, -0.005159637425094843, 0.09042821824550629, 0.023519242182374, 0.1330842673778534, -0.021304523572325706, -0.0266337301582098, -0.022079098969697952, -0.02439412660896778, -0.06666719913482666, 0.029352186247706413, 0.0031674725469201803, -0.0000764473807066679, -0.057955048978328705, -0.0569738931953907, 0.07620120793581009, 0.04411151632666588, -0.08908868581056595, 0.08868682384490967, 0.01786271668970585, 0.05251457542181015, -0.03796887397766113, -0.004023761488497257, 0.08712156862020493, -0.03620633855462074, 0.017367329448461533, 0.08059874176979065, -0.018805507570505142, -0.0356215201318264, -0.026864610612392426, 0.020592017099261284, -0.001005992409773171, 0.07700923830270767, -0.0013364067999646068, 0.06229216232895851, 0.028230972588062286, 0.04664837568998337, 0.05254801735281944, -0.06268028914928436, 0.06827261298894882, 0.03424723818898201, 0.08426524698734283, -0.006541072856634855, -0.06994592398405075, -0.027427785098552704, 0.052509766072034836, 0.05191585421562195, -0.019134163856506348, 0.006907230708748102, -0.02275354415178299, 0.011734344065189362, -0.04182826727628708, -0.0018325168639421463, -0.0053389896638691425, -0.010533665306866169, -0.039741259068250656, -0.026982653886079788, 0.03363721817731857, -0.014079824090003967, -0.06299661844968796, 0.009886377491056919, 0.06108778342604637, -0.02036815881729126, -0.023269975557923317, -0.022163426503539085, -0.01811487227678299, -0.00241107027977705, 0.07334156334400177, 0.01808112859725952, -0.02433975599706173, 0.03846629709005356, 0.033616770058870316, 0.08052880316972733, -0.008024048991501331, 0.12519562244415283, 0.051130495965480804, 0.03169506788253784, 0.02739783562719822, -0.019157012924551964, 0.05492240563035011, 0.030131392180919647, -0.0768553763628006, 0.019785357639193535, -0.040842536836862564, -0.035312652587890625, 0.024441052228212357, 0.04998574033379555, 0.0030317152850329876, 0.0415392704308033, 0.021444305777549744, 0.015368571504950523, -0.04068809375166893, 0.08054730296134949, 0.06036749854683876, -0.027974560856819153, -0.006137183401733637, -0.04408327862620354, 0.05796161666512489, -0.030131947249174118, 0.007007094565778971, 0.004200292751193047, -0.024648919701576233, -0.03591960668563843, -0.11407359689474106, -0.05414033308625221, 0.02495776303112507, 0.004832779057323933, -0.0223337821662426, 0.031007686629891396, -0.0763082504272461, 0.07555944472551346, -0.0353955440223217, 0.04768669977784157, 0.047625552862882614, 0.022857986390590668, -0.0427374504506588, 0.10349497199058533, -0.04453490674495697, -0.03763214126229286, -0.006948744412511587, -0.045829761773347855, -0.01718462072312832, -0.05105684697628021, -0.020151488482952118, -0.013967425562441349, 0.05259496346116066, -0.022145573049783707, -0.027624506503343582, 0.048208728432655334, -0.05957821384072304, -0.022999294102191925, 0.001415889710187912, 0.03256091848015785, 0.014530853368341923, 0.04803481325507164, -0.028228232637047768, 0.004681202583014965, -0.019714727997779846, 0.0996788740158081, 0.005595980677753687, 0.03410879522562027, 0.01746371015906334, -0.0483887642621994, -0.008531555533409119, 0.045675914734601974, 0.08976954966783524, 0.10356232523918152, 0.02454778552055359, 0.018420521169900894, 0.03477443754673004, -0.07024287432432175, 0.03856620565056801, 0.017037255689501762, -0.002727267099544406, -0.026555536314845085, -0.0527331717312336, 0.008853141218423843, -0.007921386510133743, -0.0377160906791687, -0.04598364979028702, 0.015510712750256062, -0.020471107214689255, 0.0022537061013281345, -0.007385503966361284, 0.006197164300829172, 0.04810909554362297, -0.02321521006524563, -0.05488836392760277, 0.011733395047485828, 0.06748803704977036, -0.028937559574842453, 0.051494937390089035, -0.006894487421959639, 0.03712139651179314, 0.016442859545350075, 0.03948371484875679, 0.03984539210796356, -0.1397985965013504, 0.0747179165482521, -0.02624725177884102, 0.005715502426028252, 0.012490006163716316, -0.10264092683792114, -0.0028593239840120077, 0.05586956441402435, 0.015685969963669777, -0.08171356469392776, 0.021130792796611786, -0.007543856743723154, 0.061181213706731796, 0.010498510673642159, -0.0599842369556427, 0.11305692046880722, 0.07500580698251724, 0.08006671816110611, -0.008069680072367191, 0.006132280454039574, 0.09151109308004379, 0.020082591101527214, -0.02132553420960903, 0.0036544413305819035, -0.04030533507466316, -0.011458642780780792, 0.04011721536517143, -0.038592200726270676, 0.037089020013809204, -0.03506297245621681, -0.02997477352619171, 0.04144181311130524, 0.023233851417899132, -0.04907193407416344, -0.09814127534627914, -0.040497247129678726, 0.03791290521621704, 0.03764091059565544, -0.08706384152173996, 0.01001302246004343, -0.05628599599003792, 0.013793115504086018, -0.00034258508821949363, 0.00976315513253212, 0.033458027988672256, 0.027580158784985542, -0.004744802135974169, 0.041499678045511246, -0.024051357060670853, 0.003074084408581257, 0.02565731666982174, -0.05301874876022339, 0.08490597456693649, -0.001928369514644146, -0.0377323254942894, -0.0036502787843346596, 0.062350720167160034, 0.028233008459210396, 0.032739438116550446, 0.07386951893568039, -0.12985309958457947, 0.004769375082105398, -0.0816413164138794, 0.021617205813527107, -0.07426111400127411, 0.06305841356515884, 0.016900086775422096, 0.03015618585050106, 0.0001972761092474684, -0.006838449742645025, -0.0018164823995903134, 0.047799743711948395, 0.025852778926491737, -0.04580700397491455, -0.02222004160284996, 0.04741666465997696, -0.010309538803994656, 0.007986225187778473, -0.07187256217002869, 0.030369382351636887, 0.06133737042546272, 0.007603201549500227, 0.011509638279676437, 0.009983927942812443, 0.062321487814188004, -0.05968709662556648, -0.016045184805989265, -0.03696412965655327, 0.009008658118546009, 0.028738664463162422, 0.015149186365306377, -0.0003511653339955956, -0.04581134766340256, -0.05025586485862732, 0.027092693373560905, -0.07275237888097763, 0.020277114585042, -0.007816342636942863, 0.02151424251496792, 0.0009670287254266441, 0.018688824027776718, -0.05637942627072334, -0.006138825323432684, -0.0001383014168823138, -0.000020444556867005304, -0.021846814081072807, 0.00837891548871994, 0.05122147873044014, -0.04711702838540077, -0.017342373728752136, 0.03395332023501396, 0.011025860905647278, -0.003298384603112936, -0.06181305646896362, -0.10373401641845703, -0.020040668547153473, -0.022644799202680588, 0.06110882759094238, 0.040072210133075714, -0.008949720300734043, 0.06055067479610443, 0.017460670322179794, 0.022826487198472023, 0.05964047461748123, -0.07643119245767593, -0.001085157273337245, 0.020814593881368637, -0.011100145988166332, -0.02634156309068203, -0.09788336604833603, 0.044557247310876846, -0.009624495171010494, 0.06093578785657883, 0.04430131986737251, 0.04655584320425987, 0.047106482088565826, 0.044688932597637177, 0.03664807230234146, 0.06478389352560043, 0.04769742861390114, -0.0491357184946537, -0.05026733875274658, -0.08823094516992569, -0.026727881282567978, 0.043357446789741516, -0.04366809502243996, 0.06671334058046341, -0.010905413888394833, -0.011824077926576138, 0.017225511372089386, -0.014064907096326351, 0.05728963017463684, 0.029984071850776672, -0.03765840083360672, -0.04042448475956917, 0.06712838262319565, 0.004658208228647709, -0.02115706354379654, 0.09125006943941116, 0.007657429203391075, 0.03224208205938339, 0.042139653116464615, 0.001262289471924305, -0.046791575849056244, 0.01617918536067009, 0.028812626376748085, -0.03618890419602394, -0.017898516729474068, 0.0004364126652944833, -0.09710146486759186, -0.03720354288816452, 0.046461135149002075, -0.05745870992541313, -0.07542776316404343, -0.023106027394533157, -0.008397448807954788, 0.008961723186075687, -0.0409468412399292, 0.025650056079030037, -0.010952315293252468, -0.021999916061758995, 0.04761481657624245, 0.009015124291181564, -0.015306798741221428, -0.028575293719768524, 0.004459735006093979, 0.012170802801847458, -0.028203869238495827, 0.023442981764674187, -0.011714315041899681, 0.033666450530290604, 0.026217402890324593, -0.05192602798342705, 0.050145506858825684, 0.018314160406589508, 0.006854199804365635, -0.039358366280794144, 0.014089907519519329, -0.01194332167506218, -0.008390779606997967, 0.04972902685403824, 0.024797514081001282, 0.04685596376657486, -0.09779265522956848, -0.01577301137149334, -0.10785253345966339, 0.012968925759196281, 0.0006945598870515823, 0.044543974101543427, 0.07777290791273117, -0.003666039789095521, -0.031083498150110245, 0.042169906198978424, 0.06225427985191345, 0.003413547296077013, -0.022760620340704918, -0.013381749391555786, -0.019806982949376106, 0.003401659894734621, 0.04582129418849945, -0.03402545675635338, 0.003039601491764188 ]
238
238
Kalman Filtering with Intermittent Observations: Weak Convergence to a Stationary Distribution
The paper studies the asymptotic behavior of Random Algebraic Riccati Equations (RARE) arising in Kalman filtering when the arrival of the observations is described by a Bernoulli i.i.d. process. We model the RARE as an order-preserving, strongly sublinear random dynamical system (RDS). Under a sufficient condition, stochastic boundedness, and using a limit-set dichotomy result for order-preserving, strongly sublinear RDS, we establish the asymptotic properties of the RARE: the sequence of random prediction error covariance matrices converges weakly to a unique invariant distribution, whose support exhibits fractal behavior. In particular, this weak convergence holds under broad conditions and even when the observations arrival rate is below the critical probability for mean stability. We apply the weak-Feller property of the Markov process governing the RARE to characterize the support of the limiting invariant distribution as the topological closure of a countable set of points, which, in general, is not dense in the set of positive semi-definite matrices. We use the explicit characterization of the support of the invariant distribution and the almost sure ergodicity of the sample paths to easily compute the moments of the invariant distribution. A one dimensional example illustrates that the support is a fractured subset of the non-negative reals with self-similarity properties.
[ -0.050529781728982925, -0.06652940809726715, 0.04444345459342003, -0.008312096819281578, 0.07689671963453293, 0.014069574885070324, 0.017366884276270866, 0.008057694882154465, -0.04316022992134094, 0.06000741198658943, 0.04891018196940422, -0.06872624903917313, 0.006293277721852064, 0.12749668955802917, 0.061300378292798996, -0.03995140641927719, -0.03455490991473198, 0.07131710648536682, -0.0512935109436512, -0.022312656044960022, -0.03591633588075638, -0.05526749789714813, 0.05478811264038086, -0.04497462511062622, 0.005577444564551115, -0.07471432536840439, -0.042701032012701035, 0.01796063780784607, 0.050897300243377686, -0.004298960790038109, -0.02893873117864132, 0.019199123606085777, 0.01044781319797039, -0.0759400874376297, 0.0509382002055645, -0.006360785104334354, -0.03657233715057373, -0.028788557276129723, -0.10363263636827469, -0.020127559080719948, 0.042914316058158875, -0.05135463550686836, 0.00017123576253652573, -0.02862214483320713, 0.08387701958417892, 0.043968770653009415, 0.025896912440657616, 0.03981488198041916, -0.030422400683164597, 0.049274247139692307, -0.06450625509023666, 0.024420177564024925, -0.010079795494675636, 0.036761753261089325, 0.06304283440113068, 0.09979191422462463, 0.07323623448610306, 0.025667838752269745, -0.09102318435907364, 0.010637371800839901, -0.03505469113588333, 0.09868070483207703, 0.010745719075202942, -0.05502627044916153, -0.013516359031200409, 0.03381190076470375, -0.05507597327232361, 0.008877352811396122, -0.03211265057325363, -0.08020144701004028, 0.005921507254242897, 0.024322083219885826, -0.0013111702864989638, 0.027241148054599762, -0.00023950870672706515, 0.043619439005851746, 0.01703321747481823, -0.01265659648925066, -0.037538133561611176, 0.06650988012552261, -0.049548108130693436, 0.001431952929124236, -0.08775882422924042, 0.08636671304702759, -0.01574530266225338, 0.06483832001686096, 0.027829186990857124, -0.0014673024415969849, 0.0010366553906351328, -0.09671277552843094, -0.04167937859892845, 0.0225717443972826, -0.115995392203331, 0.01839696243405342, -0.03311725705862045, 0.060471318662166595, 0.03873264417052269, -0.024161599576473236, -0.031093470752239227, -0.014365063048899174, 0.03604525700211525, 0.049042217433452606, 0.06769972294569016, 0.06072598323225975, -0.0235137939453125, -0.027588779106736183, -0.017923979088664055, 0.007589166983962059, 0.021129857748746872, -0.028718825429677963, 0.013208648189902306, -0.02806885354220867, -0.024548569694161415, 0.07187400758266449, -0.06218988820910454, 0.10397738963365555, -0.003794792341068387, 0.028042679652571678, 0.00909392535686493, 0.011468897573649883, 0.00019673764472827315, -0.015304850414395332, -0.060247331857681274, 0.019109129905700684, 0.019212523475289345, -0.04348329082131386, 0.04337979480624199, -0.026519663631916046, 0.09378666430711746, -0.027051640674471855, -0.06323480606079102, -0.0002997616829816252, 0.0336449109017849, -0.07917536050081253, -0.03900346904993057, 0.060255683958530426, -0.049643922597169876, 0.012375738471746445, -0.07960370928049088, 0.0778479129076004, 0.02115219086408615, -0.00477192597463727, 0.01942347176373005, 0.016862384974956512, -0.035928066819906235, 0.025820419192314148, 0.018393583595752716, 0.014426562003791332, -0.09440277516841888, -0.020765021443367004, 0.0023292074911296368, 0.013461346738040447, 0.019598573446273804, -0.019270798191428185, 0.06503003090620041, -0.05756913125514984, 0.006177600938826799, 0.023208146914839745, -0.06211196631193161, 0.044711507856845856, 0.020579563453793526, 0.03725462034344673, 0.012917942367494106, 0.022110898047685623, 0.010261749848723412, -0.015106705017387867, 0.04942210763692856, -0.029333570972085, -0.048361532390117645, -0.06060777232050896, 0.004409388173371553, 0.022032877430319786, -0.05823446437716484, 0.05928109958767891, -0.001116521074436605, -0.02217845246195793, -0.0007108035497367382, -0.011292778886854649, -0.0236071590334177, -0.06547324359416962, 0.030338315293192863, -0.024897580966353416, -0.03019435703754425, 0.04132464528083801, 0.07755499333143234, 0.05617557093501091, 0.029350418597459793, -0.04233461990952492, 0.057336315512657166, -0.030015334486961365, 0.023946313187479973, -0.013761342503130436, -0.034410711377859116, -0.019598988816142082, -0.008239331655204296, 0.021907584741711617, -0.02471819892525673, -0.05450914427638054, 0.03727369382977486, 0.040412046015262604, 0.050165530294179916, 0.014601677656173706, -0.032750025391578674, -0.07702682912349701, -0.022531449794769287, -0.011659258976578712, 0.039959751069545746, -0.037106581032276154, 0.051822811365127563, -0.04002656415104866, 0.010468651540577412, 0.023494331166148186, -0.017454713582992554, -0.04047149047255516, 0.06548372656106949, -0.09505054354667664, 0.03983044996857643, -0.06785141676664352, -0.020806001499295235, -0.0160547886043787, -0.012338275089859962, 0.06378791481256485, 0.01439985353499651, 0.006015691440552473, -0.10767532885074615, -0.05044899880886078, 0.06571515649557114, -0.013946330174803734, -0.025772815570235252, 0.05569929629564285, -0.0768619030714035, -0.023623012006282806, 0.06527445465326309, 0.00391198368743062, -0.007722798734903336, 0.03571869060397148, 0.02556849829852581, -0.06911325454711914, -0.013572454452514648, -0.02156953513622284, -0.03767261281609535, 0.050649549812078476, 0.0806109756231308, -0.05573931336402893, -0.0498642697930336, -0.010377572849392891, 0.05105733126401901, 0.08156081289052963, 0.017817288637161255, -0.008875101804733276, 0.04238501191139221, -0.06113256514072418, -0.015522579662501812, -0.035904884338378906, 0.003941593691706657, 0.041952796280384064, -0.04958420991897583, 0.040939442813396454, 0.00914045050740242, 0.012062148191034794, 0.04595058783888817, 0.08938440680503845, -0.08977632969617844, 0.11831831932067871, 0.0034188011195510626, 0.07600981742143631, 0.06648634374141693, -0.006259274668991566, 0.029167380183935165, -0.025007935240864754, -0.02859451062977314, -0.053537365049123764, -0.08014426380395889, 0.06501765549182892, -0.024251999333500862, 0.014334244653582573, 0.02724820002913475, 0.05005478858947754, 0.013329514302313328, -0.07568874210119247, 0.04467516764998436, 0.0857328474521637, -0.028944198042154312, -0.05774885416030884, -0.0369919128715992, 0.03738395869731903, -0.0017339357873424888, 0.0460665263235569, 0.00926009938120842, 0.016334310173988342, -0.01967393048107624, -0.03561156615614891, -0.04528501257300377, -0.009174088016152382, -0.02800673432648182, -0.03973587602376938, 0.026399170979857445, -0.001277356524951756, 0.025315945968031883, 0.036702170968055725, 0.04210023581981659, 0.02647506631910801, 0.06710991263389587, -0.009014571085572243, 0.08725840598344803, -0.013240058906376362, 0.041040290147066116, 0.049878545105457306, 0.008096495643258095, 0.024752037599682808, -0.04414375498890877, -0.003881375538185239, -0.022246792912483215, -0.016941184177994728, 0.0041890922002494335, 0.006676151882857084, -0.03294181451201439, -0.0656154528260231, -0.017830438911914825, 0.05176129564642906, 0.02032477594912052, -0.015088950283825397, 0.04364720731973648, 0.014745945110917091, -0.05677882581949234, 0.0041509452275931835, 0.04980040341615677, 0.03794015198945999, -0.05185345187783241, 0.002691224915906787, 0.0003483540494926274, 0.04410702362656593, -0.016817450523376465, 0.07785181701183319, -0.015472788363695145, 0.04635712131857872, -0.0730782002210617, -0.04134727641940117, -0.03489719331264496, -0.007953212596476078, 0.05774964764714241, -0.1352001577615738, -0.01114022545516491, -0.04641183465719223, 0.058828506618738174, 0.05273153632879257, 0.10305123776197433, -0.015433513559401035, -0.015370335429906845, -0.017283005639910698, -0.03425775468349457, 0.04832221567630768, 0.056498028337955475, 0.009687907993793488, -0.029352756217122078, 0.044530924409627914, 0.04384921118617058, 0.026715431362390518, 0.004035582300275564, -0.015372243709862232, -0.04637693986296654, 0.02461247146129608, -0.043709736317396164, -0.021168604493141174, -0.017105182632803917, 0.05785735324025154, -0.007861473597586155, 0.06377846002578735, -0.01894352398812771, -0.016857724636793137, 0.02188321202993393, -0.01242376584559679, -0.007349241059273481, 0.03930674493312836, -0.020068155601620674, 0.008825584314763546, 0.04314836114645004, 0.019774699583649635, -0.006229453254491091, 0.056019335985183716, -0.027361257001757622, -0.01982402428984642, -0.026696400716900826, -0.02858678624033928, -0.0133817745372653, -0.03927803784608841, -0.04284967854619026, 0.0186470840126276, 0.005210583098232746, -0.04106847196817398, -0.0028372753877192736, 0.01936095394194126, 0.06441941112279892, 0.02665039710700512, 0.038459841161966324, 0.0516166128218174, 0.07089347392320633, -0.030613552778959274, 0.00537022203207016, 0.04953910782933235, 0.0464191734790802, -0.044095706194639206, 0.0070318132638931274, -0.03135503828525543, -0.032001227140426636, -0.028727835044264793, 0.017182664945721626, -0.01802372746169567, 0.02186785452067852, 0.10576026886701584, -0.009302949532866478, 0.026613250374794006, -0.06164601817727089, 0.027218669652938843, -0.0595986507833004, -0.0058261253871023655, -0.0044884211383759975, -0.012137843295931816, 0.015586653724312782, 0.024009667336940765, -0.04859154298901558, -0.01568022556602955, 0.016148187220096588, -0.05323885381221771, -0.0705515518784523, -0.036340102553367615, 0.009803353808820248, 0.017659440636634827, 0.025172043591737747, 0.02114116959273815, -0.046136803925037384, 0.0042022098787128925, -0.06267569214105606, -0.023451875895261765, -0.019382452592253685, -0.07027655839920044, -0.015058869495987892, -0.05753693729639053, 0.026589524000883102, -0.024946726858615875, -0.030533434823155403, 0.008431230671703815, 0.012309081852436066, 0.060419999063014984, 0.0174935944378376, 0.12762023508548737, 0.01392932515591383, -0.028933849185705185, 0.023303480818867683, 0.011972181499004364, -0.01636163517832756, 0.04215547442436218, -0.031759314239025116, -0.00020181920262984931, 0.06039145216345787, 0.0251091830432415, 0.024629248306155205, 0.005243242718279362, 0.066705621778965, -0.017129870131611824, -0.1074037179350853, -0.0900314673781395, -0.025781981647014618, 0.02143925055861473, -0.030662648379802704, -0.060269251465797424, 0.009016865864396095, -0.013113083317875862, 0.08757384121417999, -0.00646332697942853, -0.05258766934275627, 0.05292647331953049, 0.010453973896801472, -0.0291912779211998, -0.00434870133176446, -0.0035794188734143972, 0.06439980864524841, 0.004554531071335077, -0.007835136726498604, -0.023251382634043694, 0.03674736246466637, -0.009240590035915375, 0.009242411702871323, 0.01018555648624897, 0.04203781113028526, 0.030169015750288963, 0.0008001876994967461, -0.02496037818491459, 0.0641460120677948, -0.03244258463382721, 0.004714000970125198, -0.027199560776352882, -0.03607650473713875, -0.03955106437206268, 0.02186114899814129, 0.04370478540658951, 0.0006987261003814638, -0.013276970013976097, -0.020097773522138596, -0.022069238126277924, -0.031669240444898605, -0.03850918263196945, 0.030121149495244026, -0.03320425748825073, -0.04103027656674385, 0.01394190639257431, 0.07004199177026749, -0.051122914999723434, -0.055092401802539825, 0.14258995652198792, -0.03147463873028755, -0.04166632145643234 ]
239
239
Optimistic Simulated Exploration as an Incentive for Real Exploration
Many reinforcement learning exploration techniques are overly optimistic and try to explore every state. Such exploration is impossible in environments with the unlimited number of states. I propose to use simulated exploration with an optimistic model to discover promising paths for real exploration. This reduces the needs for the real exploration.
[ 0.012020967900753021, -0.06692543625831604, -0.030748892575502396, -0.0024953573010861874, 0.0027377428486943245, -0.09209218621253967, 0.008877947926521301, 0.04813630133867264, -0.051543232053518295, -0.0225955992937088, -0.015940425917506218, -0.013215587474405766, 0.022103983908891678, -0.012847005389630795, 0.05769319459795952, -0.028019048273563385, -0.05503934994339943, 0.0566994808614254, -0.007457291707396507, -0.06365080922842026, 0.00945262797176838, 0.007831554859876633, 0.043066468089818954, 0.016551710665225983, -0.007946642115712166, 0.003450486110523343, 0.024006186053156853, 0.007515795528888702, 0.013817806728184223, 0.023928137496113777, 0.013967668637633324, 0.03704805299639702, -0.035749707370996475, -0.02518443949520588, -0.030370522290468216, -0.03556283563375473, 0.06260812282562256, -0.07173355668783188, 0.005903358105570078, -0.011597941629588604, -0.05854793265461922, -0.04501084238290787, -0.04012366384267807, -0.027494248002767563, 0.06021542847156525, -0.00834257248789072, 0.025450805202126503, -0.007053384091705084, -0.029960935935378075, 0.047307368367910385, -0.06912025064229965, 0.10331783443689346, -0.0031596675980836153, -0.06791581213474274, 0.0025288418401032686, 0.01676882430911064, -0.10289411246776581, -0.0032636146061122417, 0.006428034044802189, -0.01573297381401062, -0.029001682996749878, 0.07467667758464813, -0.07467114180326462, -0.004070265684276819, 0.008425150997936726, 0.05686318874359131, -0.018015149980783463, -0.0242311991751194, -0.02848745509982109, -0.022957541048526764, 0.03140228986740112, -0.10571097582578659, 0.04230038449168205, 0.06826424598693848, 0.03051704913377762, 0.10818996280431747, 0.002385147614404559, -0.020956506952643394, 0.05984703078866005, 0.09164002537727356, -0.01777384988963604, 0.07891486585140228, -0.03776608407497406, 0.07965581864118576, -0.000012729808076983318, 0.02250516787171364, -0.05921170487999916, 0.02646610513329506, -0.03782222792506218, 0.011986098252236843, 0.031597115099430084, 0.008749422617256641, -0.05352474004030228, 0.01612364687025547, -0.014120048843324184, 0.06927584111690521, -0.08674195408821106, -0.0391349233686924, -0.07376573234796524, 0.08043552190065384, -0.006386430002748966, -0.030360955744981766, 0.0031724132131785154, 0.05078794062137604, -0.015771808102726936, 0.030251942574977875, 0.03253934532403946, 0.025173865258693695, 0.0008658157894387841, -0.05833788961172104, 0.03155595064163208, -0.05238046869635582, 0.03605144843459129, -0.016347214579582214, -0.030295874923467636, 0.008688118308782578, -0.0345107764005661, -0.015264314599335194, 0.056045081466436386, 0.06104350835084915, 0.05050420016050339, 0.004715316463261843, 0.00702858529984951, 0.016490593552589417, -0.01279463805258274, -0.09829917550086975, -0.07207797467708588, 0.0075399018824100494, 0.11689621210098267, 0.014903411269187927, 0.009923302568495274, -0.07121794670820236, -0.010699774138629436, -0.09949304163455963, -0.052112847566604614, 0.017455635592341423, 0.01568249613046646, 0.0007270310306921601, -0.01682109571993351, 0.06544928252696991, 0.055448971688747406, -0.048154883086681366, -0.026036376133561134, -0.011079119518399239, -0.03153679892420769, -0.048659905791282654, -0.0059121702797710896, -0.010385887697339058, 0.015389662235975266, 0.013730695471167564, -0.029518239200115204, 0.028110187500715256, 0.0012034940300509334, 0.08399344980716705, 0.03499920293688774, -0.007078867405653, -0.08125023543834686, 0.01157333143055439, 0.0077798799611628056, 0.04484216123819351, 0.10375892370939255, 0.011816597543656826, 0.011294581927359104, -0.042353350669145584, -0.03405533730983734, -0.02117226831614971, -0.04124622792005539, -0.000751263287384063, 0.020385820418596268, -0.0593208484351635, 0.06513399630784988, -0.01212258543819189, 0.044407520443201065, 0.02668054588139057, 0.038353074342012405, 0.03546319901943207, 0.012721815146505833, -0.04341195151209831, -0.002627029549330473, 0.02605743519961834, -0.018636440858244896, -0.004228188656270504, -0.04015733674168587, 0.03542782738804817, 0.04995095357298851, 0.06959129869937897, -0.02854674495756626, 0.037931621074676514, 0.0124281644821167, 0.05468637868762016, -0.05625810846686363, 0.04321148619055748, -0.017330707982182503, -0.0365007184445858, -0.03639180213212967, 0.016060644760727882, -0.03165930137038231, -0.014898753724992275, 0.005020863376557827, 0.024281742051243782, 0.05521445348858833, 0.07312153279781342, -0.10895630717277527, -0.04259542003273964, -0.03864360973238945, -0.022667525336146355, 0.009401112794876099, -0.017690878361463547, -0.025460876524448395, -0.04455624893307686, -0.02739819884300232, 0.017433371394872665, -0.076815664768219, 0.006267912220209837, 0.04573662579059601, -0.054508380591869354, 0.026303790509700775, -0.025876538828015327, 0.027566691860556602, -0.01954958774149418, -0.0566226951777935, 0.08579204976558685, -0.020225699990987778, 0.0562785305082798, -0.06651134788990021, -0.021348565816879272, 0.0689767450094223, -0.031054312363266945, -0.01134120486676693, 0.026770928874611855, 0.03402046859264374, -0.02939317747950554, -0.044781360775232315, -0.010605866089463234, -0.08570746332406998, 0.08752544969320297, -0.07986301183700562, -0.005971963983029127, 0.06497898697853088, -0.025003861635923386, -0.01757676526904106, 0.10402755439281464, 0.0832696333527565, -0.011720078997313976, 0.01717759482562542, -0.04840260371565819, 0.017439303919672966, -0.03702162206172943, -0.07480558007955551, 0.016415756195783615, 0.048361312597990036, -0.047270387411117554, -0.020928027108311653, 0.029797224327921867, 0.06583259254693985, 0.018246835097670555, 0.013182982802391052, 0.018855556845664978, 0.022397413849830627, 0.04672173410654068, -0.013678832910954952, 0.030710656195878983, -0.025637488812208176, 0.025946905836462975, 0.017804989591240883, 0.07574868202209473, 0.013354561291635036, 0.040827032178640366, 0.0664001926779747, -0.04540107399225235, -0.006660820916295052, 0.017325064167380333, 0.019976956769824028, 0.02849840745329857, -0.03037014603614807, -0.057497289031744, 0.020149918273091316, 0.06942085176706314, -0.001063324511051178, -0.033654533326625824, -0.08813043683767319, -0.021128658205270767, 0.010479415766894817, -0.027508219704031944, 0.015069450251758099, 0.010877644643187523, -0.02258799783885479, -0.06228337064385414, -0.03515353053808212, -0.023352228105068207, -0.042175475507974625, -0.006395540665835142, -0.07446487993001938, 0.05196984484791756, 0.007875335402786732, 0.00221344456076622, 0.008991428650915623, -0.06740019470453262, 0.033014800399541855, 0.03586942330002785, 0.03636080026626587, 0.04013795405626297, 0.008305877447128296, -0.028496015816926956, 0.03912227228283882, 0.02930833026766777, -0.02849060297012329, 0.06330274045467377, -0.06873606145381927, 0.013094992376863956, 0.0512998066842556, 0.027108293026685715, -0.08692247420549393, 0.04732455313205719, 0.05585533380508423, 0.000345671724062413, -0.0004925680696032941, -0.018006904050707817, -0.016022564843297005, 0.04565693810582161, 0.01518954150378704, -0.01590014435350895, 0.04826514050364494, 0.020026277750730515, -0.042585935443639755, -0.06744904816150665, -0.025204895064234734, 0.035122063010931015, -0.005850613582879305, 0.06488948315382004, -0.050489723682403564, -0.010261901654303074, -0.07251352816820145, 0.07102685421705246, -0.06136006861925125, -0.00650243042036891, -0.08796672523021698, -0.019715342670679092, 0.06483975797891617, 0.03564774617552757, -0.005056173074990511, -0.1101079061627388, -0.0445207841694355, 0.012829978950321674, 0.03232244774699211, 0.055000077933073044, 0.04584191367030144, 0.011233324185013771, -0.0009353026398457587, 0.061529818922281265, 0.03396917134523392, -0.07080656290054321, -0.0468519926071167, 0.09699755907058716, 0.001260219607502222, -0.013172409497201443, 0.011349005624651909, 0.05469531565904617, -0.04558587074279785, -0.05522036924958229, -0.0662979781627655, -0.005139066372066736, -0.008038818836212158, 0.011357821524143219, -0.04614201933145523, 0.00271794805303216, -0.005330595653504133, 0.010173777118325233, -0.016590481624007225, -0.07694104313850403, -0.04923858493566513, 0.0431462787091732, 0.0018979216692969203, -0.031868014484643936, 0.091337651014328, -0.04308509826660156, 0.08004062622785568, -0.012782112695276737, -0.1557159423828125, 0.09361722320318222, -0.01960434578359127, -0.026342442259192467, -0.03066491335630417, -0.08836004137992859, -0.01724950410425663, -0.04348315671086311, -0.06715775281190872, 0.03965380787849426, 0.012763419188559055, -0.02932180091738701, -0.005881580524146557, 0.017627527937293053, 0.03282006084918976, 0.04986610636115074, -0.003602992044761777, 0.014785145409405231, 0.04620521143078804, -0.03499189764261246, -0.02593601681292057, 0.00840991921722889, -0.03611753508448601, -0.01421445980668068, 0.007382155861705542, -0.0782724991440773, 0.04956069588661194, -0.016857918351888657, 0.04447710141539574, -0.00006290948658715934, -0.04561658576130867, 0.004660400096327066, 0.038374945521354675, 0.012687386944890022, 0.06319976598024368, -0.048431556671857834, -0.07032210379838943, 0.025051508098840714, -0.04675128683447838, 0.00041352209518663585, 0.05209346115589142, -0.10200966894626617, -0.036171603947877884, -0.037294067442417145, -0.0343705452978611, 0.031237345188856125, -0.01845441572368145, -0.019788134843111038, -0.01886516809463501, 0.03695163130760193, -0.05334271118044853, 0.030217071995139122, -0.03902238607406616, -0.05184471979737282, -0.033981673419475555, -0.03650053218007088, -0.021525461226701736, 0.009240865707397461, -0.04867350310087204, 0.02551727183163166, -0.006048042792826891, 0.10142482072114944, -0.010622474364936352, 0.005796610377728939, -0.01698298007249832, 0.027198070660233498, -0.07475573569536209, 0.06089635193347931, -0.030612600967288017, -0.010778765194118023, 0.030892586335539818, 0.0002450291358400136, 0.038871582597494125, 0.01401443313807249, 0.048615846782922745, -0.026273537427186966, 0.024635091423988342, -0.031115734949707985, 0.06618669629096985, 0.003430911572650075, 0.05508089065551758, 0.04427166283130646, -0.024845344945788383, -0.0019191957544535398, 0.0786842554807663, 0.057505376636981964, -0.041280459612607956, 0.043484900146722794, -0.010906409472227097, -0.027739590033888817, 0.07602059096097946, 0.05715542659163475, -0.061536431312561035, 0.02678401954472065, -0.0170334130525589, 0.04267069697380066, -0.02469576708972454, -0.030436359345912933, 0.042531345039606094, 0.002120103221386671, -0.007618121802806854, -0.001506177126429975, -0.01763802208006382, 0.06325981765985489, 0.0017428037244826555, 0.024000363424420357, 0.015186174772679806, 0.07482953369617462, -0.055121175944805145, 0.055079128593206406, 0.0007923637167550623, -0.003495237324386835, 0.06112423166632652, -0.04157628118991852, 0.011794758029282093, -0.026463178917765617, 0.041365742683410645, -0.032471995800733566, 0.056426823139190674, 0.02626197226345539, 0.04459952190518379, 0.054751113057136536, -0.01936970092356205, -0.05721510946750641, -0.0432954803109169, -0.012755614705383778, 0.08517170697450638, 0.01960560493171215, -0.006962190847843885, 0.06176081299781799, -0.032319143414497375, -0.014633143320679665, -0.04286271333694458, 0.014923175796866417 ]
240
240
Efficiently Learning a Detection Cascade with Sparse Eigenvectors
In this work, we first show that feature selection methods other than boosting can also be used for training an efficient object detector. In particular, we introduce Greedy Sparse Linear Discriminant Analysis (GSLDA) \cite{Moghaddam2007Fast} for its conceptual simplicity and computational efficiency; and slightly better detection performance is achieved compared with \cite{Viola2004Robust}. Moreover, we propose a new technique, termed Boosted Greedy Sparse Linear Discriminant Analysis (BGSLDA), to efficiently train a detection cascade. BGSLDA exploits the sample re-weighting property of boosting and the class-separability criterion of GSLDA.
[ 0.006806464400142431, -0.0588487833738327, -0.013643029145896435, 0.05276697129011154, -0.041278086602687836, -0.02115502767264843, -0.06981406360864639, 0.006306187249720097, 0.021781034767627716, 0.04567567631602287, 0.03223128244280815, -0.011479322798550129, 0.04262769967317581, 0.032047756016254425, -0.0477927066385746, -0.00024751643650233746, 0.037480466067790985, -0.03413637727499008, 0.030420636758208275, -0.02847261354327202, 0.028046801686286926, -0.05018039047718048, 0.01791165955364704, -0.08039861917495728, 0.05192750692367554, 0.10220427066087723, -0.033089227974414825, 0.0038692131638526917, 0.03705883026123047, -0.004637277685105801, 0.04722443222999573, -0.017223285511136055, 0.018778568133711815, -0.014547576196491718, -0.006339545827358961, 0.01487831398844719, 0.011094140820205212, 0.047199547290802, -0.04074108600616455, 0.009283050894737244, 0.03804318979382515, 0.00367378699593246, 0.002265485003590584, -0.013934244401752949, 0.06063828244805336, 0.06158633902668953, 0.05973466485738754, -0.05045050010085106, 0.039671123027801514, 0.08974050730466843, -0.07335452735424042, -0.041234057396650314, -0.04801403358578682, -0.03043643943965435, 0.02209318056702614, 0.10488446056842804, -0.06833002716302872, -0.030778905376791954, 0.04143139719963074, -0.026056699454784393, 0.027443382889032364, 0.04415905848145485, 0.025258827954530716, 0.04659431055188179, -0.036425359547138214, -0.023775463923811913, 0.006723665166646242, -0.0002872169716283679, -0.0428534559905529, 0.011153985746204853, -0.0005903756245970726, -0.08545760810375214, -0.01835251785814762, 0.036598335951566696, 0.0618111751973629, 0.01661587506532669, 0.0245719775557518, 0.0266871377825737, 0.016248947009444237, -0.00749401468783617, -0.0333259291946888, 0.0005565833998844028, 0.021885640919208527, -0.0025274730287492275, 0.025114737451076508, -0.0320865772664547, 0.013333647511899471, -0.014720599167048931, 0.010398151353001595, 0.04521686211228371, -0.039756301790475845, 0.017446693032979965, -0.0654745027422905, 0.041470497846603394, -0.020330063998699188, -0.02993178553879261, -0.03990819677710533, -0.008720283396542072, 0.01522528100758791, -0.01661359705030918, 0.03614369407296181, -0.045274026691913605, 0.051913004368543625, 0.04171553626656532, -0.05568069592118263, -0.00910675898194313, -0.029167475178837776, 0.06472977250814438, -0.013208570890128613, -0.06438928842544556, 0.0321839340031147, 0.01128308940678835, -0.000211409802432172, -0.008954067714512348, -0.03574223816394806, 0.00851751584559679, -0.03693695366382599, 0.05338529497385025, 0.039419230073690414, -0.09960167855024338, 0.024756018072366714, 0.03906908631324768, 0.0276217982172966, 0.04077490046620369, 0.07477258890867233, -0.03619249537587166, 0.046038657426834106, -0.061806321144104004, 0.10764002799987793, -0.018822435289621353, -0.08611597120761871, 0.019732387736439705, -0.097439244389534, 0.0249455738812685, -0.09307535737752914, -0.05537639185786247, 0.07151345163583755, -0.04528727009892464, -0.025690792128443718, 0.08756141364574432, -0.027381135150790215, -0.012815246358513832, -0.030666502192616463, 0.009337256662547588, 0.022939633578062057, 0.01850859634578228, 0.01655770279467106, 0.017647836357355118, 0.0039222752675414085, -0.01487028319388628, 0.060910020023584366, -0.04775932803750038, 0.02325318567454815, 0.08489752560853958, 0.020746296271681786, -0.009882505983114243, -0.00771227665245533, -0.0484188087284565, 0.04418576508760452, 0.11179695278406143, -0.028070447966456413, 0.03343751281499863, 0.027144869789481163, 0.004869440104812384, -0.00110046926420182, 0.020435236394405365, -0.0347868837416172, -0.008595253340899944, 0.000588082242757082, -0.028324609622359276, -0.02524961158633232, 0.10278157144784927, -0.06714390963315964, -0.04170460253953934, 0.050249919295310974, -0.033676352351903915, -0.018274348229169846, 0.0035444842651486397, -0.0503045991063118, -0.013320858590304852, 0.04930970445275307, -0.0613279715180397, -0.05166974291205406, 0.008801921270787716, 0.0010822516633197665, 0.05704893171787262, -0.042395900934934616, 0.037488725036382675, 0.054036933928728104, 0.005902295000851154, 0.006276904605329037, 0.016292160376906395, 0.0055772410705685616, 0.019045354798436165, -0.07513508945703506, 0.08073659241199493, -0.05755074322223663, -0.06256259232759476, 0.004747365135699511, 0.01712048426270485, 0.007538280449807644, -0.04729984700679779, -0.04830966889858246, -0.05582600459456444, -0.05722980573773384, 0.04207063466310501, 0.07780943065881729, -0.010476335883140564, 0.04416055232286453, -0.004430285654962063, 0.0850360170006752, -0.005243768449872732, -0.027470435947179794, 0.005576594267040491, -0.043130677193403244, -0.025790570303797722, -0.061633676290512085, -0.06141058728098869, 0.035600803792476654, 0.04421471431851387, -0.03744067624211311, -0.016046615317463875, -0.04236527159810066, 0.04894108325242996, -0.00222078082151711, 0.041034188121557236, 0.0016248824540525675, 0.016322661191225052, -0.06230953708291054, 0.07219480723142624, -0.053231414407491684, -0.04154742881655693, -0.03593890741467476, -0.02301139198243618, 0.03224104270339012, 0.01354159601032734, -0.06468255817890167, -0.01600584015250206, 0.03028152510523796, -0.050318386405706406, -0.022385889664292336, 0.02443062886595726, -0.050031378865242004, -0.07257058471441269, 0.04773005470633507, 0.033021390438079834, 0.052803922444581985, 0.035040467977523804, -0.010051419958472252, 0.04084444046020508, -0.022555990144610405, -0.00024725074763409793, -0.004683430306613445, 0.03455161675810814, 0.035601090639829636, 0.04413646087050438, -0.019599301740527153, 0.015810677781701088, 0.10362157225608826, 0.08236588537693024, 0.10616502910852432, 0.04027031362056732, -0.008859341964125633, -0.06537085026502609, 0.04843384772539139, -0.0038985377177596092, 0.03262076526880264, -0.016599487513303757, 0.0016050321282818913, 0.04758366197347641, -0.07990026473999023, -0.11083008348941803, 0.004545827861875296, 0.05143195763230324, -0.030757930129766464, -0.05711236223578453, 0.04583996161818504, 0.02662462368607521, 0.008651510812342167, 0.0003104268398601562, -0.028255831450223923, 0.024069882929325104, 0.08909580856561661, -0.05498383194208145, 0.01824643649160862, -0.007152162026613951, -0.026035679504275322, -0.01765245944261551, -0.04635459557175636, -0.032536353915929794, -0.050602834671735764, 0.06573157012462616, -0.040655456483364105, -0.05360022932291031, 0.08016901463270187, -0.03500959277153015, 0.01630229875445366, -0.003834567731246352, 0.023174138739705086, 0.05695462226867676, -0.014648637734353542, 0.006888200528919697, 0.026097504422068596, 0.02655034512281418, -0.05913296341896057, 0.08497433364391327, 0.11452151834964752, 0.08006341010332108, -0.015438620001077652, 0.032334569841623306, 0.09225165843963623, -0.02434397302567959, -0.05793031305074692, -0.04206771031022072, -0.03401488438248634, 0.003391031175851822, -0.03369176387786865, -0.0189009141176939, 0.00011721371993189678, -0.013228005729615688, -0.009981652721762657, -0.038748178631067276, 0.006555773317813873, 0.04399399086833, -0.07774689793586731, -0.08972985297441483, -0.07673580199480057, 0.03179064765572548, -0.04569448530673981, 0.017125563696026802, -0.04488610848784447, 0.019999194890260696, -0.025549806654453278, 0.11406511068344116, -0.03408447280526161, -0.009412061423063278, 0.015176938846707344, 0.005641312338411808, -0.040150199085474014, -0.1026693657040596, -0.016624653711915016, -0.017686909064650536, 0.0064038061536848545, -0.018861709162592888, -0.02456602081656456, -0.0006707188440486789, 0.06957712024450302, -0.001290349056944251, 0.0035289202351123095, 0.05514806509017944, -0.06236351653933525, 0.08912264555692673, -0.060643766075372696, -0.024382809177041054, -0.05737338587641716, 0.0008465761202387512, -0.01000402681529522, -0.05231866613030434, -0.10191238671541214, 0.030556729063391685, -0.0009382690768688917, 0.040723081678152084, 0.04614255204796791, -0.039212893694639206, 0.01228537317365408, 0.09617439657449722, -0.013862989842891693, 0.08508063107728958, -0.010356739163398743, 0.05183057114481926, 0.01143696065992117, 0.009905803017318249, -0.03506322205066681, 0.0322209894657135, 0.0554017648100853, -0.043669067323207855, 0.009735465049743652, 0.003953928127884865, -0.06450317054986954, 0.10435633361339569, -0.07364601641893387, -0.007969328202307224, -0.015981702134013176, -0.008363761939108372, -0.06164451315999031, -0.021693095564842224, -0.0022364631295204163, 0.03607441484928131, 0.011120060458779335, 0.04673413187265396, -0.006257355213165283, -0.0450022891163826, 0.03317620977759361, -0.01579921878874302, 0.054429225623607635, 0.02811543457210064, 0.038363371044397354, -0.02808532491326332, 0.035138748586177826, -0.014488073997199535, -0.0014629585202783346, 0.028468135744333267, 0.00828145258128643, -0.07694200426340103, -0.06280618906021118, -0.00260592857375741, 0.008237933740019798, 0.11233341693878174, 0.02164294943213463, 0.009181656874716282, 0.06875734031200409, 0.029804134741425514, -0.018385156989097595, 0.010517686605453491, -0.004752930719405413, 0.022980796173214912, -0.022108446806669235, -0.032761357724666595, -0.038567423820495605, -0.03932306170463562, 0.030856657773256302, 0.07548355311155319, 0.00402479525655508, 0.012899689376354218, 0.04451626539230347, 0.01806015893816948, 0.1262720227241516, 0.04486866295337677, -0.08873181790113449, 0.034479737281799316, -0.041911717504262924, -0.015315491706132889, -0.09897804260253906, -0.0367085337638855, 0.08305750787258148, 0.0920238122344017, 0.08706559985876083, -0.018328186124563217, -0.0667918473482132, 0.02648092992603779, -0.03322787955403328, -0.007020349148660898, -0.022852346301078796, -0.027369895949959755, 0.06426534056663513, 0.04727496579289436, -0.01872723363339901, -0.004762174095958471, 0.11155334115028381, 0.02250082418322563, -0.031173234805464745, -0.03114844672381878, 0.0062557607889175415, 0.003982287831604481, 0.013736910186707973, 0.035006292164325714, -0.06829742342233658, -0.04653845727443695, 0.015845274552702904, -0.007916317321360111, 0.005218974780291319, -0.029740119352936745, 0.03265232592821121, -0.010047768242657185, 0.026549365371465683, 0.0009969457751139998, -0.04245273396372795, -0.016028402373194695, 0.031925179064273834, 0.049595411866903305, -0.05309968814253807, 0.04997202754020691, -0.016848066821694374, 0.000033100081054726616, 0.04294110834598541, -0.04279303178191185, -0.03890225663781166, -0.05536215379834175, -0.03216971084475517, 0.028352517634630203, -0.005472319200634956, 0.02669438160955906, 0.03280837833881378, 0.042089566588401794, -0.0022211873438209295, -0.009102340787649155, -0.014747644774615765, -0.03081115335226059, 0.0013082012301310897, 0.01201658695936203, 0.002978358883410692, 0.03933469578623772, 0.03735014423727989, 0.027556102722883224, -0.012389064766466618, -0.043050188571214676, 0.00510241836309433, 0.014373021200299263, 0.06513874232769012, -0.010350242257118225, -0.003047374775633216, -0.04208914935588837, 0.0194694846868515, -0.0074510592967271805, -0.03365971893072128, 0.028981950134038925, -0.023850787431001663, -0.00879832822829485, 0.030997348949313164, -0.004165729507803917, -0.08836442977190018, -0.0029032418970018625 ]
241
241
A New Local Distance-Based Outlier Detection Approach for Scattered Real-World Data
Detecting outliers which are grossly different from or inconsistent with the remaining dataset is a major challenge in real-world KDD applications. Existing outlier detection methods are ineffective on scattered real-world datasets due to implicit data patterns and parameter setting issues. We define a novel "Local Distance-based Outlier Factor" (LDOF) to measure the {outlier-ness} of objects in scattered datasets which addresses these issues. LDOF uses the relative location of an object to its neighbours to determine the degree to which the object deviates from its neighbourhood. Properties of LDOF are theoretically analysed including LDOF's lower bound and its false-detection probability, as well as parameter settings. In order to facilitate parameter settings in real-world applications, we employ a top-n technique in our outlier detection approach, where only the objects with the highest LDOF values are regarded as outliers. Compared to conventional approaches (such as top-n KNN and top-n LOF), our method top-n LDOF is more effective at detecting outliers in scattered data. It is also easier to set parameters, since its performance is relatively stable over a large range of parameter values, as illustrated by experimental results on both real-world and synthetic datasets.
[ 0.008995788171887398, -0.05220839008688927, -0.006767835933715105, -0.026157459244132042, 0.017960909754037857, -0.0065944683738052845, -0.016858505085110664, -0.026943767443299294, -0.04562258720397949, 0.10370432585477829, 0.02455264702439308, -0.07754284143447876, -0.017966853454709053, 0.003632516833022237, 0.02103816159069538, -0.04003395140171051, 0.04005138576030731, -0.05236538499593735, 0.058891914784908295, -0.06217189505696297, -0.01424643024802208, -0.04629930853843689, 0.023558765649795532, -0.07891193777322769, -0.004332227166742086, -0.02664726972579956, 0.058321744203567505, 0.02129228785634041, 0.02065029926598072, -0.001459854538552463, -0.032797060906887054, 0.034366972744464874, 0.0373702310025692, -0.06085195764899254, -0.008894228376448154, -0.02426188439130783, -0.046201299875974655, 0.031203461810946465, -0.04171377047896385, -0.08043482899665833, 0.0420135036110878, -0.030403239652514458, 0.027920499444007874, 0.015592366456985474, -0.025831468403339386, 0.02141476236283779, 0.0377989187836647, 0.05210687592625618, -0.0062059639021754265, 0.0752190575003624, -0.06901878118515015, 0.025380868464708328, -0.021324869245290756, 0.021809985861182213, -0.023410089313983917, 0.045307815074920654, -0.04068044200539589, 0.028456488624215126, -0.03161162510514259, 0.011425050906836987, -0.010252667590975761, 0.06260592490434647, -0.08170760422945023, -0.03032430075109005, 0.018771538510918617, -0.06791754066944122, 0.035488761961460114, 0.027583295479416847, -0.03749847784638405, -0.005554876755923033, -0.00746640469878912, -0.03177933022379875, -0.06380262970924377, 0.036247797310352325, 0.021026920527219772, 0.007215473335236311, 0.007379515562206507, 0.026124220341444016, 0.07374562323093414, 0.019004417583346367, -0.031703975051641464, 0.02201499231159687, 0.006265209522098303, -0.004457263741642237, 0.017270749434828758, 0.0405401736497879, 0.01698838360607624, -0.029094131663441658, -0.04134780913591385, 0.034002337604761124, -0.04856811463832855, 0.007989306934177876, -0.007261435966938734, -0.04098230600357056, -0.0849514901638031, -0.004638264887034893, -0.05973295494914055, 0.004780465271323919, 0.04569115489721298, 0.05220586434006691, -0.03848396986722946, -0.05290316417813301, 0.07198610156774521, 0.06769198179244995, -0.003534655785188079, 0.026970792561769485, -0.05106581747531891, 0.022043613716959953, -0.020362986251711845, -0.05120231583714485, 0.03646735101938248, -0.06431297212839127, -0.04027557373046875, 0.0959756001830101, -0.00841034296900034, 0.11890213936567307, -0.05050727725028992, 0.03920658305287361, -0.024640323594212532, -0.03357480466365814, 0.021310076117515564, 0.07231645286083221, 0.0486900694668293, -0.054657191038131714, 0.031198633834719658, 0.008175084367394447, -0.05393463000655174, -0.016208194196224213, 0.11417083442211151, 0.003463197499513626, -0.1309136599302292, 0.045799270272254944, -0.04119827225804329, 0.026897413656115532, -0.03765299543738365, -0.031782738864421844, -0.01479937694966793, 0.025574184954166412, -0.011088690720498562, 0.0244341678917408, 0.00741370115429163, 0.049604106694459915, 0.019423838704824448, -0.0566306933760643, 0.033655550330877304, -0.026830138638615608, -0.034170303493738174, 0.019023584201931953, -0.04547972232103348, -0.04439452663064003, -0.029643956571817398, -0.0224031712859869, 0.027691368013620377, -0.021625064313411713, 0.0020729536190629005, -0.09128013253211975, 0.03935804218053818, 0.029136640951037407, 0.00987281370908022, 0.09281474351882935, -0.008771010674536228, 0.015608030371367931, -0.014343558810651302, -0.05127817019820213, 0.02444675751030445, 0.002885770285502076, 0.0209853146225214, -0.05316752940416336, -0.018299322575330734, -0.0013736619148403406, 0.01358555257320404, 0.020229291170835495, -0.003856869414448738, -0.05439078062772751, 0.07371148467063904, 0.008464940823614597, -0.012742177583277225, 0.02606297843158245, -0.016258062794804573, -0.006870684213936329, -0.03726941719651222, 0.006643027067184448, 0.03326923027634621, 0.05754344165325165, -0.043947815895080566, 0.07205363363027573, 0.0073301661759614944, 0.02375304140150547, 0.03420240804553032, -0.016554221510887146, 0.028391458094120026, 0.04425237700343132, 0.021630503237247467, 0.00703327776864171, -0.02375555969774723, 0.037027593702077866, -0.0016023702919483185, -0.11388245224952698, 0.03343171998858452, 0.056932415813207626, 0.01993805356323719, -0.07334933429956436, -0.04729238897562027, -0.05373759940266609, -0.063225656747818, -0.019083458930253983, 0.02025201916694641, -0.06198564171791077, 0.05016293004155159, -0.003191904863342643, 0.010223397985100746, -0.03818516433238983, 0.0504608117043972, -0.03020729124546051, -0.002952010603621602, -0.06626629084348679, -0.08221669495105743, -0.07784533500671387, 0.06574294716119766, -0.0002133158122887835, -0.10705287009477615, -0.049112800508737564, -0.024094009771943092, 0.06237734481692314, -0.08753044903278351, -0.00023043128021527082, 0.0336027666926384, 0.030564332380890846, -0.09334277361631393, 0.021019386127591133, -0.015460249036550522, 0.007115084212273359, -0.014046699739992619, -0.005176125094294548, 0.015960557386279106, 0.015031218528747559, -0.011146304197609425, -0.04916663095355034, 0.01937068998813629, -0.032159581780433655, -0.023046769201755524, 0.005489946808665991, 0.0020303428173065186, -0.008132786490023136, 0.010972296819090843, -0.039997924119234085, 0.0414218008518219, 0.015683310106396675, -0.005094366148114204, -0.028174903243780136, -0.010284028016030788, -0.006324299145489931, -0.014054112136363983, -0.02359093725681305, 0.013152950443327427, 0.02392781712114811, -0.005809996277093887, -0.061309099197387695, 0.0526190921664238, 0.04781021922826767, 0.051786068826913834, 0.04508785903453827, -0.03627050295472145, -0.032938092947006226, 0.008663536980748177, -0.01685509644448757, 0.04534663259983063, 0.008376353420317173, 0.003062159288674593, -0.02168353646993637, 0.010377376340329647, -0.07758629322052002, -0.054875317960977554, 0.09190184623003006, -0.07776644825935364, 0.006661311723291874, 0.03637748956680298, 0.018118906766176224, -0.020713575184345245, -0.03139379248023033, -0.06702535599470139, 0.07696361094713211, 0.030277224257588387, 0.011088771745562553, -0.02994544431567192, -0.004782453645020723, 0.01611439324915409, -0.04016147553920746, -0.018739623948931694, -0.02997145988047123, -0.037274397909641266, 0.046223077923059464, -0.15310242772102356, -0.04790066182613373, -0.0033633538987487555, -0.022941522300243378, 0.1571420282125473, -0.05181286111474037, 0.04316471517086029, -0.026156583800911903, -0.00786573626101017, -0.04545369744300842, 0.062919482588768, 0.01702679879963398, -0.010118957608938217, 0.024082796648144722, 0.07435999810695648, 0.008701763115823269, -0.06353884190320969, -0.03613997623324394, 0.059694625437259674, 0.06289815902709961, -0.04488667473196983, 0.011794127523899078, 0.05742225795984268, -0.05581317096948624, 0.01556422933936119, 0.0018011581851169467, -0.029475433751940727, 0.0032125073485076427, -0.023019839078187943, -0.0036724430974572897, 0.022711817175149918, 0.05378086492419243, -0.053686149418354034, -0.06174170598387718, 0.026702281087636948, -0.011887246742844582, -0.04688933491706848, -0.013189862482249737, -0.048821352422237396, 0.009237248450517654, -0.04066228121519089, 0.014228341169655323, -0.04915577918291092, 0.010962140746414661, -0.07287044823169708, -0.019068138673901558, -0.030924731865525246, 0.02869599498808384, -0.025617599487304688, -0.06690192222595215, 0.01944359764456749, -0.05630502477288246, 0.020452018827199936, 0.03363277018070221, 0.07741200923919678, 0.03598567098379135, -0.055845968425273895, -0.08627285063266754, -0.11220729351043701, 0.09475084394216537, 0.013638309203088284, -0.07973753660917282, 0.05484240502119064, 0.11056581139564514, 0.005549726542085409, 0.009494244121015072, -0.05520601198077202, 0.056000716984272, -0.05204755440354347, 0.0793333351612091, -0.053555071353912354, 0.014900244772434235, 0.009769572876393795, 0.06138487532734871, -0.03249356895685196, 0.04867186024785042, -0.03304746747016907, 0.027702780440449715, 0.05909285321831703, 0.031115809455513954, 0.0016474011354148388, 0.0603240467607975, 0.08850713074207306, 0.02202618308365345, 0.010168129578232765, 0.0184475127607584, -0.036636628210544586, 0.049349986016750336, -0.0007448190008290112, 0.011167620308697224, 0.024818867444992065, -0.070981964468956, -0.014338608831167221, -0.025595227256417274, -0.032581571489572525, -0.03570893406867981, 0.030980437994003296, 0.04675460234284401, -0.028987208381295204, -0.04844263568520546, -0.02804909273982048, 0.05273239314556122, -0.008997962810099125, 0.01967216096818447, -0.010331612080335617, -0.015465297736227512, -0.05757463350892067, 0.05675086751580238, 0.022092416882514954, 0.026349229738116264, -0.009052986279129982, -0.12828321754932404, -0.10535537451505661, -0.026854509487748146, 0.027160106226801872, 0.09161229431629181, 0.0015328987501561642, -0.00250140018761158, -0.0432988777756691, -0.05899566039443016, 0.04115036875009537, 0.06593792140483856, -0.0331379659473896, 0.026518983766436577, -0.06099291145801544, -0.040287915617227554, -0.024069620296359062, 0.00034494177089072764, -0.0016461829654872417, 0.0742073506116867, 0.013654746115207672, 0.034409161657094955, -0.04863515496253967, 0.04343738406896591, 0.02937842719256878, 0.02652421034872532, 0.009977554902434349, 0.11637075990438461, -0.08928800374269485, -0.037914808839559555, -0.023508599027991295, -0.016852635890245438, -0.045866016298532486, -0.010672845877707005, 0.04948403686285019, -0.05066417157649994, -0.0563507154583931, 0.08076035231351852, 0.015435303561389446, -0.003786119632422924, -0.06978588551282883, 0.01855366677045822, -0.03982454538345337, 0.022893130779266357, 0.023168127983808517, 0.002442644676193595, 0.05785655230283737, 0.021667104214429855, 0.003770495066419244, 0.021096764132380486, 0.08448536694049835, -0.032626181840896606, 0.012508438900113106, -0.0017038630321621895, 0.0009310533641837537, -0.00987649243324995, 0.03245161473751068, -0.0255135465413332, -0.05075677111744881, -0.06029270216822624, 0.05649803206324577, 0.04175838083028793, -0.044033482670784, -0.006045482121407986, -0.03392980247735977, 0.014524773694574833, 0.04263858124613762, -0.003180496161803603, -0.05559564009308815, 0.031912487000226974, 0.03377516567707062, -0.0428231842815876, 0.0387268103659153, -0.052592575550079346, 0.025500204414129257, -0.020537666976451874, 0.0057600499130785465, -0.01729264296591282, 0.026486221700906754, 0.040528714656829834, 0.005797847639769316, -0.002606919500976801, 0.10249637067317963, 0.01651608943939209, -0.049446068704128265, -0.013561557047069073, -0.017382292076945305, -0.05851683020591736, -0.02400202676653862, -0.0010249038459733129, 0.02768615446984768, -0.019209306687116623, -0.027870403602719307, 0.02572251670062542, -0.003405498806387186, -0.03963924199342728, 0.021252760663628578, -0.04236424341797829, 0.012754816561937332, -0.047992296516895294, -0.03905302286148071, -0.04406183212995529, 0.06815747916698456, 0.0006566377705894411, -0.038495901972055435, -0.035131990909576416, -0.02218806929886341, 0.01174527034163475, -0.07813625782728195, 0.030395522713661194 ]
242
242
Optimal Policies Search for Sensor Management
This paper introduces a new approach to solve sensor management problems. Classically sensor management problems can be well formalized as Partially-Observed Markov Decision Processes (POMPD). The original approach developped here consists in deriving the optimal parameterized policy based on a stochastic gradient estimation. We assume in this work that it is possible to learn the optimal policy off-line (in simulation) using models of the environement and of the sensor(s). The learned policy can then be used to manage the sensor(s). In order to approximate the gradient in a stochastic context, we introduce a new method to approximate the gradient, based on Infinitesimal Perturbation Approximation (IPA). The effectiveness of this general framework is illustrated by the managing of an Electronically Scanned Array Radar. First simulations results are finally proposed.
[ -0.0013489293633028865, -0.014204743318259716, 0.006993003189563751, -0.01708667166531086, 0.03857710584998131, -0.005020979791879654, -0.029418090358376503, 0.03692828491330147, -0.066028892993927, 0.007941829971969128, 0.03799239546060562, 0.007086546625941992, 0.025898786261677742, -0.0506153330206871, 0.010938446037471294, -0.047912221401929855, 0.009296919219195843, -0.07573391497135162, -0.047291722148656845, -0.015956372022628784, 0.042646490037441254, 0.01068887673318386, -0.05722828209400177, 0.025777164846658707, 0.009987011551856995, -0.023671375587582588, -0.04336566850543022, -0.020359067246317863, -0.013020758517086506, -0.021937770769000053, -0.03666213899850845, 0.048763830214738846, -0.011288182809948921, 0.002436427865177393, 0.05263365060091019, -0.0598570816218853, 0.029970787465572357, -0.06093080714344978, -0.018404962494969368, 0.053399451076984406, 0.005952861625701189, -0.03484255075454712, 0.027071470394730568, -0.04434336721897125, 0.07333513349294662, 0.07656373828649521, -0.009725447744131088, -0.025720803067088127, -0.024480486288666725, -0.0008875943603925407, -0.004413323476910591, -0.0026225142646580935, 0.009761999361217022, -0.014587512239813805, 0.03849053382873535, 0.010890965349972248, -0.006594613194465637, 0.042382631450891495, -0.013859027996659279, -0.06133551150560379, 0.014407120645046234, 0.10260818898677826, -0.01860007829964161, 0.007093398366123438, 0.007706925272941589, -0.00632514338940382, -0.021735779941082, 0.01662108488380909, 0.03860919922590256, -0.00909609068185091, 0.029491141438484192, 0.0010956573532894254, -0.07736457139253616, -0.05911474674940109, 0.030680328607559204, 0.03747006505727768, 0.04822128266096115, 0.014424053952097893, 0.03837791457772255, 0.07284578680992126, 0.002117296913638711, -0.018781516700983047, -0.03661390393972397, 0.1177569180727005, 0.0772128775715828, -0.03612957149744034, -0.005006637889891863, 0.03281877934932709, 0.014529901556670666, 0.009373568929731846, -0.033567365258932114, 0.04717516154050827, 0.002334286691620946, -0.0382210835814476, -0.04348491132259369, 0.04852142930030823, -0.10585043579339981, 0.038696348667144775, -0.04075495898723602, 0.037289272993803024, 0.004403893835842609, 0.05020637810230255, 0.07755369693040848, 0.044971317052841187, 0.018616270273923874, -0.006884157191962004, -0.07391809672117233, 0.006890540011227131, -0.050329964607954025, 0.00034268066519871354, 0.06210066378116608, -0.0059586139395833015, 0.02040141075849533, -0.011722015216946602, -0.014500266872346401, -0.01086545828729868, -0.011784245260059834, 0.046474747359752655, -0.02576795406639576, 0.010431674309074879, 0.0014394919853657484, 0.07348205894231796, -0.007802704814821482, 0.0286717489361763, 0.03967353329062462, 0.009141308255493641, 0.014892556704580784, -0.00763489818200469, 0.03280274197459221, 0.057396966964006424, 0.016461629420518875, -0.02612554281949997, 0.017133118584752083, -0.0027550403028726578, -0.003124971641227603, 0.082581527531147, 0.06822090595960617, -0.00383284455165267, 0.0013482983922585845, 0.05966354161500931, 0.054884638637304306, -0.033450838178396225, 0.012511774897575378, 0.013549775816500187, 0.02826637215912342, -0.004523750394582748, 0.009374890476465225, 0.03883088752627373, -0.04649905860424042, 0.012067004106938839, 0.00998290628194809, -0.021574433892965317, 0.007680083159357309, 0.030459996312856674, -0.0299652349203825, -0.03832431510090828, 0.05551806464791298, 0.004458118230104446, -0.022383635863661766, 0.03479050099849701, -0.04850199073553085, 0.04733267426490784, 0.029644496738910675, 0.09550702571868896, 0.02170911431312561, -0.03995489701628685, -0.09657613188028336, 0.0006735812057740986, -0.0313694067299366, -0.033580780029296875, -0.06946820020675659, 0.045652929693460464, 0.009594487957656384, -0.004405631218105555, 0.022357521578669548, 0.00924962479621172, 0.0008073454373516142, -0.04666539654135704, -0.02319425158202648, -0.06647490710020065, 0.026062291115522385, -0.01554896030575037, -0.016973378136754036, -0.01320970430970192, 0.06262598186731339, 0.0036149516236037016, -0.023164944723248482, 0.07884106785058975, 0.09727294743061066, 0.07850322127342224, -0.007938439957797527, 0.01178472675383091, 0.05378802865743637, -0.0028262920677661896, 0.024780219420790672, 0.03640276566147804, -0.03832013159990311, -0.006843275390565395, 0.04526587575674057, 0.033697959035634995, 0.04200518876314163, -0.010049385949969292, -0.07108858972787857, 0.0005498721729964018, -0.04877692461013794, 0.056044429540634155, 0.04605313017964363, -0.017611240968108177, 0.051044367253780365, -0.03037683665752411, -0.008846805430948734, -0.05989599600434303, -0.07428767532110214, 0.004525721073150635, 0.026484522968530655, -0.07819844037294388, -0.05581684783101082, -0.06915022432804108, 0.001676836865954101, 0.01196333859115839, -0.016083668917417526, 0.07230920344591141, -0.014806670136749744, 0.0649368166923523, -0.05757619068026543, -0.024780085310339928, -0.014856867492198944, 0.02908596396446228, -0.025237394496798515, 0.06381861120462418, 0.020094502717256546, -0.06308459490537643, -0.022281888872385025, 0.02058243192732334, -0.03859236091375351, 0.01747184619307518, 0.029414761811494827, -0.04177607223391533, 0.06313324719667435, 0.004830609541386366, 0.03738512843847275, 0.038608480244874954, -0.012118932791054249, -0.040256015956401825, 0.05745396763086319, 0.016263706609606743, 0.007766183000057936, 0.0038137526717036963, -0.07564115524291992, -0.028623884543776512, -0.008353796787559986, -0.004461447708308697, 0.010287603363394737, 0.012864612974226475, -0.008355660364031792, -0.016822148114442825, -0.05806267634034157, 0.022335786372423172, 0.02409886009991169, -0.02173917554318905, 0.022730112075805664, 0.011710427701473236, 0.04943309351801872, 0.07294169068336487, -0.0017768716206774116, 0.09522370249032974, -0.03463534265756607, 0.027404505759477615, 0.040228817611932755, -0.015476957894861698, -0.07860039919614792, -0.055974725633859634, -0.10161394625902176, 0.06590911746025085, 0.05690394341945648, 0.0432109460234642, -0.015609856694936752, 0.057674698531627655, -0.0005061295232735574, -0.02251548133790493, -0.05756092444062233, -0.018597101792693138, 0.037348467856645584, -0.014309790916740894, 0.0059805274941027164, 0.095185287296772, 0.025453023612499237, -0.03056737780570984, -0.01074563805013895, -0.0013095202157273889, -0.08685163408517838, 0.027279336005449295, -0.09263455867767334, 0.006866859272122383, 0.02513762004673481, -0.02881283313035965, -0.005655926652252674, -0.01791670173406601, 0.04127561300992966, -0.005963987670838833, 0.014199959114193916, 0.020153140649199486, 0.03251641243696213, 0.025722313672304153, -0.030691467225551605, 0.06340798735618591, 0.08334856480360031, 0.02550920844078064, 0.004214600659906864, 0.012324321083724499, 0.04425756633281708, 0.06693211197853088, -0.11298179626464844, 0.014672809280455112, 0.05175523832440376, 0.024372614920139313, -0.050031810998916626, -0.017967870458960533, -0.04415677487850189, 0.09210039675235748, -0.02150840125977993, -0.047355152666568756, 0.04853624105453491, 0.0004166548606008291, -0.021981412544846535, 0.07402395457029343, -0.016750963404774666, 0.10125504434108734, -0.027416197583079338, -0.014244194142520428, -0.023282762616872787, 0.01957009732723236, -0.011197752319276333, 0.07992570847272873, -0.13905343413352966, -0.042610179632902145, -0.0761437639594078, -0.030749056488275528, 0.01699700579047203, 0.03740188479423523, -0.11472325026988983, -0.11070075631141663, -0.010624110698699951, 0.020402638241648674, -0.02833077870309353, 0.014841361902654171, 0.05617779865860939, 0.00008494893700117245, 0.01046939380466938, -0.004980219528079033, -0.04861908406019211, 0.0039044865407049656, -0.027927067130804062, 0.016861852258443832, -0.016187120229005814, 0.025377217680215836, 0.01935657672584057, 0.0016581930685788393, -0.0019104914972558618, 0.04459227994084358, -0.05774291977286339, -0.027813125401735306, -0.10409841686487198, -0.04679034650325775, -0.01992327906191349, 0.05671577528119087, -0.04298560321331024, 0.054849833250045776, -0.019446946680545807, -0.08637822419404984, 0.003518640296533704, 0.0043611242435872555, 0.043584104627370834, 0.010922850109636784, 0.05922985449433327, 0.017267905175685883, 0.11173868179321289, 0.01346216443926096, -0.08289886265993118, 0.05614659935235977, 0.046395208686590195, -0.03025391325354576, 0.0022781898733228445, -0.0239950492978096, 0.010424965992569923, 0.0384344682097435, -0.09287865459918976, -0.024828823283314705, 0.06036757305264473, -0.06172426417469978, -0.06839657574892044, 0.044795941561460495, -0.01985999569296837, 0.06933284550905228, 0.041664790362119675, -0.008463291451334953, -0.0072827693074941635, -0.013737265020608902, 0.01718631014227867, -0.010889953002333641, 0.016839638352394104, -0.02270546555519104, -0.029571808874607086, -0.17459741234779358, -0.027305150404572487, 0.027965961024165154, 0.035026874393224716, 0.04448424279689789, -0.008294727653265, 0.05642753839492798, 0.029757369309663773, -0.030194243416190147, -0.04948680102825165, -0.027692897245287895, -0.022911323234438896, -0.008852600120007992, -0.034917980432510376, 0.06099371984601021, -0.026384199038147926, -0.062298282980918884, 0.0033573280088603497, 0.02382596954703331, -0.05813426896929741, 0.06302227824926376, -0.04499175399541855, -0.0704602375626564, 0.057523708790540695, -0.025255171582102776, -0.09069156646728516, -0.011543679051101208, -0.12330649793148041, 0.06841268390417099, -0.020512234419584274, 0.06633444130420685, -0.03277598321437836, 0.01480457279831171, 0.06406787782907486, -0.023496728390455246, -0.011852762661874294, 0.017798960208892822, 0.003061298979446292, 0.04565728083252907, -0.06083521991968155, -0.04877307265996933, -0.013869993388652802, 0.059400785714387894, 0.003864545375108719, 0.02081838995218277, -0.00817627739161253, 0.029246501624584198, -0.09413659572601318, 0.033906057476997375, 0.045231904834508896, 0.015003754757344723, 0.053848572075366974, -0.007208304945379496, -0.06877397000789642, -0.006816019304096699, 0.027041757479310036, -0.05292601138353348, -0.003388244891539216, 0.020711049437522888, -0.06901955604553223, 0.04630965739488602, -0.04180135205388069, -0.04802332818508148, -0.020582295954227448, -0.011313763447105885, 0.02848619967699051, 0.01679479517042637, -0.13706395030021667, -0.021471645683050156, -0.009591858834028244, 0.06611376255750656, -0.05782744288444519, -0.0005664138589054346, 0.0011096852831542492, 0.0008146899635903537, -0.03071783296763897, 0.04853953421115875, 0.04102912172675133, 0.03987918049097061, 0.022562745958566666, 0.05092887580394745, 0.06015057861804962, -0.013312923721969128, 0.006460735108703375, -0.03333338722586632, 0.02547299675643444, -0.019868819043040276, 0.03879223018884659, -0.05126429721713066, 0.005400537978857756, 0.03008137084543705, 0.024743590503931046, -0.07174253463745117, 0.027395369485020638, 0.028133170679211617, 0.02163660153746605, 0.016653381288051605, 0.044071272015571594, -0.08664348721504211, 0.02828574739396572, 0.033082265406847, -0.0011969901388511062, 0.027238039299845695, 0.012847279198467731, 0.007275794632732868, -0.024226386100053787, 0.07028999924659729, -0.051334112882614136, 0.11248407512903214 ]
243
243
How random are a learner's mistakes?
Given a random binary sequence $X^{(n)}$ of random variables, $X_{t},$ $t=1,2,...,n$, for instance, one that is generated by a Markov source (teacher) of order $k^{*}$ (each state represented by $k^{*}$ bits). Assume that the probability of the event $X_{t}=1$ is constant and denote it by $\beta$. Consider a learner which is based on a parametric model, for instance a Markov model of order $k$, who trains on a sequence $x^{(m)}$ which is randomly drawn by the teacher. Test the learner's performance by giving it a sequence $x^{(n)}$ (generated by the teacher) and check its predictions on every bit of $x^{(n)}.$ An error occurs at time $t$ if the learner's prediction $Y_{t}$ differs from the true bit value $X_{t}$. Denote by $\xi^{(n)}$ the sequence of errors where the error bit $\xi_{t}$ at time $t$ equals 1 or 0 according to whether the event of an error occurs or not, respectively. Consider the subsequence $\xi^{(\nu)}$ of $\xi^{(n)}$ which corresponds to the errors of predicting a 0, i.e., $\xi^{(\nu)}$ consists of the bits of $\xi^{(n)}$ only at times $t$ such that $Y_{t}=0.$ In this paper we compute an estimate on the deviation of the frequency of 1s of $\xi^{(\nu)}$ from $\beta$. The result shows that the level of randomness of $\xi^{(\nu)}$ decreases relative to an increase in the complexity of the learner.
[ -0.021849356591701508, -0.023949503898620605, 0.0099293552339077, -0.10860945284366608, 0.03869735077023506, -0.08300860971212387, 0.031711578369140625, 0.042368315160274506, -0.03933379426598549, 0.017162827774882317, -0.04238969460129738, -0.04713471233844757, 0.026440782472491264, 0.04978218674659729, 0.005437936168164015, -0.008763434365391731, -0.007739424239844084, 0.011498212814331055, -0.03735809400677681, -0.01996723562479019, -0.04926320165395737, -0.034465182572603226, 0.08357734978199005, -0.05429544672369957, 0.0013610600726678967, -0.011934277601540089, 0.027010204270482063, 0.044364746659994125, -0.010451466776430607, -0.04218974709510803, -0.094997838139534, 0.02185622602701187, 0.059764593839645386, -0.014699909836053848, 0.01516591664403677, 0.008449183776974678, 0.009618857875466347, -0.021300366148352623, -0.02083900384604931, -0.009908522479236126, -0.02036946639418602, -0.05232418328523636, 0.056384891271591187, -0.039023324847221375, 0.058639660477638245, 0.015920167788863182, 0.04542224854230881, -0.04673059657216072, -0.024233302101492882, 0.04575853422284126, -0.04258662834763527, 0.057853054255247116, -0.036130573600530624, 0.006360937841236591, -0.008003064431250095, -0.012914816848933697, -0.002341724932193756, -0.014881385490298271, -0.050540100783109665, -0.04118133708834648, 0.056560393422842026, 0.08491194248199463, -0.005689385812729597, -0.018444804474711418, 0.008905414491891861, -0.015868540853261948, -0.06340542435646057, -0.009027133695781231, 0.006854497827589512, -0.02945808880031109, 0.010465459898114204, -0.044331181794404984, 0.06649443507194519, 0.048423074185848236, -0.007145093288272619, -0.042246926575899124, -0.00856737419962883, 0.04018417000770569, 0.06730584055185318, 0.11544445157051086, -0.022727230563759804, 0.04744401574134827, 0.058610234409570694, 0.008707297965884209, -0.05133524537086487, 0.00296607194468379, -0.030832376331090927, 0.0037320589181035757, -0.0590999536216259, -0.023479927331209183, -0.05929791182279587, 0.03267810493707657, -0.051756251603364944, -0.01792873814702034, -0.00802512839436531, 0.062007755041122437, 0.03787880018353462, -0.07008497416973114, -0.013770408928394318, 0.02063276618719101, 0.07014594227075577, -0.043362800031900406, 0.05511301010847092, 0.05902305245399475, -0.019472723826766014, -0.0010949705028906465, -0.0346553735435009, -0.00654576113447547, 0.03138021007180214, 0.002137240953743458, -0.004490912891924381, -0.10453110188245773, 0.023628827184438705, 0.008403862826526165, -0.06747832894325256, 0.049553032964468, 0.032257843762636185, -0.0013464485527947545, 0.01734563708305359, 0.01846575178205967, 0.039082035422325134, 0.046714767813682556, -0.056829456239938736, 0.016361800953745842, 0.023619262501597404, -0.03220098465681076, 0.005891492590308189, -0.08557256311178207, 0.07440298795700073, 0.009778249077498913, -0.06822632253170013, -0.0017961910925805569, 0.05900154262781143, -0.019958287477493286, -0.08477440476417542, 0.021504653617739677, 0.062136076390743256, -0.009916241280734539, -0.032790932804346085, 0.053505394607782364, -0.043061912059783936, -0.023745622485876083, -0.045953940600156784, 0.03058871626853943, 0.031041326001286507, 0.03005584329366684, -0.003917980939149857, 0.007797305937856436, 0.002393437549471855, 0.0193687304854393, -0.08247997611761093, 0.021089160814881325, 0.032095011323690414, 0.023621870204806328, 0.09736345708370209, -0.014926130883395672, -0.029383700340986252, 0.03150542825460434, 0.006826386321336031, 0.029477635398507118, -0.019559619948267937, 0.015428325161337852, 0.051628489047288895, 0.032729621976614, -0.03210626542568207, -0.022076915949583054, -0.027288351207971573, 0.03019246831536293, 0.009412386454641819, -0.0009212010190822184, -0.0255862046033144, 0.008824716322124004, 0.030184848234057426, 0.02389858476817608, -0.01055833324790001, 0.03988012298941612, 0.06970790028572083, -0.006123937666416168, -0.00761192012578249, 0.00999809242784977, -0.009439722634851933, -0.09915336966514587, 0.015021155588328838, 0.036499932408332825, 0.025318685919046402, 0.0621202327311039, -0.013092604465782642, -0.028751574456691742, 0.02295125462114811, 0.023809462785720825, 0.07650802284479141, -0.045200929045677185, -0.00930483266711235, -0.03522903844714165, 0.012119310908019543, 0.01859143190085888, -0.043860021978616714, -0.07081577926874161, 0.008502625860273838, 0.0947854295372963, 0.04343651235103607, 0.025438683107495308, 0.012405935674905777, -0.040443647652864456, -0.02408275380730629, 0.004166055470705032, 0.05948389694094658, -0.02009524591267109, 0.02011888474225998, 0.013740185648202896, -0.009295884519815445, 0.043655164539813995, 0.004434788133949041, 0.042261406779289246, 0.002707092324271798, -0.10134498029947281, 0.022844528779387474, -0.07224694639444351, 0.08842755854129791, 0.04043768346309662, -0.010602845810353756, 0.016486767679452896, 0.017749859020113945, -0.012992866337299347, -0.1456792950630188, -0.011848945170640945, 0.04999712109565735, 0.018603062257170677, -0.05555269867181778, 0.03633135184645653, -0.001973184756934643, -0.027173412963747978, -0.028871502727270126, 0.012392600066959858, -0.010547027923166752, 0.10067400336265564, -0.017184406518936157, -0.04336952790617943, -0.0041292100213468075, 0.04322503134608269, -0.013958845287561417, 0.031091241165995598, -0.03326966613531113, 0.059424202889204025, 0.022519830614328384, -0.07617245614528656, 0.10376086831092834, 0.00582128157839179, -0.02544398233294487, -0.0320136584341526, 0.03523308038711548, -0.02236870676279068, -0.006176063325256109, -0.004804688040167093, 0.044733475893735886, -0.008251029066741467, -0.03785974532365799, 0.03861904516816139, -0.07559005916118622, 0.012567974627017975, 0.008713636547327042, -0.0033901804126799107, -0.04781373590230942, 0.0036081743892282248, 0.06995468586683273, 0.05170493572950363, -0.06699720025062561, -0.0357990600168705, -0.01421190146356821, 0.0463474839925766, 0.08812728524208069, -0.011121921241283417, -0.020749319344758987, 0.09001471102237701, -0.03318232670426369, -0.04119718074798584, 0.02440829575061798, 0.0270544346421957, 0.019224723801016808, -0.06048286333680153, -0.013587563298642635, 0.03417251259088516, -0.0185752771794796, 0.04044191166758537, 0.031804393976926804, -0.036241255700588226, -0.013295009732246399, 0.03269664943218231, 0.008752855472266674, 0.029713477939367294, -0.02221085876226425, 0.03391085937619209, -0.08796378970146179, -0.035200636833906174, 0.03932102397084236, 0.02921862155199051, 0.07705564796924591, -0.01725189760327339, -0.00485752709209919, -0.03643949329853058, 0.05713576823472977, -0.03811996802687645, 0.050832197070121765, 0.02219581976532936, 0.03675717115402222, -0.0020110064651817083, 0.0327463336288929, 0.01624329946935177, -0.01036957185715437, 0.04936452582478523, 0.028663553297519684, 0.010725334286689758, -0.04510940983891487, 0.03900572657585144, 0.009967834688723087, -0.007089353632181883, 0.020184583961963654, -0.09924677759408951, -0.03604203835129738, 0.019775390625, 0.03936310485005379, 0.0834401324391365, -0.013630944304168224, -0.05345706269145012, -0.04669269546866417, -0.013371835462749004, 0.047321248799562454, 0.10256372392177582, -0.06598873436450958, 0.030438264831900597, -0.01273060217499733, 0.003753269324079156, -0.004360776860266924, 0.12950630486011505, -0.02969236858189106, 0.005987083073705435, -0.06352309137582779, 0.026585537940263748, 0.05766544118523598, -0.035202063620090485, 0.004198664333671331, -0.07169129699468613, 0.002500900998711586, -0.002961220918223262, 0.043671607971191406, 0.03791346773505211, 0.05175954848527908, -0.0058545698411762714, -0.013375856913626194, 0.05337899178266525, -0.045047953724861145, 0.07436195015907288, 0.050168175250291824, 0.02527007646858692, -0.010154634714126587, 0.10858258605003357, 0.05898400396108627, 0.03731152042746544, -0.025082815438508987, -0.034539882093667984, -0.0484229251742363, 0.011909821070730686, 0.022934624925255775, -0.02825363352894783, 0.053329210728406906, 0.08625303953886032, 0.012083575129508972, -0.03926479443907738, 0.008480311371386051, -0.0006559083121828735, 0.004665401764214039, -0.0149031151086092, 0.09462548047304153, 0.0066114249639213085, 0.03205084055662155, -0.02260272018611431, 0.028617674484848976, -0.05146124213933945, 0.03629560023546219, 0.06098628416657448, -0.06185796484351158, -0.05318920686841011, -0.021543441340327263, 0.02002134546637535, -0.019730515778064728, -0.09950017929077148, -0.017054740339517593, 0.04508325457572937, 0.09887398034334183, 0.010997234843671322, -0.013477488420903683, -0.0007851456175558269, -0.054390475153923035, 0.05963842198252678, 0.014308489859104156, -0.0034760201815515757, -0.011172056198120117, -0.021496668457984924, 0.006863206159323454, -0.10440606623888016, -0.008234264329075813, -0.061305973678827286, -0.02416614256799221, 0.011129999533295631, -0.06786441802978516, -0.010976426303386688, 0.02914387546479702, -0.02920282445847988, -0.01259930431842804, 0.02901981957256794, 0.022763704881072044, 0.036245159804821014, -0.055708739906549454, 0.0013963248347863555, 0.012319277971982956, 0.052956171333789825, 0.030618816614151, -0.022240430116653442, -0.04282929375767708, -0.10142815858125687, -0.027027476578950882, 0.06598176807165146, 0.0030123363249003887, 0.011006881482899189, -0.0017195787513628602, -0.020712148398160934, 0.10554488003253937, 0.06694234907627106, -0.06113392487168312, -0.015686077997088432, -0.06230538338422775, -0.0054295966401696205, 0.0012697356287389994, -0.04421225190162659, 0.013680548407137394, -0.09148212522268295, 0.0114790303632617, -0.11466796696186066, -0.035156115889549255, 0.03664027526974678, -0.0924534723162651, -0.05335862189531326, 0.036737553775310516, 0.004802841227501631, 0.043870583176612854, 0.08418881893157959, 0.03907003253698349, -0.05827596038579941, 0.03595379739999771, 0.0445050373673439, -0.000015849100236664526, 0.002877518767490983, 0.018776290118694305, -0.02608649432659149, 0.032119106501340866, -0.021547621116042137, 0.04602433368563652, -0.042678188532590866, 0.06255069375038147, 0.0472642220556736, -0.026010777801275253, -0.05444347485899925, -0.0016776606207713485, 0.015733081847429276, -0.09887468069791794, -0.0028034134302288294, -0.020711032673716545, 0.04357743635773659, 0.025870442390441895, -0.04787907749414444, -0.06789858639240265, 0.024456143379211426, -0.02342371456325054, -0.09414832293987274, -0.04866741970181465, 0.0792524442076683, -0.01307456474751234, -0.015991436317563057, 0.03437065705657005, -0.025042112916707993, 0.013122638687491417, -0.07272789627313614, 0.021260416135191917, 0.09038513153791428, 0.0516958124935627, 0.005450244527310133, -0.024355456233024597, 0.030034024268388748, 0.04675852879881859, 0.053269628435373306, 0.022479958832263947, -0.006935794837772846, 0.028326591476798058, -0.02401222474873066, 0.05114712193608284, 0.06794846802949905, 0.03307550027966499, 0.04572375863790512, -0.03551637753844261, 0.04358695447444916, 0.007860289886593819, 0.023813333362340927, 0.12235695868730545, 0.01552946213632822, -0.007110061589628458, 0.0379285030066967, 0.02892136014997959, -0.059144362807273865, -0.006989953573793173, 0.026802456006407738, 0.05857916176319122, -0.05049876123666763 ]
244
244
Conditional Probability Tree Estimation Analysis and Algorithms
We consider the problem of estimating the conditional probability of a label in time $O(\log n)$, where $n$ is the number of possible labels. We analyze a natural reduction of this problem to a set of binary regression problems organized in a tree structure, proving a regret bound that scales with the depth of the tree. Motivated by this analysis, we propose the first online algorithm which provably constructs a logarithmic depth tree on the set of labels to solve this problem. We test the algorithm empirically, showing that it works succesfully on a dataset with roughly $10^6$ labels.
[ -0.0775839239358902, -0.05487954989075661, 0.03983288258314133, -0.06430284678936005, 0.023522237315773964, -0.03041006065905094, 0.07914704084396362, -0.009577483870089054, -0.042856018990278244, 0.002620738698169589, -0.0143858278170228, 0.017474889755249023, -0.01981446146965027, 0.0011537873651832342, 0.024828637018799782, -0.08079086989164352, -0.05858388915657997, -0.029837094247341156, 0.005373320076614618, -0.03503520414233208, 0.0004516949411481619, 0.040847595781087875, 0.002166725229471922, -0.0548870712518692, 0.01784498244524002, 0.0475110188126564, 0.022801997140049934, 0.05910231173038483, -0.07541642338037491, -0.12278339266777039, -0.06373879313468933, 0.02202560007572174, -0.0035675624385476112, 0.06091694533824921, -0.004882613196969032, -0.057311683893203735, 0.049637362360954285, 0.01291543897241354, -0.02605804055929184, -0.002888286951929331, 0.05998397246003151, -0.06598885357379913, -0.027717208489775658, -0.020545553416013718, 0.0274636372923851, 0.0019577322527766228, 0.05796917527914047, 0.0027533220127224922, 0.007412350736558437, 0.053867414593696594, -0.06507951021194458, 0.03567417338490486, -0.04278853163123131, -0.024405168369412422, 0.01432111393660307, 0.032375022768974304, 0.036241017282009125, -0.006408185698091984, 0.010333927348256111, -0.009546663612127304, -0.0050996276549994946, 0.06831728667020798, -0.010151732712984085, -0.07011235505342484, -0.06326676905155182, 0.04106307774782181, -0.07641549408435822, -0.047532856464385986, -0.008924076333642006, 0.01209576241672039, -0.009248924441635609, -0.016123566776514053, -0.00816410593688488, 0.01492656022310257, 0.05751637741923332, -0.05729029327630997, 0.024266371503472328, 0.023624548688530922, -0.03954790160059929, 0.05974452197551727, -0.02903056889772415, 0.07910192012786865, 0.016124490648508072, 0.012189860455691814, -0.04510756954550743, -0.04454728588461876, 0.02213098481297493, -0.007048908621072769, 0.05157195404171944, -0.02432883530855179, -0.054758258163928986, 0.05436806008219719, -0.018744617700576782, 0.02283129282295704, 0.020231010392308235, 0.08387649804353714, 0.0043396721594035625, -0.0025914961006492376, 0.02204775996506214, 0.07415076345205307, 0.03413885086774826, -0.019082482904195786, 0.010994801297783852, 0.011710070073604584, -0.06991685926914215, 0.012913914397358894, 0.010301748290657997, 0.060320306569337845, 0.06122492626309395, -0.030933314934372902, 0.07824458926916122, -0.05069281533360481, 0.017822835594415665, 0.020024606958031654, 0.013124076649546623, 0.02738105319440365, 0.0078347809612751, 0.031008834019303322, -0.015200616791844368, 0.00846014078706503, 0.030568331480026245, 0.03712160140275955, -0.08361313492059708, 0.053945913910865784, -0.003821367397904396, -0.10087387263774872, -0.06586601585149765, -0.07501043379306793, 0.10301847010850906, 0.07254447042942047, -0.0453626923263073, 0.043790653347969055, -0.04928260296583176, 0.006171881686896086, -0.08978346735239029, -0.02105076238512993, 0.12033793330192566, -0.018485449254512787, 0.05282890796661377, 0.020126530900597572, -0.02724332921206951, 0.0556180477142334, 0.0012161387130618095, -0.01588636077940464, -0.016789132729172707, 0.0670817494392395, 0.04088738560676575, 0.013741694390773773, -0.03199758380651474, -0.048820652067661285, -0.042955853044986725, -0.05320475995540619, 0.0133208641782403, 0.03673798218369484, 0.050061170011758804, -0.0225153136998415, -0.04382863640785217, -0.0068200272507965565, 0.03573605418205261, 0.041436340659856796, -0.05874286964535713, -0.019203467294573784, 0.047811176627874374, 0.06370040029287338, -0.03198761120438576, 0.04247273504734039, -0.003696420229971409, 0.03462836146354675, -0.04288825765252113, -0.048320915549993515, 0.007644630968570709, 0.052284907549619675, -0.013181643560528755, 0.012895024381577969, 0.001906195073388517, 0.016280779615044594, 0.029783178120851517, -0.038403406739234924, -0.0416717454791069, 0.017998723313212395, 0.1255050003528595, -0.04916058108210564, -0.012454197742044926, 0.030291788280010223, 0.032101649791002274, 0.08619140088558197, 0.008983397856354713, 0.024036750197410583, 0.023147761821746826, 0.03262072429060936, 0.036235615611076355, 0.03900602087378502, 0.0020698432344943285, 0.015872688964009285, 0.029650408774614334, -0.026192987337708473, -0.06543269753456116, -0.008223406039178371, -0.05170788988471031, -0.04664204269647598, -0.002047718735411763, 0.020227055996656418, -0.0569949597120285, -0.03762420266866684, -0.032429300248622894, 0.03061206266283989, 0.047512173652648926, -0.00003182004002155736, -0.03436144068837166, -0.029500730335712433, 0.025706680491566658, 0.06859816610813141, 0.022203898057341576, -0.010914213955402374, 0.012733585201203823, -0.06635556370019913, -0.01863999478518963, -0.017539100721478462, 0.0608196035027504, 0.1070939227938652, 0.04194396361708641, 0.05272384732961655, -0.004134871996939182, 0.02988874725997448, -0.11570535600185394, 0.05014446750283241, 0.05150502547621727, 0.011563354171812534, 0.0016118449857458472, 0.07671450823545456, 0.03893009573221207, -0.06695651262998581, -0.05424943193793297, -0.006562838330864906, -0.002364978427067399, 0.12559209764003754, -0.009031823836266994, -0.035770997405052185, -0.00619154516607523, 0.05278031900525093, -0.07492689043283463, 0.028770633041858673, -0.02865142561495304, -0.08382707834243774, 0.03289421647787094, 0.03282565250992775, 0.07404516637325287, -0.022425957024097443, 0.053805820643901825, -0.07437355816364288, 0.0075613586232066154, -0.04896573722362518, -0.027054810896515846, -0.033182818442583084, 0.04895947128534317, 0.03668142482638359, -0.011612403206527233, 0.10487888008356094, 0.08889582753181458, 0.007851972244679928, 0.05189439281821251, 0.010512489825487137, -0.06888830661773682, 0.029993675649166107, 0.03812159225344658, 0.07457573711872101, 0.0027575886342674494, -0.005998432636260986, 0.04706699401140213, 0.02029164507985115, 0.013000233098864555, -0.05715564638376236, -0.004153937101364136, 0.08204402774572372, 0.013389065861701965, -0.0013814754784107208, 0.011310205794870853, -0.038838934153318405, 0.022606713697314262, -0.026692626997828484, -0.05817066505551338, 0.0112826619297266, 0.07468584179878235, 0.07495994865894318, -0.01146730873733759, 0.0009900949662551284, 0.010109825059771538, -0.04068722203373909, 0.02283923327922821, 0.028507351875305176, -0.03606738895177841, 0.01901712454855442, -0.027485046535730362, 0.00883063767105341, 0.034098874777555466, -0.04181680455803871, 0.03524184972047806, -0.0010188781889155507, 0.05946987122297287, -0.003447029972448945, -0.01073585543781519, 0.05515826493501663, 0.09147816896438599, 0.00611095828935504, -0.0042748176492750645, 0.04986736178398132, 0.004976325202733278, -0.0019086393294855952, -0.0052174716256558895, -0.027837498113512993, -0.002957019256427884, 0.001926534459926188, -0.08459367603063583, 0.027558760717511177, -0.01973036490380764, -0.017996469512581825, -0.0016961205983534455, -0.07000301778316498, 0.009679513052105904, 0.023945141583681107, 0.020756322890520096, -0.01386321522295475, 0.016601083800196648, -0.030000785365700722, -0.0638904869556427, -0.014725004322826862, 0.00864026602357626, 0.0712900385260582, -0.03296443074941635, 0.04161970317363739, -0.04013253375887871, 0.01610965095460415, -0.05857621878385544, 0.10842111706733704, -0.05624569579958916, 0.03206862881779671, -0.060253821313381195, -0.006377798970788717, 0.0009234329336322844, 0.04678013548254967, -0.08658803999423981, -0.05233337730169296, -0.022906990721821785, 0.0037418543361127377, 0.01990002579987049, 0.02545771934092045, 0.00917997770011425, 0.028354378417134285, 0.0347508005797863, 0.023731468245387077, -0.061736177653074265, 0.04746595770120621, 0.006260296329855919, 0.0952354222536087, -0.0044202315621078014, 0.038701996207237244, 0.06493895500898361, -0.08277040719985962, -0.004377043806016445, 0.009859678335487843, -0.02916884236037731, -0.0035119366366416216, 0.030374271795153618, -0.01911640726029873, -0.007910520769655704, 0.023859607055783272, -0.06978140026330948, 0.006265029311180115, -0.01474923174828291, 0.08479619771242142, 0.08263953775167465, -0.012405326589941978, 0.023351745679974556, 0.010618056170642376, -0.04426490515470505, -0.02436845935881138, 0.030178966000676155, -0.012321109883487225, 0.02639441005885601, 0.08999939262866974, -0.08714234828948975, -0.02131880447268486, -0.06990307569503784, 0.006336533930152655, 0.06243165582418442, -0.1014307290315628, -0.06522811949253082, -0.02084890939295292, 0.09778155386447906, -0.008873553946614265, 0.054642532020807266, -0.05510590597987175, 0.01722305454313755, 0.004927427973598242, -0.02332388050854206, 0.0324852354824543, -0.0036015601363033056, -0.022228727117180824, 0.020996559411287308, -0.005912786815315485, 0.0035394164733588696, -0.015882911160588264, -0.004725068341940641, -0.04164617881178856, -0.04347766935825348, 0.06645061075687408, 0.003832744201645255, 0.04882261902093887, -0.05700717121362686, -0.008796196430921555, 0.04566296935081482, 0.09155283123254776, -0.03950425237417221, 0.01453029178082943, -0.006898282095789909, 0.010727649554610252, 0.04953710362315178, -0.048600636422634125, -0.020421797409653664, -0.049074675887823105, 0.06544718146324158, 0.03505904600024223, -0.04055825620889664, 0.029297515749931335, -0.0010499187046661973, -0.0500822514295578, 0.06486565619707108, 0.0663614273071289, -0.040589332580566406, 0.04915088042616844, 0.01496821641921997, 0.030582908540964127, -0.07447518408298492, 0.0934065505862236, -0.01561590563505888, 0.02343890815973282, -0.009678317233920097, 0.003348859027028084, -0.023264439776539803, -0.003564229467883706, -0.06334345042705536, 0.019074704498052597, 0.04221511632204056, 0.033501435071229935, -0.009282770566642284, 0.036622554063797, 0.05076217278838158, 0.012363817542791367, 0.0697510614991188, -0.020256033167243004, 0.03205551952123642, 0.013143542222678661, -0.008737911470234394, 0.0067679500207304955, -0.03015085682272911, -0.06427226960659027, 0.007846171036362648, -0.017999906092882156, 0.027954762801527977, -0.007106415927410126, -0.008815542794764042, -0.07779490202665329, -0.019954895600676537, -0.04059217870235443, 0.01693771220743656, 0.02592005766928196, 0.047842372208833694, -0.00876549445092678, 0.016719801351428032, -0.053655724972486496, -0.05794811248779297, 0.05837361514568329, 0.000410247768741101, -0.007419283501803875, 0.023501409217715263, -0.049142345786094666, 0.03321346268057823, -0.07030988484621048, 0.026941966265439987, -0.01875481568276882, 0.004260122310370207, -0.05299873277544975, -0.0720381960272789, -0.007121851667761803, 0.08946657180786133, -0.014735144563019276, -0.02351180836558342, 0.003634965280070901, 0.07054153084754944, 0.05062789469957352, 0.008567454293370247, 0.003095269203186035, 0.029715480282902718, -0.0023802134674042463, 0.02425411157310009, 0.04840266332030296, 0.04201280325651169, 0.043351735919713974, -0.022798679769039154, 0.061234790831804276, 0.013465662486851215, -0.04300439730286598, 0.07567810267210007, 0.031091347336769104, 0.08175740391016006, 0.07413443922996521, -0.06430290639400482, -0.06364976614713669, -0.006783593446016312, 0.0072806705720722675, -0.02472648024559021, -0.015813544392585754 ]
245
245
Graph polynomials and approximation of partition functions with Loopy Belief Propagation
The Bethe approximation, or loopy belief propagation algorithm is a successful method for approximating partition functions of probabilistic models associated with a graph. Chertkov and Chernyak derived an interesting formula called Loop Series Expansion, which is an expansion of the partition function. The main term of the series is the Bethe approximation while other terms are labeled by subgraphs called generalized loops. In our recent paper, we derive the loop series expansion in form of a polynomial with coefficients positive integers, and extend the result to the expansion of marginals. In this paper, we give more clear derivation for the results and discuss the properties of the polynomial which is introduced in the paper.
[ -0.07240568101406097, -0.08052972704172134, 0.04740811884403229, -0.11345134675502777, 0.04149926081299782, -0.04556239768862724, 0.004546653013676405, -0.10313016176223755, -0.006812510546296835, -0.016738731414079666, -0.04492993652820587, -0.08244843780994415, -0.012658602558076382, 0.07129984349012375, 0.11647050827741623, -0.04122947156429291, -0.0037625960540026426, 0.049972232431173325, -0.0014107932802289724, 0.052535150200128555, 0.05128975212574005, 0.04134509712457657, 0.0231161005795002, -0.10496268421411514, 0.09266107529401779, -0.028975501656532288, 0.027658823877573013, 0.03340447321534157, -0.06076913699507713, -0.021457338705658913, -0.11956192553043365, 0.038250163197517395, -0.023013228550553322, 0.09056029468774796, 0.04870981723070145, -0.001079406007193029, 0.009476995095610619, -0.03305649384856224, 0.02065710909664631, -0.023384755477309227, 0.0338100828230381, -0.017044156789779663, 0.018054015934467316, -0.022417789325118065, 0.015590113587677479, -0.04725969210267067, -0.03654398396611214, 0.03982611373066902, 0.015452527441084385, 0.03080691397190094, -0.09509621560573578, 0.000328645488480106, -0.043135493993759155, -0.024222858250141144, -0.036993760615587234, 0.031182218343019485, -0.04472917690873146, 0.03949906304478645, -0.01457749493420124, 0.026811009272933006, 0.0075720204040408134, 0.03646162152290344, -0.05882604792714119, 0.003150360193103552, -0.027641987428069115, -0.0069429390132427216, -0.001429881202057004, 0.03356014937162399, -0.01106716226786375, -0.02708197757601738, 0.04624480754137039, -0.04440727084875107, 0.05891016498208046, 0.09595020860433578, 0.030360598117113113, -0.025687312707304955, -0.0117039754986763, 0.019212927669286728, -0.031320419162511826, 0.08245106786489487, -0.037159305065870285, 0.004901866428554058, -0.026273144409060478, 0.05450388044118881, -0.06239915266633034, -0.016040751710534096, 0.01465565524995327, 0.060227178037166595, 0.02771107479929924, -0.06069250777363777, -0.062233153730630875, 0.022372448816895485, -0.07504700124263763, 0.05013371631503105, 0.031297165900468826, 0.05302197486162186, -0.03276502713561058, 0.006094650365412235, -0.019472317770123482, 0.028467264026403427, -0.0604042112827301, 0.03425491973757744, 0.019810186699032784, 0.04514969512820244, -0.02233233116567135, -0.04374954104423523, 0.04906440153717995, -0.02286168932914734, 0.010677502490580082, -0.05811921879649162, 0.00839180313050747, -0.014304585754871368, -0.02487245202064514, -0.019109399989247322, -0.04363025724887848, 0.0819089263677597, 0.0072493841871619225, 0.12251822650432587, 0.09138283878564835, 0.06808017939329147, -0.010414231568574905, -0.07251013070344925, -0.024725254625082016, 0.009366492740809917, 0.013454851694405079, -0.08203025907278061, 0.03142256289720535, -0.032199736684560776, 0.08855040371417999, -0.0014092959463596344, 0.031880758702754974, 0.06367142498493195, 0.01109195314347744, -0.010654148645699024, -0.0930003970861435, -0.011379864998161793, 0.009308411739766598, -0.015024824067950249, -0.06778866797685623, 0.10990128666162491, -0.06617733836174011, -0.06483349204063416, 0.06733948737382889, -0.0013810022501274943, 0.043283626437187195, 0.10025650262832642, 0.0485653318464756, 0.050045136362314224, 0.006182035431265831, -0.027373816817998886, -0.03814264386892319, 0.04723253473639488, -0.04985116422176361, 0.0340992733836174, 0.04088439792394638, 0.019349604845046997, -0.005300539545714855, -0.013913802802562714, 0.015234019607305527, 0.04046839848160744, -0.06337035447359085, -0.04150008782744408, -0.03268814459443092, 0.059588223695755005, 0.02789737656712532, 0.045688215643167496, 0.000867268128786236, -0.03250627592206001, -0.011874621734023094, -0.04158489406108856, -0.00022870062093716115, -0.019316071644425392, 0.03592517226934433, -0.008276592940092087, 0.0012297978391870856, -0.040941622108221054, 0.004589520860463381, 0.020221155136823654, 0.025264639407396317, -0.009771238081157207, 0.05045704171061516, -0.02577451430261135, 0.031979601830244064, -0.004022881854325533, 0.02505163475871086, 0.022779181599617004, 0.045139774680137634, 0.022379718720912933, 0.03269251808524132, 0.10238095372915268, 0.03324366733431816, 0.0773685872554779, -0.02152780443429947, 0.007077530026435852, -0.058390792459249496, 0.018389923498034477, -0.03328975290060043, -0.011900706216692924, 0.05219060555100441, 0.01736857183277607, 0.018469320610165596, 0.018217818811535835, -0.03816796839237213, 0.00854430254548788, 0.03495754301548004, 0.046643417328596115, 0.029058480635285378, -0.1322287768125534, -0.011497750878334045, -0.006437018979340792, 0.01621200703084469, 0.03674716874957085, 0.0008074922952800989, -0.047763071954250336, 0.02433982864022255, -0.04353801906108856, -0.020021678879857063, -0.03339885175228119, 0.05508573353290558, 0.020799271762371063, 0.02419758215546608, 0.045772016048431396, 0.07182092219591141, 0.02379332296550274, -0.044562891125679016, 0.021745894104242325, 0.016493428498506546, -0.014206203632056713, 0.0013075713068246841, -0.003834852948784828, 0.002530221361666918, -0.03756483644247055, 0.06488866358995438, 0.02900129370391369, -0.01526291947811842, 0.09778197854757309, -0.016817204654216766, 0.0016096404287964106, -0.04283574968576431, 0.012395331636071205, -0.06678268313407898, 0.04617146775126457, -0.06949914246797562, 0.02902141585946083, -0.04081735759973526, -0.0048684910871088505, 0.03507239371538162, 0.02181716077029705, -0.04099056497216225, -0.0022047897800803185, -0.034007225185632706, -0.01912061683833599, -0.04135866090655327, 0.023052340373396873, 0.052463121712207794, -0.06983602046966553, -0.003509319154545665, 0.08089644461870193, 0.0018275952897965908, 0.013305878266692162, -0.03690475597977638, 0.023903988301753998, -0.025335604324936867, -0.03861895203590393, 0.04037193953990936, 0.054841842502355576, -0.021030303090810776, -0.0025182515382766724, -0.005579220596700907, 0.027023058384656906, 0.07296410948038101, 0.0028158403001725674, -0.07089201360940933, 0.06204050034284592, 0.008192346431314945, -0.08497323095798492, 0.05152473226189613, 0.0033004763536155224, 0.022117597982287407, -0.09913700819015503, -0.011745113879442215, 0.011398321017622948, -0.0075219846330583096, -0.06886783242225647, -0.031014518812298775, 0.04816291481256485, 0.03427876904606819, -0.024137016385793686, 0.033785380423069, 0.08401457220315933, -0.0163239985704422, 0.009885258972644806, 0.008185254409909248, -0.006994486320763826, 0.023937875404953957, -0.11242234706878662, 0.03984800726175308, -0.03303409367799759, -0.018081126734614372, -0.03436262160539627, 0.043118368834257126, 0.0003556602168828249, 0.10793092846870422, -0.04992393031716347, 0.01862301118671894, 0.03452354669570923, 0.05095946788787842, 0.03660168871283531, -0.06795655190944672, 0.00507355947047472, 0.036808162927627563, -0.024892345070838928, -0.029641922563314438, 0.0360589362680912, 0.01839250884950161, 0.0011310514528304338, -0.07002277672290802, -0.08190833777189255, -0.05010326951742172, 0.019710257649421692, -0.03581957146525383, -0.023255223408341408, -0.020967742428183556, -0.046193309128284454, -0.072320356965065, 0.06245901435613632, 0.04253009334206581, 0.1154504120349884, -0.06299225240945816, -0.003666302654892206, -0.017491884529590607, -0.01474174577742815, -0.04408557713031769, 0.06420702487230301, 0.0570150688290596, 0.014445651322603226, -0.013976125977933407, 0.016908636316657066, 0.013387953862547874, 0.033150870352983475, -0.030979320406913757, -0.0507800467312336, 0.03811636194586754, -0.027223339304327965, 0.009642321616411209, 0.04201933741569519, 0.05251041054725647, -0.029257602989673615, -0.05516337230801582, 0.024055074900388718, -0.034169331192970276, 0.051651664078235626, -0.002423291327431798, 0.08517902344465256, -0.02926022931933403, 0.09611240774393082, 0.01975659653544426, -0.046501822769641876, -0.009151531383395195, -0.030568912625312805, -0.0034511489793658257, 0.017679495736956596, -0.0168262030929327, -0.00010440983896842226, 0.029737384989857674, -0.0011564320884644985, -0.07506917417049408, -0.05604016035795212, 0.10422595590353012, 0.010494889691472054, -0.034014079719781876, -0.021986626088619232, 0.031782619655132294, -0.00545545294880867, 0.00009488474461250007, -0.01384024228900671, 0.01800266094505787, -0.020095812156796455, 0.04522058367729187, -0.014183848164975643, 0.02337537705898285, -0.03394782915711403, -0.06604091823101044, -0.05421355366706848, 0.004214917775243521, -0.030264871194958687, 0.005922573618590832, -0.02496476285159588, 0.044503677636384964, -0.05652128532528877, 0.03761103376746178, -0.08093932271003723, 0.06084468960762024, -0.02173173427581787, 0.02993781864643097, -0.013032598420977592, -0.012080894783139229, 0.00035977462539449334, 0.030289839953184128, -0.05619136616587639, -0.012779917567968369, -0.05663873255252838, 0.0006222280208021402, 0.012575624510645866, -0.04028597101569176, -0.03074980340898037, 0.046497780829668045, 0.02289215475320816, 0.03315045312047005, 0.03494618088006973, 0.00570814311504364, 0.007689427584409714, -0.04480548948049545, -0.020683232694864273, 0.03835422173142433, 0.04317529499530792, 0.08199037611484528, -0.0023428022395819426, -0.004580014850944281, -0.005805412773042917, -0.02466023527085781, 0.0034192660823464394, 0.021428309381008148, -0.019265588372945786, -0.010377638041973114, -0.057824891060590744, 0.06653560698032379, 0.04576868936419487, -0.01642593741416931, -0.04727381095290184, -0.10507892817258835, -0.013086004182696342, -0.056826770305633545, 0.005985449068248272, 0.06038368493318558, -0.0176549069583416, 0.0022838013246655464, -0.012874034233391285, 0.008925358764827251, -0.002900158055126667, -0.0026129819452762604, 0.043138567358255386, -0.019612615928053856, -0.019556846469640732, 0.07014933228492737, 0.05872425436973572, 0.03246172145009041, 0.021655526012182236, -0.013543806038796902, -0.0041639660485088825, 0.024997534230351448, -0.031860023736953735, -0.0033707204274833202, -0.012202776968479156, -0.056020040065050125, 0.02725910022854805, -0.030160680413246155, 0.04728255048394203, 0.02584858052432537, -0.06462139636278152, -0.01808876171708107, -0.0550246424973011, -0.0359024778008461, -0.0013371867826208472, -0.0271686390042305, -0.00890434067696333, 0.008231015875935555, -0.000564057903829962, 0.0053866468369960785, -0.029502971097826958, 0.008038073778152466, -0.005058378912508488, -0.030171280726790428, -0.10805754363536835, -0.06436846405267715, 0.002288670977577567, 0.09846069663763046, -0.026616379618644714, 0.034321799874305725, 0.01494919415563345, 0.06406301259994507, 0.02987733483314514, -0.07073111832141876, 0.0432366319000721, 0.012817137874662876, 0.032577306032180786, 0.02392593026161194, 0.004119789693504572, 0.02888515405356884, 0.029430413618683815, 0.06191972270607948, -0.01911969855427742, -0.03725610673427582, 0.024024583399295807, 0.08440602570772171, 0.05647570639848709, -0.00375716807320714, -0.04543009027838707, 0.01165925245732069, -0.006539902649819851, 0.09713996946811676, -0.06892621517181396, 0.06873732805252075, 0.05484966188669205, 0.04699818789958954, 0.040146369487047195, 0.025027599185705185, -0.05799771472811699, -0.04068366810679436, 0.060119178146123886, -0.03506443277001381, 0.028895525261759758 ]
246
246
An Exponential Lower Bound on the Complexity of Regularization Paths
For a variety of regularized optimization problems in machine learning, algorithms computing the entire solution path have been developed recently. Most of these methods are quadratic programs that are parameterized by a single parameter, as for example the Support Vector Machine (SVM). Solution path algorithms do not only compute the solution for one particular value of the regularization parameter but the entire path of solutions, making the selection of an optimal parameter much easier. It has been assumed that these piecewise linear solution paths have only linear complexity, i.e. linearly many bends. We prove that for the support vector machine this complexity can be exponential in the number of training points in the worst case. More strongly, we construct a single instance of n input points in d dimensions for an SVM such that at least \Theta(2^{n/2}) = \Theta(2^d) many distinct subsets of support vectors occur as the regularization parameter changes.
[ 0.029035910964012146, -0.00003799602927756496, 0.007574102375656366, -0.04910139739513397, 0.016809627413749695, -0.04236918315291405, 0.011383687146008015, 0.025772005319595337, -0.04104277119040489, -0.02118704840540886, 0.06709001213312149, 0.027646249160170555, -0.014373342506587505, -0.0030819547828286886, -0.06283639371395111, -0.0062716007232666016, 0.022196615114808083, 0.046132124960422516, 0.029613131657242775, -0.041785165667533875, 0.021982356905937195, 0.012392379343509674, 0.046971745789051056, -0.03413112834095955, 0.04395770654082298, 0.047217294573783875, 0.03497396782040596, 0.0081560630351305, 0.07278928905725479, 0.00853845663368702, -0.08098132908344269, 0.04520421475172043, -0.00597760733217001, -0.07678152620792389, 0.012766188941895962, -0.0675896406173706, 0.04358835890889168, -0.005703670438379049, -0.07569469511508942, -0.0232014711946249, -0.004194820299744606, 0.06369218230247498, 0.02796066366136074, 0.01149169635027647, 0.0873667299747467, -0.025566313415765762, 0.03374761715531349, 0.021190550178289413, -0.02386241778731346, 0.0747959166765213, -0.06278175115585327, 0.06550547480583191, -0.10335066169500351, -0.00912378542125225, 0.022355545312166214, -0.05025754123926163, -0.06937514245510101, -0.01213668379932642, 0.04139578714966774, -0.05980590730905533, 0.02456519939005375, 0.09149808436632156, -0.01365015096962452, -0.022036360576748848, -0.019187992438673973, -0.02260301262140274, -0.06465107947587967, -0.07802034914493561, -0.01398707740008831, 0.015912307426333427, -0.06699346750974655, -0.0630374476313591, 0.02788771130144596, 0.001461667474359274, 0.07610795646905899, -0.042042773216962814, -0.0035810833796858788, 0.006578270811587572, -0.026071621105074883, 0.018399415537714958, -0.005822100210934877, -0.018582139164209366, -0.01023421622812748, 0.04918867349624634, -0.04328252747654915, 0.018675627186894417, -0.00989522784948349, 0.023794716224074364, 0.010774221271276474, 0.0025044383946806192, 0.0040900553576648235, 0.057363033294677734, -0.04287770017981529, 0.05683648958802223, -0.05267981067299843, -0.014355888590216637, -0.013445192016661167, -0.04352028667926788, -0.004616012796759605, 0.07064756006002426, 0.019947199150919914, 0.07015157490968704, 0.07946209609508514, 0.08535227924585342, -0.021906515583395958, -0.04769446328282356, 0.009441708214581013, 0.10087896883487701, -0.050850074738264084, -0.007868077605962753, 0.005788698792457581, -0.02772638201713562, 0.042627353221178055, -0.026895461603999138, -0.048147957772016525, 0.024631427600979805, -0.0039745778776705265, 0.04349784553050995, 0.03807571902871132, -0.048026442527770996, -0.00353869516402483, 0.029413044452667236, -0.03003694675862789, 0.0658237412571907, 0.011717881076037884, -0.09369942545890808, 0.02597838081419468, -0.013252275064587593, 0.03195357695221901, 0.022401483729481697, -0.059666961431503296, -0.03365199640393257, 0.01691976934671402, -0.014971684664487839, -0.06542344391345978, -0.032310932874679565, 0.07957498729228973, -0.024119213223457336, -0.025198919698596, 0.05702613294124603, 0.041017886251211166, -0.019746284931898117, -0.07031241804361343, -0.021022958680987358, 0.002741377567872405, 0.04090877249836922, -0.008315245620906353, 0.011666909791529179, 0.04743611067533493, 0.020005179569125175, -0.05552690476179123, 0.019749706611037254, 0.04066008701920509, -0.05132836475968361, 0.04939146339893341, -0.0426241010427475, 0.024152474477887154, -0.0077945394441485405, 0.031062088906764984, 0.024289244785904884, -0.01599237695336342, 0.013760009780526161, 0.02923569455742836, 0.04552249610424042, 0.0028896210715174675, -0.0800633430480957, 0.07625623047351837, -0.08758265525102615, -0.04826243594288826, -0.037592172622680664, -0.03723175823688507, -0.05300433188676834, -0.006202378310263157, 0.02089284360408783, 0.008214623667299747, 0.04828658327460289, 0.03825885057449341, 0.002385868923738599, -0.08197294175624847, -0.02682800032198429, 0.032479047775268555, -0.043226458132267, 0.01592698134481907, 0.019920041784644127, 0.054961513727903366, 0.059105657041072845, 0.0018255168106406927, 0.015625877305865288, 0.02005637437105179, -0.0011098916875198483, -0.013181762769818306, -0.028656290844082832, 0.034979164600372314, -0.009965446777641773, -0.00904281809926033, 0.028317026793956757, -0.08516202121973038, -0.06641049683094025, 0.03034382499754429, 0.0440489761531353, 0.04916837066411972, -0.0045557403936982155, -0.04026877507567406, -0.09420886635780334, 0.03920550271868706, -0.027145786210894585, 0.030177462846040726, -0.05477888882160187, -0.044740866869688034, -0.03128719702363014, -0.04983481764793396, -0.013226062059402466, 0.04272375628352165, 0.01673661544919014, -0.04055275395512581, -0.028775980696082115, 0.06483197957277298, -0.019950130954384804, 0.09331290423870087, 0.06358122080564499, -0.011099584400653839, 0.033560916781425476, -0.036507751792669296, 0.0735456794500351, -0.09753594547510147, 0.03422418236732483, 0.011128771118819714, -0.015520074404776096, -0.03601636737585068, 0.08640582859516144, -0.014244558289647102, -0.05663977190852165, -0.06976582854986191, 0.0026484576519578695, -0.02393646351993084, 0.06367942690849304, -0.004808143246918917, -0.044143762439489365, 0.02432132512331009, -0.03875409811735153, -0.066004179418087, 0.014513016678392887, -0.042639441788196564, -0.05022135376930237, 0.028316833078861237, -0.042421985417604446, 0.08707402646541595, 0.0046886117197573185, 0.08089452981948853, -0.028764847666025162, 0.005842761602252722, 0.017534039914608, -0.031190786510705948, -0.03150548040866852, -0.0081973010674119, -0.049309179186820984, -0.020124025642871857, 0.09402091801166534, 0.022992471233010292, 0.05012468248605728, 0.05351182445883751, 0.0381312221288681, -0.05738047510385513, 0.023346100002527237, 0.07221995294094086, 0.006091605871915817, 0.0032560788094997406, 0.0021590697579085827, -0.028149224817752838, 0.07807166129350662, -0.019648706540465355, -0.055444251745939255, -0.033980049192905426, 0.016059137880802155, -0.009412754327058792, -0.008602895773947239, 0.07970093190670013, 0.07530819624662399, -0.014693708159029484, -0.05983983352780342, -0.05485747754573822, -0.0029201670549809933, 0.02353522926568985, -0.029450325295329094, 0.011281045153737068, 0.03477192297577858, -0.0663929283618927, 0.001889519509859383, -0.023362865671515465, 0.008578002452850342, -0.05329909548163414, 0.07280126959085464, -0.06484483927488327, -0.03863166272640228, 0.024799037724733353, -0.00912708230316639, 0.041984349489212036, 0.022052554413676262, 0.0059896595776081085, 0.01892603561282158, 0.07018169015645981, 0.0011504305293783545, 0.0009780115215107799, -0.031538110226392746, -0.02229236252605915, 0.12948253750801086, 0.0662132054567337, -0.019821111112833023, -0.0332755409181118, 0.015432116575539112, -0.006327320821583271, -0.025479745119810104, -0.04066363722085953, -0.024935834109783173, -0.009212943725287914, -0.0165232066065073, -0.014803382568061352, -0.04488443210721016, -0.04162454232573509, 0.010227298364043236, 0.0314776636660099, 0.04669640213251114, -0.011385399848222733, -0.03914021700620651, -0.11536585539579391, -0.0646367073059082, -0.02146082930266857, 0.06038089841604233, -0.008328122086822987, -0.03238808363676071, 0.009271976538002491, -0.004812607541680336, -0.0825374573469162, 0.016039814800024033, 0.01413445919752121, -0.03511003404855728, -0.001330002793110907, -0.005112763959914446, -0.07417129725217819, -0.0029332214035093784, -0.04955447092652321, -0.05454415827989578, -0.008029352873563766, 0.012765217572450638, 0.020897237583994865, 0.062348201870918274, -0.012728743255138397, -0.029758049175143242, -0.031829867511987686, 0.02231711708009243, -0.12495061010122299, 0.01495454739779234, -0.005484755616635084, 0.02567136473953724, -0.09833485633134842, 0.02370314858853817, 0.051328323781490326, -0.03912397101521492, -0.01603955589234829, -0.002144658239558339, 0.016010591760277748, -0.015086577273905277, -0.05191366747021675, 0.004795700777322054, -0.044870976358652115, 0.011623232625424862, -0.07755611091852188, 0.0031969621777534485, 0.037202343344688416, -0.011189080774784088, -0.07659947127103806, 0.01399913989007473, 0.026085570454597473, 0.0036142829339951277, -0.014808502048254013, -0.03769393265247345, 0.007281619124114513, 0.013796918094158173, -0.028808537870645523, 0.04427289217710495, -0.11281701177358627, 0.027212930843234062, -0.05806313082575798, 0.025996994227170944, 0.008592712692916393, 0.009457800537347794, -0.029074475169181824, -0.0010579413501545787, 0.021966073662042618, -0.0031735352240502834, 0.008398233912885189, 0.015795256942510605, 0.012860451824963093, 0.018041176721453667, -0.016888456419110298, 0.030687738209962845, 0.007976538501679897, -0.06014005094766617, -0.0014783249935135245, -0.007832939736545086, 0.004011367913335562, 0.005913370754569769, 0.03414750099182129, 0.04743027314543724, -0.011220423504710197, -0.03835570812225342, 0.053673043847084045, -0.009642432443797588, -0.01063960138708353, 0.08351381123065948, 0.02351003885269165, -0.008130425587296486, -0.035120561718940735, 0.09825312346220016, -0.009464951232075691, 0.027032792568206787, -0.030003327876329422, 0.0008127797627821565, 0.10258717089891434, -0.05084860697388649, -0.04462362080812454, 0.09358292818069458, 0.03943257033824921, 0.004594766069203615, 0.012095997110009193, -0.07471000403165817, 0.05447292700409889, 0.12536610662937164, -0.0556662417948246, -0.006282857619225979, -0.07242072373628616, -0.05382318049669266, -0.1057981327176094, 0.017263924703001976, 0.04710831865668297, 0.04761110991239548, 0.06340111792087555, -0.05055810511112213, 0.034112319350242615, -0.008373238146305084, -0.0327930711209774, 0.04278595745563507, -0.025555023923516273, -0.08313316851854324, 0.04667288810014725, 0.0146933663636446, 0.012258058413863182, -0.008608086965978146, 0.0870058536529541, 0.07086125016212463, -0.03707127273082733, 0.06616323441267014, -0.055950284004211426, 0.006526745855808258, 0.057486072182655334, -0.011891275644302368, 0.04761582985520363, -0.057335469871759415, -0.04620405286550522, -0.043775640428066254, 0.019389627501368523, -0.09033534675836563, -0.026228459551930428, 0.03014467842876911, -0.07829322665929794, 0.02174948900938034, -0.008938838727772236, -0.026905380189418793, -0.023781729862093925, 0.06660299748182297, -0.061264075338840485, 0.05382400378584862, -0.01634151116013527, -0.03690311685204506, 0.03561984747648239, 0.012979257851839066, 0.09786906838417053, -0.04816495627164841, 0.04239381477236748, -0.03753654286265373, 0.005731831304728985, -0.021677734330296516, -0.013448317535221577, 0.012358322739601135, 0.02916637249290943, 0.0073415120132267475, -0.09285853058099747, 0.03791102021932602, 0.034153006970882416, 0.031758636236190796, -0.003036495763808489, 0.007227388676255941, -0.01242432277649641, 0.0009426713222637773, -0.04376749321818352, -0.03293946757912636, 0.040793418884277344, -0.025620929896831512, 0.03157012537121773, 0.02167103812098503, 0.026322031393647194, -0.048629891127347946, 0.021379869431257248, 0.07373852282762527, -0.003748251125216484, 0.002670397749170661, 0.05058921128511429, -0.09132151305675507, -0.0467606782913208, 0.09043394774198532, -0.006427412386983633, -0.00117908522952348 ]
247
247
A Combinatorial Algorithm to Compute Regularization Paths
For a wide variety of regularization methods, algorithms computing the entire solution path have been developed recently. Solution path algorithms do not only compute the solution for one particular value of the regularization parameter but the entire path of solutions, making the selection of an optimal parameter much easier. Most of the currently used algorithms are not robust in the sense that they cannot deal with general or degenerate input. Here we present a new robust, generic method for parametric quadratic programming. Our algorithm directly applies to nearly all machine learning applications, where so far every application required its own different algorithm. We illustrate the usefulness of our method by applying it to a very low rank problem which could not be solved by existing path tracking methods, namely to compute part-worth values in choice based conjoint analysis, a popular technique from market research to estimate consumers preferences on a class of parameterized options.
[ 0.011198409833014011, 0.0015292392345145345, 0.005920384079217911, 0.01973591186106205, 0.017417263239622116, -0.004463746212422848, 0.00802625436335802, 0.02261020429432392, -0.018324514850974083, 0.00022576062474399805, 0.014149656519293785, -0.036349955946207047, 0.036223154515028, 0.018635017797350883, -0.03813733905553818, -0.0028471718542277813, -0.0516824834048748, 0.043818313628435135, 0.01894821971654892, -0.11219141632318497, 0.051407214254140854, -0.011720710434019566, 0.059566181153059006, -0.05549793690443039, 0.025985263288021088, 0.005737743806093931, -0.05580214411020279, 0.03807782009243965, 0.05812425538897514, -0.027101915329694748, -0.024047914892435074, 0.022181138396263123, 0.04113665223121643, -0.030315838754177094, 0.03473686799407005, -0.04183376953005791, 0.07618898898363113, 0.04018070548772812, -0.04062396660447121, -0.01698792167007923, 0.010399173945188522, 0.020269405096769333, 0.03481459990143776, 0.038040563464164734, 0.046817827969789505, -0.003191739786416292, 0.04542791098356247, 0.003465933259576559, -0.024973751977086067, 0.06355322897434235, -0.03562913462519646, 0.0561823770403862, -0.055726565420627594, -0.052668798714876175, 0.007216109428554773, -0.05941522493958473, -0.031615108251571655, -0.026504408568143845, 0.057346805930137634, -0.0069407690316438675, 0.03753294795751572, 0.0727393701672554, 0.012687661685049534, -0.03026200458407402, -0.043589863926172256, -0.04580957069993019, -0.08564532548189163, -0.060319606214761734, -0.02606639266014099, 0.0019135649781674147, 0.023333566263318062, -0.0037484040949493647, -0.0007396448054350913, 0.040900327265262604, 0.015981631353497505, -0.011393964290618896, -0.030035048723220825, -0.013965398073196411, -0.02720828354358673, 0.04096796363592148, -0.0042785098776221275, 0.0025031978730112314, -0.07944061607122421, 0.06723014265298843, -0.08241300284862518, -0.03512465953826904, -0.03389954939484596, -0.020447196438908577, 0.017721200361847878, -0.059896573424339294, -0.0492912195622921, 0.02747313119471073, -0.0619564987719059, 0.040653809905052185, -0.01400844193994999, -0.017372669652104378, -0.020155606791377068, -0.036296188831329346, 0.002227294258773327, 0.0689147487282753, 0.028994625434279442, 0.028321243822574615, 0.12271688133478165, 0.07592060416936874, 0.0020185436587780714, -0.017266757786273956, -0.07950469106435776, 0.03753227740526199, -0.030022580176591873, -0.001230166875757277, -0.02267288975417614, -0.0009470569202676415, 0.04811674728989601, -0.03827366605401039, -0.03790470212697983, 0.0641302689909935, -0.0098834577947855, 0.03707809001207352, 0.017405904829502106, -0.00008533013169653714, -0.04335172474384308, -0.0011721154442057014, -0.021762320771813393, 0.03281775116920471, 0.03496174514293671, -0.035251863300800323, 0.028634194284677505, -0.0330841951072216, 0.0661289393901825, 0.013116150163114071, -0.008815552107989788, 0.07785674929618835, 0.03751816228032112, -0.07449160516262054, -0.08357468247413635, 0.022502530366182327, 0.031072493642568588, -0.03698316588997841, -0.005030462518334389, -0.012887581251561642, 0.007974538952112198, -0.013829449191689491, -0.034176502376794815, 0.024811411276459694, 0.017317693680524826, -0.009079287759959698, 0.03718939051032066, -0.00899564754217863, -0.03705373778939247, -0.015541580505669117, -0.04194490611553192, 0.05015620216727257, 0.017231518402695656, 0.05416525527834892, 0.04055432602763176, 0.00209239823743701, 0.008263986557722092, -0.13031062483787537, -0.01199486292898655, 0.10730260610580444, -0.01894666813313961, 0.007432103157043457, 0.12862388789653778, 0.008188215084373951, -0.023396115750074387, -0.0948316752910614, -0.012911530211567879, 0.00815436989068985, -0.027919650077819824, -0.03437366336584091, 0.013778852298855782, -0.05320308357477188, -0.035624243319034576, 0.06530464440584183, 0.04539668187499046, -0.0015587930101901293, 0.03844404220581055, 0.016078224405646324, -0.05842456594109535, -0.030676817521452904, 0.0779520720243454, -0.042414821684360504, -0.032913293689489365, 0.008035765960812569, 0.01711859740316868, 0.043489132076501846, 0.004288151860237122, -0.00824659038335085, 0.04400699958205223, 0.026195412501692772, 0.008065551519393921, 0.004759069066494703, 0.035339679569005966, 0.027011528611183167, -0.039340242743492126, 0.02569958008825779, -0.05094807967543602, -0.09285477548837662, 0.015866829082369804, 0.03365987539291382, 0.06843998283147812, 0.00539625296369195, -0.03247756138443947, -0.06284923851490021, -0.05624121427536011, 0.0011930071050301194, -0.04852300509810448, -0.029120678082108498, -0.016980376094579697, -0.05645493045449257, 0.03244030475616455, -0.03795835003256798, 0.008073922246694565, -0.0798482894897461, 0.006137548945844173, -0.045639049261808395, 0.02373984456062317, -0.07808750122785568, 0.028498370200395584, 0.022080857306718826, -0.025035979226231575, 0.041114963591098785, 0.010968871414661407, 0.07098900526762009, -0.02837127074599266, 0.039174944162368774, 0.0152779221534729, -0.041387591511011124, -0.07934596389532089, 0.001945980591699481, 0.02484930120408535, -0.03013911098241806, -0.015085814520716667, -0.012492740526795387, -0.0008315182640217245, 0.08693623542785645, -0.03997663035988808, -0.08031748235225677, -0.02051093615591526, 0.03174000233411789, -0.06527026742696762, 0.1023993194103241, 0.017314650118350983, -0.06294778734445572, 0.02864784002304077, -0.01188662089407444, 0.05673079937696457, 0.0432126559317112, -0.017887556925415993, 0.049731604754924774, 0.009315583854913712, -0.00805583130568266, -0.0534479059278965, 0.004345068708062172, 0.0005277065793052316, -0.09154222160577774, -0.034765828400850296, 0.057614292949438095, -0.05343686416745186, 0.05923119932413101, 0.000597895123064518, 0.03477027267217636, -0.03734886646270752, -0.03895088657736778, 0.06777103245258331, 0.028156761080026627, 0.018409565091133118, 0.03198997303843498, -0.018935784697532654, 0.007994466461241245, -0.022204626351594925, -0.05777319520711899, -0.06199360266327858, 0.08313945680856705, -0.02616923116147518, -0.03289780393242836, 0.028339006006717682, 0.07545126229524612, -0.017048999667167664, 0.08350548148155212, -0.09422967582941055, 0.05651425942778587, 0.024922959506511688, -0.03554718568921089, -0.017092928290367126, 0.06963120400905609, -0.10170066356658936, -0.027994807809591293, 0.01237567700445652, 0.003093870123848319, -0.05029867962002754, 0.024666057899594307, 0.00747352559119463, -0.04927770048379898, 0.019353533163666725, -0.0072264461778104305, 0.07732759416103363, 0.024052761495113373, 0.0025182864628732204, 0.004269742872565985, 0.024488573893904686, -0.06178533285856247, -0.037035975605249405, 0.00925868097692728, -0.028621818870306015, 0.06393042206764221, 0.08320304751396179, 0.0008249749662354589, -0.07748721539974213, -0.05592026561498642, 0.03099076636135578, -0.037652671337127686, -0.02191009558737278, -0.058741532266139984, 0.0077697536908090115, 0.0663505271077156, -0.03840995579957962, -0.009934389032423496, -0.011935971677303314, 0.07019995152950287, -0.03957626223564148, 0.007551639806479216, 0.043710704892873764, -0.006387488916516304, -0.07096555083990097, -0.10113461315631866, -0.0207357257604599, 0.016911011189222336, -0.05995384231209755, 0.013836667872965336, -0.039074454456567764, -0.01944742724299431, -0.053152650594711304, 0.04310591146349907, -0.0515504814684391, -0.01549116987735033, -0.030180832371115685, -0.03459170088171959, -0.036607638001441956, 0.013387429527938366, -0.011753885075449944, -0.13170820474624634, -0.0324675552546978, 0.03106672689318657, 0.061793189495801926, 0.0721806064248085, 0.0189400315284729, -0.020605193451046944, -0.04122261703014374, -0.03253212943673134, -0.05900706723332405, -0.041388075798749924, -0.07432941347360611, 0.07010577619075775, -0.06957944482564926, 0.04520227015018463, 0.10661038011312485, 0.04153357073664665, -0.0035608818288892508, 0.057892926037311554, -0.013766652904450893, -0.016338098794221878, -0.04480702802538872, 0.033507704734802246, -0.04579233005642891, -0.03590718284249306, 0.002201644703745842, 0.020506368950009346, 0.008645453490316868, 0.010908686555922031, -0.015397590585052967, 0.03531749173998833, 0.04070471227169037, -0.03659321740269661, -0.033775072544813156, -0.011845210567116737, 0.09376692771911621, -0.035638462752103806, 0.011533018201589584, 0.011722777970135212, -0.04867953434586525, 0.0039168535731732845, -0.006556984037160873, 0.025322698056697845, -0.02898128516972065, -0.007795540615916252, -0.08210772275924683, 0.01762009598314762, 0.06131192296743393, -0.004844131879508495, -0.030906885862350464, -0.012866155244410038, 0.02642691880464554, -0.03277648985385895, 0.06263171881437302, -0.014830493368208408, 0.0597633458673954, -0.04123321548104286, 0.022188927978277206, -0.06751450896263123, 0.03056282177567482, -0.02870422974228859, 0.00020167444017715752, -0.10490886121988297, -0.05101402476429939, -0.01758352480828762, 0.04196217283606529, 0.03226744011044502, -0.026594946160912514, 0.036616675555706024, -0.01713709719479084, 0.03857617452740669, -0.012162105180323124, 0.08402378112077713, -0.017989955842494965, -0.05137672647833824, -0.0220583975315094, 0.000845051312353462, 0.022958174347877502, -0.03272920846939087, 0.025137271732091904, -0.024509890004992485, -0.0008699493482708931, -0.07957552373409271, -0.004855940584093332, -0.020889950916171074, 0.07660394161939621, 0.07622163742780685, -0.007220291532576084, 0.06264271587133408, -0.014480045065283775, -0.012344751507043839, -0.06587512791156769, 0.04050828889012337, 0.0024511185474693775, 0.010032170452177525, 0.0026754692662507296, 0.034878358244895935, -0.022146202623844147, -0.010367177426815033, -0.05500447377562523, 0.016008034348487854, 0.016149071976542473, -0.07307875156402588, 0.021899757906794548, 0.06845726817846298, 0.021227654069662094, 0.032912615686655045, 0.024751970544457436, 0.06373399496078491, -0.03989213705062866, 0.00824962928891182, -0.004476593807339668, -0.016157962381839752, 0.045003604143857956, -0.021054787561297417, 0.012864334508776665, -0.08542690426111221, 0.03824671357870102, 0.032521553337574005, -0.02715415507555008, -0.08646715432405472, -0.049309611320495605, 0.0750018060207367, -0.03338329866528511, 0.009149760007858276, -0.00724363187327981, -0.034817274659872055, 0.06453979015350342, 0.0741862803697586, -0.09160251170396805, 0.022535931318998337, -0.003954779822379351, -0.016434408724308014, -0.04104185849428177, -0.03733391687273979, 0.07145045697689056, -0.0616573691368103, 0.04008866101503372, -0.0382101945579052, 0.056704770773649216, -0.025070251896977425, -0.024358725175261497, -0.01488327607512474, 0.05126991495490074, 0.04807515814900398, -0.03260659798979759, 0.030305471271276474, 0.06748232990503311, 0.0088406503200531, -0.04063215106725693, 0.05280274152755737, 0.04247014969587326, 0.05526897683739662, 0.025622224435210228, 0.010040955618023872, -0.045444339513778687, -0.015791669487953186, 0.01085289940237999, 0.04198022931814194, 0.01126413606107235, -0.05295122414827347, 0.05195406824350357, 0.010911072604358196, -0.008663015440106392, 0.03265745937824249, 0.047263920307159424, -0.0920204147696495, -0.03511650860309601, 0.10177837312221527, -0.09460397809743881, -0.0485743023455143 ]
248
248
Learning Multiple Belief Propagation Fixed Points for Real Time Inference
In the context of inference with expectation constraints, we propose an approach based on the "loopy belief propagation" algorithm LBP, as a surrogate to an exact Markov Random Field MRF modelling. A prior information composed of correlations among a large set of N variables, is encoded into a graphical model; this encoding is optimized with respect to an approximate decoding procedure LBP, which is used to infer hidden variables from an observed subset. We focus on the situation where the underlying data have many different statistical components, representing a variety of independent patterns. Considering a single parameter family of models we show how LBP may be used to encode and decode efficiently such information, without solving the NP hard inverse problem yielding the optimal MRF. Contrary to usual practice, we work in the non-convex Bethe free energy minimization framework, and manage to associate a belief propagation fixed point to each component of the underlying probabilistic mixture. The mean field limit is considered and yields an exact connection with the Hopfield model at finite temperature and steady state, when the number of mixture components is proportional to the number of variables. In addition, we provide an enhanced learning procedure, based on a straightforward multi-parameter extension of the model in conjunction with an effective continuous optimization procedure. This is performed using the stochastic search heuristic CMAES and yields a significant improvement with respect to the single parameter basic model.
[ 0.04503742605447769, -0.04952366277575493, -0.01180080883204937, -0.09382238239049911, 0.05550621449947357, -0.08986476808786392, 0.02023005299270153, -0.00847961287945509, -0.06247575581073761, -0.012597206979990005, -0.014932549558579922, -0.039069339632987976, -0.012896953150629997, 0.0076735010370612144, -0.005925269797444344, -0.029994159936904907, 0.033514440059661865, 0.011930666863918304, 0.10145183652639389, -0.04086094722151756, 0.040389206260442734, 0.014097320847213268, -0.024398699402809143, -0.054274532943964005, 0.02367367036640644, 0.002551784971728921, -0.011934125795960426, -0.00381828797981143, 0.016305619850754738, -0.021819474175572395, -0.07228953391313553, 0.014447497203946114, -0.00934838317334652, -0.028278084471821785, 0.05516441538929939, -0.030362149700522423, 0.008949695155024529, -0.07507647573947906, 0.000017310592738795094, -0.021884245797991753, -0.027525804936885834, -0.057339802384376526, 0.024778643622994423, -0.0053926012478768826, 0.05097876116633415, 0.07170695066452026, 0.010162178426980972, 0.044920824468135834, 0.002932392992079258, 0.04239259660243988, -0.06511694192886353, 0.0658125951886177, -0.025743555277585983, 0.024010051041841507, -0.010042545385658741, 0.017442775890231133, -0.0166937168687582, 0.03158405423164368, -0.021205438300967216, -0.042103059589862823, 0.03203393518924713, 0.09088332206010818, -0.015519117936491966, -0.009538630954921246, -0.06195124611258507, 0.02129954658448696, 0.0064339046366512775, 0.015958616510033607, -0.011564016342163086, 0.03199147433042526, -0.0013277223333716393, -0.052727166563272476, 0.05823454633355141, -0.015457144007086754, 0.027210697531700134, 0.021113179624080658, -0.015477718785405159, -0.033279936760663986, 0.015049129724502563, 0.08400549739599228, -0.008650412783026695, 0.06576142460107803, -0.00731654791161418, 0.03742511197924614, -0.03468811511993408, 0.02585780993103981, -0.04651260748505592, 0.0033830779138952494, -0.030694063752889633, -0.05154808983206749, 0.004900047555565834, 0.03236766904592514, -0.0637020543217659, 0.05032978951931, -0.03310174494981766, 0.020687343552708626, -0.008012332022190094, 0.010896669700741768, -0.04872577637434006, -0.010100765153765678, -0.03693956509232521, -0.04656616598367691, 0.06493936479091644, 0.05933114141225815, -0.04330378398299217, 0.018765877932310104, 0.060362230986356735, 0.029534123837947845, 0.0033560479059815407, -0.04943715035915375, 0.056051064282655716, -0.051953501999378204, 0.005104932468384504, -0.010306340642273426, -0.08472054451704025, 0.08389336615800858, -0.014829153195023537, 0.06890089809894562, 0.029715165495872498, 0.07642550021409988, 0.028978843241930008, -0.041148122400045395, -0.08445599675178528, 0.012421389110386372, 0.03819364681839943, -0.042002614587545395, 0.0004563763504847884, -0.07766988128423691, 0.1212729886174202, -0.0426052063703537, 0.05251757428050041, 0.016627781093120575, 0.025681866332888603, -0.035798367112874985, -0.07822859287261963, 0.03880840912461281, -0.05969579517841339, -0.06054449826478958, -0.0485391840338707, 0.01971662975847721, -0.03692755848169327, 0.015243892557919025, 0.05313998833298683, -0.05326005071401596, 0.016310257837176323, 0.035751860588788986, 0.025926614180207253, 0.007931067608296871, -0.04337010905146599, 0.03890668973326683, -0.08163965493440628, -0.026078328490257263, 0.0042161536403000355, -0.007368673104792833, 0.014491274021565914, -0.030367102473974228, -0.013691378757357597, 0.01784708723425865, 0.02503821812570095, 0.08591851592063904, -0.07354310154914856, -0.005861008074134588, 0.03332120180130005, 0.07803617417812347, 0.01630999706685543, 0.04210037738084793, -0.009657909162342548, 0.014772784896194935, -0.05127129703760147, -0.032497379928827286, -0.020808102563023567, 0.01880713552236557, 0.10969403386116028, 0.01787441223859787, 0.02533385343849659, -0.03745441511273384, -0.008775271475315094, -0.06436478346586227, -0.03270583972334862, 0.023966751992702484, 0.01978863961994648, -0.05078520253300667, -0.020271945744752884, -0.022464029490947723, 0.06665469706058502, 0.051647089421749115, 0.03224968910217285, 0.004095468204468489, 0.023836620151996613, 0.016433091834187508, 0.03221543878316879, 0.07029484957456589, 0.02823706530034542, -0.04652129113674164, -0.043710749596357346, -0.017196446657180786, -0.025443773716688156, -0.0015313131734728813, -0.007619904819875956, -0.009624660946428776, -0.015880286693572998, 0.01234812568873167, -0.012809759937226772, -0.03299655765295029, -0.03945723921060562, 0.02236899919807911, 0.03794270008802414, -0.04736408591270447, 0.004900365136563778, -0.07143043726682663, 0.019341273233294487, 0.03450487554073334, -0.021529432386159897, -0.09331419318914413, -0.018246175721287727, -0.08709917217493057, -0.01602078415453434, -0.1281949281692505, 0.025859544053673744, 0.04966363310813904, 0.01675720326602459, 0.10509832948446274, -0.0020282440818846226, 0.043667636811733246, -0.10070780664682388, -0.005768872331827879, 0.031124796718358994, -0.017241889610886574, -0.042256880551576614, 0.039306413382291794, 0.01248177234083414, -0.03784264996647835, -0.014061473309993744, 0.03836008161306381, -0.009513135999441147, 0.08164295554161072, -0.0949769988656044, -0.029814042150974274, -0.03232622891664505, 0.04878167062997818, 0.006197722163051367, 0.08254875987768173, 0.04413379728794098, 0.01339225098490715, -0.007008788175880909, -0.06453373283147812, 0.0106775788590312, 0.006277361419051886, -0.019222941249608994, 0.03953169658780098, 0.0231638140976429, 0.04270534589886665, -0.03317158669233322, 0.006538098212331533, 0.0508602112531662, -0.026120619848370552, 0.07737939059734344, 0.05724618583917618, 0.007917479611933231, 0.04392238333821297, 0.019873647019267082, 0.006471703294664621, -0.10347644239664078, 0.05823260545730591, 0.11503653973340988, 0.02154310792684555, -0.04675750061869621, 0.015075137838721275, 0.09494688361883163, -0.047107111662626266, 0.03582689166069031, -0.018614636734128, -0.023796776309609413, 0.011507266201078892, 0.0022831230890005827, -0.04423210024833679, 0.02982647903263569, 0.022655680775642395, -0.0015041851438581944, -0.06320030242204666, -0.09924571961164474, -0.004791074898093939, 0.03259332850575447, 0.03371334448456764, 0.02973630651831627, -0.007353874389082193, 0.021440498530864716, 0.0390760637819767, -0.03936394676566124, 0.04859326779842377, -0.10712456703186035, 0.002077727345749736, -0.029512852430343628, 0.037780195474624634, 0.04573463276028633, -0.054618533700704575, 0.03913874924182892, -0.0030536025296896696, 0.0024951198138296604, -0.0061114076524972916, -0.01228401716798544, -0.011867684312164783, 0.09853556752204895, -0.01717934012413025, -0.008676715195178986, 0.022330129519104958, 0.04010501131415367, 0.05661458894610405, -0.029512988403439522, -0.003970273770391941, 0.08485368639230728, -0.050799719989299774, -0.034844815731048584, 0.020313354209065437, 0.059563785791397095, -0.025677679106593132, -0.017440374940633774, -0.058043163269758224, -0.07253684103488922, -0.07354675233364105, 0.0454498827457428, -0.026288330554962158, 0.04369506612420082, -0.026713985949754715, -0.004301242996007204, -0.019226063042879105, 0.01654985174536705, 0.07761257141828537, -0.061056554317474365, 0.05207744985818863, -0.05929548293352127, -0.018810972571372986, -0.0701175406575203, 0.1064605563879013, -0.02555214799940586, -0.06189185008406639, -0.02121385559439659, -0.022193949669599533, 0.02450122870504856, 0.017599429935216904, -0.03933171555399895, -0.15210473537445068, -0.021427402272820473, -0.046055469661951065, 0.039940379559993744, 0.0396779403090477, 0.08110251277685165, 0.008767017163336277, 0.004805655684322119, 0.029116500169038773, 0.0037328586913645267, 0.00481185270473361, -0.031462859362363815, 0.06643733382225037, 0.00034834668622352183, 0.03511212766170502, 0.04798644781112671, 0.03150815889239311, 0.009264625608921051, 0.022558320313692093, -0.01485797856003046, 0.0387168750166893, 0.006473413668572903, -0.06696988642215729, 0.0031280985567718744, -0.02025611326098442, -0.05342961475253105, -0.010336161591112614, -0.020513126626610756, 0.01573856920003891, -0.0007623946294188499, 0.04394099861383438, 0.029393622651696205, 0.005023639183491468, 0.03663164749741554, -0.0029375527519732714, 0.056455064564943314, -0.03296482190489769, 0.021970048546791077, 0.06457129865884781, 0.03909807279706001, -0.03403659909963608, -0.07691299915313721, -0.08970950543880463, -0.021847877651453018, -0.10015544295310974, -0.08195839077234268, 0.05079643055796623, 0.04735084995627403, -0.05755690112709999, -0.01691427268087864, 0.0024868245236575603, 0.08270372450351715, 0.016614504158496857, 0.044552139937877655, 0.06338566541671753, -0.0032246154733002186, -0.04350952431559563, -0.04594514146447182, 0.007460064720362425, 0.03168833628296852, -0.005465954542160034, 0.0369085967540741, -0.059843115508556366, -0.03653081879019737, -0.01448411587625742, 0.008800717070698738, 0.022043678909540176, 0.05391279235482216, 0.03628527745604515, 0.019133420661091805, 0.051375385373830795, -0.01984710432589054, -0.017002448439598083, -0.015209978446364403, 0.02086939662694931, 0.005691733211278915, -0.009341255761682987, -0.04042617976665497, -0.021151283755898476, 0.0011481329565867782, -0.021972695365548134, -0.026508323848247528, 0.019717803224921227, 0.02470150962471962, -0.0016761060105636716, 0.0596042200922966, -0.01813182421028614, -0.016985060647130013, 0.020729370415210724, -0.04196670278906822, 0.011087005026638508, -0.03562213107943535, -0.04649230092763901, 0.020574884489178658, -0.01462352555245161, 0.005555656738579273, -0.03062727488577366, -0.0021214287262409925, 0.06660961359739304, -0.02075250633060932, 0.042033109813928604, 0.03898276388645172, 0.008903798647224903, -0.0008314070291817188, 0.04017086327075958, 0.019311029464006424, 0.050103846937417984, 0.03217190504074097, 0.009217317216098309, 0.0006585679366253316, 0.020197415724396706, -0.011618653312325478, -0.01273928303271532, -0.04224235191941261, 0.031056605279445648, -0.01698525808751583, 0.005302244797348976, 0.047475505620241165, -0.026536718010902405, -0.004247379954904318, -0.09908446669578552, -0.0028131853323429823, 0.02838783897459507, -0.05629481002688408, -0.0025417215656489134, 0.06059836223721504, 0.00939217209815979, 0.0987902507185936, -0.026834458112716675, -0.05005858466029167, 0.03404100611805916, 0.01564803160727024, -0.06858176738023758, -0.03153159096837044, 0.029704321175813675, 0.03803029656410217, -0.0013701589778065681, 0.04218151420354843, -0.053688038140535355, 0.06329714506864548, 0.038720324635505676, 0.018779344856739044, 0.07302276045084, 0.0385989248752594, 0.08532515913248062, 0.05840187519788742, 0.023048190400004387, 0.05471382290124893, 0.010826943442225456, 0.053171705454587936, 0.012613389641046524, 0.04525813087821007, -0.006541314534842968, 0.0570681057870388, 0.054050154983997345, -0.025204814970493317, -0.0026947639416903257, 0.028194760903716087, 0.04699086770415306, -0.013585925102233887, -0.036260176450014114, 0.005276759620755911, 0.040926218032836914, 0.1459071785211563, 0.0843571349978447, -0.010493701323866844, -0.03241143748164177, -0.06960444152355194, 0.02815842069685459, -0.0952717661857605, 0.05126389488577843 ]
249
249
Time manipulation technique for speeding up reinforcement learning in simulations
A technique for speeding up reinforcement learning algorithms by using time manipulation is proposed. It is applicable to failure-avoidance control problems running in a computer simulation. Turning the time of the simulation backwards on failure events is shown to speed up the learning by 260% and improve the state space exploration by 12% on the cart-pole balancing task, compared to the conventional Q-learning and Actor-Critic algorithms.
[ -0.05974883213639259, -0.056037768721580505, 0.0700160339474678, -0.023388667032122612, -0.03725633770227432, -0.0960904061794281, 0.010133381001651287, 0.010708320885896683, -0.0460885614156723, 0.03793137148022652, -0.004570466466248035, -0.0041813175193965435, -0.013260929845273495, 0.010819947347044945, 0.059161603450775146, -0.0389682911336422, -0.02635139971971512, 0.022337237372994423, 0.024179697036743164, -0.09320110082626343, 0.016684625297784805, -0.04309014230966568, 0.07276494055986404, -0.007510709576308727, -0.03530500829219818, 0.011427517980337143, 0.013197445310652256, 0.01903458498418331, 0.01456301100552082, 0.02858845889568329, -0.0743790864944458, 0.0049944184720516205, 0.08384177088737488, -0.021685466170310974, 0.028792381286621094, 0.025266312062740326, 0.07466740906238556, -0.035146985203027725, -0.04228569567203522, 0.0532444529235363, -0.018400833010673523, -0.0020845343824476004, 0.07111814618110657, 0.04937783628702164, -0.019020332023501396, 0.013615037314593792, 0.02021997608244419, -0.03351018950343132, -0.03211112692952156, 0.12945504486560822, -0.05340317264199257, -0.018347661942243576, -0.08271126449108124, -0.0402219332754612, 0.020829057320952415, 0.08372701704502106, -0.010743360966444016, -0.016039753332734108, -0.0166936032474041, -0.09408523887395859, -0.08167670667171478, 0.06281336396932602, 0.02269461564719677, -0.04479676112532616, -0.04497246444225311, 0.09740506857633591, 0.013166256248950958, -0.08121199160814285, -0.06977500766515732, 0.032278165221214294, 0.05528852343559265, -0.04302885755896568, 0.04907018691301346, -0.025407591834664345, -0.06103195250034332, -0.007237152196466923, 0.022694529965519905, 0.08317813277244568, 0.08452443033456802, 0.04673124477267265, -0.04823987931013107, -0.007336265407502651, -0.0004895002348348498, 0.05482783541083336, 0.012028709053993225, -0.005281663965433836, 0.023677580058574677, -0.008710677735507488, 0.01435509230941534, 0.06511899083852768, -0.018471572548151016, 0.018875695765018463, -0.1116458997130394, -0.004535328131169081, 0.005077027250081301, 0.01911788620054722, -0.07616978883743286, -0.00905496347695589, -0.025595230981707573, 0.03666815906763077, 0.02724289707839489, 0.00985350925475359, 0.005201828200370073, 0.08730465918779373, -0.042357187718153, -0.003248851979151368, 0.008117754943668842, -0.0010292066726833582, 0.03101460449397564, -0.049201443791389465, 0.01835526153445244, 0.010101248510181904, 0.04921963810920715, 0.02713850513100624, -0.012997704558074474, 0.03838169202208519, -0.030916661024093628, -0.008715897798538208, -0.04113926738500595, 0.030177654698491096, 0.011704253032803535, -0.022440508008003235, -0.05205518752336502, -0.0004825692449230701, 0.04297466576099396, 0.016391240060329437, 0.024280857294797897, -0.05565020814538002, 0.0970461443066597, -0.04427949711680412, -0.03509621322154999, -0.00016833608970046043, -0.031782928854227066, -0.09530750662088394, -0.040108002722263336, 0.04543791711330414, -0.010918713174760342, -0.024134008213877678, 0.004496644251048565, 0.06598332524299622, -0.0006760192918591201, 0.009823360480368137, -0.06637029349803925, 0.023064708337187767, -0.013033073395490646, -0.007883693091571331, 0.042718641459941864, 0.040398065000772476, 0.0547446645796299, -0.009617337025702, 0.02933470904827118, 0.052959591150283813, -0.031855806708335876, 0.08210881054401398, 0.01414357777684927, 0.024147868156433105, -0.08928821980953217, 0.021715518087148666, -0.050686098635196686, 0.08439400047063828, 0.08656325191259384, 0.01529015600681305, -0.05007296800613403, -0.030301017686724663, 0.01737300120294094, 0.024082889780402184, 0.004926494788378477, -0.055280961096286774, -0.03190433606505394, -0.04344213008880615, 0.013258850201964378, 0.015252755954861641, -0.03533533215522766, 0.033013876527547836, -0.0008431965834461153, 0.02932773344218731, 0.02911166101694107, -0.0016999086365103722, 0.002100519137457013, -0.010848667472600937, -0.08111646771430969, -0.0012062931200489402, -0.03043495863676071, 0.016150755807757378, 0.06114394962787628, 0.04134158417582512, 0.007535985670983791, -0.040958650410175323, 0.031533800065517426, 0.0323963388800621, -0.0501583106815815, -0.008935154415667057, 0.03535478189587593, -0.002431126544252038, 0.01309378445148468, 0.0015240785432979465, -0.047553300857543945, -0.07088720053434372, 0.010671364143490791, 0.03461139276623726, 0.12626056373119354, 0.06560654193162918, -0.09778326004743576, -0.0023361723870038986, -0.02676236256957054, 0.007381814997643232, 0.07376153022050858, -0.024135349318385124, -0.02654195763170719, -0.0443454310297966, 0.005881366785615683, 0.0014175146352499723, -0.06932105123996735, 0.00911895651370287, 0.007078665774315596, -0.012074454687535763, 0.03135036677122116, -0.0650891587138176, 0.0842650830745697, -0.012756896205246449, 0.007156352512538433, 0.07633422315120697, -0.06178155541419983, 0.027334516867995262, -0.00016374432016164064, 0.0042227706871926785, 0.004645703826099634, -0.01960502564907074, -0.04164789244532585, 0.04972611740231514, 0.01598205231130123, -0.03890486806631088, -0.00806988775730133, 0.0691060870885849, -0.04410308972001076, 0.08096592873334885, -0.037650708109140396, -0.022624008357524872, -0.03608422353863716, -0.04045363888144493, -0.06317256391048431, 0.022763844579458237, -0.0025332935620099306, -0.03213568776845932, 0.09283696860074997, -0.011445295065641403, 0.009839517995715141, 0.05816804617643356, -0.08596953004598618, -0.007148133125156164, 0.08952257037162781, -0.01530942227691412, 0.04156853258609772, 0.02141726203262806, 0.055520933121442795, 0.04556994140148163, -0.0017369893612340093, 0.06013819947838783, 0.0228263046592474, 0.029859622940421104, -0.02201804518699646, -0.04299371317028999, -0.013783568516373634, -0.005534195341169834, 0.02366885170340538, 0.006991094909608364, 0.01186821423470974, -0.0028684712015092373, -0.0008015674538910389, -0.0037866090424358845, 0.028624726459383965, 0.023629605770111084, 0.042576465755701065, 0.040130872279405594, 0.007075606379657984, -0.06301983445882797, 0.06161755323410034, 0.02938007190823555, -0.033689603209495544, -0.0262240432202816, -0.025761228054761887, 0.0010319791035726666, 0.00376509060151875, 0.04413333907723427, -0.05776931345462799, 0.07250295579433441, 0.006714080460369587, -0.05719666928052902, -0.01251552440226078, 0.04794277623295784, -0.017193088307976723, -0.026921525597572327, -0.08677998185157776, 0.019676348194479942, 0.027904242277145386, -0.08689642697572708, -0.013080919161438942, -0.018994342535734177, 0.013497709296643734, -0.010729800909757614, 0.023640252649784088, 0.007557406555861235, 0.0625285878777504, 0.044239211827516556, 0.018233666196465492, 0.034692395478487015, 0.06354544311761856, 0.05499110370874405, -0.018304450437426567, 0.05883108079433441, -0.022382613271474838, 0.022453591227531433, -0.029132189229130745, 0.020733311772346497, 0.05251045525074005, -0.04079607501626015, 0.06523539125919342, -0.02349635772407055, -0.01581588201224804, 0.07038001716136932, 0.05387933552265167, 0.029746366664767265, 0.0092692282050848, 0.01474918331950903, -0.03130592033267021, -0.010027737356722355, -0.01201223861426115, -0.014528583735227585, 0.06356415897607803, 0.08676629513502121, -0.07052510976791382, -0.022516490891575813, -0.029552079737186432, 0.031886499375104904, -0.05387837812304497, -0.055798087269067764, -0.05565886199474335, -0.0731942355632782, 0.04732903093099594, 0.06448381394147873, -0.0386921763420105, -0.10015188157558441, -0.03411624953150749, -0.06844998151063919, 0.02494649402797222, 0.03824317827820778, 0.08663374185562134, -0.015189322642982006, -0.016715262085199356, 0.021577386185526848, 0.0034822362940758467, -0.11968285590410233, 0.014185597188770771, -0.0227089561522007, -0.03346773609519005, 0.0062905545346438885, -0.06744325160980225, -0.029808398336172104, 0.0357203483581543, -0.0387490950524807, -0.0018579023890197277, 0.04086438938975334, -0.06726833432912827, -0.013032598420977592, -0.04414771869778633, 0.04501322656869888, 0.029450932517647743, 0.006856847554445267, -0.0635770633816719, -0.029789337888360023, -0.00018804606224875897, 0.023377491161227226, 0.031495481729507446, 0.0538858063519001, 0.09198619425296783, 0.020650498569011688, 0.08659663051366806, -0.02184825763106346, -0.050286490470170975, 0.06950660794973373, -0.04641631618142128, -0.04224412888288498, -0.03469215705990791, -0.09583565592765808, -0.012926184572279453, 0.0005467457813210785, -0.027786891907453537, -0.02240905910730362, 0.04861345514655113, -0.010780613869428635, -0.07404377311468124, -0.03223276138305664, 0.011583253741264343, -0.014338198117911816, 0.07217857986688614, -0.02548118494451046, 0.0994858518242836, -0.04689827933907509, -0.027217090129852295, 0.029653489589691162, 0.010985078290104866, -0.10522006452083588, -0.0379900261759758, -0.018887776881456375, 0.009286805056035519, 0.05457485467195511, 0.0674697682261467, -0.0004770244413521141, 0.01772090420126915, 0.07160814851522446, -0.011297144927084446, -0.031124785542488098, -0.04047181457281113, -0.03980758786201477, -0.05689621716737747, -0.016718078404664993, -0.017385056242346764, 0.01302495039999485, 0.05434838682413101, -0.08859243988990784, -0.000987014384008944, -0.02326778508722782, 0.030718348920345306, -0.03652745857834816, -0.018325502052903175, 0.03146905079483986, 0.021062977612018585, -0.015243123285472393, 0.005387794692069292, 0.07207401096820831, -0.021246561780571938, -0.004484861623495817, -0.06851844489574432, 0.001951633021235466, -0.04175826907157898, -0.03988170623779297, -0.022173622623085976, 0.04290800914168358, -0.021518610417842865, -0.009987126104533672, 0.004365821834653616, -0.02829582989215851, 0.0338030681014061, -0.008234692737460136, -0.07635769993066788, 0.04476405680179596, -0.05610521510243416, -0.03984111547470093, 0.034948065876960754, -0.04123082011938095, -0.01043012272566557, -0.011429591104388237, 0.0653247982263565, -0.020463058724999428, 0.0630209669470787, -0.014421195723116398, 0.03608982264995575, 0.033555544912815094, -0.003406618256121874, 0.007085786666721106, 0.04783998429775238, 0.00036009401082992554, 0.035389650613069534, 0.07752089202404022, -0.03520216792821884, 0.017984628677368164, 0.02072795294225216, -0.02735115960240364, 0.09778133034706116, 0.019356559962034225, -0.026377607136964798, 0.0358610600233078, -0.01935184933245182, 0.018008636310696602, -0.07656151801347733, 0.0229474026709795, 0.030418843030929565, -0.022829163819551468, 0.051588233560323715, 0.0021805716678500175, -0.04164784774184227, 0.07810647040605545, 0.013480555266141891, 0.06380241364240646, 0.02603335492312908, 0.03166395053267479, -0.08084667474031448, 0.06358122825622559, 0.040923260152339935, 0.01244916021823883, 0.0010036920430138707, -0.042187534272670746, 0.03230571374297142, 0.013912765309214592, 0.05014301836490631, 0.015155013650655746, 0.028031425550580025, -0.0018958604196086526, 0.07767173647880554, 0.03640339523553848, -0.0138635179027915, 0.01307793240994215, 0.01949726976454258, -0.05532097816467285, -0.014370189048349857, 0.09926094114780426, 0.004732990637421608, 0.037294067442417145, 0.0462028868496418, 0.04729987308382988, -0.027953173965215683, 0.05851154401898384 ]
250
250
A Stochastic View of Optimal Regret through Minimax Duality
We study the regret of optimal strategies for online convex optimization games. Using von Neumann's minimax theorem, we show that the optimal regret in this adversarial setting is closely related to the behavior of the empirical minimization algorithm in a stochastic process setting: it is equal to the maximum, over joint distributions of the adversary's action sequence, of the difference between a sum of minimal expected losses and the minimal empirical loss. We show that the optimal regret has a natural geometric interpretation, since it can be viewed as the gap in Jensen's inequality for a concave functional--the minimizer over the player's actions of expected loss--defined on a set of probability distributions. We use this expression to obtain upper and lower bounds on the regret of an optimal strategy for a variety of online learning problems. Our method provides upper bounds without the need to construct a learning algorithm; the lower bounds provide explicit optimal strategies for the adversary.
[ -0.0026456997729837894, -0.0016425285721197724, 0.005065447650849819, -0.022409239783883095, -0.04554404690861702, -0.06537903100252151, 0.06295100599527359, -0.035724133253097534, -0.051380690187215805, 0.02921413630247116, -0.009674306027591228, 0.008871691301465034, -0.09361410140991211, 0.06610827893018723, 0.0904727429151535, -0.015652259811758995, -0.01589302346110344, 0.007145600393414497, 0.033862385898828506, -0.014619400724768639, 0.01793518476188183, 0.022998442873358727, 0.0073084780015051365, 0.0009406468598172069, -0.040564607828855515, 0.0037541724741458893, 0.005461595486849546, 0.054375454783439636, -0.03588184714317322, 0.011411524377763271, -0.052983205765485764, -0.004067218862473965, -0.011652069166302681, 0.07314609736204147, -0.027859937399625778, -0.049016449600458145, 0.09322472661733627, -0.07311637699604034, -0.01969190686941147, -0.055042561143636703, -0.03513287752866745, 0.04687031731009483, -0.04372158646583557, -0.021523699164390564, 0.023230625316500664, 0.04899761825799942, 0.015418644063174725, -0.01573319546878338, -0.012265630066394806, 0.03443416580557823, -0.0650271400809288, -0.027139315381646156, -0.03486039489507675, -0.08619453012943268, 0.05217262730002403, 0.06744654476642609, -0.005226317793130875, -0.036321308463811874, -0.044317957013845444, -0.05502244085073471, 0.03147999942302704, 0.10471928864717484, 0.007572101429104805, 0.039707716554403305, -0.047303326427936554, 0.06699296087026596, -0.07663240283727646, -0.061402250081300735, -0.051136333495378494, -0.004293227102607489, 0.01593906246125698, -0.05225275829434395, 0.006862318608909845, 0.020159386098384857, -0.02033856324851513, 0.002071382710710168, -0.019741276279091835, -0.0056520383805036545, 0.035542599856853485, 0.09792374819517136, -0.0664399266242981, 0.0646510049700737, 0.01541618350893259, 0.07434877008199692, -0.0057945651933550835, -0.052323631942272186, -0.04242550581693649, -0.024391131475567818, -0.01918606087565422, 0.029757695272564888, -0.03160620853304863, -0.018829654902219772, -0.046725403517484665, 0.045752812176942825, -0.03434155881404877, 0.09238313138484955, -0.07523596286773682, -0.04688381031155586, 0.013078956864774227, 0.0148236732929945, 0.017028620466589928, -0.01890714466571808, 0.03541677072644234, 0.03326746076345444, -0.05146250128746033, 0.02311866544187069, 0.043574441224336624, 0.008411522023379803, 0.09077725559473038, -0.029852909967303276, 0.006803160533308983, 0.014446091838181019, 0.026703545823693275, -0.007810266222804785, -0.067075215280056, -0.038023509085178375, -0.04270053654909134, 0.04233903810381889, -0.0526396706700325, 0.04319053515791893, 0.03388728201389313, 0.04418489336967468, 0.030835097655653954, -0.002029462717473507, 0.02136762998998165, -0.07067794352769852, -0.05589805915951729, 0.023590806871652603, 0.11672133952379227, 0.007552978117018938, -0.0028200186789035797, -0.011461097747087479, -0.027729256078600883, -0.10981258004903793, -0.06180136278271675, 0.004152350127696991, 0.04651246592402458, 0.021141743287444115, 0.02399969846010208, 0.058846890926361084, 0.04344986006617546, 0.053801316767930984, -0.04028938338160515, 0.02242378517985344, 0.02087879367172718, 0.04640714451670647, -0.022106876596808434, 0.051575109362602234, 0.0015485971234738827, 0.026950057595968246, -0.05442310497164726, 0.05669577419757843, 0.015123926103115082, 0.024620968848466873, 0.027731558308005333, -0.07498225569725037, -0.04425744712352753, -0.006705992855131626, -0.06881287693977356, 0.040518827736377716, 0.058627501130104065, -0.011868301779031754, 0.04367506504058838, 0.018792051821947098, -0.008164230734109879, -0.04157203063368797, 0.00865186657756567, 0.007217077538371086, 0.004339694045484066, -0.06501124799251556, -0.02165575511753559, -0.05529521405696869, 0.010114251635968685, 0.002750659827142954, -0.039288006722927094, 0.01809796504676342, -0.02361714467406273, -0.005208682734519243, -0.031411100178956985, 0.006914855912327766, 0.034479573369026184, -0.033004455268383026, 0.002562204608693719, -0.013490226119756699, 0.07134725898504257, 0.046074412763118744, 0.03155416622757912, 0.04765061289072037, 0.07970303297042847, 0.059837259352207184, 0.03384982794523239, -0.044296059757471085, 0.010263114236295223, -0.011540290899574757, 0.02944730781018734, 0.001042933319695294, -0.047158222645521164, 0.004562447313219309, -0.01807882823050022, -0.02434888668358326, 0.060825299471616745, 0.01254004705697298, -0.0851992517709732, 0.005926499143242836, -0.07441367208957672, 0.04540182650089264, -0.04184303060173988, -0.030051162466406822, -0.05287638306617737, 0.00019207989680580795, -0.031143082305788994, 0.00620850408449769, -0.07897473871707916, -0.012523435056209564, -0.0038782863412052393, -0.027869144454598427, 0.016587017104029655, -0.028413871303200722, -0.0001055634711519815, -0.031228698790073395, -0.0059066759422421455, 0.03103981725871563, 0.0010640759719535708, 0.04363575577735901, -0.06931338459253311, -0.01596636325120926, 0.018142856657505035, 0.052639465779066086, -0.07302136719226837, 0.048273611813783646, -0.025613386183977127, -0.035733532160520554, -0.0001999329833779484, 0.014210705645382404, -0.09734466671943665, 0.026241609826683998, -0.040975555777549744, -0.013549445196986198, -0.015782533213496208, -0.07439910620450974, -0.04102243110537529, -0.02059565857052803, 0.04573355242609978, -0.004607146605849266, 0.044694650918245316, 0.03309249132871628, 0.07093824446201324, -0.02414584346115589, -0.005228325724601746, -0.08423883467912674, 0.0645863264799118, 0.06278195232152939, -0.019797276705503464, 0.012050467543303967, 0.03919893875718117, 0.003665229305624962, 0.015820546075701714, 0.06991580873727798, 0.05651504173874855, 0.016681961715221405, -0.06539517641067505, 0.09715377539396286, -0.08984959125518799, -0.0008158557466231287, 0.06483007222414017, 0.017264461144804955, -0.005561975296586752, 0.00716569134965539, 0.039871785789728165, 0.04792999476194382, 0.026795491576194763, -0.04285379871726036, -0.021364860236644745, 0.08607067167758942, -0.024058375507593155, 0.021815501153469086, 0.052450258284807205, 0.012024356052279472, 0.049028828740119934, 0.03973539173603058, -0.11247538030147552, 0.02194642648100853, 0.05483829230070114, 0.025640705600380898, -0.010519332252442837, 0.0018312674947082996, 0.02421426773071289, 0.04450330510735512, 0.028505347669124603, 0.026603827252984047, -0.07531972229480743, -0.025218648836016655, -0.013227819465100765, -0.014394788071513176, 0.06201032176613808, 0.04934128001332283, -0.009088114835321903, -0.01709509827196598, -0.04698026925325394, 0.0162165779620409, 0.029333729296922684, -0.03148714080452919, 0.04799218475818634, 0.011517103761434555, 0.04311596229672432, 0.03567098453640938, 0.017620034515857697, 0.05390457436442375, -0.019487055018544197, 0.015236224979162216, -0.023838523775339127, -0.05004315823316574, -0.022836681455373764, -0.0010127942077815533, 0.06426995992660522, 0.022682365030050278, -0.0035304890479892492, -0.05125880986452103, -0.008265180513262749, 0.058285683393478394, -0.06842353194952011, -0.04096400737762451, 0.046122822910547256, 0.060333091765642166, -0.1086927130818367, 0.04129758104681969, -0.03699566796422005, 0.019746338948607445, -0.07352754473686218, 0.04055650159716606, -0.018799077719449997, -0.04644996300339699, 0.02513083443045616, 0.042313240468502045, -0.0435984767973423, 0.052051104605197906, -0.0243968665599823, -0.07386371493339539, 0.04457569494843483, 0.03403419628739357, -0.09600348770618439, -0.12369855493307114, -0.005354504566639662, -0.017962416633963585, 0.00995300430804491, 0.0931604653596878, 0.041679684072732925, 0.06432264298200607, -0.006524071097373962, 0.059712667018175125, -0.041205037385225296, -0.10070304572582245, -0.020390313118696213, 0.05316988751292229, -0.006435941904783249, 0.016717204824090004, 0.03688964620232582, -0.01351351011544466, 0.013959282077848911, -0.028083307668566704, -0.05941121280193329, -0.016314614564180374, -0.014334192499518394, -0.00019450343097560108, 0.12355456501245499, 0.03296542540192604, -0.037265293300151825, 0.05874546244740486, -0.05464794114232063, 0.009171819314360619, -0.05878138169646263, 0.018673928454518318, -0.000679134507663548, -0.005874132737517357, 0.03649243712425232, -0.017108779400587082, 0.04860391467809677, -0.05612318217754364, -0.03212733939290047, 0.038592178374528885, -0.03627477586269379, 0.016326159238815308, 0.052039045840501785, -0.062417104840278625, -0.03439527750015259, -0.04870261251926422, -0.018237518146634102, -0.013446376658976078, 0.09268947690725327, -0.09891842305660248, -0.025385551154613495, 0.002434906316921115, -0.003655955195426941, 0.057867199182510376, 0.04790132865309715, -0.04936385899782181, 0.04923999309539795, -0.03418252244591713, -0.029818326234817505, 0.05142470821738243, 0.017985383048653603, -0.031812883913517, -0.0007803334738127887, -0.07396132498979568, 0.018986839801073074, 0.03426942229270935, 0.03486928343772888, 0.03526857867836952, -0.016423450782895088, 0.03919675573706627, 0.009373219683766365, 0.050053056329488754, 0.025149652734398842, 0.041038647294044495, 0.030899306759238243, 0.006357247941195965, 0.030803969129920006, 0.031457141041755676, 0.025446012616157532, -0.0639907568693161, 0.05384370684623718, -0.0507550910115242, -0.02944992668926716, -0.017988672479987144, -0.021604271605610847, -0.043058834969997406, -0.04594870284199715, 0.05828509107232094, -0.07110323756933212, 0.08299680799245834, -0.04605221748352051, -0.06117197498679161, -0.03883601352572441, -0.02187531068921089, 0.05741691589355469, -0.04612908884882927, -0.019463632255792618, 0.018999747931957245, -0.04599711671471596, -0.025830809026956558, -0.0760219395160675, 0.09095517545938492, -0.03754603862762451, 0.033048249781131744, -0.07112878561019897, 0.01165201235562563, 0.00887464452534914, -0.007805132772773504, 0.06639628857374191, -0.03420603275299072, 0.04979833588004112, 0.06030306592583656, 0.05321996286511421, -0.06958042085170746, -0.0015775139909237623, -0.03553084656596184, -0.0030271578580141068, 0.017335854470729828, -0.023061232641339302, -0.07728715240955353, -0.03882255777716637, -0.04529711976647377, 0.05875493586063385, 0.015198971144855022, -0.0314163975417614, -0.028729183599352837, -0.0031717829406261444, 0.015795819461345673, 0.016575707122683525, -0.010166564956307411, -0.04289260879158974, 0.030545633286237717, 0.032116636633872986, -0.054652851074934006, -0.004424320533871651, -0.025738665834069252, 0.01855952851474285, 0.01899358257651329, 0.04478587210178375, 0.0344390943646431, -0.060526371002197266, 0.033534541726112366, -0.022030256688594818, -0.02742416225373745, 0.05693750083446503, 0.010698334313929081, -0.04808109626173973, 0.10437076538801193, 0.09289899468421936, 0.038176801055669785, -0.024747321382164955, -0.012773262336850166, 0.0323687307536602, 0.013834238052368164, 0.035892654210329056, -0.004970118403434753, 0.07149577140808105, -0.053578250110149384, 0.038292404264211655, 0.039406437426805496, 0.006928555201739073, 0.016109507530927658, 0.010739565826952457, 0.020653732120990753, 0.013052173890173435, -0.049435872584581375, 0.046233054250478745, 0.02119188755750656, 0.00047652528155595064, 0.04653149098157883, -0.07736746966838837, 0.04732217639684677 ]
251
251
Exact Non-Parametric Bayesian Inference on Infinite Trees
Given i.i.d. data from an unknown distribution, we consider the problem of predicting future items. An adaptive way to estimate the probability density is to recursively subdivide the domain to an appropriate data-dependent granularity. A Bayesian would assign a data-independent prior probability to "subdivide", which leads to a prior over infinite(ly many) trees. We derive an exact, fast, and simple inference algorithm for such a prior, for the data evidence, the predictive distribution, the effective model dimension, moments, and other quantities. We prove asymptotic convergence and consistency results, and illustrate the behavior of our model on some prototypical functions.
[ -0.07783042639493942, -0.03913205489516258, 0.010109489783644676, -0.04286021366715431, 0.061247263103723526, -0.020773757249116898, 0.06078702583909035, 0.014668760821223259, -0.016738658770918846, 0.004869072698056698, -0.01149856485426426, -0.050491780042648315, 0.023066606372594833, 0.07913994044065475, 0.013915051706135273, 0.012098175473511219, -0.051006436347961426, -0.0019437905866652727, -0.01202990673482418, -0.0893435999751091, 0.0589887797832489, -0.019615860655903816, 0.03503212705254555, 0.013371631503105164, 0.0014812536537647247, 0.006146378815174103, 0.04556287080049515, -0.017616361379623413, -0.0031449629459530115, -0.026007574051618576, -0.11251377314329147, 0.017938893288373947, -0.03371432423591614, 0.008293303661048412, 0.04466542974114418, -0.03956838324666023, -0.03242048621177673, -0.02593463845551014, -0.10106980055570602, -0.02796996757388115, 0.059440627694129944, -0.05801459774374962, 0.011670544743537903, 0.007160791661590338, 0.03998221084475517, 0.044036947190761566, 0.045963846147060394, 0.03842708095908165, -0.03187409043312073, 0.007154225837439299, -0.06158897653222084, 0.02699173055589199, -0.11535906791687012, 0.0371786393225193, 0.0194136630743742, 0.015296140685677528, 0.012524043209850788, 0.022335030138492584, -0.06196747347712517, -0.04791603609919548, 0.01872212626039982, 0.11262419074773788, -0.007377518806606531, -0.05654353275895119, -0.034197501838207245, 0.014873632229864597, -0.03782469034194946, 0.00800122320652008, 0.04626978188753128, -0.023815637454390526, -0.0011385147226974368, -0.040153879672288895, -0.015041190199553967, -0.009159698151051998, 0.04119694232940674, -0.05441850423812866, 0.009215671569108963, 0.06116943806409836, 0.014708240516483784, -0.009390146471560001, -0.060977958142757416, 0.09514480829238892, 0.028841212391853333, 0.01263608317822218, -0.046821463853120804, 0.04262861981987953, -0.01246446929872036, 0.020073911175131798, -0.017964046448469162, -0.08091357350349426, -0.008581714704632759, 0.04516607150435448, -0.048167187720537186, 0.03693249449133873, -0.021219175308942795, 0.028932856395840645, -0.018070127815008163, 0.05318107828497887, -0.02754944935441017, 0.005162691231817007, 0.05463961511850357, -0.06089241802692413, 0.08590962737798691, 0.04610694572329521, 0.04170633479952812, -0.034272145479917526, 0.02224668301641941, 0.029549837112426758, -0.007149146869778633, -0.028480790555477142, 0.02883627451956272, -0.014653713442385197, -0.011932721361517906, 0.019979335367679596, -0.046280331909656525, 0.11819092929363251, 0.00648583984002471, 0.09738072752952576, -0.001906990073621273, 0.05189434811472893, 0.09001260250806808, 0.03708682581782341, -0.051418062299489975, 0.06163182109594345, 0.023532314226031303, -0.05082453787326813, -0.023359214887022972, -0.08804907649755478, 0.0546063631772995, 0.022053590044379234, -0.05086054280400276, 0.02422867715358734, 0.0027446188032627106, -0.012206037528812885, -0.08530078828334808, 0.05652002990245819, 0.024327224120497704, 0.08393590152263641, 0.03823747858405113, 0.04709406942129135, -0.006294780410826206, -0.060611873865127563, -0.01373704057186842, 0.007618363481014967, -0.014700840227305889, 0.07763970643281937, -0.0017130754422396421, 0.03048713505268097, -0.08686467260122299, -0.0026549429167062044, -0.014910727739334106, -0.09091472625732422, 0.0642474815249443, 0.04397075995802879, 0.07035572081804276, -0.05161970108747482, 0.01677575521171093, 0.005601308774203062, -0.01439512800425291, 0.004664067178964615, -0.03557305410504341, 0.014604510739445686, 0.029983092099428177, 0.01124404463917017, 0.03166481852531433, 0.016184870153665543, 0.06120685487985611, -0.018058257177472115, 0.03110160306096077, -0.11663750559091568, 0.01840488240122795, -0.09074045717716217, -0.010946325957775116, -0.007083444390445948, -0.031732670962810516, -0.0435694120824337, -0.058881647884845734, -0.0069828638806939125, 0.009632585570216179, -0.060087550431489944, 0.02122548595070839, -0.08685716241598129, -0.06968402117490768, 0.011658621951937675, -0.021594922989606857, 0.06256719678640366, -0.043628059327602386, 0.044390130788087845, 0.036473438143730164, 0.016344796866178513, 0.07688406109809875, -0.015586241148412228, 0.021459195762872696, -0.021175064146518707, -0.020386945456266403, -0.046535689383745193, -0.04757467657327652, -0.032714735716581345, -0.030561843886971474, 0.08964945375919342, -0.01532784290611744, 0.02969307452440262, -0.012506561353802681, -0.043889544904232025, -0.05055656656622887, 0.03381650522351265, 0.05337967351078987, -0.07076356559991837, 0.01555710006505251, -0.02658834308385849, -0.02085311897099018, -0.03438272327184677, -0.03175284340977669, -0.020029228180646896, 0.07837682217359543, -0.0602763369679451, -0.0021446640603244305, -0.06575965136289597, -0.058427583426237106, 0.04821944981813431, -0.011709624901413918, 0.07985840737819672, -0.0635380670428276, 0.05020368471741676, -0.08707718551158905, 0.02688862569630146, 0.06449861079454422, -0.05843706056475639, -0.03290596231818199, 0.03862674906849861, -0.03805876523256302, -0.07396679371595383, -0.013533174991607666, -0.013566646724939346, 0.02482343278825283, 0.030997052788734436, 0.010812354274094105, -0.028575006872415543, 0.03087111935019493, 0.019306549802422523, -0.02201254665851593, 0.0813426673412323, -0.03924041986465454, -0.014527963474392891, -0.02214658074080944, -0.05706670507788658, -0.01524256356060505, -0.0170113705098629, 0.021160705015063286, 0.053444910794496536, 0.04541544243693352, -0.03670451045036316, -0.01686498522758484, -0.012259800918400288, -0.017831183969974518, 0.004320095758885145, -0.016570482403039932, 0.06024440377950668, 0.10825829952955246, 0.004340972285717726, 0.02253231219947338, -0.028139280155301094, -0.0022298977710306644, 0.010333060286939144, 0.008781838230788708, 0.06592842936515808, 0.04867279902100563, 0.03159371763467789, -0.02127924934029579, 0.028702225536108017, 0.022849591448903084, 0.009082765318453312, -0.054027654230594635, 0.07875347137451172, -0.047860823571681976, -0.06489639729261398, 0.04413209483027458, 0.041504234075546265, 0.04404931887984276, -0.06912613660097122, 0.025318393483757973, 0.08740104734897614, -0.03507857024669647, -0.022534072399139404, 0.0038173894863575697, 0.017420653253793716, -0.0530945248901844, 0.0082415034994483, 0.005949710961431265, 0.060453448444604874, 0.023134954273700714, 0.04499911516904831, -0.014639501459896564, 0.0022744901943951845, 0.010311240330338478, -0.03295610472559929, 0.08230338245630264, -0.02483549900352955, -0.02631807141005993, 0.012937797233462334, -0.022539697587490082, 0.024885250255465508, 0.08643054962158203, 0.026799647137522697, 0.06833813339471817, 0.04066602885723114, 0.03078465349972248, 0.03309020772576332, -0.030767984688282013, 0.0069918083027005196, -0.04733709245920181, 0.012286204844713211, 0.0009291846654377878, 0.03012203238904476, 0.022725556045770645, -0.06365154683589935, -0.060227006673812866, -0.022745124995708466, 0.044829271733760834, 0.0025387017522007227, -0.03815360739827156, 0.0406452901661396, 0.013272397220134735, -0.00016013759886845946, -0.04826121777296066, -0.055290717631578445, 0.04715762287378311, 0.03487371653318405, -0.044149212539196014, 0.052657075226306915, -0.014894017949700356, 0.04858137667179108, -0.05487026646733284, 0.09109378606081009, -0.04571370407938957, 0.011097883805632591, -0.03211657702922821, 0.05635346844792366, 0.03231140226125717, -0.007376840338110924, -0.016922367736697197, -0.04581600800156593, -0.020302457734942436, -0.01601341739296913, -0.025606753304600716, 0.07770201563835144, 0.04696173593401909, 0.02662467397749424, 0.00047314533730968833, -0.04024280235171318, -0.04000258073210716, 0.004757632967084646, 0.007247762754559517, 0.0625852644443512, -0.05618083477020264, 0.08153050392866135, 0.05736462026834488, -0.06980283558368683, -0.0069273472763597965, 0.035125359892845154, -0.01484677940607071, 0.07081948965787888, -0.026425091549754143, -0.04682572931051254, 0.021503672003746033, 0.024036074057221413, 0.007157810498028994, 0.01567011885344982, -0.08469581604003906, 0.03750651702284813, 0.013628898188471794, -0.02658737450838089, 0.04989508539438248, 0.014985325746238232, 0.09532994031906128, -0.028702469542622566, 0.05559663847088814, -0.04424606263637543, 0.07896751165390015, 0.05725137144327164, -0.024800818413496017, 0.012380794622004032, -0.06326308846473694, -0.05837848037481308, -0.008416782133281231, -0.06450573354959488, 0.047314081341028214, 0.02459368109703064, 0.052859194576740265, -0.012191643938422203, 0.011259775608778, -0.006907951552420855, 0.04581600800156593, 0.026665955781936646, 0.016315307468175888, -0.025866124778985977, 0.06996961683034897, -0.04151904955506325, -0.05794191733002663, -0.021123096346855164, 0.04084666445851326, -0.04585721716284752, 0.048870500177145004, -0.017295269295573235, -0.04138655215501785, -0.036084599792957306, 0.019106725230813026, 0.025178754702210426, -0.009111035615205765, 0.05857471376657486, 0.0389033667743206, -0.004472460597753525, 0.008189312182366848, -0.008182520978152752, -0.057745181024074554, -0.026158016175031662, 0.036474019289016724, -0.04628961905837059, -0.06800036877393723, -0.016602415591478348, 0.016909312456846237, 0.02544853836297989, -0.02099539525806904, 0.006242701318114996, 0.01143564097583294, -0.08295372873544693, -0.009806036949157715, 0.07347563654184341, -0.03478986769914627, 0.0028649254236370325, -0.045043088495731354, -0.05115298181772232, -0.05011804774403572, -0.030919361859560013, 0.02896365150809288, -0.027516836300492287, 0.0020870009902864695, -0.049102846533060074, -0.031178796663880348, 0.04972173273563385, 0.03561362624168396, -0.009561453014612198, 0.04570786654949188, -0.012683560140430927, -0.03221249207854271, 0.05336889624595642, -0.009223906323313713, 0.01695176586508751, 0.0329277403652668, -0.013255217112600803, -0.02899916283786297, 0.05291656777262688, -0.023596150800585747, -0.07123533636331558, 0.06869404017925262, 0.017970150336623192, -0.028536370024085045, -0.060087211430072784, 0.051657915115356445, -0.018119990825653076, 0.04814431816339493, -0.07665964215993881, -0.020113706588745117, 0.04859933629631996, -0.07549460232257843, -0.04613029584288597, 0.07665801793336868, -0.009614430367946625, 0.058565959334373474, -0.00485115684568882, -0.06365952640771866, 0.029228325933218002, -0.020385542884469032, 0.017155123874545097, -0.032083358615636826, -0.01521775871515274, 0.03546391427516937, -0.061006058007478714, -0.014878465794026852, -0.10103300213813782, 0.051499925553798676, 0.034762825816869736, -0.1301153600215912, 0.002595368539914489, 0.025294428691267967, 0.06314319372177124, 0.015391827560961246, -0.08652830123901367, 0.07999148219823837, 0.02461809106171131, -0.013858409598469734, 0.019857659935951233, -0.005703152157366276, 0.07164932787418365, -0.018494391813874245, 0.028884565457701683, 0.028474414721131325, 0.0006009159260429442, 0.03755127266049385, 0.0001859947806224227, -0.008107265457510948, -0.02785470522940159, 0.042161423712968826, -0.011431025341153145, 0.05114585906267166, -0.005998608656227589, 0.011677565984427929, -0.06120920553803444, -0.015162101946771145, 0.067709781229496, -0.026361998170614243, -0.025322403758764267 ]
252
252
Time Hopping technique for faster reinforcement learning in simulations
This preprint has been withdrawn by the author for revision
[ -0.056590259075164795, 0.012544437311589718, 0.09790518879890442, -0.010457423515617847, -0.014802481047809124, -0.05006931722164154, -0.04189453274011612, 0.02380167879164219, 0.02624751813709736, -0.04458629712462425, -0.032355133444070816, 0.11314363032579422, -0.04223658889532089, 0.04658053070306778, -0.011245503090322018, 0.017000161111354828, -0.04423082619905472, -0.0047407737001776695, -0.03990644961595535, -0.010275214910507202, 0.03967002406716347, -0.017205284908413887, -0.12307901680469513, -0.03707662597298622, 0.064405657351017, -0.03629860654473305, 0.008023879490792751, -0.0036687615793198347, -0.07823114842176437, -0.010141073726117611, -0.03808380290865898, -0.034672144800424576, -0.0033043448347598314, 0.03309822455048561, -0.029364624992012978, -0.0724899023771286, 0.06838518381118774, 0.02773592807352543, -0.06160211190581322, 0.011018861085176468, -0.013914912939071655, -0.0024343831464648247, 0.04509379714727402, -0.0595005601644516, -0.02154642902314663, -0.020117826759815216, 0.03419259190559387, -0.0951150506734848, -0.013277812860906124, 0.024494880810379982, 0.00716761127114296, -0.009205440059304237, -0.04812091588973999, 0.01239296980202198, 0.029023682698607445, -0.006695881485939026, 0.04490823671221733, 0.007578977383673191, 0.03636455908417702, 0.002383241895586252, 0.046269770711660385, -0.020607300102710724, 0.046533580869436264, -0.018278975039720535, 0.010749740526080132, 0.052234578877687454, 0.015493307262659073, -0.0340539775788784, 0.01418878510594368, 0.033148523420095444, -0.02810034342110157, 0.1155402809381485, -0.09939862787723541, 0.049511514604091644, -0.04277986288070679, -0.103617362678051, -0.018433235585689545, -0.023605497553944588, 0.04693153500556946, -0.004956517368555069, -0.0325515978038311, 0.013729351572692394, -0.061465732753276825, -0.06687162071466446, -0.008461235091090202, -0.0895867571234703, 0.09082253277301788, 0.0047933124005794525, 0.0019696399103850126, 0.029058335348963737, -0.0007679583504796028, -0.04058888927102089, -0.03445640206336975, 0.013087150640785694, -0.03905073553323746, 0.03355430066585541, 0.03076304867863655, 0.002088131383061409, -0.03885064274072647, 0.014829309657216072, 0.05569542571902275, 0.04098013415932655, 0.014263959601521492, -0.044955186545848846, -0.06509201973676682, 0.016870491206645966, -0.0056372834369540215, -0.04397595673799515, 0.025371689349412918, 0.0059089199639856815, 0.03011106513440609, 0.04554205387830734, 0.03304680064320564, 0.03869526460766792, 0.04149825498461723, -0.017840778455138206, 0.03705427050590515, -0.028131645172834396, 0.07934451848268509, 0.013391762971878052, -0.04695389047265053, -0.0159315038472414, -0.043562356382608414, 0.09085830301046371, 0.14449690282344818, 0.01753225363790989, -0.010990635491907597, -0.00797022320330143, 0.043533291667699814, 0.016263222321867943, -0.020642094314098358, 0.04727582633495331, -0.033898599445819855, -0.07955019921064377, -0.004731830675154924, 0.09726130962371826, -0.01340070553123951, -0.03629413619637489, -0.05806972458958626, 0.03299873694777489, -0.04734848812222481, 0.000864372355863452, -0.07125580310821533, 0.04429188743233681, -0.011697112582623959, 0.038043562322854996, -0.05730511620640755, -0.03173333778977394, -0.00749402167275548, -0.016759125515818596, -0.015505604445934296, -0.009669344872236252, -0.06336382776498795, 0.06515685468912125, 0.023423289880156517, -0.04006350412964821, -0.004331223666667938, -0.10010509938001633, -0.03368509188294411, 0.03328489884734154, -0.06577836722135544, -0.028626849874854088, 0.007140783127397299, 0.030163884162902832, -0.014218967407941818, -0.01137573178857565, 0.0270696934312582, -0.03148559480905533, -0.007073153741657734, -0.035992320626974106, 0.004516087006777525, 0.023850303143262863, 0.0053321123123168945, 0.018985450267791748, -0.032269902527332306, -0.0076751126907765865, -0.04783475026488304, 0.04415592923760414, -0.016076823696494102, 0.015307746827602386, -0.010781040415167809, -0.07803104817867279, 0.02497709169983864, 0.050817158073186874, 0.0063225217163562775, 0.046511225402355194, 0.09688571840524673, 0.004976638592779636, 0.04061423987150192, 0.045438095927238464, 0.03928343951702118, -0.0369444414973259, -0.027451995760202408, 0.046582769602537155, -0.025178302079439163, 0.024666329845786095, -0.022240610793232918, -0.05401754006743431, -0.030957551673054695, 0.04183416813611984, 0.024301914498209953, 0.02676752582192421, -0.014603504911065102, -0.06893069297075272, 0.0376674085855484, 0.0036911186762154102, 0.06783520430326462, -0.051587630063295364, 0.03675021603703499, -0.029555777087807655, -0.03377898782491684, -0.005418186541646719, -0.053210459649562836, 0.06673971563577652, -0.02193320356309414, -0.014786831103265285, 0.08238057792186737, 0.01636522449553013, 0.06124104931950569, 0.08364150673151016, -0.0008769480627961457, -0.03273044899106026, 0.015113241039216518, 0.019046371802687645, -0.0888819545507431, 0.07649625092744827, 0.018739525228738785, -0.02119961939752102, -0.01928950473666191, -0.04830871522426605, -0.005910596344619989, -0.08198709785938263, 0.03393325209617615, 0.0692526325583458, -0.007160904351621866, -0.059254638850688934, -0.027761638164520264, 0.11920681595802307, -0.01580183394253254, 0.013002194464206696, 0.005675989203155041, 0.026345331221818924, -0.015352459624409676, -0.019083820283412933, -0.10762595385313034, -0.049653761088848114, 0.0011350300628691912, 0.0206622164696455, 0.011801350861787796, -0.021272558718919754, -0.005555680952966213, -0.03951799497008324, -0.04248698800802231, 0.07892420887947083, 0.0030494765378534794, 0.06045632064342499, -0.01728968322277069, -0.01550225168466568, 0.04099131375551224, 0.018417587503790855, -0.03002750501036644, 0.11910843849182129, -0.015631919726729393, -0.039619021117687225, 0.04276533052325249, -0.036468520760536194, 0.012079414911568165, -0.030871758237481117, -0.018498070538043976, -0.00775112584233284, -0.043448857963085175, -0.015494424849748611, -0.06661787629127502, 0.013883613981306553, -0.07280073314905167, 0.029372449964284897, -0.01872890628874302, -0.03254600986838341, 0.01854502037167549, -0.021373163908720016, 0.0540812611579895, 0.020434174686670303, -0.01507495529949665, 0.009489371441304684, -0.08305799216032028, -0.03867737948894501, 0.08957502245903015, -0.012669635936617851, 0.021423466503620148, 0.08009123802185059, -0.05108096823096275, 0.025710394605994225, -0.036933545023202896, 0.0457063764333725, 0.042759738862514496, 0.02503521926701069, -0.05131096392869949, 0.026182124391198158, 0.01397639513015747, 0.06312684714794159, 0.03420600667595863, 0.003626283723860979, 0.02215118333697319, -0.008341346867382526, 0.031060392037034035, 0.0018304684199392796, 0.0016555259935557842, -0.04573097079992294, -0.04050169885158539, -0.099962018430233, -0.0062867505475878716, -0.012908854521811008, -0.018442178145051003, 0.011207496747374535, -0.027635810896754265, -0.08679382503032684, 0.03399808704853058, 0.0379871129989624, 0.12791705131530762, 0.02137092873454094, 0.026761168614029884, 0.02068457379937172, -0.055158860981464386, -0.027937140315771103, -0.014192137867212296, 0.0063538216054439545, 0.004739655647426844, 0.07494692504405975, -0.045160870999097824, -0.019823065027594566, 0.017674218863248825, 0.008274276740849018, 0.09373786300420761, 0.0316559262573719, 0.008419596590101719, 0.028086932376027107, 0.004929689224809408, 0.015880083665251732, 0.05678420513868332, 0.08389189839363098, -0.09910351783037186, 0.004137976560741663, -0.060224924236536026, -0.0057725426740944386, -0.09812204539775848, -0.06286750733852386, -0.008123367093503475, -0.015880083665251732, -0.03844933956861496, 0.00029063926194794476, 0.08001689612865448, -0.017572496086359024, -0.029840825125575066, 0.05152810364961624, 0.052547577768564224, 0.017409291118383408, 0.04406985640525818, 0.01635628379881382, 0.0037906067445874214, 0.06424468755722046, -0.03035615384578705, -0.01926267519593239, 0.05951285734772682, -0.08180377632379532, 0.06568894535303116, 0.02781836874783039, -0.028302673250436783, -0.0413680300116539, 0.08550159633159637, 0.04653861001133919, -0.00648824218660593, -0.04660065099596977, -0.00903161522001028, 0.06656085699796677, 0.08683407306671143, 0.09657271951436996, 0.06506295502185822, -0.03265443816781044, -0.015182548202574253, 0.06467393785715103, -0.02463279478251934, -0.007923273369669914, 0.057135209441185, -0.017111945897340775, 0.0023966562002897263, 0.044183872640132904, 0.04890340939164162, 0.022810710594058037, 0.015047288499772549, -0.053663741797208786, -0.045679546892642975, -0.048693254590034485, 0.10386329889297485, 0.006054239347577095, 0.00688591506332159, 0.032734643667936325, -0.010986164212226868, 0.010644104331731796, -0.023606615141034126, -0.05314674228429794, -0.029650794342160225, 0.030760252848267555, 0.02926730364561081, 0.008216148242354393, 0.02923830971121788, -0.010831901803612709, -0.015989631414413452, 0.057948999106884, -0.051742732524871826, 0.03129066899418831, 0.01824096590280533, 0.07197122275829315, -0.012152633629739285, 0.015609563328325748, -0.024614909663796425, 0.04704779013991356, 0.036191292107105255, -0.05946926400065422, -0.006423686631023884, 0.014621390961110592, -0.03696708008646965, 0.011030318215489388, -0.009998270310461521, -0.010208144783973694, -0.10399072617292404, 0.02963178977370262, 0.03667420521378517, -0.026533128693699837, 0.032095517963171005, -0.04463548585772514, 0.005480226594954729, -0.014702433720231056, -0.015701506286859512, -0.03905465081334114, 0.09100138396024704, 0.040023259818553925, 0.030031979084014893, -0.004782413132488728, -0.019535429775714874, -0.06194640323519707, 0.03317815065383911, -0.08753383904695511, 0.0435735285282135, 0.021227845922112465, -0.09655483067035675, 0.017594855278730392, -0.031148701906204224, -0.051993127912282944, -0.028833091259002686, -0.014241323806345463, -0.005590334534645081, 0.03296757489442825, 0.05542714148759842, -0.040307193994522095, -0.017116418108344078, 0.005448367912322283, -0.03618235141038895, 0.044606421142816544, -0.04785040020942688, -0.012895440682768822, 0.025723809376358986, 0.09507481008768082, 0.006101188715547323, 0.04916554316878319, -0.03417540714144707, 0.03471294790506363, 0.009544146247208118, -0.04675491154193878, 0.04069172963500023, -0.035833586007356644, 0.027226749807596207, 0.03943471610546112, -0.04771234840154648, 0.03091060183942318, -0.04808458685874939, -0.05456751957535744, -0.025112628936767578, 0.043737854808568954, 0.016268812119960785, -0.02280847541987896, -0.019365517422556877, 0.015902439132332802, -0.06155068799853325, -0.034169673919677734, 0.05161753296852112, 0.0035245600156486034, -0.01975480653345585, -0.04540679603815079, -0.0040734210051596165, -0.018359458073973656, 0.04785263538360596, 0.023175127804279327, -0.0034949369728565216, 0.10292206704616547, 0.017912600189447403, 0.038672905415296555, 0.008744888007640839, 0.00615652184933424, 0.018439942970871925, -0.0016320511931553483, -0.07048001885414124, 0.0013089944841340184, 0.0016231084009632468, -0.025708718225359917, -0.02548682875931263, -0.046198226511478424, 0.04571979120373726, -0.05914788320660591, 0.0207784716039896, 0.08466098457574844, 0.011638985015451908, -0.02785218320786953 ]
253
253
Eligibility Propagation to Speed up Time Hopping for Reinforcement Learning
A mechanism called Eligibility Propagation is proposed to speed up the Time Hopping technique used for faster Reinforcement Learning in simulations. Eligibility Propagation provides for Time Hopping similar abilities to what eligibility traces provide for conventional Reinforcement Learning. It propagates values from one state to all of its temporal predecessors using a state transitions graph. Experiments on a simulated biped crawling robot confirm that Eligibility Propagation accelerates the learning process more than 3 times.
[ -0.0787358433008194, -0.024831358343362808, -0.015582337975502014, -0.005954893305897713, -0.07248979806900024, -0.05155102536082268, -0.045635320246219635, 0.006950065493583679, -0.009333223104476929, -0.027736766263842583, -0.06306486576795578, -0.027185862883925438, 0.020074844360351562, 0.005321258679032326, 0.07234901934862137, -0.008910257369279861, -0.037056468427181244, 0.025760512799024582, 0.026286641135811806, -0.016764814034104347, 0.04119624197483063, -0.04272300377488136, 0.057683300226926804, -0.019592178985476494, -0.01705043390393257, -0.00045218237210065126, -0.062031473964452744, 0.0171324722468853, 0.0773615688085556, -0.018683571368455887, -0.08336583524942398, 0.023306673392653465, 0.011521638371050358, -0.07809088379144669, 0.06563570350408554, 0.08622946590185165, 0.06890591233968735, -0.00230731931515038, 0.01368060614913702, 0.05229641869664192, 0.013941504992544651, -0.07617870718240738, 0.012596657499670982, 0.015076191164553165, -0.0183546282351017, -0.003988247364759445, 0.022260049358010292, 0.07336277514696121, 0.010204569436609745, 0.06313171237707138, -0.08210714161396027, 0.06400453299283981, -0.021320955827832222, 0.01301359012722969, 0.025426696985960007, 0.055824678391218185, -0.018969763070344925, -0.018610430881381035, -0.033563461154699326, -0.031096966937184334, -0.0549752339720726, 0.08531566709280014, -0.029332175850868225, -0.03504738584160805, -0.025003978982567787, 0.09649249911308289, -0.016420716419816017, -0.11093524843454361, -0.05821662023663521, -0.02973659709095955, 0.0006409176858142018, -0.04642259702086449, 0.0629732608795166, 0.032509695738554, 0.022443102672696114, -0.026940273120999336, 0.06142937019467354, -0.03460684046149254, 0.09463371336460114, 0.0085511589422822, -0.0698755756020546, 0.03420369327068329, 0.032027069479227066, 0.008647349663078785, 0.04481711611151695, 0.007464736700057983, -0.018743092194199562, 0.03766637295484543, 0.04074744135141373, -0.037955932319164276, -0.0015328133013099432, 0.010575358755886555, -0.12383101880550385, 0.018338017165660858, -0.043894849717617035, -0.0030277958139777184, -0.039829958230257034, -0.02066056616604328, 0.05867178365588188, 0.06778007745742798, 0.0019597767386585474, -0.013160759583115578, 0.02656208723783493, 0.08716307580471039, -0.03582415357232094, -0.04649517312645912, 0.03738468140363693, 0.0037067902740091085, 0.024493806064128876, -0.007631333544850349, -0.020677775144577026, -0.028903691098093987, -0.0022309888154268265, -0.03317352384328842, 0.0020865548867732286, 0.028841296210885048, -0.01166166365146637, -0.0003506722568999976, -0.030131831765174866, 0.0032115993089973927, -0.03810399770736694, -0.05208214744925499, -0.06511841714382172, 0.05526134744286537, 0.009395008906722069, -0.014665947295725346, -0.029600093141198158, -0.061764493584632874, 0.11878064274787903, 0.01891441084444523, -0.04614586755633354, -0.0871102437376976, -0.009567825123667717, -0.06296786665916443, -0.047849271446466446, 0.037811681628227234, 0.004289525095373392, 0.002011493779718876, -0.04535245522856712, 0.03278525546193123, 0.056192588061094284, -0.000953522976487875, -0.025169068947434425, 0.053924597799777985, -0.03588666766881943, 0.05489354953169823, -0.008920135907828808, 0.03853859379887581, 0.013793054036796093, 0.007785687688738108, 0.07846704870462418, 0.003983483649790287, 0.01207463163882494, 0.04284043237566948, 0.0035394749138504267, 0.07710327953100204, -0.03406689688563347, -0.0475463829934597, 0.02001524530351162, 0.03703032806515694, 0.021585673093795776, 0.011193877086043358, 0.021319951862096786, -0.08780999481678009, 0.0361514613032341, -0.03323895111680031, 0.0030781447421759367, -0.047363586723804474, -0.03080652467906475, -0.05330469831824303, -0.016635281965136528, 0.002924499334767461, 0.049293167889118195, 0.04590389505028725, 0.06885206699371338, 0.05778360366821289, 0.03178001567721367, 0.012706003151834011, -0.020344816148281097, 0.009628369472920895, 0.03793849050998688, -0.031140072271227837, 0.049135372042655945, 0.030140254646539688, 0.05504857376217842, 0.03928639739751816, 0.010756043717265129, -0.03080924041569233, 0.01969689130783081, 0.017222149297595024, -0.03995301574468613, -0.026533663272857666, 0.06337155401706696, 0.022180303931236267, -0.04274138808250427, 0.01631985977292061, -0.026409698650240898, 0.007815361954271793, -0.03529740869998932, 0.039855942130088806, 0.06235509738326073, -0.00765495328232646, -0.07057833671569824, -0.009602546691894531, -0.029212182387709618, 0.06029472500085831, 0.049463387578725815, -0.08886557072401047, -0.08261358737945557, -0.054143354296684265, 0.03511320427060127, 0.04450865089893341, -0.02434028685092926, -0.010439545847475529, -0.037673842161893845, -0.03283548727631569, -0.01195521466434002, -0.06712346524000168, 0.03364713862538338, 0.08400986343622208, -0.0025529239792376757, 0.10080383718013763, -0.015349862165749073, 0.058223165571689606, -0.04780668765306473, 0.0015715690096840262, 0.060913123190402985, -0.022187262773513794, 0.006517197471112013, 0.02670607715845108, 0.05070166289806366, 0.020251458510756493, -0.021311959251761436, -0.001055471133440733, -0.020941447466611862, 0.05163290724158287, -0.08950778841972351, -0.00526984641328454, -0.0665212869644165, -0.030034124851226807, -0.00046609333367086947, 0.046085767447948456, -0.010232598520815372, -0.014710715971887112, 0.06856799870729446, -0.028242086991667747, -0.03159486502408981, 0.0421980582177639, -0.1179080680012703, -0.007919492200016975, 0.02500850521028042, 0.012865671887993813, 0.005649964325129986, -0.01121643278747797, 0.02751757577061653, -0.010123505257070065, -0.043015532195568085, 0.08386776596307755, 0.09200934320688248, 0.0739695131778717, -0.037500910460948944, -0.0011518980609253049, -0.025407297536730766, 0.06926965713500977, 0.02261780947446823, -0.004087095148861408, 0.0070413947105407715, 0.00009463338210480288, -0.05166038125753403, -0.04573824256658554, 0.0384681299328804, 0.04115907847881317, -0.00142095482442528, 0.07517337054014206, 0.015135868452489376, -0.10237966477870941, 0.08281240612268448, -0.036156874150037766, -0.03479235991835594, -0.013252285309135914, -0.0717485323548317, -0.030718129128217697, 0.043412499129772186, -0.07703672349452972, 0.021611524745821953, 0.08103450387716293, -0.0031529993284493685, -0.03789287433028221, 0.016621306538581848, 0.06033017113804817, 0.028299717232584953, -0.03995691239833832, -0.08605574816465378, 0.00800176803022623, 0.002380161313340068, -0.042113106697797775, 0.00598113052546978, -0.02936318702995777, -0.03222799301147461, 0.05202491208910942, -0.00652089761570096, 0.012084955349564552, 0.036620132625103, 0.05300787836313248, 0.009841635823249817, 0.04216616973280907, -0.016590796411037445, 0.09318622946739197, -0.0861954540014267, 0.052545979619026184, 0.015605583786964417, 0.023318523541092873, -0.04219672083854675, 0.043923914432525635, 0.01780707761645317, -0.022758502513170242, -0.019366571679711342, 0.013594336807727814, -0.017818758264183998, 0.026487130671739578, 0.03731203079223633, 0.005766881629824638, -0.041639138013124466, 0.005765661131590605, -0.07870174944400787, -0.00894186645746231, -0.006023468915373087, 0.011356852017343044, -0.016483120620250702, 0.05412678048014641, -0.06125694513320923, 0.07742881029844284, -0.0388106144964695, -0.03073885478079319, -0.03006359376013279, -0.049728695303201675, -0.023091381415724754, -0.01567286066710949, 0.00421416899189353, 0.04792195186018944, -0.014264385215938091, -0.13164804875850677, -0.05919564887881279, -0.03166757524013519, -0.01748744025826454, 0.07306639105081558, 0.0432521216571331, -0.017313122749328613, 0.06042148172855377, 0.03499782085418701, -0.0500006340444088, -0.0416104830801487, -0.031536880880594254, -0.01676156558096409, 0.03858548030257225, -0.03581738471984863, -0.0518433041870594, -0.0007464578957296908, 0.020697083324193954, 0.012757749296724796, -0.008272841572761536, -0.0007490167045034468, -0.034287068992853165, -0.049212999641895294, -0.030649611726403236, 0.0242631696164608, 0.047926679253578186, 0.013566385954618454, -0.0014287984231486917, 0.021725650876760483, 0.004273916594684124, 0.04721222445368767, -0.029136620461940765, -0.03399938344955444, 0.04940510541200638, 0.02583613619208336, 0.02479293756186962, -0.026907697319984436, -0.013045131228864193, 0.11238903552293777, -0.07222488522529602, -0.07021192461252213, -0.06857854127883911, -0.03290491923689842, 0.010399749502539635, -0.04001256451010704, -0.025091763585805893, 0.03616920858621597, 0.0706414207816124, 0.0009387657046318054, -0.04133922979235649, -0.03306739032268524, 0.02709214575588703, -0.005606462247669697, 0.008265519514679909, -0.003374275518581271, 0.02257545106112957, -0.022924313321709633, 0.03034346178174019, 0.03037252463400364, -0.008355146273970604, -0.0828305333852768, 0.006849997211247683, -0.024301255121827126, 0.03104409947991371, 0.05547896400094032, 0.07469948381185532, 0.010915441438555717, -0.007430094759911299, 0.05120602250099182, 0.05255383253097534, 0.029771555215120316, -0.148703932762146, -0.028310680761933327, -0.06629469245672226, -0.035643070936203, -0.012385563924908638, -0.04272044450044632, 0.02066194824874401, -0.06747456640005112, -0.011366968974471092, -0.01196383684873581, -0.017950084060430527, 0.055602651089429855, -0.05104004591703415, 0.04460938274860382, -0.011943248100578785, -0.009192313067615032, 0.04419666901230812, 0.019337400794029236, -0.10368875414133072, -0.03674435243010521, -0.030595000833272934, -0.050388310104608536, 0.007423348259180784, 0.0590798482298851, 0.0006732371984981, 0.029862724244594574, -0.03891316428780556, -0.04407605528831482, 0.01386310812085867, 0.02497004345059395, 0.02222747541964054, -0.0005659254966303706, -0.024078894406557083, 0.11797872930765152, -0.059500809758901596, -0.05815396085381508, 0.012826158665120602, -0.02440384216606617, -0.027915004640817642, -0.04300380498170853, 0.011381377466022968, 0.03629276528954506, -0.07016169279813766, -0.07969548553228378, 0.014920242130756378, 0.011426510289311409, 0.06779298186302185, 0.023000501096248627, 0.017604520544409752, 0.019477223977446556, -0.012539091520011425, 0.047327086329460144, 0.006159833166748285, 0.009637424722313881, -0.03570963814854622, -0.007512677926570177, 0.14836101233959198, 0.042714498937129974, 0.009737099520862103, -0.06099901720881462, 0.011192459613084793, -0.001680494868196547, -0.03298405557870865, 0.07436593621969223, 0.044100381433963776, -0.017743196338415146, -0.02867910824716091, 0.013916742987930775, -0.026954764500260353, 0.05168722942471504, -0.04177683964371681, -0.008998612873256207, 0.027571547776460648, 0.062162596732378006, -0.04018237069249153, 0.0042214118875563145, 0.06559917330741882, 0.03772612288594246, 0.05843796581029892, -0.05571594461798668, 0.004413478542119265, -0.041107334196567535, 0.09208917617797852, -0.03365461528301239, -0.0005473250639624894, -0.005772470962256193, 0.001231446978636086, 0.007607772946357727, 0.009771054610610008, -0.021233700215816498, 0.021298496052622795, -0.02179238200187683, 0.02789662964642048, 0.050385162234306335, 0.022756099700927734, 0.025435861200094223, -0.010771282948553562, -0.013814332894980907, -0.020191526040434837, 0.03596442937850952 ]
254
254
Performing Nonlinear Blind Source Separation with Signal Invariants
Given a time series of multicomponent measurements x(t), the usual objective of nonlinear blind source separation (BSS) is to find a "source" time series s(t), comprised of statistically independent combinations of the measured components. In this paper, the source time series is required to have a density function in (s,ds/dt)-space that is equal to the product of density functions of individual components. This formulation of the BSS problem has a solution that is unique, up to permutations and component-wise transformations. Separability is shown to impose constraints on certain locally invariant (scalar) functions of x, which are derived from local higher-order correlations of the data's velocity dx/dt. The data are separable if and only if they satisfy these constraints, and, if the constraints are satisfied, the sources can be explicitly constructed from the data. The method is illustrated by using it to separate two speech-like sounds recorded with a single microphone.
[ 0.055890247225761414, -0.018800273537635803, -0.015783486887812614, -0.01582871936261654, 0.05457162857055664, -0.01611916534602642, -0.04364590346813202, -0.07446034252643585, -0.060028448700904846, 0.07187861949205399, -0.0005370380822569132, -0.004975133575499058, -0.0549730621278286, 0.01005585864186287, -0.03849293291568756, -0.05202321335673332, -0.015773911029100418, -0.021451368927955627, 0.11343420296907425, -0.09906415641307831, -0.056594543159008026, -0.0010037668980658054, 0.06214680150151253, -0.07193949073553085, -0.002714193193241954, 0.018115421757102013, -0.06044738367199898, 0.017002535983920097, 0.04410146549344063, -0.04380764067173004, -0.11526774615049362, 0.04152010381221771, -0.0005512426141649485, -0.029659578576683998, -0.0008469794411212206, -0.006929015275090933, 0.050777971744537354, -0.0032497341744601727, -0.07766373455524445, 0.006558137480169535, -0.01903110183775425, 0.05327293649315834, 0.04068079590797424, 0.015410898253321648, 0.02787192165851593, 0.06033112481236458, 0.043050430715084076, -0.009674097411334515, 0.017617221921682358, 0.013347513042390347, -0.05957314372062683, -0.01294755470007658, -0.02603725902736187, 0.07000008970499039, 0.002340236445888877, 0.031657081097364426, -0.07916920632123947, -0.01991809532046318, -0.018103066831827164, -0.02400151640176773, -0.00968148186802864, 0.09870639443397522, 0.02465011738240719, -0.0073049371130764484, 0.034350525587797165, -0.06383708864450455, -0.11663372069597244, 0.0052044144831597805, -0.03548680990934372, -0.010858599096536636, -0.03185988590121269, -0.07283292710781097, -0.039688825607299805, -0.06908910721540451, -0.012436749413609505, 0.000880901818163693, 0.044461991637945175, 0.010055203922092915, -0.02021203562617302, 0.10596608370542526, -0.06677799671888351, 0.01304913591593504, -0.024774936959147453, 0.01683660037815571, -0.09354382753372192, 0.026322241872549057, -0.026412159204483032, 0.042712606489658356, -0.03747805580496788, -0.014300825074315071, -0.0996900126338005, -0.03078352101147175, -0.07100699841976166, 0.019672097638249397, -0.03965843841433525, -0.034295134246349335, 0.04206729680299759, -0.05652499198913574, 0.05909012630581856, 0.04857740178704262, 0.013649780303239822, -0.009082557633519173, 0.05329052731394768, 0.09275572746992111, -0.02851538173854351, 0.030836408957839012, -0.007833549752831459, 0.02099107950925827, -0.028974410146474838, -0.026877859607338905, 0.0292448028922081, -0.012847929261624813, 0.03234117850661278, -0.00999401044100523, -0.01136750727891922, 0.054826583713293076, 0.06376317143440247, 0.06854883581399918, 0.03230224549770355, 0.02292148768901825, -0.008910800330340862, 0.08069181442260742, -0.01649748533964157, -0.01433483138680458, 0.022308314219117165, 0.006315999664366245, 0.012505562044680119, -0.037458911538124084, 0.09050940722227097, 0.023201828822493553, -0.10683038830757141, 0.013066611252725124, 0.008445325307548046, 0.081520214676857, -0.016520170494914055, 0.05808451399207115, 0.027772890403866768, 0.014004231430590153, -0.045282699167728424, 0.010827319696545601, 0.01362843532115221, -0.05617913976311684, -0.07171282172203064, 0.030713621526956558, 0.09375659376382828, -0.017825843766331673, -0.030665649101138115, 0.05298661068081856, -0.026499152183532715, 0.005390055011957884, -0.04170111194252968, -0.05648195743560791, 0.008129604160785675, 0.006113911047577858, 0.03993535414338112, -0.09955410659313202, -0.006175579037517309, -0.0661800280213356, -0.02973591350018978, 0.0574079193174839, 0.00979670975357294, -0.011659995652735233, 0.041331201791763306, 0.04473058879375458, -0.10843509435653687, -0.0121446643024683, -0.00008992284710984677, -0.08157394081354141, -0.021634351462125778, -0.03624466434121132, -0.034550346434116364, 0.051750894635915756, -0.03081459179520607, -0.005723367445170879, -0.04299497231841087, 0.06115217134356499, -0.023599855601787567, -0.012097078375518322, -0.015150424093008041, -0.0594651885330677, 0.002412510337308049, -0.031660329550504684, 0.003329024650156498, 0.06538914144039154, -0.020359061658382416, 0.058460116386413574, -0.0129969771951437, 0.06235429272055626, 0.04641890525817871, -0.05812779814004898, 0.05271032452583313, 0.07218107581138611, -0.018282365053892136, -0.017599033191800117, -0.009699675254523754, 0.012651631608605385, -0.02767845243215561, -0.014103437773883343, 0.006703100632876158, 0.08050340414047241, 0.007804399356245995, -0.05775556340813637, -0.02010069414973259, -0.03994840756058693, -0.001109801814891398, 0.029268363490700722, 0.040828000754117966, -0.03561754152178764, 0.06379383057355881, -0.03535833954811096, -0.03316795825958252, -0.02070358581840992, 0.007820664905011654, 0.04258766025304794, 0.004037169739603996, -0.0517832487821579, -0.027579061686992645, -0.05438518524169922, -0.049243323504924774, 0.00815452728420496, -0.050669290125370026, 0.039591770619153976, -0.04597172513604164, 0.10877539962530136, -0.041239432990550995, -0.024380790069699287, 0.06438454985618591, -0.008000888861715794, -0.0263929795473814, -0.0328882560133934, -0.04173510521650314, -0.034549154341220856, -0.011797547340393066, -0.02040163055062294, -0.03211887180805206, 0.005592243280261755, -0.05778556689620018, -0.042907312512397766, 0.03487834706902504, 0.01142802182585001, -0.03798868879675865, 0.04004822298884392, -0.013917641714215279, -0.010868272744119167, -0.09599674493074417, -0.02853122539818287, -0.006364651024341583, 0.089347243309021, 0.06057891994714737, 0.04870042949914932, -0.007736564613878727, 0.06022832542657852, 0.024580473080277443, 0.0019563348032534122, 0.038705479353666306, -0.04891559109091759, -0.03376951068639755, -0.05499177798628807, 0.01787729561328888, 0.04016377776861191, 0.017133772373199463, 0.05795491114258766, -0.08151255548000336, 0.009971043094992638, 0.04440723732113838, 0.04963686689734459, 0.013080659322440624, 0.038026146590709686, -0.016545815393328667, -0.007743564900010824, -0.0059017613530159, -0.08622988313436508, -0.03330537676811218, 0.016098473221063614, 0.007463553920388222, -0.01984953135251999, 0.06313028931617737, 0.010756111703813076, -0.06752315163612366, 0.009322821162641048, 0.007654953747987747, 0.10524474084377289, 0.016055019572377205, -0.03221261128783226, -0.015121228992938995, 0.02235000766813755, 0.031881287693977356, 0.09804705530405045, -0.021391499787569046, 0.06474871188402176, 0.025893468409776688, 0.06453680247068405, -0.021118735894560814, -0.0011758526088669896, -0.010456236079335213, -0.0702056810259819, 0.040661100298166275, 0.004149245098233223, -0.00755719980224967, -0.035179853439331055, -0.05729532986879349, -0.0180512685328722, -0.013305185362696648, -0.022218016907572746, 0.08336827158927917, 0.0548282116651535, 0.07675526291131973, 0.03518203645944595, 0.05184460058808327, 0.0011530878255143762, -0.07492152601480484, 0.060092177242040634, -0.07729685306549072, 0.04060976579785347, 0.02071673609316349, -0.11745156347751617, 0.06843975931406021, 0.039998725056648254, 0.0010168530279770494, 0.010973894037306309, -0.024761764332652092, 0.08183260262012482, -0.020107828080654144, -0.044088948518037796, -0.05282121151685715, -0.025806650519371033, -0.07077667117118835, 0.0800948366522789, -0.05045050010085106, 0.042161181569099426, -0.03010941483080387, 0.024831965565681458, -0.023553412407636642, 0.054872121661901474, 0.04970749467611313, 0.0029302386101335287, 0.0014075014041736722, -0.0018070735968649387, -0.06766297668218613, 0.013996792957186699, 0.008626163937151432, -0.01823093555867672, -0.021794309839606285, -0.049000084400177, 0.027904951944947243, 0.0870727077126503, 0.03440327197313309, -0.026451844722032547, -0.011030992493033409, -0.008325186558067799, -0.09468702971935272, 0.026636453345417976, 0.050025466829538345, -0.06999795883893967, -0.0011562106665223837, 0.023138785734772682, 0.018460867926478386, 0.05137360841035843, 0.0012482209131121635, 0.06660457700490952, 0.0288285743445158, -0.01599442958831787, 0.030025096610188484, 0.03877739608287811, 0.009088500402867794, -0.02669954113662243, -0.028648052364587784, -0.029026802629232407, 0.006994133349508047, 0.02676502801477909, 0.019169962033629417, -0.0026470099110156298, 0.07719593495130539, 0.028390899300575256, -0.0030799112282693386, 0.0049248444847762585, -0.00011023302795365453, -0.10044019669294357, -0.02385547012090683, 0.015952616930007935, -0.08567994087934494, -0.0021922823507338762, -0.01686069928109646, 0.044767897576093674, -0.028414763510227203, -0.0008927282178774476, -0.003977758809924126, -0.042797960340976715, 0.022163141518831253, -0.008749362081289291, -0.14985252916812897, -0.051757264882326126, -0.01959906332194805, 0.0003733268240466714, 0.1055716797709465, 0.055651385337114334, 0.04187199845910072, 0.013303029350936413, 0.0013241700362414122, -0.0014513731002807617, 0.06353595852851868, -0.023670664057135582, -0.06999668478965759, -0.046086687594652176, -0.03430473059415817, 0.007623480167239904, 0.07783479988574982, -0.022985944524407387, 0.04078776389360428, 0.009808486327528954, 0.035261284559965134, -0.016801420599222183, -0.08270170539617538, 0.0372297503054142, -0.033297158777713776, 0.043031129986047745, 0.005965518299490213, -0.008752717636525631, -0.010693651624023914, -0.0061720265075564384, 0.008588764816522598, -0.01794399321079254, 0.001049737329594791, -0.04624868929386139, -0.00016649244935251772, -0.009706389158964157, 0.0497252531349659, 0.043476905673742294, -0.034815408289432526, 0.033254265785217285, -0.0748630166053772, -0.06958168745040894, -0.005601575598120689, 0.03376898542046547, 0.0796595960855484, -0.05356111377477646, 0.00804720725864172, -0.040501467883586884, -0.026620328426361084, 0.07601721584796906, 0.00526392413303256, -0.032158493995666504, -0.009036123752593994, -0.016628747805953026, 0.03867093101143837, 0.07088090479373932, 0.1006702184677124, 0.04306944087147713, 0.03022569790482521, 0.04352691024541855, -0.009548529051244259, -0.0012556721922010183, -0.026622122153639793, 0.014848570339381695, 0.03360699489712715, -0.013011595234274864, 0.0267950389534235, 0.01037056464701891, 0.03754638880491257, 0.040843408554792404, -0.006104887463152409, -0.021241234615445137, -0.005650982726365328, -0.02845723181962967, -0.036543767899274826, 0.033704064786434174, 0.03565086051821709, -0.059115976095199585, -0.02806032821536064, -0.02211151272058487, 0.04554281383752823, 0.01159359049052, -0.003981137648224831, -0.03184353932738304, 0.009355046786367893, -0.036712002009153366, 0.011221307329833508, -0.0003864785539917648, -0.011021294631063938, -0.011548718437552452, 0.040892649441957474, -0.03515767306089401, 0.019636180251836777, 0.007419371046125889, 0.016155125573277473, 0.00785783026367426, 0.017284728586673737, -0.05215476080775261, 0.01608671434223652, 0.019357429817318916, -0.036765336990356445, 0.02024124190211296, -0.009636100381612778, 0.009808295406401157, 0.029118727892637253, -0.014741622842848301, -0.04932045191526413, 0.015694864094257355, 0.05735483020544052, -0.03694067522883415, -0.08224082738161087, -0.04129251465201378, 0.022977720946073532, 0.00443906569853425, 0.0266201701015234, 0.05142420902848244, 0.0088771041482687, -0.08265313506126404, -0.03916891664266586, 0.08272562175989151, 0.04589067026972771, -0.031054295599460602 ]
255
255
Evolvability need not imply learnability
We show that Boolean functions expressible as monotone disjunctive normal forms are PAC-evolvable under a uniform distribution on the Boolean cube if the hypothesis size is allowed to remain fixed. We further show that this result is insufficient to prove the PAC-learnability of monotone Boolean functions, thereby demonstrating a counter-example to a recent claim to the contrary. We further discuss scenarios wherein evolvability and learnability will coincide as well as scenarios under which they differ. The implications of the latter case on the prospects of learning in complex hypothesis spaces is briefly examined.
[ -0.0020647533237934113, -0.05271390080451965, 0.08331426978111267, -0.05338870361447334, -0.03882995992898941, -0.02815605141222477, -0.04045380279421806, 0.054487116634845734, 0.026259273290634155, 0.021370800212025642, 0.03659074008464813, 0.042656805366277695, -0.03748714178800583, 0.0332159698009491, -0.019079433754086494, -0.009351259097456932, -0.0012691147858276963, 0.09784449636936188, 0.024873876944184303, -0.09076975286006927, -0.0029167865868657827, 0.006072374526411295, 0.02832462266087532, 0.0016874483553692698, -0.002802835311740637, 0.009138420224189758, 0.001090895850211382, 0.01271834410727024, 0.01593943126499653, -0.01596779190003872, -0.04289025813341141, 0.0111073674634099, -0.07708224654197693, 0.031124968081712723, 0.07520484179258347, 0.038292042911052704, 0.009694886393845081, 0.016673197969794273, 0.054107870906591415, -0.006905847229063511, -0.04291878640651703, 0.01604314334690571, 0.009738221764564514, 0.013132135383784771, -0.022495482116937637, 0.02647753246128559, 0.005011388100683689, -0.007995148189365864, -0.041329365223646164, 0.031136227771639824, -0.06371097266674042, 0.005351737141609192, -0.016617394983768463, -0.004765839781612158, -0.06052447482943535, 0.07009688019752502, -0.017299408093094826, 0.01546222623437643, -0.026417119428515434, 0.01014481857419014, 0.038478489965200424, 0.07799774408340454, 0.009746727533638477, -0.01902162656188011, -0.027978161349892616, -0.0669194757938385, -0.07788661122322083, 0.06203926354646683, 0.024957692250609398, -0.01894599385559559, 0.022615822032094002, -0.014542562887072563, 0.043507687747478485, 0.043264470994472504, 0.04165707156062126, -0.014984517358243465, -0.03876139968633652, -0.0022434862330555916, -0.08099988847970963, 0.016520114615559578, -0.037229906767606735, 0.039098240435123444, 0.02029436267912388, 0.012931160628795624, -0.04169278219342232, -0.053050447255373, -0.0031653742771595716, -0.0027294026222079992, -0.013649527914822102, -0.0038450865540653467, -0.023630646988749504, 0.0019354857504367828, -0.05137834697961807, 0.009322543628513813, -0.010454165749251842, 0.07333548367023468, 0.019280632957816124, -0.04449544847011566, -0.042403630912303925, 0.022407250478863716, 0.032159410417079926, -0.03547191992402077, 0.04213884845376015, 0.046409767121076584, -0.03024650551378727, -0.0024300802033394575, 0.006066600792109966, -0.01474094484001398, 0.021648526191711426, -0.06328456848859787, 0.017173809930682182, -0.07282949984073639, 0.0513046570122242, -0.004241820424795151, -0.07779882848262787, 0.13842496275901794, -0.038084715604782104, 0.029377399012446404, 0.04708891361951828, -0.0049183727242052555, -0.003620730945840478, -0.013039762154221535, -0.04063308611512184, 0.037395600229501724, 0.028950141742825508, -0.030134331434965134, -0.05111591890454292, -0.09115016460418701, 0.08750372380018234, 0.021830158308148384, 0.0016545053804293275, 0.03846675902605057, -0.025182057172060013, -0.06801124662160873, -0.0054540191777050495, -0.011463632807135582, -0.037482161074876785, 0.01817147433757782, -0.02316349744796753, 0.06622126698493958, -0.03548112511634827, -0.07065890729427338, -0.08587532490491867, -0.013440072536468506, 0.03579996898770332, 0.04311644658446312, -0.043944090604782104, -0.016599630936980247, 0.05410308390855789, 0.07515238970518112, -0.030919622629880905, -0.03720869496464729, -0.0006625399691984057, 0.0063514718785882, 0.03268219903111458, -0.036143139004707336, -0.005070629995316267, 0.09697980433702469, -0.025845754891633987, 0.0899057686328888, -0.010932918637990952, -0.027222974225878716, -0.05350629612803459, 0.03425532579421997, 0.04871895909309387, -0.013380385935306549, 0.03804067149758339, 0.022203730419278145, -0.06452422589063644, -0.04918020963668823, -0.01401674933731556, 0.03296033665537834, 0.022155748680233955, -0.004690155386924744, 0.018733112141489983, -0.013452999293804169, -0.030346963554620743, -0.027954164892435074, 0.002369635971263051, -0.03723704069852829, -0.024491531774401665, -0.05258563533425331, 0.01118876226246357, -0.027389956638216972, 0.007588197942823172, 0.08985483646392822, -0.026769515126943588, 0.05238611623644829, 0.05474843829870224, -0.01575765199959278, 0.08948419988155365, -0.007731266785413027, -0.07433688640594482, -0.03377712517976761, -0.038527991622686386, -0.02726837620139122, -0.1474687159061432, -0.029832759872078896, -0.014655287377536297, 0.05148903280496597, -0.0253707617521286, -0.025602122768759727, 0.000030977589631220326, 0.01922568492591381, -0.02898232266306877, 0.0653720498085022, 0.022160641849040985, -0.03860461711883545, -0.03490465134382248, -0.07963781803846359, -0.01855938695371151, 0.042130932211875916, -0.01041282620280981, 0.026416834443807602, -0.00852047000080347, -0.031605351716279984, -0.007242129184305668, -0.0016044842777773738, 0.06844612956047058, -0.034909896552562714, 0.008707746863365173, -0.008196797221899033, -0.023974183946847916, 0.14965499937534332, 0.004423283971846104, -0.00809586513787508, -0.04342973604798317, 0.023902058601379395, -0.04643150418996811, 0.043666206300258636, -0.15805132687091827, 0.026334892958402634, -0.03649337962269783, -0.029905913397669792, -0.03601560741662979, 0.023540666326880455, 0.013648208230733871, 0.04848119243979454, -0.05704907700419426, 0.09446020424365997, -0.02800361067056656, 0.013150972314178944, 0.033973995596170425, 0.015730388462543488, 0.015029323287308216, -0.009509406983852386, -0.015249932184815407, 0.005891356151551008, 0.013150734826922417, -0.01175988744944334, -0.05541326105594635, -0.10187167674303055, -0.013517335057258606, -0.058752160519361496, 0.07230805605649948, -0.009817472659051418, -0.0755624920129776, 0.033382900059223175, 0.04564785212278366, 0.022560765966773033, 0.0364377461373806, 0.07565364241600037, -0.08771063387393951, 0.008256006985902786, 0.049066998064517975, 0.04962009936571121, -0.11317559331655502, 0.01612173020839691, -0.015135071240365505, 0.037604935467243195, 0.02890663780272007, -0.10584122687578201, -0.07219430059194565, -0.046667810529470444, -0.03353290632367134, -0.043211184442043304, 0.04766704887151718, -0.03535570576786995, 0.053695473819971085, -0.05117989704012871, -0.07355213165283203, -0.017995255067944527, -0.04065704718232155, 0.01124776341021061, -0.019810885190963745, 0.041502680629491806, 0.03740586340427399, 0.0012230663560330868, 0.020349951460957527, 0.06808504462242126, 0.049000803381204605, -0.026527246460318565, 0.030087759718298912, -0.004926456604152918, -0.00349170109257102, -0.014502174220979214, -0.015030734241008759, -0.04182301089167595, -0.037910785526037216, -0.08109007775783539, -0.026108164340257645, -0.000027610625693341717, -0.0426994226872921, -0.011360476724803448, 0.011520503088831902, -0.03695593401789665, -0.026446348056197166, -0.049168266355991364, -0.03169012814760208, 0.08662594854831696, 0.03813100978732109, -0.027259020134806633, 0.04218801483511925, 0.09946445375680923, -0.017558056861162186, -0.046672094613313675, 0.008863448165357113, -0.04255492240190506, -0.009695920161902905, -0.027038710191845894, 0.026728805154561996, -0.035632602870464325, -0.04013548046350479, -0.010058596730232239, -0.08109572529792786, -0.06060691922903061, 0.03627588227391243, -0.016470015048980713, -0.08356080204248428, 0.01938190869987011, 0.015808969736099243, 0.00017744429351296276, 0.02191866561770439, 0.09766533225774765, -0.00023550618789158762, 0.04168817773461342, -0.010464703664183617, -0.03459703549742699, 0.0025925457011908293, 0.0189842339605093, -0.01991068571805954, -0.02488434500992298, 0.007336112670600414, -0.007476313505321741, -0.029131082817912102, 0.06904865801334381, 0.032181933522224426, 0.01456100307404995, -0.03088763915002346, 0.10881537944078445, -0.14347143471240997, -0.047520264983177185, -0.001209621550515294, 0.05368257313966751, -0.08801212906837463, -0.03482336178421974, 0.03949816897511482, -0.06095189228653908, 0.0854240283370018, 0.03025079518556595, 0.004180540330708027, -0.04699089378118515, -0.0801575779914856, -0.030938442796468735, -0.05852771922945976, 0.05873406305909157, 0.015650944784283638, -0.04538837447762489, -0.03647765889763832, -0.05026465281844139, 0.03705615922808647, -0.0007616468355990946, 0.03882518783211708, 0.0521540492773056, 0.024298418313264847, -0.02767382375895977, 0.021142305806279182, -0.053523506969213486, -0.008507524617016315, 0.00033546911436133087, -0.011519260704517365, -0.052999887615442276, -0.07779005169868469, -0.06294679641723633, 0.0007148084696382284, -0.0816466435790062, -0.025820599868893623, -0.005539121106266975, 0.04503348469734192, -0.01234931219369173, 0.010870769619941711, -0.0480181947350502, -0.029465077444911003, -0.03199721872806549, -0.01667013205587864, -0.03619419038295746, 0.039855387061834335, -0.024076253175735474, -0.03923611342906952, 0.03395324572920799, 0.0037624540273100138, -0.06529305875301361, -0.011603979393839836, -0.0008016591891646385, -0.04209356755018234, 0.00005138644337421283, 0.017097603529691696, 0.0512080155313015, 0.003242315724492073, 0.061344798654317856, 0.027396121993660927, 0.07057587802410126, -0.08067821711301804, 0.08939609676599503, 0.0035994439385831356, 0.07507132738828659, -0.0127743324264884, -0.014242595992982388, -0.04039580747485161, -0.08979110419750214, -0.011909029446542263, -0.06431864947080612, -0.028957167640328407, -0.024989519268274307, 0.013293443247675896, -0.050388164818286896, 0.01454564556479454, 0.012588237412273884, 0.01239066757261753, 0.08672663569450378, -0.004904092289507389, -0.018535565584897995, -0.03519127517938614, -0.0018577580340206623, -0.08016125857830048, -0.05836790055036545, 0.04416742920875549, -0.026367032900452614, 0.027550505474209785, -0.02554302103817463, -0.05738328769803047, 0.014617732726037502, 0.04373621568083763, 0.007608184590935707, -0.027168473228812218, 0.04146711155772209, -0.04626436531543732, -0.04753848910331726, 0.05066574364900589, 0.02776031568646431, 0.03973525017499924, 0.021813541650772095, 0.014534234069287777, -0.037973999977111816, 0.018897365778684616, 0.0340283177793026, 0.011734393425285816, -0.024278882890939713, 0.06694190204143524, -0.04884548485279083, -0.010665509849786758, 0.012806943617761135, 0.023650450631976128, 0.03730481117963791, -0.1447562575340271, 0.02369917556643486, 0.07063367962837219, 0.03605661913752556, -0.003145709168165922, -0.05938045680522919, 0.04122849181294441, -0.015819935128092766, 0.033207301050424576, -0.03905711695551872, 0.014259462244808674, -0.01749524287879467, 0.05324160307645798, 0.05708036944270134, 0.04417773708701134, -0.06749235838651657, 0.017118481919169426, -0.029823588207364082, -0.09156330674886703, 0.05089457705616951, -0.0038784975185990334, 0.012275485321879387, -0.033973585814237595, -0.037455618381500244, 0.05794258788228035, 0.009746327064931393, -0.006630124524235725, 0.01773436740040779, 0.04199841618537903, -0.06868589669466019, 0.004410859197378159, -0.017519831657409668, 0.01984582096338272, -0.00742357736453414, 0.012472609989345074, 0.01654782146215439, 0.027579886838793755, 0.02880047634243965, 0.014269133098423481, -0.016104236245155334, 0.004878866486251354, 0.030004587024450302, -0.04436469450592995, 0.010465302504599094, -0.022960782051086426, -0.0012625112431123853, 0.013542705215513706, 0.02132454514503479 ]
256
256
Induction of High-level Behaviors from Problem-solving Traces using Machine Learning Tools
This paper applies machine learning techniques to student modeling. It presents a method for discovering high-level student behaviors from a very large set of low-level traces corresponding to problem-solving actions in a learning environment. Basic actions are encoded into sets of domain-dependent attribute-value patterns called cases. Then a domain-independent hierarchical clustering identifies what we call general attitudes, yielding automatic diagnosis expressed in natural language, addressed in principle to teachers. The method can be applied to individual students or to entire groups, like a class. We exhibit examples of this system applied to thousands of students' actions in the domain of algebraic transformations.
[ -0.032151054590940475, -0.05485664680600166, 0.028765974566340446, 0.03670244663953781, 0.033043283969163895, -0.10035424679517746, -0.0732555240392685, 0.06989319622516632, -0.029471665620803833, 0.0053850021213293076, -0.0031714013312011957, 0.10455815494060516, 0.038866642862558365, -0.007609933614730835, 0.026039233431220055, -0.027803152799606323, 0.006527991965413094, -0.00648793950676918, 0.0037560544442385435, -0.08242102712392807, 0.06215834245085716, 0.013349192216992378, 0.024117477238178253, -0.08541469275951385, -0.0036307526752352715, 0.03195134922862053, -0.0005059997783973813, -0.08716172724962234, 0.01658621057868004, -0.05999545380473137, -0.024991998448967934, -0.05375219136476517, 0.00004857471867580898, -0.0038854386657476425, 0.04963581636548042, -0.023788727819919586, 0.04986240714788437, 0.07390575855970383, -0.015748145058751106, 0.015773514285683632, 0.007671718019992113, -0.014868722297251225, 0.03712047263979912, 0.020990226417779922, 0.0784575566649437, 0.06469544768333435, 0.029108423739671707, -0.044587742537260056, 0.023070132359862328, 0.059687525033950806, -0.10627175122499466, -0.004202025942504406, 0.003384544048458338, -0.008549164980649948, -0.027527257800102234, 0.01766229048371315, -0.007241006940603256, 0.006082505453377962, -0.013054111041128635, 0.0379367358982563, 0.036860719323158264, 0.056880053132772446, 0.02141185849905014, 0.018498819321393967, 0.007497683167457581, 0.04119298607110977, -0.033107940107584, -0.05309312418103218, -0.0564153790473938, -0.010061233304440975, 0.04892650991678238, 0.003651828970760107, 0.08255369961261749, 0.061001770198345184, 0.11168009787797928, 0.03421402350068092, -0.04430026933550835, 0.004771254491060972, 0.05429596081376076, 0.11845237761735916, -0.01252726186066866, 0.007784772198647261, -0.025023939087986946, -0.059428852051496506, -0.0719669982790947, 0.04194476082921028, -0.015585717745125294, -0.02859586663544178, 0.016538439318537712, 0.07935131341218948, -0.0338752418756485, 0.02686411514878273, -0.03487655147910118, -0.012354257516562939, -0.02895846962928772, 0.022977739572525024, 0.02696613222360611, -0.05978506803512573, 0.005996904335916042, -0.023280082270503044, -0.009379644878208637, 0.009853343479335308, 0.09336312115192413, 0.029242325574159622, -0.01755891554057598, 0.0569792203605175, 0.008111247792840004, 0.052182961255311966, -0.016197821125388145, -0.029224684461951256, 0.039100028574466705, 0.02221028506755829, 0.04923358932137489, 0.0880524292588234, -0.040049273520708084, -0.011720789596438408, -0.07916209846735, 0.09603700786828995, 0.01969844289124012, -0.04824844375252724, 0.008111593313515186, -0.03204970434308052, -0.08932501077651978, -0.008046163246035576, 0.006568052340298891, -0.04326969012618065, 0.05135141685605049, -0.0412176139652729, 0.019450651481747627, -0.008770052343606949, -0.02079331874847412, 0.03859923407435417, -0.12274036556482315, -0.046005185693502426, 0.06457003206014633, 0.00026008771965280175, -0.01852080039680004, -0.02338411472737789, -0.0735960528254509, 0.005923871416598558, -0.0044586872681975365, 0.008217988535761833, -0.038986656814813614, 0.0018490435322746634, 0.006939024198800325, -0.016909927129745483, -0.03232815861701965, 0.008573847822844982, 0.06213512271642685, 0.008799535222351551, -0.04145629703998566, -0.039980899542570114, 0.07265914231538773, 0.006609112024307251, 0.07219397276639938, -0.003551444038748741, -0.02139190584421158, -0.023350102826952934, 0.046678394079208374, 0.012093787081539631, -0.0032797642052173615, 0.005769219249486923, -0.03707107529044151, 0.01571464166045189, 0.02210625819861889, 0.030409041792154312, 0.010185793042182922, 0.05592934787273407, -0.0461624450981617, -0.04151793196797371, -0.05107352137565613, 0.002981950296089053, -0.008501768112182617, 0.04285954684019089, -0.0027644052170217037, -0.11056824028491974, 0.0062663359567523, 0.04471813514828682, -0.03385600820183754, 0.07669234275817871, 0.05028705298900604, -0.09941769391298294, -0.06589516252279282, 0.02587611973285675, 0.06383612751960754, 0.10765545815229416, -0.0007372912368737161, 0.07348258048295975, -0.001766448374837637, 0.0030173268169164658, -0.004817934241145849, -0.06670787185430527, 0.06890146434307098, 0.02574571967124939, -0.052629709243774414, -0.0024223856162279844, -0.027707450091838837, -0.02533235400915146, 0.001470336108468473, 0.09258914738893509, -0.022035783156752586, -0.013814776204526424, 0.006689536850899458, -0.017948279157280922, -0.010879565961658955, -0.03402336686849594, -0.0070020537823438644, 0.025835979729890823, -0.08602011948823929, 0.022171849384903908, 0.01479302253574133, 0.03620574250817299, 0.02244284562766552, 0.04655785113573074, 0.03113713674247265, -0.03423519432544708, -0.046429023146629333, -0.048203278332948685, 0.052715498954057693, 0.06002100929617882, -0.0459137037396431, -0.018488576635718346, 0.009836194105446339, 0.014084876514971256, -0.02473030984401703, -0.03700185567140579, 0.033593885600566864, -0.055582400411367416, -0.022321004420518875, 0.03013094700872898, -0.09575463086366653, -0.04452873021364212, -0.1071741133928299, 0.015679139643907547, 0.08015613257884979, 0.004304924979805946, -0.002017535734921694, -0.016611503437161446, -0.021703021600842476, 0.04627802222967148, -0.05814865231513977, -0.0034875518176704645, -0.05984322354197502, -0.014330850914120674, 0.020450029522180557, -0.038201671093702316, 0.06048936769366264, 0.024269631132483482, -0.05505020543932915, -0.034944381564855576, -0.020603781566023827, -0.05716565623879433, -0.015657532960176468, -0.017791034653782845, -0.05338336527347565, -0.007345419842749834, -0.060424987226724625, 0.013763800263404846, 0.010312147438526154, 0.030352892354130745, 0.01160871610045433, -0.03270468860864639, -0.03194235637784004, -0.002475115703418851, 0.07880398631095886, -0.021564511582255363, -0.037340257316827774, -0.04086577147245407, 0.013109511695802212, -0.032971810549497604, -0.03547600284218788, -0.06738951057195663, 0.0278921015560627, 0.03936085104942322, -0.037527136504650116, 0.027013903483748436, -0.040628671646118164, 0.08445630222558975, 0.003369189566001296, -0.02007073350250721, 0.01475500501692295, -0.011582884937524796, 0.0032062006648629904, -0.014444716274738312, -0.003533076262101531, 0.041185613721609116, 0.02409219928085804, 0.038273267447948456, -0.02204710990190506, 0.023457560688257217, -0.05471379682421684, 0.014691464602947235, -0.03879282623529434, 0.057395439594984055, 0.04453021287918091, -0.044772714376449585, 0.001392112229950726, 0.07029028981924057, 0.06616756319999695, -0.06533912569284439, 0.03267046809196472, 0.09614667296409607, 0.040257979184389114, -0.005445957183837891, 0.06824494898319244, 0.03758180886507034, 0.018933145329356194, 0.008544349111616611, -0.07011929899454117, -0.009187242947518826, 0.037400051951408386, -0.09115845710039139, 0.0013795992126688361, 0.02913632057607174, 0.03347337990999222, -0.02777516096830368, -0.049823563545942307, 0.05299604311585426, -0.05444380268454552, 0.028131987899541855, 0.051246657967567444, 0.02254856750369072, 0.035599805414676666, 0.04256218671798706, -0.033991552889347076, -0.024499470368027687, 0.006848412100225687, -0.005515571217983961, -0.07697681337594986, 0.0389653705060482, -0.023936597630381584, -0.02674369141459465, 0.11119123548269272, 0.10142239928245544, -0.024935012683272362, 0.0224466510117054, 0.0036301985383033752, 0.030838409438729286, 0.013247527182102203, 0.022377708926796913, -0.039191681891679764, -0.10834462195634842, -0.004967996384948492, 0.054819896817207336, 0.020834341645240784, 0.005719791166484356, 0.07483057677745819, 0.00720193050801754, 0.05776920169591904, -0.0554334856569767, -0.03323507681488991, 0.027180062606930733, -0.06649596989154816, 0.07398863136768341, -0.027021342888474464, 0.004234093241393566, 0.057941630482673645, -0.013804684393107891, 0.007744454313069582, -0.015161290764808655, -0.03815300762653351, 0.031886059790849686, -0.043962202966213226, -0.06710171699523926, -0.032506126910448074, 0.0558859147131443, -0.017969010397791862, 0.05503818392753601, -0.03538404777646065, -0.01823141798377037, 0.035614557564258575, 0.03438911214470863, 0.002675913507118821, 0.013966288417577744, 0.02837224118411541, 0.014316425658762455, 0.041853148490190506, -0.04679037630558014, 0.04637150466442108, 0.114620640873909, -0.05114009231328964, -0.03735588863492012, -0.05784169211983681, 0.047353729605674744, -0.06676574796438217, -0.06416383385658264, -0.08272435516119003, 0.010970520786941051, 0.02295079454779625, -0.057130470871925354, 0.004999845288693905, -0.0338873565196991, -0.012850631959736347, 0.04158389940857887, 0.05620722472667694, -0.08996495604515076, 0.024984119459986687, -0.051856134086847305, -0.011422846466302872, 0.01647350937128067, -0.013893910683691502, -0.0036336486227810383, -0.0026222311425954103, -0.05378393083810806, -0.04654787480831146, -0.01613566465675831, -0.025296133011579514, 0.0775759220123291, 0.03398814797401428, 0.02746155485510826, -0.00042294408194720745, 0.024657057598233223, -0.020715072751045227, -0.0654820054769516, 0.006055792327970266, 0.04626178741455078, -0.027920179069042206, 0.04514959082007408, -0.03263815864920616, -0.06752561777830124, 0.019990045577287674, 0.017896071076393127, -0.014743264764547348, 0.017378097400069237, -0.005291519686579704, -0.023940397426486015, 0.11245511472225189, -0.0040641725063323975, 0.06533748656511307, 0.03246167302131653, -0.04049578309059143, 0.01223119255155325, -0.07716881483793259, 0.06413400918245316, 0.001667421660386026, -0.0030251797288656235, 0.028568122535943985, -0.029372509568929672, 0.035939645022153854, 0.039435822516679764, -0.10403317958116531, 0.015099061653017998, -0.002786441473290324, -0.0430428571999073, 0.0708901435136795, 0.04312087222933769, -0.004440826829522848, -0.004199122544378042, 0.10300108045339584, -0.007329273037612438, -0.01619972102344036, -0.0311594158411026, -0.0048233517445623875, -0.005717168562114239, -0.04680396988987923, -0.07075010240077972, -0.033273495733737946, -0.03339623659849167, 0.06155265495181084, -0.03001321479678154, 0.058248162269592285, 0.07563066482543945, -0.05681798234581947, 0.038668420165777206, -0.05228882282972336, -0.06172238662838936, 0.03530013561248779, 0.04115549847483635, 0.05731502175331116, 0.007846970111131668, -0.07201836258172989, -0.025934843346476555, 0.005029644351452589, -0.035927221179008484, 0.003420428140088916, 0.023775378242135048, -0.029684364795684814, -0.06604493409395218, -0.05307913199067116, -0.047218989580869675, 0.04945553094148636, -0.012015227228403091, 0.03239048272371292, 0.004845208488404751, -0.00003717211802722886, 0.0010672659846022725, -0.010214479640126228, 0.05293169245123863, 0.06822193413972855, -0.025950979441404343, -0.030809035524725914, 0.003517292672768235, -0.0038547690492123365, 0.051633212715387344, -0.041772570461034775, -0.06427575647830963, 0.038194846361875534, 0.0014060302637517452, -0.0043216608464717865, 0.01818283274769783, 0.04538208246231079, -0.010197572410106659, 0.03746499866247177, 0.05284401401877403, 0.032239578664302826, 0.014818327501416206, 0.005885434336960316, -0.008170106448233128, 0.018315721303224564, -0.01517565455287695, -0.025715237483382225, -0.003747499082237482 ]
257
257
Stability Analysis and Learning Bounds for Transductive Regression Algorithms
This paper uses the notion of algorithmic stability to derive novel generalization bounds for several families of transductive regression algorithms, both by using convexity and closed-form solutions. Our analysis helps compare the stability of these algorithms. It also shows that a number of widely used transductive regression algorithms are in fact unstable. Finally, it reports the results of experiments with local transductive regression demonstrating the benefit of our stability bounds for model selection, for one of the algorithms, in particular for determining the radius of the local neighborhood used by the algorithm.
[ 0.007565715815871954, -0.0758742243051529, 0.011482837609946728, -0.015487824566662312, 0.07538854330778122, 0.009781790897250175, -0.007354815024882555, -0.031034644693136215, -0.03269198164343834, 0.11175665259361267, 0.06448929011821747, -0.04877839237451553, -0.009296635165810585, 0.006822565104812384, -0.030000561848282814, -0.09195546060800552, 0.01272676046937704, 0.007322386372834444, -0.0034191098529845476, -0.06637895107269287, 0.035802796483039856, 0.011227551847696304, 0.029440024867653847, -0.0608636811375618, 0.022185025736689568, 0.02320866473019123, 0.024446886032819748, -0.0232919380068779, 0.03444139286875725, -0.03987415134906769, -0.025028139352798462, 0.031036706641316414, -0.019707515835762024, -0.06757883727550507, -0.011500516906380653, -0.04389796406030655, 0.08258118480443954, 0.055909764021635056, -0.04116611182689667, -0.05127595365047455, 0.015290278010070324, -0.010257475078105927, 0.0049048857763409615, 0.012444096617400646, 0.05431663990020752, -0.014219245873391628, 0.08585866540670395, 0.02690259926021099, -0.027073934674263, 0.02031250111758709, 0.022883934900164604, 0.03990669548511505, -0.02945133112370968, -0.0460633784532547, 0.0033423376735299826, 0.0032529509626328945, -0.02974044904112816, -0.09371017664670944, 0.019819112494587898, 0.056626953184604645, -0.03243454545736313, 0.015257523395121098, -0.003774856450036168, -0.06704063713550568, -0.016717392951250076, -0.029351545497775078, -0.07859594374895096, -0.0272491667419672, 0.013204790651798248, -0.039434757083654404, -0.008356305770576, -0.007635276298969984, 0.017448678612709045, 0.07117199897766113, 0.06062674522399902, -0.05137079954147339, -0.003992863930761814, -0.038260675966739655, -0.001330163679085672, 0.016708118841052055, -0.06577905267477036, 0.01820869743824005, -0.0034475629217922688, 0.0385807566344738, -0.0004382459737826139, 0.00426541967317462, -0.04090660437941551, -0.02471679076552391, 0.05586498603224754, -0.052877265959978104, 0.011082708835601807, 0.04151419922709465, -0.08631587028503418, -0.054461680352687836, -0.04232175648212433, 0.0202005784958601, 0.0021266555413603783, 0.022185683250427246, -0.0015722321113571525, 0.06751572340726852, -0.031863983720541, 0.08656220883131027, 0.037000760436058044, 0.048096708953380585, -0.10650695860385895, 0.0699564665555954, -0.03906867280602455, 0.08168413490056992, -0.05028851702809334, 0.01316859107464552, -0.00903319101780653, -0.03305558115243912, 0.010816900059580803, 0.05072407424449921, 0.04392591491341591, 0.025020496919751167, 0.024274788796901703, 0.07303351908922195, 0.02580324374139309, -0.007154933176934719, -0.006225841585546732, 0.021084776148200035, 0.05660061165690422, 0.09635940194129944, -0.01870569959282875, -0.0039033691864460707, 0.002787304576486349, -0.10650663822889328, 0.12937748432159424, -0.06007615476846695, -0.02945808507502079, 0.005522239953279495, -0.05098326504230499, 0.055291905999183655, -0.01588568277657032, 0.0586782805621624, -0.04535509645938873, 0.019929399713873863, -0.03315797448158264, 0.05532136186957359, 0.08778797835111618, -0.001998704159632325, -0.02013245038688183, -0.01866217330098152, 0.0184641070663929, 0.015214323997497559, 0.005099010653793812, 0.011410281993448734, -0.003609203500673175, 0.0016426525544375181, -0.04997369647026062, -0.005904071033000946, 0.043773721903562546, 0.015459857881069183, 0.11756088584661484, -0.023725764825940132, -0.035383548587560654, -0.021687649190425873, -0.025832131505012512, 0.004671846982091665, -0.050288282334804535, 0.03016570955514908, -0.029950939118862152, -0.0230756476521492, -0.008695769123733044, 0.01479184627532959, 0.012587020173668861, -0.02572706528007984, -0.002784626791253686, -0.047485802322626114, -0.07760825753211975, 0.015119506977498531, -0.04833662137389183, 0.01552822720259428, 0.06387832760810852, -0.022474858909845352, 0.03893788903951645, 0.04598892107605934, -0.06686919927597046, -0.05173399671912193, 0.11638278514146805, -0.025782989338040352, -0.028184594586491585, 0.0727471336722374, 0.07213182747364044, 0.09860003739595413, -0.03675522655248642, 0.07618646323680878, 0.00947267934679985, 0.05516630411148071, 0.047575127333402634, -0.014689451083540916, -0.055120840668678284, 0.06802887469530106, -0.08739005029201508, 0.04288357496261597, -0.04478989541530609, -0.07465178519487381, -0.027298403903841972, 0.005338327027857304, 0.06599023193120956, -0.025502944365143776, -0.08894050121307373, -0.0758633017539978, -0.015820736065506935, 0.0491207055747509, 0.009307367727160454, -0.0841476246714592, -0.020301828160881996, -0.04407218471169472, -0.015111207962036133, 0.04416780173778534, -0.02731274627149105, -0.031201599165797234, -0.0005608048522844911, -0.02524597942829132, -0.039752911776304245, -0.06032884493470192, 0.11320202052593231, -0.03696587681770325, -0.02803194522857666, 0.05176571011543274, -0.008372356183826923, -0.035399507731199265, -0.039704691618680954, 0.03505605086684227, 0.001317757647484541, 0.054066114127635956, -0.05545506253838539, 0.04650048539042473, -0.06973961740732193, -0.07013893872499466, -0.0021336134523153305, -0.014784378930926323, -0.09455013275146484, 0.04246111214160919, -0.00740292202681303, 0.03561113774776459, 0.03266192972660065, 0.006445061415433884, -0.02147817239165306, 0.039057157933712006, -0.035741984844207764, -0.05228320136666298, 0.008444085717201233, 0.0006749888998456299, 0.1199740469455719, 0.03197736293077469, -0.008458842523396015, -0.04026567190885544, 0.022994264960289, -0.006172594614326954, -0.043795231729745865, -0.019903095439076424, -0.04199574887752533, 0.017730478197336197, -0.06214235723018646, -0.03845367208123207, 0.051048435270786285, 0.11809498071670532, -0.0331772044301033, 0.051047779619693756, -0.05915685370564461, -0.026238778606057167, 0.07402656972408295, 0.061350420117378235, -0.031507447361946106, -0.012629920616745949, 0.02691161260008812, 0.0008666443754918873, -0.031132197007536888, -0.061135053634643555, 0.00943306926637888, 0.09230902045965195, -0.06823962926864624, 0.024597348645329475, 0.08537313342094421, -0.04911758378148079, 0.022661084309220314, 0.06728611141443253, -0.03483440354466438, 0.036340221762657166, 0.03322737663984299, 0.02650868147611618, -0.0433436818420887, 0.014526178129017353, -0.019672300666570663, 0.023538809269666672, 0.025395981967449188, -0.005480398889631033, -0.05961466208100319, 0.04147326201200485, -0.05163516476750374, 0.038624729961156845, -0.0243948046118021, -0.06374981254339218, 0.06554580479860306, 0.017490703612565994, 0.037514664232730865, 0.011382018215954304, -0.01934952475130558, -0.014983917586505413, 0.02963174134492874, 0.0006267626886256039, 0.005736156366765499, 0.03455284237861633, 0.04124398157000542, -0.004920653998851776, -0.0420401506125927, -0.04711499065160751, -0.0006006116163916886, -0.06027974933385849, -0.03580119088292122, -0.018810730427503586, -0.010757695883512497, 0.030329400673508644, -0.033773068338632584, 0.0360599048435688, 0.06983844935894012, 0.0009519524173811078, -0.031741779297590256, 0.002105502411723137, 0.0219643022865057, -0.008885886520147324, -0.1252862513065338, -0.020571393892169, -0.031377315521240234, -0.029372699558734894, -0.05180952325463295, -0.014978310093283653, -0.06088799983263016, 0.006068265996873379, -0.007982886396348476, -0.0013892992865294218, 0.0009993019048124552, 0.10341861099004745, -0.06082521006464958, 0.03049415722489357, -0.11243968456983566, -0.0034549913834780455, -0.02185731753706932, -0.08796074986457825, -0.0016709307674318552, -0.03200488165020943, -0.024489324539899826, 0.05564499646425247, 0.06723327934741974, -0.027366625145077705, 0.00637618824839592, -0.0863398015499115, -0.08809511363506317, -0.0034790504723787308, -0.011975341476500034, 0.0515308603644371, -0.04145853593945503, -0.008709998801350594, -0.021239720284938812, -0.0407964251935482, 0.04372585564851761, 0.06323642283678055, -0.013685141690075397, 0.02236149087548256, -0.006041897460818291, -0.04789065197110176, -0.015745248645544052, 0.05033757910132408, -0.0421234667301178, 0.03842376172542572, 0.016337377950549126, 0.015886100009083748, -0.09041471779346466, 0.031311240047216415, 0.0410781130194664, 0.013649173080921173, -0.011053360067307949, 0.009792810305953026, 0.016159122809767723, -0.0654425099492073, 0.030148036777973175, 0.03392292931675911, -0.07818517088890076, 0.06036456301808357, -0.00039403795381076634, -0.023660700768232346, -0.0035986716393381357, 0.00009472693636780605, -0.04964219778776169, 0.02059757523238659, 0.064082570374012, -0.04136419668793678, 0.0029949063900858164, -0.03304262459278107, 0.009487018920481205, 0.05160892754793167, 0.006928692571818829, 0.008631456643342972, -0.006942333187907934, -0.05708000063896179, -0.008255605585873127, -0.0008058929815888405, -0.03737176954746246, 0.008338009007275105, 0.055179063230752945, -0.008055880665779114, -0.0586954765021801, -0.024169709533452988, 0.012864150106906891, 0.022480452433228493, -0.06351286917924881, -0.002969826338812709, -0.043569691479206085, 0.03462216258049011, -0.08667454868555069, 0.012595952488481998, 0.0057927947491407394, -0.004076769109815359, -0.03836982697248459, -0.0006564243813045323, 0.0765843465924263, -0.02802109345793724, 0.03647974878549576, -0.04663430526852608, -0.027062391862273216, 0.05002254620194435, 0.05617151036858559, -0.01384249422699213, -0.01574471965432167, 0.11340206861495972, -0.011906319297850132, 0.005190703086555004, -0.03968434035778046, -0.019468557089567184, -0.015233825892210007, -0.04879305884242058, -0.0298543069511652, 0.034225162118673325, 0.05877532809972763, 0.03408842906355858, -0.023616312071681023, -0.037223104387521744, -0.0558755062520504, 0.055223364382982254, -0.02999594435095787, 0.01016529556363821, -0.0913136750459671, 0.08017249405384064, 0.01414150558412075, -0.06047213822603226, 0.05723131075501442, 0.004252730868756771, -0.03919398412108421, 0.030921563506126404, -0.015637613832950592, -0.03424716368317604, -0.0029354789294302464, 0.06572522222995758, -0.02201681397855282, 0.061467546969652176, 0.048906922340393066, 0.004687902983278036, -0.021549753844738007, -0.01297282986342907, 0.0026957904919981956, 0.04208946228027344, -0.04797717183828354, -0.020951908081769943, -0.034071993082761765, 0.00939001701772213, 0.03543784096837044, -0.04327456280589104, -0.04001874104142189, -0.006097154226154089, 0.042946916073560715, -0.0011404904071241617, -0.05925113707780838, -0.023541243746876717, 0.029041660949587822, -0.06939628720283508, 0.004879560321569443, -0.011069507338106632, -0.0020704560447484255, -0.009828574024140835, -0.04910675436258316, -0.03985945135354996, 0.02196515165269375, 0.018400825560092926, 0.014758272096514702, 0.009481946006417274, 0.053242430090904236, 0.041876208037137985, -0.0007408872479572892, 0.03911956399679184, -0.06490115821361542, -0.004643509164452553, -0.027658779174089432, 0.05748196691274643, 0.04314754158258438, -0.027688514441251755, 0.030737970024347305, 0.0453043095767498, 0.04716096445918083, -0.010638810694217682, 0.03461085632443428, 0.03847934678196907, 0.014979136176407337, 0.054162535816431046, -0.015608617104589939, -0.0217533390969038, 0.012961168773472309, 0.017429964616894722, -0.048392850905656815, 0.022214291617274284 ]
258
258
Learning convex bodies is hard
We show that learning a convex body in $\RR^d$, given random samples from the body, requires $2^{\Omega(\sqrt{d/\eps})}$ samples. By learning a convex body we mean finding a set having at most $\eps$ relative symmetric difference with the input body. To prove the lower bound we construct a hard to learn family of convex bodies. Our construction of this family is very simple and based on error correcting codes.
[ -0.008734098635613918, 0.018997514620423317, 0.06862467527389526, -0.0850103572010994, -0.02485431358218193, -0.08142498880624771, -0.02924613282084465, -0.024114571511745453, -0.0510910302400589, -0.00018287455895915627, 0.014656288549304008, -0.017408030107617378, -0.011958558112382889, 0.03868885338306427, 0.007660417351871729, -0.01954035460948944, -0.0029982009436935186, 0.014145080000162125, 0.06055130437016487, -0.05113580450415611, 0.07435835152864456, 0.014599188230931759, 0.018208060413599014, -0.05725357308983803, 0.04529951885342598, 0.003919895738363266, 0.04352802783250809, 0.0002837922365870327, 0.02829805016517639, -0.04738582670688629, -0.05602310597896576, -0.020878098905086517, -0.026659119874238968, -0.0022007322404533625, -0.006821423303335905, -0.039354175329208374, 0.06292156875133514, 0.055167969316244125, -0.0003987962263636291, 0.034372907131910324, -0.039595913141965866, -0.00725376233458519, -0.006016767118126154, 0.018298525363206863, -0.01760643720626831, -0.01560692023485899, 0.014404763467609882, 0.007564756087958813, -0.08294598013162613, 0.04122282564640045, -0.01731099560856819, 0.06831106543540955, -0.018157662823796272, 0.05423174425959587, -0.03101135417819023, 0.030469825491309166, 0.03950635716319084, 0.011227658949792385, -0.12764255702495575, -0.02642904967069626, 0.00470281345769763, 0.1368005871772766, 0.008220969699323177, -0.06280821561813354, -0.0009086360223591328, 0.007208322174847126, -0.05663608759641647, 0.04291599616408348, -0.029229164123535156, 0.04942028969526291, -0.04082617536187172, -0.05775890499353409, -0.04217499494552612, -0.023849617689847946, 0.04697020724415779, -0.025168033316731453, 0.03960723057389259, -0.01005244068801403, -0.003411042271181941, 0.10221204906702042, -0.00979773048311472, -0.0017199378926306963, 0.015046048909425735, 0.06535329669713974, -0.05645065754652023, -0.016662226989865303, 0.04727189242839813, 0.036513980478048325, 0.014720357954502106, 0.01043248362839222, 0.007054668851196766, 0.043597135692834854, -0.09727290272712708, 0.08966058492660522, -0.06118874251842499, 0.03695131838321686, -0.041112612932920456, -0.05982661992311478, -0.08112814277410507, -0.02049710974097252, 0.06756386160850525, 0.0019662731792777777, 0.05661546438932419, 0.028521738946437836, -0.012062202207744122, 0.025175096467137337, -0.024791667237877846, 0.011817405931651592, -0.031248167157173157, -0.05417502671480179, 0.029310572892427444, -0.02130953222513199, 0.02848827838897705, -0.014069732278585434, -0.02224823646247387, 0.03227832540869713, -0.011519589461386204, 0.0720939189195633, 0.009819128550589085, -0.01889711245894432, 0.0036796017084270716, -0.007648048456758261, 0.023460550233721733, 0.016558965668082237, 0.033143047243356705, -0.06225385516881943, -0.029596513137221336, -0.05809144303202629, 0.0796055793762207, -0.0037686016876250505, -0.006217838265001774, -0.01377288717776537, 0.006201763637363911, -0.045610327273607254, -0.0755799412727356, -0.04133014380931854, -0.057593051344156265, 0.027033543214201927, -0.08404587209224701, 0.017208611592650414, -0.002660541795194149, -0.06391596049070358, -0.012624231167137623, 0.02937658503651619, 0.022677434608340263, -0.009380592964589596, -0.023958507925271988, 0.048822011798620224, -0.06765855103731155, 0.038247425109148026, 0.002604816108942032, 0.014906615950167179, 0.08754158020019531, 0.021211611106991768, 0.052361585199832916, -0.011761432513594627, 0.024347638711333275, -0.015444597229361534, -0.07144729793071747, 0.013241964392364025, 0.04326051101088524, -0.05314585566520691, 0.027106020599603653, 0.013628058135509491, 0.0007089641876518726, -0.04363976791501045, 0.05265432223677635, -0.0487007275223732, -0.04454249143600464, -0.010363125242292881, 0.005401263944804668, -0.030001692473888397, 0.04732023552060127, 0.02469298057258129, 0.01341431587934494, 0.020737197250127792, -0.01999795436859131, 0.12700672447681427, 0.014020822942256927, -0.024367880076169968, 0.002072509378194809, -0.05597611516714096, 0.005670061334967613, -0.0178562942892313, 0.001871789339929819, 0.08012555539608002, 0.05387338995933533, 0.03858393803238869, -0.02844979800283909, -0.03494403511285782, 0.015160433016717434, -0.04941834881901741, 0.001608114573173225, 0.005035101901739836, -0.044860485941171646, 0.03788681700825691, -0.03861247003078461, -0.011018863879144192, 0.015739325433969498, 0.02916066348552704, 0.09163118153810501, -0.00975117553025484, -0.10135918110609055, -0.11652418226003647, -0.07715661823749542, 0.03804671764373779, -0.019794361665844917, -0.003395902458578348, -0.012128135189414024, -0.0148346908390522, 0.01085730455815792, 0.06183696538209915, -0.021997325122356415, -0.060823407024145126, -0.0063713314011693, -0.007645732257515192, 0.019610002636909485, -0.016893496736884117, 0.06075504049658775, 0.020135346800088882, -0.04003477841615677, 0.007509877905249596, -0.026471618562936783, -0.0010840697214007378, -0.0825880840420723, 0.009989063255488873, 0.09424494206905365, 0.015423178672790527, -0.08353785425424576, 0.055216629058122635, -0.10169246047735214, -0.05797891691327095, -0.023402655497193336, 0.0412835069000721, -0.02701956033706665, 0.016417814418673515, 0.053927626460790634, 0.00899413414299488, -0.045387256890535355, 0.020524002611637115, 0.004211732652038336, 0.024305254220962524, -0.009897780604660511, 0.04583628848195076, -0.03797024115920067, -0.05043896660208702, -0.013464619405567646, -0.01534506306052208, 0.017611971125006676, 0.018617182970046997, -0.023362688720226288, 0.0018237471813336015, -0.010844875127077103, -0.007419005502015352, -0.023149514570832253, 0.015711575746536255, -0.03455672040581703, 0.016591310501098633, 0.06495434045791626, 0.08092164248228073, -0.0005780356586910784, 0.05331425368785858, -0.030571650713682175, 0.060555581003427505, 0.029937023296952248, -0.010140512138605118, -0.009146124124526978, -0.007711806334555149, 0.05252477899193764, 0.042482998222112656, 0.03728294372558594, -0.012309539131820202, -0.009629582054913044, -0.014099407941102982, -0.04014550894498825, 0.01774391159415245, 0.06865879893302917, 0.09485137462615967, 0.0005273909191600978, -0.09991617500782013, -0.09654966741800308, -0.017103087157011032, 0.0045116557739675045, 0.04448949173092842, -0.0174199678003788, 0.003126485738903284, 0.017090778797864914, 0.04778827726840973, 0.00884923618286848, 0.04006943851709366, -0.04970288276672363, 0.014814002439379692, -0.043545790016651154, -0.054682258516550064, 0.024352502077817917, -0.0004190375912003219, 0.051575496792793274, 0.00023411826987285167, -0.00972677767276764, -0.004485610872507095, -0.06513535231351852, -0.07380329817533493, -0.018248479813337326, 0.02780897356569767, -0.02504815347492695, -0.026972467079758644, -0.020130066201090813, 0.005764782894402742, -0.04766412079334259, -0.003919348120689392, -0.09372387826442719, -0.025233300402760506, -0.008408697322010994, 0.02450791746377945, -0.008128891699016094, -0.047114092856645584, 0.026655318215489388, 0.0016314334934577346, 0.01097338180989027, -0.02273770608007908, 0.03662349283695221, 0.031717974692583084, -0.09215746074914932, 0.03920562565326691, -0.09086143225431442, -0.01106913574039936, 0.026626093313097954, -0.015975911170244217, -0.045722685754299164, -0.0034304752480238676, -0.0369274839758873, 0.024656297639012337, 0.032452572137117386, -0.017211193218827248, 0.00224481918849051, 0.0389227457344532, -0.02279241941869259, -0.052275270223617554, -0.04952341690659523, 0.012441418133676052, -0.03915688395500183, -0.11217573285102844, 0.02494199201464653, -0.023350000381469727, -0.0001927473786054179, -0.0289484690874815, 0.04295845702290535, 0.020136358216404915, 0.02093820832669735, 0.003980939742177725, -0.07038125395774841, -0.05295397713780403, -0.019571583718061447, 0.03912234678864479, 0.028113430365920067, -0.03202572464942932, 0.04713408648967743, 0.01167476549744606, 0.031021753326058388, 0.06775009632110596, -0.003960863687098026, 0.03218604251742363, -0.04539477452635765, -0.02942824177443981, -0.02484886907041073, 0.04608996585011482, -0.09558948129415512, -0.012094465084373951, -0.058036211878061295, 0.008609706535935402, -0.011544642969965935, 0.051659923046827316, 0.028911840170621872, -0.02692444808781147, -0.010707435198128223, -0.05646589398384094, 0.02466108836233616, -0.020422331988811493, -0.014248269610106945, 0.0420818030834198, -0.07247590273618698, 0.01140464749187231, 0.057085465639829636, -0.025699147954583168, -0.02237018011510372, -0.03265537694096565, -0.003220380749553442, 0.09381923079490662, 0.07249879837036133, 0.04352711886167526, 0.004015164449810982, -0.0012239959323778749, 0.04097815230488777, -0.03453061357140541, -0.009981967508792877, 0.02318371832370758, -0.005696809850633144, 0.03909049928188324, -0.0032675762195140123, -0.1086040660738945, 0.03457671403884888, -0.07249482721090317, 0.017689013853669167, -0.009397943504154682, -0.10936815291643143, -0.06903260201215744, 0.044344376772642136, -0.013737051747739315, 0.009409674443304539, 0.07341931760311127, 0.010354719124734402, 0.0005098346155136824, -0.023054834455251694, 0.07547055184841156, 0.01706698350608349, 0.08178773522377014, -0.060412757098674774, 0.0038860945496708155, -0.024812238290905952, -0.02415282465517521, 0.015665827319025993, 0.004399905446916819, -0.012487974017858505, -0.0007770826341584325, 0.09275362640619278, 0.033148255199193954, 0.025034647434949875, 0.04463695362210274, -0.0491504967212677, 0.08072620630264282, -0.03808880224823952, -0.04844750463962555, -0.05511416494846344, -0.015248420648276806, -0.013008919544517994, -0.04215128347277641, -0.03067639097571373, -0.0385124608874321, -0.007835597731173038, -0.018969837576150894, -0.08787074685096741, -0.015821147710084915, 0.03581185266375542, 0.0412268303334713, -0.028003312647342682, 0.07560735195875168, -0.023167524486780167, -0.020913245156407356, 0.06446106731891632, 0.09703579545021057, -0.0018199466867372394, 0.03023139014840126, 0.020410072058439255, 0.0201997272670269, 0.07228931039571762, -0.006182560697197914, 0.004823889583349228, -0.00355603639036417, 0.025219669565558434, -0.06977108120918274, 0.0021168338134884834, -0.053656477481126785, -0.00006239711365196854, 0.07666537910699844, -0.09687947481870651, -0.009600439108908176, 0.010890020057559013, 0.034022681415081024, 0.07009246945381165, -0.08451799303293228, -0.017567627131938934, 0.07303605228662491, -0.04774533584713936, 0.022935863584280014, -0.0012795848306268454, 0.06891331076622009, 0.044174924492836, -0.008141408674418926, 0.06957800686359406, 0.017700083553791046, -0.044086895883083344, -0.0011059840908274055, -0.016463087871670723, -0.01576658897101879, 0.009304956533014774, 0.027682175859808922, -0.017701487988233566, 0.0857967883348465, 0.058586496859788895, 0.03885311633348465, 0.03918365016579628, -0.04021885246038437, 0.01854666881263256, -0.03583246469497681, 0.04298897832632065, 0.03903692215681076, 0.13460740447044373, 0.001080930233001709, 0.02953203022480011, 0.02876843698322773, 0.053364578634500504, 0.05266283079981804, -0.015989484265446663, 0.08264698833227158, 0.023733127862215042, 0.08581298589706421, 0.10402311384677887, -0.08375836163759232, -0.02230898104608059, 0.06794105470180511, -0.052994780242443085, 0.027033129706978798 ]
259
259
Online prediction of ovarian cancer
In this paper we apply computer learning methods to diagnosing ovarian cancer using the level of the standard biomarker CA125 in conjunction with information provided by mass-spectrometry. We are working with a new data set collected over a period of 7 years. Using the level of CA125 and mass-spectrometry peaks, our algorithm gives probability predictions for the disease. To estimate classification accuracy we convert probability predictions into strict predictions. Our algorithm makes fewer errors than almost any linear combination of the CA125 level and one peak's intensity (taken on the log scale). To check the power of our algorithm we use it to test the hypothesis that CA125 and the peaks do not contain useful information for the prediction of the disease at a particular time before the diagnosis. Our algorithm produces $p$-values that are better than those produced by the algorithm that has been previously applied to this data set. Our conclusion is that the proposed algorithm is more reliable for prediction on new data.
[ -0.0723993107676506, -0.03521984815597534, 0.03185585141181946, 0.023716693744063377, -0.002319704508408904, -0.05614252761006355, -0.05149073898792267, -0.038981277495622635, -0.05089534446597099, -0.02768835984170437, 0.009577114135026932, -0.038860395550727844, 0.02630998194217682, 0.05583779141306877, -0.013369393534958363, 0.08506613224744797, 0.014194556511938572, -0.02271626703441143, -0.018559139221906662, -0.09830044209957123, -0.04977362975478172, -0.012728103436529636, -0.023479605093598366, -0.05317092686891556, 0.016227398067712784, 0.05218679457902908, 0.050095949321985245, 0.011576026678085327, -0.008908988907933235, -0.018009472638368607, -0.07672832906246185, -0.03324626758694649, 0.0004833059210795909, 0.0037728201132267714, 9.264303457712231e-7, 0.08042048662900925, -0.025633180513978004, -0.010760976001620293, -0.12103437632322311, -0.0567018985748291, -0.006805120501667261, -0.007837986573576927, -0.000977693242020905, 0.006595315411686897, -0.013360641896724701, 0.06282293796539307, 0.03418003022670746, -0.06723236292600632, -0.04020914435386658, 0.017412956804037094, -0.08480618894100189, 0.010743429884314537, 0.010506261140108109, -0.0361320823431015, -0.011427581310272217, -0.06693339347839355, 0.041548654437065125, -0.0018150507239624858, -0.060754939913749695, -0.027719028294086456, -0.0023048429284244776, 0.06223306059837341, 0.06265261024236679, -0.046273790299892426, -0.021982621401548386, -0.03343566879630089, -0.03615991026163101, -0.01503820437937975, -0.02365628443658352, 0.03298773244023323, 0.025311805307865143, -0.04424002394080162, 0.06530842185020447, 0.0006705811829306185, 0.02091713435947895, 0.053568944334983826, 0.007505977526307106, 0.028265023604035378, 0.011108825914561749, 0.06933194398880005, 0.07070471346378326, 0.03428468853235245, 0.040542833507061005, 0.061205703765153885, -0.040555182844400406, 0.04295488819479942, 0.019205788150429726, -0.029560500755906105, 0.038864344358444214, 0.02967030741274357, -0.06553877145051956, 0.0743955448269844, 0.009589084424078465, 0.014119669795036316, -0.05185697600245476, 0.006163447163999081, 0.016415797173976898, -0.02407952956855297, 0.03100033849477768, 0.09468118101358414, -0.061912037432193756, -0.00934189185500145, 0.04604166001081467, 0.01695851981639862, -0.028145551681518555, -0.06000335142016411, -0.09120190143585205, 0.07858104258775711, -0.0339854471385479, 0.018576107919216156, 0.05901680141687393, -0.007880894467234612, 0.02460063062608242, -0.015002801083028316, 0.009258410893380642, -0.005647099576890469, -0.036631327122449875, 0.08930827677249908, 0.04960498586297035, 0.027134258300065994, 0.023152004927396774, 0.054518360644578934, -0.06486546993255615, 0.05768805742263794, 0.047114621847867966, -0.01175669115036726, 0.018988411873579025, -0.07459747046232224, 0.06893353909254074, -0.02542033977806568, -0.04905981197953224, 0.11049577593803406, -0.09038075804710388, 0.06187041476368904, -0.0875883623957634, -0.02538265660405159, 0.03312993049621582, -0.040379710495471954, -0.017872897908091545, 0.036091335117816925, -0.0688118264079094, -0.02506677620112896, -0.020373575389385223, 0.050622470676898956, -0.054959092289209366, -0.017497258260846138, 0.04269039258360863, 0.06481252610683441, -0.04700217768549919, 0.057368312031030655, -0.015150543302297592, -0.060340069234371185, 0.010261142626404762, 0.08287449926137924, 0.026930829510092735, -0.05468423292040825, 0.02116924338042736, -0.06681761890649796, 0.017057351768016815, -0.011317995376884937, -0.024232205003499985, -0.009345482103526592, -0.026139194145798683, -0.01724730245769024, -0.024870948866009712, 0.0698380097746849, 0.03340562805533409, -0.03607264906167984, 0.025795642286539078, -0.04118642956018448, 0.036185283213853836, 0.025699196383357048, 0.003552093403413892, 0.040197208523750305, 0.07261593639850616, -0.030449671670794487, 0.008906817995011806, -0.000997823430225253, -0.023330168798565865, -0.019993172958493233, 0.03636714816093445, -0.0538630373775959, -0.03290171176195145, 0.05828027054667473, 0.029446333646774292, 0.09485558420419693, 0.00477931322529912, 0.04977187514305115, 0.042630020529031754, -0.008294984698295593, 0.039680421352386475, 0.026092734187841415, 0.06282518059015274, -0.03646128624677658, -0.012289198115468025, 0.016682762652635574, -0.03835567086935043, -0.13020461797714233, -0.06030464544892311, 0.06954304873943329, 0.013761564157903194, -0.005300901830196381, -0.02761455439031124, -0.010161814279854298, -0.018619520589709282, 0.0021739655639976263, 0.05666802078485489, -0.006077855825424194, 0.0037545470986515284, 0.050240203738212585, 0.03729287534952164, 0.0296307560056448, 0.06137091666460037, 0.011899872682988644, 0.018322477117180824, -0.04641403630375862, -0.10781843215227127, -0.0027709242422133684, 0.020497262477874756, 0.1109955832362175, 0.0012840155977755785, -0.03668787702918053, 0.047198791056871414, 0.037517186254262924, -0.09641114622354507, 0.052303072065114975, -0.06753110140562057, -0.06467906385660172, -0.10130373388528824, 0.03110682964324951, -0.009317870251834393, -0.023694181814789772, -0.03727653995156288, -0.0431288443505764, 0.02370925061404705, 0.016741687431931496, -0.0023528821766376495, 0.0404948815703392, -0.009684092365205288, 0.01618483103811741, 0.028028978034853935, 0.06924309581518173, 0.027811357751488686, -0.05753447860479355, 0.0434013307094574, -0.014005286619067192, 0.06170225143432617, 0.10191062092781067, -0.08264794945716858, -0.0044916239567101, 0.008904080837965012, -0.010943034663796425, -0.012654290534555912, 0.00858691893517971, 0.03969165310263634, -0.01213227678090334, 0.01609252579510212, -0.013093472458422184, 0.06665327399969101, 0.05305913835763931, 0.010645322501659393, -0.005783569533377886, -0.031333960592746735, -0.02489658072590828, 0.05181015655398369, -0.041307639330625534, -0.06508517265319824, 0.019070828333497047, 0.020054476335644722, 0.015975866466760635, -0.03976798057556152, -0.0334290936589241, 0.05339030176401138, 0.0630858764052391, -0.04532274976372719, 0.005480766762048006, 0.053661663085222244, -0.03658359497785568, 0.016859421506524086, 0.02250705659389496, -0.002099899109452963, 0.007682829163968563, -0.015681961551308632, 0.028673755005002022, 0.017705686390399933, -0.058919504284858704, -0.0034322894643992186, -0.011046316474676132, 0.02622320130467415, -0.0547357052564621, 0.001971578923985362, 0.011789624579250813, 0.014052269048988819, 0.03689265623688698, 0.03510681167244911, -0.04909452050924301, 0.08178423345088959, 0.06361882388591766, 0.07464389503002167, -0.08182098716497421, -0.04477826878428459, 0.004737899173051119, 0.047016263008117676, -0.021820252761244774, -0.019462576135993004, 0.04064704477787018, 0.05231853201985359, 0.0634109154343605, 0.013975189998745918, 0.05378686636686325, 0.05910151079297066, -0.022707894444465637, -0.02624226175248623, -0.020586354658007622, -0.061495617032051086, -0.0068193767219781876, -0.0020659854635596275, 0.049912888556718826, -0.014168132096529007, -0.05944130942225456, 0.03058123029768467, -0.021434200927615166, -0.02214820869266987, -0.02618168480694294, -0.005992595572024584, -0.020915081724524498, -0.01062073279172182, 0.05432743951678276, -0.1064903512597084, -0.0065712337382137775, -0.029486553743481636, 0.019699249416589737, 0.008038722909986973, 0.12039904296398163, -0.0865946039557457, 0.03743726760149002, -0.005148781463503838, 0.045125532895326614, 0.024456383660435677, -0.0063447244465351105, -0.03979641944169998, -0.0004273932136129588, -0.02165449783205986, -0.004320066422224045, -0.02037722058594227, -0.027075504884123802, 0.010622354224324226, -0.040857598185539246, -0.039533816277980804, 0.012625209987163544, -0.08639208227396011, 0.032196927815675735, -0.014734286814928055, 0.008865052834153175, -0.022544153034687042, 0.1147717535495758, -0.007451019249856472, -0.023551540449261665, 0.028919046744704247, 0.031066959723830223, -0.012937677092850208, -0.04049273952841759, -0.10195984691381454, -0.011396309360861778, 0.00928591564297676, 0.061227839440107346, 0.07895979285240173, 0.01030692271888256, 0.033420223742723465, -0.021121537312865257, 0.005309256725013256, -0.007244873326271772, -0.0057391878217458725, 0.0000030977516871644184, 0.0504591129720211, -0.027283990755677223, -0.00576377660036087, -0.032902851700782776, 0.03481461480259895, 0.05234673246741295, -0.039789579808712006, 0.036863598972558975, -0.011264553293585777, -0.0659918338060379, -0.0017246038187295198, -0.019654298201203346, -0.09060507267713547, 0.0038036529440432787, 0.03575502336025238, 0.033210039138793945, -0.06191595643758774, -0.06634276360273361, -0.04188404232263565, 0.018062708899378777, 0.03705710917711258, 0.015057586133480072, 0.029006270691752434, 0.06361889839172363, -0.004858837462961674, 0.000378806289518252, -0.004538466688245535, -0.009547743014991283, 0.03357897326350212, -0.036245498806238174, -0.07576490193605423, 0.05300460383296013, -0.06188933178782463, 0.05149351805448532, -0.024729959666728973, 0.04864438995718956, 0.028493432328104973, 0.0297799501568079, 0.0022062843199819326, -0.017286838963627815, 0.03230724483728409, 0.04069055616855621, -0.005724123679101467, -0.06449337303638458, -0.05712996795773506, -0.07908087223768234, 0.053499557077884674, 0.0327652283012867, -0.0310837235301733, 0.03670956939458847, 0.03153638541698456, -0.005516825243830681, 0.013197454623878002, 0.045432284474372864, 0.007028262596577406, 0.08839160203933716, -0.042742952704429626, -0.026017751544713974, -0.04443759098649025, 0.041571471840143204, -0.0014242358738556504, -0.00016451618284918368, 0.04720383882522583, -0.02850506640970707, -0.002268869196996093, 0.05385603383183479, -0.0797095000743866, -0.04520457983016968, 0.007169079966843128, 0.013691241852939129, -0.013729616068303585, 0.012932760640978813, 0.0018627065001055598, 0.03770371153950691, 0.10441742837429047, -0.03802983835339546, 0.018775945529341698, 0.09769447147846222, -0.001804659841582179, -0.029912546277046204, -0.05218310281634331, -0.007361442316323519, -0.03044033981859684, -0.05078788846731186, 0.03146057203412056, -0.021745901554822922, -0.011643671430647373, 0.049485836178064346, -0.038781438022851944, 0.017086287960410118, -0.02512485533952713, 0.025653941556811333, -0.05110471695661545, -0.021974904462695122, 0.05695053189992905, -0.021460697054862976, -0.08708816021680832, -0.017914915457367897, -0.013223133981227875, 0.016543392091989517, 0.01789359748363495, -0.016546625643968582, 0.029794415459036827, -0.07373833656311035, 0.002676324686035514, -0.07635673880577087, 0.044455498456954956, -0.0416124202311039, 0.03291827067732811, 0.03185613825917244, 0.019958017393946648, -0.0394405722618103, -0.022687220945954323, 0.02980545535683632, -0.04835231229662895, 0.01238810084760189, 0.014028394594788551, 0.03369581699371338, -0.02021675556898117, -0.03282412514090538, -0.06418811529874802, 0.04460539296269417, -0.023570356890559196, -0.048439476639032364, 0.00014182105951476842, 0.02622024156153202, -0.017520535737276077, -0.04859200492501259, 0.044323381036520004, -0.09020702540874481, 0.06599871069192886, 0.002886776113882661, 0.005483946762979031, 0.048365406692028046, 0.04869310185313225, 0.11845725029706955, -0.08055956661701202, 0.0005074992659501731 ]
260
260
Recovering the state sequence of hidden Markov models using mean-field approximations
Inferring the sequence of states from observations is one of the most fundamental problems in Hidden Markov Models. In statistical physics language, this problem is equivalent to computing the marginals of a one-dimensional model with a random external field. While this task can be accomplished through transfer matrix methods, it becomes quickly intractable when the underlying state space is large. This paper develops several low-complexity approximate algorithms to address this inference problem when the state space becomes large. The new algorithms are based on various mean-field approximations of the transfer matrix. Their performances are studied in detail on a simple realistic model for DNA pyrosequencing.
[ -0.0018941545858979225, -0.0102605652064085, 0.023380141705274582, -0.05078466981649399, 0.015153060667216778, -0.048430658876895905, 0.013493885286152363, -0.024550173431634903, -0.043304797261953354, 0.04904467985033989, -0.043623823672533035, -0.01654631271958351, 0.0009992701234295964, 0.029164528474211693, -0.052958838641643524, -0.010470339097082615, -0.0703202411532402, -0.038622207939624786, -0.004887777380645275, -0.07597425580024719, 0.029691779986023903, 0.03325763717293739, -0.0015910238726064563, 0.04602887108922005, 0.01803482323884964, 0.08451027423143387, -0.0311349555850029, -0.004094388801604509, 0.02430044673383236, 0.021327152848243713, -0.06319103389978409, -0.01101020909845829, 0.03212667629122734, -0.005526866298168898, 0.0649728998541832, 0.04571695998311043, 0.05683855712413788, -0.032399553805589676, -0.03982342407107353, -0.056926075369119644, -0.07008364796638489, -0.028731904923915863, 0.0006434452370740473, -0.00268149864859879, 0.027649570256471634, 0.08524485677480698, -0.015657097101211548, 0.017473485320806503, 0.009752164594829082, 0.03808024525642395, -0.05054160952568054, 0.067782461643219, -0.0736970528960228, 0.0856906995177269, -0.05098789930343628, 0.04315458983182907, 0.029450513422489166, 0.05995272472500801, -0.03542260453104973, -0.02452530525624752, 0.036297645419836044, 0.031163616105914116, 0.015730777755379677, 0.035636503249406815, 0.005615320987999439, -0.02643994800746441, -0.0652606189250946, -0.03942057117819786, 0.02370944805443287, -0.03030211105942726, -0.009215397760272026, -0.08584214746952057, 0.03623789921402931, -0.0098866056650877, 0.04368787258863449, 0.0507550872862339, 0.07978261262178421, -0.013400505296885967, 0.13627256453037262, 0.07371663302183151, -0.07265432178974152, 0.10819180309772491, 0.013653211295604706, 0.08297130465507507, -0.003324556862935424, 0.05010516196489334, 0.01282378938049078, -0.07171936333179474, 0.029099244624376297, -0.033829934895038605, -0.007442656904459, -0.014277489855885506, -0.05775514617562294, 0.06105691194534302, -0.09832065552473068, 0.0041967472061514854, -0.04297342151403427, -0.013250074349343777, -0.03458045795559883, -0.006130569614470005, 0.028350455686450005, -0.014576219953596592, 0.1061716228723526, 0.025060808286070824, -0.045105330646038055, -0.009208070114254951, -0.005775452591478825, 0.04988671839237213, 0.028798671439290047, -0.03351683169603348, 0.026398658752441406, -0.023878686130046844, 0.04867224767804146, -0.04327866807579994, -0.053529951721429825, 0.018650144338607788, -0.005055802874267101, 0.023208584636449814, -0.03127826377749443, 0.0340714305639267, 0.000054404310503741726, 0.011197764426469803, -0.004312256816774607, 0.025535939261317253, 0.031099043786525726, -0.03037257120013237, -0.008592740632593632, -0.04405757039785385, 0.07098285108804703, -0.010805904865264893, 0.020474746823310852, -0.055295009166002274, 0.05672886222600937, 0.0026153582148253918, -0.040486302226781845, 0.07289010286331177, -0.024537434801459312, 0.02380918338894844, -0.013303963467478752, 0.07533233612775803, -0.010099723003804684, -0.030194686725735664, -0.019230950623750687, -0.038086969405412674, 0.039880868047475815, 0.00730902049690485, 0.002682029502466321, -0.008059151470661163, -0.02608509175479412, 0.03297725319862366, -0.04705038294196129, 0.011700199916958809, 0.03841879218816757, 0.03894190117716789, 0.055428531020879745, 0.026362119242548943, -0.015189092606306076, -0.02051936835050583, 0.007152073550969362, 0.022626904770731926, -0.04961065948009491, 0.009483305737376213, -0.0756031796336174, 0.033438436686992645, -0.02015741728246212, 0.07662338763475418, -0.01148719061166048, -0.01393349003046751, 0.026867296546697617, 0.014731435105204582, 0.012919727712869644, 0.0034592885058373213, 0.08871214836835861, 0.07306867837905884, 0.06706727296113968, 0.05048227682709694, -0.013897470198571682, 0.014216627925634384, 0.031219465658068657, 0.04057854041457176, -0.061855316162109375, -0.06591809540987015, -0.028410283848643303, -0.03371753543615341, -0.0012335478095337749, -0.0069651673547923565, 0.0001696338295005262, 0.0034282824490219355, 0.014551221393048763, 0.049228738993406296, 0.06256955862045288, 0.07861538231372833, 0.01062836218625307, -0.028152329847216606, -0.05936406925320625, -0.02042160928249359, 0.007729341741651297, -0.029433056712150574, 0.015734493732452393, 0.04407557100057602, 0.057925995439291, -0.011309933848679066, -0.0020345442462712526, -0.05902177840471268, -0.0433172769844532, 0.0032032050658017397, 0.028111223131418228, -0.010213457979261875, 0.08578094840049744, -0.057379916310310364, -0.03186550363898277, 0.022092485800385475, -0.030276445671916008, 0.04850352182984352, 0.013632688671350479, -0.05438024923205376, -0.06338748335838318, -0.05684441328048706, -0.03915819153189659, 0.08171594887971878, -0.03894706070423126, 0.05836574360728264, -0.000386830884963274, 0.04794922471046448, -0.08549762517213821, -0.023887917399406433, -0.07689107209444046, -0.01264480035752058, 0.012557245790958405, -0.00292758597061038, 0.026726186275482178, 0.014124559238553047, -0.06026618927717209, -0.029301555827260017, -0.0455344058573246, 0.06971530616283417, -0.018161622807383537, 0.03168722987174988, -0.03548380732536316, 0.11448771506547928, 0.05334014073014259, 0.12470447272062302, 0.002426343970000744, -0.05687612667679787, -0.022294336929917336, -0.05894610658288002, 0.05901346355676651, -0.006107156630605459, -0.025779681280255318, 0.00015627601533196867, 0.004061923362314701, 0.01900358870625496, -0.09098011255264282, 0.006695871707051992, 0.004688383545726538, -0.009563533589243889, -0.033677566796541214, 0.060834579169750214, 0.06545720249414444, 0.04851413890719414, -0.043582454323768616, 0.004728744737803936, -0.01932452991604805, 0.05435716360807419, -0.011494878679513931, 0.05220038816332817, -0.007979711517691612, 0.04013817757368088, -0.040625736117362976, -0.027008570730686188, 0.050264984369277954, -0.008233620785176754, -0.02827225625514984, 0.07688730210065842, 0.013452818617224693, -0.05133862420916557, 0.07431569695472717, 0.07508184760808945, -0.0026034379843622446, -0.08645603060722351, -0.05386265739798546, 0.005643392913043499, -0.014741547405719757, 0.005586541257798672, -0.04611640051007271, 0.03671173378825188, 0.01493517030030489, 0.0071418266743421555, -0.017668478190898895, -0.040071502327919006, -0.014001384377479553, 0.00028997939079999924, -0.053331322968006134, 0.02560608834028244, 0.026628272607922554, -0.007296665105968714, 0.012099459767341614, -0.0033680691849440336, 0.04021437093615532, -0.036621518433094025, -0.03064531646668911, 0.010491686873137951, 0.04088432341814041, -0.03280895575881004, 0.010898113250732422, -0.09656626731157303, 0.09422944486141205, 0.013366319239139557, -0.04831834137439728, 0.04942518100142479, 0.013656767085194588, -0.03163937106728554, 0.01864112913608551, -0.014634760096669197, 0.014276723377406597, -0.04303924739360809, -0.022793836891651154, 0.046141065657138824, -0.02494199573993683, -0.00793079286813736, 0.08242569118738174, 0.028714152052998543, 0.026619484648108482, -0.005632652435451746, -0.025642434135079384, -0.00586195383220911, -0.00849227700382471, 0.1003386527299881, -0.009681343100965023, -0.006811272352933884, -0.039369672536849976, 0.02790995128452778, -0.07973179221153259, 0.1366274207830429, -0.06400114297866821, -0.008366587571799755, -0.015024222433567047, -0.017364559695124626, 0.047162022441625595, 0.04131324961781502, -0.04949063062667847, -0.11655411869287491, 0.03290650248527527, 0.017285006120800972, -0.0007227074820548296, 0.06130623072385788, 0.08999095857143402, 0.0017358956392854452, 0.07784272730350494, -0.03667587786912918, -0.013007024303078651, 0.00007407243538182229, -0.01399430725723505, 0.06430713087320328, 0.037695642560720444, 0.06284844875335693, 0.013772223144769669, 0.0807698518037796, 0.035959672182798386, 0.004797604866325855, 0.06313229352235794, 0.02787884697318077, -0.012975029647350311, 0.03799635171890259, -0.02333315834403038, 0.03069724328815937, -0.08360306173563004, 0.052114374935626984, -0.03735155239701271, 0.03937598317861557, -0.005633279215544462, 0.003214432392269373, 0.0758114829659462, 0.0038849986158311367, 0.04489500820636749, -0.009640011005103588, 0.050712499767541885, -0.020095979794859886, -0.014483695849776268, 0.07588304579257965, -0.07107662409543991, -0.006333694327622652, 0.02113371714949608, -0.09583090990781784, -0.01823989301919937, -0.02268439531326294, -0.05254300683736801, 0.06160926818847656, 0.03398703783750534, -0.03562011569738388, -0.10442867875099182, 0.0259040966629982, -0.0676308423280716, 0.027900300920009613, 0.052903518080711365, -0.012990038841962814, -0.0005015222122892737, 0.028810253366827965, 0.0009205386741086841, -0.08323131501674652, 0.022941220551729202, -0.014616595581173897, 0.00048403622349724174, -0.03452272713184357, -0.048905495554208755, 0.00813229288905859, 0.012400055304169655, -0.007924378849565983, -0.004647417925298214, 0.06045525148510933, 0.008809591643512249, -0.0012415830278769135, -0.07169192284345627, 0.007053423207253218, 0.03596942126750946, 0.06886949390172958, -0.05031495913863182, -0.032364197075366974, -0.05724182724952698, -0.059950899332761765, -0.05075259134173393, 0.039405278861522675, -0.05254681035876274, -0.007445370312780142, -0.06907253712415695, -0.04593593254685402, 0.04125325754284859, -0.03375381976366043, -0.028387196362018585, -0.02861904911696911, -0.04131088778376579, 0.005196260754019022, 0.014043315313756466, -0.020255064591765404, 0.030038021504878998, 0.035739462822675705, -0.0004954920732416213, -0.05474761128425598, -0.012780663557350636, 0.05032631754875183, -0.0651383101940155, 0.002881246618926525, 0.0013084282400086522, 0.010439528152346611, 0.04800960794091225, -0.02423219569027424, 0.06388393044471741, -0.027231451123952866, -0.012533824890851974, 0.022815236821770668, -0.016575707122683525, 0.03638480603694916, -0.017090560868382454, -0.020173974335193634, -0.007169072981923819, -0.03263086453080177, 0.031025055795907974, 0.0442228764295578, 0.11911029368638992, -0.012425045482814312, -0.0013637937372550368, 0.029082834720611572, 0.028782151639461517, 0.022641349583864212, -0.09223993122577667, -0.0177902989089489, -0.03911478444933891, 0.08423808217048645, 0.09568093717098236, -0.009378536604344845, -0.053788091987371445, 0.0007924452656880021, -0.02704516611993313, 0.06737633794546127, -0.024598119780421257, 0.08518248051404953, 0.0015690027503296733, -0.04641341790556908, -0.055562153458595276, 0.014148718677461147, 0.06122027337551117, -0.016201265156269073, -0.015834691002964973, 0.014191549271345139, -0.020608441904187202, 0.06663265824317932, 0.0009572412818670273, 0.036604177206754684, -0.002744808094576001, 0.014360173605382442, 0.006134034600108862, -0.0032856371253728867, -0.015395654365420341, 0.018596168607473373, -0.025663677603006363, -0.054425161331892014, -0.04479273408651352, 0.060717761516571045, -0.03266678377985954, 0.04636894166469574, 0.01826293021440506, 0.06495615094900131, 0.003330402774736285, 0.018383963033556938, 0.06407719105482101, 0.09574904292821884, 0.0045367153361439705, 0.008869376964867115, -0.015274018049240112, 0.06498434394598007, -0.03621659800410271, 0.06532327085733414 ]
261
261
On Fodor on Darwin on Evolution
Jerry Fodor argues that Darwin was wrong about "natural selection" because (1) it is only a tautology rather than a scientific law that can support counterfactuals ("If X had happened, Y would have happened") and because (2) only minds can select. Hence Darwin's analogy with "artificial selection" by animal breeders was misleading and evolutionary explanation is nothing but post-hoc historical narrative. I argue that Darwin was right on all counts.
[ -0.015247466042637825, 0.07410276681184769, 0.11571642011404037, -0.02153368853032589, -0.010251088999211788, 0.002704763086512685, 0.05463840812444687, 0.02979351207613945, 0.025413677096366882, 0.08542308211326599, 0.03378733992576599, 0.0180729478597641, -0.030603637918829918, -0.030920159071683884, -0.046831198036670685, 0.0010730673093348742, -0.07755029201507568, -0.043789077550172806, 0.02714482881128788, -0.01178780384361744, -0.03401386737823486, 0.06856369972229004, 0.028002357110381126, 0.025673123076558113, -0.009223029017448425, 0.03424491733312607, 0.002393592381849885, 0.04124845191836357, -0.023535996675491333, -0.07299354672431946, -0.06883281469345093, 0.0471835732460022, 0.024705670773983, -0.0423244871199131, 0.023396708071231842, 0.029429854825139046, -0.0488155372440815, -0.004484068602323532, -0.004928767681121826, -0.08749311417341232, 0.07125693559646606, -0.054152537137269974, -0.06015666946768761, -0.03571871668100357, -0.03970259428024292, 0.0074675558134913445, 0.053477417677640915, 0.047633521258831024, -0.0029582271818071604, 0.08499480783939362, -0.04988214001059532, 0.045185744762420654, -0.0069123730063438416, 0.040483489632606506, -0.0921931341290474, 0.0020492186304181814, 0.0045305341482162476, -0.0043309093452990055, 0.008078332059085369, 0.04030944034457207, 0.024254994466900826, 0.07816122472286224, 0.010021934285759926, -0.0599144846200943, -0.003000653116032481, 0.007219147868454456, -0.013062122277915478, -0.043789565563201904, 0.07423067837953568, -0.03906207159161568, 0.030913572758436203, -0.016170579940080643, -0.040379688143730164, -0.03506606072187424, 0.02849685586988926, -0.000057086479500867426, -0.040985655039548874, 0.1197604238986969, -0.03832601383328438, -0.009992938488721848, -0.11683237552642822, 0.04503841698169708, 0.05291116610169411, 0.07070349156856537, 0.043187953531742096, -0.00597162963822484, 0.027267375960946083, -0.007240111008286476, -0.04951951652765274, -0.035681337118148804, 0.031653452664613724, 0.006142127327620983, -0.003985910676419735, -0.007615216542035341, -0.034877046942710876, 0.03405512869358063, 0.011235741898417473, -0.08205817639827728, 0.02206861600279808, 0.032229091972112656, -0.013051614165306091, -0.020318355411291122, 0.05512751266360283, 0.029033733531832695, -0.02469981648027897, -0.06014673039317131, 0.03937111422419548, 0.05506519228219986, 0.024773603305220604, 0.04061669111251831, -0.05386563017964363, 0.019530629739165306, 0.060770705342292786, -0.020853346213698387, -0.03936745598912239, 0.047350190579891205, -0.04833807051181793, 0.05523133650422096, 0.016388261690735817, -0.05230597034096718, -0.025553278625011444, -0.011467136442661285, -0.024370957165956497, 0.06118568032979965, 0.0447576530277729, -0.0780951976776123, 0.034236691892147064, -0.03240300714969635, 0.03288847953081131, -0.012412676587700844, -0.020095741376280785, -0.001665051095187664, -0.04686957597732544, -0.010496106930077076, -0.01343334186822176, 0.02249567024409771, 0.006167941726744175, 0.022063087671995163, 0.01642013154923916, -0.007033339701592922, -0.0016360225854441524, -0.04058288782835007, -0.04113694280385971, 0.01394013874232769, 0.004231081809848547, 0.0701189860701561, -0.045516978949308395, -0.07101021707057953, -0.020660772919654846, -0.02385074645280838, -0.014078824780881405, -0.08652379363775253, 0.00773012638092041, 0.07230528444051743, -0.008220615796744823, -0.037312544882297516, -0.05350229889154434, 0.0031145212706178427, -0.044273294508457184, 0.004041279666125774, 0.0070439656265079975, 0.0157385915517807, 0.004830347374081612, 0.05391246825456619, 0.05162934958934784, 0.09720958769321442, -0.0349789597094059, -0.018468985334038734, -0.003926395438611507, -0.09748813509941101, 0.02504625916481018, 0.030248984694480896, 0.04309060797095299, -0.078245609998703, 0.003613939043134451, 0.04774165526032448, 0.0033541806042194366, 0.0578402616083622, -0.018801605328917503, 0.03644074872136116, -0.0013275528326630592, -0.02565791830420494, -0.03193887323141098, -0.059012848883867264, 0.06257767975330353, 0.13680966198444366, -0.03548244386911392, 0.09129177778959274, 0.04836331680417061, 0.04085402935743332, 0.0025073334109038115, 0.01914861612021923, -0.10060294717550278, -0.04284399002790451, 0.00816236063838005, -0.05850505456328392, 0.0008329727570526302, -0.0182794239372015, -0.022364281117916107, -0.015916649252176285, 0.011907140724360943, 0.04950407147407532, -0.004609765950590372, 0.009273437783122063, 0.02617938071489334, 0.010076490230858326, 0.12557895481586456, -0.04761546850204468, 0.030628519132733345, -0.12246016412973404, -0.02040325291454792, 0.01034552976489067, -0.045852936804294586, 0.0448484905064106, 0.06780634075403214, 0.0070091672241687775, -0.01564943976700306, -0.045111045241355896, 0.08569252490997314, -0.00688090780749917, -0.016924060881137848, -0.0006008461350575089, -0.032157789915800095, 0.07758411765098572, 0.0008367534610442817, -0.06037458777427673, 0.017574241384863853, -0.0503641813993454, -0.016107717528939247, 0.07873653620481491, -0.11868076771497726, -0.0874871015548706, -0.05283547192811966, 0.01278690155595541, -0.04657752811908722, -0.026555364951491356, 0.024449558928608894, 0.004026888869702816, 0.009977379813790321, -0.02986697293817997, -0.012206648476421833, 0.00699253985658288, -0.04040566459298134, -0.011222000233829021, -0.05172545090317726, -0.0086450707167387, 0.02229851484298706, -0.024712318554520607, 0.03335500881075859, -0.021384187042713165, 0.0002980652207043022, -0.040052615106105804, -0.048587314784526825, 0.03938530012965202, 0.027186429128050804, -0.01400246936827898, -0.04574048891663551, -0.031451329588890076, 0.04987236112356186, 0.008295071311295033, 0.060857340693473816, 0.07183241844177246, 0.0015798838576301932, 0.07721175998449326, -0.010054294019937515, 0.052992772310972214, -0.032273516058921814, -0.05403647571802139, -0.07096533477306366, -0.016062531620264053, 0.0029771560803055763, -0.034358393400907516, -0.09155970066785812, 0.08558179438114166, -0.05469435825943947, -0.011903521604835987, 0.024844501167535782, 0.08022913336753845, -0.008604902774095535, -0.022627152502536774, -0.007035896182060242, 0.02221439592540264, 0.013018349185585976, 0.01966203935444355, -0.017133790999650955, -0.062413521111011505, -0.05982329696416855, 0.013066411018371582, -0.02208111435174942, 0.004032193683087826, 0.0018667898839339614, -0.10359542816877365, -0.034007731825113297, -0.026398852467536926, 0.025056757032871246, -0.010476764291524887, -0.023308582603931427, -0.057779040187597275, 0.09582889825105667, 0.030670592561364174, 0.032040901482105255, 0.0762445256114006, 0.03554302826523781, 0.027767058461904526, 0.06719385832548141, -0.000979821546934545, -0.029703913256525993, -0.03623710572719574, 0.05196074768900871, 0.009390375576913357, 0.0065089561976492405, -0.07182931900024414, 0.06323836743831635, 0.01067264098674059, -0.02429916523396969, -0.029480120167136192, 0.0005464084097184241, 0.020960180088877678, 0.02902359329164028, -0.004627571906894445, 0.012460920959711075, -0.051933515816926956, -0.019602788612246513, 0.026653578504920006, 0.005200947634875774, -0.05045798793435097, -0.038682498037815094, 0.02709580399096012, -0.08382754772901535, 0.022029751911759377, 0.03909332677721977, 0.007630095351487398, -0.020332785323262215, 0.06150698661804199, -0.07488022744655609, 0.03192785754799843, -0.05006527900695801, 0.009805997833609581, 0.03516748547554016, 0.04141831770539284, -0.01980375498533249, -0.026716604828834534, -0.021431749686598778, 0.08098039776086807, 0.05001717805862427, -0.045985300093889236, 0.025972407311201096, 0.02316562831401825, -0.002399156568571925, 0.026177702471613884, -0.01227197702974081, -0.033231236040592194, 0.026104316115379333, 0.026252828538417816, -0.03228539228439331, 0.04875488206744194, -0.02899356000125408, 0.004130796995013952, -0.008196712471544743, 0.031943198293447495, 0.008637824095785618, 0.04373058304190636, 0.060694362968206406, -0.013444053940474987, 0.04404862970113754, 0.05486804619431496, 0.016507292166352272, 0.0023324049543589354, -0.03501152619719505, -0.007940559647977352, 0.027654826641082764, 0.020440245047211647, 0.011706529185175896, -0.0021522934548556805, 0.003374530468136072, -0.04364744573831558, -0.033635493367910385, -0.07626782357692719, -0.11227095127105713, 0.09201466292142868, -0.04867430776357651, 0.007249667774885893, -0.04132642596960068, 0.030390942469239235, -0.0337841622531414, 0.00718792574480176, -0.03883602097630501, 0.0024974243715405464, 0.05168496072292328, -0.020557759329676628, 0.04867851734161377, 0.002458702540025115, -0.015125671401619911, 0.07603327184915543, 0.06547149270772934, -0.0006428047199733555, 0.015440688468515873, -0.0958680510520935, -0.030318770557641983, 0.014401891268789768, 0.006770068313926458, -0.04929891973733902, 0.04494117572903633, -0.028024066239595413, -0.03689365088939667, 0.0372237004339695, 0.006386642809957266, -0.029125120490789413, 0.05485944449901581, 0.010071022436022758, 0.04582974314689636, 0.06236083433032036, 0.023349255323410034, 0.03554537147283554, 0.0030892351642251015, 0.04298814758658409, 0.016912680119276047, 0.01505617517977953, -0.0067027476616203785, -0.008790138177573681, -0.001312430016696453, 0.0005664133350364864, -0.023548616096377373, -0.052323535084724426, 0.022709138691425323, -0.010183305479586124, 0.12717074155807495, 0.08226469904184341, 0.050772931426763535, 0.030001329258084297, 0.0150159802287817, -0.05292649567127228, -0.0716170147061348, -0.01850961335003376, -0.006914690136909485, 0.008481666445732117, -0.01634368486702442, 0.03678184375166893, 0.030076799914240837, -0.042084597051143646, 0.007698920089751482, 0.08788126707077026, -0.008544922806322575, 0.05611240118741989, -0.0024637130554765463, 0.060967426747083664, -0.08360615372657776, -0.0779450312256813, -0.00018862829892896116, 0.012205550447106361, 0.01480154786258936, -0.03632509335875511, -0.0350877046585083, -0.042098987847566605, 0.06299705058336258, 0.05080898106098175, -0.0002425082930130884, 0.044681891798973083, 0.0011933990754187107, 0.004466262646019459, 0.07047382742166519, -0.059028394520282745, 0.038515131920576096, -0.020569102838635445, -0.07368869334459305, 0.001231592264957726, 0.03714510053396225, -0.10989841818809509, 0.09142228215932846, 0.008600189350545406, 0.009044217877089977, -0.04770255833864212, -0.01593821682035923, 0.02591177262365818, -0.05723177269101143, -0.01686011627316475, 0.02994307316839695, -0.04432407021522522, 0.002556807594373822, -0.10655465722084045, 0.02293425239622593, -0.026159897446632385, 0.0059234159998595715, -0.055935606360435486, 0.008173052221536636, 0.04123267903923988, -0.054014649242162704, -0.046343691647052765, 0.06977783143520355, 0.042618729174137115, 0.061226267367601395, -0.03819795697927475, 0.04721589386463165, 0.026160262525081635, -0.01024267915636301, 0.07861267030239105, 0.04488865286111832, -0.0333343967795372, 0.014737232588231564, 0.020270710811018944, 0.007440423127263784, -0.009476050734519958, -0.01396983489394188, -0.06769926100969315, 0.05920452997088432, -0.0338967964053154, 0.03882100433111191, 0.005361718591302633, 0.023815255612134933, -0.008403959684073925, 0.0321434885263443, -0.018368899822235107 ]
262
262
Boosting through Optimization of Margin Distributions
Boosting has attracted much research attention in the past decade. The success of boosting algorithms may be interpreted in terms of the margin theory. Recently it has been shown that generalization error of classifiers can be obtained by explicitly taking the margin distribution of the training data into account. Most of the current boosting algorithms in practice usually optimizes a convex loss function and do not make use of the margin distribution. In this work we design a new boosting algorithm, termed margin-distribution boosting (MDBoost), which directly maximizes the average margin and minimizes the margin variance simultaneously. This way the margin distribution is optimized. A totally-corrective optimization algorithm based on column generation is proposed to implement MDBoost. Experiments on UCI datasets show that MDBoost outperforms AdaBoost and LPBoost in most cases.
[ -0.0744670033454895, -0.0954311192035675, 0.006746694445610046, -0.017913036048412323, 0.04094940051436424, -0.008381693623960018, 0.02251322939991951, -0.021069830283522606, -0.02351631410419941, 0.010158377699553967, -0.02964995615184307, -0.0690700113773346, -0.04459669068455696, 0.01790526881814003, -0.002053411677479744, 0.022165145725011826, -0.005637618713080883, -0.015339014120399952, 0.04070507362484932, -0.04107926785945892, 0.016614755615592003, -0.02864213101565838, 0.011202716268599033, -0.05584190413355827, -0.013315572403371334, 0.059327952563762665, 0.050273794680833817, -0.005897918250411749, -0.00931964349001646, 0.04587902873754501, -0.004141780082136393, -0.013319989666342735, -0.001351422630250454, 0.01584458537399769, -0.027934929355978966, 0.01750621572136879, 0.011610970832407475, -0.033367570489645004, -0.05863076448440552, 0.02153230458498001, -0.01305121835321188, -0.025125019252300262, -0.008163022808730602, -0.039099592715501785, 0.08239857852458954, 0.0715121254324913, 0.07768132537603378, 0.0020534531213343143, -0.0678258165717125, 0.047796692699193954, 0.013888794928789139, 0.008593380451202393, -0.017842184752225876, -0.036135636270046234, 0.04735076054930687, -0.05308728292584419, -0.02283010631799698, 0.03262358531355858, 0.013185118325054646, -0.061211202293634415, 0.04774460196495056, 0.12700413167476654, -0.03719833120703697, -0.058619752526283264, -0.0571867860853672, -0.01314549334347248, -0.06112745404243469, -0.02654079720377922, -0.020299037918448448, -0.047605451196432114, -0.0009054667898453772, -0.07982812076807022, 0.012644772417843342, 0.14297719299793243, 0.020413406193256378, 0.02771761827170849, -0.042952992022037506, 0.015120044350624084, 0.08134420216083527, 0.019777433946728706, -0.0196668840944767, 0.036041561514139175, -0.02747225947678089, 0.03052784502506256, -0.014227022416889668, -0.05249537155032158, -0.010821571573615074, -0.04863378405570984, 0.04766297712922096, -0.046845678240060806, 0.0725783258676529, -0.0036887661553919315, -0.04095804691314697, 0.056490663439035416, -0.06104423478245735, 0.016087215393781662, -0.031024491414427757, -0.0022137369960546494, 0.016994457691907883, 0.005859177093952894, -0.0172735545784235, -0.007798830047249794, 0.08702770620584488, 0.012115043587982655, -0.02015060745179653, -0.015268130227923393, -0.061931535601615906, 0.043804313987493515, 0.016346439719200134, -0.009059346280992031, 0.027465689927339554, -0.062137141823768616, -0.020388871431350708, -0.019528167322278023, 0.0005100016132928431, -0.014710965566337109, 0.002082770224660635, -0.020030664280056953, 0.0772269070148468, -0.03403269872069359, -0.0050109135918319225, -0.01648535020649433, 0.025821030139923096, 0.05712275579571724, -0.024810563772916794, -0.017542704939842224, 0.0007020084885880351, -0.10473795980215073, 0.08729498833417892, -0.05231662467122078, -0.06014779210090637, 0.1155262440443039, -0.022724295035004616, 0.013416186906397343, -0.031038323417305946, 0.05314083769917488, 0.018621759489178658, -0.03638676926493645, 0.0005733687430620193, 0.10574691742658615, -0.031948041170835495, 0.013720705173909664, 0.03262277692556381, 0.06631622463464737, 0.0474032461643219, 0.027742436155676842, 0.013905955478549004, 0.05494912713766098, -0.0073324148543179035, 0.04953734949231148, -0.03157668933272362, -0.030204009264707565, 0.03365204483270645, 0.059253793209791183, 0.026626067236065865, 0.0012999807950109243, 0.01531234197318554, -0.04311588034033775, -0.04325620085000992, -0.06667166948318481, -0.12100156396627426, 0.018069669604301453, 0.022974682971835136, -0.03675958886742592, -0.030192550271749496, 0.0000929490925045684, 0.004114039242267609, -0.06280620396137238, -0.02399984747171402, -0.07088147848844528, -0.030069155618548393, -0.001818785211071372, -0.06997537612915039, 0.07491227239370346, -0.03866155818104744, -0.04073440283536911, 0.011661655269563198, -0.002469864673912525, 0.035659801214933395, -0.007895415648818016, 0.014421804808080196, 0.02212468534708023, -0.03422736003994942, 0.0074602290987968445, -0.014840991236269474, 0.09102517366409302, -0.05765433609485626, 0.04167085513472557, 0.08159421384334564, 0.0903586894273758, 0.1006220132112503, -0.014731284230947495, -0.02095196023583412, 0.0518200621008873, -0.06438842415809631, 0.12201350927352905, -0.07331953197717667, 0.020721428096294403, 0.03444501757621765, 0.05531903728842735, 0.005150253884494305, -0.00147490412928164, -0.031550224870443344, -0.0446760430932045, -0.052770745009183884, 0.048005759716033936, 0.08336086571216583, -0.08522805571556091, 0.03259100019931793, -0.03991616517305374, -0.012318571098148823, 0.0015103324549272656, 0.033895619213581085, -0.0004058342310599983, 0.024708371609449387, 0.004689385648816824, -0.06961888074874878, -0.010431929491460323, 0.10706083476543427, 0.0180224422365427, 0.011540845967829227, 0.0012394319055601954, -0.03670046851038933, 0.021477462723851204, -0.06441814452409744, 0.0059126392006874084, -0.015243873000144958, 0.020979372784495354, -0.08472280949354172, 0.05239881947636604, 0.016783246770501137, -0.0721130520105362, 0.023810263723134995, -0.05161166191101074, -0.011710075661540031, 0.03298052400350571, 0.0017049185698851943, -0.02945381961762905, 0.019773896783590317, -0.03169636428356171, 0.01898953504860401, -0.025556253269314766, -0.04782866686582565, -0.01683671772480011, -0.012790749780833721, 0.008056379854679108, 0.00926057156175375, 0.0740760862827301, -0.02201991342008114, 0.02712361514568329, 0.061301350593566895, 0.03405756503343582, 0.03139099106192589, -0.011498632840812206, -0.05330531671643257, -0.031065212562680244, -0.004237227141857147, 0.035919882357120514, 0.0293816477060318, 0.09910006076097488, 0.024809151887893677, 0.02642185240983963, -0.034617893397808075, 0.02622639760375023, 0.07472357898950577, 0.020866822451353073, -0.013813117519021034, 0.007135304156690836, 0.01439556386321783, 0.04664841666817665, -0.08877142518758774, -0.05287572741508484, -0.010943569242954254, 0.0344339981675148, -0.062439072877168655, 0.02787547931075096, 0.026036225259304047, 0.01868143305182457, 0.06109483540058136, -0.03735768422484398, -0.043329279869794846, 0.01809958927333355, -0.028971008956432343, 0.037627145648002625, 0.027345294132828712, 0.011430139653384686, -0.04752510040998459, 0.003222655039280653, -0.019482111558318138, 0.03314857557415962, -0.019871501252055168, 0.008099720813333988, 0.003292651381343603, 0.010359118692576885, 0.021763576194643974, -0.027487585321068764, 0.04258008673787117, 0.022797588258981705, 0.03290499746799469, -0.016758965328335762, 0.029799828305840492, -0.011644274927675724, 0.064736507833004, 0.02585834264755249, -0.023407435044646263, 0.06391522288322449, 0.008504333905875683, 0.028251972049474716, -0.08704237639904022, 0.0071404846385121346, 0.0106321657076478, -0.034936923533678055, 0.0066345613449811935, -0.08437822759151459, 0.023026589304208755, 0.020648585632443428, -0.05342770367860794, 0.016610050573945045, 0.07018253952264786, -0.053296592086553574, 0.024869762361049652, 0.06647949665784836, 0.021320678293704987, 0.023809077218174934, -0.08426712453365326, -0.0518902912735939, -0.028440723195672035, 0.012616674415767193, -0.07190056145191193, -0.024339793249964714, -0.07227534800767899, -0.008735360577702522, -0.061438385397195816, 0.06120583042502403, -0.04204303026199341, 0.008522851392626762, -0.06305591017007828, -0.0019030389375984669, 0.01412974949926138, -0.04996516928076744, -0.0033029592595994473, -0.040125586092472076, -0.02305235154926777, 0.0339321605861187, -0.03325013816356659, 0.030228866264224052, 0.03251580148935318, 0.02895684726536274, -0.027773477137088776, 0.018348155543208122, -0.07309838384389877, 0.02925301343202591, -0.10418335348367691, 0.0563543364405632, 0.001754661789163947, -0.016110561788082123, 0.07857339829206467, 0.040643393993377686, 0.06261734664440155, -0.0026770448312163353, -0.02456364966928959, 0.046322163194417953, -0.022250518202781677, -0.058760788291692734, 0.03940003737807274, 0.06528937071561813, 0.013027493841946125, 0.007069814950227737, -0.042431723326444626, 0.0204282496124506, -0.014336996711790562, 0.08052525669336319, -0.04423210769891739, -0.02556466870009899, 0.07767883688211441, 0.0018390653422102332, 0.09705286473035812, 0.055737245827913284, -0.06179267540574074, 0.02707168273627758, 0.007234983146190643, -0.04188625141978264, -0.02689860574901104, 0.007146667223423719, -0.0849001407623291, -0.06191100925207138, -0.06412604451179504, -0.023341557011008263, 0.07367756217718124, 0.0447390042245388, 0.015760481357574463, -0.09805317223072052, 0.007778512313961983, 0.04352955147624016, 0.0555850975215435, 0.002607903443276882, 0.024017559364438057, -0.04585951194167137, -0.07088545709848404, -0.062221989035606384, 0.039026618003845215, 0.019026203081011772, -0.018695667386054993, -0.07955771684646606, -0.07393106073141098, 0.03626708686351776, -0.0178060382604599, 0.04318983852863312, 0.013750425539910793, 0.01660292223095894, 0.004924941807985306, 0.03404751047492027, -0.06865867972373962, 0.009057968854904175, 0.021314112469553947, 0.0307915098965168, -0.005294190254062414, -0.03430427983403206, 0.002757776528596878, -0.06143181398510933, 0.04801071807742119, -0.0064377752132713795, 0.019942251965403557, 0.0008141552098095417, 0.06767269223928452, 0.04075127840042114, 0.09193108230829239, 0.112773597240448, 0.005785049870610237, 0.05419699475169182, -0.0564180351793766, -0.00872344896197319, -0.05082504078745842, -0.02971912920475006, 0.051528144627809525, -0.02618938498198986, 0.07873903214931488, 0.018794532865285873, -0.0028001461178064346, 0.00786793977022171, -0.032592497766017914, 0.037245478481054306, -0.032952357083559036, -0.007960030809044838, -0.03873065486550331, 0.11202231794595718, 0.04229530319571495, 0.08376012742519379, 0.05208570510149002, 0.00926351360976696, 0.017948182299733162, 0.036489441990852356, 0.005116069223731756, -0.026365580037236214, -0.0556466244161129, -0.0006190647836774588, -0.08891504257917404, 0.013037784956395626, 0.003891977248713374, -0.021944966167211533, -0.015060605481266975, -0.009611041285097599, -0.039129409939050674, -0.0012874045642092824, -0.001266686012968421, -0.0007287386688403785, -0.025124551728367805, 0.013902991078794003, 0.07627759873867035, -0.01790904439985752, -0.06653309613466263, 0.016804397106170654, 0.00625972542911768, -0.06114795804023743, -0.020777476951479912, 0.021420912817120552, -0.05508899688720703, -0.08121935278177261, -0.0042920163832604885, -0.03222592920064926, -0.025286026298999786, -0.01459463406354189, 0.033755287528038025, 0.03774084895849228, -0.015164343640208244, -0.003243443090468645, -0.00023438491916749626, 0.010818985290825367, 0.05752885714173317, 0.04415609687566757, -0.006316918879747391, 0.06368183344602585, 0.029820209369063377, 0.03695232793688774, -0.015547327697277069, 0.01840410940349102, 0.03575289249420166, -0.035103585571050644, -0.015539362095296383, 0.06186753511428833, 0.03405565395951271, -0.07223635166883469, 0.054040029644966125, -0.012233199551701546, 0.03973895683884621, 0.019531726837158203, 0.031539592891931534, -0.01810586452484131, 0.021372130140662193, 0.06473204493522644, -0.03213877230882645, -0.05995142459869385 ]
263
263
Inferring Dynamic Bayesian Networks using Frequent Episode Mining
Motivation: Several different threads of research have been proposed for modeling and mining temporal data. On the one hand, approaches such as dynamic Bayesian networks (DBNs) provide a formal probabilistic basis to model relationships between time-indexed random variables but these models are intractable to learn in the general case. On the other, algorithms such as frequent episode mining are scalable to large datasets but do not exhibit the rigorous probabilistic interpretations that are the mainstay of the graphical models literature. Results: We present a unification of these two seemingly diverse threads of research, by demonstrating how dynamic (discrete) Bayesian networks can be inferred from the results of frequent episode mining. This helps bridge the modeling emphasis of the former with the counting emphasis of the latter. First, we show how, under reasonable assumptions on data characteristics and on influences of random variables, the optimal DBN structure can be computed using a greedy, local, algorithm. Next, we connect the optimality of the DBN structure with the notion of fixed-delay episodes and their counts of distinct occurrences. Finally, to demonstrate the practical feasibility of our approach, we focus on a specific (but broadly applicable) class of networks, called excitatory networks, and show how the search for the optimal DBN structure can be conducted using just information from frequent episodes. Application on datasets gathered from mathematical models of spiking neurons as well as real neuroscience datasets are presented. Availability: Algorithmic implementations, simulator codebases, and datasets are available from our website at http://neural-code.cs.vt.edu/dbn
[ -0.05633211508393288, -0.027332590892910957, 0.016516080126166344, -0.0021401788108050823, 0.0795903205871582, -0.10120903700590134, 0.010846578516066074, -0.03529024124145508, -0.011278786696493626, 0.0067695328034460545, -0.03980998694896698, -0.08296752721071243, -0.05323476344347, -0.00961463712155819, 0.04813697934150696, -0.032502710819244385, -0.01909012906253338, -0.04430351406335831, 0.03102392517030239, -0.07384687662124634, -0.02707142010331154, 0.003547452390193939, -0.004463613033294678, -0.023809688165783882, -0.0637274831533432, -0.017071209847927094, 0.00460773753002286, -0.02520408108830452, 0.10445293039083481, -0.041813213378190994, -0.030256178230047226, -0.0005812259623780847, -0.0016524423845112324, -0.041014932096004486, 0.047354862093925476, -0.03688744083046913, -0.023471271619200706, -0.07310675829648972, -0.04597783833742142, -0.018914952874183655, 0.00941439438611269, -0.011352584697306156, 0.010026007890701294, -0.04721129685640335, 0.09376015514135361, 0.09224960952997208, 0.0736701637506485, 0.022552764043211937, 0.058562275022268295, 0.09499629586935043, -0.12211991101503372, -0.004259017761796713, -0.03807511553168297, 0.013887316919863224, -0.08910413086414337, 0.06457672268152237, 0.0015388710889965296, -0.02786666713654995, -0.0626671090722084, -0.017828797921538353, -0.04279706999659538, 0.02406260184943676, -0.043946072459220886, 0.034664351493120193, -0.03328661993145943, 0.05319926142692566, 0.02431114763021469, -0.03440112993121147, -0.050359223037958145, 0.022488456219434738, 0.03215750306844711, -0.10969395190477371, -0.02353963814675808, -0.03680633381009102, -0.03224356845021248, -0.011410998180508614, -0.04731127992272377, 0.01010854821652174, 0.03061230666935444, 0.0902513787150383, -0.09928324818611145, 0.01808089204132557, 0.01152699813246727, 0.021039092913269997, -0.011287585832178593, -0.026685314252972603, 0.045631151646375656, 0.028715889900922775, -0.06019197031855583, -0.03171825036406517, -0.028384258970618248, 0.03591993451118469, -0.09221302717924118, -0.0010135762859135866, -0.0766640156507492, 0.09980040043592453, -0.010391484014689922, 0.0165193360298872, -0.014295710250735283, -0.01198327261954546, 0.032295841723680496, -0.03972558677196503, 0.017584307119250298, 0.08018603920936584, -0.03841947764158249, -0.0064704869873821735, 0.00510345259681344, 0.010321445763111115, 0.015066049061715603, -0.03120599500834942, 0.029257284477353096, 0.011527445167303085, -0.014866350218653679, 0.06411973387002945, -0.046466339379549026, 0.0271441787481308, 0.03274910897016525, 0.04211777448654175, 0.0006897120620124042, 0.05197847634553909, 0.05727488175034523, -0.02754061669111252, 0.011599761433899403, 0.028141940012574196, 0.017936650663614273, -0.11146051436662674, -0.013329705223441124, 0.03357978165149689, 0.08420457690954208, -0.021579792723059654, -0.05277572572231293, 0.0041348934173583984, 0.00661061704158783, -0.013855366967618465, -0.0438641719520092, 0.023516856133937836, 0.00014030025340616703, -0.048386938869953156, 0.005231962539255619, -0.00040573926526121795, 0.012981412000954151, 0.003461934393271804, -0.048500869423151016, -0.030614152550697327, 0.013573556207120419, 0.04913565143942833, 0.04011930897831917, 0.022519145160913467, 0.004677273333072662, 0.005536600016057491, -0.06147942692041397, -0.1281026154756546, 0.01914799213409424, 0.049640171229839325, 0.0021826885640621185, -0.019949767738580704, -0.08674595504999161, 0.014065919443964958, -0.02546541392803192, 0.05800705775618553, -0.03720865026116371, 0.013751035556197166, 0.08143948018550873, 0.016985902562737465, -0.0013731281505897641, 0.0023173578083515167, -0.05179648846387863, 0.09289867430925369, -0.0032712251413613558, -0.058795906603336334, -0.06435244530439377, -0.010304057039320469, 0.005438394844532013, 0.011793338693678379, 0.004850011318922043, 0.00436902791261673, -0.023516284301877022, 0.004966903477907181, 0.005302376113831997, 0.007029677275568247, 0.04187695309519768, -0.03467497602105141, -0.009905647486448288, 0.03612936660647392, 0.08843918889760971, 0.06509196013212204, -0.05131454020738602, 0.09804484993219376, 0.02858511544764042, -0.06162600591778755, 0.003628791542723775, 0.011980397626757622, 0.025564413517713547, -0.032541483640670776, 0.012417979538440704, -0.0014598056441172957, -0.0036639997269958258, -0.0059237792156636715, 0.007114915642887354, 0.04464773088693619, -0.022938724607229233, 0.012410742230713367, -0.07418376207351685, 0.03639787808060646, -0.005985886789858341, -0.030424820259213448, 0.015924794599413872, -0.026634572073817253, -0.04874034598469734, 0.012026920914649963, 0.05392555519938469, 0.04776615649461746, -0.04670167714357376, 0.02323518507182598, 0.08612462878227234, -0.0029552974738180637, -0.019326020032167435, -0.06911046802997589, 0.09707766771316528, 0.054012853652238846, -0.010158154182136059, 0.039695773273706436, -0.10701890289783478, 0.06903593242168427, -0.06728268414735794, -0.010357952676713467, 0.002340385690331459, -0.010815178044140339, -0.04879400134086609, 0.05112079903483391, -0.03293267637491226, -0.045967284590005875, -0.023316187784075737, -0.024727661162614822, -0.03735998272895813, 0.08833394199609756, 0.006403622683137655, 0.001592352637089789, -0.0037269038148224354, 0.008288757875561714, -0.05960511788725853, 0.029092678800225258, 0.02907394804060459, 0.0011783326044678688, 0.010294775478541851, -0.008792828768491745, -0.006690157111734152, 0.03629498556256294, -0.01927361451089382, 0.06045559421181679, 0.034589335322380066, 0.02176547795534134, -0.014797845855355263, 0.045704662799835205, 0.0019098659977316856, -0.009274777956306934, -0.05515258386731148, 0.06331072747707367, 0.03221955522894859, 0.006708137225359678, 0.052906960248947144, 0.006384415552020073, -0.07242127507925034, 0.07755187153816223, 0.060417402535676956, -0.03161168098449707, -0.013164711184799671, 0.011481636203825474, -0.025031719356775284, -0.09269414097070694, 0.07533873617649078, -0.005371530074626207, -0.028355566784739494, 0.06768318265676498, 0.00013141932140570134, -0.06356699019670486, 0.06942401081323624, 0.029270244762301445, -0.014210689812898636, -0.05696554854512215, -0.04432084783911705, 0.023969773203134537, -0.01236880011856556, 0.002056266414001584, -0.0510055273771286, -0.013052725233137608, -0.025210175663232803, 0.043615564703941345, -0.014593644998967648, 0.009950733743607998, -0.051577068865299225, -0.07205066084861755, -0.12653611600399017, -0.028791481629014015, 0.03389221802353859, -0.039197564125061035, 0.07919175177812576, -0.05706311762332916, 0.0354456789791584, -0.05714236572384834, -0.0015539012383669615, 0.03630897030234337, 0.10643956810235977, -0.0005012803012505174, 0.012821498326957226, 0.01514334324747324, 0.012247659265995026, 0.12051519751548767, 0.003349181730300188, 0.051622286438941956, -0.021839579567313194, -0.009229861199855804, -0.02653306908905506, 0.0405411459505558, 0.005307960789650679, 0.0007834822172299027, 0.019084112718701363, -0.02578432485461235, 0.010361897759139538, 0.062389932572841644, 0.008698503486812115, 0.04321794956922531, -0.013840429484844208, -0.03403691574931145, -0.02336754836142063, -0.002213955158367753, 0.003351179650053382, 0.049860723316669464, -0.006150918081402779, 0.007662946358323097, -0.007816201075911522, -0.036911867558956146, -0.03083328902721405, 0.08690837770700455, -0.03361651301383972, 0.013324934057891369, -0.035592131316661835, -0.010233700275421143, 0.0200672410428524, 0.009904485195875168, -0.03627030551433563, 0.006631760857999325, -0.06695353239774704, -0.03515993431210518, 0.05412282794713974, 0.12093997001647949, 0.06470265984535217, 0.01995103619992733, 0.08689887076616287, 0.06462304294109344, -0.04894328862428665, 0.018943199887871742, 0.08515112847089767, 0.06019700691103935, -0.10128295421600342, 0.00011324445949867368, 0.0349920280277729, 0.03023662231862545, 0.013744172640144825, 0.02926628850400448, -0.03817025572061539, 0.019997702911496162, -0.0134073281660676, -0.04606775939464569, -0.03235901519656181, 0.014080386608839035, -0.01640285737812519, -0.0082025658339262, -0.045575983822345734, -0.033746033906936646, 0.05018126219511032, -0.013066642917692661, 0.047829654067754745, 0.022615710273385048, 0.029344459995627403, -0.004483642987906933, -0.0012020908761769533, -0.04428962618112564, -0.06371202319860458, 0.04676540940999985, -0.02901069074869156, 0.01324483659118414, -0.01721687614917755, -0.04904551059007645, -0.032523125410079956, 0.023902691900730133, 0.0034381418954581022, -0.013246101327240467, 0.030629249289631844, 0.030720729380846024, -0.042422328144311905, -0.059325944632291794, 0.02369348146021366, -0.03308664634823799, 0.09242769330739975, -0.0056642587296664715, 0.03776750713586807, 0.04847694933414459, 0.009287355467677116, 0.04525258019566536, -0.04037339985370636, -0.04050284996628761, -0.08253902941942215, -0.0027606086805462837, -0.005191415082663298, -0.03972279280424118, 0.04662393033504486, 0.002473148051649332, 0.04911237955093384, 0.006487416569143534, 0.054054614156484604, 0.05230870470404625, -0.04736800491809845, -0.006319989450275898, -0.07694555073976517, -0.008347546681761742, 0.004537748172879219, 0.029152192175388336, 0.01308133639395237, 0.011933439411222935, -0.05949903652071953, 0.009955055080354214, 0.010571178048849106, 0.015341535210609436, -0.009891210123896599, -0.02076984941959381, 0.08930099755525589, 0.09133952856063843, -0.006334490142762661, 0.0176446083933115, -0.05324298515915871, -0.0714895948767662, -0.024458779022097588, -0.0063746473751962185, -0.019951028749346733, 0.0540379174053669, 0.022613782435655594, -0.010443814098834991, -0.037565238773822784, 0.011117192916572094, -0.0008983571897260845, -0.04123000428080559, 0.08428032696247101, -0.015839098021388054, -0.016158360987901688, 0.04984993115067482, -0.0030912677757441998, 0.008174204267561436, 0.07744899392127991, -0.0036407799925655127, 0.0257783904671669, 0.033065322786569595, -0.020871751010417938, -0.05888667330145836, -0.0028586869593709707, -0.00816737487912178, 0.029894350096583366, 0.04757973924279213, 0.03009929694235325, -0.03553954139351845, 0.06290459632873535, -0.09592994302511215, 0.013276309706270695, -0.02908269129693508, -0.09177577495574951, -0.009985784068703651, 0.050681743770837784, 0.056412044912576675, 0.049859050661325455, -0.017609983682632446, -0.006180301774293184, 0.027159202843904495, 0.023689407855272293, -0.04726029559969902, -0.03607868403196335, 0.03243759647011757, 0.03391024097800255, 0.03977051004767418, -0.014964727684855461, -0.00176997110247612, 0.04186718538403511, 0.13212454319000244, -0.001046005287207663, 0.04929499700665474, 0.0068428171798586845, 0.03593166172504425, 0.041850898414850235, -0.004037360195070505, 0.018654201179742813, 0.06310711801052094, 0.015609503723680973, -0.06106819212436676, -0.018713630735874176, 0.025891393423080444, -0.009166193194687366, 0.0008511201594956219, 0.04743467643857002, 0.02424299716949463, 0.055227186530828476, 0.032959241420030594, 0.03725149482488632, -0.05036458373069763, 0.06348343938589096, 0.07324010878801346, 0.06355136632919312, 0.026963338255882263, -0.02847922220826149, 0.04052739217877388, -0.030546996742486954, -0.037230782210826874, -0.0252920500934124, -0.02710675075650215 ]
264
264
Why Global Performance is a Poor Metric for Verifying Convergence of Multi-agent Learning
Experimental verification has been the method of choice for verifying the stability of a multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) algorithm as the number of agents grows and theoretical analysis becomes prohibitively complex. For cooperative agents, where the ultimate goal is to optimize some global metric, the stability is usually verified by observing the evolution of the global performance metric over time. If the global metric improves and eventually stabilizes, it is considered a reasonable verification of the system's stability. The main contribution of this note is establishing the need for better experimental frameworks and measures to assess the stability of large-scale adaptive cooperative systems. We show an experimental case study where the stability of the global performance metric can be rather deceiving, hiding an underlying instability in the system that later leads to a significant drop in performance. We then propose an alternative metric that relies on agents' local policies and show, experimentally, that our proposed metric is more effective (than the traditional global performance metric) in exposing the instability of MARL algorithms.
[ -0.07191616296768188, -0.08831451833248138, 0.05301244184374809, 0.037018124014139175, -0.013665956445038319, -0.03913186863064766, -0.09704373776912689, -0.03614845871925354, -0.0024334753397852182, 0.021921511739492416, 0.03205166012048721, -0.023346656933426857, -0.005085798446089029, 0.07096556574106216, 0.07983773201704025, -0.0596475750207901, 0.0421367771923542, 0.018452541902661324, 0.010898343287408352, -0.04165613651275635, 0.0010466845706105232, -0.08608970046043396, 0.024577809497714043, -0.09121324867010117, 0.012072411365807056, -0.019865145906805992, -0.014983337372541428, -0.0069129494950175285, -0.00740688806399703, -0.03239649534225464, -0.017370739951729774, 0.04687197878956795, 0.07039090245962143, 0.0011768087279051542, 0.004210959188640118, 0.006399994716048241, 0.08199174702167511, 0.06140311062335968, 0.007929089479148388, -0.054448600858449936, 0.013961621560156345, -0.07905305922031403, 0.006661452818661928, -0.029130181297659874, 0.0167471282184124, 0.04263368248939514, 0.04702199995517731, -0.0009749325108714402, 0.034846339374780655, 0.0915103629231453, -0.019412321969866753, 0.03064773604273796, -0.00249315332621336, 0.016697024926543236, -0.0442911796271801, 0.0679798349738121, -0.07527697086334229, -0.005978550761938095, -0.012088664807379246, -0.04087189584970474, -0.023909417912364006, 0.07556656748056412, 0.003234977601096034, 0.0032614900264889, 0.023998688906431198, -0.07426586002111435, -0.03523274511098862, 0.027591358870267868, -0.04608025774359703, -0.071196548640728, 0.05548033118247986, -0.04145205393433571, -0.005858520977199078, -0.026340603828430176, -0.021015051752328873, 0.0009683845564723015, 0.009132331237196922, 0.0054487194865942, 0.02377115562558174, -0.004196658730506897, -0.051261112093925476, 0.011808616109192371, -0.010128356516361237, 0.042421795427799225, -0.01120840385556221, -0.07019004225730896, -0.06819801032543182, -0.03407546877861023, -0.020646261051297188, -0.006603405810892582, 0.049729783087968826, -0.011482618749141693, -0.09932943433523178, -0.0219565536826849, 0.04760930314660072, -0.008217273280024529, -0.1203581690788269, 0.02107626013457775, -0.037065569311380386, 0.04258965328335762, 0.05678977072238922, 0.026785532012581825, 0.0488358810544014, 0.09546267241239548, -0.04511917382478714, -0.0052284495905041695, 0.033022914081811905, 0.0362045019865036, 0.023376479744911194, 0.03653719276189804, 0.03605910763144493, -0.05307779461145401, 0.004125804640352726, 0.007271059323102236, 0.035472311079502106, 0.04669450595974922, -0.009112193249166012, -0.012511993758380413, 0.026936590671539307, 0.0201333686709404, 0.03395215794444084, -0.007001595571637154, -0.0759122297167778, 0.028577623888850212, 0.07841267436742783, -0.04512703791260719, 0.0014453164767473936, -0.041949037462472916, 0.08285469561815262, -0.0155707485973835, -0.0010963322129100561, -0.025689177215099335, -0.019324399530887604, -0.06979648023843765, 0.014881660230457783, 0.01260381005704403, -0.02159942500293255, 0.012484932318329811, 0.009261900559067726, 0.03578411415219307, 0.03331010788679123, -0.03919268026947975, -0.011736158281564713, 0.04585016146302223, 0.031324367970228195, 0.006053832359611988, 0.018901770934462547, 0.032482147216796875, -0.025698157027363777, 0.01968814991414547, 0.05382242426276207, -0.05195198208093643, 0.02668805979192257, 0.045209337025880814, -0.018822534009814262, -0.02519984543323517, -0.012286384589970112, 0.008263980969786644, -0.07034963369369507, 0.10904812067747116, 0.030321931466460228, 0.09624798595905304, 0.025649741291999817, -0.04727973788976669, 0.05397189408540726, 0.0006758503150194883, -0.06591752171516418, -0.044272296130657196, -0.054708950221538544, -0.06929212808609009, -0.05809810385107994, 0.03619224950671196, -0.0063619171269237995, -0.040346451103687286, -0.0124549251049757, -0.02330523356795311, -0.011762313544750214, -0.022462517023086548, 0.014115791767835617, -0.02662947028875351, -0.037530094385147095, 0.036187946796417236, -0.0640995055437088, -0.01078441645950079, 0.12424682825803757, 0.05590352788567543, 0.03311297670006752, 0.016358504071831703, 0.08483554422855377, 0.07160612940788269, 0.014371998608112335, 0.0062475185841321945, -0.06454265862703323, -0.013083272613584995, -0.03222395107150078, 0.0635414645075798, 0.01016257144510746, -0.08359510451555252, -0.02342081442475319, 0.0150169488042593, 0.06721998751163483, -0.03439860790967941, -0.007850154303014278, -0.03164161369204521, 0.0006221840158104897, 0.043238237500190735, -0.0035773429553955793, -0.042679231613874435, -0.02592199482023716, -0.09390496462583542, -0.030234836041927338, 0.023735379800200462, -0.0693054124712944, -0.07705959677696228, 0.021064484491944313, -0.04479129984974861, 0.019533226266503334, 0.0034038119483739138, 0.04720669612288475, -0.053305480629205704, -0.02141050063073635, 0.06532561779022217, -0.04688871279358864, 0.0008333666482940316, -0.038624804466962814, 0.027341768145561218, -0.0038804300129413605, 0.037331994622945786, -0.05620861053466797, 0.021392840892076492, -0.021939437836408615, -0.06672032177448273, 0.00762859545648098, -0.004880165681242943, -0.03428298234939575, 0.04513777792453766, -0.0731162503361702, -0.05751753970980644, 0.043584391474723816, 0.008179211057722569, -0.00236135208979249, 0.06168096885085106, 0.017390141263604164, -0.04397233575582504, 0.0013375509297475219, -0.0010556105989962816, 0.033365748822689056, 0.029797503724694252, -0.0877498909831047, -0.03605661913752556, 0.052647124975919724, 0.018887480720877647, -0.0730956569314003, 0.00872610043734312, 0.04933733120560646, 0.0903732180595398, -0.03574074059724808, 0.027161359786987305, 0.006069428753107786, 0.0405830442905426, -0.037678904831409454, 0.07517047971487045, -0.03203767165541649, -0.06951936334371567, 0.03783401846885681, 0.009453216567635536, -0.03858719393610954, 0.04109134525060654, 0.03737925365567207, -0.04526586830615997, -0.03793948516249657, -0.010541374795138836, -0.042419735342264175, 0.12128498405218124, 0.01439535990357399, -0.055423758924007416, 0.0737345814704895, -0.019951773807406425, 0.0671292096376419, -0.043237894773483276, -0.018628863617777824, 0.01660684123635292, -0.015582112595438957, 0.007463239133358002, -0.028240755200386047, 0.0666663870215416, 0.027702122926712036, -0.0044386377558112144, -0.011436577886343002, -0.011035799048841, -0.09669370204210281, 0.04357798397541046, -0.0794830322265625, -0.00623248890042305, 0.036825887858867645, -0.02550216019153595, 0.02139667235314846, 0.026242617517709732, 0.044399164617061615, 0.022721659392118454, -0.013078764081001282, 0.005055158399045467, 0.04921599477529526, 0.08772542327642441, 0.0417296402156353, 0.09615076333284378, 0.06126062199473381, 0.04710797965526581, -0.005126259755343199, -0.039110418409109116, 0.019678257405757904, -0.035473864525556564, -0.07251933962106705, -0.0752929151058197, 0.034827347844839096, 0.021809102967381477, -0.08139841258525848, -0.02743724174797535, -0.01680031046271324, 0.023623747751116753, -0.01729951985180378, -0.007247195113450289, 0.07978473603725433, -0.020076533779501915, -0.05558283254504204, -0.008527738973498344, -0.02410942129790783, -0.03943651169538498, 0.0014162600273266435, 0.026247922331094742, -0.11986036598682404, 0.055629897862672806, -0.06386278569698334, 0.006199406459927559, -0.04345520958304405, -0.09101484715938568, -0.023858483880758286, -0.024937711656093597, 0.05728418752551079, 0.02823270484805107, 0.0021226489916443825, -0.10155220329761505, 0.027314206585288048, -0.002567901974543929, 0.010480290278792381, 0.12049825489521027, 0.057674020528793335, -0.013583099469542503, -0.13196930289268494, -0.04616420343518257, -0.047657761722803116, -0.08085131645202637, 0.027236957103013992, 0.0032831544522196054, -0.015320433303713799, 0.01391968596726656, -0.03275323659181595, 0.009356020018458366, 0.0465453639626503, -0.018550677224993706, -0.030935756862163544, 0.018718166276812553, -0.03199240192770958, 0.05976926535367966, -0.0066539933905005455, 0.01866440661251545, 0.006328508723527193, 0.07985451817512512, -0.022798465564846992, 0.009631375782191753, -0.09255662560462952, 0.021829919889569283, 0.07128067314624786, -0.03197883814573288, 0.05509486794471741, -0.03588634356856346, 0.10020946711301804, -0.02124498039484024, -0.03504813835024834, 0.07503197342157364, -0.04413857311010361, 0.014561626128852367, -0.002508783247321844, -0.012945463880896568, -0.00791478343307972, 0.06958530843257904, -0.0006160371121950448, 0.0030089763458818197, 0.033161986619234085, -0.04256996139883995, -0.0866314023733139, 0.0020058315712958574, -0.01789461076259613, 0.07698485255241394, -0.0003812975774053484, -0.009719531051814556, 0.0312679260969162, -0.059671491384506226, -0.05330176651477814, -0.04273975268006325, 0.04323044791817665, -0.0323680117726326, -0.005441296845674515, -0.030588192865252495, -0.002131510991603136, -0.02988850511610508, -0.0018626343226060271, 0.05739394202828407, -0.03014262206852436, 0.03880230337381363, 0.0008919220417737961, 0.03727378323674202, -0.0788775309920311, -0.0707525908946991, 0.015110645443201065, -0.025462623685598373, 0.003558496478945017, 0.04405755177140236, 0.022847499698400497, 0.02575463242828846, -0.05248409882187843, -0.04047451540827751, 0.023801766335964203, 0.02731478027999401, 0.01764964871108532, -0.02822541445493698, 0.03378500044345856, 0.06627427786588669, 0.02306256629526615, -0.01873099058866501, -0.035285819321870804, 0.05938076227903366, -0.03695640340447426, -0.07468702644109726, -0.022139020264148712, -0.043234530836343765, 0.003444070927798748, -0.006672289688140154, -0.03975575789809227, 0.00791158527135849, 0.0011022547259926796, 0.09664131700992584, -0.006095602177083492, 0.016861433163285255, -0.011950272135436535, 0.034146059304475784, 0.00914986152201891, 0.009023812599480152, 0.042527955025434494, 0.03169983997941017, -0.02357676811516285, 0.009806927293539047, 0.016368186101317406, -0.034437667578458786, 0.033437203615903854, 0.012173260562121868, -0.011259009130299091, 0.01489537488669157, 0.08429574966430664, -0.01835741102695465, -0.06856557726860046, 0.025533774867653847, 0.029605241492390633, 0.07759862393140793, -0.0004301915178075433, 0.034072715789079666, 0.047140009701251984, -0.017719680443406105, 0.05456598848104477, -0.012437756173312664, -0.060851845890283585, -0.02009076438844204, -0.030426211655139923, 0.014313055202364922, -0.06939033418893814, -0.022515306249260902, -0.005510501563549042, -0.023906469345092773, -0.03256876394152641, 0.012126767076551914, 0.0760607048869133, 0.030990025028586388, 0.030983688309788704, 0.0860925242304802, 0.019844703376293182, 0.05137911066412926, -0.06332835555076599, 0.021290486678481102, -0.06525913625955582, -0.0005449425661936402, -0.011608855798840523, 0.007715505547821522, -0.009745136834681034, 0.02892589196562767, -0.019500095397233963, -0.005104138981550932, 0.03200501576066017, -0.011343647725880146, 0.05830872431397438, 0.027645694091916084, 0.00809396430850029, -0.02768588811159134, 0.07003237307071686, 0.019511250779032707, -0.009339441545307636, 0.01548147015273571, -0.004591553937643766, -0.012628371827304363, -0.028342898935079575, 0.003301881719380617, 0.0016602150863036513, 0.04740871861577034 ]
265
265
A Methodology for Learning Players' Styles from Game Records
We describe a preliminary investigation into learning a Chess player's style from game records. The method is based on attempting to learn features of a player's individual evaluation function using the method of temporal differences, with the aid of a conventional Chess engine architecture. Some encouraging results were obtained in learning the styles of two recent Chess world champions, and we report on our attempt to use the learnt styles to discriminate between the players from game records by trying to detect who was playing white and who was playing black. We also discuss some limitations of our approach and propose possible directions for future research. The method we have presented may also be applicable to other strategic games, and may even be generalisable to other domains where sequences of agents' actions are recorded.
[ -0.05410514771938324, -0.045001816004514694, 0.06366937607526779, -0.022128088399767876, -0.060985516756772995, -0.10088814049959183, -0.012632128782570362, -0.00810280628502369, -0.008046213537454605, -0.01568789780139923, 0.025258056819438934, 0.022089120000600815, 0.004339440725743771, 0.08798329532146454, -0.016542397439479828, -0.01033241767436266, 0.016742689535021782, -0.05476435646414757, -0.03179303929209709, -0.013788999058306217, 0.022694338113069534, -0.033660028129816055, -0.07789092510938644, -0.05240177735686302, -0.003948906436562538, -0.05228808522224426, -0.03656988590955734, -0.04670240357518196, 0.02666773647069931, 0.03912390395998955, -0.05601591244339943, -0.002929508686065674, 0.08707185834646225, -0.0017926302971318364, 0.03798728436231613, -0.026694776490330696, 0.03659335523843765, -0.046069853007793427, -0.03721325471997261, 0.016634056344628334, -0.06157355755567551, 0.07610926777124405, 0.028471382334828377, 0.025638597086071968, -0.04448534920811653, -0.003892421955242753, 0.008270972408354282, -0.05561888590455055, -0.0022007098887115717, 0.1002296432852745, -0.06705380976200104, -0.061913132667541504, 0.041738301515579224, 0.04061954468488693, 0.019740939140319824, 0.10699325054883957, -0.023950781673192978, -0.053289007395505905, -0.02488325908780098, -0.08648549765348434, -0.02732827700674534, 0.07331913709640503, 0.0315200500190258, 0.02055339701473713, -0.040506765246391296, -0.022302722558379173, -0.04911003261804581, -0.01581111177802086, -0.023543812334537506, -0.025571515783667564, 0.03786580637097359, -0.01034458540380001, 0.032016605138778687, -0.04327048361301422, -0.03761618956923485, 0.03846332058310509, -0.044224098324775696, -0.011767935007810593, 0.026033934205770493, 0.13427315652370453, -0.06493544578552246, 0.007747759111225605, 0.0025513998698443174, -0.02780383639037609, -0.005851674359291792, -0.05578088387846947, 0.03559635207056999, 0.018789133056998253, -0.02070506103336811, 0.07153093814849854, -0.03758014738559723, 0.00914247427135706, -0.08835559338331223, -0.0028583162929862738, 0.00422144029289484, -0.014859328046441078, 0.011506082490086555, 0.021171335130929947, -0.0403846800327301, 0.015840260311961174, 0.016933437436819077, 0.0020762551575899124, -0.0013347472995519638, 0.0596553236246109, -0.02500700019299984, -0.026835836470127106, 0.016987567767500877, 0.05521509423851967, 0.0912870541214943, -0.031182367354631424, 0.04180384427309036, 0.041550591588020325, 0.07281819730997086, 0.013615927658975124, 0.0121884411200881, -0.0050069671124219894, -0.0033347448334097862, 0.010767868719995022, 0.05194549635052681, 0.02703193947672844, 0.0004020498599857092, 0.02219366654753685, -0.0649137794971466, -0.012444393709301949, 0.0496915727853775, -0.013967584818601608, 0.024332227185368538, -0.021061332896351814, 0.04458188638091087, -0.014802046120166779, -0.040588635951280594, -0.00038452158332802355, -0.0541314072906971, -0.10653559863567352, 0.0356375016272068, 0.003286679508164525, -0.05708646774291992, -0.003161598462611437, -0.055548038333654404, 0.011176783591508865, 0.0061953868716955185, -0.014748039655387402, -0.06056874245405197, 0.05100158229470253, -0.03863069787621498, 0.04971073195338249, -0.015022116713225842, 0.01635020412504673, 0.04624146968126297, 0.05288441479206085, 0.05440409481525421, -0.06575872004032135, 0.0450906865298748, -0.0008741167257539928, -0.038367364555597305, -0.04166770353913307, -0.021739907562732697, -0.014570561237633228, -0.04095229133963585, 0.015287783928215504, 0.00758551899343729, -0.03547138348221779, -0.014122974127531052, 0.0008660914609208703, 0.05919364467263222, 0.04589628055691719, -0.02284545637667179, 0.01271573081612587, -0.07110138982534409, -0.04432695358991623, -0.049925003200769424, 0.03531552851200104, -0.02980426698923111, -0.03226170688867569, 0.04038183391094208, -0.008580363355576992, 0.012751913629472256, 0.07907333225011826, 0.03550582751631737, 0.048831310123205185, 0.005892129614949226, -0.023868964985013008, -0.016730569303035736, 0.0022467223461717367, 0.0790657252073288, 0.02705836109817028, 0.04926759749650955, 0.05246223881840706, 0.04884704202413559, 0.048123110085725784, -0.08127430826425552, 0.07918636500835419, -0.014587805606424809, -0.03822600841522217, 0.04341232404112816, 0.09497270733118057, 0.030829956755042076, -0.04374882951378822, 0.015264352783560753, 0.03295654430985451, 0.07101911306381226, -0.029679836705327034, -0.04285641759634018, 0.012449381873011589, -0.03397957608103752, 0.0076477620750665665, -0.014018756337463856, 0.00832437165081501, -0.03619819134473801, 0.022823961451649666, 0.05966871604323387, 0.028500305488705635, -0.047729820013046265, 0.006425368133932352, -0.06971410661935806, -0.053394515067338943, -0.05726783722639084, -0.015672024339437485, 0.015095212496817112, 0.019445279613137245, 0.01408357359468937, 0.04984526336193085, -0.027676885947585106, -0.012309832498431206, 0.010924574919044971, -0.09862953424453735, 0.010529360733926296, -0.0009331966284662485, -0.11439045518636703, 0.04512558877468109, -0.023812124505639076, -0.05304626002907753, 0.013013487681746483, -0.020099660381674767, 0.006253759376704693, -0.001777630764991045, -0.0362112894654274, -0.07510336488485336, -0.008338983170688152, -0.006389222573488951, -0.02932499162852764, -0.04420747235417366, -0.013083432801067829, 0.08581261336803436, 0.0371757410466671, -0.05886077508330345, 0.024606341496109962, 0.0349339060485363, -0.005690497346222401, -0.026809940114617348, -0.013130171224474907, 0.002027061302214861, -0.017819425091147423, 0.02132645808160305, 0.0727851390838623, 0.06017423793673515, -0.05164509266614914, 0.02155919559299946, 0.09911343455314636, -0.04957765340805054, -0.03619791567325592, 0.03262721374630928, 0.006342894397675991, 0.03273290768265724, 0.08335274457931519, 0.0256984643638134, 0.02994801476597786, 0.030582662671804428, 0.03832704946398735, 0.011277980171144009, 0.023364324122667313, -0.04586838558316231, 0.05643546208739281, 0.04621800407767296, 0.014578201808035374, -0.01595447026193142, 0.07257355004549026, 0.019403472542762756, -0.00782299879938364, -0.0751827210187912, -0.030301764607429504, -0.035160962492227554, -0.025251934304833412, 0.021176015958189964, -0.004323734436184168, 0.028554076328873634, -0.014473875984549522, -0.01792879030108452, 0.05440739542245865, 0.038063839077949524, -0.06527945399284363, 0.05126600340008736, -0.09684006869792938, -0.021403251215815544, 0.07320580631494522, 0.007324205711483955, 0.03216813877224922, -0.030053766444325447, 0.010912498459219933, -0.009247222915291786, -0.03228447958827019, -0.031684279441833496, 0.03805752843618393, 0.07284104079008102, 0.09649010747671127, 0.03258098289370537, 0.007325175683945417, 0.0509953498840332, 0.02300763875246048, -0.002518653403967619, 0.02212062105536461, -0.03805999457836151, -0.051030080765485764, -0.0630418136715889, -0.05502091720700264, 0.0027110010851174593, 0.022156506776809692, -0.052774470299482346, 0.027490179985761642, -0.04366876184940338, 0.0075008561834692955, -0.08398625254631042, -0.017057625576853752, 0.039489250630140305, -0.06480930000543594, -0.0022067446261644363, -0.02339836023747921, 0.01906725950539112, -0.0028565735556185246, 0.04256460443139076, -0.03318272531032562, -0.015403184108436108, 0.0645497515797615, 0.012251824140548706, -0.10237833112478256, -0.031140491366386414, 0.04747176542878151, 0.009031109511852264, 0.046395886689424515, 0.06854898482561111, -0.02846924029290676, -0.06789610534906387, 0.008181477896869183, -0.07726796716451645, -0.031272321939468384, 0.018033334985375404, 0.0488867312669754, 0.020729638636112213, -0.00514626270160079, 0.015312070958316326, 0.0026429486460983753, -0.0678495243191719, -0.02033034712076187, -0.01750667206943035, -0.0059812855906784534, 0.047979485243558884, -0.0019955800380557775, 0.0994187742471695, 0.016492264345288277, 0.029090123251080513, -0.0007491472642868757, 0.034472569823265076, 0.025625286623835564, -0.09896404296159744, 0.061869148164987564, 0.06288249790668488, 0.004957748576998711, 0.02014312520623207, -0.053016047924757004, 0.00046319965622387826, 0.025968285277485847, 0.012875844724476337, 0.030257143080234528, 0.025237539783120155, -0.012090586125850677, -0.03412621468305588, -0.0320296548306942, -0.09505127370357513, 0.010554199106991291, 0.06561349332332611, -0.06998267024755478, -0.009540693834424019, 0.043517209589481354, -0.017409175634384155, 0.015278222970664501, -0.0074013578705489635, 0.0011524483561515808, -0.01638617552816868, -0.010702351108193398, 0.029680369421839714, -0.15861113369464874, -0.09020290523767471, -0.054123688489198685, 0.06656857579946518, 0.007517619989812374, -0.08058533817529678, 0.017575647681951523, -0.022138195112347603, 0.04906832426786423, 0.034540481865406036, 0.02120465226471424, -0.11536476016044617, -0.04943746700882912, -0.06716599315404892, -0.03658923879265785, 0.051915038377046585, 0.07269083708524704, 0.07999756187200546, 0.0010150996968150139, 0.025290628895163536, 0.05827687308192253, -0.013168263249099255, 0.038571879267692566, -0.07454469054937363, 0.006223147269338369, 0.010778672993183136, -0.012091889046132565, 0.04745795577764511, -0.03403788059949875, -0.020876413211226463, 0.04932895675301552, -0.015520010143518448, 0.03131164610385895, 0.0027220873162150383, 0.0023439256474375725, -0.0132064800709486, 0.05435319244861603, 0.01758536323904991, 0.015510929748415947, 0.09502243250608444, -0.03650219738483429, -0.07242193073034286, -0.004801869858056307, -0.043235160410404205, -0.05462902411818504, 0.03621833026409149, 0.0272994302213192, 0.002817736705765128, -0.035829607397317886, 0.018421361222863197, -0.06691697239875793, -0.03291222080588341, 0.038132134824991226, 0.017437109723687172, 0.015647150576114655, -0.020802194252610207, -0.025566833093762398, -0.017045723274350166, 0.03411736711859703, -0.07076083868741989, -0.010546446777880192, -0.04471117630600929, -0.05587195232510567, -0.025670833885669708, -0.049621593207120895, -0.006166510283946991, -0.02590395323932171, -0.0031890233512967825, 0.0692792758345604, -0.018507080152630806, -0.0421295166015625, 0.030715346336364746, 0.010113661177456379, 0.06405449658632278, -0.03475901111960411, 0.00035770429531112313, 0.025141557678580284, -0.03390011563897133, 0.0806490108370781, 0.06379624456167221, -0.028236957266926765, -0.05484617128968239, 0.03763776272535324, -0.052898064255714417, -0.05286327004432678, 0.07029576599597931, 0.022471390664577484, -0.005088011268526316, 0.006136772222816944, 0.049242909997701645, 0.03983262926340103, 0.03086424246430397, 0.09345608204603195, 0.10769838839769363, 0.020536888390779495, -0.03977291285991669, 0.005138572305440903, 0.047183871269226074, -0.012947834096848965, 0.01452677883207798, 0.024762148037552834, -0.01840301603078842, 0.04062418267130852, 0.026192134246230125, 0.03948793560266495, -0.08359188586473465, 0.052115920931100845, 0.0025696707889437675, -0.009203548543155193, -0.036776602268218994, 0.03542778640985489, 0.04843483865261078, 0.006473637651652098, 0.054095204919576645, 0.05035357177257538, 0.02780952677130699, 0.08118530362844467, 0.031911153346300125, 0.030274340882897377, 0.024253252893686295, 0.052597589790821075, 0.06467469036579132 ]
266
266
Exponential Family Graph Matching and Ranking
We present a method for learning max-weight matching predictors in bipartite graphs. The method consists of performing maximum a posteriori estimation in exponential families with sufficient statistics that encode permutations and data features. Although inference is in general hard, we show that for one very relevant application - web page ranking - exact inference is efficient. For general model instances, an appropriate sampler is readily available. Contrary to existing max-margin matching models, our approach is statistically consistent and, in addition, experiments with increasing sample sizes indicate superior improvement over such models. We apply the method to graph matching in computer vision as well as to a standard benchmark dataset for learning web page ranking, in which we obtain state-of-the-art results, in particular improving on max-margin variants. The drawback of this method with respect to max-margin alternatives is its runtime for large graphs, which is comparatively high.
[ -0.012186083942651749, -0.0020377845503389835, 0.009279989637434483, -0.047486599534749985, 0.02790641598403454, 0.011058967560529709, 0.013337081298232079, -0.009451388381421566, -0.053452279418706894, -0.09460747241973877, -0.055323485285043716, -0.06218200549483299, -0.04506979137659073, 0.009438622742891312, 0.06925816833972931, 0.019038157537579536, -0.05614762753248215, -0.03205221891403198, 0.018949126824736595, 0.011456340551376343, 0.025935735553503036, 0.02095944806933403, 0.031948547810316086, -0.004941615741699934, 0.015608435496687889, -0.0045959302224218845, 0.027169909328222275, -0.018239744007587433, -0.01877649500966072, -0.0012758284574374557, -0.046514540910720825, -0.03150327876210213, 0.029706435278058052, 0.04540902003645897, 0.03148749843239784, -0.0001770505914464593, 0.040499769151210785, -0.03086322732269764, 0.025524834170937538, 0.008551189675927162, -0.010046975687146187, -0.007485455833375454, 0.04485940933227539, 0.010946216993033886, 0.03866574168205261, -0.02451319247484207, -0.011348260566592216, 0.04729783162474632, 0.014647264033555984, 0.06868918240070343, -0.07387232035398483, 0.05465273559093475, -0.002995205344632268, 0.02545296587049961, -0.04399026185274124, 0.07828211784362793, -0.05837651714682579, 0.028202911838889122, 0.007358646020293236, -0.04670781269669533, 0.01846632920205593, 0.0910305306315422, -0.012849206104874611, -0.01549954991787672, 0.02077977918088436, -0.00001145863006968284, -0.04211457818746567, 0.02858329750597477, -0.054941870272159576, -0.02687450312077999, -0.008555898442864418, -0.016811415553092957, 0.04639653116464615, 0.020318472757935524, 0.0907198041677475, 0.011731752194464207, 0.024939002469182014, -0.05565677955746651, 0.08225172758102417, 0.07756080478429794, -0.053873658180236816, 0.10915957391262054, -0.05919685959815979, -0.017265746369957924, -0.03697048872709274, 0.010143313556909561, -0.003054199740290642, 0.026373472064733505, -0.029706871137022972, -0.02635333128273487, 0.014482972212135792, -0.030573919415473938, -0.05289997532963753, 0.08870700746774673, -0.1061655804514885, 0.010915937833487988, -0.10567812621593475, 0.044234562665224075, -0.0009071799577213824, 0.01189284399151802, -0.013914071954786777, -0.08527907729148865, -0.017409952357411385, 0.016090067103505135, -0.03753199428319931, -0.019882643595337868, 0.002630110364407301, 0.01788533851504326, 0.06884080916643143, -0.06604419648647308, 0.0069075943902134895, -0.03068782016634941, -0.01319844275712967, 0.0049688429571688175, -0.0534270778298378, 0.016418375074863434, -0.02237171120941639, 0.07480408251285553, 0.01614757627248764, 0.036199864000082016, 0.02040364407002926, -0.06510664522647858, -0.01695866882801056, -0.011049940250813961, 0.016848381608724594, -0.08274532854557037, -0.022950148209929466, -0.035608675330877304, 0.056162625551223755, 0.030722158029675484, -0.05291340500116348, 0.058800771832466125, -0.03490963205695152, -0.01955132558941841, -0.11079458892345428, 0.03002212382853031, 0.00018108391668647528, 0.012887164950370789, 0.051642075181007385, 0.09082059562206268, -0.05963021516799927, -0.02377970516681671, -0.025027062743902206, 0.03197944164276123, 0.01490519754588604, 0.03866041824221611, -0.03224101662635803, 0.026752395555377007, -0.0263871680945158, -0.02775026671588421, -0.03571122884750366, -0.041737426072359085, 0.0558369979262352, 0.04093625396490097, -0.03644989803433418, -0.0263795368373394, 0.03009773977100849, -0.049953654408454895, -0.03000810369849205, -0.05450928583741188, -0.00899926945567131, -0.00629386305809021, 0.06954377144575119, -0.044229257851839066, 0.03876456245779991, 0.007383838761597872, -0.013382563367486, 0.005262862890958786, -0.02311607263982296, -0.036466408520936966, 0.053126607090234756, -0.04876992478966713, 0.021865297108888626, 0.05636648088693619, -0.0029761733021587133, -0.06400199234485626, 0.02633604221045971, 0.09446827322244644, -0.011092524975538254, 0.02383590303361416, 0.0687522143125534, -0.05596437305212021, 0.019182754680514336, 0.027091914787888527, 0.042584240436553955, 0.06371476501226425, 0.005709048826247454, 0.05573565512895584, 0.020814979448914528, 0.047633036971092224, 0.00889913085848093, -0.014471578411757946, 0.05381603166460991, -0.0313299223780632, -0.09623859822750092, -0.03465115651488304, -0.03809627890586853, -0.011290039867162704, -0.016289545223116875, 0.04363663122057915, 0.03543119877576828, -0.09140852838754654, 0.0015048910863697529, -0.06682780385017395, -0.033652905374765396, -0.006204911973327398, 0.060797274112701416, -0.09250611811876297, -0.04231252148747444, 0.005752822384238243, 0.06011003628373146, 0.04581430181860924, 0.018882067874073982, -0.004002479370683432, 0.010958005674183369, -0.023681247606873512, 0.01634916663169861, -0.06828248500823975, 0.01347304042428732, 0.028277751058340073, 0.018724290654063225, 0.05214134603738785, -0.022774044424295425, 0.009424341842532158, -0.05989732965826988, -0.011698190122842789, 0.04019884765148163, 0.011903385631740093, -0.08506431430578232, 0.0521998405456543, -0.022767508402466774, -0.06792023032903671, -0.0456952303647995, -0.01105031743645668, -0.04440579190850258, 0.0005462331464514136, -0.09226420521736145, -0.032076261937618256, -0.005538849160075188, -0.044511325657367706, -0.006163741461932659, 0.04036477580666542, 0.062065642327070236, -0.05493639409542084, -0.045009270310401917, -0.059831179678440094, -0.03134731203317642, 0.0009330250322818756, -0.050875984132289886, -0.019150402396917343, 0.020369617268443108, 0.027109527960419655, -0.026861276477575302, -0.0014196302508935332, 0.01513080857694149, 0.02887890301644802, 0.02831832692027092, 0.1014736145734787, -0.006772130727767944, 0.073677197098732, 0.09200675040483475, 0.006051530130207539, -0.07279495894908905, -0.024729348719120026, 0.10642512887716293, -0.0020714090205729008, -0.04426833242177963, 0.030754264444112778, -0.014139862731099129, 0.04883108660578728, 0.05267328768968582, -0.02298842743039131, -0.05467669293284416, 0.08856774866580963, 0.05486379936337471, 0.007603047415614128, 0.0301254503428936, 0.008413614705204964, 0.013941550627350807, -0.004567501600831747, -0.08843082934617996, -0.016424521803855896, 0.023679422214627266, -0.01757754758000374, -0.03144441545009613, 0.10318631678819656, -0.08343479782342911, -0.02211776375770569, -0.025395801290869713, -0.0030854474753141403, -0.05419673025608063, -0.022946413606405258, -0.042919572442770004, -0.009846306405961514, 0.023253316059708595, -0.03346109762787819, 0.04126635193824768, 0.05025723949074745, 0.02220301702618599, 0.03282161429524422, -0.0751400962471962, -0.0450003519654274, 0.026698222383856773, 0.0021344292908906937, 0.027967406436800957, 0.020742163062095642, 0.040404390543699265, 0.017206836491823196, -0.060608260333538055, 0.006198914721608162, 0.0277615487575531, -0.0239128228276968, -0.03949465975165367, -0.021315038204193115, 0.05307227000594139, -0.025647664442658424, -0.13262560963630676, -0.008081033825874329, -0.07977499067783356, 0.017979873344302177, 0.03185316547751427, 0.020155824720859528, -0.036837246268987656, 0.04322639852762222, -0.055751580744981766, -0.024507366120815277, -0.0018610532861202955, 0.06985461711883545, -0.02057155780494213, -0.00007096299668774009, -0.04565487056970596, 0.0010788822546601295, -0.03363905847072601, 0.0505237951874733, 0.023235706612467766, 0.030420981347560883, -0.004374899435788393, -0.029814936220645905, 0.008397109806537628, 0.021910596638917923, -0.04511386528611183, -0.049824465066194534, -0.04816054925322533, -0.019068943336606026, 0.02934063971042633, 0.09388396888971329, 0.00517543638125062, 0.028229696676135063, 0.004946644883602858, -0.05362939089536667, -0.042938508093357086, 0.04383034631609917, 0.02054080367088318, -0.002000285079702735, -0.033277299255132675, 0.02422226592898369, 0.09792932122945786, -0.0037860600277781487, 0.0035845772363245487, 0.041654571890830994, -0.07373900711536407, -0.02283817157149315, -0.0031245711725205183, 0.020303307101130486, 0.05184663459658623, 0.05833371728658676, -0.052165351808071136, -0.018765242770314217, -0.023395881056785583, 0.012716019526124, 0.0014998245751485229, 0.06751172989606857, -0.0011254037963226438, -0.031124074012041092, -0.05822068452835083, -0.12064778059720993, -0.023546641692519188, -0.010437018238008022, -0.00020999011758249253, 0.03593821078538895, -0.015580512583255768, 0.03202667087316513, 0.004108813125640154, 0.00860658474266529, 0.005716219544410706, -0.03599870949983597, -0.06729209423065186, 0.030434807762503624, 0.07036713510751724, 0.017226442694664, 0.052305664867162704, -0.027881331741809845, -0.004135953262448311, -0.011524590663611889, 0.03927329182624817, -0.03716490417718887, 0.014378836378455162, 0.026371657848358154, -0.06939207762479782, -0.026972712948918343, 0.009171712212264538, -0.05801882594823837, -0.04530820623040199, -0.10754726827144623, -0.055097781121730804, -0.005728361662477255, -0.008296256884932518, 0.05433475226163864, 0.02245767042040825, 0.04196445643901825, -0.02822885848581791, 0.06678474694490433, -0.1231057196855545, 0.0011807084083557129, -0.003954560961574316, 0.03736058995127678, 0.02398316003382206, -0.001167924259789288, -0.039707787334918976, -0.041922442615032196, 0.05257532745599747, -0.03209144249558449, 0.034158844500780106, -0.02989630401134491, 0.02998778223991394, -0.028416864573955536, 0.040539391338825226, 0.004447437822818756, 0.017687873914837837, 0.013213994912803173, -0.06434062123298645, -0.01616303250193596, -0.05262105539441109, -0.013758792541921139, 0.022566955536603928, 0.037650126963853836, -0.011192107573151588, 0.016334155574440956, -0.03703540936112404, -0.0354633666574955, -0.03673893213272095, 0.0048509747721254826, 0.01117108203470707, -0.018988564610481262, 0.05889671668410301, -0.0035818791948258877, 0.05460935831069946, 0.026418030261993408, 0.07498373091220856, -0.005361522547900677, -0.0041604540310800076, -0.007260660175234079, -0.0802338495850563, -0.054392844438552856, -0.04956621304154396, -0.027700992301106453, -0.028797302395105362, -0.05713805928826332, 0.03236393630504608, -0.0654592514038086, 0.013177306391298771, -0.05534768104553223, -0.010244452394545078, 0.03076876513659954, -0.10018284618854523, 0.047721367329359055, 0.02884429506957531, 0.055171240121126175, 0.08711761981248856, 0.03315580636262894, -0.00967173557728529, -0.0051452843472361565, 0.013517335057258606, -0.02491469867527485, -0.024782145395874977, 0.06887268275022507, 0.01185031607747078, 0.0009591382695361972, 0.020378466695547104, 0.0074425386264920235, 0.024284277111291885, 0.052190572023391724, -0.07560203224420547, -0.0658644437789917, 0.009999527595937252, 0.08878594636917114, -0.0667942687869072, 0.06414470821619034, 0.04804255813360214, 0.08275695890188217, -0.038389407098293304, -0.0320960134267807, 0.031239155679941177, 0.013931965455412865, 0.031443145126104355, 0.075621597468853, 0.09591122716665268, 0.022392867133021355, -0.0055450452491641045, -0.012113559059798717, 0.05777781456708908, -0.019078750163316727, 0.01748625561594963, 0.06692323088645935, 0.1287299394607544, 0.04659556224942207, 0.017840979620814323, 0.03146989643573761, -0.07686714828014374, 0.029572108760476112, -0.06981893628835678, -0.02238248847424984 ]
267
267
Efficient Construction of Neighborhood Graphs by the Multiple Sorting Method
Neighborhood graphs are gaining popularity as a concise data representation in machine learning. However, naive graph construction by pairwise distance calculation takes $O(n^2)$ runtime for $n$ data points and this is prohibitively slow for millions of data points. For strings of equal length, the multiple sorting method (Uno, 2008) can construct an $\epsilon$-neighbor graph in $O(n+m)$ time, where $m$ is the number of $\epsilon$-neighbor pairs in the data. To introduce this remarkably efficient algorithm to continuous domains such as images, signals and texts, we employ a random projection method to convert vectors to strings. Theoretical results are presented to elucidate the trade-off between approximation quality and computation time. Empirical results show the efficiency of our method in comparison to fast nearest neighbor alternatives.
[ -0.012790903449058533, -0.060426659882068634, 0.03537798672914505, -0.04403894022107124, 0.08445116132497787, -0.0022648447193205357, 0.009536894038319588, -0.034128736704587936, -0.06570672988891602, 0.012404297478497028, 0.015337664633989334, 0.007919585332274437, 0.0035146037116646767, 0.04031705856323242, 0.03701074793934822, 0.0021237321197986603, -0.05593569576740265, 0.04005025699734688, 0.08590404689311981, -0.012594238854944706, -0.018849655985832214, -0.023312460631132126, -0.02050955966114998, -0.08329977095127106, 0.05604586750268936, 0.02332036942243576, -0.06034303084015846, 0.04844416305422783, -0.008055889047682285, -0.009360291063785553, -0.01560391765087843, 0.007458415813744068, 0.07717087864875793, 0.02639138698577881, -0.036314792931079865, 0.021133530884981155, 0.008393963798880577, 0.035356201231479645, -0.04349160194396973, -0.01478542946279049, -0.004730973858386278, -0.09347319602966309, 0.05834410712122917, -0.00715487077832222, -0.002410270506516099, 0.0105997109785676, -0.0266935583204031, 0.046405065804719925, 0.01990388333797455, 0.08090882748365402, -0.05393344163894653, 0.015653589740395546, 0.0314745157957077, 0.09702625870704651, 0.01676877774298191, 0.008684655651450157, -0.021396324038505554, -0.022347036749124527, 0.004123355261981487, -0.04864444583654404, 0.043594665825366974, 0.08314184099435806, -0.003654519561678171, -0.014037652872502804, -0.04076157137751579, 0.02181532233953476, -0.058527421206235886, -0.01970597729086876, -0.02438502013683319, -0.010103278793394566, -0.05241650715470314, -0.08671332895755768, -0.00991910696029663, 0.005367389880120754, 0.023294270038604736, 0.010603978298604488, 0.029205262660980225, -0.016013624146580696, 0.0728888213634491, 0.10346562415361404, -0.07242846488952637, 0.07864581793546677, -0.01727912575006485, -0.0160545464605093, -0.023695526644587517, 0.032513268291950226, -0.061012569814920425, 0.003105373354628682, 0.042360737919807434, -0.0018207005923613906, -0.08022866398096085, -0.020012203603982925, -0.08557221293449402, 0.10769043862819672, -0.09198318421840668, -0.0032122808042913675, -0.026286935433745384, -0.02271549217402935, -0.00790855661034584, 0.07217150181531906, -0.009966611862182617, -0.015683455392718315, 0.036062512546777725, 0.05961965024471283, -0.02852107398211956, -0.047442302107810974, -0.07786181569099426, 0.025584794580936432, 0.06922896951436996, -0.06174293905496597, 0.0747046023607254, 0.04764805734157562, -0.009025351144373417, 0.006965076085180044, -0.0008615631959401071, 0.04483108967542648, 0.005615076515823603, 0.06799618154764175, 0.0014567876933142543, -0.028295939788222313, -0.03911992534995079, 0.005285182967782021, 0.021707763895392418, -0.008724462240934372, 0.022354623302817345, -0.06621798872947693, 0.005490070674568415, 0.061808131635189056, 0.055674437433481216, 0.049244124442338943, -0.07616660743951797, -0.022023433819413185, -0.0022208704613149166, 0.03451770544052124, -0.15090033411979675, 0.004835882689803839, 0.049959536641836166, -0.07136288285255432, 0.02109486795961857, 0.09165814518928528, 0.01941809244453907, -0.055478535592556, -0.0661577582359314, 0.0021031787618994713, 0.05257490277290344, 0.06345854699611664, -0.07106287777423859, 0.044363707304000854, 0.009251733310520649, -0.02289186604321003, 0.030386248603463173, -0.10825514048337936, 0.015889234840869904, -0.017360948026180267, 0.04379235580563545, -0.0617804117500782, -0.05238472670316696, -0.12535732984542847, 0.049997370690107346, 0.01572410576045513, -0.04671188443899155, 0.008386905305087566, -0.05162181705236435, 0.026647178456187248, 0.015702037140727043, -0.042464729398489, -0.022179316729307175, -0.03190331533551216, 0.0185410026460886, -0.040558356791734695, 0.053937263786792755, 0.015527423471212387, -0.044798970222473145, 0.029261484742164612, -0.013122116215527058, 0.03807485103607178, -0.0007616492221131921, -0.0437035858631134, -0.023323891684412956, -0.013279853388667107, 0.03602809086441994, -0.1228836253285408, 0.003251022193580866, 0.0208689346909523, 0.07377848774194717, 0.14254876971244812, -0.037868086248636246, 0.017772458493709564, 0.015406974591314793, -0.021504297852516174, 0.05995819717645645, -0.042660124599933624, 0.12023936212062836, 0.015725819393992424, -0.006455096881836653, 0.07840403914451599, -0.04483718052506447, -0.045732371509075165, 0.01822052150964737, -0.0024259653873741627, -0.02766505256295204, 0.008207094855606556, -0.04707948863506317, -0.10418125987052917, -0.027149206027388573, 0.03060930408537388, -0.02365214005112648, -0.028524257242679596, -0.041405510157346725, 0.03746640682220459, 0.03463982418179512, 0.012298353016376495, -0.015296299010515213, -0.024044515565037727, 0.010679579339921474, 0.02909732051193714, -0.0356530100107193, 0.02834809385240078, 0.035879384726285934, 0.026696352288126945, -0.047366540879011154, 0.038778550922870636, -0.07441097497940063, 0.05967453867197037, 0.004549406003206968, 0.026821866631507874, -0.00012245051038917154, -0.006433835253119469, -0.041915424168109894, 0.04626048356294632, 0.007330866996198893, -0.02220473438501358, -0.04169930890202522, 0.0189342238008976, 0.03361881896853447, 0.10175106674432755, -0.008657246828079224, 0.0026736094150692225, 0.014614693820476532, 0.005523646716028452, -0.054733190685510635, 0.08247005939483643, -0.0105128837749362, -0.01685325615108013, -0.01522898767143488, -0.052766960114240646, 0.05126013606786728, 0.00011158968118252233, 0.013285993598401546, 0.0012331596808508039, 0.020216990262269974, -0.009262749925255775, -0.04552533105015755, -0.03221217542886734, 0.03758270666003227, 0.05596533045172691, 0.03782187029719353, 0.02759242057800293, 0.018437393009662628, 0.11708291620016098, 0.044828638434410095, 0.02909986302256584, 0.018446972593665123, 0.033239711076021194, 0.0672464519739151, 0.03302277624607086, -0.004626936744898558, -0.01811160333454609, 0.0001997142971958965, 0.005262242630124092, 0.04512600600719452, -0.061012957245111465, -0.027515733614563942, 0.08334662020206451, -0.05833665654063225, 0.03135113790631294, 0.043177902698516846, 0.10484148561954498, -0.03733690828084946, -0.04825054854154587, -0.046037010848522186, 0.037245944142341614, 0.041792482137680054, -0.022222479805350304, 0.01936190575361252, 0.04453625902533531, 0.035991962999105453, -0.0724223330616951, 0.05903568118810654, 0.031259581446647644, -0.042606472969055176, -0.022012073546648026, -0.05781501904129982, -0.007620241027325392, 0.016593238338828087, -0.06614179909229279, -0.01526492927223444, -0.07079331576824188, 0.06548640877008438, -0.02858576737344265, 0.01407239306718111, 0.030387062579393387, 0.03398198261857033, 0.00978241115808487, -0.06925520300865173, -0.005473487079143524, 0.05705427750945091, 0.021046550944447517, -0.04664584994316101, -0.035917144268751144, 0.023312883451581, -0.0724683478474617, -0.02292889729142189, -0.03782632201910019, -0.026783717796206474, -0.04623899236321449, -0.009652774780988693, 0.02079811505973339, -0.04541049152612686, 0.006712077185511589, -0.016664918512105942, 0.0022101912181824446, 0.0286891907453537, -0.07351391762495041, -0.05748996138572693, 0.01662547141313553, 0.05130717530846596, 0.07287425547838211, -0.07660982012748718, -0.09673677384853363, -0.03994007408618927, 0.11285966634750366, -0.07261636853218079, 0.10826172679662704, 0.034198254346847534, -0.06481928378343582, 0.018854571506381035, -0.03648798540234566, -0.030056672170758247, -0.014384177513420582, -0.00836810190230608, 0.015142412856221199, -0.04048182815313339, -0.0017308384412899613, 0.045649196952581406, 0.015210747718811035, 0.018204955384135246, -0.020507799461483955, 0.04675648733973503, -0.01579042337834835, -0.016332345083355904, -0.00026057896320708096, 0.06327284127473831, 0.015523879788815975, -0.0010531623847782612, 0.12728092074394226, 0.05039769411087036, 0.03526974469423294, -0.01080853771418333, 0.005784922745078802, -0.037636447697877884, -0.0024150321260094643, -0.002725672908127308, -0.030265575274825096, 0.015522884204983711, 0.043477531522512436, -0.049260422587394714, 0.01896805502474308, 0.020563963800668716, 0.022243475541472435, 0.02824542112648487, 0.04339740797877312, 0.03692139312624931, 0.007091291714459658, 0.03489357605576515, -0.09150262922048569, 0.04391629248857498, -0.05097793787717819, 0.05801532790064812, 0.07726851850748062, -0.019250821322202682, -0.04285745695233345, -0.04600393399596214, 0.007271830923855305, -0.0017924767453223467, 0.002396713476628065, 0.014367254450917244, 0.022323796525597572, 0.006001967471092939, 0.012617118656635284, 0.05751617252826691, -0.02204599604010582, -0.02928035520017147, 0.04252338036894798, 0.06586316972970963, 0.02575748786330223, 0.029256748035550117, -0.007837457582354546, 0.056415360420942307, 0.011054258793592453, -0.004387218039482832, -0.03269335627555847, -0.03969389945268631, 0.02353500761091709, -0.05191192030906677, 0.011555523611605167, -0.045294925570487976, 0.04300486296415329, -0.03266759589314461, 0.034995339810848236, 0.0622667595744133, 0.038986243307590485, -0.03090265393257141, 0.02116444520652294, 0.0033436783123761415, 0.022180553525686264, 0.009967408142983913, 0.017346160486340523, 0.05351148173213005, -0.06312716752290726, -0.06081289052963257, 0.0277272816747427, -0.05237816274166107, -0.0026165482122451067, -0.03763561695814133, -0.011092187836766243, 0.04271523654460907, -0.00476353382691741, 0.024006793275475502, 0.03957191854715347, -0.022184301167726517, -0.032778799533843994, -0.02848644368350506, -0.012666593305766582, 0.05195649713277817, -0.012316571548581123, 0.010225939564406872, -0.04609433189034462, 0.000013130954357620794, 0.0034641895908862352, 0.0543217696249485, -0.05268804728984833, -0.037986062467098236, 0.0016173491021618247, -0.022734174504876137, -0.0029143444262444973, 0.06963155418634415, 0.002432870911434293, 0.05095542594790459, 0.03103923611342907, 0.00017018988728523254, 0.0009348546154797077, -0.0715022161602974, -0.0010866279480978847, -0.059399377554655075, -0.030583661049604416, -0.003583996556699276, -0.0005328762345016003, 0.027983849868178368, -0.0918600857257843, -0.030483802780508995, -0.02393343672156334, 0.009265043772757053, 0.026274634525179863, 0.028749391436576843, 0.038497600704431534, 0.07396480441093445, 0.011623476631939411, 0.07597000896930695, 0.02100921981036663, -0.03344639763236046, 0.00017617610865272582, 0.027190199121832848, -0.05242016538977623, -0.0009717956418171525, 0.018725592643022537, 0.02364322356879711, -0.05469399690628052, 0.009776096791028976, -0.031459249556064606, 0.05176148563623428, 0.04454658925533295, -0.027379600331187248, 0.006562171503901482, 0.016850028187036514, -0.0017823186935856938, -0.04060324653983116, 0.0032624395098537207, 0.012233317829668522, -0.006819961126893759, 0.05906118452548981, -0.06637738645076752, -0.009010381065309048, 0.027739468961954117, -0.03185145556926727, -0.037543732672929764, 0.00009064319601748139, -0.005726487375795841, 0.04079094156622887, 0.07936153560876846, 0.05849752575159073, -0.04419546574354172, 0.017076266929507256, -0.006770500913262367, 0.06992435455322266, 0.03836524859070778, 0.05828849971294403, -0.044883109629154205, 0.002669611480087042, 0.032491326332092285, -0.05246296152472496, 0.0006608721450902522 ]
268
268
Optimistic Initialization and Greediness Lead to Polynomial Time Learning in Factored MDPs - Extended Version
In this paper we propose an algorithm for polynomial-time reinforcement learning in factored Markov decision processes (FMDPs). The factored optimistic initial model (FOIM) algorithm, maintains an empirical model of the FMDP in a conventional way, and always follows a greedy policy with respect to its model. The only trick of the algorithm is that the model is initialized optimistically. We prove that with suitable initialization (i) FOIM converges to the fixed point of approximate value iteration (AVI); (ii) the number of steps when the agent makes non-near-optimal decisions (with respect to the solution of AVI) is polynomial in all relevant quantities; (iii) the per-step costs of the algorithm are also polynomial. To our best knowledge, FOIM is the first algorithm with these properties. This extended version contains the rigorous proofs of the main theorem. A version of this paper appeared in ICML'09.
[ -0.04765300825238228, -0.003343980060890317, 0.019688650965690613, -0.012999233789741993, 0.04586110636591911, -0.04019297659397125, 0.010927042923867702, 0.009020566008985043, -0.026400957256555557, 0.04343277961015701, -0.025789132341742516, -0.0036419755779206753, -0.010321416892111301, 0.027303626760840416, 0.034082699567079544, -0.0355062372982502, -0.028619974851608276, -0.004364629741758108, 0.016772007569670677, -0.010083875618875027, 0.04172133281826973, -0.03748328238725662, 0.004961144644767046, 0.0002769697457551956, -0.02088184468448162, 0.008033043704926968, 0.029096446931362152, -0.01606745272874832, 0.04823187366127968, 0.045227617025375366, -0.0803874060511589, -0.01934189163148403, 0.009120233356952667, 0.018931670114398003, -0.018801892176270485, -0.028543217107653618, 0.026198340579867363, -0.023279104381799698, -0.03687547147274017, -0.057597871869802475, -0.06717603653669357, -0.02956085279583931, -0.0064826528541743755, -0.018588170409202576, 0.03738725185394287, 0.08234891295433044, 0.05953017994761467, 0.006392046343535185, -0.0244804248213768, 0.07891955971717834, -0.045355331152677536, 0.018643023446202278, -0.049232497811317444, -0.04355524107813835, 0.039343565702438354, 0.04468570649623871, -0.047111876308918, 0.04953307285904884, 0.015620538033545017, -0.08822570741176605, 0.022807547822594643, 0.013451660983264446, 0.013280750252306461, -0.012925180606544018, -0.10339504480361938, 0.04403069242835045, 0.05136789754033089, 0.03151840344071388, -0.036989275366067886, -0.025486597791314125, 0.05471617355942726, -0.05381128191947937, 0.07412336021661758, 0.018317123875021935, -0.014398249797523022, -0.02271711453795433, -0.016053562983870506, 0.004904840141534805, 0.0698767751455307, 0.11493205279111862, -0.03501265123486519, 0.05810707062482834, -0.011404566466808319, 0.04631931334733963, -0.024412991479039192, -0.015164824202656746, -0.04859454184770584, -0.014602507464587688, 0.012667332775890827, 0.006388972979038954, 0.016945354640483856, 0.05327298864722252, -0.0311990138143301, 0.07748235762119293, -0.04745578393340111, 0.03655087947845459, -0.0671425387263298, 0.0617978572845459, -0.04354875907301903, 0.03868222236633301, 0.000861794629599899, 0.053966742008924484, 0.05361425131559372, 0.048358988016843796, -0.025547657161951065, 0.016750575974583626, 0.007423035800457001, -0.037780217826366425, 0.02978116273880005, -0.060630690306425095, 0.03521112725138664, -0.002921838779002428, 0.09433550387620926, -0.028687959536910057, -0.049181126058101654, 0.030826754868030548, -0.02716085873544216, 0.021356001496315002, 0.0705326497554779, 0.00770743191242218, -0.07386414706707001, -0.05133284628391266, 0.0037678570952266455, 0.06631464511156082, 0.048134393990039825, -0.07112979888916016, -0.004803408402949572, -0.021571526303887367, 0.11525877565145493, -0.009079101495444775, 0.012570974417030811, -0.017553335055708885, 0.004538233391940594, -0.10386151820421219, -0.08007264137268066, 0.0344708114862442, 0.044041913002729416, -0.08277104794979095, -0.04100072383880615, 0.10538981854915619, -0.002881044987589121, -0.007156607694923878, -0.04053352400660515, -0.07451672852039337, -0.012843212112784386, -0.035313162952661514, 0.015572339296340942, 0.017110558226704597, -0.06178189441561699, -0.013951772823929787, -0.051018569618463516, 0.0336175411939621, 0.019026344642043114, 0.020933182910084724, -0.01447299961000681, 0.030998874455690384, 0.018745258450508118, -0.0006998764001764357, 0.018028557300567627, 0.022754564881324768, -0.0009418654954060912, -0.012892715632915497, 0.022773377597332, -0.001462313230149448, 0.04165073484182358, 0.025069795548915863, -0.02544122189283371, 0.020003363490104675, -0.031173208728432655, -0.032882802188396454, -0.02336779795587063, 0.020368734374642372, 0.03229738771915436, 0.001687698531895876, 0.0474674329161644, -0.004754786845296621, -0.057711921632289886, 0.019355807453393936, -0.06685250252485275, 0.04002780839800835, 0.022394955158233643, -0.055161915719509125, -0.043364159762859344, -0.037674110382795334, 0.025797730311751366, -0.024108082056045532, 0.007001337595283985, 0.0024839742109179497, 0.053547993302345276, 0.05238550156354904, -0.06634645164012909, 0.043577954173088074, 0.004233049228787422, 0.060786738991737366, 0.0485043078660965, -0.020916897803544998, -0.009547906927764416, -0.0150736253708601, 0.011104770004749298, 0.031225120648741722, 0.10264898091554642, 0.012058214284479618, -0.028884433209896088, -0.02807530015707016, -0.06468267738819122, -0.0068109952844679356, 0.05909142643213272, 0.011955454014241695, 0.00955512560904026, -0.025397000834345818, 0.008408303372561932, -0.019724858924746513, -0.045237306505441666, 0.02449062280356884, 0.07989127933979034, -0.04824209585785866, -0.08658955246210098, -0.010797073133289814, 0.02659764140844345, -0.0317566841840744, 0.024652842432260513, -0.005616888403892517, -0.02429223619401455, 0.0358838215470314, -0.040522392839193344, -0.016318384557962418, 0.02230747975409031, -0.028468988835811615, -0.09021327644586563, -0.030696403235197067, -0.022440271452069283, -0.00410773791372776, 0.024597931653261185, 0.005693826824426651, -0.038664136081933975, 0.04418278858065605, 0.02062469720840454, -0.059705451130867004, -0.017961673438549042, -0.052762240171432495, -0.02288888767361641, 0.021243521943688393, 0.019968682900071144, -0.029289837926626205, 0.04643255099654198, -0.000757991336286068, -0.0031409268267452717, -0.01959775947034359, -0.055559758096933365, -0.11686286330223083, 0.034242354333400726, 0.07289434224367142, -0.0795978382229805, -0.008830142207443714, 0.029899563640356064, -0.01709919422864914, -0.02574274316430092, 0.12446578592061996, 0.012885205447673798, -0.026806429028511047, -0.020553212612867355, 0.014573529362678528, -0.012440024875104427, 0.03587073087692261, 0.07407192885875702, -0.00653215404599905, 0.000021444831872940995, 0.04191669076681137, 0.037650298327207565, -0.02727784961462021, 0.0296805240213871, 0.008029315620660782, -0.02465984970331192, 0.09233681857585907, -0.02784939669072628, -0.027262955904006958, 0.022535884752869606, -0.0003616299363784492, 0.032532766461372375, -0.057179324328899384, -0.02409498207271099, 0.000044624743168242276, 0.05830346792936325, 0.02077373117208481, -0.003512926632538438, 0.033069249242544174, -0.02148183435201645, 0.04336820915341377, -0.03175010532140732, 0.01932523585855961, -0.100787453353405, -0.07454384863376617, -0.02151513658463955, 0.03715406358242035, 0.03503108769655228, -0.07394065707921982, 0.04993729293346405, 0.01883959211409092, -0.008408654481172562, 0.06545843929052353, 0.041212793439626694, -0.06389698386192322, 0.08837742358446121, 0.015207645483314991, 0.015467132441699505, 0.034334391355514526, 0.04490352421998978, 0.04859870672225952, -0.04366401955485344, 0.06144601106643677, 0.021134762093424797, 0.03291136771440506, -0.03746529296040535, 0.028076892718672752, 0.0777621939778328, 0.035106007009744644, -0.03457862511277199, -0.0381171852350235, -0.03887570649385452, 0.008176987059414387, 0.003608092898502946, -0.07438601553440094, 0.04179445281624794, 0.062404830008745193, -0.08651215583086014, -0.005714087281376123, -0.0026118780951946974, 0.004858389962464571, -0.030162779614329338, 0.03435085713863373, 0.016383811831474304, 0.003590425243601203, -0.03421220928430557, 0.0072973789647221565, -0.044816695153713226, -0.01872509904205799, -0.11458392441272736, -0.07928933948278427, -0.00665209861472249, -0.030677923932671547, -0.08788078278303146, -0.13596569001674652, 0.009260319173336029, -0.007679087109863758, 0.04610853269696236, 0.0028361957520246506, 0.02630031108856201, -0.011210406199097633, 0.025167692452669144, 0.09308572113513947, -0.00975407287478447, -0.026738625019788742, 0.013866976834833622, 0.011323045939207077, -0.02783978544175625, 0.08656178414821625, -0.009042680263519287, -0.05155191197991371, 0.03161102533340454, -0.018689723685383797, -0.06720022857189178, 0.011749759316444397, -0.02015208825469017, 0.021360816434025764, -0.023075828328728676, 0.07884407043457031, -0.011816843412816525, -0.008624490350484848, 0.001087669632397592, -0.040945690125226974, -0.011180425062775612, 0.03197100758552551, 0.0884021446108818, 0.0023912936449050903, 0.1146804466843605, 0.024395279586315155, 0.056756388396024704, -0.014343648217618465, -0.026858747005462646, 0.03410059213638306, 0.018188035115599632, -0.06108478456735611, 0.003941760864108801, -0.11011010408401489, -0.037675488740205765, -0.07252074778079987, -0.03289900720119476, 0.05864917114377022, 0.044033631682395935, -0.0801679939031601, -0.04875338077545166, -0.043518465012311935, 0.01032240130007267, 0.029575034976005554, 0.0167253315448761, -0.05762772262096405, 0.11184307932853699, -0.049724239856004715, -0.020874325186014175, -0.06583493202924728, 0.05736086890101433, -0.07332203537225723, -0.01316563505679369, -0.0757877454161644, -0.046863507479429245, -0.029287731274962425, -0.02165091596543789, -0.0059252455830574036, 0.007519581355154514, 0.09969199448823929, 0.009977887384593487, 0.0006596808088943362, -0.02940760739147663, -0.011269141919910908, 0.006941467989236116, 0.010076789185404778, -0.02476181462407112, 0.05395108461380005, 0.09287253022193909, -0.09751985967159271, 0.028137098997831345, -0.05909641832113266, 0.026648711413145065, 0.019014079123735428, -0.03195038065314293, -0.08752430975437164, 0.03528961166739464, 0.12504661083221436, -0.08044275641441345, 0.0195695199072361, -0.020905766636133194, 0.020977318286895752, -0.030580487102270126, -0.0749296098947525, 0.0004505656543187797, -0.024015434086322784, -0.008756100200116634, 0.03905361145734787, 0.010579768568277359, 0.009644793346524239, -0.03458353504538536, 0.05898261442780495, -0.0656975656747818, -0.024557972326874733, 0.0008303731447085738, 0.11122497916221619, -0.014393595047295094, -0.05817284807562828, 0.037527889013290405, 0.023598631843924522, 0.05843158811330795, 0.0019795638509094715, 0.06686388701200485, -0.00343308481387794, 0.011458075605332851, 0.06012505292892456, -0.005482351873070002, -0.010489407926797867, 0.035578321665525436, -0.020423373207449913, -0.044867828488349915, -0.015312837436795235, 0.05449342355132103, -0.013541661202907562, -0.033934690058231354, -0.04998868331313133, 0.027374429628252983, -0.0045091803185641766, 0.07732012122869492, 0.009618240408599377, -0.04075353220105171, 0.031159624457359314, 0.005567467771470547, -0.03288305178284645, -0.07437457144260406, -0.00819503515958786, 0.059360697865486145, 0.01778731867671013, -0.023929575458168983, 0.015330612659454346, 0.04596957191824913, 0.02016410231590271, -0.054695624858140945, 0.04311534762382507, 0.017133869230747223, 0.036444079130887985, 0.020545337349176407, -0.015931833535432816, 0.0782642737030983, 0.0428958423435688, -0.014690050855278969, -0.052407700568437576, -0.003955187276005745, 0.02628301829099655, -0.022416243329644203, -0.04467593878507614, 0.021384065970778465, 0.008235619403421879, 0.03091457672417164, 0.05057617276906967, 0.049292709678411484, -0.04634727165102959, -0.004299326334148645, -0.010457245633006096, 0.041141897439956665, 0.013451685197651386, 0.026811283081769943, -0.011190014891326427, -0.06928138434886932, 0.0539676696062088, 0.0037447158247232437, 0.06189198046922684 ]
269
269
Introduction to Machine Learning: Class Notes 67577
Introduction to Machine learning covering Statistical Inference (Bayes, EM, ML/MaxEnt duality), algebraic and spectral methods (PCA, LDA, CCA, Clustering), and PAC learning (the Formal model, VC dimension, Double Sampling theorem).
[ 0.02619405835866928, -0.05081038177013397, 0.013665314763784409, 0.0022590383887290955, 0.006947209592908621, -0.06016410142183304, 0.06184493377804756, 0.01357685774564743, -0.06567949801683426, -0.061304930597543716, 0.011563080362975597, 0.028117092326283455, 0.0021872036159038544, 0.020985763520002365, -0.0008968890178948641, 0.033036112785339355, 0.009740397334098816, -0.0063154189847409725, 0.030752429738640785, -0.03936485946178436, 0.00961238145828247, -0.04889587312936783, 0.012256708927452564, -0.00799695122987032, 0.06299548596143723, 0.02142459712922573, -0.019579986110329628, -0.05661916360259056, -0.04553970694541931, 0.03813986852765083, -0.03203100711107254, -0.010371645912528038, -0.030707640573382378, -0.003533079521730542, 0.05788382887840271, 0.009232671931385994, -0.012072278186678886, 0.02079327404499054, -0.06827081739902496, -0.003569887951016426, -0.026496274396777153, 0.026516113430261612, -0.0072829811833798885, 0.011512013152241707, -0.0020296629518270493, -0.01338026113808155, 0.044041480869054794, 0.05934586375951767, 0.013730213977396488, 0.07557114958763123, -0.14244091510772705, 0.032999031245708466, -0.102176234126091, 0.010930205695331097, -0.05159537494182587, -0.034195076674222946, 0.03701841086149216, 0.04613833129405975, -0.019784873351454735, -0.035776372998952866, 0.052408572286367416, 0.07707542181015015, 0.03523083031177521, 0.03208094835281372, -0.08438258618116379, 0.0008141279104165733, -0.05440538004040718, -0.03314289450645447, -0.0335635207593441, -0.02878204733133316, -0.03152347356081009, -0.04115770757198334, 0.005789560731500387, 0.05389269441366196, 0.010619464330375195, -0.042547136545181274, -0.04863348975777626, -0.017094051465392113, -0.04328152537345886, 0.0778004378080368, 0.030052602291107178, 0.04217005893588066, 0.0159868486225605, -0.006722948048263788, -0.036532845348119736, -0.020596424117684364, 0.004344805143773556, 0.026982227340340614, -0.019144326448440552, -0.0034639956429600716, -0.005616676528006792, 0.008318115025758743, 0.006071165204048157, 0.020982159301638603, -0.023203961551189423, 0.03198299929499626, -0.06635583937168121, -0.048114605247974396, -0.06148359924554825, 0.019957099109888077, -0.020643170922994614, -0.00813291035592556, 0.03317512944340706, 0.07232704758644104, -0.020579317584633827, 0.06376978754997253, -0.024699553847312927, 0.10478328168392181, 0.010520273819565773, 0.01585480384528637, 0.07053109258413315, 0.02373625338077545, 0.040178678929805756, 0.05688480660319328, -0.06524631381034851, 0.03113957867026329, -0.04659762606024742, 0.07304973155260086, 0.04736107587814331, -0.02885894849896431, 0.04687163606286049, -0.03600667789578438, -0.08408098667860031, 0.012077043764293194, 0.028094425797462463, -0.0021755024790763855, 0.016732631251215935, -0.03359389677643776, 0.06420188397169113, -0.023915918543934822, 0.03151185065507889, 0.060866329818964005, -0.0019326432375237346, -0.010839384980499744, -0.07293984293937683, -0.03803851082921028, -0.048958953469991684, -0.03285850211977959, -0.055073514580726624, 0.013649874366819859, -0.029647549614310265, -0.03646047040820122, -0.03964382782578468, 0.04463568702340126, 0.028913086280226707, 0.05942126363515854, 0.01702074520289898, 0.03675951063632965, 0.011076685041189194, 0.022570157423615456, -0.066617451608181, -0.04764407500624657, -0.01359215285629034, 0.02175920642912388, 0.037264369428157806, -0.07606834918260574, -0.0447731614112854, -0.010624733753502369, -0.0232780072838068, 0.055305447429418564, -0.011483767069876194, 0.03241712599992752, -0.011293990537524223, 0.06648106873035431, -0.02415323629975319, -0.005459814332425594, -0.01803162507712841, 0.02662615105509758, -0.06737067550420761, -0.1279059648513794, -0.040580086410045624, 0.02336018532514572, -0.04679274559020996, -0.012568380683660507, -0.036502547562122345, -0.02392510138452053, -0.03620830923318863, -0.022251123562455177, -0.010481218807399273, -0.00499046640470624, 0.04507537558674812, -0.030002929270267487, -0.030403098091483116, -0.015455566346645355, 0.01518177893012762, 0.02680182456970215, -0.043153274804353714, 0.05585695430636406, 0.040964096784591675, 0.07101667672395706, 0.048170242458581924, 0.019684288650751114, -0.003816311713308096, -0.06840471923351288, 0.010553131811320782, 0.01740231364965439, -0.02099219523370266, -0.0156698115170002, -0.010048815049231052, 0.0673275887966156, 0.04983058199286461, -0.019678553566336632, -0.012057090178132057, -0.03791607543826103, -0.05419274419546127, 0.060899339616298676, 0.0995173379778862, -0.012378835119307041, 0.012303048744797707, 0.02761138044297695, -0.0064146863296628, 0.06707744300365448, -0.0027675970923155546, 0.0007605036371387541, 0.017796127125620842, 0.04055962711572647, -0.06252356618642807, -0.0003110517282038927, 0.022032752633094788, 0.08885137736797333, -0.0385490283370018, 0.02470172382891178, -0.03320101276040077, 0.05888812243938446, -0.02483934722840786, -0.014922733418643475, 0.03620288893580437, 0.019358979538083076, -0.055521801114082336, 0.047620128840208054, -0.06884612143039703, -0.05457090213894844, -0.08570706844329834, 0.0006098597659729421, 0.008656133897602558, 0.018893098458647728, 0.0015062837628647685, 0.013337485492229462, 0.03057822771370411, -0.0078714145347476, -0.05988900363445282, 0.03314661234617233, 0.03627108037471771, -0.007341254502534866, -0.07196345180273056, -0.0694170743227005, -0.004525671247392893, 0.035573810338974, -0.045709412544965744, -0.05985087528824806, -0.07284189760684967, -0.017142407596111298, 0.02982253022491932, -0.011318749748170376, -0.04581263288855553, -0.005488893017172813, -0.07062098383903503, 0.07328491657972336, 0.0921643003821373, 0.09878488630056381, -0.00978472363203764, -0.003673726925626397, -0.03678872436285019, 0.03298357129096985, 0.08036556839942932, -0.002767151454463601, -0.003716269973665476, 0.053569402545690536, -0.03974177688360214, 0.0073172710835933685, -0.06949332356452942, 0.0176982544362545, -0.009296989999711514, 0.07275975495576859, -0.036807719618082047, 0.011320415884256363, 0.0171419158577919, 0.06625169515609741, 0.0006197399343363941, -0.062174078077077866, -0.05390075221657753, -0.023112056776881218, -0.01964988373219967, 0.025330916047096252, -0.009552073664963245, 0.025520602241158485, 0.04679553955793381, -0.012585196644067764, -0.03699539601802826, 0.03524694964289665, 0.02369583770632744, 0.02819342166185379, -0.04744693636894226, 0.007674779277294874, 0.053525734692811966, -0.03436168283224106, 0.02946263924241066, 0.06218864768743515, 0.07775084674358368, -0.06194687634706497, -0.021706977859139442, -0.005959577392786741, 0.0994386076927185, 0.04057899862527847, 0.029900021851062775, 0.06149060279130936, 0.05850934237241745, 0.03058568201959133, -0.039806563407182693, 0.04945482313632965, 0.06591227650642395, -0.019043123349547386, 0.02444392815232277, -0.0026237142737954855, -0.030010059475898743, -0.023173121735453606, 0.015846900641918182, 0.002593027660623193, 0.002717711729928851, -0.020261136814951897, 0.035770706832408905, 0.033685725182294846, -0.0027906314935535192, -0.036757729947566986, -0.08429641276597977, 0.014214769005775452, 0.057333946228027344, -0.00010550496517680585, -0.07369647175073624, 0.001699548214673996, -0.010048273019492626, -0.040041014552116394, 0.0010083996457979083, 0.13640153408050537, -0.0022216099314391613, 0.02152952179312706, -0.05331739783287048, -0.017167899757623672, 0.01063341274857521, 0.012266380712389946, -0.059666138142347336, 0.02381281368434429, -0.011636464856564999, 0.0558343268930912, -0.019811686128377914, 0.026296967640519142, 0.08275618404150009, -0.006057681981474161, 0.005671463441103697, 0.06685798615217209, -0.07949069142341614, -0.015556924976408482, -0.030761418864130974, 0.09184589236974716, -0.05844239145517349, 0.05170603469014168, 0.039491768926382065, -0.02058613859117031, -0.031374070793390274, 0.0015487880446016788, 0.011558509431779385, 0.015217472799122334, -0.031405530869960785, -0.03266027569770813, -0.001964569790288806, 0.10411166399717331, -0.07517191767692566, 0.02956738881766796, -0.019953804090619087, -0.10212234407663345, 0.0302592720836401, -0.0027213634457439184, 0.03160391002893448, 0.07945937663316727, 0.0662834644317627, 0.016365397721529007, -0.009764808230102062, 0.03364775329828262, -0.03743310645222664, 0.08455771207809448, -0.062425851821899414, -0.05452781915664673, -0.02439294569194317, 0.004203150514513254, -0.041046593338251114, -0.0988980233669281, 0.006672772578895092, 0.017324259504675865, 0.04423501342535019, 0.04258308932185173, -0.024621518328785896, -0.04671324044466019, 0.014022279530763626, -0.013402888551354408, 0.07257191836833954, 0.019411519169807434, -0.00489623611792922, 0.01522735320031643, -0.022414516657590866, 0.045001495629549026, 0.03810819610953331, -0.001528930850327015, 0.04839178919792175, -0.012785744853317738, -0.03303099796175957, -0.012921917252242565, -0.03469613939523697, 0.061556626111269, -0.019157927483320236, 0.0034511706326156855, 0.048669133335351944, 0.0204937681555748, -0.01585790328681469, 0.013441343791782856, 0.0959530845284462, 0.05461212620139122, 0.013192718848586082, -0.06453952193260193, -0.019631294533610344, -0.13151606917381287, 0.03907030448317528, 0.01456472184509039, 0.0009342400589957833, 0.012988094240427017, 0.010331815108656883, -0.01547385472804308, 0.03777565807104111, 0.08476880192756653, 0.02291026897728443, 0.04051824286580086, 0.010023785755038261, 0.018717657774686813, -0.017901049926877022, -0.00874447450041771, 0.0015193799044936895, -0.00032259797444567084, 0.03426187485456467, -0.026965254917740822, 0.04137840121984482, -0.0241182092577219, -0.10505489259958267, 0.05848345905542374, 0.07121293991804123, -0.028786620125174522, -0.0013056579045951366, 0.08316534757614136, 0.013670234940946102, -0.025692377239465714, 0.06532489508390427, 0.08453012257814407, 0.05781625583767891, 0.04133768007159233, 0.05571948364377022, -0.03026345744729042, 0.06286344677209854, 0.03869625926017761, -0.02341892570257187, -0.03021990694105625, 0.0727740153670311, -0.09447851032018661, 0.03284408524632454, -0.047663599252700806, 0.004799798130989075, 0.05387843772768974, -0.12047233432531357, 0.03670518845319748, -0.011620346456766129, 0.07067569345235825, 0.025227969512343407, -0.014521868899464607, 0.0331137590110302, 0.014374557882547379, -0.002590702846646309, -0.060720957815647125, -0.020594507455825806, 0.005777215585112572, 0.006454594433307648, -0.024187643080949783, -0.005433331243693829, -0.04186892509460449, 0.06546314060688019, -0.055690813809633255, -0.08336403220891953, 0.03964971750974655, 0.007063369732350111, 0.013328767381608486, -0.035158921033144, -0.02850702963769436, -0.01653820276260376, -0.0021563423797488213, -0.002018814207985997, -0.014527525752782822, 0.0044107697904109955, -0.02911289967596531, -0.08864865452051163, 0.02472900040447712, 0.016734490171074867, -0.025312667712569237, 0.025235330685973167, 0.01730234920978546, 0.07256223261356354, -0.049555640667676926, 0.10861896723508835, 0.003713557729497552, 0.09434398263692856, -0.018951836973428726, 0.07511868327856064, 0.0020535304211080074, 0.0005222941399551928, 0.027262281626462936, -0.03066582791507244, -0.06890067458152771 ]
270
270
Considerations upon the Machine Learning Technologies
Artificial intelligence offers superior techniques and methods by which problems from diverse domains may find an optimal solution. The Machine Learning technologies refer to the domain of artificial intelligence aiming to develop the techniques allowing the computers to "learn". Some systems based on Machine Learning technologies tend to eliminate the necessity of the human intelligence while the others adopt a man-machine collaborative approach.
[ -0.007105112075805664, -0.023050127550959587, 0.03725624457001686, 0.02736831083893776, -0.005011219996958971, -0.07300783693790436, 0.03646213933825493, -0.005689686164259911, -0.05956604331731796, -0.03905505686998367, 0.032648004591464996, 0.021291542798280716, -0.01412053033709526, -0.022465217858552933, -0.010356673039495945, 0.0152138601988554, 0.06341901421546936, -0.04971517249941826, 0.09221787750720978, -0.021262748166918755, 0.002116927644237876, -0.009121779352426529, -0.014690862968564034, 0.04324720799922943, -0.03319505974650383, -0.017332501709461212, -0.10451998561620712, 0.027693631127476692, -0.04482610896229744, 0.023081893101334572, -0.024192577227950096, -0.04413784295320511, 0.01437324844300747, -0.04581732675433159, 0.0317884236574173, 0.024978967383503914, 0.05174063518643379, -0.043056610971689224, -0.07436492294073105, 0.023963069543242455, -0.0385013185441494, -0.0333152711391449, 0.023438522592186928, 0.06079899147152901, 0.01894659548997879, 0.053442079573869705, 0.01908031292259693, 0.009548342786729336, 0.026143129914999008, 0.10218364000320435, -0.050831858068704605, -0.044666189700365067, -0.03649020567536354, -0.0047905403189361095, -0.03226035088300705, 0.003224440850317478, -0.02703654021024704, -0.041040580719709396, -0.004841989371925592, -0.061767756938934326, 0.02982570044696331, 0.058010365813970566, 0.005380076821893454, 0.034872885793447495, -0.06206668168306351, 0.008280539885163307, -0.10848459601402283, -0.07616220414638519, -0.10265007615089417, -0.06033346801996231, -0.05824282020330429, -0.0844024047255516, 0.0879218578338623, 0.09152769297361374, 0.04460528492927551, 0.08849354088306427, 0.09504314512014389, 0.03477618470788002, 0.0029502264223992825, 0.0006171896820887923, 0.01587604358792305, -0.07211608439683914, -0.053841475397348404, -0.0022807877976447344, -0.02417977899312973, 0.04292640462517738, 0.018122192472219467, -0.025180308148264885, -0.018132377415895462, 0.022187981754541397, 0.03866426646709442, -0.030024811625480652, -0.0776478573679924, -0.025316759943962097, 0.0020119724795222282, -0.00215486460365355, -0.11149099469184875, -0.07860993593931198, -0.03947214037179947, 0.03459577262401581, -0.01754549704492092, 0.020901575684547424, 0.10477295517921448, 0.06875590234994888, -0.015323557890951633, 0.05660856142640114, 0.0029229738283902407, 0.0612405426800251, -0.016864780336618423, 0.012487199157476425, 0.0014354337472468615, 0.041058752685785294, 0.028840310871601105, 0.08582983911037445, 0.0009708131547085941, -0.05282298102974892, -0.10091286897659302, 0.050719644874334335, 0.02635384164750576, 0.0028073701541870832, -0.015113419853150845, -0.0018974189879372716, 0.020940283313393593, 0.036603350192308426, 0.07122182846069336, -0.046326618641614914, 0.018603788688778877, -0.025352496653795242, 0.023063838481903076, 0.004537465050816536, -0.0438009537756443, 0.012073549441993237, -0.04335634037852287, -0.01875484175980091, 0.010016926564276218, 0.07732739299535751, -0.017127733677625656, -0.01403878629207611, -0.01334946509450674, -0.0017966346349567175, 0.002006630413234234, 0.033832818269729614, -0.03097442165017128, -0.018227791413664818, 0.10554175078868866, 0.010127166286110878, -0.023836975917220116, 0.04613213241100311, 0.048617687076330185, 0.006880015134811401, 0.0408736951649189, -0.00041947755380533636, -0.00035640166606754065, 0.03996463492512703, 0.007016707677394152, -0.009177600033581257, -0.0791127160191536, -0.07401179522275925, 0.011187758296728134, 0.023734819144010544, 0.07103002816438675, 0.03862067684531212, -0.020142322406172752, 0.07593932002782822, 0.014417527243494987, 0.006801505573093891, -0.047301895916461945, -0.03137226030230522, -0.020448416471481323, -0.037352126091718674, -0.07964383065700531, -0.10461685806512833, 0.015259454026818275, 0.06937960535287857, -0.05675642192363739, -0.01840156316757202, -0.04149092733860016, -0.015892067924141884, -0.02859303541481495, 0.057157933712005615, -0.00527806393802166, -0.07127530127763748, -0.004211223218590021, 0.04018688574433327, 0.03626875579357147, 0.006681388709694147, -0.009358200244605541, 0.07258207350969315, 0.05882553383708, -0.007379365619271994, 0.020147835835814476, -0.03694164752960205, 0.056194908916950226, -0.03795957565307617, -0.022742860019207, 0.013874211348593235, 0.050096545368433, -0.011030596680939198, 0.005642849951982498, -0.007717198692262173, 0.003985665272921324, 0.014528138563036919, -0.008813313208520412, -0.042967624962329865, -0.02242579497396946, 0.020955339074134827, 0.0101860286667943, 0.0027515715919435024, -0.015216260217130184, 0.028286511078476906, -0.000514891289640218, 0.03617219626903534, 0.015578489750623703, 0.07240427285432816, -0.03411126136779785, -0.023339280858635902, -0.074728824198246, -0.11440596729516983, 0.03456816077232361, 0.029368571937084198, 0.015467077493667603, 0.023444293066859245, -0.032302193343639374, 0.037694476544857025, 0.020119568333029747, 0.0036658295430243015, 0.08541207760572433, -0.008470052853226662, -0.010658684186637402, -0.003892479930073023, -0.033126845955848694, -0.0693197250366211, -0.07773267477750778, -0.01982657052576542, 0.03931136429309845, 0.030701620504260063, -0.03169700875878334, -0.0630706399679184, -0.0029165816958993673, -0.014684042893350124, 0.03392123430967331, 0.07801925390958786, -0.006190578918904066, -0.06764227151870728, 0.03399082273244858, 0.002946513006463647, 0.010876135900616646, -0.0013671014457941055, -0.02519059367477894, -0.006260311231017113, -0.026783687993884087, 0.039559196680784225, 0.0171506330370903, -0.0025319629348814487, -0.02978050708770752, 0.015584059990942478, -0.015322471968829632, 0.0322379544377327, 0.023029301315546036, 0.07916870713233948, -0.08666308224201202, -0.0838218629360199, 0.017746038734912872, 0.008496963419020176, 0.04253486543893814, -0.0023257522843778133, 0.01368812657892704, 0.028305714949965477, -0.04158461093902588, -0.029018282890319824, -0.05114198476076126, -0.000290211959509179, -0.032641150057315826, 0.07531742006540298, -0.07199165225028992, 0.024877727031707764, -0.008125007152557373, 0.024724435061216354, -0.019004542380571365, -0.027184683829545975, -0.08774176985025406, -0.04307783767580986, -0.027498632669448853, -0.029722001403570175, 0.04957457259297371, 0.025685029104351997, -0.014594299718737602, -0.04558078944683075, 0.002553774043917656, 0.014795183204114437, 0.05070986598730087, -0.03767693415284157, -0.05682961270213127, -0.051716919988393784, -0.0030233007855713367, -0.06745760887861252, 0.002762998454272747, -0.04125712066888809, -0.010541672818362713, -0.009849638678133488, 0.014555249363183975, 0.013652504421770573, 0.08951909840106964, 0.10585804283618927, 0.04517091065645218, 0.0857999250292778, -0.01504520047456026, 0.06794185191392899, -0.015822909772396088, 0.0383758582174778, -0.041145022958517075, 0.05115489289164543, -0.0056955707259476185, 0.0005685971700586379, 0.022424738854169846, 0.034715183079242706, 0.05031776800751686, 0.05110872909426689, -0.02792949602007866, 0.017081698402762413, 0.009257243946194649, -0.009456814266741276, -0.023426495492458344, 0.017942121252417564, -0.08123626559972763, -0.03756741061806679, -0.03628898039460182, -0.0554690808057785, -0.04100304841995239, -0.007320774719119072, -0.031723491847515106, -0.03797134757041931, 0.05553891509771347, 0.08739439398050308, -0.05771041661500931, -0.015764031559228897, 0.05354492366313934, 0.061100490391254425, -0.0009451100486330688, -0.05115295201539993, -0.07363062351942062, -0.058852896094322205, -0.060261018574237823, 0.060180578380823135, -0.012275288812816143, 0.002339605474844575, 0.06496372073888779, 0.004252880811691284, -0.02329622395336628, 0.07073070108890533, -0.04452506825327873, 0.02079104818403721, -0.054420534521341324, 0.04551977291703224, 0.028187155723571777, 0.0072407848201692104, 0.033687155693769455, 0.028633199632167816, 0.03496633097529411, 0.03516361117362976, -0.030156562104821205, 0.009430646896362305, -0.06006196513772011, -0.05885438248515129, 0.00729943485930562, 0.05272718891501427, 0.000008170156434061937, 0.05495567247271538, -0.040543749928474426, -0.07943883538246155, -0.008169456385076046, -0.0028579123318195343, 0.0362548865377903, -0.02500779740512371, 0.05424243211746216, -0.04702838882803917, 0.06818818300962448, 0.058366402983665466, 0.07732030749320984, 0.037145402282476425, -0.09891214966773987, -0.018352799117565155, 0.01434491015970707, 0.008549526333808899, -0.001504222978837788, 0.019922949373722076, -0.05157597362995148, -0.02925487421452999, -0.01721520721912384, 0.01200187485665083, -0.056958675384521484, 0.0516568198800087, -0.054920367896556854, 0.0558946393430233, 0.014389874413609505, 0.013993135653436184, -0.0410279855132103, -0.09305934607982635, 0.022049997001886368, 0.023028645664453506, 0.008501362055540085, -0.03730733320116997, 0.04917023330926895, -0.04531363025307655, 0.002091103233397007, 0.03036230243742466, -0.027054188773036003, 0.03930177167057991, -0.09478867799043655, -0.013103445991873741, 0.0893452987074852, -0.007653894368559122, -0.015347803942859173, -0.0016298606060445309, 0.04807205870747566, -0.018961848691105843, 0.05075204372406006, 0.004407428205013275, 0.0407855361700058, -0.09716778993606567, -0.03130307048559189, 0.02717108465731144, -0.014036900363862514, -0.017907269299030304, 0.04274163022637367, 0.03290762007236481, 0.026491649448871613, 0.004484673496335745, 0.04823312163352966, 0.04212621599435806, -0.02815733104944229, 0.009470497258007526, -0.01755760982632637, 0.00937891099601984, 0.019026638939976692, -0.00538236228749156, -0.01756063848733902, -0.02997327782213688, 0.01748526468873024, -0.04041130840778351, -0.022064147517085075, 0.02361072413623333, 0.04936123266816139, 0.0029250590596348047, -0.019772278144955635, 0.05067082867026329, -0.02461674064397812, -0.056141775101423264, 0.017278224229812622, -0.029945138841867447, 0.004447593353688717, -0.00722550367936492, 0.03884595260024071, -0.04888107627630234, 0.020173944532871246, -0.0066758752800524235, -0.07269513607025146, 0.016474291682243347, 0.040240250527858734, -0.0778048038482666, 0.02802298031747341, 0.11034990847110748, 0.00810731016099453, 0.07632217556238174, 0.014940074644982815, -0.11956247687339783, 0.0381055548787117, 0.017639540135860443, 0.05327261984348297, -0.0063210162334144115, -0.03951156511902809, -0.02849385142326355, 0.016355054453015327, -0.0011673610424622893, 0.01717241294682026, -0.05638459697365761, -0.008603118360042572, -0.08615528047084808, -0.0215399619191885, -0.04808851331472397, -0.0054396106861531734, -0.013787511736154556, -0.024905437603592873, -0.010580524802207947, -0.04894552379846573, -0.05138217285275459, -0.0303634162992239, 0.07375994324684143, 0.04824334755539894, -0.015603057108819485, 0.06986935436725616, -0.07625613361597061, 0.030411293730139732, -0.003466889029368758, -0.07618505507707596, -0.014797567389905453, 0.03398579731583595, -0.004568288568407297, 0.0716586709022522, 0.031638845801353455, 0.04386403039097786, -0.00984641071408987, -0.026292135939002037, 0.04752814397215843, 0.00302444351837039, -0.03324722498655319, 0.1096901223063469, 0.013239053077995777, 0.04101480543613434, 0.06862577795982361, 0.022046126425266266, -0.07533296197652817 ]
271
271
Limits of Learning about a Categorical Latent Variable under Prior Near-Ignorance
In this paper, we consider the coherent theory of (epistemic) uncertainty of Walley, in which beliefs are represented through sets of probability distributions, and we focus on the problem of modeling prior ignorance about a categorical random variable. In this setting, it is a known result that a state of prior ignorance is not compatible with learning. To overcome this problem, another state of beliefs, called \emph{near-ignorance}, has been proposed. Near-ignorance resembles ignorance very closely, by satisfying some principles that can arguably be regarded as necessary in a state of ignorance, and allows learning to take place. What this paper does, is to provide new and substantial evidence that also near-ignorance cannot be really regarded as a way out of the problem of starting statistical inference in conditions of very weak beliefs. The key to this result is focusing on a setting characterized by a variable of interest that is \emph{latent}. We argue that such a setting is by far the most common case in practice, and we provide, for the case of categorical latent variables (and general \emph{manifest} variables) a condition that, if satisfied, prevents learning to take place under prior near-ignorance. This condition is shown to be easily satisfied even in the most common statistical problems. We regard these results as a strong form of evidence against the possibility to adopt a condition of prior near-ignorance in real statistical problems.
[ 0.019271543249487877, -0.057860273867845535, 0.025632519274950027, -0.0464395172894001, 0.03528471663594246, -0.012000326998531818, 0.023374006152153015, -0.021893218159675598, -0.005189776886254549, 0.06318793445825577, -0.010722227394580841, -0.011321275494992733, 0.05845804139971733, 0.06445170193910599, 0.041437119245529175, -0.05683582276105881, 0.03316284343600273, 0.04215899109840393, -0.0066527631133794785, -0.09083488583564758, -0.010968244634568691, 0.028250636532902718, 0.022325491532683372, -0.07104631513357162, 0.026466654613614082, 0.004176154732704163, -0.046060219407081604, -0.027612632140517235, 0.000523122726008296, -0.12939533591270447, -0.10044708102941513, 0.01528992410749197, 0.012107332237064838, -0.04389236122369766, 0.07847514748573303, -0.04312429577112198, -0.008308223448693752, 0.0534697063267231, -0.08697357028722763, -0.035441990941762924, 0.012097586877644062, -0.04387299716472626, 0.06198327615857124, 0.01278043631464243, -0.00524481013417244, -0.01992797665297985, 0.0685933455824852, 0.0282549150288105, -0.05375787243247032, 0.03685945272445679, -0.10982125997543335, 0.018255110830068588, -0.03977816551923752, 0.043093740940093994, 0.04031112417578697, 0.039091408252716064, -0.011683866381645203, 0.006550533697009087, -0.029851440340280533, -0.012588463723659515, 0.01297952700406313, 0.046877421438694, -0.027053002268075943, -0.018975241109728813, -0.009543721564114094, 0.013246512971818447, -0.057245884090662, -0.005970711819827557, 0.024384092539548874, -0.0229164008051157, 0.0054171341471374035, -0.04222818464040756, -0.007048563566058874, 0.0016347098862752318, 0.006199834868311882, 0.007404318079352379, 0.003198425518348813, 0.005663941614329815, -0.0705249086022377, 0.09663353115320206, -0.05785222724080086, 0.02343994937837124, -0.000479533220641315, -0.028115101158618927, -0.05571206659078598, 0.0003522550978232175, -0.0146181033924222, 0.02673894539475441, -0.0724434033036232, 0.003209016751497984, -0.019968295469880104, 0.05455517768859863, 0.014371665194630623, 0.04694017395377159, 0.0232939962297678, 0.0178596843034029, 0.07836245000362396, -0.032676611095666885, 0.035708166658878326, -0.01980726234614849, 0.042483702301979065, -0.03181717172265053, 0.05702647939324379, -0.0460466705262661, -0.02369106188416481, 0.022859660908579826, 0.07129739224910736, -0.018080497160553932, 0.04975300654768944, -0.07836109399795532, 0.016698414459824562, -0.04065017029643059, 0.04141225293278694, 0.0341472402215004, -0.054348528385162354, 0.07175863534212112, 0.048783671110868454, 0.005781945772469044, 0.07524333149194717, 0.11250578612089157, 0.024895166978240013, -0.005873051472008228, -0.06178438663482666, 0.002245318843051791, -0.012377451173961163, 0.039307549595832825, 0.0010855193249881268, -0.08705724030733109, 0.16296425461769104, -0.03218313306570053, 0.0030204581562429667, -0.0701398104429245, -0.0825071930885315, -0.08658189326524734, -0.029154760763049126, 0.04517994076013565, -0.015947669744491577, 0.014975935220718384, -0.050899047404527664, 0.013693513348698616, -0.06944616883993149, -0.08278326690196991, 0.021418852731585503, -0.007286982145160437, -0.0024256156757473946, 0.04734526202082634, -0.04466801509261131, 0.013257751241326332, -0.038400229066610336, -0.03304752707481384, -0.05713626742362976, 0.014412783086299896, 0.008358530700206757, 0.0739763081073761, 0.075236015021801, -0.06730234622955322, 0.013278007507324219, -0.015793778002262115, -0.025060204789042473, 0.057083263993263245, 0.010720068588852882, 0.027088472619652748, 0.02688315138220787, 0.07565438747406006, -0.028607841581106186, -0.007380387280136347, -0.004900919273495674, -0.0216435045003891, -0.053014885634183884, -0.06466443836688995, 0.018694277852773666, 0.03183262050151825, 0.03363596647977829, -0.044462449848651886, -0.030899928882718086, -0.041672613471746445, -0.03812359645962715, -0.004172365181148052, 0.018680421635508537, -0.011670690029859543, 0.007533298339694738, -0.03140765056014061, -0.016876408830285072, 0.034532394260168076, 0.045616645365953445, 0.11284139007329941, -0.02946573868393898, 0.037706781178712845, 0.050776492804288864, -0.026300378143787384, 0.011823384091258049, -0.050662845373153687, -0.07538830488920212, -0.05029687285423279, -0.01396859996020794, 0.028791142627596855, -0.011283141560852528, -0.01817268691956997, -0.03157665207982063, 0.0688035860657692, -0.03491898998618126, 0.03356471657752991, -0.035873893648386, 0.0301799513399601, -0.1054249033331871, -0.005682836752384901, -0.011785374023020267, -0.030893810093402863, 0.020245680585503578, 0.0023563564755022526, -0.001215964788571, -0.03589409217238426, -0.00354788894765079, -0.008373393677175045, 0.00019898373284377158, -0.09705909341573715, -0.03721243515610695, -0.031719088554382324, 0.04041744023561478, 0.034890756011009216, -0.09708824753761292, 0.03256789222359657, 0.030291318893432617, 0.044136084616184235, -0.03491465374827385, -0.06671305000782013, 0.08163785934448242, -0.03663003444671631, 0.003050632541999221, 0.04876713082194328, -0.11890208721160889, 0.004477228038012981, -0.04347960278391838, -0.014760090038180351, 0.004172525368630886, -0.05274912342429161, 0.0018485001055523753, -0.06549785286188126, -0.04568513110280037, 0.058128081262111664, -0.03378238528966904, 0.02210700325667858, -0.04178791120648384, 0.039128243923187256, 0.04924234747886658, -0.08407331258058548, -0.010189028456807137, 0.05841343104839325, 0.04352067783474922, 0.05964120477437973, -0.046324245631694794, -0.010848341509699821, -0.02676883339881897, 0.002848484320566058, 0.027542412281036377, -0.031391263008117676, -0.038488030433654785, 0.042155101895332336, 0.031885962933301926, 0.020136862993240356, 0.02360537461936474, 0.02358943037688732, -0.012872160412371159, 0.019242579117417336, 0.08385518938302994, 0.0011087508173659444, 0.05625234916806221, 0.02824154682457447, 0.007874137721955776, 0.0035986588336527348, -0.0013181250542402267, 0.025043347850441933, 0.0017196043627336621, 0.04001384228467941, -0.04569036141037941, -0.008130834437906742, 0.019865863025188446, -0.009514577686786652, 0.009248757734894753, -0.04083940386772156, -0.01228819414973259, 0.01842482015490532, 0.023091809824109077, -0.02262413501739502, 0.01126004382967949, -0.018066510558128357, 0.07349192351102829, 0.0073991515673696995, -0.004784127697348595, -0.0031413740944117308, 0.05326620861887932, -0.005102429538965225, -0.05417843163013458, -0.04197879508137703, -0.022064216434955597, -0.0018009174382314086, 0.055187299847602844, -0.03934953361749649, 0.028024641796946526, -0.014645303599536419, 0.003340340219438076, 0.03123222105205059, 0.048797041177749634, 0.010505665093660355, 0.05105280131101608, 0.018890615552663803, 0.04757557809352875, 0.0574449747800827, -0.013169629499316216, -0.02641470730304718, 0.02347113937139511, -0.014484245330095291, -0.027120091021060944, 0.029593821614980698, -0.041131675243377686, -0.07209537923336029, -0.0032253905665129423, -0.08920972794294357, -0.009751592762768269, -0.04974496737122536, 0.012502714991569519, -0.06298279017210007, 0.03296295553445816, -0.0322469137609005, -0.055759575217962265, -0.01579643227159977, 0.010111886076629162, 0.03421371057629585, -0.0717073380947113, 0.06269925087690353, -0.05388285219669342, -0.019453193992376328, -0.04199794679880142, 0.12117777019739151, -0.025894328951835632, 0.026461416855454445, -0.0666290819644928, 0.008728963322937489, -0.0007637757225893438, 0.034924253821372986, 0.04248424619436264, -0.07129741460084915, -0.025571703910827637, 0.015351076610386372, 0.009874873794615269, 0.04797029122710228, 0.12397848814725876, 0.023106323555111885, -0.033961664885282516, 0.04189053550362587, 0.04563470184803009, 0.010252872481942177, -0.010588695295155048, 0.02141556888818741, 0.02539793774485588, 0.05298460274934769, 0.01069151796400547, -0.015504791401326656, 0.027317453175783157, 0.007657522335648537, 0.03230195492506027, 0.09966815263032913, -0.03453387692570686, -0.07663816213607788, 0.0038861450739204884, 0.054438989609479904, 0.029185833409428596, -0.03107548877596855, -0.04819459840655327, -0.020682694390416145, -0.0060600824654102325, 0.006725797429680824, 0.024345412850379944, 0.07292428612709045, 0.08080734312534332, -0.03678198531270027, 0.09954294562339783, -0.012169606052339077, -0.00947296991944313, 0.05617816001176834, 0.011838467791676521, -0.08588791638612747, 0.02573472261428833, -0.04625685140490532, -0.037350185215473175, -0.1127709299325943, -0.00806527677923441, -0.0020011949818581343, 0.07333053648471832, -0.0024197606835514307, 0.015468213707208633, -0.08215311914682388, 0.03127054497599602, 0.02456302009522915, 0.055713951587677, -0.011820261366665363, 0.011165663599967957, 0.03001461923122406, -0.02760082669556141, 0.05543933063745499, -0.007944784127175808, 0.0005080911214463413, 0.0332837849855423, -0.06870918720960617, 0.02179649844765663, -0.011010119691491127, 0.02265915647149086, 0.09243591874837875, 0.012623961083590984, -0.0016353552928194404, 0.0090076494961977, 0.019625144079327583, 0.0003630001738201827, 0.0012652979930862784, -0.013171633705496788, 0.005215170793235302, 0.07163190841674805, 0.009769231081008911, -0.04378115385770798, -0.03036125935614109, 0.0009353620698675513, 0.006941274739801884, -0.029985688626766205, -0.014145074412226677, -0.0014093330828472972, 0.0302322618663311, 0.07153017818927765, 0.04220974072813988, -0.05484646186232567, 0.04802698642015457, 0.010525565594434738, -0.03341946750879288, -0.02775057777762413, -0.02335864119231701, 0.022670608013868332, -0.035957567393779755, -0.016570836305618286, -0.05833125859498978, 0.04747150093317032, 0.08657343685626984, -0.015898339450359344, 0.01658942550420761, 0.06971151381731033, 0.08508127182722092, -0.04495479539036751, 0.00735080661252141, 0.03182332590222359, -0.016246115788817406, 0.03882451355457306, 0.030809126794338226, -0.038203850388526917, 0.029103998094797134, 0.038497477769851685, -0.035290658473968506, 0.07010573148727417, 0.04019228741526604, -0.0037792022339999676, -0.03807806223630905, 0.09835398942232132, -0.0007538428180851042, 0.004022795241326094, -0.05659518390893936, 0.011677415110170841, -0.007610283326357603, -0.0830642580986023, -0.022149063646793365, 0.02710704319179058, -0.036678384989500046, 0.05121784284710884, -0.038764387369155884, -0.03422291949391365, -0.020842770114541054, 0.013662777841091156, -0.031013403087854385, 0.003075416898354888, -0.013936333358287811, 0.036712344735860825, 0.03420350328087807, -0.0008658110164105892, -0.08036455512046814, 0.07168041914701462, -0.0513823963701725, -0.048331860452890396, 0.030818788334727287, 0.06158459931612015, 0.05349830165505409, -0.016600755974650383, 0.043334271758794785, 0.025736847892403603, 0.052757132798433304, 0.05468503013253212, -0.031994301825761795, 0.020753199234604836, -0.037928082048892975, -0.03390880301594734, 0.10312192887067795, -0.03252960368990898, 0.025237085297703743, 0.06796266883611679, -0.01158297061920166, 0.018359413370490074, 0.00892674271017313, 0.053494956344366074, -0.008863097988069057, 0.11237334460020065, 0.01613301783800125, 0.026976456865668297, -0.05681522563099861, -0.033814091235399246, 0.06761782616376877, -0.03942994400858879, -0.012989679351449013 ]
272
272
Temporal data mining for root-cause analysis of machine faults in automotive assembly lines
Engine assembly is a complex and heavily automated distributed-control process, with large amounts of faults data logged everyday. We describe an application of temporal data mining for analyzing fault logs in an engine assembly plant. Frequent episode discovery framework is a model-free method that can be used to deduce (temporal) correlations among events from the logs in an efficient manner. In addition to being theoretically elegant and computationally efficient, frequent episodes are also easy to interpret in the form actionable recommendations. Incorporation of domain-specific information is critical to successful application of the method for analyzing fault logs in the manufacturing domain. We show how domain-specific knowledge can be incorporated using heuristic rules that act as pre-filters and post-filters to frequent episode discovery. The system described here is currently being used in one of the engine assembly plants of General Motors and is planned for adaptation in other plants. To the best of our knowledge, this paper presents the first real, large-scale application of temporal data mining in the manufacturing domain. We believe that the ideas presented in this paper can help practitioners engineer tools for analysis in other similar or related application domains as well.
[ 0.020645592361688614, -0.08478198945522308, 0.027658268809318542, -0.010848382487893105, 0.0828559398651123, -0.08188345283269882, -0.09261669963598251, -0.02746204286813736, 0.05741356685757637, 0.007098156958818436, -0.01745876856148243, -0.05326109379529953, -0.04074925184249878, -0.005284393206238747, 0.011004025116562843, -0.03868139907717705, -0.042748402804136276, -0.06827033311128616, -0.06300579756498337, -0.06890968233346939, 0.013846386224031448, 0.002395169110968709, 0.004261413589119911, -0.041240841150283813, -0.011805655434727669, -0.07009250670671463, -0.0570952370762825, 0.04316569119691849, 0.007587115280330181, -0.002192381303757429, -0.07152493298053741, 0.0339999720454216, 0.11617325991392136, -0.00535518629476428, 0.04828783869743347, -0.0689506009221077, -0.02576790377497673, 0.012538250535726547, -0.014662920497357845, 0.015830837190151215, 0.05745083466172218, 0.039048463106155396, 0.023253383114933968, -0.009539776481688023, 0.059547580778598785, 0.125468909740448, 0.08476373553276062, 0.03765193372964859, 0.02116800844669342, 0.09849788248538971, -0.006136420648545027, 0.043374452739953995, -0.09162752330303192, -0.01336253248155117, 0.019820643588900566, 0.09002669900655746, -0.0024479832500219345, -0.02982766553759575, -0.004558829590678215, -0.038290053606033325, -0.01921108178794384, 0.09162899106740952, 0.0032062556128948927, -0.025518495589494705, -0.04735192656517029, 0.020926499739289284, 0.0012854230590164661, 0.011909387074410915, -0.058985497802495956, 0.00961729884147644, 0.03482406958937645, -0.020418088883161545, 0.0653294175863266, -0.036182671785354614, 0.019143162295222282, -0.02400411106646061, 0.042291924357414246, 0.026223698630928993, 0.011032070964574814, 0.0970688983798027, -0.02249900810420513, 0.02584879845380783, -0.02738897129893303, -0.032475464046001434, -0.04799138382077217, 0.014928027056157589, 0.019582780078053474, -0.01703420840203762, -0.05827972665429115, 0.010571759194135666, -0.02943793125450611, 0.11208721995353699, -0.10439004004001617, -0.010059894062578678, -0.053557734936475754, 0.02516583912074566, -0.04591452330350876, -0.005955452565103769, -0.019771333783864975, 0.0384162962436676, 0.039925772696733475, -0.005188454408198595, 0.04210276901721954, 0.01942412182688713, -0.10060476511716843, 0.018954820930957794, 0.027521217241883278, 0.02953524701297283, -0.006326464936137199, -0.05127282440662384, 0.014009364880621433, 0.005031770560890436, 0.0551714263856411, 0.04184052348136902, 0.04568326100707054, 0.02870231494307518, -0.019706230610609055, 0.027646968141198158, 0.014449653215706348, -0.05033838748931885, -0.012043132446706295, -0.007917680777609348, -0.05495407059788704, 0.037037961184978485, 0.03938829153776169, -0.022855540737509727, 0.017912182956933975, 0.005227991845458746, 0.051768723875284195, 0.027198869735002518, -0.016752343624830246, 0.05211388319730759, -0.05377568304538727, 0.03265443444252014, -0.03427449241280556, -0.0049915919080376625, -0.013116602785885334, 0.05387427285313606, -0.0029016025364398956, 0.01984914392232895, -0.036335378885269165, 0.04881518334150314, -0.010558749549090862, 0.0009522580076009035, -0.03443080186843872, 0.007117256056517363, 0.006059539970010519, 0.05188019201159477, 0.03137807548046112, 0.016413681209087372, -0.030783243477344513, -0.0840410515666008, -0.03715408965945244, 0.07293166220188141, -0.014416242949664593, -0.030857345089316368, -0.003619394963607192, -0.042910780757665634, 0.012239107862114906, 0.0383191779255867, 0.0026727309450507164, -0.06039971858263016, 0.023721380159258842, 0.027601419016718864, 0.0437452457845211, 0.009006933309137821, 0.003013070672750473, 0.03392712399363518, 0.025707751512527466, -0.044962525367736816, -0.006943513639271259, 0.02670697495341301, 0.05927601829171181, 0.02453702874481678, -0.009919680655002594, 0.013533167541027069, 0.0020855518523603678, 0.0010003597708418965, 0.022997578606009483, -0.026288742199540138, 0.001478333491832018, -0.039186473935842514, 0.032425977289676666, -0.0022929981350898743, 0.05457605421543121, 0.0352957621216774, -0.0440332368016243, 0.09334146976470947, -0.04038139805197716, 0.045884113758802414, 0.007253317628055811, 0.02735995501279831, 0.03681309521198273, 0.03622571751475334, -0.03155259042978287, 0.01764867454767227, 0.0027280866634100676, -0.016554322093725204, 0.018161974847316742, 0.0681346207857132, -0.029830042272806168, -0.021823536604642868, -0.06206211447715759, -0.06910844892263412, 0.001478990656323731, -0.06378721445798874, 0.04326893016695976, -0.002392719266936183, -0.02782849781215191, -0.023533090949058533, 0.05177657678723335, 0.005033205263316631, -0.06271348148584366, 0.01229717954993248, 0.058125220239162445, -0.03863276168704033, 0.006006642710417509, -0.05232047289609909, 0.07798273861408234, 0.016898874193429947, -0.03907470405101776, -0.01646202802658081, -0.06093730032444, 0.040124837309122086, -0.01646646298468113, 0.022915856912732124, 0.0004978632205165923, -0.04920663684606552, -0.0456484891474247, 0.015782387927174568, -0.05740837752819061, -0.060224369168281555, -0.09583799540996552, 0.016822228208184242, 0.07976876944303513, 0.01572236604988575, 0.03144415467977524, -0.0777413547039032, -0.037913642823696136, 0.039639078080654144, -0.01422896422445774, 0.0314832478761673, 0.05815998837351799, -0.009995166212320328, 0.015366761945188046, 0.01397152990102768, -0.03132674843072891, 0.08456109464168549, -0.0404527448117733, -0.01864566281437874, -0.004777917638421059, -0.0386122390627861, 0.03586546704173088, 0.010777793824672699, -0.02903774566948414, 0.010362326167523861, -0.08169236034154892, 0.006459493190050125, 0.012170929461717606, -0.02599216066300869, 0.014144768007099628, -0.06307359039783478, -0.028023675084114075, 0.03811830282211304, 0.07299704849720001, -0.022745264694094658, -0.03471643850207329, -0.0063344757072627544, 0.03588775172829628, -0.07929795980453491, -0.03584239259362221, -0.05536963790655136, 0.036431025713682175, 0.16596251726150513, -0.04695237800478935, -0.044242702424526215, -0.00612074788659811, 0.032152969390153885, -0.004884582944214344, 0.015862179920077324, -0.02996698208153248, -0.024592632427811623, -0.0031954955775290728, 0.020894553512334824, -0.04510931670665741, -0.006965607404708862, -0.030803034082055092, -0.030698053538799286, -0.02171250991523266, -0.04521830752491951, -0.04352909326553345, -0.02563120611011982, -0.08502989262342453, 0.0010760084260255098, 0.021708982065320015, -0.05436452105641365, -0.018804455175995827, -0.03973981365561485, 0.07561994343996048, 0.022083744406700134, 0.02138172835111618, -0.005040663294494152, 0.11785636842250824, 0.004283906891942024, 0.04960279539227486, 0.014770757406949997, 0.02763381414115429, 0.09949494898319244, 0.012677258811891079, -0.015295788645744324, 0.0017703850753605366, 0.024955948814749718, 0.005088008474558592, 0.011237147264182568, -0.003419579705223441, -0.0319935642182827, -0.039405133575201035, -0.020433882251381874, -0.021910443902015686, 0.031157588586211205, -0.006290050223469734, -0.02384539321064949, 0.013680516742169857, 0.007414628751575947, 0.006734488066285849, 0.008614531718194485, 0.03307948634028435, -0.016572505235671997, -0.029852010309696198, -0.0393286794424057, 0.03746017441153526, -0.09340226650238037, 0.011484676972031593, 0.01767887733876705, -0.07136228680610657, -0.007065760437399149, 0.06182098388671875, 0.00013282174768391997, 0.005577710922807455, 0.03927769511938095, -0.022367926314473152, -0.07986040413379669, -0.06001406908035278, -0.08495151251554489, 0.0814128965139389, 0.039380189031362534, 0.06418624520301819, 0.057540472596883774, -0.021477386355400085, 0.016756664961576462, 0.019549978896975517, -0.06384006887674332, -0.018987951800227165, 0.018765581771731377, -0.005175713915377855, 0.0720505341887474, 0.009175887331366539, 0.028217967599630356, 0.01980377919971943, 0.022602519020438194, 0.025245321914553642, 0.015151545405387878, -0.05553825572133064, -0.00908554159104824, 0.023759616538882256, 0.07439335435628891, -0.004289278760552406, 0.033947914838790894, -0.04199061542749405, 0.014718317426741123, 0.07885807007551193, 0.043052513152360916, 0.02405995875597, 0.011830061674118042, 0.021004216745495796, 0.0009575319709256291, 0.030656548216938972, -0.02786833420395851, -0.00484340637922287, 0.06494066119194031, -0.03202974796295166, -0.0009007850894704461, -0.03220274671912193, 0.00006438531272578984, -0.10003376752138138, -0.018953189253807068, -0.038861777633428574, -0.07070159167051315, 0.021127570420503616, 0.0505131259560585, -0.03169436380267143, 0.026216378435492516, 0.0493641160428524, 0.013547706417739391, 0.1492975801229477, -0.03273382410407066, 0.06093619018793106, 0.03866514563560486, -0.0334540456533432, 0.016510874032974243, 0.02914917841553688, -0.11103662848472595, -0.09010244905948639, -0.10307161509990692, 0.014341205358505249, 0.06789005547761917, 0.005405629985034466, -0.02543039806187153, 0.05067194253206253, 0.006446833722293377, 0.060877397656440735, -0.051232170313596725, 0.012495335191488266, 0.011109237559139729, 0.016005396842956543, 0.010639581829309464, -0.05134669318795204, 0.057682570070028305, 0.023451561108231544, 0.03986550122499466, 0.020254330709576607, 0.042889755219221115, 0.03374709561467171, -0.07509280741214752, -0.02006368339061737, 0.027202779427170753, 0.07996674627065659, 0.008086479268968105, -0.024157237261533737, 0.04535522311925888, -0.08501695096492767, -0.04317586123943329, -0.0636526569724083, 0.08298210799694061, -0.0015297002391889691, 0.014151792973279953, 0.02307126484811306, -0.028248753398656845, -0.08276667445898056, 0.0057524703443050385, -0.0346989631652832, 0.000960871868301183, 0.07573531568050385, -0.004879599437117577, -0.05120353028178215, 0.057993873953819275, -0.057224687188863754, -0.019910801202058792, 0.01200155634433031, -0.0463411919772625, 0.0021759867668151855, 0.06475522369146347, 0.03527437523007393, 0.008130237460136414, 0.042628802359104156, 0.002943588187918067, -0.040126923471689224, 0.026020923629403114, 0.029795344918966293, -0.06623661518096924, 0.08046603947877884, 0.005195545963943005, -0.010349161922931671, -0.007343080826103687, -0.03491707146167755, -0.035082943737506866, 0.04681095480918884, 0.05408268794417381, 0.0820927768945694, 0.0014010004233568907, -0.025769172236323357, 0.004441247787326574, -0.033038873225450516, -0.0042022159323096275, -0.01447068341076374, -0.03303326293826103, 0.03823748230934143, -0.006986646912992001, -0.03010721690952778, -0.04075448587536812, 0.10934247076511383, 0.03552209585905075, -0.033288661390542984, 0.033682771027088165, 0.01916845329105854, 0.07376384735107422, -0.012137397192418575, -0.0650385171175003, 0.06398975104093552, -0.055455587804317474, 0.04219141602516174, -0.005743833724409342, -0.014306388795375824, 0.047209128737449646, 0.013382512144744396, -0.007943392731249332, 0.026687299832701683, 0.003115816740319133, 0.0208135899156332, -0.057110730558633804, 0.062314603477716446, -0.01556134968996048, -0.03216886892914772, 0.024620987474918365, 0.14264164865016937, 0.040960755199193954, -0.023646116256713867, 0.01589149422943592, -0.013371981680393219, 0.02729118801653385, 0.05599765479564667, -0.04691975936293602 ]
273
273
Continuous Strategy Replicator Dynamics for Multi--Agent Learning
The problem of multi-agent learning and adaptation has attracted a great deal of attention in recent years. It has been suggested that the dynamics of multi agent learning can be studied using replicator equations from population biology. Most existing studies so far have been limited to discrete strategy spaces with a small number of available actions. In many cases, however, the choices available to agents are better characterized by continuous spectra. This paper suggests a generalization of the replicator framework that allows to study the adaptive dynamics of Q-learning agents with continuous strategy spaces. Instead of probability vectors, agents strategies are now characterized by probability measures over continuous variables. As a result, the ordinary differential equations for the discrete case are replaced by a system of coupled integral--differential replicator equations that describe the mutual evolution of individual agent strategies. We derive a set of functional equations describing the steady state of the replicator dynamics, examine their solutions for several two-player games, and confirm our analytical results using simulations.
[ -0.04532681033015251, -0.022134212777018547, 0.08042050153017044, 0.050888314843177795, -0.012916969135403633, -0.13151104748249054, -0.03072626329958439, -0.004169863183051348, -0.0046404036693274975, -0.025508403778076172, 0.02003326825797558, -0.025698933750391006, -0.007292689755558968, 0.06523889303207397, 0.01055094227194786, -0.01732300966978073, -0.004007963463664055, -0.03159879520535469, 0.005730035249143839, -0.029031848534941673, 0.07804020494222641, -0.05715125426650047, -0.02891390584409237, -0.039277344942092896, -0.01711195334792137, -0.02957167476415634, -0.055409226566553116, -0.00346225593239069, 0.06117637827992439, -0.04321315884590149, -0.007574522402137518, 0.05689370259642601, -0.01805691607296467, 0.0798981562256813, 0.03124714083969593, -0.07015249133110046, 0.026572370901703835, -0.0813715010881424, -0.048382919281721115, 0.013439647853374481, -0.08376161754131317, -0.03653130307793617, 0.038576170802116394, 0.04428360238671303, -0.020723726600408554, 0.059189341962337494, 0.05564669892191887, -0.018968550488352776, -0.0029903093818575144, 0.07064441591501236, -0.12681953608989716, 0.013596197590231895, 0.0029899869114160538, 0.010010256431996822, -0.04318281263113022, 0.02843899093568325, -0.039629578590393066, -0.031233064830303192, -0.03109906055033207, -0.06121303141117096, 0.04471740126609802, 0.08555690199136734, -0.005873098503798246, 0.021282682195305824, 0.005126063711941242, 0.030839046463370323, -0.046309035271406174, -0.028717482462525368, -0.06436119973659515, -0.04011799395084381, 0.07767320424318314, 0.051570527255535126, 0.004489651881158352, -0.0325663760304451, -0.027629822492599487, 0.0266385730355978, 0.002631465205922723, -0.01682480052113533, -0.05385952815413475, 0.004639226943254471, -0.1247728243470192, 0.004806479439139366, -0.012643568217754364, 0.07481647282838821, -0.013941224664449692, 0.008423717692494392, 0.043781593441963196, 0.018075408414006233, 0.016262497752904892, 0.015487118624150753, 0.025488924235105515, -0.02739541605114937, -0.061801712960004807, 0.05654307082295418, 0.014813795685768127, 0.11353318393230438, -0.09693184494972229, -0.07450820505619049, 0.021636459976434708, 0.038463328033685684, 0.012148560956120491, -0.021598098799586296, 0.08406589925289154, 0.08980761468410492, 0.03023352101445198, -0.0024632366839796305, 0.005507856607437134, 0.012800208292901516, 0.07056091725826263, -0.00045444080024026334, -0.0017829886637628078, -0.019206484779715538, -0.03649259731173515, -0.024516019970178604, -0.026857666671276093, -0.009029625914990902, -0.024287646636366844, 0.021293267607688904, 0.0017618336714804173, 0.09705513715744019, 0.038559913635253906, -0.02157832309603691, -0.03830265998840332, 0.007314805872738361, 0.016510531306266785, -0.0797051265835762, -0.030500350520014763, -0.04205011948943138, 0.0443129688501358, 0.0019775594118982553, 0.04322023689746857, -0.06665898114442825, -0.026868145912885666, -0.16264784336090088, -0.05087430030107498, 0.029851965606212616, -0.06584969162940979, -0.04207703843712807, 0.022449733689427376, -0.006280983332544565, 0.021375412121415138, 0.06144855543971062, -0.09306350350379944, -0.004697720054537058, 0.008230142295360565, -0.021853389218449593, 0.015264135785400867, 0.059811707586050034, 0.02286740019917488, 0.04538519307971001, -0.00692322663962841, -0.037987109273672104, -0.03222130239009857, 0.04530908167362213, 0.04342762380838394, -0.008175551891326904, -0.0251446682959795, -0.021496308967471123, -0.0685420036315918, 0.04225141927599907, 0.03330065310001373, 0.011652042157948017, -0.014176594093441963, -0.0019893785938620567, 0.021282894536852837, 0.020433882251381874, -0.10543686896562576, 0.04041668027639389, -0.07850056141614914, -0.029300324618816376, -0.02451302669942379, 0.0020025731064379215, -0.006893133278936148, 0.02558334544301033, 0.007419606205075979, -0.0068560210056602955, 0.0018424115842208266, 0.011252940632402897, 0.010775145143270493, 0.0090851541608572, -0.009300380945205688, -0.04660317674279213, -0.04003753885626793, -0.04114489629864693, 0.07732896506786346, 0.013466342352330685, 0.009463530033826828, 0.033059097826480865, 0.08737344294786453, 0.07475484907627106, -0.03859959915280342, 0.031944841146469116, -0.052451569586992264, 0.010875565931200981, -0.006786277052015066, 0.01978715881705284, -0.028744643554091454, -0.10976629704236984, 0.02661413699388504, 0.0034513073042035103, 0.044277217239141464, -0.013683058321475983, -0.024113114923238754, -0.01816084422171116, 0.010583249852061272, 0.053594641387462616, -0.029285579919815063, 0.01974489912390709, -0.07053731381893158, -0.01908605918288231, -0.0013159698573872447, -0.009063460864126682, -0.037447240203619, -0.05228091776371002, 0.03513704612851143, 0.0003710805031005293, -0.031109390780329704, -0.09477327764034271, -0.03600672259926796, 0.0691249743103981, 0.016385534778237343, 0.00040736806113272905, 0.016196241602301598, 0.009286491200327873, -0.051015280187129974, -0.007037837523967028, 0.10027202218770981, 0.03967799246311188, -0.0703771635890007, 0.0017622861778363585, -0.0005309073603712022, -0.009159555658698082, -0.027914512902498245, 0.04823697358369827, -0.03981298580765724, 0.05231941118836403, -0.004638914484530687, -0.07769054174423218, 0.053247854113578796, 0.03229925408959389, -0.0395701602101326, 0.011429203674197197, 0.008474997244775295, -0.07221116125583649, 0.04780905693769455, 0.007664794567972422, 0.07787801325321198, 0.03328891843557358, -0.07187934964895248, 0.012887857854366302, 0.0604509562253952, 0.004647508263587952, -0.06023111194372177, 0.04736713692545891, 0.06044694036245346, 0.004318022634834051, -0.00569266639649868, -0.019713938236236572, 0.05485217645764351, 0.017381081357598305, 0.005251789931207895, 0.02913573943078518, -0.03330874443054199, 0.007232844829559326, 0.06986596435308456, -0.013227047398686409, 0.014713574200868607, 0.03143920749425888, -0.023709530010819435, 0.017480937764048576, -0.01103486493229866, -0.047636132687330246, -0.014031738042831421, 0.024801211431622505, -0.033724915236234665, -0.07865650951862335, 0.09807316213846207, -0.022895632311701775, 0.02487475425004959, -0.0878511518239975, -0.023467645049095154, 0.0022262269631028175, -0.0359235517680645, -0.03958316147327423, -0.0073060221038758755, -0.019040627405047417, 0.0343933142721653, 0.05645561218261719, 0.04321564733982086, 0.033861637115478516, -0.008300069719552994, -0.036862313747406006, 0.02893192134797573, 0.0030308037530630827, 0.008548871614038944, -0.058650147169828415, -0.011604982428252697, -0.037631720304489136, -0.0019667455926537514, -0.01815984956920147, 0.00038894207682460546, 0.013157441280782223, -0.025391189381480217, -0.03823429346084595, 0.043395135551691055, 0.07816055417060852, 0.039116356521844864, 0.062012333422899246, -0.09957736730575562, 0.000839579151943326, 0.014368915930390358, -0.039508093148469925, 0.0028954334557056427, -0.004087742883712053, -0.02046123892068863, 0.03804019093513489, -0.014409534633159637, 0.028387820348143578, -0.004795717541128397, 0.002984065329656005, 0.028607765212655067, -0.022269612178206444, -0.006734779570251703, 0.023131823167204857, -0.07387954741716385, 0.02677423134446144, -0.033249422907829285, 0.04216704145073891, 0.005078999791294336, 0.08476044237613678, -0.027590926736593246, 0.0005907360464334488, -0.00228305347263813, 0.07996884733438492, -0.09629257768392563, -0.013845005072653294, -0.08744105696678162, -0.06937310844659805, -0.004667503759264946, 0.09853330999612808, -0.01049512904137373, -0.07036024332046509, -0.08508333563804626, -0.034609612077474594, -0.0029372370336204767, 0.08331266045570374, 0.10441698879003525, 0.003181806532666087, -0.03467559441924095, -0.03689754381775856, -0.03485475853085518, -0.08225662261247635, -0.02924995683133602, 0.06340612471103668, -0.04730862379074097, 0.01429225318133831, 0.029909012839198112, 0.06048126518726349, 0.003365772310644388, 0.0478128045797348, -0.05212569236755371, 0.019960660487413406, 0.019948404282331467, 0.07393048703670502, -0.05293300002813339, 0.03245476633310318, -0.010211925022304058, 0.0003581310447771102, -0.01085985079407692, -0.03621278703212738, 0.008640588261187077, -0.031747568398714066, 0.055936820805072784, 0.054612018167972565, -0.011643651872873306, -0.10143603384494781, 0.047912925481796265, -0.03465665131807327, -0.05375044047832489, 0.05056537315249443, -0.07232094556093216, 0.005643762648105621, -0.005246445070952177, -0.04439106583595276, 0.0016231404151767492, -0.033859655261039734, -0.04978799819946289, -0.0071310726925730705, -0.008869122713804245, -0.02990889735519886, -0.10911952704191208, -0.03999221697449684, -0.07198988646268845, 0.022126400843262672, -0.06712039560079575, -0.002887619426473975, 0.05001777037978172, -0.04099418222904205, -0.02115469053387642, 0.009353714063763618, 0.06064863130450249, -0.06594043970108032, 0.05480809882283211, -0.03922271728515625, -0.001989283598959446, 0.049241017550230026, 0.06276220083236694, 0.03157792612910271, -0.0594487264752388, 0.03659471869468689, 0.027458742260932922, 0.06863824278116226, -0.005850503221154213, -0.08738479763269424, 0.0019172304309904575, -0.0055545782670378685, 0.0007461118511855602, 0.06537602841854095, 0.0771581307053566, -0.08158478140830994, -0.028534501791000366, -0.0005441043758764863, 0.03710675984621048, 0.018778609111905098, 0.016954168677330017, 0.0004603468405548483, 0.03807755932211876, 0.023606663569808006, 0.017215853556990623, 0.055388472974300385, -0.039680365473032, -0.04923748970031738, -0.014034336432814598, -0.018467791378498077, 0.0037569908890873194, -0.052186593413352966, -0.05171048641204834, 0.021707680076360703, 0.06242496147751808, 0.013513059355318546, -0.03304045647382736, 0.012386595830321312, -0.027667248621582985, 0.041324954479932785, 0.08243690431118011, 0.0144620630890131, -0.029096610844135284, 0.03011671081185341, 0.07145068049430847, -0.009646110236644745, -0.03136436268687248, 0.030778173357248306, 0.07593848556280136, 0.005707449745386839, 0.02499774470925331, 0.014665206894278526, 0.05674980208277702, -0.0051228660158813, -0.009508497081696987, 0.011913316324353218, 0.054956790059804916, 0.018827060237526894, 0.05097491666674614, 0.03569347411394119, -0.041459035128355026, 0.00272755092009902, 0.02341155707836151, -0.007064919453114271, 0.006452968344092369, 0.033230990171432495, -0.00428785802796483, -0.058601561933755875, 0.03946555033326149, -0.0597173273563385, -0.0853780135512352, 0.04917727783322334, -0.0021212014835327864, 0.014233080670237541, -0.004761213436722755, 0.016088882461190224, 0.0885171964764595, 0.03534824028611183, 0.03993444889783859, 0.010637100785970688, -0.015186204575002193, -0.021251525729894638, -0.014124699868261814, 0.03843686729669571, -0.007403122261166573, 0.016476880759000778, -0.00993294920772314, -0.04042820259928703, 0.05078062415122986, -0.002515455475077033, 0.028164638206362724, -0.027430152520537376, 0.07429682463407516, -0.019932877272367477, 0.0017282372573390603, 0.017359565943479538, -0.008346888236701488, 0.008708327077329159, -0.0017406184924766421, -0.057001303881406784, -0.003224644111469388, 0.04147815704345703, 0.07082173973321915, -0.038767289370298386, 0.0020261190365999937, 0.05032811686396599, -0.024343915283679962, 0.031154517084360123 ]
274
274
Dictionary Identification - Sparse Matrix-Factorisation via $\ell_1$-Minimisation
This article treats the problem of learning a dictionary providing sparse representations for a given signal class, via $\ell_1$-minimisation. The problem can also be seen as factorising a $\ddim \times \nsig$ matrix $Y=(y_1 >... y_\nsig), y_n\in \R^\ddim$ of training signals into a $\ddim \times \natoms$ dictionary matrix $\dico$ and a $\natoms \times \nsig$ coefficient matrix $\X=(x_1... x_\nsig), x_n \in \R^\natoms$, which is sparse. The exact question studied here is when a dictionary coefficient pair $(\dico,\X)$ can be recovered as local minimum of a (nonconvex) $\ell_1$-criterion with input $Y=\dico \X$. First, for general dictionaries and coefficient matrices, algebraic conditions ensuring local identifiability are derived, which are then specialised to the case when the dictionary is a basis. Finally, assuming a random Bernoulli-Gaussian sparse model on the coefficient matrix, it is shown that sufficiently incoherent bases are locally identifiable with high probability. The perhaps surprising result is that the typically sufficient number of training samples $\nsig$ grows up to a logarithmic factor only linearly with the signal dimension, i.e. $\nsig \approx C \natoms \log \natoms$, in contrast to previous approaches requiring combinatorially many samples.
[ 0.04896258935332298, 0.011008680798113346, -0.0012641086941584945, 0.019860513508319855, 0.029544180259108543, -0.0747007504105568, -0.0240195170044899, -0.010053930804133415, -0.02060091681778431, 0.03888874500989914, 0.01118746679276228, -0.008831685408949852, 0.01131613552570343, 0.09543182700872421, -0.013567655347287655, -0.07306195795536041, 0.034111130982637405, -0.060717225074768066, 0.006473396439105272, -0.055020399391651154, -0.019979527220129967, -0.02030492201447487, -0.038727037608623505, -0.05381661653518677, -0.022780586034059525, -0.043218277394771576, -0.04444650560617447, 0.038682594895362854, 0.07741136848926544, -0.011016630567610264, -0.06458526104688644, -0.002041156869381666, 0.014760931953787804, -0.0016352339880540967, -0.029650747776031494, 0.017361508682370186, 0.05945584923028946, 0.05327724292874336, -0.06249291077256203, -0.03135224059224129, -0.03288571164011955, 0.030971413478255272, 0.07477079331874847, -0.010174675844609737, 0.09310721606016159, 0.035375986248254776, 0.04285087063908577, -0.06387331336736679, -0.019728222861886024, 0.018612602725625038, -0.022836975753307343, 0.0009362408891320229, 0.018092479556798935, -0.03262616693973541, -0.028521932661533356, 0.03010515496134758, -0.04643113166093826, 0.023517122492194176, 0.005275349598377943, -0.007322849705815315, 0.0534539520740509, 0.06406892091035843, 0.00494514312595129, 0.01752273552119732, -0.04265589639544487, -0.016420215368270874, -0.04257224127650261, 0.016130398958921432, -0.021643847227096558, -0.01734229549765587, -0.00869494304060936, -0.07925951480865479, -0.012409881688654423, -0.006258619017899036, 0.06318249553442001, 0.030209532007575035, -0.022060945630073547, 0.02586745098233223, 0.018636738881468773, 0.0890275239944458, -0.05176093801856041, 0.04631216451525688, -0.017135251313447952, 0.004358123522251844, -0.011667074635624886, -0.014310304075479507, -0.03813168406486511, -0.021638894453644753, 0.0018194873118773103, 0.042100850492715836, -0.06539209932088852, 0.06625033169984818, -0.07779163122177124, 0.015043314546346664, -0.013091112487018108, 0.01599941961467266, -0.051081642508506775, 0.054844632744789124, -0.050550855696201324, -0.017590947449207306, 0.04001332074403763, -0.0355064831674099, 0.000113122325274162, 0.0385596789419651, -0.044507816433906555, -0.008199283853173256, -0.06791988760232925, 0.06617047637701035, -0.03243240714073181, 0.0108335604891181, 0.05288638919591904, 0.00971919298171997, -0.0003860783181153238, -0.02687055431306362, -0.07844827324151993, 0.006673604715615511, 0.052112650126218796, 0.03528834134340286, -0.031415995210409164, 0.030182981863617897, 0.03605685755610466, -0.014120952226221561, -0.039473701268434525, 0.051037389785051346, 0.022231997922062874, 0.0027933402452617884, -0.020862583070993423, -0.04295005649328232, 0.11539261788129807, 0.011608841829001904, -0.10958106815814972, -0.008875374682247639, 0.0006877781124785542, -0.02386484481394291, -0.06425144523382187, 0.09510331600904465, -0.0046178787015378475, -0.03805169835686684, -0.045354120433330536, 0.05991174280643463, -0.04159856215119362, -0.04178259149193764, 0.0004740491567645222, -0.03633250296115875, -0.011898563243448734, 0.006075806450098753, 0.026852969080209732, 0.026627931743860245, -0.05137263238430023, 0.0006306038703769445, 0.006337583530694246, -0.011891957372426987, 0.09011201560497284, 0.007201931439340115, 0.0385398268699646, -0.003498953999951482, 0.031745050102472305, -0.08419520407915115, -0.004482597578316927, 0.006293489597737789, -0.11006360501050949, -0.022255361080169678, 0.04640786722302437, 0.03235878795385361, -0.10992936044931412, 0.02149360068142414, -0.036776963621377945, -0.036815132945775986, -0.08250316977500916, 0.01928921602666378, -0.05249185115098953, 0.03346652537584305, 0.023499995470046997, 0.00939395185559988, 0.03146635368466377, 0.08908509463071823, -0.007630525156855583, 0.07734991610050201, -0.013721763156354427, 0.029339691624045372, 0.001504063606262207, 0.013963181525468826, 0.0021674372255802155, 0.030606873333454132, -0.016089562326669693, 0.006262511480599642, 0.05593404173851013, 0.047226157039403915, 0.03917299956083298, -0.03867269679903984, 0.04469463974237442, -0.030691523104906082, -0.019737936556339264, 0.06317906826734543, -0.04876149818301201, 0.04185359179973602, 0.021895842626690865, -0.018667900934815407, 0.030390193685889244, 0.06185290589928627, 0.032904718071222305, -0.010122611187398434, -0.0030085183680057526, -0.06394790858030319, -0.09366949647665024, 0.021301593631505966, 0.007437988184392452, -0.03492508828639984, -0.021477317437529564, 0.027267470955848694, 0.04399268329143524, 0.0609516017138958, 0.07030675560235977, 0.01093683484941721, 0.005704767536371946, 0.050930991768836975, -0.05518709495663643, -0.04236343130469322, 0.034512076526880264, 0.019928328692913055, -0.0357244536280632, 0.022407134994864464, 0.03562396019697189, -0.0013473493745550513, -0.020618382841348648, -0.02097223699092865, 0.012976625002920628, -0.03999684378504753, -0.08987145870923996, 0.021692970767617226, -0.02292022295296192, -0.038796696811914444, -0.07964502274990082, -0.09997399896383286, 0.0071683176793158054, -0.013066772371530533, -0.02373730018734932, 0.016271701082587242, -0.05974823981523514, 0.01714830845594406, -0.016129247844219208, 0.10238050669431686, -0.023365672677755356, 0.012270037084817886, 0.03329073637723923, -0.05046437680721283, 0.04015369713306427, 0.010113196447491646, -0.022188659757375717, 0.02791639044880867, -0.020070724189281464, 0.03298285976052284, 0.029736017808318138, -0.0266888327896595, 0.021120697259902954, 0.035937920212745667, -0.0010779002914205194, 0.020303580909967422, 0.04312099516391754, 0.06978018581867218, 0.020478492602705956, 0.06573734432458878, -0.034809280186891556, 0.012832283042371273, 0.040146972984075546, -0.0460648275911808, -0.014868618920445442, 0.04042588546872139, 0.04388915374875069, 0.018947241827845573, 0.025963224470615387, -0.018418021500110626, 0.01705947145819664, 0.05868392810225487, -0.08205259591341019, 0.024860171601176262, 0.05835457146167755, 0.04123207926750183, -0.0012634425656870008, -0.08403626084327698, -0.023868048563599586, 0.027245135977864265, -0.0009137240122072399, -0.07267335057258606, 0.06342162936925888, 0.03507944941520691, 0.04707285761833191, 0.02711491659283638, 0.011861422099173069, -0.006967406719923019, -0.040552861988544464, 0.07497081160545349, -0.05324726179242134, 0.03709599748253822, -0.022890936583280563, -0.00833886582404375, 0.048813771456480026, 0.008116943761706352, -0.017255989834666252, 0.03348078951239586, 0.025386329740285873, -0.04622286930680275, 0.040314119309186935, -0.013684614561498165, 0.06737350672483444, 0.05722867697477341, 0.06238807737827301, 0.10974497348070145, -0.017603544518351555, 0.06806513667106628, -0.005418071988970041, 0.07264938950538635, -0.06937016546726227, -0.024931976571679115, 0.02163269929587841, -0.07940205931663513, 0.06124451383948326, -0.054085541516542435, -0.008375665172934532, -0.05304742977023125, -0.04033030942082405, 0.05653127282857895, -0.03213070333003998, 0.035226970911026, -0.08828910440206528, -0.0035542966797947884, -0.03641862794756889, 0.036027997732162476, -0.12430498749017715, 0.011584644205868244, 0.012650948949158192, -0.02438163012266159, -0.050449732691049576, 0.04184757173061371, -0.04539496451616287, 0.08959028869867325, -0.053127046674489975, 0.016710828989744186, -0.0858260840177536, -0.05629879608750343, -0.016372188925743103, -0.022846655920147896, -0.05549139529466629, -0.0031778630800545216, 0.06261063367128372, 0.039269525557756424, 0.05347944423556328, -0.03765932843089104, -0.0382724329829216, 0.05446905642747879, -0.04897727072238922, 0.010190417058765888, -0.04740525782108307, -0.036211587488651276, -0.006389652378857136, 0.11550024896860123, 0.02661932446062565, 0.012737422250211239, -0.02520161122083664, 0.011627771891653538, -0.057136498391628265, 0.06987465173006058, -0.01010441966354847, -0.005613589659333229, -0.0021295594051480293, 0.08363934606313705, 0.016611162573099136, -0.035391878336668015, -0.045275695621967316, 0.053361676633358, 0.005949898157268763, 0.011334342882037163, 0.06582313776016235, -0.05421482026576996, 0.04128609225153923, -0.046609412878751755, 0.08365963399410248, -0.06409117579460144, 0.038417354226112366, 0.03706858679652214, -0.02784440666437149, -0.029990434646606445, 0.025812622159719467, 0.03297347575426102, -0.02547556906938553, -0.044030286371707916, -0.03514723852276802, -0.00881202146410942, 0.016450943425297737, 0.022905224934220314, -0.03601846098899841, -0.0939745381474495, 0.04017798975110054, -0.04218533635139465, 0.015461265109479427, -0.04076239466667175, -0.03694463521242142, 0.10716404765844345, -0.04721960052847862, -0.03973086178302765, 0.02363635040819645, -0.004712360445410013, -0.027116024866700172, -0.06222336366772652, -0.10581937432289124, -0.05284887179732323, 0.049223680049180984, 0.07743209600448608, -0.022472968325018883, 0.09401790797710419, 0.025789838284254074, 0.008613859303295612, -0.05328289791941643, 0.012040119618177414, 0.0007332166424021125, 0.02210897020995617, -0.014032276347279549, -0.01213256549090147, 0.00020740830223076046, -0.053826458752155304, 0.0053064171224832535, 0.0033598681911826134, -0.002417393494397402, -0.007983861491084099, 0.016775090247392654, 0.005412722937762737, 0.06397856771945953, 0.09471769630908966, 0.00961263943463564, 0.0015714308246970177, -0.09057153761386871, -0.03115321509540081, -0.08752225339412689, 0.06071137264370918, -0.010002445429563522, 0.007829371839761734, 0.05619589239358902, -0.04217706620693207, -0.008196333423256874, 0.0511283203959465, -0.028788398951292038, -0.008705955930054188, 0.02746693044900894, 0.024800339713692665, 0.03938496857881546, 0.04431576281785965, 0.03673262149095535, -0.03658232092857361, 0.13045160472393036, 0.0344543494284153, -0.015464765019714832, -0.04149425029754639, 0.028782058507204056, -0.009127918630838394, -0.07592615485191345, 0.030104665085673332, 0.09350831061601639, 0.036743853241205215, 0.06778238713741302, -0.0221608504652977, -0.01665590889751911, -0.00866108387708664, 0.036038510501384735, -0.06947222352027893, -0.07775726914405823, -0.014645762741565704, 0.01804845780134201, 0.0030161673203110695, -0.008565344847738743, 0.044574081897735596, -0.015040471218526363, 0.07977379858493805, -0.05019184201955795, -0.02964598685503006, -0.004499554168432951, 0.02468850649893284, 0.010601135902106762, -0.03135909140110016, -0.01236162893474102, 0.032019149512052536, 0.004496144596487284, -0.03181995078921318, -0.023442931473255157, 0.08047399669885635, 0.007271658629179001, 0.029794642701745033, -0.0669504776597023, 0.04874609783291817, 0.026221778243780136, 0.006947151850908995, 0.0030152651015669107, -0.009245011024177074, 0.06742661446332932, 0.00027948289061896503, -0.05698719620704651, -0.020792193710803986, 0.00046409343485720456, -0.005758670158684254, 0.0397784598171711, -0.010321246460080147, -0.0003010883228853345, 0.018481390550732613, 0.007276566699147224, 0.024768372997641563, 0.04676143825054169, 0.0509704165160656, 0.05388738214969635, -0.05058547481894493, -0.05459405109286308, 0.05213075876235962, -0.02332092821598053, 0.05093761160969734 ]
275
275
Fast and Near-Optimal Matrix Completion via Randomized Basis Pursuit
Motivated by the philosophy and phenomenal success of compressed sensing, the problem of reconstructing a matrix from a sampling of its entries has attracted much attention recently. Such a problem can be viewed as an information-theoretic variant of the well-studied matrix completion problem, and the main objective is to design an efficient algorithm that can reconstruct a matrix by inspecting only a small number of its entries. Although this is an impossible task in general, Cand\`es and co-authors have recently shown that under a so-called incoherence assumption, a rank $r$ $n\times n$ matrix can be reconstructed using semidefinite programming (SDP) after one inspects $O(nr\log^6n)$ of its entries. In this paper we propose an alternative approach that is much more efficient and can reconstruct a larger class of matrices by inspecting a significantly smaller number of the entries. Specifically, we first introduce a class of so-called stable matrices and show that it includes all those that satisfy the incoherence assumption. Then, we propose a randomized basis pursuit (RBP) algorithm and show that it can reconstruct a stable rank $r$ $n\times n$ matrix after inspecting $O(nr\log n)$ of its entries. Our sampling bound is only a logarithmic factor away from the information-theoretic limit and is essentially optimal. Moreover, the runtime of the RBP algorithm is bounded by $O(nr^2\log n+n^2r)$, which compares very favorably with the $\Omega(n^4r^2\log^{12}n)$ runtime of the SDP-based algorithm. Perhaps more importantly, our algorithm will provide an exact reconstruction of the input matrix in polynomial time. By contrast, the SDP-based algorithm can only provide an approximate one in polynomial time.
[ -0.020783931016921997, -0.06232718005776405, 0.03381361439824104, -0.07942627370357513, -0.001669829012826085, -0.0055145504884421825, -0.0175201203674078, 0.01158235128968954, -0.05552607774734497, -0.0035520829260349274, 0.020445602014660835, -0.03980376943945885, -0.014390678144991398, 0.050664272159338, -0.07014679163694382, -0.10780639201402664, -0.05253864452242851, 0.020351916551589966, 0.01650979556143284, -0.07840044796466827, 0.008836756460368633, 0.03258294239640236, 0.007378345355391502, 0.013338175602257252, -0.02421724982559681, 0.06322100013494492, -0.034474484622478485, -0.022271929308772087, -0.008587782271206379, -0.028062667697668076, -0.033006202429533005, 0.02806767076253891, -0.010829530656337738, -0.024287840351462364, -0.04491152614355087, -0.040154363960027695, 0.05428917333483696, 0.0020028622820973396, -0.004520122427493334, 0.0035837425384670496, -0.05238199606537819, 0.018687576055526733, -0.055116984993219376, 0.04227060824632645, 0.05329379811882973, 0.09406707435846329, 0.04982279986143112, -0.03395997732877731, -0.00371814938262105, 0.021661240607500076, -0.03824232518672943, 0.07769273966550827, -0.041583187878131866, -0.015090182423591614, -0.04580637812614441, 0.038434531539678574, -0.009503155015408993, -0.025107774883508682, 0.013405526988208294, 0.02911495417356491, 0.022917499765753746, 0.1023077517747879, 0.05641027167439461, -0.00024179700994864106, -0.014477425254881382, 0.0007787441718392074, -0.017883703112602234, 0.013548053801059723, -0.10877709090709686, -0.059546105563640594, -0.007698218338191509, -0.08113060146570206, 0.07206791639328003, 0.008003784343600273, 0.0802660584449768, 0.033989615738391876, 0.050029024481773376, -0.01391080766916275, 0.030471259728074074, 0.06600110977888107, -0.03646394610404968, 0.06768893450498581, -0.013290626928210258, 0.02527160756289959, -0.10367744415998459, 0.027170078828930855, -0.04175246134400368, 0.042042847722768784, 0.07683616876602173, -0.035916537046432495, 0.03821463882923126, 0.023841630667448044, -0.10226168483495712, 0.05672452226281166, 0.0071374522522091866, -0.019294893369078636, -0.011798464693129063, 0.019574034959077835, -0.07762424647808075, 0.06521263718605042, 0.09010621905326843, 0.031455956399440765, 0.035946931689977646, 0.06966173648834229, -0.062227826565504074, 0.051253389567136765, -0.046798743307590485, 0.076041579246521, 0.016614750027656555, -0.031061982735991478, -0.021859176456928253, -0.013580990955233574, 0.02752826176583767, 0.027565019205212593, -0.03367975354194641, 0.003261848818510771, -0.010028400458395481, 0.06285785883665085, -0.02053328976035118, 0.0428701788187027, 0.021266719326376915, -0.021648401394486427, -0.028039248660206795, 0.04899542033672333, -0.015566801652312279, -0.023566121235489845, -0.007625374011695385, -0.08315982669591904, 0.11082610487937927, 0.009266301989555359, -0.07861846685409546, -0.03765726462006569, 0.020237158983945847, -0.027439044788479805, -0.02639727108180523, 0.036044713109731674, -0.03223390132188797, -0.019827838987112045, -0.030391937121748924, 0.06698466092348099, 0.013723605312407017, -0.09290556609630585, 0.028928611427545547, -0.01694408990442753, -0.0336558073759079, -0.06743534654378891, -0.0040421197190880775, -0.005685251206159592, -0.020192116498947144, -0.059875380247831345, -0.07733996212482452, 0.006453132256865501, 0.00045193033292889595, 0.018329355865716934, 0.014320958405733109, -0.06664054840803146, -0.0373404286801815, -0.022578246891498566, -0.055304817855358124, 0.020351121202111244, -0.11044048517942429, -0.0005028033046983182, 0.04827136546373367, 0.03963424265384674, -0.04354939982295036, -0.028272978961467743, 0.026880910620093346, -0.05151641368865967, -0.02038382552564144, -0.012476274743676186, -0.00903010368347168, 0.02249978482723236, 0.0254299808293581, 0.029997743666172028, 0.015608448535203934, -0.010265764780342579, -0.03704138472676277, 0.015024658292531967, -0.021182788535952568, -0.10828287154436111, 0.02962031587958336, 0.0026215645484626293, -0.034517791122198105, 0.02008465677499771, -0.00041338257142342627, 0.0857415646314621, -0.030276359990239143, -0.006194045767188072, 0.05330663546919823, 0.037090934813022614, 0.018937628716230392, -0.017994465306401253, 0.04754073917865753, 0.003863309742882848, -0.02547343820333481, 0.04052374139428139, -0.02274351753294468, -0.002334209159016609, -0.0035478523932397366, 0.02896486222743988, 0.03141635283827782, 0.031547922641038895, -0.007969356141984463, -0.1585519015789032, -0.05720677226781845, -0.016980763524770737, -0.03575815632939339, 0.06350092589855194, 0.06371632218360901, -0.014710720628499985, 0.06621124595403671, 0.07533734291791916, -0.002414369024336338, -0.010510616935789585, 0.035857416689395905, -0.08158045262098312, -0.020365938544273376, -0.005149888340383768, 0.008555022068321705, 0.03337173908948898, -0.059664614498615265, 0.05724368616938591, -0.07143841683864594, 0.030860785394906998, -0.029070299118757248, -0.021599911153316498, 0.06364741176366806, -0.04527144506573677, -0.0573037788271904, -0.008849299512803555, -0.005551034584641457, -0.06363508105278015, -0.04270424321293831, -0.05899205431342125, -0.03689394146203995, 0.051445428282022476, 0.0005933120264671743, -0.007013494614511728, -0.022223301231861115, 0.04258442670106888, 0.015513362362980843, 0.026081249117851257, 0.037702079862356186, -0.005826340056955814, -0.0025249531026929617, -0.029446925967931747, 0.02490045130252838, 0.06250133365392685, 0.01703202724456787, 0.03437746688723564, 0.032837994396686554, -0.06594313681125641, -0.007701820693910122, -0.012932877987623215, 0.08359598368406296, 0.051954202353954315, -0.0011770897544920444, -0.008845415897667408, 0.016336984932422638, 0.02513919211924076, 0.023994669318199158, -0.0036185423377901316, -0.08309640735387802, 0.08777732402086258, 0.0221463181078434, 0.03241826966404915, -0.045877810567617416, 0.04508011415600777, 0.020279256626963615, 0.06943574547767639, -0.022791728377342224, 0.015057221986353397, -0.05570710822939873, 0.04226046800613403, -0.008068704977631569, -0.04983973875641823, 0.03817683458328247, 0.03275937959551811, -0.056859344244003296, -0.02200937829911709, -0.05703623965382576, 0.02060290239751339, 0.001101190922781825, -0.0181291326880455, -0.007491029798984528, 0.06570302695035934, 0.014856181107461452, 0.049592506140470505, -0.0196915864944458, 0.045655522495508194, -0.03211338445544243, 0.05800270289182663, -0.099321149289608, 0.033116914331912994, -0.0018579699099063873, -0.04404420033097267, 0.022423259913921356, 0.033454570919275284, 0.02785980887711048, -0.006073949858546257, 0.030701912939548492, -0.04379871115088463, 0.00557962991297245, -0.05707170441746712, 0.07454792410135269, -0.012190932407975197, 0.11257513612508774, 0.04631391912698746, -0.010545370168983936, 0.025107286870479584, 0.06527572125196457, -0.009593550115823746, -0.02387007139623165, -0.024969026446342468, 0.014412034302949905, -0.0021864252630621195, 0.004612635355442762, -0.05099894106388092, -0.004671383649110794, -0.01847943849861622, -0.009681310504674911, -0.005984606686979532, -0.009556582197546959, -0.012616918422281742, -0.0840795561671257, -0.026039982214570045, -0.03933149203658104, 0.019323356449604034, -0.018815238028764725, -0.054147277027368546, -0.07466676086187363, 0.014551341533660889, 0.025294341146945953, 0.07509205490350723, 0.02907400205731392, -0.015874160453677177, -0.01275167427957058, -0.04160194844007492, 0.00966428592801094, 0.04907212406396866, 0.01782524771988392, -0.11465685814619064, -0.059796299785375595, 0.010594870895147324, 0.08714999258518219, 0.07875117659568787, 0.09987974166870117, -0.07496778666973114, 0.014173570089042187, -0.05031116306781769, -0.05656241253018379, 0.06911785155534744, -0.004764622077345848, 0.06068272143602371, -0.019880086183547974, -0.029235675930976868, 0.08831607550382614, 0.02855674736201763, 0.010952641256153584, 0.03537439927458763, -0.03943698853254318, 0.05932530388236046, -0.018407244235277176, -0.03228079527616501, -0.02147924341261387, 0.014765436761081219, -0.021225949749350548, -0.02390219084918499, 0.008913429453969002, 0.03353680670261383, -0.006270363461226225, 0.000023404470994137228, 0.036811426281929016, 0.004785618744790554, -0.014748623594641685, -0.058482542634010315, 0.07112281769514084, 0.007546938024461269, 0.02922324277460575, 0.10942911356687546, -0.04301348328590393, 0.061480823904275894, 0.013069084845483303, -0.0038416378665715456, -0.04568714275956154, 0.022736171260476112, -0.05031696334481239, 0.0349285863339901, 0.016141919419169426, 0.0022197540383785963, -0.011148391291499138, 0.017259931191802025, 0.07729450613260269, -0.0019353394163772464, 0.018966995179653168, -0.002211397746577859, 0.03610711172223091, 0.02392038144171238, -0.002695821225643158, -0.061291709542274475, 0.03203306719660759, -0.025578631088137627, -0.00929310917854309, -0.12431570142507553, -0.0654260590672493, -0.04576979577541351, -0.04043062776327133, 0.07472115755081177, 0.02318529412150383, 0.07828546315431595, -0.042898356914520264, 0.03629354387521744, -0.03141116350889206, 0.04347697272896767, 0.007666340563446283, 0.051524568349123, -0.006479768548160791, -0.010991574265062809, 0.009546888060867786, -0.02382505312561989, 0.026095909997820854, -0.05835087597370148, -0.020775800570845604, -0.0315123125910759, 0.020914336666464806, 0.031053951010107994, 0.04002680629491806, 0.025207798928022385, 0.009368198923766613, 0.006659034639596939, -0.061680033802986145, -0.04286880046129227, 0.028992846608161926, 0.0359184667468071, 0.05937403067946434, 0.02685551531612873, 0.012340453453361988, 0.007752553094178438, -0.05827266350388527, 0.017492588609457016, -0.017781106755137444, -0.017408272251486778, 0.00026001108926720917, -0.02762129157781601, 0.05584268271923065, 0.046029429882764816, 0.017777658998966217, -0.026838848367333412, 0.02848799154162407, 0.011764985509216785, -0.027042295783758163, -0.01535067893564701, -0.050920940935611725, -0.013256934471428394, -0.009650129824876785, 0.012583469972014427, 0.0447126068174839, 0.03150925412774086, 0.0519283227622509, 0.0014259624294936657, -0.048334185034036636, 0.003960340283811092, 0.01931038871407509, -0.009809646755456924, 0.01954677142202854, -0.056085556745529175, 0.029587384313344955, -0.00006150375702418387, 0.04906695336103439, 0.04226312041282654, -0.03386451303958893, 0.05254931375384331, -0.002653719624504447, 0.049477651715278625, 0.03933430835604668, -0.008538980036973953, 0.0312587134540081, -0.06478334218263626, -0.025529494509100914, -0.042724307626485825, 0.015799179673194885, -0.027809834107756615, -0.03684736415743828, 0.02079201303422451, 0.0640476867556572, 0.10338088124990463, -0.11407189071178436, -0.037060171365737915, 0.08698535710573196, -0.0010109219001606107, 0.01616089418530464, 0.04542798548936844, 0.07035936415195465, -0.014307835139334202, -0.03063478320837021, 0.0030151652172207832, 0.01978619582951069, 0.054702576249837875, 0.03839169815182686, 0.034077905118465424, -0.050851643085479736, -0.03491227328777313, 0.03492020443081856, 0.04118554666638374, 0.04806528612971306, 0.10304135084152222, -0.002045202301815152, -0.09916042536497116, -0.07163634896278381, 0.051023900508880615, -0.018220460042357445, -0.01892479695379734 ]
276
276
Experience-driven formation of parts-based representations in a model of layered visual memory
Growing neuropsychological and neurophysiological evidence suggests that the visual cortex uses parts-based representations to encode, store and retrieve relevant objects. In such a scheme, objects are represented as a set of spatially distributed local features, or parts, arranged in stereotypical fashion. To encode the local appearance and to represent the relations between the constituent parts, there has to be an appropriate memory structure formed by previous experience with visual objects. Here, we propose a model how a hierarchical memory structure supporting efficient storage and rapid recall of parts-based representations can be established by an experience-driven process of self-organization. The process is based on the collaboration of slow bidirectional synaptic plasticity and homeostatic unit activity regulation, both running at the top of fast activity dynamics with winner-take-all character modulated by an oscillatory rhythm. These neural mechanisms lay down the basis for cooperation and competition between the distributed units and their synaptic connections. Choosing human face recognition as a test task, we show that, under the condition of open-ended, unsupervised incremental learning, the system is able to form memory traces for individual faces in a parts-based fashion. On a lower memory layer the synaptic structure is developed to represent local facial features and their interrelations, while the identities of different persons are captured explicitly on a higher layer. An additional property of the resulting representations is the sparseness of both the activity during the recall and the synaptic patterns comprising the memory traces.
[ -0.02090657688677311, 0.010208162479102612, 0.016293007880449295, -0.019939318299293518, -0.013598251156508923, -0.055367209017276764, 0.01539174746721983, 0.038869064301252365, -0.037816233932971954, 0.01833542063832283, 0.03809541091322899, 0.04894331842660904, -0.039421841502189636, 0.05470592901110649, -0.041312702000141144, -0.039769623428583145, 0.002488540019840002, -0.06736569106578827, 0.028757408261299133, -0.04779035225510597, 0.02893102541565895, -0.027679814025759697, -0.020220212638378143, -0.008365195244550705, 0.0035278473515063524, -0.019804060459136963, -0.053724583238363266, 0.027516042813658714, 0.05442102625966072, 0.030288802459836006, 0.022939665243029594, -0.06591706722974777, 0.0416288748383522, 0.04505705460906029, 0.03986101225018501, 0.04084349051117897, 0.007327438332140446, -0.052122291177511215, -0.025586118921637535, -0.0009421217255294323, 0.006186098791658878, 0.04559609293937683, 0.014047299511730671, 0.035472527146339417, 0.03128720819950104, 0.04032687097787857, -0.004991166293621063, 0.02987636625766754, 0.03273211047053337, 0.06289691478013992, -0.10096967965364456, -0.032252345234155655, -0.006148560903966427, 0.013623921200633049, -0.07407423853874207, 0.07943704724311829, -0.025442492216825485, -0.00039705101517029107, 0.038016073405742645, -0.011863169260323048, -0.020473025739192963, 0.05922110751271248, -0.0012824091827496886, 0.08043462783098221, 0.020241688936948776, 0.0721837505698204, -0.04012218490242958, 0.02065509930253029, -0.05221555009484291, -0.04209989309310913, 0.021955695003271103, -0.012360995635390282, -0.06873693317174911, -0.047793928533792496, 0.002423919504508376, 0.0024861155543476343, -0.033004000782966614, -0.016156669706106186, 0.04395447298884392, 0.10087458789348602, -0.05696086212992668, 0.054746028035879135, -0.01994061842560768, -0.056933868676424026, -0.04330267012119293, -0.00981950480490923, -0.03611396625638008, -0.02320772409439087, 0.04869394749403, 0.07539153099060059, -0.024365222081542015, -0.022282397374510765, -0.007881958037614822, 0.06358344107866287, 0.024004878476262093, 0.04268499091267586, 0.02358142100274563, 0.021991850808262825, -0.033023737370967865, 0.03070744313299656, 0.0646904706954956, -0.024645835161209106, 0.013492908328771591, 0.040331434458494186, -0.030731704086065292, -0.03010382317006588, -0.005076185800135136, 0.01890701986849308, 0.07590404152870178, -0.035361260175704956, 0.04864547401666641, 0.0030382229015231133, 0.03513814136385918, 0.002564416266977787, -0.04739166423678398, 0.010543563403189182, -0.031320348381996155, 0.051751211285591125, -0.020504066720604897, 0.006737471092492342, -0.05764021351933479, 0.03679775446653366, -0.05679173022508621, -0.05489844083786011, -0.030700664967298508, -0.05426659435033798, -0.02008172683417797, -0.00796046294271946, 0.04473257437348366, -0.013086547143757343, -0.08941090852022171, -0.0029243670869618654, -0.005323632154613733, -0.10882747918367386, -0.03835637494921684, 0.04158699885010719, -0.049856554716825485, -0.05144499987363815, -0.06258333474397659, 0.07338184118270874, 0.037819769233465195, -0.06215665861964226, -0.03572985902428627, 0.0810127779841423, -0.0025062852073460817, 0.053026583045721054, 0.016635950654745102, 0.03346811234951019, 0.008915094658732414, -0.037565235048532486, 0.09135489910840988, -0.07139071822166443, 0.022102706134319305, 0.013830280862748623, 0.06474827229976654, -0.056283656507730484, -0.007782076485455036, -0.02824247069656849, 0.014812235720455647, 0.13441291451454163, -0.024992072954773903, 0.0062835062853991985, 0.0200042687356472, 0.02544476091861725, 0.02019495703279972, -0.03229479491710663, -0.08986087143421173, -0.0225603636354208, -0.058617956936359406, -0.04957374185323715, -0.048776332288980484, 0.06655160337686539, -0.024342866614460945, -0.0007273926748894155, 0.049912963062524796, -0.03974397853016853, -0.06774372607469559, -0.014116436243057251, -0.002979388227686286, 0.024292288348078728, 0.008271035738289356, -0.04738437384366989, -0.022168708965182304, -0.00228779180906713, 0.04000251740217209, 0.05589914321899414, -0.04103910177946091, -0.0009945101337507367, 0.05006183683872223, 0.00458961958065629, -0.01140631828457117, -0.006217652931809425, 0.02648884430527687, -0.00965323206037283, -0.025750258937478065, 0.026152106001973152, -0.01769419200718403, -0.018270345404744148, 0.055589642375707626, 0.01415122952312231, 0.06528273224830627, 0.04026629403233528, -0.015512874349951744, -0.02933359332382679, -0.0406162403523922, -0.03055357187986374, 0.01369138527661562, -0.037875667214393616, -0.059219591319561005, -0.022351441904902458, -0.016120128333568573, 0.0632181242108345, -0.05044420808553696, 0.015589461661875248, 0.021028460934758186, -0.043091047555208206, 0.026254814118146896, -0.11627519875764847, -0.0017157633556053042, 0.06456942856311798, -0.05150202661752701, 0.07608933746814728, 0.029001053422689438, 0.044487398117780685, -0.04495085030794144, -0.029516059905290604, 0.11870449781417847, 0.04554117098450661, -0.009122285060584545, 0.07110092788934708, -0.06072836369276047, 0.008195643313229084, -0.062034040689468384, -0.04023372381925583, -0.005690108984708786, 0.0024137285072356462, -0.010762130841612816, -0.013843955472111702, -0.013723001815378666, -0.013770638965070248, -0.03818945586681366, -0.02380947209894657, 0.010394242592155933, 0.008940103463828564, -0.014700445346534252, -0.006083810701966286, -0.027323616668581963, -0.007670687977224588, -0.017824729904532433, -0.0335199311375618, 0.06493112444877625, -0.017201440408825874, -0.01258651353418827, 0.04557151719927788, -0.0005358715425245464, -0.004734592977911234, -0.06553484499454498, -0.0014178091660141945, 0.059884510934352875, 0.003929440397769213, 0.055699896067380905, -0.02645556814968586, -0.018981432542204857, 0.024136574938893318, 0.03222647309303284, -0.06761692464351654, 0.021528851240873337, -0.01561333891004324, -0.012494632974267006, -0.012790457345545292, 0.06612578779459, -0.03416642174124718, -0.0045355623587965965, -0.0046604098752141, 0.04747139662504196, 0.04181308671832085, 0.08491598814725876, 0.08743452280759811, -0.0865572839975357, -0.03934050723910332, -0.02740001305937767, 0.006198583170771599, -0.01257921289652586, -0.05650300905108452, -0.026933923363685608, 0.09980646520853043, 0.009113355539739132, 0.05914701893925667, -0.012553040869534016, -0.008323273621499538, -0.11100070923566818, 0.05682465806603432, -0.09456922113895416, 0.004297567531466484, 0.0068933432921767235, -0.0933404490351677, 0.07280106097459793, -0.02686576172709465, 0.01394018903374672, 0.056938931345939636, 0.013181661255657673, -0.05904268100857735, 0.05867162346839905, 0.06276064366102219, 0.03498009964823723, -0.02197130210697651, 0.06113865599036217, 0.11305241286754608, -0.05420932173728943, 0.045120541006326675, 0.006662013474851847, -0.05641331523656845, -0.0649075135588646, -0.009852835908532143, -0.04422936961054802, -0.004046645015478134, 0.029162419959902763, 0.007722892332822084, -0.01824163645505905, -0.008794089779257774, -0.013240420259535313, -0.03861398622393608, -0.006220766343176365, 0.05401630699634552, -0.05917908251285553, -0.09839656949043274, -0.061275966465473175, 0.011159020476043224, -0.026349801570177078, 0.07372613251209259, -0.019906602799892426, 0.02038354054093361, 0.014475872740149498, 0.08982927352190018, -0.005080356728285551, -0.003609337145462632, 0.021084118634462357, 0.036603786051273346, -0.05210356041789055, 0.0005828877328895032, -0.04155880585312843, -0.01694755256175995, 0.07806549966335297, -0.02229873277246952, -0.05992509424686432, 0.06030059978365898, 0.05998765304684639, 0.052273720502853394, 0.051559098064899445, 0.018817195668816566, 0.0076565551571547985, 0.03127549961209297, -0.0559597946703434, 0.02175992913544178, -0.02535582147538662, 0.04932502284646034, 0.04258101060986519, -0.03417148068547249, 0.03371431678533554, 0.03005870245397091, 0.01682271994650364, 0.006682320963591337, -0.016661711037158966, 0.02502860687673092, -0.001704586436972022, 0.053750064224004745, 0.003742305329069495, -0.018092351034283638, -0.05911035090684891, -0.022237159311771393, -0.012631041929125786, -0.004424364306032658, 0.02349371649324894, -0.027559997513890266, 0.032848987728357315, -0.0011769935954362154, 0.0023179298732429743, -0.006486959755420685, 0.056624699383974075, -0.007905364967882633, -0.03119214065372944, -0.07589251548051834, -0.04411039128899574, -0.04250599443912506, -0.03243565559387207, 0.016192564740777016, 0.0884312316775322, -0.01822671853005886, 0.004995242692530155, -0.023459626361727715, -0.017839593812823296, 0.0018804729916155338, 0.021329671144485474, -0.007700915448367596, 0.006368947681039572, -0.06012994796037674, 0.0630156472325325, -0.04243456572294235, 0.01367858238518238, -0.0022875904105603695, -0.0016225333092734218, -0.0737847089767456, -0.05753594636917114, -0.033080536872148514, -0.04177713021636009, -0.04849283769726753, 0.012470200657844543, 0.0696907564997673, -0.05566951259970665, -0.014145619235932827, -0.006083854008466005, 0.08216817677021027, -0.020527232438325882, -0.017102016136050224, 0.0008072314085438848, -0.014115014113485813, 0.04105270653963089, -0.030542632564902306, 0.040685877203941345, -0.02035829797387123, -0.08728816360235214, -0.06475798040628433, 0.00956486351788044, 0.009034239687025547, -0.047054752707481384, -0.044464025646448135, 0.09379535913467407, 0.02927989885210991, 0.059643443673849106, 0.021733401343226433, -0.04881962761282921, 0.008553612045943737, 0.00933961570262909, 0.03222924470901489, -0.0014095216756686568, 0.013644147664308548, 0.0045513189397752285, -0.02123539336025715, 0.00983864814043045, 0.06855379790067673, -0.0020788945257663727, -0.07175930589437485, 0.016851356253027916, -0.0005133025115355849, -0.015232160687446594, 0.01927061751484871, -0.04597209021449089, -0.02400417998433113, 0.06535211205482483, -0.030698666349053383, -0.10511244088411331, -0.0801316648721695, 0.0759102925658226, -0.009200598113238811, -0.06819309294223785, 0.01254029106348753, 0.049114760011434555, -0.015401500277221203, -0.0015859478153288364, -0.06799767911434174, 0.007273686118423939, -0.0716862753033638, 0.05539215728640556, 0.015234573744237423, -0.12093840539455414, -0.01067931018769741, 0.10389377176761627, 0.032297924160957336, -0.050789035856723785, 0.05728287622332573, -0.033732395619153976, 0.00961281917989254, -0.03143969178199768, 0.04301980882883072, -0.011066733859479427, 0.010527086444199085, 0.10863225162029266, -0.08050491660833359, -0.044027987867593765, -0.01431755069643259, -0.021492019295692444, 0.09028103202581406, -0.0073615070432424545, 0.04312159866094589, 0.03522494435310364, 0.06330016255378723, 0.028024990111589432, 0.08625251054763794, 0.01913989894092083, 0.043972667306661606, -0.023230867460370064, -0.057700760662555695, 0.031149843707680702, -0.03510919585824013, 0.038183778524398804, 0.0014192663365975022, 0.05078030750155449, 0.04255560785531998, 0.012551117688417435, 0.039286188781261444, 0.04288091883063316, 0.013145800679922104, 0.04168957471847534, 0.025006558746099472, 0.03615310415625572, 0.05177290365099907, 0.07265587151050568, -0.04812021926045418, -0.06286033987998962, 0.007611784152686596, -0.08832881599664688, 0.029725557193160057 ]
277
277
Combining Supervised and Unsupervised Learning for GIS Classification
This paper presents a new hybrid learning algorithm for unsupervised classification tasks. We combined Fuzzy c-means learning algorithm and a supervised version of Minimerror to develop a hybrid incremental strategy allowing unsupervised classifications. We applied this new approach to a real-world database in order to know if the information contained in unlabeled features of a Geographic Information System (GIS), allows to well classify it. Finally, we compared our results to a classical supervised classification obtained by a multilayer perceptron.
[ -0.010391129180788994, -0.058433499187231064, 0.025813614949584007, 0.046084336936473846, 0.01101842150092125, -0.08690293878316879, 0.03183727338910103, 0.005860297940671444, -0.032696302980184555, -0.021961379796266556, -0.03837180510163307, -0.03514936938881874, -0.032153621315956116, 0.04931851476430893, 0.01277271006256342, 0.04942634329199791, -0.010614288039505482, -0.0005026634316891432, -0.06442764401435852, -0.13335710763931274, 0.04681684076786041, -0.05707893148064613, -0.006619454827159643, -0.012049133889377117, -0.007443621288985014, -0.024595027789473534, 0.007397495675832033, 0.004615414422005415, -0.058908943086862564, 0.019266333431005478, -0.04846951737999916, -0.07905945181846619, 0.04087797924876213, 0.011863915249705315, 0.07462527602910995, -0.05696496739983559, -0.023402228951454163, -0.027906600385904312, -0.03978005424141884, -0.010835644789040089, -0.006365055218338966, 0.06527972966432571, 0.03907301276922226, -0.07482878863811493, 0.05949904024600983, 0.04055342450737953, 0.028927961364388466, -0.0737500786781311, 0.0194920115172863, 0.07211639732122421, -0.05729098990559578, 0.03822938725352287, -0.023001132532954216, -0.03465820476412773, 0.005198352504521608, 0.022961746901273727, 0.04448637366294861, -0.0016635800711810589, -0.013489414006471634, -0.06153159216046333, 0.07417897135019302, 0.07761311531066895, 0.0659799575805664, 0.02769625559449196, -0.05618926137685776, -0.01435772329568863, -0.024760782718658447, -0.019946813583374023, 0.04972010850906372, 0.004599751904606819, 0.011196045204997063, -0.03220515325665474, -0.002667216816917062, 0.00302259367890656, 0.027905719354748726, -0.009469705633819103, 0.027046246454119682, -0.006384582258760929, 0.021680813282728195, 0.0653829276561737, 0.017671911045908928, -0.04299594461917877, 0.02163458615541458, -0.0040244669653475285, -0.013774638995528221, -0.015352992340922356, -0.021740173920989037, 0.004559749737381935, 0.007879677228629589, 0.07128694653511047, 0.000637201766949147, 0.00572169991210103, -0.07681800425052643, 0.004178513772785664, -0.04727409407496452, -0.012469740584492683, 0.024872176349163055, -0.03933052718639374, 0.03368634730577469, 0.023062117397785187, -0.04857061803340912, -0.02474534511566162, -0.004233107436448336, 0.007855797186493874, 0.021172262728214264, 0.004724437370896339, -0.062178272753953934, 0.04998209327459335, 0.04271272197365761, -0.004758310504257679, 0.031870998442173004, 0.010204008780419827, 0.007026743609458208, -0.0008029314922168851, -0.05936380475759506, -0.0009361254051327705, -0.05951602756977081, 0.016325796023011208, -0.02075512707233429, 0.024473007768392563, 0.031036105006933212, 0.007172854617238045, -0.009498141705989838, -0.0054952772334218025, 0.04434213414788246, 0.04434274509549141, 0.01766284741461277, -0.03325764089822769, 0.12725944817066193, -0.041956670582294464, -0.010496212169528008, 0.09713314473628998, -0.03109099343419075, 0.05430353805422783, -0.0984211415052414, 0.048706989735364914, -0.0009911180241033435, 0.043837085366249084, -0.0008727724198251963, 0.05010395497083664, -0.05019316449761391, -0.07890812307596207, 0.03302783519029617, 0.06862469017505646, 0.024362534284591675, 0.056630220264196396, 0.01860629767179489, 0.07721052318811417, 0.010935308411717415, 0.049684103578329086, 0.027767213061451912, -0.07672512531280518, 0.0771181657910347, 0.06497561931610107, 0.009324568323791027, -0.01058987807482481, -0.014142157509922981, 0.047552648931741714, -0.00723604578524828, 0.09797006100416183, -0.030214177444577217, 0.012537745758891106, -0.02068646252155304, -0.012169179506599903, 0.00006398102414095774, 0.03228295221924782, -0.009571586735546589, -0.05288899317383766, 0.02029133401811123, -0.10086435079574585, 0.00695831747725606, -0.012204999104142189, -0.022969380021095276, 0.05804476514458656, -0.023018397390842438, 0.0509704053401947, -0.04684100300073624, 0.027852918952703476, 0.010879299603402615, 0.05986266955733299, 0.05943787097930908, -0.030202606692910194, -0.010331235826015472, 0.002836859319359064, 0.07713176310062408, 0.06892360001802444, 0.025203516706824303, 0.08932070434093475, 0.03741011396050453, -0.004882102832198143, 0.007686815224587917, -0.02152988873422146, 0.01715962588787079, -0.035187266767024994, -0.053681712597608566, 0.05487825721502304, -0.03763057664036751, 0.00005092029459774494, 0.02483898214995861, 0.002694339258596301, -0.010996909812092781, -0.03261173143982887, -0.06619954109191895, -0.007277469150722027, -0.0752146765589714, -0.030871495604515076, 0.056899938732385635, -0.07154687494039536, 0.00723861763253808, -0.02169523388147354, 0.010169382207095623, -0.01884423941373825, 0.04725489765405655, 0.02367597259581089, -0.0011299089528620243, -0.05630882829427719, -0.051794830709695816, -0.047639280557632446, 0.04951521009206772, 0.08998158574104309, -0.06745737791061401, -0.009925415739417076, -0.02348448894917965, 0.005296702962368727, -0.06133757531642914, 0.06426508724689484, -0.04491349309682846, -0.021558096632361412, -0.12316334247589111, 0.07949058711528778, -0.03932861611247063, -0.09102726727724075, -0.07400475442409515, -0.026121487841010094, 0.03601207584142685, 0.004172524902969599, -0.040846049785614014, -0.04926571622490883, 0.009543771855533123, -0.010099688544869423, 0.08219579607248306, 0.08140090107917786, 0.007288215681910515, -0.011196881532669067, 0.012795763090252876, -0.004617250990122557, 0.024525213986635208, 0.029681609943509102, 0.017158927395939827, -0.005443107802420855, -0.04005667567253113, 0.11771199852228165, -0.007024860940873623, 0.030745388939976692, -0.015367422252893448, 0.006203679367899895, -0.00816188845783472, 0.08785801380872726, 0.05607040971517563, 0.06814692914485931, 0.02525213174521923, 0.025167172774672508, 0.042974453419446945, -0.014337149448692799, 0.061634425073862076, 0.021730586886405945, -0.005875305738300085, 0.0116324033588171, -0.0101377684623003, -0.03125988319516182, 0.01251116394996643, -0.07301529496908188, -0.014356143772602081, 0.014951389282941818, -0.026186075061559677, 0.010004717856645584, 0.029935697093605995, 0.05113530904054642, 0.09017830342054367, -0.012265288271009922, -0.06877458095550537, 0.0065272715874016285, 0.005270949099212885, -0.03535902500152588, 0.013270433992147446, -0.039240479469299316, 0.05860007554292679, -0.04515616595745087, -0.025339405983686447, -0.033313628286123276, -0.01937289349734783, 0.046337395906448364, -0.05593595281243324, 0.026744673028588295, 0.08619137853384018, -0.05009949207305908, 0.04125966131687164, -0.05414857342839241, 0.028827793896198273, 0.01027129590511322, 0.011354252696037292, -0.014353525824844837, 0.09157328307628632, 0.06794770061969757, 0.014210253022611141, 0.02173282578587532, 0.02209951914846897, 0.06233224645256996, -0.04598968103528023, 0.007690507918596268, 0.033067259937524796, 0.013780076056718826, -0.013764350675046444, -0.02479296736419201, 0.019264625385403633, -0.03482977673411369, 0.0687933936715126, -0.021307241171598434, -0.060710806399583817, -0.04679363965988159, -0.0004678347904700786, -0.0318753719329834, -0.01685742847621441, -0.012272912077605724, -0.07772058248519897, -0.014962153509259224, 0.00657437602058053, 0.01177353598177433, -0.12688514590263367, 0.029325682669878006, -0.07294902205467224, -0.07139422744512558, -0.028058359399437904, 0.059381403028964996, -0.024197353050112724, 0.034352757036685944, -0.06543029844760895, -0.006302213296294212, 0.016435811296105385, -0.014769311062991619, -0.05184564366936684, -0.03379447013139725, -0.01629403606057167, -0.04329562559723854, -0.06731075048446655, -0.0047058286145329475, 0.08427294343709946, 0.0071693831123411655, -0.06526615470647812, 0.05922757834196091, -0.011888566426932812, 0.018059290945529938, -0.06447207182645798, 0.005207068752497435, -0.009336416609585285, 0.03083510510623455, 0.08789122849702835, 0.05820217728614807, -0.010513663291931152, 0.015885112807154655, -0.015354526229202747, 0.04671095684170723, -0.08949246257543564, -0.007875938899815083, 0.0697985365986824, 0.09369856119155884, 0.07572547346353531, 0.01845351792871952, -0.034164320677518845, -0.03344159573316574, -0.0009553846903145313, 0.033936724066734314, -0.03163346275687218, 0.03168388456106186, 0.06458672881126404, -0.05100274085998535, 0.0056245108135044575, -0.030967770144343376, -0.024136660620570183, 0.020660415291786194, 0.03601529076695442, 0.03154994547367096, 0.01753201335668564, 0.049050938338041306, -0.04346862807869911, -0.011882027611136436, 0.015774894505739212, -0.03722161427140236, 0.08031637221574783, -0.0007891635177657008, 0.033291954547166824, -0.019748257473111153, -0.024063333868980408, 0.05316637456417084, 0.03346234932541847, 0.022297799587249756, 0.0342891700565815, 0.0455910786986351, -0.03754368796944618, 0.023315763100981712, -0.06688432395458221, -0.0038258510176092386, -0.05790453031659126, -0.12729103863239288, -0.03946741670370102, 0.01244051568210125, -0.07471304386854172, 0.056589167565107346, -0.027136310935020447, 0.026229536160826683, 0.06309913843870163, 0.08977814018726349, 0.009965461678802967, -0.0512605719268322, 0.027646120637655258, 0.04895152524113655, 0.06217368319630623, -0.006389719899743795, -0.013129831291735172, -0.05489435791969299, -0.04752083495259285, 0.05003444477915764, -0.018018143251538277, -0.019455300644040108, 0.021900486201047897, -0.001826150226406753, -0.011348429135978222, 0.0674910694360733, -0.030380111187696457, 0.031361669301986694, -0.07636956870555878, -0.0025882278569042683, -0.03596581891179085, 0.00506462249904871, 0.08643745630979538, -0.014400671236217022, 0.02178051322698593, -0.0121852345764637, -0.04780144616961479, 0.04008382558822632, -0.06630987673997879, 0.019042639061808586, 0.014912078157067299, 0.011323115788400173, -0.04966137930750847, 0.0948396772146225, 0.08704350888729095, -0.0009013553499244153, -0.0028483769856393337, -0.042223650962114334, 0.00024534325348213315, -0.008398983627557755, 0.051177579909563065, -0.023543767631053925, -0.0028245151042938232, -0.04469038546085358, -0.01057657040655613, -0.08420280367136002, 0.05593962222337723, -0.09947136789560318, -0.026048414409160614, -0.024414408951997757, -0.015504036098718643, -0.02341598831117153, -0.09167225658893585, 0.010574723593890667, 0.03518570587038994, 0.030322108417749405, 0.022316206246614456, -0.01723015122115612, -0.06785430014133453, -0.007532934192568064, 0.022423096001148224, -0.029629455879330635, -0.014643369242548943, -0.04441704973578453, 0.0407438799738884, -0.05404246971011162, -0.012837554328143597, -0.021947162225842476, -0.0016580690862610936, 0.006172120571136475, 0.0014837333001196384, 0.030985845252871513, 0.09640971571207047, -0.017331819981336594, -0.022971555590629578, 0.048678115010261536, 0.027971012517809868, 0.01738116145133972, 0.05948508903384209, 0.007658536080271006, -0.04958534613251686, -0.0015414227964356542, -0.01107176672667265, 0.021827172487974167, -0.03403511270880699, 0.0583905354142189, 0.023466797545552254, -0.02694101445376873, -0.05644628778100014, 0.02196894772350788, 0.04157807677984238, 0.0050309691578149796, 0.05868237093091011, 0.04736544191837311, 0.002970190020278096, 0.04056011140346527, -0.012249876745045185, 0.06926634907722473, -0.06372972577810287, 0.0079786516726017 ]
278
278
Information-theoretic limits of selecting binary graphical models in high dimensions
The problem of graphical model selection is to correctly estimate the graph structure of a Markov random field given samples from the underlying distribution. We analyze the information-theoretic limitations of the problem of graph selection for binary Markov random fields under high-dimensional scaling, in which the graph size $p$ and the number of edges $k$, and/or the maximal node degree $d$ are allowed to increase to infinity as a function of the sample size $n$. For pairwise binary Markov random fields, we derive both necessary and sufficient conditions for correct graph selection over the class $\mathcal{G}_{p,k}$ of graphs on $p$ vertices with at most $k$ edges, and over the class $\mathcal{G}_{p,d}$ of graphs on $p$ vertices with maximum degree at most $d$. For the class $\mathcal{G}_{p, k}$, we establish the existence of constants $c$ and $c'$ such that if $\numobs < c k \log p$, any method has error probability at least 1/2 uniformly over the family, and we demonstrate a graph decoder that succeeds with high probability uniformly over the family for sample sizes $\numobs > c' k^2 \log p$. Similarly, for the class $\mathcal{G}_{p,d}$, we exhibit constants $c$ and $c'$ such that for $n < c d^2 \log p$, any method fails with probability at least 1/2, and we demonstrate a graph decoder that succeeds with high probability for $n > c' d^3 \log p$.
[ -0.06506235152482986, -0.02576969936490059, 0.003315371461212635, -0.04915309697389603, 0.007945418357849121, -0.00311529403552413, 0.06724433600902557, 0.019451873376965523, -0.07934893667697906, -0.01330215111374855, 0.013692706823348999, -0.09575452655553818, -0.040471892803907394, -0.00003691280653583817, 0.016004405915737152, -0.02353096939623356, 0.009760652668774128, -0.004373406060039997, 0.06350548565387726, -0.04592786356806755, -0.02200225181877613, 0.02058573253452778, -0.0001216587916132994, 0.014861405827105045, 0.01191096194088459, 0.05494345724582672, 0.016333799809217453, -0.05751720815896988, -0.09691065549850464, 0.01973743550479412, -0.036527059972286224, 0.040047843009233475, -0.03354605287313461, -0.00291150133125484, 0.022604238241910934, -0.021929346024990082, -0.018847163766622543, -0.025856919586658478, -0.04958232864737511, -0.005459084641188383, 0.0025237733498215675, -0.04855605587363243, -0.03229918330907822, -0.0386795811355114, 0.03515991196036339, 0.03231612965464592, 0.0027928936760872602, 0.023900555446743965, 0.03255612403154373, 0.07985415309667587, -0.05491049960255623, 0.08890572190284729, 0.012704596854746342, 0.02454400062561035, -0.06312042474746704, 0.006382879335433245, -0.05846695601940155, 0.040534719824790955, -0.014939007349312305, 0.008309523575007915, 0.051109690219163895, 0.052022866904735565, -0.05155220255255699, -0.10245022177696228, -0.0425591878592968, -0.004156447947025299, -0.041196130216121674, 0.07956089824438095, -0.024710729718208313, -0.02430707961320877, 0.04603159800171852, -0.0352044478058815, 0.06307975947856903, 0.06965573132038116, -0.014405936934053898, 0.0015090738888829947, -0.03512559086084366, 0.036933381110429764, 0.013573572970926762, 0.08759184181690216, -0.06663012504577637, 0.0444759875535965, -0.016933005303144455, 0.08088400214910507, -0.015176580287516117, 0.06826672703027725, 0.005837435834109783, -0.08554530888795853, -0.06839913874864578, -0.02927669696509838, -0.017361773177981377, 0.0675554946064949, -0.010570147074759007, 0.07299522310495377, -0.07941263169050217, 0.06140732765197754, -0.07188678532838821, 0.03816447779536247, -0.0018614078871905804, 0.029116254299879074, -0.06172647699713707, -0.09697705507278442, 0.0025871656835079193, 0.028075775131583214, -0.009273435920476913, -0.016017241403460503, -0.03360006958246231, 0.0776987373828888, 0.05274626240134239, -0.12565170228481293, 0.019995536655187607, -0.07788141071796417, 0.0005698708700947464, 0.0029130850452929735, -0.08635780215263367, 0.04856384918093681, 0.0008200923912227154, 0.04147951304912567, -0.010162290185689926, -0.009667961858212948, 0.00685345521196723, -0.017689358443021774, -0.06677301228046417, 0.02050340175628662, 0.013035852462053299, -0.08695860952138901, 0.012890447862446308, -0.017521724104881287, 0.07320038974285126, 0.01770860143005848, -0.05213741585612297, -0.01623113825917244, -0.03150595724582672, 0.013414712622761726, -0.09602685272693634, 0.022414088249206543, 0.03865725174546242, -0.03912336751818657, 0.006973630748689175, 0.10729161649942398, -0.018667396157979965, -0.042558230459690094, 0.05793584883213043, -0.02025247924029827, -0.056032441556453705, 0.1218867301940918, -0.03292078524827957, -0.0022382293827831745, -0.04300696402788162, -0.011592758819460869, -0.02777710370719433, -0.07676128298044205, 0.055541928857564926, 0.010586600750684738, 0.07747574150562286, -0.03333460912108421, -0.00991417933255434, 0.007467930670827627, 0.02451445162296295, -0.006918054074048996, -0.0394572876393795, 0.018484342843294144, 0.0526362769305706, 0.01433560810983181, -0.003060795832425356, -0.01786867156624794, -0.08448208123445511, 0.0023886901326477528, -0.02675275318324566, 0.0026359455659985542, 0.050785306841135025, -0.037121500819921494, 0.00037729385076090693, 0.025232596322894096, 0.041600458323955536, 0.008047620765864849, -0.00036400032695382833, 0.01769561506807804, 0.03179300203919411, -0.006025274284183979, 0.022696025669574738, -0.013557245954871178, 0.023950273171067238, -0.0075757065787911415, 0.007815311662852764, 0.09335462749004364, -0.0372975617647171, -0.004517819732427597, 0.03104209713637829, 0.08019337803125381, 0.032887473702430725, -0.018636858090758324, 0.027883486822247505, -0.019233232364058495, -0.08473871648311615, -0.014477848075330257, -0.1562882959842682, 0.022558266296982765, 0.012716630473732948, 0.02569366618990898, 0.012243403121829033, 0.008438716642558575, -0.0055207759141922, -0.01630343869328499, -0.04037787392735481, 0.0027583909686654806, 0.11384602636098862, -0.04195554926991463, -0.03810933977365494, -0.0820794478058815, 0.0028193385805934668, 0.018774116411805153, 0.020213518291711807, 0.0015756454085931182, 0.04754573479294777, -0.07001873850822449, -0.03584039956331253, -0.037762150168418884, 0.06856469064950943, -0.014959010295569897, -0.06837348639965057, 0.06452951580286026, -0.0177907794713974, -0.029264377430081367, -0.06631011515855789, 0.019785864278674126, 0.0285116545855999, 0.05658378824591637, -0.0646425262093544, 0.07742247730493546, 0.025255562737584114, -0.07424671947956085, -0.028967203572392464, 0.008473888970911503, -0.0085263317450881, 0.06234613433480263, -0.0464877225458622, 0.007256615906953812, -0.01632203906774521, 0.05333540961146355, -0.025930192321538925, 0.015018540434539318, -0.04053002595901489, -0.08856441080570221, -0.017020918428897858, -0.07004912942647934, 0.07280018925666809, 0.038667887449264526, 0.0019916160963475704, 0.012733166106045246, -0.01280620601028204, 0.058498136699199677, 0.0233142226934433, 0.038505446165800095, -0.01727534830570221, -0.026068415492773056, 0.008816856890916824, 0.07370984554290771, 0.07144011557102203, 0.05220161750912666, 0.06271366029977798, 0.003760361345484853, -0.05503981187939644, -0.02812275104224682, 0.09156554937362671, 0.04496166110038757, 0.031741913408041, 0.00864937249571085, 0.0066437385976314545, 0.016965247690677643, 0.0763719379901886, -0.07212086766958237, -0.04880336672067642, 0.09568452090024948, -0.005839684512466192, 0.08053728193044662, 0.05264607444405556, 0.04950781911611557, 0.00428105378523469, -0.04055032506585121, -0.004182402975857258, 0.021284662187099457, -0.007889257743954659, -0.05372501537203789, 0.04751770943403244, 0.09744678437709808, -0.058827128261327744, -0.003708850359544158, -0.02087082900106907, -0.0008376277983188629, -0.05744145065546036, 0.012709047645330429, -0.0824771299958229, -0.028140854090452194, 0.011730249971151352, -0.043692875653505325, 0.06800125539302826, 0.013279471546411514, 0.08193153887987137, -0.026241427287459373, -0.035216350108385086, 0.02955358661711216, 0.0424659438431263, 0.03268396109342575, 0.016606276854872704, 0.029221538454294205, -0.049946703016757965, -0.05263087525963783, -0.04289736971259117, -0.08390656858682632, -0.009515197016298771, -0.03836807981133461, -0.03057701699435711, -0.007944419980049133, 0.019318105652928352, -0.00017824055976234376, -0.020859813317656517, -0.005234187003225088, -0.03587904945015907, -0.002720347372815013, -0.019412590190768242, 0.027122601866722107, -0.02374815009534359, 0.03694374859333038, -0.04100990667939186, 0.01845385879278183, 0.02414373867213726, 0.11931346356868744, 0.011641101911664009, -0.05061554163694382, -0.03235325962305069, -0.02917899377644062, -0.04346013441681862, 0.05700385197997093, -0.0015510838711634278, -0.02113964967429638, -0.04609198868274689, -0.04396028071641922, -0.03328336402773857, 0.020773127675056458, -0.007509310729801655, -0.09621550142765045, -0.04390169680118561, 0.016141794621944427, 0.10409186035394669, 0.10295898467302322, 0.045144982635974884, -0.04006081819534302, 0.08592028170824051, 0.009951228275895119, -0.019663052633404732, 0.02818562462925911, 0.026450160890817642, 0.022118426859378815, -0.007674121297895908, 0.0838097557425499, 0.07053972780704498, -0.03774312511086464, 0.024935631081461906, -0.0032158822286874056, -0.04197346046566963, -0.002436156617477536, 0.012074174359440804, 0.01885008066892624, 0.008995162323117256, 0.009349699132144451, -0.0015052866656333208, 0.0793788880109787, -0.00006656166806351393, 0.03335924074053764, 0.045222774147987366, 0.02984429895877838, -0.021734250709414482, 0.05225564166903496, -0.004664234351366758, -0.04794374480843544, 0.0028652180917561054, -0.0529547855257988, 0.05255519971251488, 0.07837853580713272, -0.02853732369840145, 0.008630985394120216, -0.033203624188899994, 0.007031159475445747, 0.015599246136844158, -0.036904092878103256, -0.07840666174888611, 0.04438605532050133, 0.11652164906263351, 0.026530278846621513, -0.00888128113001585, 0.02406841702759266, 0.000321688101394102, 0.01539184432476759, 0.025479832664132118, 0.03379707783460617, 0.04728950560092926, -0.0027109705843031406, -0.026996394619345665, -0.003976218868046999, 0.022972378879785538, -0.05951251462101936, -0.03482342138886452, -0.05371624976396561, -0.054698504507541656, -0.038640040904283524, -0.05256791040301323, -0.008852469734847546, 0.04685666784644127, 0.033926356583833694, 0.02081148512661457, 0.034870851784944534, -0.038194384425878525, 0.045084405690431595, -0.010486381128430367, 0.06301958858966827, -0.048659797757864, 0.04383891448378563, -0.029465600848197937, 0.013800439424812794, 0.040162742137908936, 0.019428323954343796, -0.03750866279006004, 0.006726216524839401, -0.03508248180150986, -0.05121631547808647, 0.0990108922123909, 0.04371991381049156, 0.0003507419896777719, 0.03309560567140579, -0.039904214441776276, -0.01552687119692564, -0.03961823508143425, -0.02466798759996891, 0.00781459454447031, -0.03852703049778938, -0.04269123077392578, -0.0299682579934597, 0.025967683643102646, -0.012769345194101334, -0.0008810616564005613, 0.04159899428486824, -0.041276004165410995, -0.008068563416600227, 0.018526673316955566, 0.03850407153367996, 0.0447540208697319, -0.02482072450220585, 0.009677037596702576, 0.11777767539024353, -0.012581514194607735, 0.06391917169094086, 0.021169956773519516, -0.044638894498348236, -0.008242185227572918, -0.027896612882614136, 0.03507031500339508, 0.0002208202931797132, 0.037529345601797104, -0.004308418370783329, -0.006017356179654598, -0.0730290487408638, 0.015717465430498123, 0.03582385554909706, -0.0520985946059227, 0.01804182305932045, 0.02944222092628479, -0.0526246652007103, 0.08559677749872208, 0.0004972008755430579, -0.0525224506855011, 0.06107744202017784, -0.006147073581814766, -0.002239910652860999, 0.025402376428246498, -0.02769222855567932, 0.006587098352611065, -0.048730552196502686, 0.029404709115624428, -0.05866019055247307, 0.013358182273805141, 0.032923854887485504, 0.00908840075135231, -0.04298187419772148, 0.03381548076868057, 0.050131767988204956, -0.015740428119897842, 0.009090321138501167, -0.024255216121673584, -0.00518674124032259, -0.03589801490306854, -0.008787314407527447, 0.009081980213522911, -0.006144560407847166, -0.018688499927520752, 0.032154567539691925, 0.03202592208981514, 0.025169357657432556, 0.0036125434562563896, 0.026957347989082336, 0.01241274829953909, -0.016694188117980957, 0.03756987303495407, 0.006284342613071203, 0.04100213944911957, 0.02126404270529747, 0.03544443100690842, -0.011402948759496212, -0.04653530195355415, 0.017348235473036766, 0.00939298514276743, -0.026298265904188156 ]
279
279
Average-Case Active Learning with Costs
We analyze the expected cost of a greedy active learning algorithm. Our analysis extends previous work to a more general setting in which different queries have different costs. Moreover, queries may have more than two possible responses and the distribution over hypotheses may be non uniform. Specific applications include active learning with label costs, active learning for multiclass and partial label queries, and batch mode active learning. We also discuss an approximate version of interest when there are very many queries.
[ 0.00848704855889082, -0.02363787405192852, 0.07378555089235306, 0.03653120994567871, 0.03750460967421532, -0.054185785353183746, -0.03639078885316849, 0.005389669444411993, 0.018802007660269737, 0.03036811761558056, 0.04176893085241318, 0.0000574169862375129, 0.014218267984688282, 0.07331593334674835, 0.03998332470655441, 0.02870173566043377, -0.0998649075627327, -0.0553029403090477, -0.00742005230858922, -0.05005187541246414, 0.08149149268865585, -0.013094883412122726, 0.009959101676940918, -0.002769949147477746, -0.022778358310461044, -0.01701655238866806, -0.024527810513973236, 0.04205426201224327, 0.0086965998634696, -0.028479721397161484, -0.06680991500616074, 0.09854353219270706, -0.016408855095505714, 0.009713280946016312, -0.011005541309714317, -0.05064947530627251, 0.09622085094451904, -0.019350867718458176, -0.04582349210977554, -0.0825265496969223, 0.06186838820576668, -0.037193577736616135, -0.0012666104594245553, 0.049363214522600174, 0.09104383736848831, 0.022634468972682953, 0.015457851812243462, -0.02501293085515499, 0.020669253543019295, 0.08400630950927734, -0.0828729122877121, -0.0846564769744873, -0.0023792744614183903, 0.0003235448675695807, 0.01199912279844284, 0.042904082685709, -0.00910796970129013, -0.01810491643846035, -0.0012081428430974483, -0.0265683364123106, 0.04339483752846718, 0.07666286081075668, -0.009638414718210697, 0.05972304195165634, -0.035520829260349274, 0.056610945612192154, -0.039360929280519485, -0.028801847249269485, -0.028892435133457184, 0.05160580202937126, 0.06352163851261139, -0.05107706040143967, 0.011473235674202442, 0.03312179073691368, 0.03404797241091728, -0.030592063441872597, -0.09190700203180313, 0.021619314327836037, -0.02904457226395607, 0.0808706134557724, -0.061551980674266815, 0.008578665554523468, -0.030701052397489548, 0.05234658345580101, -0.0459318682551384, -0.026100652292370796, 0.021466948091983795, -0.04962530732154846, -0.019019441679120064, 0.02933989278972149, -0.028703561052680016, 0.020589087158441544, -0.018298909068107605, 0.05496639758348465, -0.026081878691911697, 0.08606716245412827, 0.026008212938904762, -0.02097366936504841, -0.027643905952572823, 0.04235771670937538, 0.027909360826015472, -0.02607898600399494, 0.0015017978148534894, 0.0634990707039833, -0.1000840961933136, -0.006233049090951681, -0.0029160319827497005, 0.005745705217123032, 0.054578933864831924, -0.06938609480857849, 0.015659837052226067, -0.013943258672952652, 0.01142627838999033, 0.01915661431849003, -0.06408945471048355, 0.08752948045730591, -0.012613318860530853, 0.03842126205563545, -0.01682381145656109, 0.05017706751823425, 0.0014507034793496132, -0.003274299670010805, -0.0692138597369194, 0.04660290479660034, 0.001152374199591577, -0.050098393112421036, -0.011925249360501766, -0.08875694870948792, 0.08897010236978531, 0.056081414222717285, 0.013073140755295753, 0.06894038617610931, 0.006454946473240852, -0.13343513011932373, -0.0651467964053154, 0.027727322652935982, 0.06306805461645126, -0.06308060884475708, 0.043108388781547546, 0.02815779112279415, 0.012131803669035435, 0.0636533573269844, -0.04073815420269966, -0.0022030917461961508, -0.00849562231451273, 0.014086473733186722, -0.03394438326358795, 0.004548138473182917, 0.01393585279583931, -0.008525134064257145, 0.013569609262049198, 0.059594571590423584, 0.05100212246179581, 0.05023466795682907, 0.027942383661866188, -0.0020238831639289856, -0.0173074658960104, 0.03911153972148895, -0.05068548768758774, -0.012440172024071217, 0.018995344638824463, 0.08767278492450714, -0.03675404191017151, 0.0021611498668789864, -0.025921469554305077, 0.012808984145522118, -0.01923302747309208, 0.01870105043053627, -0.05455823987722397, 0.0015140227042138577, -0.0073834615759551525, -0.0035326573997735977, -0.057250674813985825, 0.0413985438644886, 0.0077149816788733006, 0.0020720171742141247, 0.033324938267469406, 0.004658564459532499, -0.032269127666950226, -0.001470689196139574, 0.08537790179252625, -0.09955006837844849, -0.04269014298915863, -0.05273684486746788, 0.026075510308146477, 0.03801131248474121, 0.05417025461792946, 0.002657029777765274, 0.03755289316177368, -0.019618825986981392, -0.045574598014354706, 0.013109003193676472, 0.026608906686306, 0.08972261101007462, -0.01013751607388258, 0.038044337183237076, -0.030171524733304977, 0.0017929079476743937, -0.03663912042975426, 0.04761029779911041, 0.015340571291744709, 0.004605219699442387, -0.00023564498405903578, -0.03332560881972313, 0.018021835014224052, -0.002498684683814645, 0.003172428347170353, -0.021542686969041824, -0.05328210070729256, -0.010791964828968048, 0.09724310785531998, -0.0020629768259823322, -0.015319205820560455, -0.023373084142804146, 0.026006756350398064, -0.037678543478250504, 0.007544832304120064, 0.03218097239732742, 0.03624257445335388, -0.004105837550014257, -0.061275314539670944, 0.04782920703291893, -0.006322965957224369, 0.05046042427420616, -0.07226511836051941, 0.001146583934314549, 0.030308473855257034, -0.03385528549551964, -0.024489520117640495, 0.06669051945209503, -0.05062280222773552, 0.005541467573493719, -0.021391374990344048, 0.034011196345090866, -0.011609064415097237, 0.047601260244846344, -0.007285195402801037, -0.04103969782590866, -0.009089216589927673, 0.0037299746181815863, -0.03757932037115097, 0.09220913052558899, 0.019020337611436844, -0.06862962245941162, 0.03499159961938858, 0.0790499672293663, 0.054597459733486176, -0.06684323400259018, -0.12209189683198929, -0.04115748032927513, 0.05457698926329613, 0.000366467545973137, -0.042646363377571106, 0.016183335334062576, -0.0032473281025886536, -0.0036226867232471704, 0.046461060643196106, 0.10520897805690765, 0.02643936313688755, 0.06169751659035683, -0.03291483595967293, 0.10620191693305969, -0.09025143086910248, 0.011385111138224602, 0.06537706404924393, -0.04530077055096626, 0.01106890756636858, 0.025326643139123917, 0.044124044477939606, 0.008004271425306797, 0.01695074886083603, -0.08588990569114685, -0.045146241784095764, 0.09124205261468887, -0.04574979096651077, -0.03431720286607742, 0.05645057186484337, -0.02077396586537361, 0.09447009861469269, -0.029556261375546455, -0.05554063990712166, -0.012574505992233753, 0.06778715550899506, -0.010889353230595589, -0.0205494724214077, 0.008675456047058105, -0.042380087077617645, -0.07133781909942627, 0.03394830599427223, -0.019076820462942123, -0.052498362958431244, -0.01065914798527956, -0.055082499980926514, 0.048367440700531006, 0.010277976281940937, -0.022499779239296913, -0.0005661475006490946, -0.007258365396410227, 0.018247824162244797, 0.030003746971488, -0.034359078854322433, 0.11865927278995514, 0.0406218059360981, -0.008413971401751041, 0.05288982391357422, 0.010226555168628693, 0.005063938908278942, 0.040068723261356354, -0.047333262860774994, -0.0014206127962097526, -0.012200044468045235, -0.01157701201736927, 0.025079024955630302, 0.018331745639443398, 0.036614663898944855, 0.06171410530805588, -0.05096401646733284, -0.02247779630124569, -0.03948136791586876, 0.015357529744505882, 0.02569081261754036, -0.04287901893258095, 0.06761083751916885, -0.011151297949254513, -0.09894649684429169, -0.061735156923532486, -0.010881507769227028, -0.028342651203274727, -0.02959204837679863, 0.06342342495918274, -0.07505344599485397, -0.004741309210658073, -0.03077004849910736, 0.10745041072368622, -0.06993254274129868, 0.0241192989051342, -0.06706512719392776, 0.08023510128259659, -0.02768510952591896, 0.03288106620311737, -0.02419230341911316, -0.052843425422906876, -0.015536990948021412, -0.016772035509347916, 0.013103124685585499, -0.0010092239826917648, 0.0654124766588211, 0.029847268015146255, -0.06121479719877243, 0.1378437876701355, -0.02869291417300701, -0.03941427543759346, -0.01905220001935959, 0.08061837404966354, -0.03301762416958809, 0.0070364754647016525, 0.0513264499604702, 0.006075217388570309, -0.014158086851239204, 0.01712525635957718, 0.0013528666459023952, -0.012038514949381351, -0.018927844241261482, -0.010915371589362621, -0.012570369057357311, -0.005544829182326794, -0.07302891463041306, -0.02689889445900917, -0.025225911289453506, 0.05252491310238838, 0.015176611952483654, -0.006593838334083557, 0.06333037465810776, 0.0030695111490786076, -0.012714630924165249, 0.01503234263509512, -0.030008872970938683, -0.07391810417175293, 0.023783480748534203, 0.0246907789260149, -0.02625431679189205, 0.009865504689514637, -0.03628320246934891, -0.049285586923360825, -0.0766310915350914, -0.08174661546945572, 0.0013414728455245495, 0.05210921913385391, 0.08146262913942337, -0.01290010567754507, 0.02825007028877735, -0.027614394202828407, 0.026858951896429062, 0.01387765072286129, 0.03434641659259796, -0.018677666783332825, -0.016165683045983315, -0.028017545118927956, -0.016239967197179794, 0.03947104886174202, 0.01364116556942463, 0.03663913160562515, 0.0266848336905241, -0.05449644848704338, -0.05088960379362106, 0.01470194198191166, 0.056578706949949265, 0.09447944164276123, -0.004771064035594463, 0.0684024915099144, 0.077721007168293, -0.006329316645860672, -0.011406759731471539, 0.014207210391759872, -0.02747841738164425, 0.04456327483057976, -0.0014945600414648652, -0.009880689904093742, -0.01385406032204628, -0.09476077556610107, -0.004508222918957472, -0.04644223675131798, 0.00947542767971754, -0.005372840445488691, -0.0422961451113224, -0.0885394737124443, 0.028935134410858154, -0.0400652140378952, 0.008247574791312218, 0.03645642101764679, 0.04796456918120384, -0.018279818817973137, -0.08879052847623825, 0.02060086466372013, -0.019901800900697708, 0.028182847425341606, 0.06848642975091934, 0.07545562833547592, 0.004553784150630236, 0.018639057874679565, -0.04935483634471893, 0.034455522894859314, -0.0006757048540748656, -0.011459993198513985, -0.0359203927218914, 0.029363567009568214, -0.002226598560810089, -0.010433650575578213, 0.07741057127714157, 0.031419605016708374, 0.00399034982547164, 0.030342523008584976, -0.03119191899895668, 0.006774531677365303, -0.0043197316117584705, 0.006040830630809069, -0.010453888215124607, -0.0434565506875515, 0.02365749701857567, -0.011631590314209461, 0.0008050051401369274, -0.031248513609170914, 0.04161517322063446, 0.015917878597974777, -0.035653434693813324, -0.0051188901998102665, 0.048862721771001816, 0.0034191682934761047, 0.05054760351777077, 0.012212857604026794, -0.01860416680574417, 0.046984948217868805, 0.01930338889360428, -0.12617839872837067, -0.023241505026817322, 0.09175540506839752, 0.02010573074221611, -0.005701633635908365, 0.07943342626094818, -0.03325280174612999, 0.041387397795915604, 0.05382687225937843, -0.0635661706328392, -0.012899022549390793, 0.004688973072916269, 0.03780839219689369, -0.08001021295785904, 0.030022097751498222, -0.008498908951878548, 0.03510056808590889, -0.004114522598683834, -0.054558951407670975, -0.05851421877741814, 0.006733742076903582, -0.048079609870910645, -0.04572431370615959, 0.026573343202471733, -0.004113850183784962, 0.022776499390602112, -0.003667831886559725, 0.04733430594205856, -0.04885635897517204, 0.044248901307582855, 0.008663389831781387, 0.03677705302834511, 0.0022003743797540665, -0.012002553790807724, 0.022467711940407753, -0.008016935549676418, -0.03184894099831581, -0.031113505363464355, 0.021885471418499947 ]
280
280
Information Distance in Multiples
Information distance is a parameter-free similarity measure based on compression, used in pattern recognition, data mining, phylogeny, clustering, and classification. The notion of information distance is extended from pairs to multiples (finite lists). We study maximal overlap, metricity, universality, minimal overlap, additivity, and normalized information distance in multiples. We use the theoretical notion of Kolmogorov complexity which for practical purposes is approximated by the length of the compressed version of the file involved, using a real-world compression program. {\em Index Terms}-- Information distance, multiples, pattern recognition, data mining, similarity, Kolmogorov complexity
[ 0.0433163158595562, -0.017572687938809395, 0.020625272765755653, -0.017459088936448097, -0.060675524175167084, -0.012892068363726139, 0.004993443842977285, -0.013608627021312714, -0.03222222253680229, -0.013936697505414486, -0.003360598348081112, -0.05419350415468216, -0.014142538420855999, -0.026393534615635872, -0.03312095254659653, 0.013578761368989944, -0.05074264854192734, -0.03703789785504341, 0.0017528388416394591, -0.06582006812095642, -0.02126951701939106, 0.05046086013317108, -0.04369570314884186, -0.04145347326993942, 0.0003534396819304675, -0.010228036902844906, 0.03767147287726402, 0.024520782753825188, 0.0030933748930692673, 0.003116745501756668, 0.011841289699077606, -0.038672953844070435, 0.11497507244348526, 0.049567870795726776, 0.00013983235112391412, 0.040696825832128525, -0.04407365992665291, 0.0012997534358873963, -0.06137050315737724, -0.046339403837919235, -0.03530282527208328, -0.06109653040766716, -0.03982097655534744, 0.015609598718583584, 0.050787195563316345, 0.04176566004753113, 0.0025989548303186893, 0.05001789331436157, 0.02545091323554516, 0.07133011519908905, -0.07324924319982529, 0.04256756231188774, 0.009243760257959366, -0.024146029725670815, 0.027714595198631287, 0.06145717203617096, 0.016477486118674278, -0.04803372919559479, 0.058767784386873245, -0.05599924549460411, 0.03508003056049347, 0.08367756754159927, 0.010885936208069324, -0.024348357692360878, -0.07596439123153687, -0.019399605691432953, -0.12130419909954071, 0.03698771446943283, -0.05777762830257416, -0.07813549041748047, -0.04825534299015999, -0.06050033122301102, 0.01431705430150032, -0.03449594974517822, 0.041069962084293365, 0.02210063301026821, -0.006359112914651632, 0.0362204909324646, 0.04044188931584358, 0.07906752824783325, 0.013965816237032413, 0.05655035004019737, -0.06763407588005066, -0.07445072382688522, -0.10981611162424088, -0.008389360271394253, 0.025883309543132782, -0.02032526768743992, 0.05725868418812752, 0.0011913292109966278, -0.018001167103648186, -0.07359403371810913, -0.1281646341085434, 0.06189284473657608, -0.012393506243824959, 0.052811961621046066, -0.00981256552040577, 0.020889876410365105, 0.011211656033992767, -0.031242074444890022, -0.018933191895484924, -0.010133863426744938, 0.018052486702799797, -0.03974932059645653, 0.029579928144812584, -0.028391679748892784, -0.07471858710050583, 0.06979589909315109, 0.014486754313111305, -0.06475018709897995, 0.002593833254650235, -0.020355671644210815, -0.04594583064317703, -0.02988537587225437, -0.04978273808956146, 0.051411841064691544, 0.014639798551797867, 0.014108287170529366, 0.0022040926851332188, 0.029506154358386993, 0.0034532458521425724, -0.012508433312177658, 0.026505209505558014, 0.05580423027276993, 0.01929289475083351, -0.027746647596359253, -0.08769827336072922, 0.0010699406266212463, 0.13214731216430664, -0.00049742148257792, -0.106373630464077, 0.02910122647881508, -0.008599377237260342, 0.0007438249886035919, -0.05275079235434532, -0.004586823750287294, 0.03687004745006561, 0.0481463260948658, 0.01102520152926445, 0.06176232919096947, -0.020363127812743187, -0.025198522955179214, 0.006311837118119001, -0.030109956860542297, -0.003331555752083659, 0.016482148319482803, -0.015605646185576916, -0.0018937031272798777, 0.024540992453694344, 0.0001883907098090276, 0.017607802525162697, -0.03339221701025963, 0.04184415936470032, 0.02051187865436077, -0.03622822463512421, -0.07970604300498962, -0.02708137407898903, -0.0201678778976202, -0.01253248006105423, -0.00955311767756939, -0.0739353746175766, 0.0040533216670155525, 0.0075695510022342205, -0.015029078349471092, 0.014721537940204144, -0.027544766664505005, -0.009634698741137981, -0.05757889896631241, 0.02136988937854767, 0.02962196059525013, 0.035906124860048294, -0.014447969384491444, 0.04549102112650871, 0.06436724215745926, 0.06567542999982834, -0.02489263005554676, -0.09291739761829376, 0.021777279675006866, 0.0015007780166342854, -0.035909056663513184, 0.014970622025430202, -0.04688504338264465, -0.00784357637166977, 0.06615040451288223, -0.024950126186013222, 0.038152243942022324, -0.03071299009025097, -0.033002905547618866, 0.001979468623176217, 0.007766720373183489, 0.08585331588983536, -0.016891052946448326, 0.061998359858989716, 0.004599214531481266, 0.0007302211015485227, 0.033388592302799225, -0.07071009278297424, -0.08048925548791885, -0.0069559658877551556, 0.06100885197520256, 0.05974072217941284, -0.03666604682803154, 0.0411943718791008, -0.05070482939481735, -0.06578712910413742, -0.012307761237025261, -0.01466774009168148, 0.021212834864854813, -0.014117163605988026, -0.038834936916828156, -0.03753219172358513, 0.03850533440709114, 0.06958311051130295, 0.023287152871489525, 0.039245545864105225, -0.010565736331045628, -0.018634460866451263, -0.0030621846672147512, 0.001363252871669829, 0.03998834267258644, 0.00608105817809701, -0.013259700499475002, 0.04238921403884888, 0.056723710149526596, -0.06283773481845856, 0.004505040589720011, 0.008431159891188145, 0.034001994878053665, -0.05791585519909859, -0.01742151938378811, -0.028020421043038368, 0.0032619701232761145, -0.059302814304828644, -0.05370703712105751, 0.022676881402730942, 0.0094709862023592, -0.05084299296140671, -0.010430875234305859, 0.045293357223272324, 0.020880701020359993, -0.07183147966861725, 0.059404898434877396, 0.008318782784044743, 0.05964003503322601, 0.006329765077680349, 0.08435601741075516, 0.03408395126461983, 0.020603716373443604, -0.000346216227626428, -0.013175605796277523, -0.02163238637149334, -0.0613945871591568, 0.11732488125562668, -0.021683912724256516, 0.04535015672445297, 0.054523516446352005, 0.0197371244430542, 0.004782263655215502, 0.06319718807935715, 0.08940614759922028, -0.029455991461873055, 0.0864037498831749, -0.07110113650560379, -0.017992611974477768, 0.012553438544273376, -0.03676365688443184, -0.0048901354894042015, 0.06880835443735123, 0.04153525084257126, -0.02648855932056904, 0.02885703183710575, -0.034543704241514206, -0.06718765944242477, 0.07065622508525848, -0.004053728189319372, -0.07419166713953018, 0.013602035120129585, 0.05799614265561104, 0.03981779143214226, -0.09650091826915741, -0.1209597960114479, -0.00794791616499424, -0.005653959233313799, -0.04082639515399933, -0.04870451241731644, 0.013814466074109077, -0.00351400556974113, 0.0070307436399161816, 0.01682964339852333, -0.018828323110938072, -0.05871697515249252, 0.035253480076789856, -0.13839150965213776, -0.0263250432908535, -0.04902016371488571, 0.0025386763736605644, 0.03529142588376999, 0.020486993715167046, 0.07003504037857056, 0.005750262178480625, -0.013904141262173653, -0.0026717702858150005, 0.10310474783182144, 0.04125939682126045, -0.009901179932057858, 0.022355983033776283, 0.08171599358320236, 0.01817222684621811, -0.08791972696781158, -0.021347275003790855, 0.042809002101421356, 0.05577496439218521, -0.04691193252801895, 0.00414179777726531, 0.010373542085289955, -0.0631270781159401, -0.04093237966299057, 0.04235224425792694, -0.046715691685676575, -0.08195580542087555, 0.00045196618884801865, 0.06845852732658386, 0.009580282494425774, -0.08126107603311539, -0.048187676817178726, -0.03394860401749611, 0.04049074649810791, -0.0507856085896492, -0.0415816456079483, 0.05481882020831108, -0.12155453860759735, -0.011214337311685085, -0.053958941251039505, 0.048958487808704376, 0.022664394229650497, -0.029309317469596863, -0.029170852154493332, -0.015444404445588589, -0.01669466309249401, -0.003406875068321824, 0.002831892343237996, -0.0013693426735699177, -0.019428281113505363, -0.09231889992952347, 0.02695135399699211, 0.032247498631477356, 0.040266238152980804, -0.05469492822885513, 0.02485346794128418, -0.021719055250287056, -0.015708444640040398, 0.07544168829917908, 0.045406609773635864, -0.048283424228429794, 0.00850362703204155, 0.12374614924192429, 0.059981975704431534, 0.018649008125066757, 0.024774961173534393, 0.027327770367264748, 0.006997867487370968, 0.09663417190313339, -0.024782244116067886, 0.007375084795057774, 0.05782417580485344, 0.03968127444386482, -0.0736590176820755, 0.009611617773771286, -0.023676272481679916, 0.02891862764954567, 0.044572863727808, 0.07842378318309784, 0.0895603820681572, -0.03441762179136276, 0.01941029727458954, -0.0660027340054512, -0.02098121866583824, -0.033146850764751434, 0.001209215261042118, -0.022875096648931503, -0.06706888973712921, -0.013793711550533772, -0.04460921138525009, 0.014724314212799072, -0.018633006140589714, 0.006383715197443962, 0.002252026228234172, 0.0015326584689319134, 0.007404225878417492, 0.0381523035466671, -0.007866235449910164, -0.043530043214559555, -0.005748895928263664, -0.0681326687335968, 0.02826526388525963, -0.004323980771005154, 0.019139431416988373, 0.02968556061387062, -0.03271597623825073, -0.047897979617118835, 0.04340009018778801, -0.012939834035933018, -0.011269548907876015, -0.05518193915486336, -0.08401007205247879, 0.003967105410993099, -0.03438585251569748, 0.032288774847984314, -0.038513511419296265, 0.028192853555083275, 0.022116797044873238, -0.05733943730592728, 0.0030618361197412014, -0.0017132769571617246, 0.051084719598293304, 0.07159362733364105, 0.03961155563592911, -0.03466162085533142, 0.07192552834749222, -0.02494358830153942, 0.02723226696252823, -0.026668565347790718, -0.0031631384044885635, 0.010339905507862568, 0.003666824195533991, -0.03694024682044983, -0.0001440290652681142, 0.019902529194951057, 0.009272798895835876, 0.013091279193758965, -0.017881812527775764, 0.014647028408944607, 0.014050892554223537, 0.02540556527674198, 0.06884617358446121, -0.007364125922322273, 0.08129235357046127, -0.01312771625816822, -0.03414987772703171, -0.024518918246030807, 0.03115862049162388, 0.08368083834648132, 0.054941486567258835, 0.06565909087657928, 0.014542803168296814, -0.053475651890039444, 0.07159268856048584, 0.028652682900428772, 0.0145651800557971, 0.011223127134144306, 0.011042555794119835, 0.001924340846017003, 0.03116000071167946, 0.061775002628564835, 0.0021862522698938847, -0.007871699519455433, -0.04804718866944313, -0.04167376458644867, 0.06971125304698944, 0.006019447930157185, -0.020160479471087456, -0.015269995667040348, 0.041115157306194305, 0.025806212797760963, -0.06051582843065262, 0.005993725266307592, 0.05320330336689949, 0.06057315319776535, 0.05928298830986023, 0.04389321431517601, -0.048904888331890106, 0.004585486836731434, 0.008098766207695007, -0.055843934416770935, 0.03714631125330925, 0.0061699701473116875, -0.022647812962532043, -0.008552664890885353, 0.011587177403271198, -0.05039723217487335, 0.013968325220048428, 0.040037982165813446, -0.052970316261053085, -0.0007726025069132447, 0.05654774233698845, -0.009181743487715721, -0.046306297183036804, -0.058430012315511703, 0.01804475486278534, -0.03670885041356087, 0.05001385137438774, -0.051477376371622086, -0.05426935479044914, -0.0026208609342575073, -0.06518156081438065, -0.01449976209551096, 0.03248924762010574, 0.025757785886526108, -0.021585343405604362, 0.03913567587733269, 0.0072174775414168835, -0.07344243675470352, -0.0641801580786705, 0.02026585303246975, 0.03997190669178963, -0.05842164158821106, 0.06770926713943481, -0.03564947471022606, -0.035138729959726334, 0.037533845752477646, 0.03375394269824028, 0.000715545320417732 ]
281
281
Learning Nonlinear Dynamic Models
We present a novel approach for learning nonlinear dynamic models, which leads to a new set of tools capable of solving problems that are otherwise difficult. We provide theory showing this new approach is consistent for models with long range structure, and apply the approach to motion capture and high-dimensional video data, yielding results superior to standard alternatives.
[ -0.05525273457169533, -0.0480346716940403, 0.0006931163370609283, -0.033648066222667694, 0.03167392313480377, -0.09467123448848724, 0.003694449085742235, -0.008372967131435871, 0.004402340389788151, 0.024148309603333473, -0.006585367489606142, -0.029806459322571754, -0.03651277348399162, -0.010474435985088348, 0.01678374409675598, -0.013499368913471699, 0.020999757573008537, -0.003501648548990488, 0.08202897757291794, -0.03919000178575516, 0.00013045645027887076, 0.0037870509549975395, -0.026459714397788048, -0.00023034866899251938, 0.042575061321258545, -0.00860527716577053, 0.0214278195053339, -0.05443311482667923, 0.0240160021930933, 0.02973034419119358, -0.0507100485265255, 0.047670572996139526, 0.029431892558932304, 0.011569872498512268, 0.05691072344779968, 0.008911464363336563, 0.03988876938819885, 0.004022384528070688, -0.0397496372461319, 0.014875468797981739, -0.0304330475628376, -0.02704431302845478, 0.03616418316960335, -0.06954361498355865, 0.0807996392250061, 0.05112607404589653, -0.02713428996503353, -0.03963381052017212, 0.01524065900593996, 0.12207215279340744, -0.07411081343889236, 0.006342324893921614, -0.043892864137887955, 0.04311761632561684, -0.020957697182893753, 0.08462099730968475, -0.0666424110531807, -0.037865880876779556, -0.060112886130809784, -0.04516930133104324, -0.038223929703235626, 0.07341672480106354, -0.012439263984560966, -0.015950419008731842, -0.0717472955584526, 0.028989337384700775, 0.025374094024300575, -0.05748365446925163, -0.07792061567306519, 0.025361236184835434, 0.00020675809355452657, -0.03378857672214508, -0.060006946325302124, -0.0021938695572316647, 0.050554726272821426, -0.0018971357494592667, -0.03515813499689102, -0.016071055084466934, 0.025494607165455818, 0.050051912665367126, -0.06216384842991829, -0.043830756098032, 0.03756823018193245, 0.034996148198843, 0.013156515546143055, -0.015099933370947838, -0.002515856409445405, 0.0232996828854084, -0.0029154252260923386, 0.01048653107136488, -0.023664457723498344, 0.024987054988741875, -0.04998914897441864, 0.0677938237786293, -0.09295102953910828, -0.01175911445170641, -0.0015983844641596079, -0.027747398242354393, -0.01832345500588417, -0.005648200865834951, 0.03750760853290558, -0.030831636860966682, 0.09057562798261642, 0.11030061542987823, 0.06244584918022156, 0.020815718919038773, -0.012877216562628746, 0.03723661229014397, -0.060537517070770264, -0.014133714139461517, 0.04613739997148514, 0.01526152528822422, 0.005511146504431963, 0.002709702355787158, -0.0457974337041378, 0.054673921316862106, 0.0288610327988863, 0.11161254346370697, 0.040557436645030975, -0.019383272156119347, -0.024237224832177162, 0.015784278512001038, -0.07278000563383102, 0.04607801511883736, 0.09331490844488144, -0.07335853576660156, 0.016198312863707542, -0.04184086248278618, 0.07103554159402847, -0.020848842337727547, -0.044177696108818054, -0.01682656817138195, 0.05906737968325615, 0.010603448376059532, -0.054232511669397354, 0.028299877420067787, -0.05986880511045456, -0.04814205691218376, -0.009655745700001717, -0.0008325485978275537, 0.01705397479236126, -0.05756450071930885, -0.06880255043506622, 0.02547602914273739, 0.023193027824163437, 0.06819835305213928, -0.0032344157807528973, -0.023738905787467957, 0.07036378234624863, 0.024462996050715446, 0.006017000880092382, -0.09385891258716583, 0.035227980464696884, 0.006601943634450436, 0.04533205181360245, -0.01020099874585867, -0.029522331431508064, -0.020395828410983086, 0.008218674920499325, 0.11948885023593903, -0.002801721915602684, 0.0020830673165619373, 0.026216600090265274, 0.0013504381058737636, 0.025395886972546577, -0.0351468063890934, -0.014606655575335026, 0.0338575504720211, -0.019406821578741074, -0.06312825530767441, -0.1448899656534195, -0.03198327124118805, -0.04050012677907944, -0.023171452805399895, 0.016239609569311142, 0.05334167927503586, -0.05424002930521965, 0.06151949241757393, -0.02435871958732605, -0.006228812504559755, -0.025780800729990005, -0.08268579840660095, 0.008246082812547684, 0.05834059417247772, 0.043320588767528534, 0.025080546736717224, -0.03744331747293472, 0.10064123570919037, -0.0014120297273620963, -0.06016633287072182, -0.05410899966955185, 0.040105950087308884, 0.01876883953809738, -0.03888893872499466, 0.003717641346156597, 0.05410709232091904, 0.013680193573236465, -0.016337988898158073, -0.0004200812254566699, 0.050512608140707016, 0.019968418404459953, -0.06086546182632446, -0.10468725860118866, -0.021010082215070724, -0.07777721434831619, 0.0368339940905571, 0.0232574250549078, -0.03388359397649765, -0.042149774730205536, 0.022792261093854904, 0.02758757770061493, -0.043614570051431656, -0.06928766518831253, -0.003920340444892645, -0.040834151208400726, -0.01924043335020542, -0.01773156225681305, -0.04513439163565636, 0.06910547614097595, 0.027252787724137306, -0.032957784831523895, 0.05612967535853386, -0.07123025506734848, 0.04589054360985756, -0.022190291434526443, -0.03172611817717552, 0.0540519580245018, -0.04027070105075836, -0.07964713871479034, 0.018813202157616615, -0.04914751648902893, -0.11356604099273682, -0.030054399743676186, -0.010344211012125015, 0.0377342663705349, 0.05036262050271034, 0.0027380737010389566, -0.013246669434010983, -0.06292931735515594, -0.007778027094900608, -0.00006729853339493275, 0.03659187629818916, 0.020407378673553467, -0.06560643762350082, 0.000912704854272306, -0.047305431216955185, 0.028504885733127594, 0.035007111728191376, 0.004147120751440525, 0.010449156165122986, 0.030610375106334686, 0.03857588395476341, -0.026316409930586815, 0.008565152063965797, -0.04410577565431595, -0.06096645072102547, -0.018314789980649948, -0.030287908390164375, 0.04319710284471512, 0.032979197800159454, 0.030401993542909622, -0.04493182897567749, -0.018545247614383698, 0.030801888555288315, 0.09114659577608109, 0.07386869937181473, -0.04981936514377594, 0.025005796924233437, 0.03504849225282669, 0.004775866866111755, 0.01509078312665224, -0.07940904796123505, -0.0369316004216671, 0.015775561332702637, 0.007940600626170635, -0.034868188202381134, 0.03220392391085625, 0.04574545845389366, -0.018114514648914337, -0.03255489096045494, 0.023166930302977562, 0.05871951952576637, -0.01676718145608902, -0.05224055051803589, -0.013520617038011551, 0.04931090399622917, 0.021439261734485626, 0.031278714537620544, 0.028031930327415466, 0.030854681506752968, -0.0059862323105335236, -0.0424797423183918, -0.028170311823487282, -0.05556301027536392, 0.01769374869763851, -0.08903433382511139, 0.06316304206848145, -0.050887443125247955, -0.043888941407203674, -0.04363048076629639, 0.015610753558576107, -0.019251439720392227, 0.012281594797968864, 0.010564520955085754, -0.0037068540696054697, 0.05521884933114052, 0.025278860703110695, 0.0648341104388237, -0.05007283389568329, 0.035957492887973785, -0.0006109306705184281, -0.028925204649567604, -0.017529163509607315, -0.011493788100779057, -0.007172925863415003, -0.01127395499497652, -0.0369652658700943, 0.03905599191784859, -0.04744354635477066, 0.05492876097559929, 0.0057584987953305244, -0.03137999400496483, 0.004442819859832525, -0.021643131971359253, 0.015968481078743935, -0.008251473307609558, -0.01202068105340004, 0.09293556213378906, -0.00907011516392231, 0.02301318384706974, -0.03834683075547218, 0.030417097732424736, 0.03990164026618004, 0.0899968072772026, 0.009417491033673286, -0.008889454416930676, -0.06328039616346359, -0.04648423194885254, -0.019170615822076797, 0.03468485549092293, -0.06380724161863327, -0.09149662405252457, -0.050418902188539505, -0.09925390779972076, 0.001800566096790135, 0.08788958936929703, 0.06223805248737335, -0.03511509671807289, 0.00978556927293539, 0.027751022949814796, -0.04461943358182907, -0.009425798431038857, -0.01371887605637312, 0.043221183121204376, -0.03336198255419731, 0.03076179139316082, 0.061561934649944305, 0.004822557792067528, -0.014891731552779675, 0.07440196722745895, -0.0019075135933235288, 0.05284137651324272, -0.00190141168422997, -0.006860337220132351, -0.0383843295276165, 0.031020639464259148, -0.006731392350047827, 0.05404585599899292, -0.010016530752182007, -0.02768586203455925, 0.008940081112086773, -0.03342768922448158, 0.06873369216918945, 0.031389933079481125, 0.05337290093302727, -0.00018371232727076858, 0.004775866866111755, -0.03506377711892128, -0.02013453282415867, 0.04537781700491905, -0.045510534197092056, -0.039926376193761826, 0.06605079025030136, -0.0035077505744993687, -0.0797886848449707, 0.030187880620360374, 0.029926586896181107, 0.037936270236968994, 0.0024116330314427614, 0.009988493286073208, -0.17457203567028046, -0.0013629690511152148, -0.03318530321121216, -0.01053523737937212, 0.04861883074045181, 0.0007211471674963832, 0.008649734780192375, -0.007646290119737387, 0.03873780369758606, 0.003511564340442419, -0.025979602709412575, -0.03748003765940666, -0.029058855026960373, -0.05772209167480469, -0.08640622347593307, -0.058620303869247437, 0.008455125615000725, 0.02521718665957451, 0.08569449931383133, 0.0787678062915802, 0.0324789434671402, 0.013118106871843338, -0.02650698833167553, 0.019572174176573753, -0.028940467163920403, 0.05562097579240799, -0.005978550296276808, 0.03581583872437477, 0.0395105704665184, -0.09670111536979675, 0.05964276194572449, 0.0076641603372991085, -0.0338374488055706, -0.011856010183691978, -0.020485231652855873, 0.007518952712416649, 0.02003750205039978, 0.040643110871315, -0.10065081715583801, 0.03517317399382591, -0.0056700208224356174, -0.03181928023695946, -0.065823495388031, 0.010031281970441341, 0.03593335673213005, 0.01585891842842102, 0.00879313051700592, -0.017063794657588005, -0.012017684988677502, -0.015018210746347904, -0.05328681692481041, -0.07363268733024597, -0.07037205994129181, -0.04646461829543114, 0.08111819624900818, 0.1078386977314949, 0.00020531432528514415, 0.01893048733472824, 0.026566481217741966, -0.055719535797834396, -0.028604859486222267, -0.016194578260183334, -0.011481475085020065, -0.05466398224234581, 0.012155305594205856, 0.0012234956957399845, 0.008248095400631428, -0.047880619764328, 0.0752486139535904, 0.050933536142110825, 0.038523364812135696, -0.047479283064603806, 0.009402671828866005, -0.03570276498794556, -0.08362408727407455, -0.03930092602968216, 0.03864605724811554, 0.03016085736453533, 0.03098919801414013, 0.01683550328016281, -0.07985188812017441, 0.0363551564514637, 0.03997018188238144, 0.027964754030108452, -0.014436236582696438, 0.07237742841243744, 0.058816276490688324, -0.05109294876456261, -0.01940973475575447, 0.007998677901923656, 0.04970875754952431, 0.09867656975984573, 0.021363837644457817, 0.040125127881765366, -0.031657688319683075, 0.014477371238172054, -0.011659085750579834, 0.010907947085797787, 0.037459444254636765, 0.0023284393828362226, 0.02655046246945858, -0.00637697521597147, 0.0812104344367981, 0.047948263585567474, -0.025028908625245094, -0.050035566091537476, -0.04589898884296417, -0.037621691823005676, 0.07733545452356339, -0.008218674920499325, 0.03222086653113365, 0.02438012883067131, 0.01980557292699814, 0.034337740391492844, 0.04240474849939346, -0.006831788457930088, -0.04322061315178871, -0.016824932768940926, 0.004729298409074545, 0.0022045753430575132, -0.0544564314186573, -0.013087745755910873 ]
282
282
Finding Anomalous Periodic Time Series: An Application to Catalogs of Periodic Variable Stars
Catalogs of periodic variable stars contain large numbers of periodic light-curves (photometric time series data from the astrophysics domain). Separating anomalous objects from well-known classes is an important step towards the discovery of new classes of astronomical objects. Most anomaly detection methods for time series data assume either a single continuous time series or a set of time series whose periods are aligned. Light-curve data precludes the use of these methods as the periods of any given pair of light-curves may be out of sync. One may use an existing anomaly detection method if, prior to similarity calculation, one performs the costly act of aligning two light-curves, an operation that scales poorly to massive data sets. This paper presents PCAD, an unsupervised anomaly detection method for large sets of unsynchronized periodic time-series data, that outputs a ranked list of both global and local anomalies. It calculates its anomaly score for each light-curve in relation to a set of centroids produced by a modified k-means clustering algorithm. Our method is able to scale to large data sets through the use of sampling. We validate our method on both light-curve data and other time series data sets. We demonstrate its effectiveness at finding known anomalies, and discuss the effect of sample size and number of centroids on our results. We compare our method to naive solutions and existing time series anomaly detection methods for unphased data, and show that PCAD's reported anomalies are comparable to or better than all other methods. Finally, astrophysicists on our team have verified that PCAD finds true anomalies that might be indicative of novel astrophysical phenomena.
[ 0.04902235418558121, -0.009148156270384789, 0.04574398696422577, -0.04215390235185623, 0.06343434751033783, -0.030137766152620316, -0.06510747224092484, -0.02599387615919113, -0.025344235822558403, 0.03932080417871475, 0.054072000086307526, -0.05681535229086876, 0.00993373990058899, 0.021297240629792213, -0.0763409361243248, -0.03199216350913048, 0.006876942701637745, -0.038244087249040604, -0.08819853514432907, -0.10014636069536209, -0.022508811205625534, -0.05775555223226547, 0.016178574413061142, -0.08464068174362183, 0.009981739334762096, -0.01693461276590824, 0.03639338165521622, 0.0399613156914711, -0.0003374058287590742, -0.039302051067352295, -0.009328399784862995, -0.0277567058801651, 0.04547712579369545, -0.03037135675549507, -0.02953403815627098, 0.0067205242812633514, -0.09541314095258713, 0.03623038902878761, -0.04916895925998688, -0.015624480322003365, 0.008999504148960114, -0.01525180321186781, 0.028822507709264755, 0.04939333349466324, 0.0035642744041979313, 0.06082810461521149, -0.013784185983240604, -0.07215553522109985, -0.008918647654354572, 0.041948121041059494, -0.054269708693027496, 0.01652059145271778, -0.0785617083311081, 0.009473550133407116, 0.024312909692525864, -0.02837296761572361, 0.053084272891283035, -0.05142563208937645, -0.060426678508520126, -0.08335773646831512, -0.004624607972800732, 0.03399202972650528, -0.06164458766579628, 0.019616033881902695, 0.01121948380023241, -0.07971459627151489, 0.0015754193300381303, 0.02016426995396614, -0.020237021148204803, -0.029707644134759903, 0.01035810261964798, -0.06060931459069252, 0.005558180622756481, -0.04537083953619003, -0.06628048419952393, 0.006624519359320402, -0.057846128940582275, 0.026562364771962166, 0.03392037749290466, 0.01859622821211815, 0.010830843821167946, -0.046080198138952255, -0.009003447368741035, 0.028790410608053207, -0.022467514500021935, -0.033960167318582535, 0.060039669275283813, -0.0011022246908396482, -0.00039101485162973404, 0.012443341314792633, -0.08189593255519867, 0.04169163852930069, -0.04513588920235634, -0.008976481854915619, 0.011973432265222073, 0.014128675684332848, -0.046102121472358704, -0.010739332996308804, -0.00032931973692029715, 0.07140365242958069, -0.008189456537365913, -0.006033601704984903, 0.03269880637526512, 0.02916032075881958, -0.03860485181212425, -0.0042226254008710384, -0.06769171357154846, 0.030972909182310104, -0.021075544878840446, 0.028218932449817657, 0.028496000915765762, -0.028263403102755547, -0.02220640517771244, 0.035577159374952316, -0.059575796127319336, -0.05116594582796097, -0.02585465833544731, 0.05759259685873985, 0.01695876754820347, -0.005043286830186844, -0.05910324677824974, 0.0459422767162323, -0.023296520113945007, 0.04738018289208412, -0.009765466675162315, 0.00036886995076201856, 0.04758791625499725, 0.010884975083172321, 0.04705148562788963, 0.006691163405776024, -0.032805245369672775, 0.07911233603954315, -0.039583124220371246, 0.025300728157162666, -0.03219577670097351, -0.012583887204527855, 0.01317311730235815, -0.02235446684062481, 0.011456090025603771, 0.01057532336562872, -0.07385943830013275, -0.09056788682937622, -0.028725335374474525, 0.08644025772809982, -0.0031792917288839817, 0.028139309957623482, 0.008160675875842571, 0.03924209251999855, -0.004476700909435749, -0.006372513249516487, 0.016944555565714836, -0.03488819673657417, 0.05612089857459068, -0.011008779518306255, 0.06606310606002808, 0.0170222707092762, 0.02467264048755169, 0.009987624362111092, 0.031105637550354004, 0.05878496915102005, -0.029176952317357063, 0.05435582622885704, -0.04539972171187401, 0.03176579996943474, -0.011118149384856224, 0.04124734178185463, 0.0028113825246691704, -0.07921532541513443, 0.021161161363124847, -0.008681999519467354, 0.04100861772894859, 0.0034161603543907404, -0.023430828005075455, -0.04023578763008118, 0.029387889429926872, 0.01714540831744671, 0.04416649043560028, -0.012890848331153393, -0.021144993603229523, -0.03357132524251938, -0.003002447308972478, 0.011825842782855034, -0.00323885097168386, 0.07972344756126404, -0.005902888253331184, 0.0848192572593689, 0.040632493793964386, 0.11008754372596741, 0.06573286652565002, 0.045860353857278824, -0.025708651170134544, 0.0035087482538074255, 0.01505077164620161, -0.02975335717201233, -0.03337281197309494, 0.07856592535972595, -0.05427217856049538, -0.1055876836180687, -0.04058467224240303, 0.07012356072664261, 0.05084880813956261, -0.0003144591173622757, -0.023144274950027466, -0.052665095776319504, -0.06314338743686676, -0.06898412853479385, 0.04739765077829361, -0.04579756408929825, -0.000984912388958037, 0.015128768049180508, 0.020174475386738777, 0.014320139773190022, -0.0003845806932076812, 0.008344687521457672, 0.02833792380988598, -0.07046128809452057, -0.08571082353591919, -0.040523625910282135, 0.006215756759047508, 0.004436546005308628, -0.12013763934373856, -0.021298686042428017, -0.02799682691693306, 0.009190227836370468, -0.024394778534770012, 0.03374744951725006, -0.00563824875280261, 0.07948584854602814, -0.035977933555841446, 0.012777543626725674, -0.1204974427819252, -0.015497843734920025, -0.0469101145863533, 0.004830367863178253, -0.0075411489233374596, -0.052022192627191544, 0.02865222655236721, -0.03707059100270271, 0.030173704028129578, 0.02495528757572174, 0.07397691905498505, 0.025684203952550888, -0.0012470181100070477, 0.04392688721418381, 0.03506915643811226, 0.059295643121004105, -0.03330504894256592, 0.090835802257061, -0.022495439276099205, 0.016879525035619736, -0.005327151622623205, -0.0503796711564064, 0.0121276481077075, -0.01710660196840763, 0.004206446465104818, -0.03244161978363991, -0.05201919004321098, -0.006870993413031101, 0.037809502333402634, 0.007841707207262516, 0.006940093357115984, 0.004462795797735453, 0.03066733479499817, -0.05598237365484238, -0.05416727438569069, -0.03396833688020706, 0.06953664869070053, 0.03105618618428707, -0.007822923362255096, 0.0058968025259673595, -0.041754163801670074, -0.0931137204170227, -0.020521752536296844, 0.07691795378923416, -0.06830722093582153, -0.044711772352457047, 0.00711572403088212, 0.020119331777095795, -0.027174344286322594, -0.014421741478145123, -0.034865062683820724, 0.03434830531477928, -0.046551454812288284, -0.012474057264626026, -0.10181998461484909, 0.003303632140159607, 0.039423972368240356, -0.0740090012550354, 0.036865197122097015, -0.042710304260253906, -0.02400670386850834, -0.010471832007169724, -0.12461676448583603, -0.01272442564368248, -0.01775982230901718, -0.10539668053388596, 0.04832562804222107, 0.003993135876953602, 0.07810590416193008, -0.03741518780589104, 0.0036827975418418646, 0.03243264555931091, 0.011760355904698372, 0.02594008669257164, -0.006443799007683992, 0.03578992560505867, 0.09950738400220871, 0.009771550074219704, -0.0060931178741157055, -0.027479376643896103, 0.11245357990264893, -0.03117973543703556, -0.09923464059829712, 0.06831614673137665, -0.06898586452007294, -0.00998414121568203, -0.009397650137543678, 0.027844760566949844, -0.014655232429504395, -0.0030225091613829136, -0.02079731598496437, 0.031145626679062843, 0.01137198880314827, 0.01395321637392044, -0.014940613880753517, -0.00948988739401102, 0.014791048131883144, -0.0515613779425621, -0.0331583246588707, 0.025939494371414185, 0.03290132060647011, -0.013842599466443062, -0.0010443748906254768, 0.016371535137295723, -0.037684157490730286, 0.04111456125974655, 0.008954683318734169, 0.06516338884830475, 0.014090477488934994, -0.022313950583338737, 0.012950611300766468, 0.05764878913760185, 0.0005061220726929605, 0.017533449456095695, -0.03194774314761162, 0.0042165713384747505, 0.04112141951918602, 0.024372417479753494, -0.037892844527959824, -0.03286947309970856, -0.07840052992105484, 0.012770282104611397, -0.0339033268392086, -0.07310162484645844, -0.01801334321498871, 0.0890234112739563, -0.03714907914400101, 0.04269366338849068, 0.019928086549043655, -0.016677964478731155, -0.00396728003397584, 0.006127204280346632, -0.03127023205161095, 0.04361799359321594, 0.030656252056360245, 0.058812882751226425, 0.005509916692972183, 0.038225460797548294, -0.032961856573820114, -0.039477311074733734, 0.01743999309837818, -0.015845414251089096, -0.08879736065864563, 0.03948701545596123, 0.02214980684220791, 0.039493829011917114, 0.022760367020964622, 0.03176945075392723, -0.03635720536112785, 0.013560888357460499, -0.010467838495969772, -0.01914968155324459, 0.041284702718257904, -0.014098971150815487, -0.0038847457617521286, 0.07138481736183167, 0.018312962725758553, -0.04403448477387428, 0.00005923891148995608, 0.07161513715982437, 0.012548362836241722, -0.07438573241233826, 0.013268380425870419, 0.027902746573090553, 0.07060909271240234, -0.029690509662032127, 0.07286464422941208, 0.011642894707620144, -0.010387451387941837, -0.07251248508691788, 0.0314386785030365, -0.06859637796878815, -0.07711578160524368, -0.05994146317243576, -0.010402246378362179, -0.04824062064290047, -0.027269886806607246, 0.004006836097687483, 0.07633809000253677, 0.01679057814180851, -0.04776918515563011, 0.0018405035370960832, -0.016280505806207657, -0.006787879392504692, 0.002841932699084282, 0.09821530431509018, 0.0023743552155792713, -0.03538481146097183, 0.01567871868610382, 0.004872782155871391, 0.036095574498176575, 0.05023563653230667, -0.023947523906826973, 0.057007964700460434, -0.009811039082705975, 0.02494504116475582, 0.03138364851474762, 0.0306873582303524, -0.02126697450876236, 0.007122623734176159, -0.09440885484218597, 0.0033524464815855026, -0.0026072245091199875, 0.06342712789773941, 0.06661166250705719, -0.032699812203645706, 0.11392788589000702, 0.013224436901509762, -0.02361391671001911, -0.006780717987567186, 0.00010952073353109881, -0.016737816855311394, -0.02436635084450245, -0.12708498537540436, 0.004034813493490219, 0.0943407416343689, -0.02734256722033024, -0.012392209842801094, 0.0008057572995312512, 0.036069415509700775, 0.0006665787659585476, 0.048148754984140396, 0.03490705043077469, -0.06617588549852371, 0.029527513310313225, -0.013405767269432545, -0.026103591546416283, -0.07082511484622955, 0.08769512921571732, -0.10210960358381271, -0.010151375085115433, -0.06645096838474274, -0.003975227475166321, -0.013605186715722084, -0.09918960928916931, 0.0210280604660511, -0.016203314065933228, 0.010151209309697151, 0.04413114860653877, -0.0440816767513752, -0.03228769823908806, 0.024449734017252922, -0.05047452077269554, -0.030247703194618225, 0.006657745223492384, -0.03523501381278038, 0.012670673429965973, -0.032452382147312164, 0.016970006749033928, -0.011980777606368065, 0.042865362018346786, 0.049258314073085785, 0.008995097130537033, 0.05317145958542824, 0.04601448401808739, 0.034952495247125626, 0.021597325801849365, 0.010800788179039955, -0.024363165721297264, 0.00961246807128191, 0.07573825120925903, -0.007862595841288567, 0.05612596869468689, -0.0013530839933082461, -0.15250320732593536, 0.0025046735536307096, -0.010798227041959763, 0.020289357751607895, 0.024391504004597664, -0.05206165462732315, -0.01526992954313755, -0.092164546251297, 0.09452816098928452, 0.0559939481317997, 0.04252956062555313, 0.1258060783147812, -0.03137209266424179, 0.00019432771659921855, -0.03780914470553398, 0.009984423406422138, -0.0468972884118557, 0.017828913405537605 ]
283
283
Quantum Annealing for Clustering
This paper studies quantum annealing (QA) for clustering, which can be seen as an extension of simulated annealing (SA). We derive a QA algorithm for clustering and propose an annealing schedule, which is crucial in practice. Experiments show the proposed QA algorithm finds better clustering assignments than SA. Furthermore, QA is as easy as SA to implement.
[ -0.04876674711704254, 0.009259472601115704, 0.008233411237597466, 0.02900101989507675, 0.0068095591850578785, -0.059186775237321854, -0.042762529104948044, -0.06515547633171082, -0.018307268619537354, -0.014254160225391388, -0.009656256064772606, -0.013884744606912136, -0.0024114951957017183, 0.0576791949570179, 0.05908752232789993, 0.001505910768173635, -0.05925348028540611, 0.04675503075122833, -0.04994824528694153, -0.07363112270832062, 0.023492688313126564, -0.08630385994911194, 0.043166108429431915, 0.03669885918498039, 0.014740189537405968, 0.006859246175736189, 0.037748318165540695, -0.02045080065727234, -0.0036475982051342726, -0.028885630890727043, 0.009046059101819992, 0.04643607512116432, 0.05674748495221138, 0.008314562030136585, -0.007196999620646238, -0.08069271594285965, 0.06946985423564911, 0.014859182760119438, 0.029217278584837914, -0.025737298652529716, 0.018597252666950226, -0.005423183087259531, -0.0003600216587074101, 0.07951397448778152, 0.006717003416270018, -0.035733792930841446, -0.010990862734615803, -0.017969347536563873, -0.014309868216514587, 0.06814581900835037, -0.07762451469898224, 0.026820583269000053, -0.05852019414305687, -0.03573622182011604, 0.008192798122763634, -0.06497026979923248, 0.017088962718844414, 0.023577654734253883, -0.08146397769451141, -0.006214996334165335, 0.027024751529097557, 0.09294100850820541, -0.0425616130232811, 0.006519089452922344, -0.03796151280403137, 0.01460806280374527, -0.001065693562850356, -0.06235319748520851, -0.009748787619173527, -0.027938097715377808, -0.037323158234357834, 0.04365169256925583, -0.03004520572721958, -0.011268187314271927, -0.06307636201381683, -0.0020613570231944323, -0.016962513327598572, 0.020670147612690926, 0.03610457852482796, 0.07424391806125641, 0.033563338220119476, -0.07966543734073639, 0.03975685313344002, 0.08575951308012009, -0.052753668278455734, 0.019543705508112907, 0.029981551691889763, -0.04628662019968033, -0.024915559217333794, -0.05901510268449783, -0.06179703027009964, 0.015053638257086277, -0.06385646015405655, 0.006453682668507099, -0.050271593034267426, 0.031417038291692734, -0.04162971302866936, -0.03526443988084793, 0.006755801383405924, 0.014238807372748852, -0.011027036234736443, -0.011417487636208534, 0.059768687933683395, 0.12068711221218109, -0.015907561406493187, 0.0421578511595726, -0.10314826667308807, -0.002515197731554508, 0.033754780888557434, 0.007720698602497578, -0.023074738681316376, -0.027265705168247223, 0.03886956721544266, 0.008868402801454067, 0.003886419115588069, 0.010538358241319656, 0.010679596103727818, 0.05098406970500946, 0.036104973405599594, 0.054685916751623154, 0.014406556263566017, 0.005944967735558748, -0.016110945492982864, 0.027318188920617104, 0.0561794675886631, 0.00906881783157587, -0.05314282700419426, 0.0039160544984042645, 0.13136102259159088, 0.018756859004497528, -0.06753260642290115, -0.02641323022544384, -0.09650424867868423, -0.03972794860601425, -0.05786002799868584, -0.04551076143980026, 0.015669574961066246, -0.01570773497223854, -0.029654208570718765, 0.08835853636264801, 0.016896149143576622, -0.008572537451982498, -0.03205820918083191, 0.047534238547086716, 0.044298455119132996, -0.03641339763998985, -0.009996707551181316, 0.02120964042842388, 0.037358175963163376, 0.053270548582077026, -0.02345614694058895, -0.012234630063176155, -0.01775115169584751, 0.04684259369969368, 0.025615589693188667, 0.02857431396842003, -0.0019117443589493632, -0.004892174154520035, 0.01270786952227354, 0.09491897374391556, -0.05134683847427368, 0.07159491628408432, -0.04320080578327179, 0.014013481326401234, 0.014388849027454853, 0.07709132879972458, -0.03358256444334984, 0.03793254867196083, 0.025561440736055374, 0.014572293497622013, 0.0799713060259819, 0.027685517445206642, -0.030224064365029335, -0.008382373489439487, 0.04376842826604843, -0.015794306993484497, 0.02005818299949169, 0.01365443505346775, -0.016587113961577415, -0.031580764800310135, 0.003319850889965892, -0.05727287381887436, -0.03358182683587074, 0.023729227483272552, 0.0637051984667778, 0.1387133002281189, -0.03424060717225075, 0.025619611144065857, 0.0080265449360013, 0.01788984052836895, -0.02209414541721344, -0.02516796626150608, 0.007385544944554567, -0.03823086619377136, -0.024404218420386314, -0.027913328260183334, -0.036676786839962006, 0.011436867527663708, 0.04527105763554573, 0.060134407132864, 0.04027258977293968, 0.10259773582220078, -0.1071283221244812, -0.04253906011581421, 0.0035063487011939287, -0.03229619935154915, 0.05145464837551117, 0.008491244167089462, -0.009110608138144016, -0.03573131561279297, 0.04429669305682182, -0.03952861204743385, -0.010700196959078312, -0.030026493594050407, 0.050668779760599136, -0.017871201038360596, -0.07425186783075333, -0.07992245256900787, 0.05009470507502556, 0.036626070737838745, -0.04683886840939522, 0.01734740287065506, -0.013551087118685246, 0.1014266312122345, 0.05999304726719856, -0.011779379099607468, 0.06583315134048462, -0.011792621575295925, -0.03401787579059601, -0.03707651421427727, -0.02850959450006485, 0.0037675725761801004, -0.09048373997211456, 0.01871759444475174, 0.01881680265069008, 0.045330747961997986, -0.033803850412368774, 0.01828530989587307, 0.01040401216596365, 0.05148358643054962, -0.03564704954624176, 0.014242289587855339, -0.007099097594618797, -0.025356119498610497, 0.03398682549595833, -0.007337758783251047, -0.00671258894726634, 0.10661955177783966, -0.0523897223174572, 0.050237834453582764, -0.03808470070362091, 0.019828658550977707, -0.05315842479467392, 0.017816312611103058, 0.025774607434868813, -0.007556530646979809, -0.02946188487112522, 0.06975237280130386, 0.03933212161064148, 0.07197568565607071, -0.01779274456202984, 0.0786801278591156, -0.04475343972444534, -0.03361091390252113, 0.04290222004055977, 0.042508725076913834, -0.009707636199891567, 0.03500962629914284, -0.06012283265590668, 0.02953026071190834, 0.02106352336704731, -0.048951368778944016, 0.015937676653265953, 0.06971480697393417, -0.008082227781414986, -0.017893468961119652, 0.07749471068382263, 0.014543403871357441, 0.011935649439692497, -0.06647844612598419, 0.008685988374054432, -0.05102242901921272, -0.05144895985722542, 0.002966058673337102, -0.018067888915538788, -0.001255698036402464, -0.02724270150065422, -0.049540452659130096, -0.01780380681157112, -0.003943432588130236, 0.005640390329062939, 0.019513076171278954, -0.036436546593904495, -0.019963912665843964, 0.01967266947031021, -0.04367052763700485, 0.0149026894941926, 0.02876092493534088, 0.07672012597322464, -0.0984250158071518, -0.027474557980895042, 0.01968642883002758, 0.05405209958553314, 0.038872331380844116, -0.03582705929875374, -0.03206341341137886, 0.0837259292602539, 0.01974017545580864, -0.11725129932165146, 0.04443589225411415, 0.017108188942074776, 0.05509871616959572, 0.014748036861419678, -0.02987312711775303, 0.01566707342863083, 0.0073779914528131485, 0.02135055884718895, 0.0009728432632982731, 0.02370806224644184, 0.10139314830303192, 0.10539937764406204, 0.008696534670889378, 0.029656514525413513, -0.06547724455595016, -0.055884089320898056, 0.02271248586475849, 0.033104922622442245, 0.050516534596681595, 0.018890246748924255, 0.030768902972340584, 0.017659001052379608, 0.014141346327960491, 0.0417642705142498, 0.034963496029376984, 0.0021235146559774876, 0.01874481700360775, -0.021577462553977966, 0.021692750975489616, 0.0016921998467296362, 0.022813061252236366, 0.014247840270400047, -0.06224416196346283, 0.014049027115106583, 0.009924580343067646, -0.005714798346161842, 0.010503803379833698, 0.11474473774433136, -0.01712290570139885, 0.01754288747906685, -0.005198119208216667, -0.04476148262619972, 0.03145667165517807, -0.01347991731017828, 0.014636106789112091, -0.05169297754764557, 0.06824857741594315, 0.04662741720676422, 0.056748829782009125, -0.013452448882162571, 0.013491443358361721, 0.03220290690660477, 0.009584227576851845, 0.009686348028481007, 0.02206781692802906, -0.006376601755619049, 0.08847919851541519, -0.04632251709699631, -0.09404903650283813, -0.03531572222709656, -0.013689529150724411, 0.029968222603201866, 0.03860776126384735, 0.008998186327517033, 0.01974330097436905, 0.02145365998148918, -0.027859456837177277, -0.03964691981673241, -0.02632906101644039, -0.05292563512921333, -0.015636343508958817, 0.00020512405899353325, -0.02119811438024044, 0.0019854530692100525, -0.009810295887291431, -0.02905217744410038, 0.05802224576473236, 0.033694591373205185, 0.01369749940931797, 0.03586122393608093, 0.00845523551106453, 0.027633966878056526, -0.053763002157211304, 0.005043031647801399, 0.018396714702248573, 0.04576076194643974, -0.07815059274435043, 0.05060186609625816, -0.025763418525457382, 0.018248511478304863, -0.004011886660009623, -0.0012397693935781717, -0.06384999305009842, -0.006732208654284477, -0.12651076912879944, -0.07929128408432007, 0.08361212909221649, 0.010385104455053806, 0.051195867359638214, -0.04460923373699188, 0.060033366084098816, 0.028642861172556877, -0.03041628748178482, -0.024555034935474396, -0.015540012158453465, 0.012968492694199085, -0.03683633357286453, -0.05213191732764244, -0.033975839614868164, 0.0694439560174942, -0.09195129573345184, -0.018698515370488167, -0.014273632317781448, 0.1034904345870018, -0.04953775554895401, -0.019182570278644562, 0.0852854922413826, 0.03912307322025299, -0.012437325902283192, 0.04941694438457489, 0.07871720939874649, -0.018550826236605644, 0.08654110878705978, -0.009293758310377598, 0.007549664005637169, 0.09631957858800888, -0.04830429330468178, -0.025536227971315384, 0.03135503828525543, -0.02362453192472458, 0.05371396616101265, 0.01949021779000759, 0.005050063598901033, -0.026074985042214394, -0.06709685176610947, -0.029744280502200127, 0.04397112503647804, -0.006306068506091833, -0.0361979678273201, -0.015041351318359375, 0.057929545640945435, 0.005616343580186367, 0.012795335613191128, 0.0291146170347929, -0.028459269553422928, 0.05197182297706604, 0.07677432149648666, 0.015091504901647568, -0.04644693806767464, 0.015218909829854965, -0.05526278540492058, -0.06343875825405121, 0.011721205897629261, 0.018467333167791367, -0.05712876468896866, -0.0190130565315485, 0.03889106959104538, -0.009444329887628555, -0.004252571612596512, 0.060385145246982574, -0.014732543379068375, -0.011423967778682709, 0.07729312032461166, -0.03861342370510101, -0.010853622108697891, -0.03775631636381149, 0.031520240008831024, 0.05104434862732887, -0.04263431206345558, 0.0331350639462471, -0.0010749270441010594, 0.08661159873008728, -0.03787604346871376, -0.020974645391106606, 0.048884712159633636, 0.049023523926734924, 0.0005812338786199689, -0.026541344821453094, 0.12799465656280518, 0.05563315749168396, -0.017089257016777992, 0.019818922504782677, -0.028313828632235527, 0.009087773971259594, -0.08703304827213287, -0.05679226294159889, 0.0026730382815003395, 0.053522367030382156, 0.04802316054701805, 0.03702307492494583, -0.022058671340346336, 0.015884460881352425, -0.07184524834156036, 0.014757944270968437, -0.056226946413517, -0.022054802626371384, -0.00196179305203259, 0.034806981682777405, 0.012732111848890781, -0.035068854689598083, 0.0609813891351223, -0.01152219157665968, -0.10022787004709244 ]
284
284
Quantum Annealing for Variational Bayes Inference
This paper presents studies on a deterministic annealing algorithm based on quantum annealing for variational Bayes (QAVB) inference, which can be seen as an extension of the simulated annealing for variational Bayes (SAVB) inference. QAVB is as easy as SAVB to implement. Experiments revealed QAVB finds a better local optimum than SAVB in terms of the variational free energy in latent Dirichlet allocation (LDA).
[ -0.04027798771858215, -0.02322898805141449, -0.028425076976418495, -0.02974884584546089, 0.018081681802868843, -0.005344812758266926, 0.06044201925396919, -0.03796818479895592, 0.03527238592505455, -0.006807015743106604, 0.011135432869195938, -0.034551262855529785, 0.027880169451236725, 0.03932784125208855, 0.08094479888677597, -0.03767503425478935, -0.019888995215296745, 0.07837481796741486, 0.036514315754175186, -0.02987651713192463, 0.03230903297662735, -0.11908992379903793, 0.0635116770863533, 0.02540876716375351, 0.021129552274942398, -0.03455883637070656, 0.0397285595536232, 0.014920475892722607, 0.07047539204359055, -0.0504913404583931, -0.03615499660372734, 0.02284964732825756, -0.015169834718108177, 0.0038376234006136656, -0.011893796734511852, -0.06782542914152145, 0.008054827339947224, -0.025242559611797333, -0.031431958079338074, -0.05030928552150726, 0.004669501446187496, 0.004468227736651897, 0.08858059346675873, 0.07721391320228577, 0.05712394788861275, -0.051607515662908554, 0.005228376481682062, 0.029264602810144424, -0.054799940437078476, 0.08202700316905975, -0.007329925894737244, 0.007844682782888412, -0.05216110125184059, -0.030471406877040863, 0.04521086439490318, -0.006062756292521954, 0.05911651998758316, 0.02827327698469162, -0.08609099686145782, 0.00019730624626390636, 0.045643411576747894, 0.11806142330169678, -0.01972290128469467, -0.00022624703706242144, -0.05862126499414444, 0.0705975592136383, 0.03579334914684296, -0.044096898287534714, -0.0044686864130198956, 0.01987575925886631, -0.029276125133037567, 0.007955806329846382, -0.08772574365139008, -0.02552439086139202, -0.09698089212179184, 0.007715736981481314, -0.029697561636567116, 0.01330035924911499, -0.01425246149301529, 0.013574766926467419, -0.019414879381656647, 0.014942364767193794, 0.05687882751226425, 0.06602374464273453, -0.0516040101647377, 0.018250739201903343, -0.027951665222644806, -0.00846701581031084, -0.03101513907313347, -0.10535814613103867, 0.021345917135477066, 0.03459017723798752, -0.07631966471672058, -0.017305295914411545, -0.05411725491285324, 0.04361271485686302, 0.061475977301597595, -0.056376997381448746, -0.028157757595181465, -0.03475315123796463, 0.09040530025959015, -0.0014204774051904678, 0.04070782661437988, 0.11887019127607346, -0.00010532170563237742, 0.03321315720677376, -0.036833688616752625, 0.02836923860013485, -0.006755900103598833, -0.033522289246320724, -0.018099943175911903, -0.014642806723713875, 0.031392328441143036, 0.036773402243852615, -0.061208248138427734, 0.07132510840892792, 0.020462235435843468, 0.024925699457526207, 0.06585702300071716, 0.059144746512174606, 0.10563509911298752, 0.027352701872587204, -0.0009989114478230476, -0.012284123338758945, 0.04008740186691284, -0.05360139161348343, -0.021467046812176704, -0.06388600170612335, 0.13425590097904205, -0.03443647176027298, -0.01569797657430172, -0.03196553513407707, -0.01782534457743168, -0.005910361651331186, -0.041494641453027725, 0.023011844605207443, -0.043441545218229294, 0.0030898405238986015, -0.060743771493434906, 0.051876626908779144, 0.06173482909798622, 0.010231615975499153, 0.004763459321111441, 0.03646220266819, 0.011202019639313221, -0.02674473449587822, -0.020088596269488335, 0.05632432550191879, -0.06520240753889084, 0.020674554631114006, -0.058656077831983566, -0.03120833821594715, -0.012097143568098545, 0.040278926491737366, 0.056980255991220474, -0.07739588618278503, -0.018871184438467026, 0.06021953374147415, 0.02079911343753338, 0.11302027851343155, 0.03571538254618645, 0.0668511912226677, 0.03827310726046562, 0.03889074549078941, 0.04682702198624611, 0.09180743247270584, -0.0018793086055666208, 0.006080097984522581, -0.0014144567539915442, -0.04935048893094063, 0.01856275461614132, 0.0033277112524956465, -0.006294372491538525, -0.028183234855532646, 0.031132003292441368, 0.01699732430279255, 0.05475492775440216, 0.03765186294913292, 0.012473056092858315, 0.009929627180099487, -0.025937039405107498, -0.054179735481739044, -0.05688580870628357, -0.06879215687513351, 0.04787295311689377, 0.04922057315707207, -0.030220704153180122, 0.011510089971125126, 0.04651299864053726, 0.008179275318980217, 0.027064867317676544, 0.007895280607044697, 0.006250862032175064, -0.02696564607322216, 0.004461195319890976, -0.046842899173498154, -0.022244349122047424, -0.08074081689119339, 0.007788864430040121, 0.019097378477454185, 0.007300231605768204, 0.06667757779359818, -0.12191177904605865, -0.0017958417301997542, 0.001109595992602408, -0.006224207580089569, 0.0038431757129728794, -0.05540771037340164, 0.01535874791443348, -0.0090414397418499, -0.0006800905102863908, 0.009554032236337662, -0.05787123739719391, -0.017648274078965187, 0.033688630908727646, -0.012235916219651699, -0.03163861855864525, -0.07564917206764221, 0.01634141057729721, 0.04512864723801613, -0.02746044658124447, 0.053000323474407196, -0.057773470878601074, 0.06618134677410126, 0.0019444694044068456, -0.04532848298549652, 0.0522204264998436, 0.02191500924527645, -0.0475349985063076, -0.02781449817121029, 0.037228818982839584, -0.009116826578974724, -0.04957149550318718, -0.014379916712641716, -0.0031303451396524906, 0.049133919179439545, -0.06684616953134537, -0.020837310701608658, 0.03941654413938522, 0.05350494012236595, -0.040721744298934937, 0.10154614597558975, 0.05223159119486809, -0.03677187114953995, 0.0033434706274420023, -0.03303847834467888, -0.00878696609288454, 0.05058607459068298, -0.04498100280761719, 0.09805464744567871, 0.010484423488378525, 0.026201874017715454, -0.07542282342910767, -0.001289558014832437, 0.029166877269744873, -0.019686207175254822, -0.05774614214897156, 0.0856175571680069, 0.0035627963952720165, 0.048676133155822754, -0.005096624605357647, 0.07522232830524445, 0.0018231839640066028, -0.013708608224987984, 0.06456980109214783, 0.03786733001470566, -0.027470005676150322, 0.006739702075719833, 0.0034152702428400517, 0.03015793301165104, -0.032044101506471634, -0.026328153908252716, 0.00964318122714758, 0.06270068883895874, -0.03805599734187126, -0.0636117160320282, 0.09104787558317184, 0.04767526686191559, 0.03464815020561218, -0.021671270951628685, -0.009443427436053753, -0.0020101433619856834, -0.02030254900455475, 0.02334980107843876, -0.026453714817762375, 0.01902305707335472, -0.033401355147361755, 0.0013115073088556528, 0.01458646822720766, -0.022026918828487396, -0.018007917329669, -0.0064424267038702965, -0.05412263795733452, -0.03204572945833206, 0.04211657866835594, 0.012089887633919716, 0.02716861478984356, 0.000743870681617409, 0.020652523264288902, -0.007139866705983877, -0.024224748834967613, 0.05052044615149498, 0.08829537779092789, 0.028464891016483307, -0.0653194710612297, 0.029068658128380775, 0.01201504748314619, 0.00478782132267952, -0.06963517516851425, 0.042869023978710175, 0.04438416287302971, 0.032420702278614044, -0.018084034323692322, 0.020948154851794243, -0.003379823872819543, -0.009978837333619595, -0.021778209134936333, -0.092196024954319, 0.033095140010118484, 0.025792114436626434, 0.05242999270558357, 0.01862126961350441, 0.07271459698677063, -0.050926025956869125, -0.06160580366849899, 0.00007471999560948461, -0.0039017675444483757, 0.06066478416323662, -0.012746896594762802, 0.0613853894174099, 0.018525535240769386, -0.011500260792672634, 0.052157189697027206, 0.05647611990571022, -0.016257431358098984, 0.0686841830611229, -0.017177464440464973, 0.056185152381658554, 0.036015577614307404, -0.02531205676496029, 0.003911556210368872, -0.01869535632431507, 0.04918290302157402, 0.004745716694742441, 0.026470616459846497, 0.05216532573103905, 0.10965163260698318, -0.006323070265352726, -0.019474666565656662, 0.09590347856283188, -0.002824068535119295, 0.006294223014265299, -0.013068812899291515, 0.07533514499664307, -0.02301711030304432, 0.08485767990350723, 0.012072383426129818, 0.020909259095788002, -0.028847500681877136, 0.03748555853962898, 0.038128651678562164, 0.01327365543693304, 0.024018075317144394, -0.07873261719942093, -0.0010002272902056575, 0.049970414489507675, -0.09076637774705887, -0.02581874094903469, -0.030199158936738968, -0.013532454147934914, 0.008476871997117996, 0.008839866146445274, -0.012428159825503826, 0.06642743200063705, 0.01678602211177349, 0.00009760648390511051, -0.004143839702010155, -0.0356595441699028, -0.077012799680233, -0.014126465655863285, -0.03032890148460865, 0.03182094916701317, -0.00690876878798008, -0.056837476789951324, -0.03188996762037277, -0.04438072815537453, 0.016160951927304268, 0.04189275950193405, 0.04470193758606911, 0.05838638171553612, 0.03736422583460808, -0.030884409323334694, -0.040467020124197006, 0.022839359939098358, 0.042435672134160995, 0.039848607033491135, 0.041240014135837555, -0.02006317675113678, -0.027129899710416794, 0.10938093066215515, -0.043280184268951416, -0.08356785774230957, 0.0480475127696991, -0.06078515946865082, -0.005044776014983654, 0.04499690979719162, 0.09741510450839996, 0.06861864030361176, -0.009594501927495003, 0.028157366439700127, 0.0321878120303154, 0.0218985415995121, -0.01439289003610611, -0.015405088663101196, 0.008649812079966068, -0.03316100686788559, -0.06135959178209305, -0.025394195690751076, -0.011958823539316654, -0.06468064337968826, 0.019071223214268684, -0.062289126217365265, 0.01933501660823822, -0.035114310681819916, 0.013876747339963913, 0.021611901000142097, -0.00003389114135643467, 0.01012850645929575, -0.03236508369445801, 0.09171213954687119, -0.0592927522957325, 0.05396275222301483, -0.028448941186070442, -0.045701365917921066, 0.039725739508867264, 0.0043870084919035435, -0.013463654555380344, -0.060369931161403656, -0.03489557281136513, 0.03864379599690437, 0.01880483888089657, 0.024438224732875824, 0.0019398491131141782, -0.046027835458517075, -0.07539040595293045, 0.06294119358062744, -0.009049692191183567, 0.010309366509318352, 0.01933198608458042, 0.10003276914358139, 0.028178788721561432, 0.04558418318629265, 0.039185576140880585, -0.04276973381638527, 0.08139679580926895, 0.06945010274648666, -0.013424559496343136, -0.022045070305466652, 0.03586575761437416, -0.041818320751190186, -0.040268175303936005, -0.049475084990262985, -0.011126382276415825, -0.012638803571462631, -0.06682399660348892, 0.025820624083280563, -0.010558804497122765, -0.02542027086019516, 0.08831608295440674, 0.009156509302556515, 0.0255061537027359, 0.04516429081559181, -0.010506553575396538, -0.0473526231944561, -0.043925948441028595, 0.02463598921895027, 0.047522157430648804, -0.0006694397307001054, 0.06662854552268982, -0.0456615686416626, 0.08455529063940048, -0.003348803613334894, -0.09274566173553467, 0.0663519948720932, 0.033733487129211426, 0.030578341335058212, -0.012650246731936932, 0.04343831539154053, 0.025554360821843147, 0.005985175259411335, 0.037701383233070374, -0.02757016383111477, -0.001967639895156026, -0.049281805753707886, -0.04649314656853676, 0.040467169135808945, 0.06295226514339447, 0.04084259271621704, 0.05900631099939346, -0.023985199630260468, 0.024169007316231728, -0.04675384610891342, 0.045599643141031265, -0.029108982533216476, -0.0021519679576158524, -0.00032252405071631074, -0.000009409775884705596, -0.010702822357416153, -0.04828391224145889, 0.03037816472351551, -0.03420427441596985, -0.028766142204403877 ]
285
285
Coevolutionary Genetic Algorithms for Establishing Nash Equilibrium in Symmetric Cournot Games
We use co-evolutionary genetic algorithms to model the players' learning process in several Cournot models, and evaluate them in terms of their convergence to the Nash Equilibrium. The "social-learning" versions of the two co-evolutionary algorithms we introduce, establish Nash Equilibrium in those models, in contrast to the "individual learning" versions which, as we see here, do not imply the convergence of the players' strategies to the Nash outcome. When players use "canonical co-evolutionary genetic algorithms" as learning algorithms, the process of the game is an ergodic Markov Chain, and therefore we analyze simulation results using both the relevant methodology and more general statistical tests, to find that in the "social" case, states leading to NE play are highly frequent at the stationary distribution of the chain, in contrast to the "individual learning" case, when NE is not reached at all in our simulations; to find that the expected Hamming distance of the states at the limiting distribution from the "NE state" is significantly smaller in the "social" than in the "individual learning case"; to estimate the expected time that the "social" algorithms need to get to the "NE state" and verify their robustness and finally to show that a large fraction of the games played are indeed at the Nash Equilibrium.
[ -0.059901654720306396, -0.009886248968541622, 0.014552933163940907, 0.03189001977443695, -0.008554518222808838, -0.06595955789089203, 0.051947806030511856, 0.0012200834462419152, -0.0029801721684634686, -0.00008899498061509803, -0.013924537226557732, -0.03212212398648262, 0.027947094291448593, 0.042542360723018646, 0.055214058607816696, 0.048155527561903, -0.041566621512174606, -0.001394608523696661, 0.04997265711426735, -0.01642211526632309, 0.010135999880731106, -0.007622978184372187, 0.008586381562054157, 0.08377913385629654, -0.017165368422865868, 0.021442245692014694, 0.012524783611297607, 0.024109521880745888, 0.044392336159944534, -0.00031709560425952077, -0.024770177900791168, 0.003119182540103793, 0.011583205312490463, 0.028095001354813576, 0.033177781850099564, -0.024395378306508064, 0.05824526771903038, -0.05035572126507759, 0.009343843907117844, -0.06929006427526474, -0.052191853523254395, -0.025052383542060852, -0.017683368176221848, 0.009389227256178856, 0.017871085554361343, -0.022316554561257362, 0.037989795207977295, 0.032373782247304916, -0.018310396000742912, 0.07586491107940674, -0.06274963915348053, -0.08763565868139267, -0.007816549390554428, -0.04026651009917259, -0.029565708711743355, 0.005044288467615843, -0.10505595058202744, -0.011663351207971573, -0.04349563270807266, 0.023292457684874535, -0.013832648284733295, 0.05203990265727043, -0.02853131853044033, 0.01192345842719078, -0.06669335067272186, -0.008478847332298756, -0.006807919126003981, -0.007739605847746134, -0.02682901732623577, -0.014568449929356575, 0.021589091047644615, -0.02116353251039982, 0.04042041301727295, 0.08059193193912506, -0.007056482136249542, -0.015294014476239681, -0.010581682436168194, 0.02874365821480751, -0.07162013649940491, 0.06079787388443947, -0.08558136224746704, 0.057088207453489304, 0.04486161097884178, 0.05728819593787193, -0.007965300232172012, -0.029416562989354134, 0.012155536562204361, -0.012575164437294006, -0.06991471350193024, 0.012817105278372765, 0.002874569268897176, 0.0073785665445029736, -0.12487225234508514, 0.08586061745882034, -0.00922070536762476, 0.07375029474496841, -0.08083890378475189, -0.04127407819032669, -0.007741213776171207, -0.0021297044586390257, 0.030595198273658752, -0.04508720710873604, 0.07425124198198318, 0.035992421209812164, -0.03779270872473717, 0.0021292581222951412, -0.02669120579957962, 0.011259258724749088, 0.0612604022026062, -0.02381865680217743, -0.019021449610590935, 0.03057730197906494, 0.05607951432466507, 0.005181188229471445, -0.0032598269172012806, 0.04439309611916542, 0.006667707115411758, 0.02719910815358162, 0.010803453624248505, -0.0030303034000098705, 0.03525379300117493, -0.04137174412608147, -0.04733295366168022, 0.001525336760096252, 0.024533715099096298, -0.02714582532644272, -0.07872068136930466, -0.002893865806981921, 0.06984500586986542, -0.06626588106155396, -0.053446389734745026, -0.017033874988555908, -0.07981549948453903, -0.14896591007709503, -0.07070077955722809, 0.03803257271647453, 0.00932270847260952, 0.041703443974256516, -0.049341220408678055, 0.013055776245892048, 0.004627471789717674, -0.009913482703268528, -0.02385227382183075, 0.02303185686469078, -0.0454428531229496, -0.061719655990600586, -0.002733378205448389, -0.002875955542549491, 0.07469376176595688, 0.06526415795087814, 0.009645207785069942, 0.018575280904769897, 0.07470947504043579, 0.03394250571727753, -0.001892575528472662, 0.02405759133398533, -0.07849850505590439, 0.010602816939353943, 0.011308634653687477, 0.046734120696783066, 0.07161416858434677, 0.006774738896638155, 0.04332561790943146, -0.015021518804132938, 0.020030654966831207, -0.01615189015865326, -0.08576589822769165, 0.0013185680145397782, 0.01583741046488285, -0.026982497423887253, -0.09385188668966293, -0.03216005116701126, 0.02080744318664074, -0.0347406305372715, 0.048079244792461395, 0.006889105308800936, 0.0660778135061264, 0.037947628647089005, -0.04225578159093857, 0.009541884064674377, 0.03492244333028793, 0.018807638436555862, 0.04196283593773842, 0.01241500023752451, 0.08112175762653351, 0.05238436535000801, 0.030670197680592537, 0.02771603874862194, 0.06780444085597992, 0.027565661817789078, -0.02856774814426899, 0.05464211106300354, 0.034786514937877655, -0.026924001052975655, -0.02960222214460373, -0.029730727896094322, -0.06098270043730736, -0.02645774744451046, 0.053865671157836914, 0.056446898728609085, 0.047778885811567307, 0.013057197444140911, -0.06783469766378403, 0.022698232904076576, -0.023122001439332962, 0.05344358831644058, 0.00816273968666792, 0.005055612418800592, -0.045676376670598984, -0.02185927890241146, -0.02365681529045105, 0.045137763023376465, -0.12472101300954819, -0.010721361264586449, -0.02691737376153469, 0.013046800158917904, -0.04751911759376526, -0.050424814224243164, 0.07750478386878967, -0.006564748473465443, 0.013271206989884377, 0.03972512111067772, -0.029638225212693214, 0.018764110282063484, -0.04836312681436539, -0.020860323682427406, 0.024749306961894035, 0.08350463211536407, -0.05485690012574196, -0.01743439957499504, -0.03911649435758591, -0.01624918542802334, -0.040714774280786514, -0.014164105989038944, -0.09501791000366211, 0.08156737685203552, -0.019591407850384712, 0.00943712331354618, -0.07395632565021515, -0.0015585438814014196, -0.06292134523391724, 0.009160066023468971, 0.021700900048017502, -0.00276344851590693, 0.059303976595401764, -0.06624343246221542, 0.04624437168240547, -0.052907008677721024, -0.07019160687923431, -0.035109810531139374, 0.06818654388189316, 0.0179865974932909, -0.027243418619036674, 0.027158191427588463, 0.07170408964157104, -0.06121813878417015, -0.05302110314369202, 0.023526454344391823, 0.08230136334896088, -0.005339017137885094, -0.017196809872984886, 0.07238751649856567, 0.03923972323536873, 0.004982341546565294, 0.11230804026126862, 0.01767802983522415, -0.030330119654536247, 0.0908849835395813, -0.019390277564525604, -0.043183766305446625, -0.003254867857322097, -0.08070473372936249, -0.06530056893825531, 0.016776084899902344, -0.14468097686767578, -0.010853001847863197, 0.11561661958694458, -0.01653946563601494, 0.026092393323779106, 0.005817197263240814, -0.04300432279706001, 0.042796920984983444, -0.0027834565844386816, 0.028782768175005913, 0.019489450380206108, -0.00836229044944048, -0.07003314048051834, 0.04205500707030296, -0.007706581614911556, -0.02402723953127861, -0.031940851360559464, -0.05626818165183067, -0.04096069186925888, -0.016593974083662033, -0.007534566335380077, -0.011407160200178623, -0.010039067827165127, 0.000009302966645918787, -0.05571547895669937, -0.029164496809244156, -0.021459879353642464, -0.007751446217298508, 0.0164443701505661, 0.07957389950752258, 0.01584947481751442, 0.03703245520591736, -0.06719033420085907, 0.0004807242949027568, -0.019990868866443634, -0.03875766694545746, 0.08468858152627945, -0.03576672077178955, 0.0023652028758078814, -0.035440295934677124, -0.002822960028424859, 0.03538937121629715, 0.018830779939889908, 0.004670300055295229, -0.00891297310590744, -0.039922844618558884, 0.025864101946353912, -0.039949629455804825, 0.001101676607504487, 0.03963948041200638, -0.033200703561306, -0.02351061813533306, -0.023466769605875015, 0.047025732696056366, -0.0054133497178554535, 0.04650331661105156, -0.05758361145853996, -0.030923020094633102, -0.020056141540408134, 0.09360989183187485, -0.053231511265039444, 0.030009465292096138, 0.004644438624382019, -0.07908642292022705, 0.04321832209825516, 0.09141433238983154, 0.03318726271390915, -0.10323426127433777, -0.05023159086704254, 0.031447939574718475, 0.026698565110564232, 0.06520261615514755, 0.1099938303232193, 0.03295782580971718, -0.005632610991597176, -0.03247424215078354, -0.018036050722002983, -0.0668429434299469, -0.05221167579293251, 0.019224388524889946, -0.03009091690182686, -0.02169020287692547, -0.021459810435771942, 0.06235657259821892, 0.06800307333469391, -0.010604489594697952, -0.07375214993953705, 0.005101009272038937, 0.005965454503893852, -0.03231251612305641, 0.01193163637071848, 0.04408598318696022, -0.018035542219877243, -0.001624322379939258, -0.03317611292004585, 0.01254376769065857, -0.09571456909179688, 0.023639537394046783, 0.02371274121105671, -0.07235511392354965, -0.02611086517572403, -0.019807664677500725, 0.014336365275084972, -0.0371021069586277, 0.004928113892674446, 0.0320788137614727, -0.044580861926078796, -0.015792986378073692, 0.017078854143619537, -0.026308029890060425, 0.02151024341583252, 0.03734274581074715, -0.007427705451846123, 0.0690036192536354, 0.014073377475142479, 0.04459425434470177, -0.008838371373713017, -0.023167725652456284, -0.09752444177865982, 0.09688177704811096, -0.02600899152457714, -0.09819085896015167, -0.00784609466791153, -0.04990515112876892, -0.05519041791558266, -0.028465306386351585, -0.031612906605005264, -0.1263943761587143, 0.03232591971755028, -0.007361219264566898, 0.0014081993140280247, -0.02092883549630642, 0.006745471153408289, 0.07601770013570786, 0.0355476438999176, 0.06391023099422455, 0.012036400847136974, 0.07336334139108658, 0.016040384769439697, -0.013525685295462608, -0.006226155441254377, 0.06275823712348938, 0.02044443041086197, 0.021085646003484726, 0.07930108904838562, -0.043343011289834976, -0.02641369216144085, -0.09451375156641006, 0.016398413106799126, -0.005496083293110132, 0.007084300275892019, -0.011606503278017044, 0.0002013475459534675, 0.016969824209809303, 0.04152844473719597, 0.09791157394647598, -0.04740185663104057, -0.07710208743810654, 0.0017814881866797805, -0.04719485342502594, -0.03456325829029083, -0.03359146788716316, -0.01109560951590538, -0.0007665400044061244, -0.01664516143500805, -0.020214952528476715, 0.01295054703950882, -0.03292720019817352, -0.020656222477555275, 0.07593197375535965, -0.04896169155836105, 0.06428604573011398, -0.015809446573257446, 0.008897551335394382, 0.010403444990515709, 0.04225105792284012, -0.004885159432888031, 0.002416103845462203, 0.0005885962164029479, 0.007843324914574623, 0.006629574112594128, 0.014861855655908585, 0.024830030277371407, -0.008325237780809402, 0.058647818863391876, -0.0028867416549474, -0.06829798221588135, -0.037766095250844955, 0.01941874250769615, -0.02390170842409134, -0.014783295802772045, -0.03532637655735016, -0.010129614733159542, 0.022126823663711548, 0.09993468225002289, 0.008854242041707039, -0.03960013389587402, 0.019255157560110092, -0.04993489384651184, -0.05811591073870659, -0.026831284165382385, 0.032848428934812546, 0.06759604811668396, -0.0703774094581604, -0.002985763130709529, 0.008656570687890053, 0.011373573914170265, 0.058324821293354034, -0.0003784167056437582, 0.0376351997256279, 0.028427107259631157, -0.005635685753077269, -0.05314873903989792, 0.008062298409640789, 0.05415121838450432, 0.03367079421877861, 0.0035763669293373823, -0.025166789069771767, 0.03258221596479416, -0.017110668122768402, 0.022490214556455612, 0.04887700825929642, 0.06466545164585114, -0.015201641246676445, 0.02701709419488907, -0.00333829945884645, 0.03159289434552193, 0.01854332536458969, 0.05141906812787056, -0.0398409478366375, -0.019936809316277504, -0.00600102823227644, 0.05669507011771202, 0.053845882415771484, -0.06815079599618912, 0.019392045214772224, -0.04762265458703041, 0.02040986157953739 ]
286
286
Transfer Learning Using Feature Selection
We present three related ways of using Transfer Learning to improve feature selection. The three methods address different problems, and hence share different kinds of information between tasks or feature classes, but all three are based on the information theoretic Minimum Description Length (MDL) principle and share the same underlying Bayesian interpretation. The first method, MIC, applies when predictive models are to be built simultaneously for multiple tasks (``simultaneous transfer'') that share the same set of features. MIC allows each feature to be added to none, some, or all of the task models and is most beneficial for selecting a small set of predictive features from a large pool of features, as is common in genomic and biological datasets. Our second method, TPC (Three Part Coding), uses a similar methodology for the case when the features can be divided into feature classes. Our third method, Transfer-TPC, addresses the ``sequential transfer'' problem in which the task to which we want to transfer knowledge may not be known in advance and may have different amounts of data than the other tasks. Transfer-TPC is most beneficial when we want to transfer knowledge between tasks which have unequal amounts of labeled data, for example the data for disambiguating the senses of different verbs. We demonstrate the effectiveness of these approaches with experimental results on real world data pertaining to genomics and to Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD).
[ 0.01661389134824276, -0.009105341508984566, 0.04520449787378311, 0.01627272181212902, 0.05548221990466118, -0.06518583744764328, -0.02047111839056015, 0.029193727299571037, -0.011740082874894142, 0.04685542359948158, 0.005232324358075857, -0.002588569885119796, -0.018156256526708603, -0.07307212799787521, -0.050449736416339874, 0.04081074893474579, -0.0009313735645264387, -0.024792015552520752, 0.041860733181238174, -0.09112745523452759, -0.006967158522456884, 0.004610840231180191, -0.00827055610716343, -0.017254075035452843, 0.046130161732435226, 0.01003880612552166, -0.11641941219568253, 0.0120184775441885, 0.011479190550744534, 0.011145122349262238, -0.04904402792453766, -0.03431626409292221, 0.03540297970175743, -0.025744859129190445, 0.03106844425201416, 0.008849186822772026, 0.014738436788320541, 0.034118879586458206, 0.00298853381536901, 0.016995809972286224, 0.021741807460784912, -0.02019038051366806, -0.041652459651231766, 0.02613242343068123, 0.06605762988328934, 0.009144277311861515, -0.02890353836119175, 0.025706639513373375, 0.02879536896944046, 0.039496857672929764, -0.06521523743867874, 0.04726756736636162, -0.002837245585396886, 0.03089858591556549, -0.0387197807431221, 0.002392569789662957, -0.08894945681095123, -0.042282551527023315, 0.0127604054287076, -0.005672632250934839, -0.01225946843624115, 0.04642237722873688, -0.006316409446299076, 0.04084043577313423, -0.06376459449529648, 0.050415609031915665, -0.04993782937526703, -0.028257498517632484, 0.015788091346621513, -0.04774470999836922, -0.033130183815956116, -0.042300865054130554, -0.006782675161957741, -0.007556853350251913, 0.07582248747348785, 0.11330924183130264, 0.015250216238200665, 0.0221419557929039, 0.05297403410077095, 0.05127415806055069, -0.01831057481467724, 0.019874760881066322, -0.026128726080060005, -0.020668162032961845, 0.029142744839191437, 0.038029711693525314, 0.03788522258400917, 0.004834402818232775, 0.02090841718018055, -0.018132023513317108, 0.007933098822832108, -0.015643537044525146, -0.09647209942340851, -0.020912865176796913, -0.00816391222178936, -0.00883063580840826, -0.04109795764088631, -0.05163270980119705, -0.0036092984955757856, 0.022897789254784584, -0.01676282472908497, -0.01236011553555727, 0.05822450667619705, 0.03777886554598808, -0.034990936517715454, 0.012230130843818188, -0.033279985189437866, 0.11717547476291656, -0.017523324117064476, 0.0772337093949318, -0.010166725143790245, -0.011837305501103401, 0.03849015012383461, 0.018103957176208496, -0.05501456931233406, 0.04418609291315079, 0.013674384914338589, 0.050942156463861465, 0.03323205187916756, -0.0676577091217041, -0.057783324271440506, 0.028727877885103226, -0.03652505949139595, -0.006995638832449913, 0.06278049200773239, 0.011234477162361145, -0.03363963961601257, -0.09600777924060822, 0.03426499664783478, -0.03175186365842819, -0.06639330834150314, 0.005089621990919113, -0.016505783423781395, 0.007325547281652689, -0.025684695690870285, 0.03481603041291237, 0.01008553896099329, -0.04318172112107277, -0.011561490595340729, 0.019434744492173195, -0.0384751632809639, -0.04371529072523117, -0.01145345438271761, -0.004565124865621328, 0.042559586465358734, 0.062256913632154465, -0.015954632312059402, -0.014276606030762196, 0.011675437912344933, 0.01098665315657854, 0.005825283005833626, -0.0784246101975441, 0.05655638501048088, 0.006447700317949057, 0.016495926305651665, -0.04966055601835251, -0.00233533070422709, -0.1000475287437439, -0.007869773544371128, 0.03322337195277214, -0.015751555562019348, -0.031170492991805077, 0.007188910618424416, 0.010730880312621593, -0.019282478839159012, 0.05761207640171051, -0.03975740820169449, -0.010083942674100399, -0.028453148901462555, -0.08021915704011917, -0.05752211809158325, -0.02964704856276512, 0.013300053775310516, -0.002954772673547268, 0.056535325944423676, -0.0324876569211483, -0.0030075267422944307, 0.03141596168279648, -0.004002744797617197, 0.06912481039762497, 0.022319216281175613, -0.03306178003549576, -0.04528521001338959, -0.03904431685805321, 0.01320178247988224, 0.013606087304651737, -0.0012782019330188632, 0.04465075582265854, 0.039131876081228256, 0.04999569430947304, -0.002029093913733959, 0.007664868608117104, -0.00273207388818264, 0.023670684546232224, -0.09281335771083832, 0.022972198203206062, 0.011215051636099815, 0.011599760502576828, 0.03997965529561043, 0.05547246336936951, -0.03506064787507057, -0.0456288680434227, -0.019266925752162933, -0.041922472417354584, -0.08432506769895554, 0.051148008555173874, 0.10315835475921631, -0.019017551094293594, 0.07207845151424408, -0.06603919714689255, 0.0046670460142195225, -0.0026727840304374695, 0.003904114942997694, 0.0816035270690918, -0.013369566760957241, -0.062209852039813995, -0.10360154509544373, -0.07916798442602158, 0.013582081533968449, 0.09432204812765121, 0.0015821363776922226, 0.03854557126760483, -0.08818094432353973, 0.11374108493328094, 0.0403885655105114, -0.021455729380249977, 0.04523535445332527, -0.015863019973039627, 0.019297443330287933, 0.03795991837978363, -0.009527518413960934, -0.03149194270372391, -0.08293849229812622, -0.007348401937633753, 0.008109055459499359, 0.001897843787446618, -0.07545346021652222, -0.07306201010942459, -0.01973106898367405, 0.010983586311340332, -0.016141105443239212, 0.02131016179919243, -0.024133993312716484, -0.006211126688867807, 0.0037333942018449306, 0.018902862444519997, 0.009575462900102139, 0.0054313624277710915, -0.020222483202815056, -0.0026008659042418003, -0.06682634353637695, -0.01980004645884037, 0.015002604573965073, 0.026633234694600105, -0.06717771291732788, -0.07841257005929947, -0.010304317809641361, -0.02078821323812008, 0.055021826177835464, 0.015218354761600494, -0.012955849058926105, -0.03942752629518509, -0.015665404498577118, -0.002113638212904334, 0.009454314596951008, 0.00749395415186882, 0.0498659610748291, 0.06210164725780487, -0.015341447666287422, -0.05993691459298134, -0.03782319650053978, -0.04608159139752388, -0.0024467480834573507, 0.06595470756292343, -0.020661357790231705, 0.031839560717344284, 0.024370979517698288, 0.08233340829610825, 0.10674680769443512, -0.03679303452372551, -0.11733264476060867, 0.05152760446071625, 0.006266395095735788, 0.062193162739276886, 0.056597087532281876, 0.008044760674238205, 0.03795827180147171, -0.02284872531890869, 0.0005305100930854678, -0.0390193834900856, -0.057037536054849625, 0.006359272636473179, -0.00883298460394144, 0.043722692877054214, 0.05412043631076813, -0.04672304913401604, -0.014602289535105228, 0.06054344400763512, 0.06616433709859848, -0.01816188357770443, 0.011858100071549416, -0.00003726111026480794, -0.0027709868736565113, 0.0744452029466629, -0.026548365131020546, 0.0831429734826088, 0.07307688146829605, 0.08264276385307312, -0.06377549469470978, -0.03997764736413956, 0.03961491957306862, 0.004431441891938448, -0.004058232996612787, 0.00882558710873127, -0.007527770474553108, -0.06302820146083832, 0.03987901657819748, 0.033954355865716934, -0.03135431930422783, -0.05769502371549606, 0.1326783299446106, 0.06135661527514458, 0.009850052185356617, 0.004626220092177391, -0.04201456159353256, 0.01681964099407196, -0.05378194525837898, -0.0055748592130839825, -0.06551724672317505, -0.0009269980946555734, -0.05060848221182823, -0.06597401201725006, -0.022557010874152184, 0.06531587988138199, -0.04627971351146698, -0.004417238291352987, -0.024143734946846962, -0.023974226787686348, -0.026017678901553154, -0.059752337634563446, -0.03219320997595787, -0.015076275914907455, -0.002812119433656335, 0.014523978345096111, 0.027486156672239304, -0.026396967470645905, 0.06384555995464325, 0.051264531910419464, 0.06325875967741013, 0.031245045363903046, -0.0635138750076294, -0.02872653864324093, -0.07173008471727371, 0.02024681679904461, -0.028809210285544395, 0.026254650205373764, 0.03783492371439934, -0.025904782116413116, 0.013219878077507019, 0.03308635577559471, 0.020770905539393425, 0.014174426905810833, 0.0024024462327361107, -0.06153997778892517, 0.006258705630898476, 0.06598129123449326, -0.014157934114336967, -0.005141435656696558, -0.053009033203125, -0.02594597078859806, 0.02263573184609413, 0.06656032800674438, 0.041267700493335724, -0.025921111926436424, -0.04585764557123184, -0.062356799840927124, 0.0595540925860405, -0.056411728262901306, -0.018727149814367294, 0.04570872709155083, -0.06127624586224556, -0.05218426510691643, -0.0608941949903965, 0.0013685279991477728, -0.11945871263742447, -0.06121200695633888, -0.015138612128794193, 0.027652384713292122, 0.028855662792921066, 0.02272539585828781, -0.08894377946853638, -0.10061925649642944, -0.08462264388799667, -0.03715185821056366, 0.06860041618347168, -0.028023038059473038, -0.029811840504407883, -0.01765064336359501, -0.03227967023849487, 0.03180940821766853, 0.03768119588494301, 0.006441738456487656, -0.029876593500375748, -0.032329000532627106, -0.12267837673425674, 0.012906884774565697, 0.008201922290027142, 0.01989291049540043, -0.02405817247927189, -0.0689806267619133, -0.009726813063025475, 0.00606088200584054, -0.009203946217894554, -0.039899345487356186, 0.05881757661700249, 0.05230399966239929, 0.0030751314479857683, 0.015669655054807663, -0.067839115858078, -0.10865134000778198, 0.03513941913843155, 0.014758138917386532, 0.03846978396177292, -0.05500739812850952, 0.006160928402096033, -0.03401374816894531, 0.049917109310626984, 0.03627501800656319, -0.004350933711975813, 0.06956840306520462, -0.019817989319562912, -0.03808332979679108, -0.06030222028493881, -0.044655539095401764, 0.035886190831661224, 0.1011216789484024, 0.020354777574539185, 0.029757728800177574, 0.008388628251850605, 0.032482799142599106, -0.0614849254488945, -0.00035616816603578627, 0.1261979043483734, -0.03965853899717331, -0.0014939014799892902, 0.023290669545531273, 0.01931440643966198, 0.0013594641350209713, 0.07565897703170776, 0.0021030078642070293, 0.017811542376875877, 0.0035530885215848684, 0.05523320287466049, -0.02489185892045498, -0.04586789011955261, -0.026634560897946358, -0.05227973312139511, 0.0408196896314621, 0.05665277689695358, -0.005975016858428717, -0.023573804646730423, 0.008350970223546028, 0.01520291343331337, 0.024116627871990204, -0.10866837203502655, 0.021242819726467133, 0.04317387193441391, 0.07785704731941223, 0.05632316693663597, 0.047223132103681564, -0.05794014781713486, 0.009804543107748032, 0.03818483650684357, -0.020365292206406593, 0.03996368497610092, 0.007718720473349094, -0.020109642297029495, 0.03033646009862423, -0.03168598562479019, -0.04683832824230194, 0.0021159949246793985, 0.05032076686620712, -0.0531538650393486, 0.060240842401981354, -0.06775549799203873, -0.003340923460200429, 0.016200687736272812, -0.050576526671648026, -0.008212607353925705, 0.020182279869914055, -0.007086051627993584, 0.038515977561473846, -0.03421089053153992, -0.009427993558347225, -0.0025135823525488377, -0.06923788040876389, -0.0088689886033535, 0.035778071731328964, 0.026414910331368446, 0.07206372916698456, 0.08220356702804565, 0.01989283785223961, 0.02332483045756817, 0.040133219212293625, 0.065907783806324, 0.013139208778738976, 0.06614361703395844, 0.02341490425169468, 0.028397822752594948, 0.005958906374871731, -0.0580400750041008, 0.069735586643219 ]
287
287
A Minimum Description Length Approach to Multitask Feature Selection
Many regression problems involve not one but several response variables (y's). Often the responses are suspected to share a common underlying structure, in which case it may be advantageous to share information across them; this is known as multitask learning. As a special case, we can use multiple responses to better identify shared predictive features -- a project we might call multitask feature selection. This thesis is organized as follows. Section 1 introduces feature selection for regression, focusing on ell_0 regularization methods and their interpretation within a Minimum Description Length (MDL) framework. Section 2 proposes a novel extension of MDL feature selection to the multitask setting. The approach, called the "Multiple Inclusion Criterion" (MIC), is designed to borrow information across regression tasks by more easily selecting features that are associated with multiple responses. We show in experiments on synthetic and real biological data sets that MIC can reduce prediction error in settings where features are at least partially shared across responses. Section 3 surveys hypothesis testing by regression with a single response, focusing on the parallel between the standard Bonferroni correction and an MDL approach. Mirroring the ideas in Section 2, Section 4 proposes a novel MIC approach to hypothesis testing with multiple responses and shows that on synthetic data with significant sharing of features across responses, MIC sometimes outperforms standard FDR-controlling methods in terms of finding true positives for a given level of false positives. Section 5 concludes.
[ 0.027997132390737534, -0.11259244382381439, -0.018688803538680077, 0.006574886851012707, 0.0059999399818480015, -0.004095499403774738, -0.0014958898536860943, 0.011489697732031345, -0.04595402628183365, 0.054524779319763184, 0.04022742062807083, -0.07336027920246124, 0.020800329744815826, 0.025104328989982605, -0.015746593475341797, 0.042585596442222595, 0.01161668635904789, -0.07545933872461319, 0.04735367372632027, -0.04295061528682709, -0.02791123278439045, -0.0037678589578717947, 0.009083527140319347, -0.02410714700818062, -0.018889617174863815, 0.027764376252889633, -0.03845834359526634, 0.05828450247645378, 0.00964475329965353, 0.0030954552348703146, -0.04711127281188965, 0.033586081117391586, 0.006353149656206369, -0.030117057263851166, 0.05359300225973129, -0.00837817694991827, 0.0350407250225544, 0.022220918908715248, 0.01754576899111271, -0.01035977341234684, 0.05547979474067688, -0.057316817343235016, -0.019907193258404732, 0.04939567297697067, 0.06266248971223831, 0.010589011013507843, 0.039656128734350204, -0.004530636593699455, -0.009245018474757671, 0.06407439708709717, -0.058662012219429016, 0.03652404248714447, 0.005784342065453529, -0.014797553420066833, 0.04862164333462715, -0.02376287803053856, -0.05666143074631691, -0.010612222366034985, -0.002372972434386611, 0.015252156183123589, -0.015786822885274887, 0.057261865586042404, 0.04432375356554985, 0.021924329921603203, -0.017408382147550583, 0.050857823342084885, -0.03681620955467224, -0.03133536875247955, -0.01447863969951868, -0.07367301732301712, -0.00000692500270815799, -0.08511491119861603, 0.023640437051653862, 0.037277013063430786, 0.09667926281690598, -0.004849087446928024, 0.02572001703083515, 0.0034109815023839474, 0.025922300294041634, 0.06808847188949585, -0.03526323288679123, -0.01750844530761242, -0.009576709009706974, -0.02753957360982895, 0.013161774724721909, 0.007477085571736097, -0.01758253015577793, -0.01152077130973339, 0.015898073092103004, 0.027865631505846977, -0.022211972624063492, 0.00178976368624717, -0.006041224114596844, 0.044163573533296585, 0.05566881224513054, -0.006373099982738495, 0.01085689477622509, -0.014362351037561893, -0.025012563914060593, 0.027355236932635307, 0.047760266810655594, -0.054781150072813034, 0.005188236013054848, 0.07338596880435944, -0.0560743622481823, -0.009481635875999928, -0.015033887699246407, 0.038880545645952225, -0.006227007135748863, 0.0016215622890740633, -0.035136569291353226, -0.06807534396648407, 0.02760378271341324, 0.06258049607276917, -0.03526308760046959, 0.059199050068855286, 0.004054730758070946, 0.08165062963962555, -0.016970140859484673, -0.05181503668427467, -0.017723938450217247, 0.026660725474357605, -0.0927719697356224, 0.008873945102095604, 0.03703423589468002, -0.020012911409139633, 0.003599138231948018, -0.11049725860357285, 0.07071210443973541, -0.025402856990695, -0.04535369202494621, 0.055073924362659454, 0.07074365764856339, 0.0367918387055397, -0.017090242356061935, 0.023752234876155853, -0.031321872025728226, -0.013388174585998058, -0.039535216987133026, -0.04802677780389786, -0.05124736949801445, -0.02131938375532627, -0.010200604796409607, 0.010336417704820633, -0.03372509405016899, 0.010832414031028748, 0.001649577752687037, 0.021674538031220436, -0.05172593146562576, 0.024802546948194504, 0.007855025120079517, -0.07593830674886703, 0.06298501789569855, 0.01967393048107624, 0.03282107785344124, -0.0746636688709259, -0.02563375234603882, -0.010449199937283993, -0.020369883626699448, 0.05104352906346321, -0.04132169112563133, -0.021194444969296455, 0.05013476684689522, 0.023255696520209312, -0.03398774191737175, -0.00029327612719498575, -0.09517798572778702, 0.006947770714759827, -0.047563206404447556, -0.045061249285936356, -0.05901990085840225, 0.04410659894347191, -0.04769424721598625, 0.056670572608709335, 0.03770507872104645, 0.028765399008989334, 0.007832634262740612, 0.07270623743534088, -0.10131701827049255, 0.022465862333774567, -0.038418982177972794, -0.07551596313714981, -0.010538414120674133, -0.004292982630431652, 0.03933579474687576, 0.05883348733186722, 0.023245908319950104, 0.01596672087907791, 0.07646453380584717, -0.010598091408610344, 0.02179689146578312, -0.02518272213637829, -0.0018377859378233552, 0.06604847311973572, -0.05507123842835426, 0.06255104392766953, -0.009403460659086704, -0.02309197559952736, 0.044893328100442886, 0.008075154386460781, -0.02896271087229252, -0.04225818067789078, 0.08849842846393585, -0.053122617304325104, -0.05124587193131447, 0.06373509764671326, 0.03753872960805893, -0.05633021891117096, 0.00981274712830782, -0.04668870568275452, 0.061425160616636276, -0.009067640639841557, -0.016070140525698662, 0.028063300997018814, 0.02119840309023857, -0.06393356621265411, -0.007950293831527233, -0.06507448107004166, 0.07663834095001221, -0.0233134888112545, 0.006469616666436195, 0.06625401228666306, -0.0749911516904831, 0.06513069570064545, -0.08546223491430283, -0.009609989821910858, 0.041541196405887604, -0.04357569292187691, 0.018157958984375, 0.04623539745807648, 0.012552731670439243, -0.060377322137355804, -0.10407021641731262, -0.08062990009784698, -0.040179293602705, 0.03438194468617439, -0.08440062403678894, -0.06553693860769272, 0.019106220453977585, -0.029178347438573837, 0.05779767781496048, -0.046575870364904404, -0.0058721392415463924, -0.027161573991179466, -0.05249461531639099, 0.006740960758179426, 0.0761183425784111, 0.05791129544377327, -0.04841034114360809, -0.022736988961696625, -0.03380769491195679, 0.024787023663520813, -0.00746955769136548, 0.06966050714254379, -0.040621526539325714, -0.018158363178372383, -0.024806177243590355, 0.006459150463342667, 0.04695051535964012, 0.05415124073624611, 0.04805372282862663, 0.02091027796268463, -0.06013113260269165, -0.015430779196321964, -0.018273308873176575, -0.033699728548526764, 0.04154712334275246, 0.0010354295372962952, -0.0202733613550663, -0.04555122181773186, -0.039443690329790115, -0.08106479793787003, -0.058048345148563385, 0.018465358763933182, -0.050240408629179, 0.05548181012272835, 0.00423029949888587, 0.03505602106451988, 0.07292652875185013, -0.02164710871875286, -0.03180084377527237, 0.056136999279260635, 0.017738260328769684, 0.04688718914985657, -0.06121248006820679, 0.022041453048586845, 0.040545281022787094, 0.013902340084314346, 0.027486862614750862, -0.02824142761528492, -0.1222766861319542, 0.04792485386133194, -0.03696928545832634, 0.06435077637434006, 0.02768169343471527, -0.040103729814291, 0.014456191100180149, 0.03669142723083496, 0.06298946589231491, 0.01801808923482895, 0.06464327126741409, -0.0015996756264939904, 0.017331046983599663, 0.056505706161260605, 0.06770580261945724, 0.013086291030049324, 0.05429717153310776, 0.08826391398906708, -0.054751813411712646, -0.010694079101085663, -0.05895180627703667, -0.06162739172577858, 0.018820658326148987, -0.03205914795398712, 0.008169412612915039, -0.02138627879321575, -0.017043501138687134, 0.017144588753581047, -0.012297175824642181, -0.045938845723867416, 0.07437239587306976, 0.04113868623971939, 0.036457359790802, -0.022657256573438644, -0.11359359323978424, -0.013454769738018513, -0.052764859050512314, -0.022209173068404198, -0.06606896221637726, 0.013922779820859432, -0.07042332738637924, -0.053056541830301285, -0.07450215518474579, 0.03230755403637886, -0.07586155831813812, 0.000946287764236331, -0.0678473487496376, -0.04418621212244034, -0.045455992221832275, -0.04745905101299286, -0.0233230609446764, 0.0352734811604023, -0.06374874711036682, 0.007401565555483103, 0.04818310961127281, 0.024619268253445625, 0.04963952675461769, 0.004324954468756914, -0.004939565435051918, 0.005486692767590284, -0.07077554613351822, 0.05117977783083916, -0.0015112097607925534, 0.026392804458737373, -0.0425165519118309, 0.057941630482673645, 0.08854282647371292, 0.02578059583902359, -0.016191992908716202, 0.008111104369163513, -0.017454493790864944, -0.000886945694219321, -0.08532974123954773, 0.024080343544483185, 0.04270877689123154, 0.05014552175998688, 0.007721129804849625, 0.06373722851276398, -0.04677213355898857, -0.045875195413827896, 0.004387616645544767, 0.11996476352214813, 0.009264989756047726, 0.01755269430577755, -0.06802946329116821, -0.016798539087176323, 0.01312561146914959, 0.007950155064463615, 0.0021164151839911938, 0.06198989227414131, -0.058710288256406784, -0.045680176466703415, -0.07357489317655563, 0.022633301094174385, -0.064099982380867, -0.08627606928348541, -0.04496020823717117, -0.018037497997283936, 0.05258195474743843, 0.005339371506124735, -0.09270256757736206, 0.013851316645741463, -0.0807344987988472, 0.015363066457211971, 0.017908819019794464, 0.054905328899621964, -0.008548536337912083, -0.01615261472761631, -0.07005269825458527, 0.020153533667325974, 0.031559597700834274, 0.037677109241485596, -0.018858226016163826, -0.07926569133996964, -0.07415372878313065, 0.004318943712860346, 0.028127597644925117, -0.03410032391548157, -0.048015326261520386, -0.0031505790539085865, 0.0017779883928596973, 0.028446704149246216, -0.004728939849883318, -0.014554589986801147, 0.10160821676254272, 0.0012567779049277306, 0.059600748121738434, -0.03795592486858368, -0.025496358051896095, -0.11785920709371567, 0.009329096414148808, 0.04248667135834694, 0.025683404877781868, 0.014816650189459324, 0.03417612239718437, 0.04755835980176926, 0.04558176174759865, 0.06582371890544891, -0.017151154577732086, 0.03347298130393028, 0.028232702985405922, 0.005177380982786417, -0.03707576543092728, -0.03813299536705017, -0.04973432794213295, 0.05564701557159424, 0.037356916815042496, 0.03169035166501999, 0.0287867933511734, 0.03990026190876961, -0.043718960136175156, -0.023774538189172745, 0.00727116921916604, 0.004804317839443684, -0.008531399071216583, 0.08142422884702682, -0.025802409276366234, -0.029906099662184715, 0.07911413162946701, -0.003851058427244425, -0.008419838733971119, 0.023957867175340652, 0.025840088725090027, 0.027382908388972282, -0.04393690079450607, 0.02685016766190529, -0.032775022089481354, -0.0034171740990132093, 0.0198140200227499, -0.013080306351184845, -0.04004508629441261, -0.03576226532459259, 0.02800525724887848, 0.07175552099943161, -0.14393585920333862, 0.061649516224861145, 0.07714080810546875, 0.04940418899059296, 0.03471487760543823, 0.05271340161561966, -0.025948114693164825, 0.002940812148153782, 0.021961146965622902, -0.03324441239237785, -0.03458854928612709, -0.0015598980244249105, 0.009891152381896973, -0.02038971148431301, 0.04298262298107147, -0.007440108805894852, 0.028379958122968674, 0.037402328103780746, -0.031682632863521576, -0.011961379088461399, -0.01575135439634323, 0.03331531211733818, -0.06471234560012817, 0.014092332683503628, -0.010174136608839035, 0.04391653835773468, 0.00016378628788515925, -0.051043346524238586, -0.037048522382974625, 0.015348006971180439, -0.0065271491184830666, 0.010040932334959507, -0.02016938477754593, 0.018264073878526688, 0.09862972795963287, 0.026242803782224655, 0.011561159044504166, -0.00936332531273365, 0.06830251216888428, -0.0054406458511948586, 0.07095523178577423, 0.03832193836569786, 0.026784904301166534, -0.03794936463236809, 0.044512756168842316, -0.003829998429864645, -0.07204600423574448, 0.0386517271399498 ]
288
288
Equations of States in Statistical Learning for a Nonparametrizable and Regular Case
Many learning machines that have hierarchical structure or hidden variables are now being used in information science, artificial intelligence, and bioinformatics. However, several learning machines used in such fields are not regular but singular statistical models, hence their generalization performance is still left unknown. To overcome these problems, in the previous papers, we proved new equations in statistical learning, by which we can estimate the Bayes generalization loss from the Bayes training loss and the functional variance, on the condition that the true distribution is a singularity contained in a learning machine. In this paper, we prove that the same equations hold even if a true distribution is not contained in a parametric model. Also we prove that, the proposed equations in a regular case are asymptotically equivalent to the Takeuchi information criterion. Therefore, the proposed equations are always applicable without any condition on the unknown true distribution.
[ 0.0077926055528223515, -0.026882508769631386, 0.016555169597268105, -0.012202111072838306, 0.04761699214577675, -0.062142129987478256, 0.0467413030564785, 0.05160512775182724, 0.0005376696353778243, 0.05425785854458809, -0.02722996100783348, -0.020068742334842682, -0.03782108798623085, -0.023203900083899498, -0.013336666859686375, -0.0011998256668448448, 0.06911426782608032, -0.02290406823158264, 0.10338147729635239, -0.03633800148963928, 0.07102857530117035, 0.06604944169521332, 0.03451645001769066, -0.06379801779985428, 0.025141986086964607, 0.029378321021795273, 0.013276668265461922, 0.030233604833483696, 0.0004907689290121198, 0.016619756817817688, -0.08568716794252396, 0.036688465625047684, -0.002128870692104101, 0.011828250251710415, 0.09107149392366409, -0.0401015430688858, -0.02299010008573532, -0.0247444249689579, -0.026889970526099205, 0.00023352964490186423, 0.009612097404897213, 0.01090173702687025, 0.01270546019077301, 0.047541294246912, 0.09460669755935669, 0.01425247360020876, 0.04280964285135269, 0.048373669385910034, 0.012151235714554787, 0.036917079240083694, -0.06287286430597305, 0.03598050773143768, -0.07949629426002502, -0.07912462949752808, 0.006572321057319641, 0.04335350915789604, 0.002062984509393573, 0.012808670289814472, -0.02746455743908882, -0.05192448943853378, 0.031017133966088295, 0.05307667329907417, -0.03489462658762932, 0.0003967743832617998, 0.011441067792475224, 0.014058045111596584, -0.1276523470878601, -0.02710888907313347, 0.013607565313577652, -0.03623228520154953, 0.018844550475478172, -0.05326137691736221, 0.09830684214830399, 0.09072165191173553, 0.08591282367706299, -0.07499445974826813, -0.020317358896136284, -0.0004371522809378803, -0.047063857316970825, 0.02840277925133705, -0.07235334813594818, 0.03987849876284599, -0.036752842366695404, 0.011820729821920395, -0.04086661711335182, -0.014826182276010513, -0.01331306342035532, -0.02640923485159874, 0.02241215668618679, -0.028662828728556633, 0.038702357560396194, 0.0008194547845050693, -0.01741824299097061, -0.008794974535703659, 0.0028538925107568502, 0.06019046530127525, -0.08902573585510254, -0.011441564187407494, 0.04279791936278343, -0.02902541682124138, 0.018251271918416023, 0.001283031771890819, 0.030735455453395844, 0.028896920382976532, 0.02685469016432762, 0.019841276109218597, 0.03989820554852486, 0.04890838637948036, -0.014175628311932087, 0.007324002683162689, 0.012631790712475777, -0.02236689068377018, 0.060289692133665085, -0.022714633494615555, -0.022975340485572815, 0.08983489871025085, -0.035813793540000916, 0.06083936616778374, 0.054997749626636505, 0.03377683460712433, 0.03978664427995682, 0.0185445174574852, -0.06307253986597061, 0.0011328563559800386, 0.055848632007837296, -0.03564336523413658, -0.014741231687366962, -0.03586377203464508, 0.09139382094144821, 0.023517051711678505, -0.0535237081348896, 0.04431925714015961, 0.04575057700276375, -0.01085477601736784, 0.0027008275501430035, 0.07126238942146301, 0.000821164227090776, 0.023621857166290283, -0.005831096321344376, 0.051830582320690155, -0.006430818699300289, 0.058431778103113174, 0.015688875690102577, 0.04959114268422127, -0.04493909329175949, 0.1015247106552124, 0.004160983022302389, -0.027291473001241684, -0.017142407596111298, 0.038579728454351425, 0.014222624711692333, -0.04801516979932785, 0.013685455545783043, 0.049172792583703995, 0.04517291858792305, -0.02865978144109249, -0.019382841885089874, 0.05177365615963936, -0.010005871765315533, 0.04868306219577789, 0.014244945719838142, -0.02789831906557083, -0.007105877157300711, 0.03977937251329422, 0.013672120869159698, -0.028954584151506424, -0.030889378860592842, 0.059745144098997116, -0.014696504920721054, -0.004935040138661861, -0.06407810747623444, -0.04852869361639023, 0.02866331674158573, -0.03857535123825073, -0.03052753023803234, -0.02466677688062191, 0.018070809543132782, 0.0016846564831212163, 0.0006903111934661865, 0.0053239427506923676, 0.006818781606853008, -0.05259646847844124, 0.010864542797207832, -0.002056157449260354, 0.06640461832284927, 0.08652496337890625, 0.021238146349787712, 0.06250441819429398, 0.04015867039561272, -0.011138145811855793, 0.06603149324655533, 0.012335928156971931, 0.03504576534032822, -0.013810118660330772, -0.08705436438322067, 0.028160013258457184, -0.02926541306078434, -0.03787371516227722, 0.05658630281686783, 0.09538839012384415, 0.023140402510762215, 0.03893931955099106, -0.028336457908153534, -0.035490069538354874, -0.025516079738736153, 0.08031494170427322, 0.05776972696185112, -0.05175406485795975, -0.00859356950968504, 0.03240865468978882, -0.016504134982824326, 0.012483319267630577, 0.006525387521833181, -0.0010000610491260886, -0.014385263435542583, -0.0979437455534935, 0.007933360524475574, -0.01886098086833954, 0.007695872336626053, -0.008516976609826088, -0.005789191462099552, 0.065577931702137, 0.038346532732248306, 0.047060854732990265, -0.0325893834233284, -0.022892536595463753, 0.012233295477926731, -0.004424912389367819, 0.005735982209444046, 0.08195661753416061, -0.048333343118429184, -0.028507953509688377, -0.0188930481672287, -0.03604745864868164, 0.018602026626467705, 0.09577770531177521, -0.08283467590808868, -0.005777334328740835, -0.019191069528460503, 0.0560317225754261, -0.06080656498670578, 0.01044599711894989, -0.037564899772405624, 0.012161384336650372, 0.020440926775336266, -0.07772152870893478, 0.021012354642152786, -0.02490910142660141, 0.022776268422603607, -0.016436250880360603, 0.017854565754532814, -0.019796259701251984, -0.01753743551671505, -0.06961334496736526, -0.023458177223801613, -0.032703496515750885, -0.0629827007651329, 0.0026446757838129997, 0.026844393461942673, 0.054620224982500076, 0.026237769052386284, 0.028240706771612167, -0.04154391214251518, -0.014766720123589039, 0.09225811064243317, -0.07536866515874863, -0.04282563179731369, 0.030639220029115677, -0.020728405565023422, 0.02333005890250206, -0.04693574458360672, -0.0031803606543689966, -0.03824695572257042, 0.10695616900920868, -0.045709677040576935, 0.029691679403185844, 0.002183829667046666, 0.018847662955522537, 0.07484905421733856, -0.0456552729010582, -0.04466820880770683, 0.0837772861123085, -0.018771156668663025, -0.0023381118662655354, -0.009501919150352478, 0.04762447625398636, -0.05348092317581177, 0.05447477847337723, 0.023621708154678345, 0.03533133119344711, 0.019484085962176323, 0.007967527955770493, -0.07424843311309814, -0.02803986892104149, 0.057218752801418304, -0.010674472898244858, 0.03150324895977974, 0.005216378252953291, 0.04065440222620964, -0.03155321627855301, 0.017464853823184967, -0.03544772043824196, 0.020190898329019547, -0.035593483597040176, 0.028940189629793167, 0.03595918044447899, -0.02781819924712181, 0.0052871499210596085, -0.046255338937044144, -0.014225419610738754, 0.08264512568712234, -0.02872266247868538, 0.012376551516354084, 0.01217124704271555, -0.026692895218729973, -0.06270965933799744, -0.03211112692952156, -0.025714166462421417, -0.022705797106027603, -0.04670656472444534, 0.028627540916204453, -0.006491971667855978, -0.002205771626904607, -0.02368132583796978, -0.10869637876749039, -0.02570193074643612, -0.00974382646381855, 0.010800013318657875, -0.05847790837287903, 0.05443808063864708, 0.005862985737621784, -0.09080345928668976, -0.028815502300858498, 0.07525486499071121, -0.040878619998693466, 0.03902876004576683, 0.009875351563096046, 0.05629897490143776, -0.030786285176873207, 0.021391788497567177, -0.02583867870271206, -0.05424682796001434, -0.01766187697649002, -0.010704385116696358, -0.008285216055810452, 0.05637011677026749, 0.06919293850660324, 0.015337444841861725, -0.0749184787273407, 0.07535948604345322, -0.02015620283782482, -0.03507812321186066, -0.037876956164836884, 0.10084297508001328, -0.06416720896959305, 0.039002105593681335, -0.013868297450244427, 0.014623635448515415, 0.016574157401919365, 0.08156441152095795, 0.035718709230422974, 0.045386720448732376, -0.03201005235314369, -0.07200059294700623, 0.006465403828769922, 0.035415660589933395, -0.03436323627829552, 0.031989842653274536, -0.059214215725660324, 0.007879659533500671, -0.007978323847055435, -0.039607785642147064, 0.06908386945724487, 0.019908731803297997, 0.032826922833919525, -0.008070304989814758, 0.05460444092750549, -0.004213996231555939, -0.005858690477907658, 0.03780375048518181, -0.10121295601129532, -0.016772335395216942, -0.05487196519970894, 0.012411382980644703, 0.01252256240695715, -0.06858441978693008, 0.005586537532508373, -0.021435752511024475, 0.05772364139556885, -0.03679729253053665, -0.024124298244714737, -0.06340295076370239, -0.019420653581619263, 0.06045028194785118, 0.03225031495094299, 0.07353968918323517, 0.023828046396374702, 0.0015917231794446707, -0.05564303696155548, 0.04399535804986954, -0.04991672560572624, 0.001626288634724915, 0.03132730722427368, -0.04961588606238365, -0.044725026935338974, -0.016991490498185158, 0.05637252703309059, 0.01591271162033081, 0.004949054215103388, 0.031663183122873306, 0.05193708837032318, 0.05564679950475693, -0.06212369352579117, -0.029419979080557823, 0.04290328174829483, 0.028446579352021217, 0.03190624341368675, -0.02668585442006588, 0.021359531208872795, -0.06730543822050095, 0.004246343392878771, 0.034376371651887894, -0.0007223986322060227, -0.021073797717690468, -0.042990509420633316, 0.011152193881571293, 0.03638741001486778, 0.11666598916053772, 0.044012848287820816, 0.08689538389444351, -0.04428555816411972, -0.05439061298966408, -0.1111733615398407, -0.01777023635804653, 0.02964424155652523, -0.053575802594423294, 0.022467896342277527, -0.08153711259365082, 0.01623055897653103, -0.011746509931981564, -0.005515017081052065, -0.02012724243104458, 0.08065034449100494, 0.013642653822898865, 0.005360053386539221, 0.10855428874492645, 0.01739669404923916, -0.005603420082479715, 0.10973911732435226, 0.00665722182020545, 0.02403111942112446, 0.0045941793359816074, -0.008359859697520733, -0.048757217824459076, 0.017301682382822037, 0.005836790893226862, 0.019393371418118477, 0.016222190111875534, -0.008266576565802097, -0.005015155300498009, -0.01570427604019642, -0.08242961764335632, 0.01291385106742382, 0.042578913271427155, -0.11108123511075974, -0.028925487771630287, 0.05697532743215561, -0.03286144137382507, 0.05605834349989891, 0.0594908781349659, -0.05681368708610535, -0.07286836206912994, 0.0064284526742994785, -0.08884838223457336, -0.012941262684762478, -0.010426336899399757, 0.06645612418651581, -0.10587264597415924, -0.022364143282175064, -0.0946991890668869, 0.01706605963408947, -0.012567330151796341, -0.059982068836688995, 0.026882285252213478, 0.023317188024520874, 0.020614732056856155, 0.015339646488428116, 0.0005928687169216573, 0.09006402641534805, -0.03481927514076233, 0.05143990367650986, 0.00622269744053483, -0.00136273424141109, 0.003752372460439801, 0.003294754773378372, -0.008305707946419716, -0.033423665910959244, -0.03769285976886749, 0.05670055001974106, -0.000011869056834257208, 0.0461212657392025, -0.02132515236735344, 0.019287602975964546, 0.07804130017757416, 0.05983693525195122, -0.003795875236392021, 0.029143543913960457, -0.07361940294504166, 0.057624924927949905, 0.08357780426740646, 0.01167075615376234, -0.026317983865737915 ]
289
289
An optimal linear separator for the Sonar Signals Classification task
The problem of classifying sonar signals from rocks and mines first studied by Gorman and Sejnowski has become a benchmark against which many learning algorithms have been tested. We show that both the training set and the test set of this benchmark are linearly separable, although with different hyperplanes. Moreover, the complete set of learning and test patterns together, is also linearly separable. We give the weights that separate these sets, which may be used to compare results found by other algorithms.
[ -0.037416812032461166, 0.05473649129271507, 0.07870237529277802, 0.02880909852683544, -0.002804931253194809, -0.08010154217481613, -0.023654043674468994, -0.01828862726688385, -0.05184464156627655, 0.04778621345758438, -0.0074723209254443645, -0.006005731876939535, 0.00360114686191082, 0.07663756608963013, 0.08633977174758911, 0.017367059364914894, -0.029810046777129173, 0.02189936675131321, -0.008834258653223515, -0.056504618376493454, 0.0338890515267849, 0.014231635257601738, -0.020258627831935883, -0.05115725100040436, 0.02150462009012699, 0.0009848865447565913, -0.02477806620299816, 0.03813057020306587, -0.04673820734024048, 0.01380971260368824, -0.04637736454606056, 0.027693651616573334, 0.043974827975034714, -0.04020367190241814, 0.05957368388772011, 0.04589581489562988, 0.0679982379078865, -0.03778432309627533, -0.06319472193717957, -0.021737653762102127, 0.0445522703230381, 0.029618194326758385, 0.08545587956905365, -0.033996470272541046, 0.029913604259490967, -0.008065934292972088, -0.022461138665676117, -0.06918298453092575, 0.07897698879241943, 0.044236987829208374, -0.09437794983386993, -0.03638499975204468, -0.03193006291985512, 0.005461781285703182, -0.01949242874979973, 0.11435515433549881, -0.06150135025382042, 0.01259793620556593, 0.007500036619603634, -0.01893465779721737, 0.0151505833491683, 0.06509217619895935, 0.009671797975897789, -0.011323647573590279, 0.02277115173637867, -0.09437185525894165, -0.07362687587738037, -0.03679823502898216, 0.016410235315561295, -0.06453494727611542, 0.05488769710063934, -0.04555516317486763, -0.009470609948039055, -0.003944271244108677, 0.007799151353538036, -0.03101896308362484, 0.0387851782143116, 0.04058819264173508, 0.01708926260471344, 0.06990940123796463, -0.09736284613609314, 0.00284735020250082, 0.059347040951251984, 0.09509049355983734, -0.06620967388153076, -0.010966048575937748, 0.05776413530111313, 0.014630885794758797, -0.007457055617123842, 0.005248676985502243, -0.08194264024496078, 0.011468237265944481, -0.041949424892663956, 0.016141699627041817, -0.061125192791223526, 0.018274804577231407, 0.022124135866761208, -0.037514738738536835, -0.04755077138543129, 0.04606814309954643, -0.007255868054926395, -0.00006203290104167536, 0.009954394772648811, 0.06223941966891289, -0.030620208010077477, 0.023349976167082787, -0.01156509667634964, -0.020132381469011307, 0.02123582921922207, -0.052543774247169495, 0.013948295265436172, 0.023201819509267807, 0.06389672309160233, -0.03144725039601326, -0.08074305951595306, 0.03440767154097557, -0.01039538811892271, 0.06017656251788139, 0.011097182519733906, -0.018240053206682205, -0.03501993417739868, 0.022279832512140274, -0.010367915034294128, 0.008429239504039288, -0.0045683723874390125, 0.0006752745830453932, 0.06514079123735428, -0.006006362847983837, 0.07766152918338776, -0.01164357177913189, -0.08249689638614655, 0.00003057825597352348, -0.005224347580224276, 0.05082673951983452, -0.04146019369363785, 0.005625332705676556, 0.008209006860852242, -0.016407625749707222, -0.037601158022880554, 0.006878564599901438, -0.012176101095974445, -0.04822772368788719, -0.022625090554356575, -0.034027256071567535, 0.047373052686452866, 0.032798487693071365, 0.0474189892411232, -0.020478172227740288, -0.00866936519742012, 0.049049656838178635, 0.03636225312948227, -0.04990513622760773, 0.07010967284440994, 0.10595712065696716, 0.03130527585744858, -0.02481931447982788, -0.004026918206363916, 0.012328923679888248, 0.024405067786574364, 0.08133290708065033, 0.017655903473496437, -0.04016805440187454, -0.005013653077185154, 0.07990767061710358, -0.018710920587182045, -0.05026089772582054, 0.06506786495447159, -0.02218141034245491, -0.025880292057991028, -0.031248006969690323, -0.08026672154664993, 0.002154683694243431, -0.00267246481962502, -0.04944837465882301, 0.04854067414999008, 0.005729746073484421, 0.016207676380872726, 0.0341096930205822, -0.07104218751192093, 0.01633922941982746, 0.0958283320069313, -0.07998449355363846, 0.03741014376282692, 0.06486684828996658, 0.02573184296488762, 0.0559106171131134, 0.08072090893983841, 0.08096334338188171, -0.008937316946685314, -0.023000145331025124, 0.022512074559926987, 0.019866205751895905, 0.05608505755662918, -0.009088610298931599, 0.0038996136281639338, 0.01568436436355114, -0.06218470633029938, -0.025085926055908203, 0.006526552606374025, 0.05889589339494705, 0.026292424649000168, -0.03624103590846062, -0.027572253718972206, -0.04391273856163025, -0.024420499801635742, -0.034879181534051895, 0.057432860136032104, -0.04662029817700386, 0.006773226894438267, -0.018400486558675766, 0.03326838091015816, 0.021061846986413002, 0.011369090527296066, 0.009229323826730251, -0.09666524082422256, -0.050156962126493454, -0.056350335478782654, -0.04847482219338417, 0.0655248835682869, -0.029873566702008247, -0.04693985357880592, 0.0010288107441738248, -0.007201760541647673, -0.013713686726987362, -0.06487909704446793, 0.00678803026676178, 0.030518662184476852, -0.04185372591018677, -0.0685340091586113, 0.0033547680359333754, -0.058086417615413666, -0.020357385277748108, -0.09161633998155594, -0.04065220057964325, 0.03488306701183319, 0.025275280699133873, -0.025404738262295723, -0.03793090581893921, -0.022252388298511505, -0.03313269466161728, -0.010530970059335232, 0.04177035763859749, 0.009466666728258133, -0.028914188966155052, 0.044627413153648376, -0.0030061760917305946, 0.03566276654601097, 0.074580617249012, -0.05266128107905388, -0.08645491302013397, -0.025591373443603516, 0.042304277420043945, -0.043342474848032, -0.03639814630150795, 0.028952598571777344, 0.04146537184715271, 0.037936050444841385, -0.025724144652485847, -0.011305438354611397, 0.0665864497423172, 0.06301389634609222, 0.05935603752732277, -0.033821284770965576, 0.02986724115908146, 0.1074799969792366, 0.03465672954916954, -0.017857516184449196, 0.026908066123723984, 0.008328278549015522, -0.00734163960441947, -0.021383099257946014, -0.12090501934289932, -0.014922408387064934, 0.1375310719013214, -0.07270835340023041, 0.016738438978791237, -0.003749475348740816, 0.019931308925151825, 0.06450705230236053, 0.04787487909197807, -0.032929372042417526, 0.026290670037269592, 0.03408311679959297, -0.01568675972521305, -0.03319268673658371, 0.03954300284385681, 0.010391006246209145, 0.017226705327630043, 0.03274824470281601, 0.03584061190485954, -0.004534212406724691, 0.01954725943505764, -0.036200083792209625, -0.0496830940246582, 0.05751308053731918, -0.06365714222192764, -0.014025870710611343, 0.012783883139491081, -0.000030178167435224168, -0.08151839673519135, -0.03373705968260765, 0.000791357655543834, 0.05655539035797119, 0.06534426659345627, 0.022287072613835335, 0.023446178063750267, 0.027623005211353302, 0.08280172944068909, -0.0005603203899227083, -0.03585531935095787, 0.030982138589024544, -0.06995268166065216, -0.014658206142485142, -0.05516622215509415, -0.04911131039261818, -0.06626629829406738, 0.036209650337696075, 0.005909814964979887, -0.05063896253705025, 0.042314667254686356, 0.043069351464509964, -0.0463414303958416, 0.022301550954580307, -0.009794625453650951, -0.05267401039600372, -0.0052093095146119595, 0.009620643220841885, 0.06693551689386368, -0.12822559475898743, 0.02195069193840027, -0.039235230535268784, 0.02660617046058178, 0.05393295735120773, 0.15637807548046112, 0.0015492220409214497, 0.04456591233611107, -0.03911364823579788, 0.010606978088617325, -0.04968724772334099, 0.05853131785988808, -0.042193956673145294, -0.07213816046714783, 0.013847625814378262, -0.047583576291799545, -0.027763305231928825, 0.028650697320699692, -0.02153635211288929, -0.026743220165371895, -0.04914842173457146, 0.020950354635715485, -0.07258059084415436, 0.020579224452376366, -0.011586587876081467, -0.000640295329503715, -0.0011376255424693227, 0.04074178263545036, 0.014974134974181652, 0.005197246093302965, -0.0222499780356884, 0.041968345642089844, -0.0006144228973425925, -0.015310085378587246, -0.06376372277736664, 0.003936497960239649, -0.007028521969914436, -0.01821892522275448, -0.06538175791501999, 0.02528214082121849, -0.06454797834157944, -0.04261012375354767, -0.013833221979439259, -0.03521685674786568, 0.06802969425916672, 0.0086814621463418, -0.035389311611652374, -0.0628400593996048, -0.0323539674282074, -0.09224318712949753, -0.05059655383229256, 0.043006230145692825, -0.07476291060447693, 0.01877463050186634, 0.006479923147708178, 0.044035930186510086, 0.00549683254212141, 0.01905105449259281, -0.002808322198688984, 0.07513180375099182, 0.019248299300670624, 0.012876779772341251, -0.02331170067191124, -0.060591209679841995, -0.0018713512690737844, 0.0006532601546496153, 0.039014045149087906, -0.0292471032589674, -0.005906861741095781, 0.025752568617463112, -0.03156502917408943, -0.08097503334283829, 0.03043043240904808, -0.0037459793966263533, -0.09114142507314682, -0.07009793817996979, -0.09784645587205887, 0.041082240641117096, -0.026247726753354073, 0.009496597573161125, 0.03940664976835251, 0.06133823096752167, 0.026377012953162193, 0.045702014118433, -0.06984797865152359, 0.0603371299803257, -0.026247918605804443, 0.035115018486976624, 0.0515054427087307, 0.05674370005726814, -0.008548842743039131, -0.0164685919880867, -0.013489535078406334, 0.026523446664214134, -0.03406044468283653, -0.06343390047550201, 0.023705946281552315, 0.024186354130506516, 0.038976334035396576, 0.04373151436448097, -0.01716872863471508, 0.03753325715661049, -0.05178375542163849, 0.025575539097189903, -0.07241304218769073, 0.03566684201359749, -0.0018995670834556222, -0.017412230372428894, 0.02177312783896923, -0.06201712787151337, -0.02362382784485817, -0.01024838350713253, -0.10539953410625458, -0.017775459215044975, 0.008228247053921223, -0.031819067895412445, 0.017402591183781624, 0.044246528297662735, 0.08446861803531647, 0.003932897467166185, 0.04378405958414078, -0.04736867547035217, 0.027087802067399025, -0.027059633284807205, 0.011324643157422543, 0.02173026092350483, -0.04637661203742027, -0.02931709960103035, 0.014588934369385242, -0.09436895698308945, 0.06838544458150864, -0.03103976882994175, -0.04065524786710739, 0.01737942360341549, 0.07350388169288635, 0.0356270894408226, -0.03388158604502678, -0.016505170613527298, 0.005989965982735157, 0.005719553213566542, 0.0038304172921925783, -0.0345219187438488, -0.09607682377099991, 0.03640412911772728, -0.0519302599132061, 0.017273342236876488, 0.010260969400405884, -0.031661659479141235, 0.016962643712759018, -0.047803495079278946, -0.019886916503310204, 0.044648293405771255, 0.07278691977262497, -0.05889212340116501, -0.006323202513158321, 0.017681052908301353, 0.013942427933216095, 0.028325887396931648, -0.07318517565727234, 0.00380945997312665, -0.004851426463574171, 0.003008295549079776, 0.07036039233207703, -0.02367463894188404, -0.015531468205153942, -0.003558356547728181, -0.00583330262452364, -0.024306073784828186, -0.023288019001483917, -0.029972625896334648, 0.06245775520801544, 0.011208522133529186, 0.03293265029788017, 0.049435876309871674, 0.041388288140296936, -0.00540027255192399, 0.0037321855779737234, 0.02885478548705578, 0.030486460775136948, -0.01912272721529007, 0.00599144259467721, 0.04188218340277672, 0.04259739816188812, 0.003120634937658906 ]
290
290
Using Genetic Algorithms for Texts Classification Problems
The avalanche quantity of the information developed by mankind has led to concept of automation of knowledge extraction - Data Mining ([1]). This direction is connected with a wide spectrum of problems - from recognition of the fuzzy set to creation of search machines. Important component of Data Mining is processing of the text information. Such problems lean on concept of classification and clustering ([2]). Classification consists in definition of an accessory of some element (text) to one of in advance created classes. Clustering means splitting a set of elements (texts) on clusters which quantity are defined by localization of elements of the given set in vicinities of these some natural centers of these clusters. Realization of a problem of classification initially should lean on the given postulates, basic of which - the aprioristic information on primary set of texts and a measure of affinity of elements and classes.
[ -0.02451099269092083, 0.024444427341222763, 0.03225868567824364, 0.05047173425555229, 0.09219067543745041, -0.06457574665546417, -0.0485079325735569, -0.030408715829253197, -0.04326038807630539, -0.03246130421757698, -0.012179653160274029, 0.037263430655002594, 0.008312609046697617, 0.01239757239818573, -0.02365938015282154, 0.0395532064139843, -0.045054495334625244, -0.005895513109862804, 0.007924128323793411, -0.07368695735931396, -0.023435214534401894, 0.050268832594156265, -0.02967814914882183, 0.00881609134376049, -0.005366566125303507, -0.027574623003602028, -0.06233389303088188, 0.0632566586136818, -0.03826550766825676, 0.07270770519971848, -0.013005167245864868, -0.009489248506724834, 0.02696976065635681, -0.022008253261446953, 0.06472622603178024, -0.028922153636813164, -0.0719972625374794, 0.009642078541219234, -0.12931624054908752, -0.0316358283162117, 0.04096035659313202, 0.023259153589606285, -0.035924725234508514, 0.007507112342864275, 0.06534066796302795, 0.020888887345790863, 0.04854641482234001, 0.01944563165307045, 0.03616755083203316, 0.0425507053732872, -0.04971762374043465, 0.017229586839675903, -0.015105199068784714, 0.0000349000001733657, -0.0026186483446508646, -0.05466356873512268, 0.01717919297516346, 0.0024372688494622707, 0.011538508348166943, -0.07460538297891617, 0.1067359447479248, 0.06288568675518036, 0.003854275681078434, 0.02719823084771633, -0.04376290366053581, -0.049654558300971985, -0.040734853595495224, -0.04483078792691231, 0.015147547237575054, -0.07423776388168335, -0.019720586016774178, 0.01551903784275055, 0.05812705308198929, 0.018757851794362068, -0.010012288577854633, 0.01813325472176075, -0.007886184379458427, -0.00451272027567029, 0.008331900462508202, 0.07252556085586548, 0.005231116898357868, -0.007816975004971027, -0.07232575118541718, -0.0590328723192215, -0.02659723535180092, 0.004892472643405199, 0.025046268478035927, -0.05678611248731613, 0.015540451742708683, -0.009688446298241615, -0.027178512886166573, -0.04172983020544052, -0.07505001872777939, 0.0055213188752532005, -0.005936010275036097, 0.029229875653982162, -0.055869679898023605, -0.021710379049181938, 0.05742305517196655, 0.07624389976263046, -0.07706637680530548, -0.044261809438467026, 0.07176385819911957, 0.004271135665476322, -0.028419746086001396, 0.011976676993072033, -0.0739617720246315, 0.06612026691436768, 0.031206374987959862, 0.029320748522877693, 0.013976032845675945, 0.019552886486053467, -0.012088935822248459, 0.050632961094379425, -0.018596459180116653, 0.0141065688803792, -0.012704803608357906, 0.07762817293405533, -0.002957345684990287, -0.01155684981495142, 0.03873440623283386, 0.0037803836166858673, -0.014721271581947803, 0.027686765417456627, 0.05501408502459526, -0.031204771250486374, -0.019009428098797798, -0.038593754172325134, 0.08803050965070724, 0.005875010974705219, -0.09972550719976425, 0.05731628090143204, -0.08560698479413986, 0.04209776967763901, 0.0007469269330613315, 0.024858567863702774, 0.06390658020973206, -0.050775010138750076, 0.003215349279344082, -0.02359808050096035, -0.0023715663701295853, -0.016863591969013214, 0.0014712691772729158, -0.03303820267319679, 0.08318285644054413, 0.0452912338078022, -0.04584013298153877, 0.013462813571095467, 0.06366828083992004, -0.02150309830904007, -0.05787263810634613, -0.08476342260837555, 0.01978100650012493, 0.0232065599411726, 0.009318266063928604, -0.013504096306860447, 0.002623965498059988, -0.0907667726278305, 0.009537098929286003, -0.006827192846685648, -0.044151123613119125, -0.044652488082647324, 0.008220089599490166, 0.03405727073550224, -0.028396913781762123, 0.030795693397521973, -0.032088685780763626, -0.034510236233472824, 0.011939610354602337, -0.030082471668720245, 0.021137647330760956, 0.02431352436542511, 0.034520234912633896, 0.05042465776205063, -0.03382030501961708, -0.016249656677246094, -0.08977582305669785, -0.02639453485608101, -0.054198116064071655, 0.004964608699083328, 0.021180827170610428, -0.12263165414333344, 0.013135512359440327, 0.04383759945631027, 0.029246781021356583, 0.15910698473453522, -0.04894358292222023, 0.06464824825525284, 0.014749625697731972, -0.04538803920149803, -0.014860503375530243, -0.03676223009824753, 0.07102012634277344, 0.01060519553720951, -0.04858964681625366, -0.02209947071969509, -0.013705825433135033, 0.04441269114613533, 0.0641242116689682, -0.0091550936922431, -0.07817725092172623, 0.04977003112435341, 0.022704843431711197, 0.006927839480340481, -0.025371931493282318, -0.08945101499557495, 0.0335964597761631, -0.014807021245360374, -0.016693582758307457, 0.008467838168144226, 0.004045097157359123, -0.05311671644449234, 0.053494762629270554, 0.02141418121755123, 0.009117620065808296, -0.046394433826208115, -0.11165662854909897, -0.03347008302807808, 0.04095577448606491, 0.06783275306224823, -0.005250152666121721, -0.06744584441184998, -0.049515895545482635, 0.053639136254787445, 0.021762613207101822, 0.02542511746287346, 0.07435958832502365, -0.07569468766450882, -0.08216242492198944, 0.02750466763973236, -0.07422016561031342, -0.07584559172391891, -0.051309533417224884, 0.0014022886753082275, 0.07061896473169327, -0.02481582947075367, 0.028713444247841835, 0.029748648405075073, -0.02380123920738697, -0.04786692187190056, -0.004598136059939861, 0.042579520493745804, -0.00012093463010387495, -0.06339264661073685, 0.017400717362761497, -0.014633993618190289, 0.03726859763264656, 0.017022356390953064, 0.016118759289383888, -0.022710109129548073, -0.03999735042452812, 0.012211933732032776, 0.010252658277750015, 0.026908431202173233, 0.01149959396570921, 0.0186180267482996, -0.024721551686525345, 0.03964260593056679, 0.06701374053955078, 0.09718535095453262, -0.027009161189198494, 0.007662495598196983, -0.018470216542482376, -0.031758297234773636, 0.08311422914266586, -0.0042864601127803326, -0.032384034246206284, 0.011337063275277615, -0.028949113562703133, -0.08015746623277664, -0.023353787139058113, -0.04799354448914528, 0.0046448553912341595, 0.09660422056913376, -0.0672210156917572, -0.007776700891554356, -0.06301283091306686, 0.021056897938251495, 0.0022314689122140408, -0.0218344759196043, -0.03769995644688606, 0.01780097372829914, 0.04572252556681633, 0.013743441551923752, -0.030374083667993546, -0.032490283250808716, 0.03789381682872772, -0.029264191165566444, 0.012771456502377987, -0.029455777257680893, -0.031143466010689735, -0.048953503370285034, -0.04764088615775108, 0.023381974548101425, 0.024226805195212364, -0.03910329192876816, 0.02556380070745945, 0.06977057456970215, -0.008342917077243328, -0.05623266473412514, -0.03595072403550148, 0.04833710193634033, 0.101272352039814, 0.017479853704571724, 0.009806354530155659, 0.030417902395129204, 0.07120344787836075, -0.0002915543445851654, 0.0020864177495241165, 0.016386453062295914, -0.04052193462848663, -0.0035607588943094015, 0.03557749465107918, 0.022264109924435616, 0.043048713356256485, -0.0037622421514242887, 0.0055754478089511395, 0.025821473449468613, -0.014349274337291718, -0.010089569725096226, 0.03162738308310509, -0.014012354426085949, 0.0028666530270129442, -0.0341266468167305, -0.02068192884325981, -0.01059925276786089, -0.025528647005558014, 0.0020572601351886988, -0.07774730026721954, -0.04898345097899437, -0.0600985549390316, -0.01065230555832386, 0.06520240753889084, 0.08491979539394379, -0.008647690527141094, 0.0009494946571066976, 0.04991470277309418, 0.07008010149002075, -0.04118259251117706, 0.02293642982840538, -0.06382908672094345, -0.048202596604824066, -0.01878354512155056, -0.0024140486493706703, -0.026826905086636543, -0.025724243372678757, 0.03675412759184837, 0.06824976950883865, 0.03319348767399788, -0.008551949635148048, -0.055472131818532944, 0.10032878071069717, -0.1158929318189621, 0.01687512919306755, 0.008429452776908875, 0.08185037225484848, 0.06176488474011421, 0.046927500516176224, 0.04124240204691887, -0.03635824844241142, 0.033795665949583054, -0.006093427538871765, -0.0022244902793318033, -0.027840912342071533, -0.013990077190101147, 0.06904733926057816, 0.020709402859210968, 0.02242504060268402, -0.014682039618492126, 0.012751790694892406, 0.10101736336946487, 0.010406645014882088, -0.0024614313151687384, -0.038702014833688736, 0.06606368720531464, 0.009778378531336784, -0.01060383953154087, -0.047729283571243286, 0.04142732173204422, 0.0008579824934713542, -0.026403242722153664, 0.007288355380296707, -0.04605325683951378, 0.022817252203822136, -0.04434124380350113, 0.009665058925747871, -0.01128607988357544, -0.0029052996542304754, 0.06097245216369629, 0.0013851174153387547, 0.04394342377781868, -0.03514373302459717, 0.011857002042233944, 0.03483642637729645, 0.08394411951303482, -0.03541697934269905, -0.03397021070122719, 0.01524041686207056, -0.04937266185879707, -0.06406858563423157, 0.006981913466006517, -0.003487407462671399, -0.026445502415299416, -0.10532829165458679, -0.014580115675926208, 0.05995110794901848, -0.043672073632478714, 0.08869987726211548, 0.034028686583042145, -0.05016050860285759, 0.05988098308444023, -0.0026585992891341448, -0.07045656442642212, -0.008820568211376667, 0.021783381700515747, 0.021300585940480232, 0.06845172494649887, 0.003147333161905408, 0.07906262576580048, -0.07259875535964966, 0.04097626730799675, 0.01009432878345251, 0.03501676395535469, -0.0037866609636694193, -0.03467933088541031, -0.02175479754805565, 0.07120683044195175, -0.008853628300130367, -0.007573835086077452, 0.0486895777285099, -0.0018669631099328399, -0.0029687858186662197, -0.04764702171087265, 0.01252888236194849, 0.07799768447875977, 0.0368809811770916, 0.023447781801223755, 0.02843244932591915, 0.029273785650730133, 0.01965498924255371, 0.0010938083287328482, 0.08482925593852997, 0.03445828706026077, -0.035415828227996826, -0.009239435195922852, 0.017914632335305214, 0.04750973731279373, -0.043300192803144455, 0.019209228456020355, -0.013203338719904423, 0.019512511789798737, -0.015197310596704483, 0.04834602400660515, -0.047237738966941833, -0.03939250484108925, -0.009128671139478683, -0.06835662573575974, -0.048543743789196014, 0.06348300725221634, -0.13912634551525116, -0.0028387526981532574, 0.054716598242521286, 0.004636347759515047, -0.03656237572431564, -0.043883439153432846, -0.0003749129828065634, 0.06132734566926956, -0.011259699240326881, 0.07112522423267365, 0.02118036337196827, -0.03584485128521919, 0.01892470382153988, 0.007116990629583597, 0.03471555560827255, -0.0048306779935956, -0.04655178263783455, -0.05117303505539894, -0.02882635034620762, -0.09037474542856216, -0.06667519360780716, 0.08510187268257141, 0.010454913601279259, -0.04062729701399803, 0.013195572420954704, 0.06556014716625214, -0.029278142377734184, -0.02758583426475525, 0.05309121683239937, 0.0535731241106987, -0.004324957262724638, -0.004132159985601902, -0.03559377044439316, -0.04335997626185417, -0.03861718997359276, -0.04966684430837631, -0.014652951620519161, 0.030968274921178818, -0.0043289815075695515, 0.006161157041788101, 0.04034451022744179, 0.032614387571811676, -0.017528625205159187, 0.0530540868639946, 0.01865653693675995, 0.09929760545492172, -0.032172247767448425, -0.026273265480995178, 0.018624568358063698, 0.024489212781190872, 0.05574418231844902, 0.022489771246910095, -0.05234232172369957 ]
291
291
Fast Weak Learner Based on Genetic Algorithm
An approach to the acceleration of parametric weak classifier boosting is proposed. Weak classifier is called parametric if it has fixed number of parameters and, so, can be represented as a point into multidimensional space. Genetic algorithm is used instead of exhaustive search to learn parameters of such classifier. Proposed approach also takes cases when effective algorithm for learning some of the classifier parameters exists into account. Experiments confirm that such an approach can dramatically decrease classifier training time while keeping both training and test errors small.
[ -0.034658294171094894, -0.0069222357124090195, 0.00035551146720536053, -0.009737883694469929, 0.0781700611114502, -0.01072843186557293, -0.03520328924059868, 0.04349922761321068, -0.026995660737156868, -0.006656226702034473, -0.04085893929004669, 0.0033636402804404497, -0.047359712421894073, 0.06325888633728027, -0.045095525681972504, -0.001912343199364841, 0.031901415437459946, -0.005644967779517174, -0.025465333834290504, -0.07783006131649017, 0.031066423282027245, -0.03311346098780632, -0.04260794073343277, -0.07520224153995514, -0.0407501757144928, 0.022487802430987358, -0.021492833271622658, -0.024660855531692505, 0.05343034118413925, 0.0681445300579071, -0.013552320189774036, 0.0033540576696395874, -0.045360956341028214, -0.008897812105715275, 0.00794018991291523, 0.03538599610328674, 0.013884788379073143, -0.012512757442891598, -0.046191055327653885, -0.041509345173835754, -0.01918528974056244, 0.0250208992511034, 0.011184176430106163, 0.007465897127985954, 0.058286018669605255, 0.0686129480600357, 0.03868110105395317, 0.024064475670456886, -0.0748075544834137, 0.08459171652793884, -0.03212760016322136, 0.033745650202035904, -0.04707512632012367, -0.09539154917001724, 0.0658273696899414, 0.00043112144339829683, -0.0381956584751606, -0.004055891651660204, -0.0012794063659384847, -0.015397864393889904, 0.03799637779593468, 0.09462475031614304, -0.03405165299773216, 0.006123528350144625, 0.018524102866649628, -0.04909122735261917, -0.08060596883296967, 0.03336506336927414, -0.08073273301124573, -0.010201823897659779, 0.049643319100141525, -0.036693353205919266, 0.030016088858246803, 0.0819309651851654, -0.03520597517490387, 0.019477590918540955, 0.014384661801159382, 0.04911835491657257, -0.013107688166201115, 0.03804672136902809, -0.009738286025822163, -0.03243342414498329, -0.012755142524838448, 0.035529546439647675, 0.07927502691745758, -0.08160427957773209, 0.032838743180036545, -0.02902013622224331, 0.061293259263038635, -0.0322580561041832, -0.012002327479422092, 0.029222901910543442, -0.11412443220615387, 0.02668609842658043, -0.04715679958462715, -0.011050672270357609, -0.038270458579063416, 0.056195855140686035, 0.025866463780403137, 0.0663440153002739, 0.025650938972830772, 0.0569506511092186, 0.08028551191091537, 0.011547154746949673, -0.06240955367684364, 0.05442819371819496, -0.06795012950897217, 0.027637548744678497, 0.0022109379060566425, 0.027761222794651985, 0.07983942329883575, -0.022953476756811142, 0.055851809680461884, -0.009764889255166054, -0.02101980149745941, -0.022613869979977608, -0.046114034950733185, 0.0220959410071373, 0.0702153891324997, -0.025036180391907692, 0.006729016546159983, 0.060701657086610794, -0.047100890427827835, 0.014754329808056355, 0.05187501385807991, -0.007024719379842281, 0.039974719285964966, -0.00836826954036951, 0.1170053482055664, 0.013326255604624748, -0.03377564251422882, 0.09260474890470505, -0.05305900424718857, -0.035245630890131, 0.010850071907043457, 0.008002392016351223, 0.0771411806344986, -0.022685376927256584, 0.04933944717049599, 0.048953257501125336, 0.03644488379359245, -0.03972587734460831, 0.06481023132801056, 0.029279431328177452, -0.006693937815725803, 0.0030358165968209505, 0.01601570099592209, 0.03302470222115517, -0.008977587334811687, 0.08591349422931671, -0.014187066815793514, -0.00921317283064127, -0.003866528859362006, 0.06153111904859543, 0.03468162193894386, -0.004261431284248829, -0.020782804116606712, -0.05812520161271095, 0.012003829702734947, -0.010859206318855286, -0.014135601930320263, 0.05160646513104439, 0.053416043519973755, 0.04623371362686157, -0.009527243673801422, -0.0056199682876467705, -0.010519527830183506, -0.011709854006767273, -0.040856361389160156, -0.05640468746423721, 0.011382038705050945, 0.03079766221344471, -0.05789840221405029, -0.035382963716983795, 0.06018779054284096, -0.003500410122796893, 0.028556132689118385, 0.0012763822451233864, -0.01455978024750948, 0.020558509975671768, 0.007797900587320328, -0.02590114437043667, -0.04290620982646942, -0.0025144515093415976, 0.0750439465045929, 0.08205938339233398, -0.034584272652864456, 0.000673023343551904, 0.07152421772480011, -0.03219073638319969, 0.02326762117445469, -0.03673207759857178, 0.007596395444124937, 0.014847757294774055, -0.09470127522945404, 0.05508533865213394, -0.05312342569231987, -0.022481592372059822, 0.03831097483634949, 0.08712905645370483, 0.04142488166689873, 0.017910437658429146, -0.06840761005878448, -0.08359977602958679, -0.05852507799863815, 0.04391204193234444, 0.034482236951589584, -0.06489211320877075, 0.05205761268734932, -0.02860204130411148, 0.05469455197453499, 0.00807928666472435, 0.04857703670859337, -0.047206904739141464, -0.0273838359862566, -0.04858401417732239, -0.06764034181833267, -0.04818259924650192, 0.06028793007135391, 0.0623941645026207, -0.0681699737906456, 0.011760889552533627, -0.036915820091962814, 0.04917411506175995, -0.004156818613409996, 0.005586451385170221, -0.005057132337242365, 0.025559712201356888, -0.05084121227264404, 0.04588605463504791, -0.02108435146510601, 0.01729344204068184, -0.031831059604883194, 0.029945675283670425, 0.0022200553212314844, -0.0009225842077285051, -0.007226491812616587, 0.030767928808927536, -0.054553382098674774, 0.010935259982943535, 0.0032702384050935507, 0.02475639618933201, -0.03763018175959587, 0.02400159277021885, 0.04118335247039795, -0.03761458024382591, 0.014360539615154266, 0.07878348976373672, -0.0412154421210289, 0.0483865849673748, 0.04768674820661545, -0.005725154187530279, -0.011956015601754189, -0.03607405349612236, 0.06024591252207756, 0.029319733381271362, 0.011724526062607765, 0.07071179151535034, 0.03280404582619667, 0.09944324940443039, 0.0030279429629445076, 0.005290274508297443, 0.06336046755313873, -0.015137235634028912, 0.06343398243188858, 0.02138085663318634, 0.009192485362291336, -0.02024073339998722, -0.013223789632320404, 0.0134425712749362, -0.011848646216094494, -0.04273989796638489, 0.018207455053925514, 0.033391691744327545, -0.0540522001683712, 0.07046593725681305, -0.01259615644812584, 0.031583741307258606, 0.043740879744291306, -0.003840760327875614, -0.1152738481760025, 0.013375313952565193, 0.02183236926794052, 0.036147937178611755, -0.013707181438803673, -0.017444590106606483, -0.08389309793710709, -0.030082549899816513, 0.027979517355561256, 0.022256797179579735, -0.013820151798427105, 0.06789153814315796, -0.08885529637336731, 0.021171262487769127, 0.041843511164188385, -0.032694973051548004, 0.01972711831331253, 0.03342805057764053, -0.04314135015010834, -0.049880027770996094, 0.027667218819260597, -0.006584435235708952, 0.029640110209584236, 0.0074469465762376785, -0.022590572014451027, 0.11706375330686569, 0.038379114121198654, 0.028792979195713997, -0.04840950667858124, 0.038402631878852844, 0.09522537887096405, -0.014143922366201878, 0.027377000078558922, -0.023637596517801285, -0.020484820008277893, 0.04731384664773941, -0.08451440930366516, 0.04134027287364006, 0.02324068918824196, -0.004883490037173033, 0.03000742755830288, 0.037764910608530045, -0.029362069442868233, -0.012011220678687096, -0.08634611964225769, -0.04137672856450081, -0.0008819272043183446, 0.04667392373085022, -0.05530785396695137, -0.040991686284542084, -0.08230706304311752, -0.008640861138701439, -0.07248810678720474, 0.06421784311532974, -0.020339306443929672, -0.022008955478668213, -0.011279609985649586, 0.027800390496850014, -0.0006050118827261031, -0.01655261591076851, -0.03691530227661133, -0.05264262855052948, 0.021396353840827942, 0.027572624385356903, -0.03721015527844429, -0.022946640849113464, 0.04661934822797775, 0.05999166518449783, -0.025803295895457268, 0.008142132312059402, -0.05930579453706741, 0.0008804955868981779, -0.05135892704129219, 0.0012270105071365833, -0.06688673794269562, 0.06183164194226265, 0.00735157635062933, -0.07913852483034134, 0.02291296236217022, -0.0045656426809728146, 0.03626035526394844, 0.026296619325876236, 0.0027745526749640703, -0.01582350954413414, 0.01143856905400753, 0.039740245789289474, 0.029315615072846413, -0.01001843810081482, -0.005871596280485392, 0.019290290772914886, -0.00450644688680768, 0.0014099042164161801, -0.00008115290984278545, 0.04795140027999878, 0.041705042123794556, -0.05370678752660751, 0.034977469593286514, 0.009862597100436687, -0.007204230409115553, 0.05875856801867485, -0.07392387837171555, 0.012104756198823452, -0.04765942692756653, 0.009301071055233479, -0.011360119096934795, -0.021356867626309395, -0.062051285058259964, 0.003483186475932598, 0.05020364001393318, 0.017869677394628525, 0.0026343557983636856, -0.08577420562505722, 0.04071896895766258, 0.014080019667744637, 0.016285588964819908, 0.08329398185014725, 0.006174751557409763, -0.009986787103116512, -0.015128977596759796, -0.028636399656534195, 0.03281104192137718, -0.01207929290831089, 0.004507296718657017, -0.044914256781339645, -0.08733534812927246, 0.0038148844614624977, 0.05170055478811264, 0.10840753465890884, -0.02046794444322586, 0.057827893644571304, 0.027476539835333824, -0.01627945899963379, -0.10529318451881409, 0.01921500451862812, -0.00023925343703012913, 0.02090276964008808, 0.00385453924536705, -0.025185173377394676, 0.0023713288828730583, -0.07097076624631882, -0.01705588772892952, 0.08469615131616592, 0.048536282032728195, 0.00026094194618053734, -0.004467113874852657, 0.07925276458263397, 0.11432728171348572, 0.06693756580352783, -0.04260915517807007, 0.0058690994046628475, -0.07379462569952011, 0.007755126338452101, 0.022440236061811447, -0.09119532257318497, 0.01842695288360119, -0.022503208369016647, 0.17308993637561798, 0.05687052384018898, -0.008389018476009369, 0.031854528933763504, -0.08390998840332031, 0.009022350423038006, 0.03976481780409813, -0.00603698892518878, -0.03478662669658661, 0.03895540162920952, 0.025047142058610916, -0.035143159329891205, 0.05920550227165222, 0.041396964341402054, -0.03390869125723839, -0.01257245521992445, -0.02168331854045391, -0.05049854516983032, -0.009768770076334476, -0.018593141809105873, -0.04705293849110603, -0.052249372005462646, 0.07330403476953506, -0.04402664303779602, -0.0016317550325766206, -0.02190437726676464, -0.011990955099463463, 0.020083867013454437, 0.038821544498205185, 0.01189613901078701, -0.02471228502690792, -0.017159106209874153, 0.07604315876960754, 0.019144641235470772, -0.07679294049739838, 0.019380390644073486, 0.001326169935055077, -0.0208298172801733, -0.04085114598274231, 0.06065870821475983, -0.03774413466453552, -0.0950736254453659, 0.02209516242146492, -0.06116606295108795, 0.034875884652137756, 0.027608443051576614, -0.0078348433598876, 0.10669765621423721, 0.007358618080615997, -0.027503658086061478, 0.027499038726091385, 0.052434761077165604, 0.04021027311682701, 0.056191667914390564, 0.014789334498345852, 0.04295295476913452, 0.07918219268321991, 0.027452195063233376, -0.030707722529768944, -0.01693098247051239, -0.002452589338645339, -0.037526097148656845, 0.025682898238301277, 0.08315125107765198, 0.053112875670194626, -0.025668727234005928, 0.0470762625336647, 0.01883450709283352, -0.004109365865588188, 0.025519341230392456, 0.03735372796654701, 0.0034307725727558136, 0.026850320398807526, 0.04884771630167961, -0.00892296340316534, -0.04765785112977028 ]
292
292
Feature Reinforcement Learning: Part I: Unstructured MDPs
General-purpose, intelligent, learning agents cycle through sequences of observations, actions, and rewards that are complex, uncertain, unknown, and non-Markovian. On the other hand, reinforcement learning is well-developed for small finite state Markov decision processes (MDPs). Up to now, extracting the right state representations out of bare observations, that is, reducing the general agent setup to the MDP framework, is an art that involves significant effort by designers. The primary goal of this work is to automate the reduction process and thereby significantly expand the scope of many existing reinforcement learning algorithms and the agents that employ them. Before we can think of mechanizing this search for suitable MDPs, we need a formal objective criterion. The main contribution of this article is to develop such a criterion. I also integrate the various parts into one learning algorithm. Extensions to more realistic dynamic Bayesian networks are developed in Part II. The role of POMDPs is also considered there.
[ -0.05189768224954605, -0.09689388424158096, 0.07381682842969894, 0.0056130713783204556, 0.026292741298675537, -0.13843181729316711, -0.03671412169933319, 0.021653028205037117, -0.02502330020070076, 0.01563861407339573, 0.014855006709694862, -0.0668664276599884, 0.02309543825685978, 0.04948318749666214, 0.02359061688184738, -0.022687159478664398, -0.021285530179739, -0.0438210591673851, 0.03587716445326805, -0.03185121715068817, 0.07737553119659424, 0.003540536155924201, -0.01831999234855175, 0.004271714016795158, -0.0033607117366045713, 0.049490392208099365, -0.04068027436733246, -0.031892549246549606, 0.02877342700958252, 0.03897039592266083, -0.03117835894227028, -0.018040021881461143, 0.003633322659879923, 0.004969990812242031, 0.017302127555012703, -0.03193770721554756, -0.03233927860856056, -0.045486707240343094, -0.07599832862615585, -0.010266819037497044, -0.0379050076007843, -0.05293652042746544, -0.002890471601858735, 0.027371065691113472, 0.05661413446068764, 0.07608924061059952, 0.04464845731854439, -0.015031632035970688, 0.024436457082629204, 0.06924272328615189, -0.09060090780258179, 0.030602402985095978, -0.03450695797801018, -0.06712806969881058, -0.007831957191228867, 0.048570793122053146, -0.03282031789422035, -0.01379851158708334, -0.052902232855558395, -0.05627624690532684, 0.018016189336776733, 0.04546207934617996, 0.0017263413174077868, 0.014944931492209435, -0.035944052040576935, -0.0402328297495842, -0.05419028550386429, 0.031818848103284836, 0.0040807644836604595, -0.015185500495135784, 0.06732812523841858, -0.04865150526165962, 0.03217461332678795, 0.0342659130692482, 0.005949442274868488, 0.046141624450683594, -0.03519110009074211, 0.06199588626623154, -0.02329922281205654, 0.11972565203905106, -0.06945531070232391, 0.1012190729379654, -0.05387553200125694, 0.06653933972120285, -0.04358769208192825, 0.029657498002052307, -0.0412178598344326, -0.03473694249987602, 0.0009139163885265589, 0.008556987158954144, -0.03381970897316933, -0.002873343648388982, -0.07074522227048874, -0.025693876668810844, -0.014041442424058914, 0.05496358126401901, -0.09949959069490433, 0.04088345170021057, -0.04845016449689865, 0.03464212268590927, 0.04003552719950676, -0.027145566418766975, 0.04333805292844772, 0.04334656894207001, -0.018825402483344078, 0.010164718143641949, 0.014917709864675999, 0.023953735828399658, 0.030737699940800667, -0.0370701439678669, 0.08440729975700378, 0.03972002491354942, -0.03361279144883156, -0.012588202953338623, -0.055976420640945435, 0.035311613231897354, -0.019403629004955292, 0.09272164851427078, 0.051921866834163666, 0.10025711357593536, -0.03458818048238754, -0.033586535602808, -0.05959378555417061, -0.008202532306313515, 0.07449396699666977, -0.10097652673721313, -0.0003915612178388983, -0.029131578281521797, 0.07795447111129761, -0.0040680100210011005, 0.015849309042096138, -0.023373443633317947, 0.032285336405038834, -0.1411042958498001, -0.043265897780656815, 0.01935417950153351, 0.004410631954669952, -0.10525698214769363, -0.020893000066280365, 0.037567753344774246, 0.02013479918241501, 0.029755739495158195, -0.0014229153748601675, -0.038436729460954666, -0.06480952352285385, 0.0003752688062377274, 0.023600807413458824, 0.023205356672406197, -0.007921341806650162, 0.032990243285894394, -0.015361261554062366, -0.012822767719626427, -0.00919512938708067, 0.06125390902161598, -0.007501441985368729, -0.007380071561783552, -0.03737428039312363, -0.03758738562464714, -0.015577215701341629, 0.052566297352313995, 0.021324336528778076, 0.04520266875624657, -0.002633871277794242, 0.04722160845994949, 0.03916999697685242, -0.006636171601712704, -0.0809616893529892, 0.02221173420548439, -0.04185393452644348, -0.09731961786746979, -0.08571429550647736, -0.014980126172304153, 0.007939626462757587, 0.050206273794174194, -0.003453869139775634, -0.04861699417233467, -0.014986135996878147, 0.015600442886352539, 0.01039281114935875, -0.04694001376628876, -0.025078127160668373, -0.03884079307317734, -0.022361064329743385, -0.040393006056547165, 0.012219884432852268, -0.016272664070129395, 0.0016990876756608486, -0.027025168761610985, 0.041792288422584534, 0.008990534581243992, -0.058174941688776016, -0.004376055207103491, 0.002465905388817191, -0.0036318115890026093, -0.001607821206562221, -0.0007817433215677738, -0.0070242020301520824, 0.006762273609638214, 0.02187473513185978, 0.04361740127205849, 0.07240770757198334, 0.003092935075983405, -0.025140203535556793, -0.007708489894866943, -0.06257552653551102, 0.07031663507223129, 0.020765913650393486, -0.01470413338392973, 0.010956517420709133, -0.009648320265114307, 0.02078063413500786, 0.018526732921600342, -0.061968717724084854, -0.01610351912677288, 0.08247874677181244, -0.05220227688550949, -0.0070213922299444675, -0.09785006195306778, 0.03998162969946861, 0.004249560181051493, -0.007069298066198826, 0.028083184733986855, 0.02292553521692753, 0.040632009506225586, -0.07069199532270432, -0.02285202033817768, 0.04390387237071991, -0.0659274309873581, -0.05652156099677086, 0.05282781273126602, -0.017688127234578133, -0.02557886205613613, 0.008856863714754581, -0.015883173793554306, -0.0228826105594635, 0.054981544613838196, -0.013204388320446014, -0.03221026435494423, -0.010604738257825375, -0.016846084967255592, -0.015058023855090141, 0.09605595469474792, 0.030269917100667953, -0.0891704112291336, 0.05729612335562706, -0.0026754869613796473, 0.008468566462397575, -0.015750525519251823, -0.05090310797095299, -0.0347919836640358, -0.009023120626807213, 0.02047889679670334, -0.017431121319532394, 0.026071585714817047, 0.009287901222705841, 0.0023774802684783936, 0.016758685931563377, 0.048792097717523575, 0.06098419055342674, -0.009097414091229439, -0.06062030792236328, 0.010216602124273777, -0.038868967443704605, 0.07360971719026566, 0.0571756474673748, 0.03630674257874489, 0.024235334247350693, 0.048513613641262054, 0.03462783992290497, -0.015359408222138882, 0.003764319233596325, 0.002871617441996932, -0.024622099474072456, 0.08484604954719543, -0.017036650329828262, -0.025815170258283615, 0.005117394030094147, 0.02343994379043579, 0.025960464030504227, -0.051671843975782394, -0.08874175697565079, -0.017524151131510735, 0.02841571718454361, 0.02536364644765854, 0.06055296212434769, 0.062421735376119614, 0.04234199970960617, 0.05652572214603424, 0.04697789251804352, 0.025217188522219658, -0.0594656802713871, -0.02113274671137333, -0.04067528247833252, 0.030560128390789032, 0.0645722821354866, -0.061454225331544876, -0.005454611033201218, -0.03434017673134804, -0.030317379161715508, -0.03187426179647446, 0.0022067890968173742, -0.04430418461561203, 0.07366161048412323, 0.00205548875965178, -0.010237823240458965, 0.07836729288101196, 0.01754182204604149, 0.030665382742881775, -0.033146388828754425, 0.044099509716033936, 0.0672357901930809, 0.059750866144895554, -0.049354348331689835, 0.010123390704393387, 0.05159303545951843, -0.02312999591231346, -0.038960400968790054, 0.0164234209805727, -0.056423723697662354, 0.016283616423606873, -0.027196940034627914, -0.008245712146162987, 0.05153822526335716, 0.03602946549654007, -0.053539976477622986, -0.005802633240818977, -0.012988953851163387, 0.06779095530509949, -0.035917118191719055, 0.04959879815578461, -0.08960437774658203, -0.02444792538881302, 0.01931692846119404, 0.08915780484676361, -0.04915051907300949, -0.01343153789639473, -0.10568692535161972, -0.03551018610596657, 0.05553172901272774, 0.04821961745619774, -0.028579922392964363, -0.14872384071350098, -0.03952192887663841, -0.029540983960032463, 0.07626613229513168, 0.05945425108075142, 0.06835506111383438, -0.01786132901906967, -0.023667581379413605, 0.05345440283417702, -0.00023857533233240247, 0.005880407989025116, -0.022601211443543434, 0.10336337983608246, -0.033822398632764816, -0.026441002264618874, 0.022615456953644753, -0.006422584876418114, 0.00415628869086504, 0.02644067443907261, -0.07814347743988037, -0.020105812698602676, -0.007482490036636591, -0.0038452029693871737, -0.03169538080692291, 0.028171014040708542, -0.013846936635673046, 0.0040186261758208275, -0.022067485377192497, -0.029533840715885162, 0.014193728566169739, 0.019957097247242928, 0.06309159845113754, -0.013096475042402744, 0.07817430794239044, -0.04376021772623062, 0.09056276828050613, 0.020372670143842697, -0.010804329067468643, 0.09702509641647339, -0.06915603578090668, -0.01596766710281372, -0.010343915782868862, -0.05812406912446022, -0.06590916216373444, -0.025832686573266983, -0.034895699471235275, 0.0015647225081920624, 0.04767999053001404, -0.06075664609670639, -0.05259305611252785, 0.016339916735887527, 0.01538420282304287, 0.02548433095216751, -0.020397372543811798, -0.050605058670043945, 0.06233201548457146, 0.006082797423005104, -0.02580723725259304, 0.009942968375980854, 0.046665433794260025, -0.033362552523612976, 0.0472954586148262, -0.04426584392786026, -0.0503968670964241, 0.0015432595973834395, 0.042359478771686554, 0.04679098725318909, -0.015819111838936806, 0.06750059872865677, 0.05954127013683319, 0.05714743584394455, 0.0027592822443693876, -0.06972668319940567, -0.0015837082173675299, 0.03560785949230194, 0.02188858576118946, 0.04859009012579918, 0.0011183819733560085, -0.06873053312301636, -0.04834223538637161, -0.0502614751458168, 0.007304885424673557, 0.013253221288323402, -0.04614243283867836, -0.02194235660135746, 0.04344216734170914, 0.050018325448036194, 0.003073192434385419, 0.020160671323537827, 0.005899463780224323, -0.05972447991371155, -0.05418868362903595, -0.0021710011642426252, 0.01703261211514473, -0.03891811519861221, -0.019128210842609406, 0.018018772825598717, 0.0009823384461924434, -0.0011835318291559815, -0.017653442919254303, 0.02470228634774685, 0.028986727818846703, 0.006874679122120142, 0.05268245190382004, 0.05688778683543205, 0.01796102710068226, 0.0037747444584965706, 0.031455148011446, 0.022167429327964783, -0.019168337807059288, 0.06655377894639969, 0.13679125905036926, -0.01987258531153202, 0.02121332660317421, 0.005287880543619394, 0.0433446541428566, -0.0009810335468500853, 0.11749830842018127, 0.03454318270087242, -0.028196144849061966, -0.016844280064105988, 0.030767465010285378, 0.01267441175878048, -0.037934545427560806, -0.030006183311343193, 0.011323985643684864, -0.007696441374719143, 0.09777002781629562, 0.0019574761390686035, -0.051115330308675766, 0.0344880148768425, 0.009595823474228382, 0.0015037179691717029, -0.03327539935708046, 0.03036186657845974, 0.009533041156828403, -0.03530324622988701, -0.022146813571453094, -0.0355338416993618, 0.06223517656326294, 0.08390385657548904, -0.002533798571676016, 0.03901601955294609, 0.030549393966794014, 0.03722301125526428, -0.0032776878215372562, -0.0335656963288784, 0.0375281497836113, 0.019118908792734146, -0.0015471052611246705, -0.0740223154425621, 0.03283631429076195, -0.0019619064405560493, -0.015400939621031284, -0.044731542468070984, 0.015991467982530594, -0.022570602595806122, 0.07463743537664413, 0.012853830121457577, 0.05382265895605087, -0.04648939147591591, 0.02927410788834095, 0.038487184792757034, 0.0767635926604271, 0.01587197743356228, 0.018658768385648727, 0.011322380043566227, 0.00869906134903431, 0.0575065016746521, -0.09524508565664291, 0.06123774126172066 ]
293
293
Large-Margin kNN Classification Using a Deep Encoder Network
KNN is one of the most popular classification methods, but it often fails to work well with inappropriate choice of distance metric or due to the presence of numerous class-irrelevant features. Linear feature transformation methods have been widely applied to extract class-relevant information to improve kNN classification, which is very limited in many applications. Kernels have been used to learn powerful non-linear feature transformations, but these methods fail to scale to large datasets. In this paper, we present a scalable non-linear feature mapping method based on a deep neural network pretrained with restricted boltzmann machines for improving kNN classification in a large-margin framework, which we call DNet-kNN. DNet-kNN can be used for both classification and for supervised dimensionality reduction. The experimental results on two benchmark handwritten digit datasets show that DNet-kNN has much better performance than large-margin kNN using a linear mapping and kNN based on a deep autoencoder pretrained with retricted boltzmann machines.
[ -0.05015689134597778, -0.13060037791728973, 0.023218663409352303, -0.09152037650346756, -0.018842991441488266, -0.051619019359350204, -0.0059234886430203915, -0.031951095908880234, -0.07605224847793579, 0.016069360077381134, -0.011791693978011608, 0.017143890261650085, -0.03173283860087395, 0.06560806930065155, -0.0027831224724650383, 0.028247302398085594, 0.09731796383857727, 0.03461126610636711, 0.09637262672185898, -0.038233432918787, 0.030875641852617264, -0.01487808022648096, -0.06038125231862068, -0.07991211861371994, 0.02164568565785885, 0.02318939007818699, -0.030992047861218452, -0.04645627364516258, -0.05560030788183212, 0.021541668102145195, 0.012014100328087807, -0.026351140812039375, 0.014966788701713085, -0.03547908365726471, -0.068571537733078, -0.03410613164305687, 0.015343844890594482, 0.0379837229847908, 0.013075221329927444, -0.032749369740486145, 0.008998382836580276, 0.04709519073367119, 0.0038507753051817417, -0.0376674123108387, 0.038913384079933167, 0.04117155820131302, -0.006931369658559561, -0.03750591725111008, 0.005746588576585054, 0.0333782359957695, -0.0684681087732315, 0.07001540064811707, -0.018794655799865723, 0.023386090993881226, 0.004532456863671541, 0.07528617233037949, -0.018537504598498344, -0.016450367867946625, 0.03223072364926338, 0.005772239528596401, 0.022037742659449577, -0.009483630768954754, -0.006245408207178116, 0.044385287910699844, 0.018469860777258873, -0.018275240436196327, -0.047499898821115494, -0.019693240523338318, -0.04339306801557541, 0.008765106089413166, 0.0423920638859272, -0.002835867926478386, -0.05480993539094925, 0.09745492786169052, 0.055933285504579544, -0.001259134034626186, -0.00838554184883833, -0.016169466078281403, 0.1211409643292427, 0.042211465537548065, -0.018223611637949944, 0.06217242032289505, -0.0036975862458348274, 0.04571137949824333, -0.00721491314470768, 0.028876395896077156, 0.02432459220290184, -0.023355286568403244, -0.029742872342467308, -0.008138515055179596, -0.034984149038791656, 0.04884035140275955, -0.04279423505067825, -0.0068724690936505795, -0.018641307950019836, -0.050883688032627106, 0.009523366577923298, -0.04425628483295441, 0.006413327530026436, -0.040288250893354416, 0.02614377811551094, 0.009529013186693192, 0.04313812032341957, 0.038391489535570145, -0.023776695132255554, 0.02119586430490017, -0.044645585119724274, 0.04283566027879715, 0.01577596925199032, -0.10813707113265991, 0.024367699399590492, -0.04726923629641533, -0.03439328074455261, 0.01286195870488882, -0.07889409363269806, -0.03329627588391304, 0.00594820873811841, 0.06456976383924484, 0.06347531080245972, -0.04551941901445389, -0.05667140334844589, -0.030547235161066055, 0.07367194443941116, -0.02138548344373703, 0.11266898363828659, -0.09165820479393005, -0.02388451062142849, -0.011929509229958057, 0.09983428567647934, 0.00370239419862628, -0.07296779006719589, 0.012740402482450008, -0.0025658525992184877, 0.02465151436626911, -0.04405461996793747, -0.036340583115816116, -0.006700838916003704, -0.03333866968750954, 0.014351420104503632, 0.01975054293870926, -0.010927248746156693, 0.004995774012058973, -0.00006547150405822322, -0.018192095682024956, 0.02724948525428772, 0.03951401263475418, -0.06465651094913483, -0.030064810067415237, 0.03688153624534607, -0.03923631086945534, 0.021505527198314667, -0.0846795067191124, 0.018307974562048912, -0.06915117055177689, 0.06858649849891663, -0.06192321702837944, -0.06777966767549515, -0.08118249475955963, 0.0233951173722744, 0.06933069974184036, -0.02020789310336113, 0.014840612187981606, 0.002642242470756173, 0.0006606822717003524, -0.004475364461541176, -0.027552738785743713, -0.02635275572538376, 0.010178414173424244, -0.007839284837245941, -0.03934776410460472, -0.061639007180929184, -0.008102397434413433, -0.001171380514279008, 0.04511868581175804, 0.011856603436172009, -0.004303880501538515, -0.04723287746310234, 0.06719773262739182, -0.03099994920194149, 0.005315704271197319, -0.004520205315202475, -0.05099188908934593, 0.0264731477946043, 0.04867887496948242, 0.02459036372601986, 0.06156379356980324, -0.004093948286026716, -0.010784470476210117, 0.007581746205687523, -0.04028159752488136, 0.001557897194288671, 0.003692390862852335, 0.028006836771965027, 0.02053980343043804, -0.05422307178378105, 0.08116724342107773, -0.038379836827516556, -0.06931567192077637, 0.07650066167116165, 0.06151441112160683, 0.028634123504161835, -0.03553418070077896, -0.05313047766685486, -0.03984978422522545, -0.03390687704086304, 0.01776617206633091, 0.05742301791906357, -0.04420066252350807, -0.05976724624633789, -0.035628680139780045, 0.02742139622569084, -0.03422984108328819, 0.027129586786031723, 0.08031462132930756, -0.002746154088526964, -0.07797551155090332, -0.06273051351308823, -0.011557303369045258, 0.07979138195514679, 0.05687839537858963, -0.049782369285821915, 0.022137483581900597, -0.019246166571974754, 0.09688844531774521, -0.06964294612407684, 0.013353811576962471, 0.005401101894676685, -0.041231006383895874, -0.09097229689359665, 0.014901550486683846, -0.006796189583837986, -0.03387262299656868, 0.0028908944223076105, -0.06011669337749481, 0.02274802140891552, 0.013987023383378983, -0.08479513972997665, 0.07472660392522812, -0.030962884426116943, -0.03924579918384552, 0.005570119712501764, 0.0023595793172717094, -0.0697832703590393, -0.06087664142251015, -0.021264255046844482, -0.027108805254101753, 0.04742511734366417, 0.015892673283815384, 0.03720229119062424, -0.01686805486679077, -0.030391592532396317, 0.0496002621948719, 0.017030807211995125, -0.034101903438568115, -0.01714259758591652, 0.040988583117723465, -0.010725737549364567, 0.04034200683236122, 0.09460079669952393, 0.04202468693256378, 0.033026453107595444, 0.034161534160375595, -0.02536480501294136, -0.04636938124895096, 0.06720230728387833, 0.06947867572307587, 0.019953131675720215, 0.020846307277679443, -0.019219541922211647, 0.04065299406647682, 0.01336169894784689, -0.055437974631786346, 0.02334858477115631, 0.03756583109498024, -0.09771163016557693, -0.0045681120827794075, -0.0026044922415167093, 0.04910871386528015, 0.029307343065738678, -0.050433166325092316, 0.0070854369550943375, 0.06375410407781601, -0.07808240503072739, 0.024609843268990517, 0.003937859553843737, 0.017815107479691505, -0.007592882961034775, 0.05637838691473007, 0.04430835321545601, 0.04709409549832344, 0.008554326370358467, 0.05858131870627403, -0.0858924388885498, -0.08229941874742508, 0.0200608279556036, -0.08639805018901825, 0.11626293510198593, -0.03312423452734947, -0.011808838695287704, 0.0188511423766613, 0.05504779517650604, 0.011807234957814217, 0.033345676958560944, 0.0034730653278529644, -0.0390256866812706, 0.07162782549858093, 0.03635895252227783, 0.07299196720123291, -0.05086645856499672, -0.017712177708745003, 0.007208990398794413, -0.02749563567340374, 0.03023802675306797, -0.06989165395498276, -0.013327151536941528, -0.024908849969506264, 0.01866772025823593, 0.04457797482609749, 0.009848624467849731, 0.027008499950170517, 0.0795658603310585, 0.02974742092192173, -0.04060111939907074, -0.007860930636525154, -0.01491091400384903, -0.006175437942147255, -0.05231164023280144, 0.11836864799261093, -0.05306174233555794, -0.07658261805772781, -0.08909380435943604, -0.053517963737249374, -0.032540664076805115, -0.002193339867517352, -0.0012884902535006404, -0.0002557703119236976, -0.0154914865270257, -0.008518737740814686, -0.01853429339826107, 0.03326517343521118, -0.061632540076971054, -0.004477875307202339, -0.026363270357251167, 0.0281565859913826, -0.000682121841236949, 0.04993410035967827, -0.015911316499114037, -0.025460219010710716, 0.04240822792053223, 0.05179983377456665, -0.020548729225993156, 0.07770946621894836, -0.044214699417352676, 0.03422679379582405, 0.06398168951272964, 0.005146875511854887, 0.09338304400444031, -0.04756953939795494, -0.02132600173354149, -0.009457405656576157, 0.007788080722093582, 0.05773087218403816, -0.08100321143865585, -0.003764046123251319, 0.051141396164894104, 0.07944586873054504, 0.004780166316777468, 0.07205245643854141, 0.007983089424669743, -0.03186863288283348, 0.02046968787908554, 0.06264346092939377, -0.027910327538847923, 0.0070663257502019405, 0.032443802803754807, -0.07281317561864853, 0.021392062306404114, 0.015422883443534374, 0.10106060653924942, -0.002494764979928732, -0.07322344183921814, -0.004328278824687004, -0.005199482664465904, 0.06256730109453201, -0.040010396391153336, 0.008191458880901337, -0.0024159241002053022, 0.02810508757829666, 0.028576672077178955, 0.00005045194848207757, 0.010522624477744102, -0.03219222277402878, -0.0423705130815506, -0.025102967396378517, 0.0342266708612442, -0.033854030072689056, -0.00649596843868494, 0.019406184554100037, 0.03877168521285057, 0.003697972046211362, -0.06621485203504562, -0.017784280702471733, -0.04171197861433029, -0.047514162957668304, -0.10576988011598587, -0.040068987756967545, -0.04467948153614998, 0.08746158331632614, 0.009130029007792473, -0.05154598131775856, -0.0032461434602737427, 0.01820436120033264, -0.029789958149194717, -0.0363653227686882, 0.021842075511813164, 0.037858717143535614, -0.013622989878058434, -0.035956308245658875, -0.024183882400393486, -0.06846838444471359, -0.044689130038022995, 0.05009067803621292, 0.06521610915660858, 0.002504267729818821, -0.08873290568590164, 0.04911647364497185, 0.03479735180735588, -0.0011192172532901168, -0.021736612543463707, 0.04632002115249634, -0.036877840757369995, 0.034355953335762024, -0.0758202001452446, -0.05471331626176834, 0.058934424072504044, 0.039023589342832565, 0.01521007064729929, -0.07132717967033386, 0.013548830524086952, 0.03848859667778015, 0.014841803349554539, -0.036286938935518265, 0.007981565780937672, 0.016136465594172478, -0.0026513386983424425, 0.05051961541175842, 0.06838102638721466, -0.03296015039086342, 0.014944157563149929, 0.01606670208275318, 0.058971039950847626, -0.015589342452585697, 0.025228895246982574, -0.1010628417134285, -0.00825406052172184, -0.07028442621231079, -0.05022413283586502, 0.005302291363477707, 0.01007706020027399, -0.04119716212153435, -0.007879587821662426, -0.04659752920269966, 0.05128492787480354, 0.01606200449168682, -0.023749222978949547, 0.01606663316488266, -0.026730166748166084, -0.009862287901341915, 0.029362108558416367, 0.010488978587090969, -0.020259922370314598, 0.028101395815610886, 0.09508401155471802, 0.00793878547847271, 0.03458377718925476, -0.047295358031988144, 0.0651128888130188, -0.05785290151834488, -0.03140830993652344, -0.011016040109097958, -0.058410800993442535, 0.029506409540772438, -0.03699667379260063, -0.04333548620343208, 0.012130203656852245, -0.03431200608611107, -0.0003155714657623321, 0.03650736063718796, 0.010548992082476616, 0.008991703391075134, 0.027897395193576813, 0.0019347146153450012, 0.03320228308439255, 0.04892340302467346, -0.038321394473314285, -0.04189540818333626, -0.004831288941204548, 0.0025063136126846075, 0.021519578993320465, 0.06702666729688644, 0.02382616326212883, -0.006904734764248133, 0.005753869656473398, 0.029805010184645653, 0.002893699798732996, 0.012005471624433994, -0.06182006001472473, -0.05442298948764801, 0.06267453730106354, 0.06096085533499718, -0.07297351211309433, 0.005749284755438566 ]
294
294
Matrix Completion from Noisy Entries
Given a matrix M of low-rank, we consider the problem of reconstructing it from noisy observations of a small, random subset of its entries. The problem arises in a variety of applications, from collaborative filtering (the `Netflix problem') to structure-from-motion and positioning. We study a low complexity algorithm introduced by Keshavan et al.(2009), based on a combination of spectral techniques and manifold optimization, that we call here OptSpace. We prove performance guarantees that are order-optimal in a number of circumstances.
[ 0.027545634657144547, -0.06913667172193527, 0.04808155074715614, -0.04320698231458664, -0.017663070932030678, -0.046796366572380066, 0.019431961700320244, 0.01526237465441227, -0.08096065372228622, 0.04086649417877197, 0.0439005047082901, -0.04961249604821205, -0.03109182044863701, 0.06040773168206215, -0.06734154373407364, -0.07020498812198639, -0.02883736602962017, 0.013722131960093975, 0.029201284050941467, -0.05736715719103813, -0.07065655291080475, -0.021227950230240822, -0.010220583528280258, -0.026968514546751976, -0.08775202184915543, 0.026760563254356384, -0.08143728971481323, 0.001705039176158607, -0.037553612142801285, -0.04152398183941841, 0.009970402345061302, 0.027631670236587524, 0.01522237341850996, 0.03936569765210152, -0.02905610017478466, 0.004761591088026762, 0.04386081174015999, 0.03003782033920288, -0.056163061410188675, -0.01539812795817852, -0.005149438511580229, 0.03990255668759346, 0.010515286587178707, -0.003042536089196801, 0.0071070073172450066, 0.06969118863344193, 0.013422369956970215, -0.0067873140797019005, 0.026232950389385223, 0.08115186542272568, -0.010540884919464588, 0.0286561269313097, -0.018443817272782326, 0.07389834523200989, -0.05333646014332771, 0.02433769963681698, -0.060684558004140854, 0.02984488010406494, 0.02794865146279335, -0.01129058562219143, 0.03743338957428932, 0.09034038335084915, -0.00856025516986847, -0.016407350078225136, 0.00025153375463560224, -0.03102024830877781, -0.023113025352358818, 0.016431016847491264, -0.061620358377695084, 0.007128316443413496, -0.01895183138549328, -0.08015495538711548, 0.014771501533687115, 0.019691694527864456, 0.04503064975142479, 0.06268548220396042, 0.057668279856443405, 0.03829155117273331, 0.020679116249084473, 0.08920184522867203, -0.047025326639413834, 0.0401303768157959, 0.027915799990296364, 0.05931971222162247, -0.04277464747428894, 0.05025244876742363, -0.009381777606904507, -0.0036570229567587376, 0.02209216170012951, 0.037761133164167404, -0.01671627350151539, -0.03012954816222191, -0.05652758106589317, 0.07033266127109528, -0.008498608134686947, -0.014641767367720604, -0.010089431889355183, 0.003522551618516445, -0.022149842232465744, 0.08024902641773224, 0.006516908295452595, 0.05782192945480347, 0.06996429711580276, 0.08269771188497543, -0.054508276283741, 0.0057332636788487434, -0.07267758995294571, 0.009686523117125034, 0.023718390613794327, -0.02360679768025875, 0.007067242171615362, -0.021426523104310036, -0.007488539908081293, 0.025512106716632843, -0.027736425399780273, 0.02673938311636448, -0.03202066570520401, 0.03749559074640274, -0.08281329274177551, 0.023971784859895706, 0.027812901884317398, -0.005014112219214439, -0.08246509730815887, 0.05456974729895592, 0.022445455193519592, -0.036053139716386795, 0.05252481624484062, -0.018504410982131958, 0.08059649169445038, -0.0008272931445389986, -0.10030654072761536, 0.027364304289221764, 0.029460053890943527, -0.00964419823139906, -0.09637175500392914, 0.0034113144502043724, -0.015880847349762917, -0.027679534628987312, -0.04049713537096977, 0.0955197662115097, 0.06168799847364426, -0.08179600536823273, -0.020914345979690552, -0.03881971165537834, 0.03944934532046318, -0.03201017528772354, 0.003945276141166687, 0.057472772896289825, -0.034089796245098114, -0.03133513778448105, -0.061499904841184616, -0.0397489070892334, 0.017667075619101524, 0.009201097302138805, 0.005847305059432983, -0.06306266039609909, -0.06110009923577309, -0.07950856536626816, -0.05080268532037735, 0.029718898236751556, -0.07824721187353134, 0.04696199670433998, -0.01872321590781212, 0.018833084031939507, -0.01750287227332592, -0.0499727688729763, -0.013945871964097023, -0.010143800638616085, 0.01214631274342537, -0.042871203273534775, 0.0071364156901836395, 0.011803267523646355, -0.033392779529094696, 0.05703234300017357, -0.004374311771243811, 0.03077142871916294, -0.05584866181015968, 0.017342086881399155, -0.012963714078068733, -0.03638310730457306, 0.046405449509620667, -0.023205433040857315, -0.056410230696201324, 0.021518848836421967, 0.022720688953995705, 0.0754837915301323, 0.047231972217559814, 0.041825369000434875, 0.09288094192743301, 0.05323534086346626, 0.024853596463799477, -0.013694333843886852, 0.07420557737350464, -0.04849814996123314, 0.0035407659597694874, 0.06403897702693939, 0.002680371515452862, 0.017816659063100815, 0.04581538960337639, 0.06623706966638565, 0.06668362766504288, 0.052494630217552185, 0.010489294305443764, -0.08121055364608765, -0.06115390732884407, -0.026102062314748764, -0.0024610511027276516, -0.0009396169916726649, 0.03344874829053879, -0.04961647838354111, 0.050160959362983704, -0.04243070259690285, 0.007307341322302818, -0.014798138290643692, -0.007794426288455725, -0.015313510783016682, 0.013954903930425644, -0.017334453761577606, 0.011286797001957893, 0.05326653644442558, -0.0772765576839447, 0.0670444667339325, -0.029754638671875, 0.02212192676961422, -0.05754022300243378, 0.003590785665437579, 0.039161503314971924, -0.007913853973150253, -0.04268074408173561, 0.028376247733831406, -0.00623311148956418, -0.058496471494436264, 0.0019789529033005238, 0.019568519666790962, 0.005795234348624945, 0.04649942368268967, 0.03860027343034744, -0.023032963275909424, -0.021341733634471893, -0.02429494634270668, 0.04505136236548424, 0.02451992779970169, 0.0443345345556736, -0.06388495862483978, -0.039457302540540695, -0.024314066395163536, 0.0049954247660934925, 0.041116002947092056, 0.0056669446639716625, 0.06287863850593567, 0.00465152645483613, 0.006497889291495085, 0.010021486319601536, 0.07215587049722672, 0.01868072897195816, 0.05580152943730354, 0.018517373129725456, 0.045478951185941696, 0.04161454737186432, 0.08136230707168579, 0.04489532485604286, 0.0211492832750082, -0.07392298430204391, 0.06247968226671219, 0.019650835543870926, 0.01977665163576603, -0.020420247688889503, 0.015430772677063942, 0.07097557187080383, 0.023719554767012596, 0.002911325776949525, 0.01113788690418005, -0.04896470904350281, 0.10638131946325302, -0.029068944975733757, 0.02081025205552578, 0.03643236681818962, 0.09681105613708496, -0.053207654505968094, -0.0363171212375164, -0.07403609901666641, 0.05539259314537048, -0.03138335049152374, 0.0003689817385748029, -0.02780659683048725, 0.034205470234155655, 0.06195022910833359, -0.007809297181665897, -0.006353809032589197, 0.055008821189403534, -0.05197989195585251, 0.08405429124832153, -0.08431512862443924, -0.004970970097929239, 0.03961586952209473, -0.05883466824889183, 0.06840304285287857, 0.020662536844611168, 0.021919086575508118, 0.013346499763429165, 0.03493514657020569, -0.054684799164533615, -0.005435990635305643, -0.050901830196380615, 0.028665287420153618, -0.016532020643353462, 0.11079016327857971, 0.009071367792785168, 0.04022921994328499, -0.001768256421200931, -0.03381940722465515, -0.010649989359080791, -0.06070341542363167, -0.02268907241523266, 0.021853797137737274, -0.002980615245178342, 0.023611271753907204, -0.031540900468826294, -0.021456588059663773, 0.017151113599538803, 0.020139094442129135, -0.04606367275118828, 0.030229121446609497, -0.01738998480141163, -0.10183632373809814, -0.10790977627038956, -0.0034866526257246733, 0.0018544059712439775, -0.02201448194682598, -0.025182966142892838, -0.04051750525832176, 0.008467739447951317, -0.04547806829214096, 0.11273758113384247, 0.06801661103963852, -0.044429630041122437, -0.04202273488044739, -0.03199524059891701, 0.006241741590201855, -0.02836715243756771, 0.007618007715791464, -0.09834113717079163, -0.004240100737661123, 0.037115272134542465, 0.09157375991344452, 0.07466589659452438, 0.07193135470151901, -0.018406592309474945, 0.04025740548968315, 0.02778605744242668, -0.03984357416629791, 0.046191029250621796, -0.01183284167200327, 0.039312489330768585, 0.010035397484898567, 0.04028380289673805, 0.09814639389514923, 0.04262099787592888, -0.032057441771030426, 0.024684961885213852, -0.0024492822121828794, 0.00028027858934365213, -0.022346340119838715, 0.016649557277560234, 0.008147479966282845, 0.022623317316174507, -0.046218954026699066, 0.0025599028449505568, -0.06564094871282578, 0.004049916286021471, 0.04387176036834717, -0.03308601677417755, 0.0208258219063282, 0.0019445737125352025, 0.06754308938980103, -0.04709363728761673, 0.07254254817962646, -0.04325165972113609, -0.046442098915576935, 0.03538372740149498, -0.037351079285144806, 0.02779836393892765, -0.022888509556651115, 0.0006702256505377591, 0.01898115687072277, 0.04921126365661621, -0.07697676867246628, 0.0072721075266599655, 0.02083345502614975, 0.028682207688689232, -0.016300760209560394, 0.04124821722507477, 0.04791655391454697, -0.010158604010939598, 0.07202455401420593, 0.035498786717653275, 0.030340852215886116, -0.06491775065660477, -0.012805510312318802, -0.0012620668858289719, 0.06055949255824089, 0.05402824282646179, -0.04365056753158569, -0.10672596842050552, -0.08070947229862213, 0.012221559882164001, -0.0030063893646001816, 0.02183564007282257, -0.02816775254905224, 0.07592163980007172, 0.036456990987062454, 0.009996619075536728, -0.0010712258517742157, 0.028807923197746277, -0.03208429738879204, -0.002958865836262703, -0.013501674868166447, -0.005469216499477625, -0.002379289362579584, -0.018686622381210327, -0.013570243492722511, -0.03650937229394913, -0.023125555366277695, -0.004801579285413027, -0.015640240162611008, -0.023744747042655945, 0.032007984817028046, 0.033077023923397064, -0.0005814228788949549, 0.059855442494153976, -0.06569179147481918, 0.012279679998755455, 0.009920347481966019, 0.00800742395222187, 0.0536423921585083, 0.038467273116111755, -0.012420433573424816, -0.02313297428190708, -0.025818312540650368, 0.065931037068367, -0.0005199791630730033, -0.02393816038966179, -0.10501820594072342, 0.016185292974114418, 0.07246429473161697, 0.015661906450986862, 0.02351517789065838, -0.016143692657351494, 0.052563052624464035, 0.008254161104559898, -0.04685338959097862, -0.00038123395643197, 0.026984015479683876, -0.009224497713148594, -0.046342138200998306, -0.0051905307918787, 0.06190807372331619, 0.02267538011074066, 0.07495513558387756, -0.055952418595552444, -0.01682165637612343, 0.03361916169524193, 0.0200793519616127, -0.016975872218608856, -0.040624260902404785, -0.030110033228993416, 0.0353311188519001, 0.043506428599357605, 0.059132546186447144, 0.0064391628839075565, -0.07828322798013687, 0.02667253650724888, 0.009044262580573559, -0.021504942327737808, -0.004800916183739901, -0.015928978100419044, 0.021575720980763435, -0.052746277302503586, -0.08754283934831619, -0.0647231787443161, 0.03655083104968071, 0.004414395894855261, 0.02112143486738205, -0.014983981847763062, 0.013153957203030586, 0.07636017352342606, -0.035167984664440155, 0.09287972003221512, 0.060600586235523224, 0.02152169682085514, -0.014402905479073524, 0.007706988602876663, 0.07123842090368271, 0.04120304435491562, -0.04852570220828056, -0.08855926990509033, 0.01513247936964035, -0.011005265638232231, 0.0426221638917923, -0.007098758593201637, -0.03357122465968132, -0.07835399359464645, -0.0066966465674340725, 0.0688108503818512, 0.08203612267971039, 0.08464764803647995, 0.0049568465910851955, -0.048127058893442154, -0.05842062458395958, 0.12184188514947891, -0.04493865743279457, -0.0421912707388401 ]
295
295
Bayesian History Reconstruction of Complex Human Gene Clusters on a Phylogeny
Clusters of genes that have evolved by repeated segmental duplication present difficult challenges throughout genomic analysis, from sequence assembly to functional analysis. Improved understanding of these clusters is of utmost importance, since they have been shown to be the source of evolutionary innovation, and have been linked to multiple diseases, including HIV and a variety of cancers. Previously, Zhang et al. (2008) developed an algorithm for reconstructing parsimonious evolutionary histories of such gene clusters, using only human genomic sequence data. In this paper, we propose a probabilistic model for the evolution of gene clusters on a phylogeny, and an MCMC algorithm for reconstruction of duplication histories from genomic sequences in multiple species. Several projects are underway to obtain high quality BAC-based assemblies of duplicated clusters in multiple species, and we anticipate that our method will be useful in analyzing these valuable new data sets.
[ 0.01518110278993845, -0.07103540003299713, 0.04104847088456154, 0.054700467735528946, 0.01044989563524723, -0.03558685630559921, -0.026388036087155342, -0.03830582648515701, 0.04965512081980705, -0.014678827486932278, -0.006906195543706417, -0.08935029804706573, 0.004719561897218227, -0.022443968802690506, -0.07973843067884445, 0.04970414936542511, -0.09135648608207703, -0.02882602997124195, -0.036750394850969315, -0.09450618922710419, 0.04900924488902092, -0.008846738375723362, -0.007843689061701298, 0.05191793665289879, 0.0603991262614727, 0.03843439370393753, -0.02263677679002285, 0.06721524894237518, -0.04578102007508278, -0.05238422006368637, -0.002714143367484212, -0.009942489676177502, 0.02231866680085659, 0.022661801427602768, 0.039246730506420135, 0.0048118880949914455, -0.02106894552707672, 0.04496155306696892, 0.005177972838282585, -0.01100084651261568, -0.007985131815075874, -0.09332095086574554, -0.03837040066719055, 0.04214124381542206, 0.02609795145690441, 0.048160258680582047, 0.07850216329097748, 0.0069295126013457775, -0.011957687325775623, 0.027151577174663544, -0.10599575191736221, 0.11574503779411316, 0.041012685745954514, 0.0014244221383705735, -0.08507174998521805, 0.05293984338641167, -0.04850630834698677, -0.04912100359797478, -0.08970188349485397, 0.004528607241809368, 0.1152481734752655, 0.026306454092264175, -0.05304017290472984, -0.00542404456064105, -0.07008327543735504, 0.010094965808093548, -0.04402080923318863, -0.03174399584531784, -0.013059173710644245, -0.10034799575805664, 0.040899209678173065, 0.004629560746252537, 0.02557547762989998, -0.02581142447888851, 0.012346360832452774, 0.027318807318806648, 0.010140866041183472, -0.02884930931031704, -0.060323212295770645, 0.05411066859960556, 0.01833530329167843, -0.026097185909748077, 0.058645542711019516, 0.0031403969042003155, -0.042836785316467285, -0.008258783258497715, 0.0355096273124218, -0.0006269147270359099, 0.08409193903207779, -0.02165539748966694, -0.06967316567897797, -0.071978859603405, -0.08274959772825241, 0.06998207420110703, -0.06250271946191788, 0.04011564701795578, -0.06666742265224457, -0.010703532956540585, -0.017507966607809067, 0.05702538043260574, 0.008715549483895302, -0.01804087683558464, 0.028369734063744545, 0.018286025151610374, -0.022472580894827843, 0.013601211830973625, -0.10700062662363052, 0.08280237764120102, 0.019679339602589607, -0.06604358553886414, 0.03796781599521637, -0.011008699424564838, -0.009352256543934345, 0.011021511629223824, 0.005129464901983738, 0.05555364489555359, -0.02630762942135334, 0.07079391181468964, 0.022532869130373, -0.06305418163537979, 0.007117927074432373, -0.030907927080988884, -0.06807878613471985, 0.009510907344520092, 0.045139286667108536, -0.029854321852326393, -0.09206607937812805, -0.026051562279462814, 0.0828891173005104, -0.004774804227054119, -0.03329217806458473, 0.04715986177325249, 0.004202323500066996, -0.01825094409286976, -0.08783494681119919, -0.03407900780439377, 0.07051026076078415, 0.03695700690150261, -0.01965656876564026, 0.04417196661233902, 0.03341032564640045, -0.06947066634893417, -0.030480604618787766, 0.06462667137384415, 0.0012662644730880857, -0.0023839748464524746, -0.010209375061094761, 0.03279517963528633, -0.03792236000299454, 0.07442694902420044, -0.08664171397686005, -0.03650926426053047, 0.01808130368590355, -0.03088255040347576, 0.07911479473114014, 0.005828520283102989, -0.014492674730718136, -0.03756434842944145, 0.0015538966981694102, 0.043991927057504654, -0.05932224541902542, 0.08275298029184341, 0.006153574213385582, -0.04175181686878204, 0.0325787253677845, 0.08139872550964355, 0.04933343827724457, 0.02133532613515854, -0.03173284977674484, -0.011620243079960346, 0.041661638766527176, 0.02344583347439766, 0.06773515790700912, 0.04997742548584938, 0.08082010596990585, 0.004600593354552984, -0.010226082056760788, 0.046621859073638916, 0.016428807750344276, 0.050224050879478455, 0.09849047660827637, -0.04558708146214485, -0.060527969151735306, -0.014666822738945484, 0.031446605920791626, 0.07451347261667252, -0.03545674309134483, -0.00248995004221797, 0.006129231303930283, 0.10242382436990738, 0.0006775087094865739, 0.03360870108008385, 0.012135245837271214, -0.05338332802057266, -0.05554434284567833, 0.05769046023488045, -0.02644447796046734, -0.043394532054662704, 0.03817204013466835, 0.03568745404481888, 0.04379557818174362, 0.009521721862256527, 0.008343267254531384, -0.04478706419467926, 0.0114241112023592, 0.04924630746245384, 0.003842692356556654, 0.02869732305407524, 0.010136693716049194, -0.06721354275941849, -0.008558603003621101, 0.03306401148438454, -0.004464125260710716, 0.024060549214482307, -0.009811485186219215, 0.008229728788137436, -0.05321807786822319, -0.06340707838535309, 0.023366199806332588, 0.058551207184791565, 0.0017009658040478826, 0.04603235796093941, -0.007990762591362, 0.05788803845643997, -0.06427109986543655, 0.042671576142311096, 0.011956998147070408, 0.0260532908141613, -0.022771893069148064, 0.005957127083092928, -0.026823431253433228, -0.04336009919643402, -0.029171451926231384, -0.007246752269566059, 0.012909241020679474, 0.10039079189300537, 0.019482681527733803, -0.02388118952512741, 0.010357239283621311, 0.04335913807153702, 0.028622152283787727, 0.04377784952521324, 0.05566587299108505, -0.03171226382255554, 0.04821138456463814, 0.021395964547991753, 0.0635276734828949, 0.05941146984696388, 0.0064951106905937195, 0.020777961239218712, 0.01774420030415058, -0.029708700254559517, -0.06865917891263962, 0.02715471386909485, 0.001033933600410819, 0.018967201933264732, -0.07069993019104004, -0.026244064792990685, 0.04390580952167511, 0.10544943064451218, 0.03213554620742798, 0.06109028682112694, 0.019931834191083908, -0.008740084245800972, 0.06686542183160782, 0.0909174382686615, 0.008678500540554523, 0.007509331218898296, -0.03464818745851517, 0.07342872768640518, 0.015496964566409588, -0.08937778323888779, 0.00011890762107213959, 0.0780264362692833, -0.05386973172426224, -0.09058693796396255, 0.0325799286365509, 0.04967422038316727, 0.01563069596886635, -0.059653595089912415, -0.02396460436284542, 0.0308181531727314, 0.03180215507745743, 0.033444929867982864, -0.01419137418270111, -0.01938832364976406, 0.0156727097928524, 0.05560621619224548, 0.004732568748295307, 0.04343472793698311, 0.030809558928012848, -0.009122082032263279, 0.00008490246545989066, 0.030677247792482376, -0.004817891865968704, -0.003866481827571988, 0.007495270576328039, 0.045288391411304474, 0.07499973475933075, 0.027129342779517174, 0.03919361159205437, -0.01738269068300724, 0.052021343261003494, -0.025411248207092285, 0.05297496169805527, 0.052137020975351334, 0.0052369702607393265, 0.05484951660037041, -0.008144532330334187, 0.04014132171869278, 0.0172465518116951, -0.07212989032268524, -0.006425147410482168, 0.036802828311920166, -0.021870819851756096, -0.05075376480817795, -0.0010821032337844372, 0.10591170191764832, 0.015945298597216606, -0.038721561431884766, 0.059681884944438934, 0.001970740035176277, -0.025870490819215775, 0.00450508389621973, -0.010061614215373993, -0.056219834834337234, -0.013746460899710655, 0.05628828704357147, -0.029171036556363106, -0.003185264766216278, -0.004524256102740765, -0.0494835190474987, -0.016548775136470795, 0.035900723189115524, -0.01670149154961109, -0.04253840819001198, -0.05297662690281868, 0.05278056487441063, 0.01040852814912796, 0.019078848883509636, 0.014524807222187519, -0.028132541105151176, 0.010660105384886265, -0.02453456073999405, -0.038764022290706635, -0.03836691007018089, 0.05558928847312927, 0.07925403863191605, 0.06428840756416321, -0.00505429832264781, -0.11494826525449753, 0.010292181745171547, -0.05013701319694519, 0.013032402843236923, -0.0499112494289875, 0.10587261617183685, 0.011342411860823631, 0.027384066954255104, 0.05874665081501007, 0.05048874393105507, 0.027913684025406837, -0.01793679967522621, 0.0009148017270490527, 0.05074817314743996, -0.03812311217188835, 0.05543200299143791, 0.023080037906765938, 0.009985952638089657, -0.002231910824775696, 0.07156959176063538, 0.05271919071674347, -0.04164857789874077, 0.054697562009096146, 0.0159189123660326, -0.009532109834253788, -0.008573419414460659, -0.010837195441126823, -0.07835724949836731, -0.027077628299593925, 0.0025874683633446693, -0.08588048815727234, 0.049590788781642914, -0.042365677654743195, 0.004867019131779671, 0.004841415211558342, -0.11252543330192566, -0.00941046979278326, 0.021424662321805954, 0.035516321659088135, -0.040681272745132446, -0.015783578157424927, 0.004025526810437441, -0.12488292902708054, 0.051791004836559296, -0.023756271228194237, 0.023948723450303078, 0.013535240665078163, -0.020703855901956558, 0.025808434933423996, 0.021328002214431763, 0.048362426459789276, -0.05658369138836861, 0.03229245916008949, -0.031403906643390656, -0.09392000734806061, 0.03594302386045456, -0.08746258914470673, 0.0457976758480072, -0.015943089500069618, 0.020893888548016548, 0.06763992458581924, 0.022133843973279, -0.0006619417108595371, -0.026908403262495995, 0.03047388792037964, 0.03505456820130348, 0.01742471382021904, -0.010163160972297192, 0.02549644559621811, -0.06735741347074509, 0.028623005375266075, 0.011411215178668499, -0.029487069696187973, 0.009640621952712536, -0.03845395892858505, -0.012357904575765133, 0.030115006491541862, 0.014867900870740414, 0.0460951142013073, 0.020287979394197464, -0.04184931144118309, -0.04119934141635895, 0.023151928558945656, 0.010835913941264153, 0.026531483978033066, -0.05190453305840492, 0.002502092160284519, 0.006402943748980761, -0.031362384557724, 0.020557669922709465, -0.022134462371468544, 0.025000888854265213, 0.019900353625416756, -0.019299626350402832, 0.030034396797418594, -0.007391627877950668, -0.05411569029092789, -0.03188222274184227, 0.010148551315069199, -0.07226969301700592, 0.00686061754822731, 0.05266518518328667, -0.008563647978007793, 0.06081005930900574, 0.011228338815271854, 0.006008655298501253, -0.003766544396057725, -0.007186288945376873, 0.038613442331552505, -0.03149611875414848, 0.004883544519543648, 0.06693977862596512, -0.0169012900441885, -0.010632381774485111, -0.04532966762781143, -0.04078591614961624, 0.08775417506694794, 0.0011801831424236298, 0.0583166740834713, 0.024299701675772667, -0.00018211481801699847, -0.004234724212437868, -0.005354464985430241, -0.005022337660193443, -0.014534469693899155, 0.004313234705477953, 0.059486374258995056, -0.05356132984161377, -0.02368851751089096, -0.06636206805706024, 0.044529423117637634, 0.0006601535133086145, 0.04148552194237709, 0.03835299611091614, -0.018008114770054817, -0.014331097714602947, 0.04591771215200424, -0.12134203314781189, -0.0345895029604435, 0.0030536868143826723, 0.126459538936615, 0.01719427853822708, 0.021776409819722176, -0.02136559598147869, 0.012796875089406967, -0.021351462230086327, -0.013807426206767559, 0.023994555696845055, -0.019707420840859413, 0.04511706903576851, -0.01612013205885887, -0.012132500298321247, -0.01869950070977211, -0.027699770405888557, 0.024836087599396706, -0.0122841140255332, 0.024951288476586342, -0.016524437814950943, 0.00527234049513936, 0.023562196642160416, -0.013031935319304466, -0.05109129473567009 ]
296
296
Entropy Message Passing
The paper proposes a new message passing algorithm for cycle-free factor graphs. The proposed "entropy message passing" (EMP) algorithm may be viewed as sum-product message passing over the entropy semiring, which has previously appeared in automata theory. The primary use of EMP is to compute the entropy of a model. However, EMP can also be used to compute expressions that appear in expectation maximization and in gradient descent algorithms.
[ -0.06295366585254669, -0.00912046991288662, -0.020869223400950432, -0.04168867692351341, 0.001500193146057427, -0.04281622916460037, -0.01991986110806465, -0.0545024499297142, -0.024325506761670113, 0.039656344801187515, 0.03717518597841263, -0.01952519826591015, 0.018144642934203148, 0.059270668774843216, 0.0957607552409172, -0.0140918530523777, -0.01597985066473484, 0.05101878196001053, -0.06679856777191162, 0.0016811713576316833, 0.024269117042422295, 0.056597791612148285, 0.02836529165506363, -0.00271508633159101, 0.008384334854781628, -0.07998953014612198, -0.05665844678878784, 0.004554459825158119, 0.003209202317520976, -0.0013970178551971912, -0.1686878204345703, 0.018679162487387657, 0.014411474578082561, 0.06579902768135071, 0.040815625339746475, 0.0006211275467649102, 0.010330582037568092, -0.03571440279483795, -0.029350003227591515, -0.02986784093081951, 0.034281935542821884, -0.05693059414625168, -0.07780438661575317, -0.05043864622712135, 0.024724578484892845, -0.023808678612113, 0.1009727269411087, 0.07383708655834198, 0.041280973702669144, 0.0649438425898552, -0.0801854133605957, 0.02429773472249508, -0.055980388075113297, -0.05543098226189613, 0.06157797574996948, 0.0795455127954483, -0.009890670888125896, 0.06504430621862411, -0.013707676902413368, -0.030098600313067436, 0.036864038556814194, 0.035239189863204956, -0.000039799229853088036, 0.042281586676836014, -0.07522115111351013, 0.06876502186059952, -0.041447609663009644, -0.0005330068524926901, -0.020755710080266, -0.004015904851257801, -0.0005694751162081957, 0.06442335993051529, 0.0020539863035082817, 0.062031060457229614, 0.06958410888910294, -0.03470073267817497, -0.022092163562774658, -0.000008119367521430831, 0.015745311975479126, 0.05763119086623192, -0.022747553884983063, 0.006921345368027687, -0.009148523211479187, -0.02606581524014473, 0.0069964127615094185, 0.0029381781350821257, -0.08641654253005981, -0.03589239344000816, -0.06277827173471451, -0.06839065253734589, -0.02933921292424202, 0.10172164440155029, -0.06299127638339996, 0.06603860855102539, -0.005827737506479025, 0.047947995364665985, -0.061338745057582855, -0.0012004009913653135, -0.04554253816604614, -0.0112143037840724, -0.024355852976441383, 0.04222378134727478, 0.07135613262653351, 0.04362988471984863, -0.051701754331588745, -0.011992286890745163, 0.06515099853277206, -0.015638966113328934, 0.021468916907906532, -0.06257477402687073, 0.018978457897901535, -0.00035358587047085166, 0.027503356337547302, -0.03338318318128586, -0.03849329799413681, 0.013217992149293423, -0.01654125191271305, 0.0937960296869278, 0.03965906798839569, 0.0029573424253612757, -0.002455661306157708, -0.04159722477197647, -0.024802880361676216, 0.051353465765714645, 0.03526614233851433, 0.01346237026154995, -0.03157731518149376, 0.03799234703183174, 0.05337447673082352, 0.004962444771081209, 0.054791949689388275, 0.03068770468235016, -0.05873717740178108, 0.009901291690766811, -0.007467028219252825, 0.0779883861541748, 0.042497433722019196, 0.0012120811734348536, -0.0421290397644043, 0.05042874068021774, 0.0031127973925322294, -0.0355498380959034, 0.011084864847362041, -0.021766632795333862, 0.051799219101667404, -0.012790044769644737, -0.020854752510786057, 0.0014043072005733848, -0.01037280447781086, -0.06471830606460571, 0.03585426136851311, 0.01101106870919466, 0.001512024668045342, -0.022423231974244118, 0.028280701488256454, -0.0017011575400829315, -0.05697597190737724, -0.05252667888998985, -0.014551983214914799, 0.05858057364821434, -0.1021185964345932, -0.055829234421253204, -0.01680009998381138, -0.018526887521147728, 0.017066948115825653, 0.047617316246032715, -0.024871405214071274, -0.024530811235308647, -0.020675094798207283, -0.05884333699941635, 0.008627924136817455, -0.013200566172599792, 0.04520898312330246, -0.0054117110557854176, 0.03448138013482094, 0.10726536810398102, -0.023937378078699112, 0.001839156961068511, -0.057075560092926025, 0.030782975256443024, 0.015138892456889153, -0.00011457419896032661, -0.011280226521193981, 0.014775031246244907, 0.04605982080101967, 0.02479322999715805, -0.025518860667943954, 0.019867246970534325, -0.016165709123015404, 0.04691394791007042, 0.003092573257163167, 0.08066421747207642, 0.04345210641622543, 0.04490114375948906, -0.003809521906077862, -0.08217312395572662, -0.10058139264583588, 0.012244751676917076, -0.006250252481549978, 0.00046428831410594285, 0.0742780789732933, -0.03170735388994217, -0.0596516951918602, -0.09937746822834015, -0.037621691823005676, 0.054038356989622116, 0.01976187527179718, -0.03131801635026932, 0.051204998046159744, -0.044325485825538635, 0.001577909803017974, 0.05552459880709648, -0.016624052077531815, -0.041788458824157715, 0.009293640032410622, -0.07519078999757767, -0.005200721323490143, -0.001998180989176035, -0.05373449623584747, 0.020286619663238525, 0.0416145958006382, 0.0505715012550354, -0.01680518127977848, 0.012970136478543282, -0.0596383698284626, -0.021050332114100456, -0.024076025933027267, 0.026067199185490608, -0.04097452014684677, 0.058329470455646515, -0.06257511675357819, -0.021435583010315895, -0.04616217687726021, -0.0835600420832634, -0.048855025321245193, 0.03964230418205261, -0.07374468445777893, -0.04045288637280464, -0.08922165632247925, 0.013307314366102219, -0.045873284339904785, 0.13108551502227783, 0.05857010558247566, 0.010328419506549835, 0.019967446103692055, -0.03532535210251808, -0.08800474554300308, 0.026754513382911682, -0.048643484711647034, 0.012539006769657135, 0.016129005700349808, 0.03752189129590988, 0.008075588382780552, 0.02350776270031929, 0.007013143505901098, 0.011987830512225628, -0.03397660329937935, 0.07011543214321136, 0.03583738952875137, 0.06901678442955017, 0.004270549397915602, 0.01041776780039072, 0.005693582817912102, 0.040367063134908676, 0.06257357448339462, 0.010218020528554916, 0.06094084307551384, 0.02205318585038185, 0.06191393360495567, 0.02680748514831066, 0.04255688562989235, 0.00597390765324235, 0.016780177131295204, 0.11223415285348892, 0.06294006109237671, -0.004972178488969803, -0.0002202368195867166, 0.0038999784737825394, -0.0017692487454041839, -0.01485731266438961, -0.02295881323516369, -0.0609634667634964, 0.0055556269362568855, -0.016132313758134842, -0.015803063288331032, -0.01805182732641697, -0.006749917287379503, 0.02346787601709366, -0.02125984989106655, 0.00006965946522541344, -0.06548994034528732, -0.04262843728065491, -0.039589159190654755, 0.041562508791685104, 0.04081082344055176, -0.03929992392659187, 0.036720845848321915, 0.00297477631829679, -0.021451180800795555, 0.02944701723754406, 0.013381020165979862, -0.05930626392364502, 0.07104992866516113, 0.00759287690743804, -0.03729512169957161, 0.0015437775291502476, -0.01743137091398239, 0.01547082606703043, -0.008191563189029694, -0.0007300779107026756, 0.046085432171821594, -0.008489370346069336, 0.02497447095811367, -0.005473778583109379, 0.06009458750486374, 0.006550607271492481, -0.060922909528017044, -0.06558307260274887, -0.061433397233486176, -0.026517275720834732, 0.040106289088726044, 0.0038971882313489914, -0.015509587712585926, -0.04785952717065811, -0.05195694416761398, 0.02381577342748642, -0.006475664675235748, 0.04641386494040489, -0.04884325712919235, 0.020978260785341263, -0.016680851578712463, -0.028160378336906433, -0.025324422866106033, 0.07497154176235199, -0.0324401780962944, 0.037385839968919754, -0.028764590620994568, -0.0651615560054779, 0.0622643381357193, -0.011280096136033535, -0.07162671536207199, -0.03938255086541176, -0.02689805068075657, 0.009570416994392872, 0.08786510676145554, 0.012928520329296589, 0.02437274530529976, -0.007755615282803774, -0.04466217756271362, 0.07454898208379745, 0.025759845972061157, 0.02308606170117855, -0.029965879395604134, -0.007813037373125553, -0.0008609395590610802, 0.030451171100139618, -0.027601372450590134, -0.015813466161489487, 0.023882046341896057, -0.03737545758485794, -0.03742997720837593, -0.035775553435087204, 0.045243896543979645, -0.010926262475550175, 0.07296035438776016, 0.10528575628995895, 0.02130972035229206, -0.04789305478334427, -0.017627684399485588, 0.021148791536688805, -0.06859899312257767, 0.023970559239387512, 0.03468044474720955, -0.0715687945485115, 0.021962881088256836, -0.004437744151800871, 0.06830001622438431, -0.04478306695818901, -0.0040147691033780575, 0.023056775331497192, -0.0092798275873065, -0.06848175823688507, -0.035761017352342606, -0.00885370746254921, -0.017920535057783127, -0.05270075798034668, -0.02792465314269066, 0.028412671759724617, 0.07797318696975708, -0.03630879521369934, -0.0073766144923865795, 0.005642059724777937, 0.04650695621967316, 0.06858302652835846, 0.06937240064144135, -0.016113346442580223, -0.008963998407125473, 0.01269980426877737, -0.0038959337398409843, -0.037536557763814926, -0.017549946904182434, -0.05930950492620468, 0.00012303153926040977, -0.05368725582957268, 0.0012763440608978271, 0.02606356330215931, 0.028510482981801033, -0.016017070040106773, -0.01386596541851759, 0.09781264513731003, -0.00672572385519743, 0.02756148763000965, -0.09514179825782776, -0.01987430825829506, 0.07995223999023438, -0.0026529107708483934, 0.01744754984974861, 0.0607297308743, 0.02705724909901619, -0.06926848739385605, -0.07790320366621017, -0.004486568737775087, 0.020671462640166283, 0.04669193923473358, 0.029351500794291496, 0.0034820432774722576, 0.042948994785547256, 0.0738399401307106, -0.021735040470957756, -0.00822462234646082, -0.06521311402320862, -0.00840086117386818, -0.07790474593639374, 0.044224128127098083, 0.013033123686909676, 0.005125102587044239, -0.019957344979047775, -0.04517143592238426, 0.048673562705516815, 0.022964157164096832, 0.03807137906551361, 0.057660043239593506, -0.032830558717250824, 0.016698891296982765, 0.01437401119619608, 0.05180726572871208, -0.013334931805729866, -0.04301561415195465, 0.05564403906464577, 0.06607485562562943, 0.07940997183322906, -0.038685109466314316, 0.028286373242735863, -0.04279598221182823, -0.00042215303983539343, -0.04246201738715172, -0.031049802899360657, -0.012331315316259861, -0.010204100981354713, -0.08128932118415833, 0.05169634893536568, 0.0007670220220461488, -0.041134580969810486, 0.041514359414577484, -0.07109855860471725, -0.0072411238215863705, 0.005792311392724514, 0.05467455834150314, 0.0413709320127964, 0.028628550469875336, -0.07089190185070038, 0.042416542768478394, -0.011577791534364223, -0.08402811735868454, -0.0405256561934948, 0.06597613543272018, 0.013924366794526577, 0.007627078797668219, -0.041655536741018295, -0.06527004390954971, 0.04826072230935097, 0.03166474401950836, -0.02169032208621502, 0.006859051529318094, -0.030163750052452087, 0.10742124170064926, -0.014424149878323078, -0.01657482236623764, 0.03570380434393883, 0.040755320340394974, 0.06986153870820999, -0.0007755010155960917, -0.024253912270069122, 0.022185303270816803, 0.028156355023384094, 0.06527697294950485, -0.05990346521139145, -0.04181579500436783, 0.00551617331802845, 0.005582944955676794, 0.03938445448875427, 0.00011096198431914672, -0.00519085768610239, 0.06942473351955414, 0.06113109737634659, 0.058258213102817535, 0.07314527779817581, -0.01976007968187332, -0.08835385739803314, 0.096704863011837, -0.05083157867193222, 0.01722763665020466 ]
297
297
Bayesian Forecasting of WWW Traffic on the Time Varying Poisson Model
Traffic forecasting from past observed traffic data with small calculation complexity is one of important problems for planning of servers and networks. Focusing on World Wide Web (WWW) traffic as fundamental investigation, this paper would deal with Bayesian forecasting of network traffic on the time varying Poisson model from a viewpoint from statistical decision theory. Under this model, we would show that the estimated forecasting value is obtained by simple arithmetic calculation and expresses real WWW traffic well from both theoretical and empirical points of view.
[ -0.09956212341785431, -0.00827315915375948, 0.020990567281842232, 0.005778732243925333, 0.05491430312395096, 0.0667988657951355, -0.00809241458773613, -0.051391683518886566, 0.05358192324638367, -0.01687559485435486, 0.04143653064966202, 0.010301790200173855, -0.0005231737741269171, -0.008239121176302433, 0.019825683906674385, -0.06343920528888702, 0.007603956386446953, -0.0014139304403215647, -0.015069871209561825, -0.087993323802948, -0.038230907171964645, 0.0013463494833558798, -0.012446620501577854, 0.034233804792165756, 0.03749227523803711, -0.021772082895040512, 0.08840469270944595, -0.06504799425601959, 0.022552063688635826, -0.023158004507422447, -0.10196352750062943, 0.026045214384794235, 0.009627380408346653, -0.0021717895288020372, 0.06271879374980927, -0.03596187382936478, -0.023905234411358833, 0.00856099184602499, 0.023278431966900826, -0.03619331866502762, 0.07516331225633621, -0.0196934025734663, 0.07127922028303146, -0.005163661669939756, 0.07942818850278854, 0.02882448025047779, 0.03525904193520546, 0.05847520753741264, -0.05538705736398697, 0.030937252566218376, -0.03338540717959404, -0.056252747774124146, -0.08921974897384644, -0.00438495771959424, -0.0391656756401062, 0.10236417502164841, 0.016300689429044724, -0.011588524095714092, -0.07789058238267899, -0.08381649106740952, -0.012074789963662624, 0.07136686891317368, -0.024701567366719246, -0.01009289175271988, -0.003809778718277812, 0.04196130856871605, -0.03619327396154404, 0.015898868441581726, -0.007086006924510002, -0.10157308727502823, 0.006184797268360853, -0.0010304430034011602, 0.00767283421009779, -0.0497298538684845, -0.016922445967793465, -0.030742721632122993, 0.02763623744249344, 0.06406105309724808, 0.005136167164891958, 0.06559816002845764, -0.05574704706668854, 0.07318112999200821, -0.023740394040942192, -0.020972486585378647, -0.021215155720710754, -0.0069958814419806, 0.03945652022957802, 0.011482746340334415, 0.03956548497080803, -0.0028904627542942762, -0.02744808979332447, -0.050381727516651154, -0.06953763961791992, -0.026497291401028633, -0.048461057245731354, 0.04463476687669754, -0.0450093075633049, 0.07533815503120422, -0.01872820034623146, -0.02664792910218239, -0.02096422389149666, -0.011258415877819061, 0.030513392761349678, 0.004323252942413092, 0.007262525614351034, 0.011431297287344933, 0.034539006650447845, 0.03188805654644966, 0.002719045849516988, -0.048099495470523834, 0.034704841673374176, 0.02387385256588459, -0.02446438930928707, -0.054840702563524246, -0.001816915231756866, 0.009204947389662266, -0.0002872355980798602, 0.09303241968154907, 0.004359120968729258, -0.022541474550962448, 0.04906678572297096, 0.04549098387360573, 0.02439921908080578, 0.07448530197143555, 0.019305290654301643, -0.07629157602787018, 0.009064712561666965, 0.0005930948536843061, 0.055166102945804596, 0.04987165704369545, -0.03070256859064102, 0.08852223306894302, 0.012688785791397095, 0.007051415741443634, -0.07534671574831009, -0.021062351763248444, 0.012866164557635784, 0.07145039737224579, 0.030490532517433167, 0.03502935543656349, 0.0012358089443296194, -0.10917901992797852, -0.06488937884569168, -0.024119410663843155, 0.01611056737601757, 0.050547048449516296, -0.020145129412412643, 0.02227148786187172, -0.011008499190211296, 0.007464238908141851, -0.03992602601647377, -0.08456835150718689, -0.028952820226550102, 0.05087776109576225, 0.0017992632929235697, -0.01640835963189602, -0.05755873769521713, -0.0010666738962754607, -0.10295271128416061, 0.07196404039859772, 0.01730627752840519, 0.06014194339513779, 0.012225468643009663, 0.0033946558833122253, -0.005618991330265999, -0.021517565473914146, 0.02442014217376709, 0.03208180516958237, -0.04220326989889145, -0.09178894758224487, 0.011661484837532043, 0.019333327189087868, 0.04123690351843834, -0.05954958498477936, -0.08072886615991592, -0.07003089040517807, 0.03205156698822975, -0.01787625439465046, -0.009991168044507504, -0.07115918397903442, 0.08473167568445206, -0.10805699974298477, -0.0712573230266571, 0.02086789533495903, 0.014354024082422256, 0.0692596286535263, 0.05467110127210617, 0.07433781027793884, 0.05273132026195526, 0.019395774230360985, 0.016188396140933037, 0.0273389033973217, 0.007821965962648392, -0.025929175317287445, 0.06769998371601105, -0.01587085798382759, -0.00493536377325654, 0.024842871353030205, -0.07557330280542374, 0.05415495112538338, -0.03459443897008896, 0.03741278871893883, -0.07587090879678726, -0.025039734318852425, -0.09948566555976868, 0.0203406922519207, 0.03965893015265465, -0.1076202318072319, 0.022757254540920258, 0.02912851981818676, 0.0077619669027626514, -0.05305932089686394, 0.012188581749796867, 0.01679529808461666, 0.044568512588739395, -0.0009231496951542795, -0.06824763864278793, -0.055978626012802124, -0.023434195667505264, 0.008107958361506462, -0.0328560471534729, 0.053469523787498474, -0.041847050189971924, 0.02756252884864807, -0.07329867035150528, -0.0367894247174263, -0.05861029028892517, -0.031078824773430824, -0.07463550567626953, 0.03796231374144554, -0.030802180990576744, -0.04016701877117157, 0.02730814553797245, 0.08579621464014053, 0.11185326427221298, 0.06841367483139038, -0.012642627581954002, 0.005815123673528433, 0.02824029140174389, -0.04220843315124512, -0.10216134041547775, 0.020724575966596603, -0.019271433353424072, 0.06217033788561821, 0.01607089303433895, -0.03927367180585861, -0.0175921767950058, 0.017809873446822166, -0.06765084713697433, 0.021490223705768585, 0.013361666351556778, -0.022039905190467834, -0.050998665392398834, -0.04930749163031578, -0.043555039912462234, 0.07474280893802643, 0.011095893569290638, 0.06885485351085663, 0.0345773920416832, -0.027061928063631058, 0.04234051704406738, -0.0018707088893279433, -0.03243427723646164, 0.03449059650301933, 0.038445476442575455, 0.030594198033213615, -0.02650030329823494, 0.003887796076014638, 0.02450939267873764, 0.08347158133983612, 0.05202360078692436, 0.03438183292746544, 0.004111768677830696, 0.0595669187605381, 0.000011910573448403738, -0.02283884584903717, -0.010765939019620419, -0.010679558850824833, 0.005045090802013874, -0.0027165377978235483, 0.032998669892549515, 0.05211196839809418, 0.004280112683773041, -0.05333854258060455, -0.03168149292469025, -0.005998685490339994, -0.061555951833724976, -0.009689821861684322, -0.003786483546718955, -0.04195806011557579, -0.052330583333969116, 0.05405706539750099, -0.07417017221450806, 0.03466957435011864, 0.053885288536548615, -0.045275334268808365, 0.022276338189840317, 0.012269888073205948, 0.00746343657374382, -0.009158126078546047, -0.09645253419876099, 0.004626472946256399, 0.06293190270662308, 0.04822241887450218, -0.001014966401271522, 0.07959775626659393, 0.0379483699798584, 0.002204383257776499, 0.0030670170672237873, 0.05675923451781273, -0.036489859223365784, 0.006996392272412777, -0.10946208983659744, 0.03286679834127426, 0.009772446937859058, 0.010670258663594723, -0.07969418168067932, -0.0848066657781601, -0.01941794343292713, 0.0492258295416832, -0.020807815715670586, -0.016892366111278534, 0.027484433725476265, -0.006690943147987127, 0.004767884500324726, 0.009930609725415707, -0.007271850947290659, -0.0006137154414318502, 0.05999448522925377, 0.03931419923901558, -0.04141698405146599, -0.005907898303121328, 0.017973482608795166, 0.11587660759687424, 0.001361014787107706, -0.01253962330520153, -0.09125428646802902, 0.008376306854188442, 0.044053733348846436, 0.0003113464917987585, -0.058464229106903076, -0.017397800460457802, 0.0013818404404446483, -0.013252295553684235, 0.05657374486327171, 0.05863500386476517, 0.04954242333769798, -0.002399772172793746, -0.07218948751688004, -0.03343590348958969, -0.03342527523636818, 0.027195477858185768, 0.005403321702033281, 0.0299361702054739, -0.039537400007247925, 0.0831848680973053, -0.008647753857076168, -0.014887146651744843, 0.00835540983825922, -0.037598829716444016, -0.009880534373223782, -0.01383987721055746, -0.04541614279150963, -0.037298817187547684, 0.03853277489542961, 0.0386262908577919, -0.027950158342719078, 0.032763492316007614, -0.05299563333392143, -0.05367205664515495, 0.06604798138141632, -0.014911537989974022, -0.001436739694327116, 0.01306868065148592, 0.02313138172030449, 0.00008590590732637793, 0.03487465903162956, -0.05390087515115738, -0.05038800090551376, 0.05239347368478775, 0.024748459458351135, -0.004331365693360567, -0.030829554423689842, -0.06536907702684402, 0.042233895510435104, -0.03648047894239426, -0.0029935301281511784, -0.06315207481384277, 0.10219332575798035, 0.015832718461751938, -0.005092910956591368, -0.024754879996180534, -0.09007217735052109, 0.027270648628473282, 0.04446764290332794, -0.04872337356209755, 0.024332981556653976, -0.039589766412973404, -0.053666852414608, 0.014188844710588455, -0.02743830531835556, -0.061092112213373184, -0.027956468984484673, 0.01968812569975853, -0.07227806746959686, 0.06404268741607666, -0.03717236593365669, 0.0689825564622879, -0.0024803949054330587, 0.04478314891457558, 0.026674313470721245, -0.010295995511114597, 0.005929646547883749, 0.04325048252940178, -0.006251446437090635, 0.052861690521240234, 0.029529236257076263, -0.03271385282278061, -0.046274807304143906, -0.030842648819088936, 0.033202897757291794, -0.01402471773326397, 0.011448557488620281, -0.01109206024557352, -0.020411619916558266, -0.07742742449045181, 0.06000503897666931, 0.024851948022842407, -0.08410961180925369, -0.014277532696723938, -0.022910665720701218, -0.06036735326051712, -0.06052824854850769, -0.0046225860714912415, -0.03159235790371895, 0.0018438566476106644, 0.022076211869716644, -0.028999820351600647, -0.022808916866779327, 0.01081365067511797, -0.0179689172655344, 0.017581306397914886, 0.03604395315051079, 0.040671464055776596, 0.022216178476810455, -0.01990981586277485, 0.012439915910363197, -0.023833421990275383, -0.004430349916219711, 0.029213570058345795, 0.00045759425847791135, 0.06678736954927444, 0.01708490215241909, -0.08693976700305939, 0.04651114344596863, 0.02422557957470417, -0.07223759591579437, -0.06639683991670609, 0.10505924373865128, -0.028901096433401108, -0.022365419194102287, -0.053169332444667816, -0.04631387069821358, 0.022438202053308487, -0.09072742611169815, 0.011798212304711342, 0.026013558730483055, -0.03956649824976921, 0.03746645525097847, -0.011097872629761696, -0.1039617657661438, -0.00528774643316865, 0.0021641962230205536, -0.04944395646452904, -0.016172634437680244, 0.06795549392700195, -0.044777337461709976, 0.012677927501499653, -0.01507764495909214, -0.01755497232079506, 0.07220888882875443, 0.04722920060157776, -0.03978697583079338, -0.011335727758705616, 0.014724750071763992, 0.043120428919792175, 0.03138500079512596, -0.026501525193452835, -0.010832925327122211, 0.006211725063621998, -0.01829385571181774, -0.048206157982349396, -0.06561097502708435, 0.03927136957645416, 0.01860588602721691, 0.0033424135763198137, -0.01647268421947956, 0.038732632994651794, -0.0029551773332059383, 0.035621244460344315, 0.0275774747133255, 0.02424042299389839, 0.0678698718547821, 0.015098826959729195, 0.054572608321905136, -0.0038689752109348774, 0.011251908726990223, 0.02709290012717247, 0.01342027448117733, 0.017359361052513123, 0.031091943383216858, 0.03634671866893768 ]
298
298
Bayesian two-sample tests
In this paper, we present two classes of Bayesian approaches to the two-sample problem. Our first class of methods extends the Bayesian t-test to include all parametric models in the exponential family and their conjugate priors. Our second class of methods uses Dirichlet process mixtures (DPM) of such conjugate-exponential distributions as flexible nonparametric priors over the unknown distributions.
[ -0.05132779851555824, 0.010599379427731037, -0.016854068264365196, -0.043974559754133224, 0.05817902088165283, -0.02675492689013481, -0.007929581217467785, 0.03581945225596428, -0.005615602247416973, -0.043388765305280685, -0.028142940253019333, -0.05885547026991844, -0.027131278067827225, 0.04199959710240364, 0.021093910560011864, -0.020245840772986412, -0.03464745730161667, -0.047160349786281586, 0.03634259104728699, -0.01858396828174591, 0.03250082582235336, 0.027798043563961983, -0.003017328679561615, -0.004917745478451252, -0.01695645973086357, 0.050242092460393906, 0.006851058453321457, -0.034505587071180344, -0.04804488644003868, -0.034538667649030685, -0.06769450008869171, -0.02662068046629429, -0.05749564990401268, 0.01887347921729088, 0.09145908802747726, -0.0673295333981514, -0.004282483831048012, -0.027391472831368446, -0.05229882895946503, 0.014299076050519943, 0.05367259308695793, 0.02093680016696453, 0.00003953139093937352, -0.003566453931853175, 0.01976103149354458, 0.04877057299017906, 0.045640695840120316, -0.02282085083425045, 0.015929345041513443, 0.07674563676118851, -0.0985439270734787, 0.04419578239321709, -0.02617228962481022, -0.0487992949783802, 0.011375007219612598, 0.010240035131573677, -0.01778903789818287, 0.013526709750294685, -0.07171265780925751, -0.015312845818698406, 0.00019539945060387254, 0.11669345945119858, -0.0567479133605957, 0.008649623952805996, -0.015460154041647911, -0.02825019508600235, -0.0998089388012886, -0.04530448094010353, 0.01914152130484581, 0.00150791194755584, 0.028417453169822693, -0.017675360664725304, 0.009747146628797054, 0.010968707501888275, -0.021166451275348663, -0.06377878785133362, -0.06839065998792648, -0.004003205336630344, -0.034579433500766754, 0.044869132339954376, -0.06491877138614655, 0.007159997709095478, -0.05643162876367569, 0.05928640440106392, -0.007625684607774019, 0.05632716789841652, -0.006592386402189732, -0.004965152591466904, -0.031214147806167603, -0.08960732817649841, -0.016743149608373642, 0.04074131324887276, -0.11767932772636414, 0.0720149576663971, -0.01574651151895523, 0.05391226336359978, -0.013989121653139591, 0.001868911786004901, -0.027535922825336456, -0.00933392345905304, -0.030254609882831573, -0.041817791759967804, 0.07309223711490631, 0.03263622522354126, 0.031672973185777664, 0.051157936453819275, -0.0338524654507637, 0.07153626531362534, -0.05325523018836975, -0.014671162702143192, 0.09386056661605835, -0.05927220359444618, 0.07970733195543289, 0.004073338583111763, -0.06530425697565079, 0.1011088564991951, 0.013127845712006092, 0.03331191837787628, 0.04050803557038307, 0.036476071923971176, 0.049099646508693695, -0.009299509227275848, -0.025969352573156357, 0.009660308249294758, 0.07375474274158478, -0.04698644205927849, 0.0360095389187336, -0.04011824354529381, 0.0704161524772644, -0.07309595495462418, -0.04190639778971672, 0.037924252450466156, 0.02748013660311699, -0.009721537120640278, -0.03913738206028938, -0.023320460692048073, -0.0199833195656538, -0.05289463326334953, 0.040204793214797974, 0.02556758001446724, -0.03212542459368706, -0.039692528545856476, -0.05454925820231438, -0.00689785135909915, 0.02646360732614994, -0.02426525205373764, -0.022758694365620613, 0.021861059591174126, -0.08344000577926636, -0.03886507451534271, -0.083838552236557, -0.05077826976776123, 0.017347991466522217, 0.024005137383937836, 0.02347693033516407, -0.015850482508540154, -0.02202831581234932, 0.009825062938034534, 0.009420511312782764, 0.1453360617160797, 0.002636851742863655, -0.013551641255617142, 0.06317778676748276, 0.016550660133361816, -0.04158993065357208, -0.0046597630716860294, -0.0025552932638674974, -0.0198785699903965, -0.054668646305799484, -0.06743402779102325, -0.07593318074941635, -0.07551704347133636, 0.01497221365571022, -0.08643253147602081, -0.018760593608021736, -0.017328696325421333, 0.008510787039995193, 0.0040976195596158504, 0.00026126837474294007, 0.012088478542864323, 0.04488388076424599, -0.04958320036530495, -0.03254617378115654, 0.03967457264661789, 0.0033780275844037533, 0.028376860544085503, -0.08342093974351883, 0.002631038660183549, 0.054968900978565216, 0.005501686129719019, 0.12263400107622147, -0.008609095588326454, 0.026307538151741028, -0.011000863276422024, -0.05609765276312828, -0.024342358112335205, -0.07482639700174332, 0.0009156433516182005, -0.06219140812754631, 0.028788786381483078, -0.02358032390475273, -0.0445113442838192, -0.06687095761299133, -0.02748440019786358, -0.03913180157542229, 0.08263225108385086, 0.04265180975198746, -0.0013024916406720877, 0.016935525462031364, -0.034376032650470734, -0.025315340608358383, -0.038223959505558014, -0.060653895139694214, -0.05131365358829498, 0.06906194239854813, -0.08435674011707306, -0.05614190176129341, 0.05839649587869644, -0.06396668404340744, 0.012570581398904324, -0.0009763450943864882, 0.018813593313097954, -0.03308095037937164, 0.10418026894330978, -0.066280297935009, -0.06846074014902115, -0.009742280468344688, -0.00009030012734001502, -0.07067624479532242, 0.018252115696668625, 0.01103949174284935, -0.09208295494318008, -0.03554153069853783, -0.03431946784257889, -0.012049047276377678, 0.01887601427733898, -0.03528086468577385, -0.016358621418476105, 0.088239885866642, -0.017907030880451202, -0.03944560885429382, 0.07560890167951584, 0.02946397289633751, -0.018767528235912323, -0.04839678853750229, -0.08159143477678299, -0.03374013304710388, 0.0633356124162674, -0.011543718166649342, 0.09383207559585571, 0.01593451201915741, -0.0009080180316232145, 0.01022753119468689, 0.06805802136659622, -0.02492835558950901, -0.02174306847155094, 0.0049226111732423306, 0.05690734460949898, 0.020227229222655296, -0.031556885689496994, 0.07871723175048828, 0.0130146574229002, -0.019794290885329247, 0.0030655893497169018, 0.07009578496217728, -0.0019253493519499898, -0.0019924223888665438, 0.09003404527902603, 0.040645696222782135, -0.04054132476449013, 0.007597301155328751, -0.0811021625995636, -0.029010022059082985, -0.003917119465768337, 0.022415101528167725, -0.007140081841498613, 0.08489732444286346, 0.07695114612579346, 0.024571603164076805, -0.04622318595647812, -0.0292271189391613, 0.04129304736852646, -0.036667972803115845, 0.04434522986412048, 0.03944661095738411, 0.009855306707322598, -0.05349831283092499, 0.006698764860630035, 0.007075491826981306, -0.017482304945588112, 0.009790491312742233, 0.042393479496240616, -0.07603108137845993, 0.011203136295080185, 0.036983221769332886, -0.07125487923622131, 0.024528954178094864, 0.02016843482851982, 0.016237594187259674, 0.02751816436648369, -0.022458797320723534, 0.03259485960006714, -0.03942824900150299, 0.02006438933312893, -0.01673121005296707, 0.1062716692686081, 0.03791903331875801, 0.044754788279533386, -0.0824580192565918, -0.00807248055934906, 0.017182184383273125, 0.016195228323340416, -0.03910677880048752, 0.04111781716346741, 0.004837064538151026, -0.04528970643877983, -0.04105304926633835, 0.057140521705150604, 0.024135621264576912, 0.035008735954761505, 0.02383391745388508, 0.056777287274599075, 0.02293059043586254, 0.0015312896575778723, -0.06868027150630951, -0.0384589247405529, 0.018074218183755875, 0.0017047160072252154, -0.04869896173477173, -0.008622558787465096, -0.05063951015472412, 0.017353076487779617, -0.011706609278917313, 0.09440946578979492, -0.030812034383416176, 0.02017340064048767, -0.02095183916389942, -0.0013824950437992811, 0.06457382440567017, 0.05186568945646286, -0.06189412251114845, -0.058100610971450806, 0.009514172561466694, 0.0640546977519989, 0.016880104318261147, 0.022280775010585785, -0.0087352329865098, -0.02068600431084633, -0.023111917078495026, -0.04675756022334099, -0.09901991486549377, 0.02182478830218315, 0.029818659648299217, 0.01643935590982437, -0.07626989483833313, 0.01131260022521019, 0.031220469623804092, -0.030571211129426956, 0.041703008115291595, 0.03931862488389015, -0.007665766403079033, 0.07360266894102097, -0.006494385190308094, 0.044907357543706894, 0.0175669863820076, 0.006072985008358955, -0.013978912495076656, -0.011365827172994614, 0.048277564346790314, 0.030662445351481438, -0.04956800118088722, -0.014196610078215599, 0.061519261449575424, 0.06530661135911942, 0.02102593518793583, 0.0371476411819458, 0.00030787326977588236, 0.0090994443744421, -0.061654284596443176, 0.056980814784765244, -0.0032901857048273087, -0.04492204636335373, -0.06255441159009933, -0.013444348238408566, -0.000725712045095861, -0.035183340311050415, -0.009156660176813602, -0.014162748120725155, 0.07331287860870361, -0.02012845128774643, -0.06287999451160431, -0.03213370218873024, -0.009024438448250294, 0.031050503253936768, -0.0010933339362964034, 0.05338318273425102, 0.03872902691364288, 0.011380274780094624, -0.06883348524570465, -0.015701310709118843, -0.05209078639745712, -0.0088858213275671, -0.08975783735513687, -0.07857691496610641, -0.03390489146113396, 0.016364390030503273, 0.012303217314183712, 0.07426132261753082, -0.0385730043053627, 0.04516651853919029, 0.06607205420732498, -0.012372473254799843, -0.018766775727272034, 0.05164181813597679, 0.011167993769049644, 0.005052794236689806, 0.013946052640676498, 0.006887015886604786, -0.048280268907547, -0.09694923460483551, 0.012518608011305332, 0.028877833858132362, 0.017426872625947, 0.012953103519976139, 0.04394787177443504, -0.0021334534976631403, 0.008547610603272915, 0.0580771304666996, -0.019978828728199005, 0.018474003300070763, -0.10092204064130783, 0.005146485287696123, -0.012629677541553974, 0.03228069469332695, -0.02886812388896942, -0.020978927612304688, 0.048283983021974564, 0.04522290825843811, 0.04053792729973793, -0.09082186967134476, -0.04867016524076462, 0.011045336723327637, 0.07146269828081131, -0.08212938159704208, 0.02737409621477127, 0.023910673335194588, 0.03959500417113304, 0.008249719627201557, 0.03221266716718674, 0.08543014526367188, 0.05491073429584503, 0.02973647229373455, -0.04303082451224327, -0.047083646059036255, 0.04240313544869423, 0.010683847591280937, -0.04526443034410477, -0.043928805738687515, 0.0410495363175869, -0.01202396396547556, -0.007301004137843847, -0.0118514783680439, -0.039588481187820435, -0.010354014113545418, -0.04984848201274872, 0.03187799081206322, 0.07473500072956085, 0.023635558784008026, 0.05018429830670357, -0.007227020338177681, 0.0034344149753451347, 0.019826097413897514, -0.033838268369436264, 0.014196987263858318, 0.0016375427367165685, 0.014884421601891518, 0.030517831444740295, 0.032342396676540375, 0.038842953741550446, -0.06005460396409035, 0.02300175279378891, 0.03775779902935028, -0.031536418944597244, -0.002803819254040718, 0.0186684001237154, 0.07675015181303024, -0.038353629410266876, -0.04246439039707184, -0.02649732120335102, 0.03822595253586769, 0.011458685621619225, 0.10092444717884064, -0.017938649281859398, 0.039205897599458694, -0.026638338342308998, -0.012752787210047245, -0.03346643224358559, -0.02706189639866352, 0.0037361180875450373, 0.003634680761024356, 0.0615120492875576, -0.053306177258491516, 0.06452134996652603, -0.011053638532757759, 0.046361155807971954, -0.011619871482253075, -0.07623738795518875, -0.005755423102527857, -0.033910371363162994, 0.011896942742168903, -0.03263426572084427, 0.05462988466024399 ]
299
299
Rough Set Model for Discovering Hybrid Association Rules
In this paper, the mining of hybrid association rules with rough set approach is investigated as the algorithm RSHAR.The RSHAR algorithm is constituted of two steps mainly. At first, to join the participant tables into a general table to generate the rules which is expressing the relationship between two or more domains that belong to several different tables in a database. Then we apply the mapping code on selected dimension, which can be added directly into the information system as one certain attribute. To find the association rules, frequent itemsets are generated in second step where candidate itemsets are generated through equivalence classes and also transforming the mapping code in to real dimensions. The searching method for candidate itemset is similar to apriori algorithm. The analysis of the performance of algorithm has been carried out.
[ -0.027618570253252983, -0.04639485478401184, 0.08475231379270554, 0.05402738228440285, -0.029355337843298912, -0.04292655736207962, -0.05017053335905075, -0.062435731291770935, -0.0585719533264637, 0.019091878086328506, -0.03820478543639183, -0.08308695256710052, -0.007811329793184996, 0.04952630773186684, 0.04230279475450516, 0.03980712220072746, -0.014027737081050873, 0.05322480946779251, -0.01454939041286707, -0.028505193069577217, 0.035616159439086914, -0.009605242870748043, -0.06287571787834167, -0.05292590335011482, 0.03408826142549515, -0.023126408457756042, -0.09206506609916687, 0.052338261157274246, 0.05141640827059746, 0.07803051173686981, -0.03009236976504326, -0.06268258392810822, 0.057798027992248535, 0.013499428518116474, 0.004387739114463329, 0.012663506902754307, -0.030583493411540985, -0.018605243414640427, -0.06586135923862457, 0.04281061887741089, 0.019909195601940155, 0.006476109381765127, -0.009782901965081692, -0.03694705665111542, 0.0423937663435936, 0.0674596056342125, -0.013417105190455914, -0.02294646017253399, 0.01301155798137188, -0.0006507218931801617, -0.03449413180351257, -0.057942651212215424, -0.009890563786029816, 0.017401954159140587, -0.018259430304169655, -0.00610304344445467, -0.03756566345691681, 0.0234882403165102, 0.012114085257053375, 0.028676707297563553, 0.07239159196615219, 0.09463226050138474, -0.014368778094649315, -0.05172891914844513, -0.022456543520092964, -0.06279049068689346, -0.003908082842826843, 0.022946368902921677, -0.017386959865689278, -0.032368287444114685, -0.03766874596476555, -0.0008241555187851191, 0.024700572714209557, 0.08051377534866333, -0.009541540406644344, 0.015214807353913784, -0.000831620127428323, -0.02536585181951523, 0.020108070224523544, 0.09133344143629074, -0.05296818166971207, 0.0015136771835386753, -0.04279940947890282, -0.012641122564673424, -0.04796794801950455, 0.0024674374144524336, 0.01481438335031271, -0.03686070442199707, 0.03357331082224846, -0.03827629238367081, -0.03337594121694565, 0.04567146301269531, -0.14534221589565277, 0.015219287946820259, -0.007915928959846497, 0.047391533851623535, -0.01964706741273403, 0.08087333291769028, 0.02097170613706112, -0.019185146316885948, 0.09632082283496857, 0.006541718728840351, 0.009922427125275135, -0.06448609381914139, -0.04850716516375542, 0.07420458644628525, -0.000945166393648833, 0.06241074576973915, -0.05817432701587677, -0.020390955731272697, 0.02538451924920082, 0.03484673053026199, -0.029863940551877022, 0.0574786514043808, -0.016197439283132553, 0.09749060124158859, 0.02078670635819435, 0.0234969574958086, -0.05985347926616669, 0.027069365605711937, -0.03341022878885269, 0.054184120148420334, -0.05302942916750908, -0.010212702676653862, 0.011331639252603054, -0.018139265477657318, 0.046572040766477585, -0.006244569551199675, 0.04219944402575493, 0.02075551077723503, -0.0763777568936348, 0.09702684730291367, -0.10292326658964157, 0.027871834114193916, -0.0404500737786293, 0.017488164827227592, 0.011745297349989414, 0.02590000070631504, 0.03202744945883751, 0.014275473542511463, 0.057688068598508835, 0.030259311199188232, 0.0021643368527293205, -0.04536479711532593, -0.014218508265912533, -0.043131712824106216, 0.026285693049430847, 0.014349021948873997, 0.02982689067721367, 0.009143519215285778, -0.042455390095710754, -0.07896013557910919, 0.022263016551733017, 0.039517778903245926, -0.030004536733031273, 0.04617389664053917, 0.040558263659477234, 0.035998959094285965, 0.034332528710365295, 0.0034412890672683716, 0.11009997129440308, -0.017583001405000687, -0.03441782295703888, 0.0567326657474041, 0.05334167182445526, 0.022116392850875854, 0.014957716688513756, -0.022259604185819626, 0.02239542081952095, -0.06408829987049103, 0.05662465840578079, 0.019752511754631996, -0.014814785681664944, 0.01734386943280697, 0.04165315628051758, -0.04532012715935707, -0.0036844576243311167, 0.006917352322489023, -0.048364683985710144, 0.0358472503721714, 0.00726157845929265, -0.08558609336614609, -0.00284229195676744, 0.02365485392510891, 0.05583452060818672, 0.04966753348708153, 0.02060028538107872, 0.01490318775177002, 0.015345652587711811, -0.009252417832612991, 0.0014471081085503101, 0.005070717539638281, 0.05472462624311447, 0.024603260681033134, -0.06390343606472015, -0.0409671850502491, -0.014719054102897644, 0.057078491896390915, 0.10715202987194061, 0.04216909781098366, -0.027969999238848686, -0.016716348007321358, -0.04081117734313011, -0.08105397969484329, 0.008056767284870148, -0.05849694460630417, -0.008568504825234413, 0.029617050662636757, -0.0069118682295084, -0.043325696140527725, 0.042245857417583466, 0.01548768300563097, 0.002926559653133154, -0.07894113659858704, 0.06440068781375885, 0.02433714084327221, -0.09504138678312302, -0.07350105047225952, 0.07090888172388077, 0.003451272612437606, 0.04613679647445679, -0.0053506167605519295, 0.02573435567319393, 0.05785568058490753, -0.07348211109638214, -0.03057289868593216, 0.0946512520313263, -0.07600871473550797, -0.06043366342782974, -0.04545021429657936, -0.05061354860663414, -0.07480426132678986, -0.020074518397450447, 0.0210581012070179, 0.09253863990306854, 0.0019065793603658676, -0.01631878688931465, -0.08896332234144211, 0.006279543042182922, 0.018860090523958206, 0.0597420260310173, 0.05957513302564621, -0.01111985556781292, 0.013504987582564354, 0.00663868710398674, -0.039934124797582626, 0.0127267986536026, -0.030750108882784843, -0.043423235416412354, -0.042679596692323685, 0.028295615687966347, -0.00665020989254117, -0.050874222069978714, -0.01568879373371601, 0.0766700953245163, 0.0065986281260848045, 0.014353478327393532, 0.03149718791246414, 0.04736090078949928, 0.06641867756843567, 0.04064415022730827, -0.03314081206917763, -0.005733273923397064, -0.027540696784853935, 0.05475476756691933, 0.05726011469960213, 0.09175820648670197, 0.017814505845308304, -0.00046256856876425445, -0.04996172711253166, 0.008776750415563583, -0.06986970454454422, 0.03558526188135147, 0.0815160945057869, -0.025303633883595467, -0.04664712771773338, 0.03714896738529205, 0.0586833618581295, 0.06262225657701492, -0.030733998864889145, -0.056648313999176025, -0.00569568295031786, 0.10541966557502747, 0.025889966636896133, -0.07987802475690842, -0.011042592115700245, 0.04317306727170944, 0.0023844221141189337, 0.03590044379234314, 0.04606406390666962, -0.07022880762815475, -0.045649319887161255, -0.02031686156988144, -0.03315417468547821, 0.07683099806308746, 0.009872928261756897, -0.023856181651353836, -0.0032054742332547903, 0.05901315435767174, -0.015514673665165901, -0.0726381316781044, 0.02611389197409153, 0.06265191733837128, 0.013528120703995228, 0.03666532039642334, 0.010977580212056637, 0.04905258119106293, 0.0494026280939579, 0.007493138778954744, -0.019339710474014282, -0.07617288827896118, 0.011721557006239891, 0.0317823588848114, -0.08134137094020844, 0.027495166286826134, -0.01637442596256733, -0.020305883139371872, 0.009131569415330887, -0.026582160964608192, 0.025839457288384438, 0.010310369543731213, -0.03874535486102104, 0.016295529901981354, 0.0183413103222847, -0.046488206833601, -0.03591662645339966, -0.008306416682898998, -0.03418941795825958, -0.01778155192732811, 0.005337093491107225, -0.09098394960165024, -0.004035251215100288, -0.0646151527762413, 0.05305906757712364, -0.06843437254428864, 0.007258908823132515, 0.002754833782091737, 0.009159332141280174, 0.0008190702646970749, -0.017314694821834564, 0.013037445954978466, -0.09501564502716064, 0.000056984434195328504, -0.07310155034065247, 0.01885545440018177, 0.010708761401474476, 0.0955905169248581, 0.045961614698171616, 0.010816704481840134, 0.009702697396278381, -0.03923233970999718, 0.007895971648395061, 0.00605526240542531, 0.07209498435258865, -0.015093633905053139, 0.034750234335660934, 0.050574760884046555, 0.06177409738302231, -0.0014243928017094731, 0.06782623380422592, 0.05100727081298828, -0.0647348165512085, 0.013382692821323872, 0.00018159115279559046, 0.06911464035511017, -0.008044565096497536, -0.007086915895342827, -0.017964931204915047, -0.02787715382874012, 0.04818684607744217, 0.04160043224692345, -0.011393921449780464, 0.054276254028081894, 0.018473414704203606, -0.06109943240880966, 0.012048694305121899, -0.04816092178225517, -0.00459402147680521, -0.011522479355335236, 0.06107459217309952, -0.056565653532743454, -0.001072135055437684, 0.04140688478946686, -0.034220125526189804, -0.021462827920913696, -0.005423941183835268, 0.02849229983985424, -0.03773653507232666, 0.015615954995155334, 0.033917032182216644, -0.016574373468756676, -0.02926258184015751, 0.11092761158943176, -0.03448791801929474, 0.0002562679292168468, 0.03188661113381386, -0.053174372762441635, -0.06433012336492538, 0.009623034857213497, -0.03125414624810219, 0.04121428355574608, -0.11823443323373795, -0.0822455883026123, -0.05356732755899429, 0.045268427580595016, 0.06031319126486778, -0.0021717899944633245, 0.05180797725915909, -0.015831703320145607, 0.029025575146079063, 0.03760547190904617, -0.047709085047245026, -0.03783135861158371, 0.041694313287734985, -0.012658147141337395, 0.01438515167683363, 0.02247568778693676, 0.027200879529118538, 0.003926319070160389, 0.023822885006666183, -0.028723178431391716, 0.010944177396595478, 0.006409465800970793, -0.05829942971467972, -0.08095589280128479, -0.018669506534934044, 0.022345228120684624, 0.0264600720256567, -0.026578204706311226, -0.020333927124738693, -0.007971235550940037, -0.10049720853567123, 0.017032016068696976, 0.025521675124764442, 0.038410838693380356, 0.05704740434885025, 0.028315262869000435, -0.023210562765598297, 0.04828106239438057, 0.0030693074222654104, 0.020916976034641266, 0.01998928375542164, 0.020023224875330925, 0.020598415285348892, 0.007537951692938805, 0.03609171509742737, 0.023309649899601936, -0.044239193201065063, 0.03304964676499367, -0.024991104379296303, -0.008693506941199303, 0.03894158452749252, -0.0358843170106411, 0.02760295197367668, -0.02729649282991886, 0.024733053520321846, 0.008997957222163677, -0.11120166629552841, 0.09264449030160904, -0.13019344210624695, -0.0337643064558506, -0.01835034042596817, -0.005935324355959892, 0.023675138130784035, -0.07164404541254044, -0.0407184474170208, 0.01833534985780716, 0.02269514463841915, 0.06898217648267746, 0.02061031199991703, -0.044521596282720566, -0.01744193024933338, 0.03732002153992653, 0.0017175846733152866, 0.06415572762489319, -0.015559916384518147, 0.03150516003370285, 0.03303254023194313, -0.023885803297162056, -0.005226520821452141, -0.0042569381184875965, -0.016942525282502174, 0.03471149131655693, 0.024852817878127098, 0.060080040246248245, 0.010951092466711998, 0.010801062919199467, -0.029025839641690254, 0.03201873600482941, -0.014539606869220734, -0.000057071683841058984, -0.05791233852505684, -0.029231781139969826, 0.09607387334108353, 0.016196567565202713, -0.034291792660951614, -0.001338311703875661, -0.01810779981315136, 0.047802504152059555, -0.006707562133669853, 0.05570807307958603, -0.06503083556890488, 0.017823291942477226, 0.037197601050138474, 0.07987562566995621, 0.038540471345186234, -0.020667502656579018, 0.046811543405056, -0.015452844090759754, 0.05576128885149956, -0.011717705056071281, -0.06440696120262146 ]